tv Inside Story Al Jazeera May 16, 2022 8:30pm-9:01pm AST
8:30 pm
so far, the most isolated nation on earth has refused outside help, leaving many relying on pain killers the battle the effects of coven 19. but even those seem to be in short supply. laura about money out to sarah. ah! it's good to have you with us. hello, adrian finnegan here in dough. how the headlines and al serra, a special collaboration service, has been held in bethlehem for al jazeera journalist, sharina barclay church leaders and hospital officials in occupied east jerusalem have condemned israeli forces for attacking mourners at her funeral procession on friday. the videos also been released showing the moment that is ready forces storm st. joseph hospital, where sharina barclay's body had been lying. officials say that force is pushed past a pregnant woman, and it's a disabled patient preliminary results from sunday's parliamentary elections.
8:31 pm
lebanon showed major gains for the lebanese forces party. that's a kristian groups aligned with saudi arabia. vote was the 1st since the bay route port explosion on the collapse of the country's economy, said a hodder reports from bay rude. this is a parliamentary democracy, but the reality is it's consensual democracy. if none of the communities a work together, if one community feels that they are marginalized, set out or under attack by the others, then there will be no national unity and there will be no peace and this country has seen a civil war. it has seen bouts of violence ever since. so if these different political forces don't come together and work together, then we're not going to see political stability. and of course, economic stability. so people are concerned soldiers defending ukraine, 2nd largest city. ha keith say that they've reached the board with worshipped. the defense ministry showed a video of celebrations at a border marker. hockey was being shall daily by russian artillery a month ago. but ukrainian forces have regained territory in the northeast since
8:32 pm
sweeping has announced that it will join finland and formerly applied from nato membership. after avoiding military alliances for 200 years, prime minister magdalena anderson says the swedes need the security guarantees that come from joining nato. russia, as ward, rather than expanding nato, would be a mistake. france is to have its 1st female prime minister in 30 years, newly re elected president manuel mac crohn accepted the resignation of john cast x . that clears the way for a cabinet re shuffle and the appointment of labor minister elizabeth born to leave the government shall anchors prime minister says his country will run out of fuel in just one more day. he says that she will anchor needs $75000000.00 in the next few days in order to pay for essential imports and those bad lions that he's continues here on al jazeera, after today's inside story, coming up next. ah
8:33 pm
will finland and sweden joining nato? make europe safer? despite warnings from russia, both countries made the decision after the invasion of ukraine. how will the kremlin respond? this is inside story. ah hello and welcome to the program. i'm hammer, jim, jim, finland, and sweden decided against joining nato for many years. both have a long history of remaining neutral during wars and staying out of military alliances. all that changed when russia invaded ukraine. leaders of the nordic
8:34 pm
nations blame president vladimir putin for endangering security in europe for finland. the decision could mean abandoning its policy of avoiding confrontation with its enormous neighbor. russia's deputy foreign minister warned a far reaching consequences. the kremlin says it could send more troops to the 1300 kilometer border with finland, but becoming a member of the western military alliance isn't guaranteed. a step vast and reports from the german capital berlin, finland, and sweden will be warmly welcomed into the nato military alliance. that was the message from all nato foreign ministers at a meeting in berlin. except for one. turkey has made objection saying the nordic nations are hosting, but it calls terrorist organizations pointing among others at the p. k. k. the kurdish workers party to be frank on a bit confused. because i had a telephone discussion with the president aradonda that is approximately months ago
8:35 pm
and turn actually, he took up himself before i had the possibility to do that, that your applying for nato membership and we will assess it favorable. i thanked him and he was very pleased to receiving my thanks. for turkey, there was nothing confusing about its demands even though they need to stop supporting terrorist organizations. but offense, industry restriction over prohibitions on export permits impose to an allies such as turkey should definitely be lifted. i'm not say, wrist as a bargaining chip. i'm say it as a requirement of a lawyers rush as president flattered me. putin has called the possible northern expansion of nato, a threat, finland joining with double the border between nato and russia. but nato's minister sat put in, has himself to blame. after invading ukraine. they're confident the issue with
8:36 pm
turkey will be resolved soon. i heard almost across the board, very strong support for finland, nato joining the alliance if that's what they choose to do. ah, and i'm very confident that we will reach consensus on that. all 30 nato states have to approve the admission of new members a process that normally takes month at ministers and berlin said they want to speed this up to prevent the so called grace period in which finland and sweden would not be protected by nato's article 5 weeks as an attack on one is an attack on all. it was expected that as soon as finland and sweden applied for nato membership, the process would be smooth and swift. but turkish possession may now have slow this down. no one can say for sure when the tumor flex will be added to this collection steadfast and al jazeera in berlin, sweden and finland have beneficial nato partners since 1994 and have taken part in several need omission since the end of the cold war. let's take
8:37 pm
a look at what they need to become full members. made oh candidates must be democracies, have an open market economy and be able to contribute militarily to the alliance, finland, and sweden check all those boxes, have strong militaries, and sweden is a major supplier of weapons. once the application goes through the parliaments of all 30 nato countries, need to approve new members. finland says it already meets nato as target of spending 2 percent of his g. d. p on defense, sweden expects to reach that by 2028. ah. all right, let's go ahead and bring in our guests in finland capital helsinki. owen mcnamara visiting research fellow at the finish institute of international affairs in brussels and belgium. theresa fallon, director of center for russia, europe, asia studies, and in russia's capital. moscow popple falcon, how're a defense and military analyst, a warm welcome to you all and thanks so much for joining us today on inside story, teresa, let me start with you today. i guess the big question right now is will finland and
8:38 pm
sweden joining nato make europe safer? well, this has been a long time coming. i think we say invasion rushes, you invasion of ukraine. it has been a hinge moment. let's remember sweden has been neutral for 200 years, and this is a huge change for finland as well. so yes, i think that this will fill a vacuum that's in that area and the baltic feel a whole lot safer. there was the leonard mary conference in this tony this weekend and everyone was pretty much dancing for joy about this event. yes, there's a small fly in your me now with turkey, but i think that overall book, sweden and, and then bring a lot to the table. in addition, looking forward, also arctic security will be tied up with the baltics as well. so i think that this is when for everybody, and it shows how upset and angry the public was with the brutality of what's going on in ukraine. i mean, daily news about russian soldiers,
8:39 pm
brutalizing civilians. i think something just, you know, turn to switch in these countries that were traditionally neutral, that they needed to join nato. that it wasn't good enough just to be a partner that they needed article 5 to feel safe. owen theresa, there was just talking about how historic is this all is that countries that have traditionally been neutral would now want to join nato. i want to ask you from, from your perspective, if sweden and finland do, join nato, how significant a redrawing of europe security map would it constitute well it's, it's certainly, it's certainly historic. but whether it's, whether it's all that, whether it's such a big thing, well it isn't, it isn't. i mean, philip and sweden, i mean they both john the, the european union in 9095. they have been politically aligned since then with the european union and with the west. they've just been militarily non aligned, but they've been cooperating very, very closely with nato for many,
8:40 pm
many years. there is good as nato members, essentially in terms of their interoperability, the military operability under their political situ, situational awareness with the alliance. there is good as nato members, without the article, by guarantees. so this essentially just adds an extra layer of. 7 which would give them nato's collective defense on access to nato's nuclear deterrence, so that they are never again, alone to pace down our russian aggression like we've seen in ukraine. so it would certainly redraw the map of european security, but particularly insecurity in northern europe. it would make things, crystal clear weights, nato's contingency planning in the region. and this is good news, not just or society isn't billions. sweden, but it's also good news for all the other nato nations around the baltic. sea broader nordic states, iceland, norway, in denmark, but also for the both the states and poland as well. probably russia has said that
8:41 pm
finland and sweden joining nato is a serious mistake. that it would have far reaching consequences and that both countries should not assume that moscow would not respond. what kind of a response or what kind of a retaliation would be expected on my course, does not to write this at all, and it has very vocal. it said that this is a wrong move. this will decrease security in europe and decrease security or the to northern nations as russian foreign ministers talking about possible count moore trip technical countermeasures. but the crime one or more softer approach, which actually is the typical for russian policies in any kind of a century. the year russians are, is always the, the peacemaker. so the prem on said, well, it's all depend what really happens then today on monday,
8:42 pm
the 16th of may president bush and actually said that we don't have any problems with sweden or frame and, and then just joining late there is also not much of a problem to teresa from, from your vantage point there, how do you think the kremlin might respond? well, it's very difficult to predict. what isn't president putin's mind? i think that he is not on his pay right now with ukraine and so in, for example, it has already experienced cyber attacks when they 1st announced that they were contemplating joining nato. so i think that there has been a lot of saber rattling towards both finland and sweden and i think they've made their own calculations and they've decided to join the club when it comes specifically to finland. do you think that this decision means that the country is going to abandon its policy of avoiding confrontation with russia? well, no, i don't. i. i think that dimension can still be preserved within nato. but one
8:43 pm
thing i would like to say, i mean, the view from helsinki is certainly right now that russia has overstretched itself . and, and that is the view of most military analysts in ukraine. so it is very unlikely to pose much of a tread, despite it saber rattling right now to bill and, and sweden. it's from its northern military district. but of course, nordic society is if you understand the societies, it's all about the long term. you know how, stretching our prosperity for as long as possible the next generation and social development sustainability of the nordic model. and of course, all that needs to be secured. so we don't know in 5 or 10 years, how russia might look like white or russia will be more aggressive, even more aggressive than it is now. or whether it will have gotten the right bloody nose in ukraine and will have decided to amend its fences with the west and
8:44 pm
try reintegration with the west. once again, we just don't know. and the northern states been and sweden they don't know either . so natal membership really is to lock down, their prosperity locked down their social progress for the long term. it's not really about the short term, even though as theresa. i think a said that a switch has split, but it, but it is with a long term with a long term outlook. if that is not too paradoxical, probably no. go ahead are to that. but, but if i can just finally, if i can just just briefly, i just reply this to your question that yeah and obviously in the long term picture, finn and sweden populations are very, very angry right now. but if russia wants to, we'll back from it's aggression, i'm sure both states will keep the door open. we'll keep the channel for dialogue
8:45 pm
open to talk russia out of some of it's brutal aggression that we're seeing in ukraine right now. probably despite what russia might be saying publicly, just how concerned is moscow about the possibility of finland and sweden joining nato, lose the plastic. oh, no things that russia to not deal at the same time with ukraine and the, the expansion of finland and sweden joining nato. they're simply not enough. my capability for all those talk about military technical measures being taken. well, not much can be taken all the conventional capabilities are more or less used right now, new brandishing the nuclear deterrence. well, yes, it's there, but there was always been there, so not much russia can do. and that's why president bush it was on monday 16th may was very, very, kind of a soft. he said, i would say, he said that we don't have
8:46 pm
a problem with these countries. if they join a to that doesn't change anything, much of a formality of joining. but later on if there's american because of course, rush is really a 0 on right. now, the grandma on american, the stand off with the united states and nato, as it says, is an american weapon aimed at russia. so american missiles or any kind of other infrastructure appearing in finland and sladen, that means russia will react again if it has the capability and deals with ukraine or doesn't deal with the upgrade. so that's kind of postpone to the future right now for russia will not really do anything drastic. there was some here expressed, especially in finland, russia good years. this great period when for england has applied for a membership, but this doesn't yet have for the formality of the article. 5 guarantees that
8:47 pm
russia could make some kind of move with that's not happening with the russian simply does not have the capability to do that. right. now, even if it did one deal with their parents, it doesn't want to do right now. so it's gone right now. it's not going further than a rhetoric. teresa, a turkey has expressed reservations about offended and sweden. joining nato are they have objections and they've laid out some demands. i want to ask you, from your perspective, is this something that's going to present a major hiccup when it comes to the accession of sweden and finland to nato is, is something that could delay things or will, will everybody was involved be able to get past this and based here in brussels and i think a lot of people are rather surprised by this because security is such a important issue that all of these conversations happened. for example, the prime minister of finland noticed that they spoke to turkey back in april and
8:48 pm
are gone so that they would support finish joining finland's, joining of nato. so i think everyone's been taken aback like this, and it's not something you can mess around with. i mean, if you give kind of, if you kind of assert that you're going to join nato and then a country blocks your membership because they know you need unity. all 30 members must agree. so that turkey is kind of maybe forcing them to twist in the went, i know many leaders said that this is something that will be required conversation that this is nothing to be concerned about. but i think it sends that worrying message to my mind from turkey, that there might be using this as an opportunity to use a leverage and get what they want. but i think that, you know, as the alliance and not really the smartest move at this point, and there has been a lot of good will in many respects with bio tar the, the incredible turkish jones that they have been supplying to ukraine. so i think
8:49 pm
that's already gone, maybe overplayed his hand at this point, but let's see, maybe everything can be smoothed over. maybe there was a misunderstanding, but i think that you know, security issues defense issues are a really very, very serious and that this kind of horse trading should be done in public. or when it's being reported. the turkeys objections focus on what it considers to be both finland and sweden's leniency towards the kurdistan workers. part of the p k. k. a group that they consider to be what they call a terrorist organization. is there a lot of concern in finland right now that, that this could delay things that this could be a major hiccup? well, it is true so that there is some sympathy towards the p k. k. a . from some sections of the finish and swedish political to sit systems. but
8:50 pm
not all. we've seen out a trick like this pulled before by president out of the home. he did it just before nato's 70 anniversary meeting in london right at the end in december 2019. there was a lot of where he tried to do the same thing unless unless the rest of nato recognizes the p. k is terrorist, then he would block extra defense provisions for nato's enhanced over presence for the both the states and poland. he's kind of making a domestic point on that. he's not happy about the ally of the land regarding other perceptions of the p k. k. with a nato that he's a strong man as the always projects himself. but there's often a lot of diplomacy taking place behind the scenes. he was taught down at the end of 2019, and the mood in stock on the mood in helsinki is that they have a no and there is a not would in the, the alliance to talk him down this time as well. or the gone on turkey are,
8:51 pm
are quite isolated on right now. you know there strategically very important oper, western strategic interest in ukraine us, ter, theresa mentioned. but of course it is not in arrogant interest to be isolated within nato either. and if i could also follow up with you, if things are able to get back on track now if things are able to be smoothed over when it comes to turkeys. objections, how long might the accession to nato take when it comes to finland and sweden? so what we're looking at now, and in the next week or 2, we're looking at phil and, and sweden filing their applications for nato membership. it is likely then that spin london, sweden will be issued an invitation to join nato at ne hose madrid somewhere in june. and from there, depending on different parliamentary procedures and different parliamentary protocols, because of course, nato is in the lines of consensus. all 30 nasal member states will have to agree.
8:52 pm
there is no fixed time limit on, on this. but the most ambitious or fast track our perception on this is that i could take as little as 4 months from june and wider estimates. i stretched out the 18 months of 4 to 18 months seems to be the range or the membership ratification process. problem, one of the reasons that president putin was so adamantly opposed to ukraine. joining nato was that he didn't want nato on russia's border. but you know, finland has a 1300 kilometer border land border with russia. a sweden has a maritime border with russia. did president putin think that things would go this far, that, that he could be confronted with the possibility of nato getting to russia's border in this particular way?
8:53 pm
i won't send one that actually join the need to in moscow. yes, it was a bit of a surprise because of the relationship with harrison. he was always considered as a privileged one since the soviet times since after and world war 2. when fin during the cold war was basically a rush. so yet protectorate. and it was believed in moscow that that was very good for moscow and good for the friends. all the friends finish people have a very, are somewhat different kind of, or a correction of those times. they don't like them. and the finish military as, as the swedish military for, oh, all the time they were always thinking about defending against russian soviet troops. they were not that they were neutral, but not preparing to fight anyone else that so there's different perceptions in moscow. and in those 2 countries of what's really about what they should
8:54 pm
do and why cloudy can react so. so important to notice that russia for russia, ukraine, and for put in ukraine, is very special. he has many times said that the radians and russians are the same . people basically one folk and that they should be together and pulling ukraine away from russia is splitting there of the historical russian nation. of course, england was also once part of the russian empire, but now it ruined moscow considers fins to be russian. so there that's a god, there's a different that they're seen as far. and i also need go hand in the, in the beginning of the 2000 taken in the baltic states everyone soviet republics. and they have a border with russia. and actually they're closer to moscow than finland. and so that does not really change that much in the strategic out though the russian
8:55 pm
military, the russian general staff, lou sure will be say that this is a big threat that they need more money from the budget. they should build new bases, they new need, new weapons. this they'll be playing up this threat. theresa owe and touched on this in an earlier answer. the fact that both finland and sweden essentially broke there of strict neutrality is when they joined the you, when they became partners to nato in the 990 s. i'm curious from your perspective, would they have, have to have joint nato at some point any way or, or was joining nato really a nonstarter until russia invaded ukraine? i think that they are very careful balancing at and carefully cultivated neutrality . finland has a different form of neutrality compared to sweden, but sweden, historically, as i noted, 200 years of 2 centuries, hooton's actions and ukraine. how upset their calculus. they realize they cannot be safe at this partnership level with nato. and that the only thing that will keep
8:56 pm
their civilian safe because it's overwhelming, it's about 77 percent of the population wants them to join nato. this is unheard of and they want to do it together because in sweden, i kind of partners and all of this. and most analysts assume that sweden would be 1st and then that would follow. but in this case, finley is really leading. sweden is joining them and it looks like it will be a joint application. but i think that this shows that this is a hinge point in history. countries and for 2 centuries were willing to remain neutral in order to have good neighborly relations with russia. have recalculated that because of this horrific war in ukraine, and they see the brutality of russian soldiers, so they once more safety. and this is why they're joining nato. and i think that's the whole region we, you asked earlier about the landscape strategic landscape has changed dramatically . should this go through, you know, some people described it as
8:57 pm
a baltic. so you have increased security in an area that, that was a bit of a vacuum for security. so this will change dramatically. and i think this is going to be very hard for putting to explain to the public that are pushing back. you know, it's actually got 2 new members. all right, well we have run out of time, so we're going to have to leave the conversation there. thanks so much. all of our guests on mcnamara, theresa fallon and pablo, fog and howard. and thank you for watching it to see the program again. any time by visiting our website, al jazeera dot com, and for further discussion got our facebook page at facebook dot com forward slash ha inside story. you can also, during the conversation on twitter, i handle is at ha, inside store for me mohammed jim jones, the whole team here feifring out ah ah.
8:58 pm
just an authority is at an all time low you. what was that 4 hench hateful distrust . this is a battle about what the truth actually is. al jazeera investigative unit pulls back the curtain and reveals how fear suspicion and conspiracy theories have become the tools of the powerful were in a dangerous territory. and that dangerous territory was di. what happens now that we've literally diverge, that may well be how democracy does the truth illusion on a jesse either. in november 2020 austrian security services carried out operation luck. so if i opened my eyes and saw a machine gun pointed at my head,
8:59 pm
al jazeera well goes to vienna and grunts to examine events and allegations of his lam, a phobia. this is a terrible mistake because it affected some said 2 young families, austria operation luck. so on al jazeera, we understand the differences. samaritans have cultures across the world. so no matter how you take it out there, we're bringing the news and current to fast cut matter to you count his arrow generations. this indigenous community has lived off of what the rain forest provides. but when they discovered that their territory was being invaded by gold mining projects all along their river, the community brought a lawsuit against a po to us government. you've won, you wanna be unprecedented ruling obliges the state to consult communities over oil and mining projects that impact their land and to seek their consent. the tiny
9:00 pm
seemingly community has won a huge battle, but may not necessarily have the last word. since the court ruling does leave room for exceptions in the name of overriding national interests. ah, this is al jazeera ah, hello, i'm adrian for the good. this is lisa live from doha, coming up in the next 60 minutes, just leaders in occupied east jerusalem condemn israeli forces for attacking mourners at the funeral. procession of houses who are a journalist, surely novel, our clear view security camera footage of the moment. that is where the forces storm st. joseph hospital where shall be installed to have been life. partial is
9:01 pm
29 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/380d2/380d23e594f017818b27bcb79e8610c33615f337" alt=""