tv Inside Story Al Jazeera September 5, 2022 8:30pm-9:01pm AST
8:30 pm
that were settled by free african americans which represent an unparalleled type of story in the history of the african diaspora. almost 800000 people across west africa are displaced because of ongoing torrential, rains and floods. monrovia is barely a meter above sea level. with the rising ocean, the slums are sinking and so are the historical sites. on providence island archeologist found the remains of vessel artifacts and settlements. but look at it now. it is for them race against the tie to dig and retrieve what they can because an important chapter of human history is disappearing as we speak for young archaeologists. full day there is a sinking feeling of grief to allow the last to seeing his roots, his identity vanish, and the water. nicholas hawk al jazeera, providence island liberia.
8:31 pm
ah, you'll see on there with lisa hill robin in the hall. reminder of all top stories. the israeli military has admitted for the 1st time that i'll just have a gentleman. we never actually was likely killed by israeli gunfire. it released its long awaited reported to her death saying that the high possibility she was accidentally hit by ready troops who responding to fall from palestinian gunman is where the army says it will not pursue any criminal investigation. not a surprise to sharina family, not a surprise to the policy authority, not a surprise to the palestinians that we've been speaking to and even not a surprise. within the israeli public, it was predicted actually that criminal investigation would not be launched. the thinking being that with everyone in israel, having a family member who has either served or is serving in the israeli military, that even if an investigation was lodge, that would publicly name
8:32 pm
a soldier and people would not would be loath to do that. there was also little precedent oven is really soldier being convicted. there was a case in 2016 where it is really soldier shot and killed a palestinian man who was already lying on the ground injured. he served 9 months in prison, but in any event among the palestinian populace. this was not a surprise. mistress has been picked up the new leader of the u. k. conservative party and will replace both johnson and british prime minister trust beat, former chancellor rashly soon like by around 20000 balance can use supreme court was or has upheld william router waited last month presidential election. his rival riley dingum challenged the result, claiming that the vote was ranked. a u. s. judge has agreed to appoint a cycle special master as an independent official to review record sees from former president donald trump's florida home. more than 300 classified documents had been
8:33 pm
removed from his residence, the f b. i says it has evidence that trump's team was deliberately hiding material and obstructing their investigation and follow their stories on a website out there a dot com updated through the day. i'll be back in half now with the out there in news. our next it's inside story to stay with us. ah, a is at somali as door, nearly 8000000 people are going hungry because of severe drought. high food prices and political instability is that time to prevent a crisis, and what's needed to break somali, a cycle of a dependency. this is inside story. ah
8:34 pm
hello and welcome to the program. i'm laura kyle. parts of southern and central somalia will likely be and famine by the end of the year. that's the warning from the un humanitarian chief who was calling for urgent international aid to avoid a catastrophe. martin griffiths who's in somalia says he's been shot to the core by the suffering. and so there's only going to get worse. extreme drought caused by for failed rating seasons. the space, millions of somalis, roches invasion of ukraine has made staples such as grains and cooking oil unaffordable and political instability, has hampered humanitarian efforts. they all grew polish. about frequently, a tax relief convoys. un has received just 2 thirds of the $1500000000.00. it needs
8:35 pm
to provide immediate assistance. we want the world to observe, to listen and to contribute to. and many, many governments has united states government recently, very generously gave money to the humana response program. we need more and we're going to need more through next year. life saving, which is the core of the humanitarian business, is what we have to do today in somalia. no question about that. we need to save lives lives which are at great risk, but or, and we need to invest in alternative livelihood, so many of the pastoralists, family, generations of living off their livestock have no more animals. they have lost their livestock sold or died from the drought. and the likelihood of further droughts will mean that they won't be able to pursue that way of life if they have had the generation. so what we're seeing threatened to the horn of africa as well
8:36 pm
as elsewhere, but particularly here in on is a way of life is under threat. and that means we need to invest in people for an alternative. i went to a site for internally displaced people and by the people have been there for 9 years, 9 years that they have been displaced. and we have still not been able to give the alternative ways to live and to live independently of humanitarian aid. it's a massive requirements for international attention. over the case, somalia has struggled with civil war, political instability, and fun. and in 1991 warlords, ousted president sidebar, and then turned on each other attempts at peace or several interim civilian government, st. 19912000. after bob has been fighting government forces and african union peacekeepers for control of the country, the group still operates in southern and central somalia. and now in the midst the
8:37 pm
dry conditions in 40 is you an estimate? 7.8000000 people need humanitarian assistance. ah. ok. let's bring in our guests than in mogadishu is gary l. me directive director of the heritage institute for policy studies as a think tank in somalia. joining us from dar 4 in sudan is michael dunford. the world food programs regional director for easton africa. and in bristol, in the u. k. is this all my g. a research associates, the london school of economics and coal for of famine in somalia, competing imperatives, collective failures, welcome to all of you. if you are a, if i could start with you because it's in parts of southern and central somalia where, where this threat of famine is, seems to be looming, the largest, what are you seeing and hearing happening in these areas?
8:38 pm
well, i just wanted to add my voice to the human, a pity coordinator. and by the way, this is really what this was come in for quite some time. while the community has been warning and also some government for the bus 3 months that it existed, it made one of its 1st decisions to raise awareness of this running problem. so at the moment that we have to just focus on rescue and as many people as possible, simply because it regional level where it's about 2 or at least the countries about to declare famine. and i think later on than we can discuss this is dana ways or the long term solution is for now, all the efforts on all the thinking has to focus on saving as many people as possible. so it's an emergency situation. just just give us
8:39 pm
a picture of what that looks like on the ground. well, i mean, by a nation of factors here that actually is affecting everyday life. there is the, the conflict that's going on. the countries side. we have you know, the, the demick that has had serious effect and also the 5 season and rain was actually short supply. so we have a number of factors that have affected the vulnerable communities and the people who are living outside the big cities as well as the beast and people who are already living under the buffer line. so the whole so called the resilience factors that are out of the way we are in a situation according to the people who are working in the humanitarian sector, where everybody who can do how should, how and i think he had
8:40 pm
a baby. maybe i should just emphasize the role that the the gulf countries and other places come complain because of that it went off, it broke, submit the data. i mean it's, it's, i mean it can amik or at least like we will definitely look into national response a little later, the discussion, michael marson, griffith you and him un humanitarian chief, said that he was shocked to the call. bye bye. what he saw. but that his concern is what's happening to the people. he didn't see the people he didn't have access to. do we know the full extent we know the full picture? i think we have a very good sense of the situation today. but as modern indicated, access to the population is extremely challenging because of the insecurity because
8:41 pm
of the role that else above plays with in somalia. i would say 2 weeks ago i met many of the beneficiaries that you saw on your player. and it really is heartbreaking seeing people who have been forced to walk from their homes. the day i even met a woman who was for 20 a day 7 children to try and find humanitarian relief, the world food program, the scaled up dramatically. but the problem is that despite the warning sign that we had, the funding has been slow to arrive and only now we hitting our peak level of operation. and i fear we're going to have to continue to grow that response to meet these needs. the value of the, the human humanitarian chief human turn chief, again, he said, somali is one step away from famine. when you looks at the last famine in somalia, back in 2011,
8:42 pm
you found that the us had called it too late and that the response was the full too slow. do you see the same thing happening again? yeah, i think there's no doubt that you can say the same again way. in fact the, myself and 3 colleagues who did the work on the famine research on time. and in 2011, 12, it put an opinion piece in elgin, or actually in january of this year. so at least for the last 6 months, if not for more than that time, we've been raising the possibility that there's going to be a famine in somalia. we can't necessarily say that the famine itself has been called too late because this recently been a technical assessment and they're predicting that the family may take place in the last quarter of this year. but that's in the way. sometimes we're playing with semantics here. the situation in somalia is already horrendous, and a lot of people have died already. and this has been going on for many months
8:43 pm
already somali communities from around the world for at least the last year. in many places have been raising money and sending money to their relatives in different parts of the country. and we also know very much where the most effected people come from. because they predominantly come from certain identity groups, certain population groups in southern somalia that with predominantly the victims of famine in 9192 and in 201112. i'm frankly, the humanitarian system is also must take some responsibility for not having called for more resources and, and look for more resources earlier when we raised the issue in january, this is even before the ukraine crisis, which is clearly taken away from funding possibilities, the amounts of money that we're talking about also need to be put into context because they are miniscule in comparison with the amount of money that was raised
8:44 pm
for in response to the co bid panoramic and for the crime crisis at the moment. so there's not way, it's not really a question of there was a need for more fund but, but in the end this is also about the political will, both from the somalia government side as well as from the international community. and that should have been an acting over 6 months ago. the cost also by osha bob is an interesting $1.00. moment let me just get a response from michael on that point that you raised that humanitarian groups have not called for resources early enough on the call should have been made 6 months ago. michael, what's your response to that? i'm inclined to disagree. we've been cooling and making it absolutely clear that we needed to move far in excess of the beginning of this year. we were talking about the risk of famine because of the drought. well, in the middle of last year, we knew this was coming. i agree, however,
8:45 pm
that the international community has been slow to make the funding available to allow wilson program and others to scale up. in april we were only feeding 1700000 that was purely because of a lack of funding. we are now at 4.5 because fortunately, the u. s. government particularly has come through the levels of funding require boss. we need another 327000000 just to get through to the end of the year. this is a huge population. as a result, it requires a huge amount of funding and i agree that other don't is need to step out. ok, fair i, what was your take on this? do you think? why do you think the response has been so slow? well, i think that our other international practice, actually the ukraine crisis was one of the main ones that so molly and other countries in the home were actually the attention of the international community
8:46 pm
that don't want to be particular shifted to a to other other context. we have, if you will be in war, we have other major, i mean, political event that were taking place in the continent. so that has overshadow with the somalia christ and 2nd. i think the other factor here is that this became a recording problem where it just happened every few months. if you, yes, i mean that there is some sort of at the, from the donor been expected. but that doesn't justify people or die. and now, and in fact, so the credit of them and one of the credit, the decision is of the president was the men or to appoint a some i mean on invoice that raises the profile of the issue. and they've been trying their best. so that ever they can, but again, this is the matter of priorities. donors just focusing other areas. absolutely, i mean that's all that's, it's true, isn't it? a big problem here is dona fatigue and you know, these international organizations,
8:47 pm
they've got to be careful about continuously asking for money asking for more more more. when there's lots of other things on the world stage happening. do you think this now is the wake up call that the world needs for somalia as a no e refugee council has said or do you think people are already awake and simply ignoring it? and i think people are ignoring it. i mean that the f word, the famine word is always very evocative, and therefore it can help to raise attention and mobilize fun further. the problem with the f word is that it's already late by the time that it's announced. so yes, it may help to alleviate the situation or make it, or contain the situation to some degree, but that degree is where we already have a catastrophic situation in many parts of the country and where we also struggle to
8:48 pm
reach people. i think that's the other issue is that yes, more resources needed, but we have also myself and colleagues have also pointed out that more could be done with existing resources where in particular we have difficulty and we've had difficulty for the last 10 years to reach many areas of somalia and with constrained to working in certain centers. and so that's been there's been a great stagnation around any kind of access, not just humanity area and developmental as well. and that's going to remain the case. and it's something that we, we've raised in 2014 actually in anticipation of the potential for famine and these kinds of disasters that one needs to be talking to groups like how should bob early on in the crisis. they all they have there are pervasive presence and they have a very well established and have been so for over 10 years micro new experience.
8:49 pm
how does the wsp access these areas that are controlled by groups that are not the government it's challenging. it really is. there are a number of areas that have the siege where we are forced to fly commodities in that adds dramatically to the cos. what we're finding at the moment is the populations are increasingly moving toward centers where we are even able to access them. and this is why we've seen such a large number of a 1000000 people displace because of this conflict. the challenges of access a very real in somalia today all of us as few managerial actors are struggling with this. but we are eager to ensure that to the extent possible, we are able to reach the beneficiaries before they need to move. and so issues of access negotiations with the various parties is key to us being able to do
8:50 pm
a p r i. one of the critical points that allow for a fun in to take place to occur is the political failure of the leaders. we've got some, all is new president declaring all out war on al shabba, particularly after it attacks the popular hotel in mogadishu. is that the right approach given the situation? is it not better at this stage to be declaring all out negotiations? well, i think this is not either or situation in general. when it comes to government is for the consolidated its power. i think it will employ both strategies. sure. force as well as negotiations. and i think due to the normal i on, on record say i'm calling for negotiations. but i understand that normally
8:51 pm
when a given state is consolidating its powder, also use some sort of salt or force. i think that that's just a different issue. this is stage at the moment, i think or what. but as an talk i did was, even, i mean, before the government was appointed, he appointed, i call you monetary and invoice that the raises the profile of the issue. understandably though some, some oddball. attrition is, are concerned that if sometimes you know, just wanted to f or family to use it, it might shift. all the development sector is, might shifted to the release. and this has been a concern that some politician is, i've been expressing this when i made them. but all, i think what we are now facing, the level of understanding of the government level is, is fine, but the capacity is limited and that's why they are calling for the international
8:52 pm
community. when 7100000 people are facing some sort of, i mean hunger, i think this is everything has to focus on saving as many as many people as possible. yes, we have to pay attention to the institution building later on. we talk about longer term info infrastructure, and all of these things now will come. the debate will come of the later stage. this at this moment, i think micro griffith and others are actually raising the the flag and saying, let's try to save as many as me, people as possible. i agree with that, and i really hope that the countries that are close like the other countries and also we play a role. now the heavy lifting is being done by the somebody else anyway who are
8:53 pm
sending whatever they can. but what is needed is much, much more than this i'll ship out, but that controls so much of central and southern somali doesn't, especially the rural areas. it only has to be a partner in relief efforts. but how interested is it in helping the people that it controls? because just last week it attacks of food convoys were killed. 20 people and burned 7 truckloads of desperately needed food. is it a tool, a reliable partner? well, that's a good question for me. and i think for many people to answer actually, and really what the raises is the fact that these discussions should have been, should you shouldn't, the negotiation shouldn't com, right at the, in the middle of the crisis. and these assumptions are issues that should have been planned for kind of months or even years in advance. so clearly i think about is
8:54 pm
not one single entity. so different that can be different command structures, different autonomy of different branches of the group in different parts of the country. so i think it's not clear how exactly they are organized. and we know that there are negotiations taking place by different sets of actors, whether those are working, to what extent they're working and maybe working in some areas better than in other areas. how much that joined up and all the humanitarian sector kind of presenting one face. maybe that's not even a good strategy. so i think, i think there's a lot that we don't know and there's a lot will be happening kind of under the surface that we won't know about. but, but i would kind of, i would also say that these are also the symptoms of acting very late. and actually these types of negotiations and possibilities should have been explored much earlier. and i don't think they were ok. so michael, given the situation that we are in, which is the emergency situation,
8:55 pm
what at this stage can the international community and should be international community be doing us in fullness. we need funding wi fi and you can only go level if we've got the level of funding required. and as i indicated, w p alone need $327000000.00 before the end of the year. but it's not just about the food, it's about all of the sectors, the nutrition, the hell, the water, the water and sanitation, all happening simultaneously because the children why simply die. because of a lack of food back combination of factors, particularly diseases and illnesses that will increase the mortality, right? so it has to be that collective effort. we have already moved substantially but as indicated for failed rainy seasons, the 5th one is likely to fail at the end of the year. we could be in
8:56 pm
a situation this time next year where there has been no substantial rain. and the population in need continues to grow. is the world ready to allow large numbers to die? i desperately hope, not. the only way to avoid that is to allow the un world food program and others to continue to upscale if separations affairs are you hopeful that that will be the response? i mean, as michael says, we're expecting the next 2 reins to fail, sees us into 2023, that the crisis is only going to continue and lesson. well, that is the general prediction of the moment. but i, you know, in 2011 department response of the time for key lead it and they did a good job at least by how big relief the problem by, by combining 8 and development. i hope this time the gulf states might be so
8:57 pm
without a b or a top or i'm and others can lead by at least the giving you the initial funding aspect of it. but also trying to how do the state because we have a state unless it's how did an, unless it is actually able to, to, to control it cannot do anything about i'm in or any other issue. so i think these out of the 2, we have a long term response, but also at this time, maybe these countries with rich economist might be able to, to provide immediate response while also learning some lessons from the past. which i think turkey can, can be instructed fear. absolutely. so immediate and long term help desperately needed that in somalia. we'll have to leave it there for today. our discussion. thank you very much for all august re i'll me michael dunford and nissan. deed for
8:58 pm
joining us today. and thank you to for watching. you can see the program again any time by visiting our website. the sound is there a dot com? and if i got to go to facebook page, that's facebook dot com forward slash a inside story, because i joined the conversation on twitter where a j inside story. from me laura kyle, i'm the whole team here by the aah. a son in prison,
8:59 pm
dissidence to inspirational leader from founding the independent states to fiercely defending his people from ethnic cleansing. in the conclusion of a 2 pod documentary seems a world expose the rise to power of the 1st independent bosnia herzegovina is a bag of rich from prisoner to president on a jessina o iraq, a nation where women's chastity is seen the central to its patriarchal item but out of sight, human trafficking for prosecution is on the rise. people have power talks to survivors and goes behind the scenes with a dedicated police squad working to bring the perpetrators to justice. iraq human trafficking on a just, you know, a flying
9:00 pm
a flag. but in the occupied west bank raising the palestinian flag could get you shot or arrested. there's also a court of the $8900.00 ninety's between the palestine liberation organization and israel. the bottom of the palestinian flag was but on the ground it's becoming much harder to express any type of support for the palestinian calling. one day there are no palestinian flags. the neck that's 3 are filled with. it's a really fly here. net by young men were not even born when these really government for the or the palestinian flag it ah, this is al jazeera ah.
26 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on