tv Up Front Al Jazeera October 24, 2022 11:30am-12:01pm AST
11:30 am
are obsessed with football, the the love the game. so i promise myself that i'm going to be delivering the best descriptive commentary for them. life is giving me the opportunity to, to share what i feel inside my heart that were vis game through my voice, and explain and build a maximum for somebody will share this feeling accessible via an app on your phone . this type of commentary has become increasingly common in europe, but arabic hadn't been heard a major tournament and celestial arab cup. audio descriptive commentary made it well. w in south africa in 2010, but this is the 1st time it will be available at the finals. in the arabic language, this specialized commentary will be an offer in arabic and english at every game. during this world, when we speak of the clutter was the top, we all speak of legacy was this tournament will lead to the region. and i hope that
11:31 am
the descriptive coming through will be a part of this legacy. it's about making football in the middle east, a more inclusive experience. just one long term targets of this world cup. and the richardson al jazeera, doha, ah, this is al jazeera, these, the top stories, olma, british finance minister, where she's tonight is leading the race to become the next prime minister, senior cabinet minister penny morgan is now his only challenger of the former leader board johnson dropped out under simmons who moved from london. if there isn't a to come to that situation, then there's only one candidate that's going to be automatic. more or less. you could see richie sooner becoming prime minister on monday. that's a technical possibility could be announced. but penny mordant has done quite well, but by no means enough to reach the 100 threshold of votes that she really needs
11:32 am
her. or has johnson coming back from his sunshine on sand holiday, or like a knight in shining armor, was really something of a destruction of something of a sideshow at the end of the day because many conservative so that he never really had a chance of winning over the parliamentary party at least 60 people have been killed in an air strike by the me and mon military in the northern coach and stays. the victims were asked an event celebrating the anniversary of the coach in ethnic groups. political wing august darney douglas, i shall sharif, has been shot dead in the canyon capital, nairobi. it was an outspoken critic of pox, dan's government and had recently received death threats. ukraine says russian allegations it may use an explosive lace with radioactive material. absurd and dangerous ashes, defense minister, of course, the voice, the concerns during calls with the british, french, and turkish defense ministers,
11:33 am
least a $133.00 children have died from acute kidney injury and indonesia and death are linked to tainted medicinal syrups including cough medication which are found to contain ha or chemicals. china's economy has rebounded out of faster than expected pace, and 3rd quarter of this year, the national bureau statistics has reported a 3.9 percent rise in g d t p. a risk remain because of beijing strips cove 19 measures. ok. as the headlights coming up next up front. from talk to al jazeera, we also do believe that women of afghanistan was somehow abandoned by the international community. we listen, we have a huge price for the war against terrorism as going on in so money. we meet with global news makers and talk about the stories that matter on al jazeera, the u. s. state of oklahoma is set to execute 24 people by december 2024. that's
11:34 am
nearly one person a month for the next 2 years. this we got up front, we take a closer look at the criminal legal structure in the u. s. we asked why the death penalty is still legal and explore the flaws in the system that lead to thousands of wrongful convictions. with 2400 people on death row and executions up in the last year. the debate on whether the death penalty should still exist in the united states in the 21st century is back in the spotlight. supporters of the death penalty argue that it is the only way to deliver justice against those who commit the most heinous crimes and can be carried out in a humane way. opponents say that it is unfairly applied and that it cannot be carried out without violating the constitution's ban on cruel and unusual punishment. so can the death penalty ever be justified? and is there really a way to execute someone in a humane way? joining us to discuss this is sister helen,
11:35 am
pre john anti death penalty activist catholic nun and spiritual advisor to those on death row. she is the author of the books, dead man walking the death of innocence and river of fire. sister helen, thank you so much for joining us on up front. 11 people have been executed in the united states so far in the year 2022 this year with at least another 8 scheduled to die before the end of the year. you spent more than 3 decades counseling, people sentenced to die. you've accompany people to their executions and your view, what determines who is put to death by our criminal legal system. when you look at and look at the deaths in 2021, it's solely up to a prosecutor to an attorney general or even to the president in the united states. that's what basically fundamentally broken in the way the supreme court set up the death penalty in the greg decision in 1976. they said we're going to set the
11:36 am
criteria to kill people that the government can take their lives. that is the worst of the worst murder, which has been impossible to know, who knows the difference between a quote, ordinary murder and the worst of the worst. and it was coupled with complete discretionary power to prosecutors to see death from square one. so when any crime is committed, when any murder a prosecutor is never hash to seek death and then along the way during the appeals, it is up to them to see it through and to see that the person dies. it's a fundamental flaw in the way the supreme court said the death penalty. and that when we look now, most of the united states to shut down the death penalty bound state, louisiana. that in the eighty's killed 8 people in 8 and a half weeks had had an execution in 20 years. we're shutting it down,
11:37 am
but there are pockets where we see killings like in texas because the discretions up to the prosecutor. and then when you, when you look in those states where this louisiana, texas, mississippi, alabama, it's not just the state, it's who in those states is being executed. it's whose death is being a green lit up through the discretion of the prosecutors. i'm thinking specifically about poor people, things specifically about black and brown population. this isn't a universal death felony crisis. seems to be one of particular populations. why? i mean, the legacy of slavery is with us. it's written in every institution. we have more, but definitely in the criminal justice system. and when you look at the over 1500 people have been executed in this country, 8 out of every 10 of them were killed because of the killing of a white person. a victim has to have some status in society and it plays out and
11:38 am
race big time, and black on black murder, hard to gives a blip on the, on the prosecutor's radar strain. because race matters who you care about and whose death you care about matters in this country, most people will never actually witness an execution in their own life with their own eyes. executions are carried out quietly. there's little information about the process itself that is made public. some states limit the number of witnesses that can be present at executions. and even they are typically shielded from a large part of the lethal injection process with an actual curtain that they put up to prevent people from seeing it. but what can you, can you been there? what can you tell us about what is like a company, someone to their death torture in the united nations convention against torture is defined as a mental or physical assault on someone rendered defenseless. and that's
11:39 am
a really big thing about when you're going to be executed. that you're rendered completely defenseless. and imagine these are human beings, imaginative, conscious. human beings, when you have consciousness and imagination, you anticipate dying, you die in your dreams and nightmares a 1000 times before you drive because you anticipate it. there is no way the killing of conscious imaginative human beings can ever be humane. yes, i've been there. i've been down with 6 human beings have been killed about 3 electrocuted 3 lethal injection. lethal injection is every bit as terrible as electrocution because they're the supreme court's allowing states to experiment with ways to kill people. oklahoma right now, with the people they are blind up, one is richard blossom. he said 3 last meals and almost killed 3,
11:40 am
tom snatched away from death. that too is torture. there is no way you can say you're doing this. he mainly my big thing and being with human beings who were killed in front of my eyes was to tell them, look at my face. you have a dignity, no one can take from you. i will be the face of dignity and love for you. look at me when they do this, but mark, it's such a helpless feel and there's nothing you could do. so that's why i'm a voice out there. yeah. and it appears that part of why so much of this is shrouded in mystery. is so that people can't see the brutality of it. they can't see the torture because they're proponents of the depth who would say, well, the reasons not torture is because this can be carried out humanely. they say that a person being executed does not need to endure needless pain and suffering while being killed. now again, you've been an execution witness for 3 decades. you are very familiar, intimately familiar with the u. s. execution process. is there
11:41 am
a humane way to execute somebody? absolutely not. it's always going to be torture. and i gotta tell you more. this was the talking point. i had in my dialogue with the catholic church, specifically with pope john paul, the 2nd who came before frank pope francis. then i took him there. i said when i'm walking with amanda execution, any shackled hand and foot surrounded by 6 guards, who can walk 30 steps, be strapped down to be killed. and he whispers to me, please pray god holds up my legs. where is there any in viable dignity to the human person being rendered defenceless and kill? it was a telling point i was part of a discussion on what the only one that influence the catholic church. but when pope francis and 2018 changed the teaching of the church about the death penalty, it was precisely the point of the vital but dignity of all life,
11:42 am
even those guilty of crimes. and we can never entrust over the government that right to think they have the wisdom to be able to decide who should dot, which now aligns the catholic church. right with the united nations universal declaration of human rights. article 3. d. an alien bull. right to life of every human person because they are a human person, you can never take their life for me. that is political rhetoric spinning that or yeah, it's the only just punishment looked at with the victims of saw that completed a pack or see about victims. they're going to wait 17 years on average to watch a person be killed their eyes and that supposed bring him peace. that's political rhetoric that's not to reality. 19 out of $27.00 death penalties. faith, have secrets these statutes on the books,
11:43 am
and many concealed the sources of their lethal injection drugs. most states prevent witnesses from viewing at least some part of the execution. how is the secrecy legal? how can you have an accountability of any accountability? in fact, if everything is so opaque, that is by design, that it secret. they have been the least to court cases, tried to make executions, public, and they have all been defeated. the, the basic secrecy is it's done behind prison walls with only a few witnesses. they keep the curtain drawn, my poor don't be jealous. williams, he had an i q a 653 years after he was executed, the supreme court decided in atkins. you can't kill mentally cow, and people yell fine. it came too late for doby, but they couldn't find a vein he was scared a needle to couldn't be with him. i was on the other side of that curtain and it was taking too long. they kept waiting,
11:44 am
waiting. they tried to find it then one arm. okay. they got they even have it. that's going to have been to science cuz they don't want to glitch. they couldn't find it. in the 2nd arm, they tried his leg, then they finally put the needle in his neck. and finally, then, end it took about what 2530 minutes poor don't be there on the table waiting to be killed. so we got to bring it close to the people, we have to bring it to the p. and that's what my next workers can be about. how we, the people are shutting down the deaf education, education, education, let the witnesses been there, get out there during the 2020 election, president biden promised that if elected, he would work to pass legislation to eliminate the death penalty at the federal level and incentivized states to follow the federal government example, amnesty international points out that other than
11:45 am
a moratorium of federal executions his administration has then very little to make good on this pledge. given that most executions are carried out in republican state than any significant public policy changes would need to happen through passage from congress. what concrete steps should biden take to have some progress on its own? these promises? let's come back some slack because he's handling a lot of things. he absolutely, i believe is going to say like, do you know this was the 1st presidential election we've ever had. where a president came out against the death penalty, even though mama didn't come out again to death. and he said there are some cases which are so terrible that you have to allow for the definitely want to allow for that your laundry, everything. and so he's got to take it step by step, i believe is going to do the right thing, but he's got to do it there to actions are going to happen. federal level and the state level. we got to work at the state level with the people,
11:46 am
but i do believe that the president that in the end will do the right thing and the right thing would be before he leaves office to commute all the senses on death row . that people will not be able to be put to death. well, we will certainly see if that happened style and thank you so much for joining us. thank you. great jim. from the death penalty, we turn now to another issue affecting our legal system. false convictions, back conversation coming up next on upfront the innocent until proven guilty. it's a fundamental tenant of the u. s. judicial system and it's the backbone of the criminal process. however, at least 5 percent of the car, so population is wrongfully convicted. that means that about one in every 20 judgments, put an innocent person behind bars more often than not. it's a person of color. there is now some recourse within the system, but exonerations are lengthy, complicated,
11:47 am
and legal resources are not easily accessible. so what does this say about the u. s . criminal justice system? joining us to discuss is advocate an author anthony. hidden anthony was released in 2015 after spending 28 years on death row. falsely convicted for robbery and double murder in 1985. he's now community educator at the equal justice initiative. anthony, thank you so much for joining us on upfront. you are wrongly convicted for to capital murders in birmingham, alabama. almost 4 decades ago. police force the identified you. they then searched your mother's house. they found your mother's revolver and linked you to the killings without any other physical evidence. as a result, you spent nearly 30 years in prison talk to me about the specific factors that you would say influence your arrest and your conviction. well, let me 1st say thank you for having me. but all the toners often did not fan are gone and my mother house,
11:48 am
i am the one who told them that my mother only smith weston handler. and i told him because i knew that i hadn't committed a crown. and now was brought up to always tell the truth and then they are told the truth in little did i know that they would get to go tell a lie like the gone match. and it would cost me almost my life in this system is a system. they treat you better if you're rich and you take a poll to report them. so adam, have the mind to high, decent defense. and therefore, the system, if you don't have the money, cannot convince you. but he can come pick 2 more easily if you're born black in paul. and when you have to rely on a state appointed turner, which i had to rely on. and so conviction was very easy for them to obtain incentives me to their knowing that i was in the suit,
11:49 am
they didn't make an honest mistake. they did it on purpose. this system is work in exactly the way it was designed to work. and it was designed to put me in the car behind the prison wall for many people. they can wrap their minds around a mistake. they can even wrap their minds around police, believing that you're guilty and being a little overzealous in closing the case because they noted got the right guy. but in your case, you're saying they just made the stuff up, they lied and it's not just your case. we hear about false confessions, ah, we hear about government misconduct planted evidence, this kinds of stuff all the time. it's hard for many americans, though many people around the world to wrap their mind around the idea that these things are happening wilfully, that these aren't just hard working. police officers who sometimes make a mistake. well, you know, i can tell people that are coming to town. this is to have been newly
11:50 am
from 1800 to the 19 log back in 181900. a white woman could say a black man or look to her row. he was charged toward a crime. no little dish. aw, minimum, lucy minch. no evidence. and so we still have this modern day linton. we just have a different so we're starting to see the reports coming out as people look into these exonerating cases. and we find the kind of flaws you're talking about. now on a positive note, is that we're seeing more more exonerations in recent years. ah we had in the right direction we shouldn't we have to get to that point all been exonerated, i've been exonerated in heaven not being offered or given one painting have not even been offered an apology all when i try and filed for
11:51 am
compensation for 30 years of my life, i'm told that since i was not found guilty about jewelry, i am not eligible to receive minute thing. so once the charges are dropped and it's been realised, effectively that you spent 28 years in prison for something you didn't do and that the case against you was manufactured. what does the state say to you? do you do it? he said they didn't a power as they say anything. they haven't said anything for mom will be honest with, you know, be only would to i didn't hear him say these words when i was told tale and we'll be glad that we just didn't execute in there. to handle that, just be glad we didn't execute him in him being the inward, they used a legit, allegedly that that is a, a that, that's a, that, that's an incredibly of, i mean i don't even know to say it's, it's overwhelming and it's the end of the journey, i want you to take me step back though. bob talked to me about the fight to,
11:52 am
to get the conviction overturned. all it took brash themes in the it was just finished it 16 years to finally get a court united states supreme court to rule ameritrade where they granted me a new trial and goes back to birmingham. the state of alabama cosy and is a young or it is with great sadness that we inform you that we lost going on. and so while we thought man was looking for the gone and the bullets which they trained me all, all they had actually old expert to come in and re examine the bullet. similar to the same man is saying in mac, started years a go 30 years later say the gone not mashed away at the in the for wow. as you mentioned, you didn't receive any money. you didn't receive any reparations. after your conviction was overturned by the supreme court,
11:53 am
despite the fact that in alabama state senate up proposal i was supposed to give you one point. $5000000.00 of compensation for wrongful conviction is possible, but it's, it's not uniform. it varies from state to state, not to mention the process can be fraught with complications as exonerate, trying to access the, the money that they are do. how is it that somebody can be falsely convicted, spin, decades imprisoned, and still has to go through so many hurdles just to get restitution? oh, easy. i will do to re live in the state of alabama and be black. that's the to do now. you know, i saw quote for 30 years of being in solitary confinement. all i will know will make it, you know, this chairman say that i'm free. i'm just release ashley and go through all the all
11:54 am
feelings in motion. oh williams, there's another execution. i haven't been offered to see a psycho psychology or they just opened the door and say, hey, all, try the liam the best life you can, but we mackerel helped you one way another i've said own death row, 20 years at witness scripted for me being executed i have to remind myself that i was so close to the, i mean it is a trauma to what you're describing so that it would sound like you need therapy. you need some kind of response to post traumatic stress from being in a kind of in the kind of that kind of context for so long. so no, so when i think about bet and 1500000 and i'm, i'm sticking there just for a 2nd because i want to go to understand what you need there for. this isn't like you're trying to make a pay this. am i getting a lot of re last 30 years? what? what does that money necessary for it that morning necessary for me to get out and
11:55 am
sign a decent doctor. they can treat me and perhaps help me or it oddly for i don't have all money tied up in his so security. i was didn't put anything in his so security for 30 year or so. they are who i am that's coming out. all i needed to live on because who has some one they've been on there for for 30 years, have no computer experience tale, nothing, and most people is afraid of it because you've been locked up. lack of a cage. animal is system is, was design associated to put millions of call and we will help people to believe that we're dealing with mass incarceration. we not dealing with national concentration. we didn't want to leave foremost. there was a study by the american psychological association this year. i found that 80 percent of exonerated people experienced at least one serious traumatic event while
11:56 am
incarcerated and more than half of their group showed significant signs of p t. s. d. what should people know about the trauma that's experienced by people who are wrongly convicted, imprison it, the people that know that when we put innocent men, women are special and therefore all that traumas there will because we don't have the money to go out in the c k, qualify at all psychiatric onto training least kiddos back on the right roll. at some point it goes, hits you and you will all just cry like a baby. little scream, michael, are so long as chasing you. and so no one knows when i go to return, there's an execution in the state while about. all i knew exactly wouldn't it in made is going to revenue exactly what has taken place because i was there for 30
11:57 am
years on this is something you can't turn off and turn all i do when it is best. and i can, and i will more than in the same if the state of alabama gave me a 1000000 and a half dollar, it would come close to trying to make me whole. oh, it is just a shame that we have a balcony in this country. and me and women goals to death row and stay for decade . and a lot of states say you're free to go in there. see it. they all, you know, reparation. they owe you nothing. and they act as doting, giving you something. and the egg is so we doing your fable. we didn't execute that . you should be thankful that she should go home and be quiet. and yes, do i think that at any time they can knock on the door and say, i did something else they needed one time out of me. and so all of that plays in my
11:58 am
mind, even there, every day, all of these plays in you psychologically called uh, would they be it to you before? and so people see me, they see a hampton looking man, but they don't see his goss in the mill to the all they did is inside me, i have to be open there. no one else within. thank you for your work and i wish you luck. i hope you get justice and i hope you get everything you deserve from state of alabama. thank you so much for joining us on up front. thank you for having that is our show up front. we'll be back next. oh inmates learning from other inmate's acquiring knowledge that could set them free through legal education classes and mach tribunals that
11:59 am
dedication has led to staggering results you've been in prison for within the us in the wrist in that they was teaching empowerment can yeah, part of the rebel education series on al jazeera. on november the americans woven all the seats in the house of representatives. at 35 percent of the senate will be contested. americans are expected to split on strict ideological lines with abortion and the economy named as the key issues. the results will define the rest of job biden's presidency and put americas democratic principles to the test. special coverage of the midterm elections on al jazeera. a filmmaker follows her mother's return to south saddam. after years in exile, we came home and into
12:00 pm
a vice presidential position. my mother stepping into the role that my father died in will not be history, repeating itself. she will more likely be remembered for what she does in this new position. an intimate portrayal of a family and challenging times. no simple way home. people. as i said, i know what to us on a jesse eda. what happens that in new york has implications all around the world. it's the home of the united nations. it's a center of international finance, international culture to make these stories resonate requires talking to everyday people to normal people, not just power brokers, and that's where al jazeera is different. the mayor of the city announced that he was doing the way with the curfew. that was, it was to get everybody off. it's international perspective with the human touch zooming way in and then pulling back out again. ah.
9 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on