tv Inside Story Al Jazeera January 26, 2023 10:30am-11:00am AST
10:30 am
to remain confined in their villages. in this indigenous community, a per military group imposed occur few and land mines surrounding the village. mean they can't move hunt or grow from any more air. of course, the confinement homes are food safety. we can't harvest freely any more, nor go to the fields. the insecurity means we never know what can happen at any time. gustavo pedro columbus 1st left his president as promised to change all this, bringing to an am 6 decades of conflict with his ambitious total peace plans. trying to negotiate deals with all criminal groups, the leader of the government delegation hopes the caravan can be a 1st step in this direction. and we are most of these people from ali, up on the government, and it is situations on one side and the e l and on the other needs to build the conditions for people to return and remain in their territories. it's a partial measure and emergency measure, which doesn't mean we will not address more structural needs, but this is a necessary step to try and address this tragedy. but many like gloria say they
10:31 am
heard it all before. you see a lot more. yes, if whether we want to believe that this government will do things differently. not any say it wants pace, but be able to construct it because one thing is desiring peace. another is making it happen. the caravan will turn your findings into a report they will present to piece negotiators in february, mexico, who will then devise a plan to implement immediately hopefully bringing some relief to those who for too long of only known abandonment and neglect. allison and betty al jazeera along the san juan river. ah, you're watching out here. and these are the headlines. this. our ukraine's military campaign against russian forces has received a major boost from its western allies. the u. s. has confirmed it funding 31 abrams
10:32 am
tanks earlier germany announced he would provide 14 of its most advanced left to tanks, flushing you much than i think mister chancellor, old german politicians and public figures for their willingness to strengthen the defense of europe, which is also a very powerful step by the united states. ukraine will receive abrams. thank you for the decisions that i thank mister president biden. personally, i thank congress. i thank every american family for the tangible strength of american global leadership glitched by the best with the key now as speed and volume. the speed of training our military, the speed of supplying tanks to ukraine, the amount of tank support. we have to form a fist of tank, a fist of freedom, which will not allow tyranny to rise again. maybe at least 3 palestinians have been killed. anti israeli forces rated the janine refugee camp in the occupied west bank
10:33 am
eye. witnesses it a large number of security officers and to the camp from different directions. rallies are being held in several cities across a strongly calling for change in the way the national day is observed. it's really a de commemorates the rival of the 1st british that was changed for morning at the top of the hour. a weekly look at the world's top business stories from global markets to economies and small businesses to understand how it affects our daily lives, economic damage in counting the cost on o g 0 again, the u. s. has hit its debt ceiling that's triggered a battling congress probably can say spending must be caught to lift the borrowing cap. the president biden insist that should be no preconditions. so what happens next, and what effect is all this have on the global economy? this is inside story.
10:34 am
ah hello and welcome to the program. i'm laura kyle. the white house has sought to assure americans that congress will find a bypass and solution to avoid a debt default. that is off to the country, hit a $31.00 trillion dollar borrowing limit on thursday last week. congress usually votes and agrees to raise that limit as it did the last time in 2021. the stand off in washington this time scene significantly risky. some republicans have declared they won't raise the borrowing ceiling again unless president joe biden agrees to steep cuts and federal spending. but democrats on bunching. that's raised phase of a political showdown that could unsettled markets and hit global growth.
10:35 am
a republican economic with medicare or lower shield. we won't talk with the republican record coming around. let's take a closer look at what's next for the u. s. reaching the debt ceiling means the government isn't allowed to borrow any more money unless congress agrees. the federal government could run out of money to pay its bills as soon as june. that would pressure congress to either raise all suspend the federal borrowing limit. if that doesn't happen, some agencies will be forced to shut down or scale back their work. that's happened 3 times in the past 10 years, but even delays come with a cost, the dollar would weaken and borrowing costs rise in the form of higher interest
10:36 am
rates for mortgages, credit card debt and other loans. however, america's debt to g d. p. that's the gross domestic product ratio, fits at a 128 percent, and that's lower than more than a dozen other countries, including japan, greece and italy. ah, of more on this, let's bring in our guests and in california, william lee chief economist at the milken institute in washington, dc. laura blessing senior fellow at the government affairs institute at georgetown university and in sol, june park schmidt futures, asia fellow at the international strategy for a very warm welcome to all of you, william. first of all, tell us how the u. s. managed to a master's extraordinary amount of debt. $31.00 trillion dollars is more than most of us. can even imagine it's a phenomenal number. and when you think in terms of trillions of dollars,
10:37 am
it's really hard to run your head around it. one of the things you have to remember is that governance finance themselves, either through taxes and or by borrowing. and what has happened is that the huge level of government expenditures, whether it's for welfare programs or for defense or just for government administration, has resulted in larger, larger governments, over time. and be these larger governments have had the fund themselves. and they've not always raised taxes to balance the budget. and once you have a deficit, there's only one way to finance it and that is through borrowing. and so the u. s. deficits have cumulated over over many, many decades and centuries. are going back to the revolutionary days and so big now have a position where the u. s. is borrowed enormous, not money from its own people, but now about a 3rd of the debt is been bar from the rest of the world. and what steps to you as, apart from the rest of the world borrowing is that the u. s. has reserve currency, in other words, countries are willing to lend to the us if they're paid backing us dollars. and
10:38 am
that gives us a special privilege which in some sense has allowed us to run a much larger deficit and much larger levels of debt outstanding than other countries. okay, june, the whole world is in more debt than ever before. give us an idea is how the u. s. ranks when you look at the situation as a whole? well, because the federal reserve board has been going on with the interest hikes, the rest of the world, coupled with the impacts from the russian invasion of ukraine, is seeing ro arrives in prices generally. and in the case of south korea, the bank of korea keeps on raising interest rates following the federal reserve for the nation of new interest rates. so in general, a lot of countries, especially in the industrialized world, people are grappling with having to pay their bills and having to pay for their
10:39 am
loans. and everything that has to do with a borrowing scheme has a burden on these people and going further because the u. s. is in contender, the fed is intended to raise further the interest rate. we're going to see a huge burden on these people around the globe. i think it's generally assume doesn't at lower the data is not a good thing. but how much debt is too much that we have christian debt is, is a economic concept, but it's also a political one to and we've created structural deficits by from a series of different government policies. i mean, the united states economy has actually been fairly government spending has been roughly about the same percentage of u. s. g d p for, you know,
10:40 am
multiple generations at this point. the policy decisions to cut taxes in particular have caused a lot of structural deficit. but you have spending that have been priorities by both parties has created this current state of affairs. economists certainly have different levels of debt that they find to be concerning. and i think everyone would consider the united states debt right now to certainly be in that category. so william, if the percentage of g of jet debt to g d p in the u. s. hasn't changed that much over the generations. why does the u. s. both are having a debt ceiling? yeah. that the levels of spending a taxation delta g to have been roughly the same. but unfortunately spending has always exceeded the level of revenues and taxes. and so what you find in the case to not states is that you are finding it difficult to finance more and more of this debt because the rest of the world and us citizens in general,
10:41 am
are less willing to hold on to the stead because of concerns about not getting paid off. now, as i said earlier, by definition u. s. is able to pay off it's, that's with you was dollars. and by printing more us dollars, we can always pay off the debt. unfortunately, one consequence of doing that would be higher and higher inflation, which is a consequence that no government's willing to accept. so. so one of the things that we have to consider in managing the levels of us that would be what is sustainable . and at the i m f, where used to work, there are formulas that are used to calculate sustainable levels of debt with low interest rates as they are now, even though they're rising, they're still low enough that the u. s. levels of. busy are more than sustainable, we are able to pay our interest payments are in a fairly easy fashion. and, and so the question really comes down to the point of politics. what government is willing to cut back on expenditures in order to limit the him out of debt that's issued. and right now the republicans are asking democrats,
10:42 am
you've got to cut back on entitlements that is spending that is made made permanent by, by legislation. and the, and the democrats are say no, because our people need these entitlements cut back on something else. cut back on defense, and so the debate in congress is going back and forth about where the cut and that ceiling has been used as a hostage of for these discussions in order to get one site to move on or the other site to move so long we've had the treasury section on it yet yet, and it implements some extraordinary measures to tie the u. s. over until she says about june. so is william says the focus now is on congress, isn't it to source out this issue for a longer term, and you've got this north of hard core republicans suddenly in the house of representatives on the one side. and you've got a very stubborn sounding joe biden. leading the democrats on the other. so who's gonna, who's going to give in, what's gonna happen here?
10:43 am
an excellent question, and we've seen a this is, has become a particularly familiar dance, but i think we've become a little bit to in your, to and, but we've been having kind of partisan fight concerning the debt ceiling where a majority of one party is lining up against the other since 1953. i really want to underscore the bitches. i. you know, there's no kind of good era for the debt chewing. it's also not designed to result in fiscal restraint. if it was actually designed to give the treasury more flexibility when it's originally created in 1917. and we were also perfectly capable of raising it without having any effect on government, taxing or spending. of course, it's being used as a tool to, you know, try to bring people to the table in terms of having some larger part bargain. you know, obama and, and speaker banner banner famously attempted and failed at a grand bargain, a terrain in federal spending. but there is,
10:44 am
there is no requirement that you actually do any legislating of around spending and taxing and i want to put taxing on the, on the table to not just spending cuts, you know, because it's a, it's a math problem. you can, you can add and subtract. but you know, we, this is not a circumstance that is particularly fortuitous for, you know, calm and measured, expert policy making. when you engage in this level of gratian ship, and in fact it's never been use successfully as a tool for fiscal restraint. and in the meantime, during the rest of the world watches and whole that breath, i mean, what about the country? think of the u. s. when it watches the brinkman ship play out in the 11th hour. so regarding the treasury bonds that are issued in order to secure government expenditure and budgets. many of the foreign countries that hold
10:45 am
us treasury bills. they've been scaling back, especially japan and china in the past months hasn't happened, scaling back the amount of their teeth people purchases. and it also has to do with the fact that the fed has been increasing its interest rate because the overall impact that the us economy has on 2 other countries is very much correlated associated with the amounts of the liabilities of the u. s. has onto these countries and it could be the case that into the coming was they could scale back even further. and we, we won't know until june, how do the, how the congress would react in response to the ceiling. but the chances are there with the very, very harsh criticisms from china regarding the typical discipline william,
10:46 am
the japan, china, they hold most of the us treasury bonds. don't they generally seen across the world as robust as you mentioned earlier. but we have not so much the case now. what impact does that have? well, let's, let's remember why it is that other countries, whole u. s. treasury's and your stat securities in general, it's because they've been running our current account, treat surpluses with united states. in other words, they've exported more to us and that they've important from us. and this imbalance is resulted in accepting u. s. dollars as payment for their exports. and in order to invest these dollars to earn some interest, they have what u. s. charges because of all financial assets that are denominated us dollars. it is the most safe, is the most secure because of the u. s. credit worthiness. the belief that the u. s . will always pay it's dead obligations, whether this interest payments or, or rolling over the debt. but the debt ceiling puts that in question. and i think one of the things to remember also is that the us treasury security is the
10:47 am
foundation of pricing for all of the securities in the world. so. so the consequences for the rest of the world goes beyond the amount of debt that's held by japan. or, or u, k, or, or, or china, it really is the, at the basis of all financial instrument pricing. in other words, everything that's issued, whether it's in, by emerging market countries or, or by, by the euro area. every security is priced based upon the price. that's a credit worthiness of us treasury so. so that's very important thing to keep in mind is that, that the jet that discussions about the possibility of not paying us interest or is something that will shape the global financial markets towards very cool assets on the planet. they're priced in relation, not they to us treasury bonds. so if the u. s. does defaults, what's, what happened? the entire financial world becomes riskier. well, as we have been in the case of the 2011, that feeling crisis,
10:48 am
i think there is a possibility for a last minute cap increase. or there could be some other avenues or of policy action by the us government that we don't know yet. it's, it's not something that we can anticipate at this moment because it will be played out until june. but let us look ahead hypothetically say that that doesn't happen. that soothing does not increase. would you, do you agree with that? lord, you agree that that scenario simply cannot exist. it would be catastrophic. it would be absolutely economically catastrophic to the united states as well as to the rest of the world. and historically, what has happened is the threat of that cast or has prompted action, even if l b a last minute action in episode such as 2011 were you know, what had previously been a, a, you know, partisan but not perilous pattern of raising the debt ceiling. busy you know,
10:49 am
all of a sudden i became genuinely dangerous. you know, historically the pattern is. busy these folks play with fire, but come together at the last minute and we are shaping up to what have potentially are most dangerous episode yet. just given the coordination challenges in congress, we have a lot of coordination. difficulties in the house of representatives which the world has seen. busy play out with the speakership, vote or vote. rather i would say. 4 but, but, and you know, while the houses the more worrisome chamber i, you know, it's also going to be difficult in the senate. you know, they've got 51 senators. you know, unless you attached to a reconciliation package, which will happen. this is something that you're going to need 60 senators to vote for, you know, in december of 2021 they had, this is perfectly highly unusual episode where they had a filibuster, cargo. so they, you know,
10:50 am
created mechanism by which they could raise the debt ceiling without having a single republican senator vote for it. so the house will be particularly difficult, but the senate is not going to be a cakewalk either. we should, we should genuinely b concern. and even though historically this has been raised, but i, you know, in the world and you know that the press is right to be paying a lot of attention to this. and this is an important issue to educate people. but the thing that i strongly get my head around william is that it doesn't have to be this way. it could be quite simply not have a debt ceiling. i mean, just you. thank you. janet let yellen has said that she would support getting rid of that ceiling, but present biden has said he is against it. can you explain to us why people want to keep it bullets? remember it when you asked the question, what would have happened if the u. s. did not raise the debt ceiling? well, it happened in 2011 and, and what happened was, stop markets crashed around the world. are all asset prices. the value of these
10:51 am
financial assets started to crash because the, the basis of his pricing on us treasury's was put in doubt. so that's the financial disaster that the world wants for void. the u. s. had a triple, a rating status on its securities and it became double 8 by, by standard and poors. so the u. s. really paid a huge price for that kind of recalcitrance in not raising the debt ceiling. now, why is it that every politician wants to keep that around? why don't we just raise the debt ceiling to be 5 times the level of that that we have now to give it more room the way they do and then martin all or but, but the reason why is because every minority party and democrats, republicans together both realized they will be the minority at some point, it gives the minority party united states leverage to get it's a political agenda across and pass legislation on. unfortunately, it puts the rest of the world at hostage to these domestic political battles. and
10:52 am
so the political science of the debt ceiling is really what drives the discussion and the dynamics. no party will ever get rid of the u. s. that's usually because it knows that if it's ever in the minority, it can hold up everything and sort of put pressure on the majority of it to get some of its political agenda pass so, so that history is something that has played the u. s. that silly, whereas you have other facilities in say the euro area, 60 percent of g d. p was the mandate from maastricht. the maastricht treaty that put together the euro area and allow the euro to be the common currency for all these european countries. well, that 60 percent actually has consequences because the euro itself is based on having no more debt than 60 percent. so when italy and greece starts to exceed these limits on other countries pull together and force discipline on to italy,
10:53 am
or greece or whatever country is exceeding its share of the debt ceiling. united states, there is no such limit to that. that is placed on congress. it's the 2 parties debating and because there is no forceful limit that can be placed on u. s. congress. no political party will ever allow that, that silly discussion to go away. laura, do you agree with that? do you agree that this perennial battle is here to say? i agree that i cannot, hey, circumstance in the near future where let's be frank, the democratic party would have the votes to abolish the debt ceiling. and i, and while you have had certainly both parties using it as a partisan tool to a show that they would prefer to do spending a different way or do fiscal politics a different way than, you know, from the other party. i, you know, i, the, you do, you have had serious voices, including of major party leaders in a democratic party recently be in favor of abolishing it or at least performing it
10:54 am
in a major way. so i testified to, to congress last february and you had a number of different bills that were had, you know, been put forward to either abolish it were to, you know, kind of blunted as a, as a dangerous tool. so in a while it has been used by both parties over time. you know, i wouldn't describe it as being kind of attend to the filibuster is something that you always want when you're, you know, in the, in the minority or when you're trying to point out that you have a difference of opinion from whoever's in charge. and you know, i do think that there was a missed opportunity for barton last fall to use the bully pulpit of the presidency . i to push harder for a potential abolition of the debt ceiling or at least some level of reforming. i mean, let's be clear, there are a lot of different ways that we could reform this to be less dangerous and it is
10:55 am
right now i would personally fail personally. fav favorite secretary yell and i does, which is to get rid of it entirely. but we could, there are, there are lots of different ways of blunting it, to be fair to biden sen, mansion. i'm not sure that the votes in the senate were there. but if ever there were an issue to kind of more stridently campaign on and try and try to push for or this is would have been you know, this, this would have been an issue. i would have gone to the notch for a while when they had more democratic votes to to make the attempt. i could see william is still very adamant that though beneatha at a bit of a be a change to this debt ceiling. but i just want to bring jude and last day because i don't foresee, i don't foresee them having the votes, right? anytime soon, the u. s. is not an island, it's, it may be the safe part of the world, but it certainly is influenced by the rest of the world. is that no pressure that can come from outside the u. s. to force a change to force some reform given,
10:56 am
but it's actions does hold the rest of the global financial system to hostage yes, the u. s. does not come to a causal conclusion. in resolving this question, i think the consequences could be quite disastrous, especially for the countries that are holding and the us treasury bills. chances are, it's not going to be the case that the treasury bonds are secured for investors. and that might impact countries, decisions to keep on buying and the willingness to buy is the key issue here. because previously there, there has been assured kind of insurance by buying the treasury bills for these countries. but the scaling back efforts by china and japan in recent months gives me the sense that depending on the geopolitical situation or geopolitical risk per
10:57 am
say, there are chances that countries would not be willing to hold them if they do not desire them. and that would be a constant very, very consequential situation for the united states. ok, well, we're gonna have to leave it. there has been a great discussion on that. some key data will definitely be watching out for in the coming months in this on going debacle. i think we should call it in the us, william lee laura, blessing and jude park. thank you very much for joining us. and thank you to for watching, you can see the program again any time by visiting our website. that's al jazeera dot com. and for further discussion, do go to our facebook page, that's facebook dot com forward slash ha inside story. because it doesn't the conversation on twitter handle is at ha, inside story from me laura kyle, i'm the whole team here. it's bye for now. i'm
10:58 am
ah. and i hope frances is set to visit the democratic republic of congo and south to dawn in a trip that is meant to heal the wounds that is still bleeding. will the pontiff visit started chapter apiece and reconciliation ending the internal conflicts of these 2 nations? pope and africa on al jazeera aah al jazeera with
10:59 am
all steel production is responsible for around 7 percent of global c o. 2 emissions. but a solution for this has been discovered as the say, b is sweet and largest sheets deal. manufacturer. martin pain is leading us as a beast charge to become the 1st company to bring what's known as far from free steel to market green electricity is used to split 2 to into oxygen, which is released into the air and hydrogen which is captured to use energy essentially, we use 3 hydrogen to replace coal that we used today in the preferences. and without the week a 3 though for the suit you mission problems in making. this is a huge project shrouded in secrecy. i can see the end product. so these are both, it's an extra cure i am holding a well fast is, is a big step for the whole industry. when we make these transition
11:00 am
54 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on