tv Inside Story Al Jazeera August 20, 2023 10:30am-11:01am AST
10:30 am
this is a region that is largely develop thing, but it's one also that is afflicted by conflicts, flip flops, people, some of those we talked to elsewhere saying that they fled up to a hearing that other villages had been a talk. what we do in all just there is try to balance the stories, the good, the bad, the i'd be tell it as it was. and he's the people allow us into their lives, dignity ends. you mind if he asked me to tell this story to cement the security of life leaders of the united states. japan and south korea agreed to shore up relations in the asia pacific. washington says it's not about china, but does anyone can boost? and what does it don't mean for the region? this is inside story, the
10:31 am
live are welcome to the program. i'm the clock, a new era of co operation. that's how you as president joe biden has described his meeting with the leaders of south korea and japan attempt. they've been in maryland . the 3 heads of state pledge to deepen the security partnership in the asia pacific. the meeting scene hasn't been to project units in the face of china is growing influence in the region. a nuclear threats from north career change has been out so, so i mentioned within uh is it carried out drills and time in these waters. taiwan, accuse china of intimidation or japan, south korea, and the us condemned. it's dangerous and aggressive actions, so sub for it in japan and naples, but they've never been friends for decades. they've struggled to become deep historical grievances. just look at the g, a political tensions of problem together. the biggest concern is china is growing incident and that includes the taiwan issue of aging claims. the island is that
10:32 am
entire train has not ruled out, forced to take it. the chinese military holds drills and the taiwan strait and enters taiwanese space, which type paces, intimidation, south career and japan also accused badging of aggressive behavior and territorial disputes in the east and south china seas then is north korea, and it's increasingly frequent weapons tests. so missiles have landed in japanese waters is accused of flying drains into the south korean aerospace. i will discuss this with, i guess in just a few moments with us this report from car like history in the making a moment unimaginable a few decades ago. the 1st official meeting between the 3 heads, the state, and the sign of improve relations between south korea and japan. the senate appointed 1st, the us, the president, prays to pay for what he calls more than political courage. seem like i'm happy is because i am this is another great,
10:33 am
great meeting mister president. mister prime minister i uh, we made this a storage place to make a historic moment. and i believe that to be true. tokyo and so have a long history of hostility and fort relation since depends occupations on the korean peninsula that more than a century ago been a recent months. they've taken tentative steps towards resolution and his trends and ties with the u. s. thank you. the meeting at camp david was the 1st time far needed to visited the presidential retreat in 80 is an indication of how seriously the us leadership takes their relationship to they will feel you see for the 1st time, instead of on the sidelines of multinational conferences, we have held the trial after world summit on a stand alone basis of numerous historical meetings have taken place here at camp david's. and it is a huge honor to have turned to page and it's history. with this meeting,
10:34 am
it goes to $23.00 or a 100. how strong today will be remembered as a historic day where we established of the institutional basis and commitments to the trial actual partnership today, i hope we will explode together ways to innovate, cooperation between korea, the us and japan, to a new plane through in depth discussions however, some analysts say the relationship between japan and south korea remains politically charged. china is an important trading on the for both. and beijing has already expressed displeasure with the summit. just are the teacher for being part of the coating. no country should seek its own security ethics, been some security interest on the other end of regional peace and stability. international community has its own judgment as to who is creating contradictions and increasing tension. split urgency in the white house says it's worked on the meeting for almost as long as president biden has been in office. and while he's made progress with previous administrations have failed,
10:35 am
there were concerns that with the 2024 election around the corner, any change in us leadership could bring a change of hot car leg inside story or let spring in august, nancy snow is a foreign policy advisor to the japanese government to professor of public deployment st. joins us from take care. in london, we have edward house, who's it politics. electra you college ox with. his research focuses on east asia security and korean peninsula politics. and joining us from washington dc is surely you a senior visiting fellow at the london school of economics. i certainly specializes in china is political economy. i will welcome to one of you and edward. i like to stop with you at some time, david, it is a venue resident with a history of a famous negotiations, if any of the bible describes a, symbolizing the power of new beginnings and new possibilities. i suppose it
10:36 am
demonstrates just how important this is to president biden strengthening the us position as he sees it's in the, in the pacific. thank you. yes, i mean this is on historic moment of protecting, given what has been done by law actually in terms of us relations with japan on to us relations based sales career since the start of the by didn't the station. but i think it's very important that we don't get ahead of ourselves. yes, this is extremely significant. yes, this is an historic moment, but we still a long way to go, particularly in terms of the individual biological relations between took care and soul. and was this a, this turned off for some, it ain't trying, cement, is a much longer term framework as well. so that in the event that any one of the 3 leaders is in these come office in a big a news is a next election. for instance,
10:37 am
these principles, these values, the shed commitments can still trying continue a pace, and this is all to the a t concern for the by this ministration with the upcoming us selection. next year you raise lots of points that good will come to those ethical is the next 20 minutes to say, but 9. see, i'd like to come to you at 9 see snow? well, this might be driven by the shed. perceptions of threats posed by china renewals career, but it's complex because it's not just about security and defense. you know, and i actually saw that the, for this historic summit, they should have led more with economics with sustainability with the discussion of climate change because it was clear that it was about cooperation and collaboration . and there was a whole popery of issues bite and mentioned having a youth summit amongst the 3 and the tri. lateral emphasis was obviously in
10:38 am
response to a try lateral competition. visa be russia, north korea, and china. but i say nomics should have been the up assess because living is i do here in northeast asia. we get a little uncomfortable with an over emphasis on security. it's a dangerous neighborhood to be sure, but the domestic populations in all 3 really are concerned more with the pocketbook issues and, and in particular in the us with the upcoming election. this could go arrive, although i am bullied by the, the interest that this has incurred across at least the global media emphasis. and i just hope that the populations domestically will pay more attention to both the defense and the diplomacy aspects of living in this increasingly
10:39 am
chaotic and complex world that we do monday the, the surely you, what's your perspective, how does beijing view this summit? and it's outcome the united states dependent sides. korea collectively represented 40 percent of the global g, d, p. as midnight, as you mentioned, e for russia, north korea, and in china where the carter party is here in terms of the economic competition. i'm not sure if it's even a symmetrical or comparative here. so the, the power of the allies is of evidence in these statistics. now this 3 parties have started, i think the station security and economic next those uh, according to the spirit of come day, that they prioritized our defense security, followed closely by discussions of economic security. but a couple of things are actually not worth
10:40 am
a. i thought did they have toned down the rhetoric so surrounding tie one, it started start the positions of the 3 countries towards type what have not changed and they support a peaceful resolution across the taiwan strait. and my last point is that at the meeting, although it did not, is so institutionalized the out the rise of the ation. they told however with the. busy our heads of states, a security military meetings, and the annual military trail was i think, 8 is a defect. so institutionalization of the emergence of the on a oh, we'll come on to what about certainly i said, you talked about taiwan. the thing that you say it's that they've kind of turned on the rhetoric. but within hours of the summit to china and carried out drills in time in these waters, there will be a lot of symbolic gestures. so just as we remember, very well with the speaker, nancy pelosi was flying to taiwan. so
10:41 am
a lot of these things are going to be both symbolic and strategic in nature. they are not a that any, uh, physical, i don't believe any physical or actual, a publication towards type one. so what do you want them to come back on the strategies? the a yes, i mean i think what's important is the trying as the rhetoric of to take the institutional arrangements as being on to china has also been applied to orchestra and also to the court without food dialogue. i mean, i think a show these mentioned bolts key is that in the comp david principal was needing to try enough full statement. we see the us highlighting it's commitment to consult in this tried call type relationship. but the biological relations between washington and sold in washington and take a main 1st and foremost power. now i think that's very important. i think that was of a clear jashka from washington to a new show. but it didn't want to budge into saying this was any kind of sort of
10:42 am
try locks was a strategic alliance, or as one might say, a default to collective security arrangement. but is it an effect, isn't it? it is what it, what it's doing is it's highlight st stepping off the comprehensive strategic alliance of the us, highlighted with south korea in the washington declaration earlier this year. and is also crucial the both away of the tele, china and north korea regional sweats, but also for the us to reassure its allies of south korea and japan. and i think this balance between the towns and reassurance is particularly important and has been particularly important for the by this ministration. nazi, i'm sure you want to jump in on that, but also ask you, you said that there is too much emphasis on security. but the point is that the summit would not have happened if it wasn't for extraordinary to be in security
10:43 am
right around the world. 8 and invested primarily by russia's invasion of ukraine. all right, and that did change the paradigm for japan when that happened. but i looked at security in a broader context because the prime minister, because she has really emphasized growing ties with ozzy on with the greater ation nations. and many of them are really agnostic about the conflict, the ongoing conflict, competition, whatever we want to call it between the us and china. they want to do business with those countries that are willing to help them, not just in a but also in growing their g d p. and so they have a larger plate of worries and they feel like they're getting caught up in this new cold war. and because she to, to has an ongoing conundrum with his own population. and that you had
10:44 am
the hiroshima summit, the g 7 recently. and so lensky came and, and, and so the discussion quickly turned to ukraine and, and russia, which is an ongoing conflict, but not the only conflict. and there were some of the he but kotia, the survivors of the atomic bomb who are rather upset that this piece city that is marketed itself as an international city of peace. that, that was sort of lost. i would add, as a public diplomacy scholar who was long, looked at japan's nation brand, a significant portion of the japanese people really believed strongly in their hearts in this specific brand, this piece brand. and so it's so hard, it's sort of threading the needle now as japan wraps up it's defense and security. i'm not saying that it doesn't need it, but it has to be careful. it has to have
10:45 am
a marketing campaign of public information campaign with the japanese people and include of course, the korea and people invest as well. it surely you do that is a piece brand is nancy put to is it more likely or less likely? following this summit? i think in the major development of the start, how that are relationships depend in the united states have not really changed what's made. the moments he story is really south korea's kid that's to a historic date touch with tokyo. and so china is obviously quite caught off guard in a way by died it's fail since may. so i think up from the chinese public opinion, you know, a lot of stuff that the hawks have been driven towards south korea. so. busy change your path to choose and basically are trying to spence, is that the korean can you sort pennies? solar essentially the endure hallmark of the tragedy of the 1st cold war. so of
10:46 am
all countries in the region, how could south korea, especially the victim of the cold war today, supports the code for 2 point. oh, edward, on to you on that one. a yes, i mean, i think the, one of the key things that we've taken out from this is a, this is a continuation of past effort protected by the self clean president. use up to y'all in his efforts to engage new hop personal with the tokyo. we saw this earlier in the year with quite a controversial maneuver with respect to compensating victims of forced labor and the conflict women from bank of japan next to clean peninsula in the early 20th century. so they susan, not for culmination old efforts, particularly by president ewing to try and punch off this relationship. and i just
10:47 am
to add on that point if i may, the language that we see in the come david principles and the tri locked will statement is very much reflective of south korea's own in the pacific strategy and self crease approach to value based diplomacy. and this idea of sold is that the pivotal state respecting, not holding the norms of the rules based international order. nancy, this, this, the tones, the faith and talking brought to tell us a little bit more about this mutual documented, if we could put it that way between south korea and japan where it stems from briefly if you would, and how much it is taken for both countries to, to at least for now it seems put it behind them. of this has been remarkable. i've lived here on and on since 2012. and when i 1st arrived, i had no idea really the extent of the acrimony, the, the sense on the korean side that the japanese had not fully apologize. not only
10:48 am
over the comfort women or sexual slavery issue, but also just in addition to the occupation of korea for so long. and i've traveled a lot to sol and i heard this firsthand, it was brought to my attention. it was not brought to my attention in japan, it's not chevrolet talked about in polite company. now there's an opportunity beyond really the camp, david's summit for people in this region to engage with each other more in a, in a truth and reconciliation campaign that we all want to live more peaceably together. and perhaps this is an opportunity for that not to give her up to go to war, but rather to come to terms with how we're going to reconcile the past with the present . yeah, i share any given the i'm going to you between soccer in japan. up until now,
10:49 am
how fragile is disagreement and how may perhaps future elections change the dynamic of disagreement. and i think the story co hospitality with the or cost city to happened during the 2nd world war is profound in the region that that applies not only to south korea but also to china. i think it just takes another japanese prime minister's visit to the yes of 20 shrine for the war, dead of, for south korea to protest against a private gun which will make a precedence you own. so a cum david statement quite unpopular in south korea. and so i'm the reality of sides of japan. i really never of fully account for the world horseshoe atrocities . we understand that it's decades ago, but it's not for me as well as in china. i think the memories is so very much alive, but at the same time i want to say from chinese perspective, chinese not sit there idly watching. you know this rise of the security you cannot
10:50 am
make. next is on the east of china neighborhoods. china is busy at the break, somebody in johannesburg and just about the rights of the time when uh the us broke, heard that they tons between just kind of south korea, china broker to deal between a saudi arabia and you run in today. saw the radios being fast tracked to become a member to the night spent the brakes summit so we can see a ad. so the u. s. a starts to garner more support in alliance among the industrialized economies. china is moving very fast and massively across the developing world. right. interesting is edward's china focus on diplomacy. beyond the asian pacific region, does us focus on the asia pacific region, leaving vacuum elsewhere for that enables china to grow its influence around the world. on the one hand, last thing you could say yes,
10:51 am
but i think that since the post, when the post for you, the us has tried to remain extremely committed to it. and so for the inside of the allies in japan and south korea, and i think china is very, very aware of this. and i think one of the things to bear in mind is the ongoing, north korean nuclear missiles, sweat. how this has been changed and playing out in the wake of the provider says we see, but the united nations security council folding losses invasion of ukraine. so i think it in the us does need to continue focusing on strengthening its economic yes . but also security relations with its historic calloway as in northeast asia and i think tojo and so um would one of that as well they would well, not quite clearly. yeah, nancy, is it based upon a crib in range of the north christmas?
10:52 am
all tests female because she does say that north korea at the thread is only becoming larger from north griff. how does this summits in the agreements? how does it fits in? how does north career fit into the and well, north korea continues to be the, the major irritant. and whenever the missile flies over japan, the, the feeling of in security here, and the support for japan having some better capability in defense goes way up at the same time, you know, economic concerns are prevalent here across the region with inflation and, and incomes of staying flat and so people you know, are little bit wavering and their public opinion. and as i said with security, we need to broaden it out and, and north korea is going to continue to do what it does. and uh,
10:53 am
i think the us and japan and south korea working together, but also working within this region to try to dampen of a triggering some type of an accidental occurrence. that is probably the biggest we're a rather than an intentional or breaking out. and also, and, and what's happening in the south china sea, it was interesting to monitor the summit and to watch the press or, and how bite and really play down china. he mentioned china the very end. but he said that this summit was more about cooperation and building cooperation in the region and less about taking on china and you know, militarily, so we'll see how this plays out. this is not a one off, this is supposedly going to be an annual summit amongst the 3. and this could be the beginning of something really quite special. but we'll,
10:54 am
we'll see in the context of elections how it happens. and every time they make note crew will be high on the, on the agenda. surely. how does china play the north korea? cod does everything kimmie? i'm going to have china is function. how does it look? and it's interesting all that it clearly shows are in the north korean k start. so new clear is joe political power because i present a bite and recently announced that he so willing to meet with the president can join one on one without any precondition. and also today, i think president biden made a remark that he looked for. busy a to meeting with the chinese president, she's in the later part of the year. so now they're trying to deal as put the us in the stronger position, east asia. and i think the next the strategy is or perhaps more real paula cheek. then additional, i think the
10:55 am
a bite administration's approach will be to approach of both north korea and china, one on one to try to negotiate based on the real position of strength that he has today. but on the other points that you just mentioned about the power overreach of the united states, across all regions in the world. as we know, there are many, many tender jo political spots in the world today. but there is only one united states uh, using uh movies name. uh the us cannot be everywhere and everything all at once. um. so there are security batch is left essentially show, particularly after getting some uh, security backend left in the middle east. and now in west africa where seeing india and mar, uh, so china is uh, starting to fill in a lot of the security vacuums, both with it. so you cannot make footprints but also with some of the. busy of fi,
10:56 am
strategic and political presents as well. so i don't know if the us trop chain china within the pacific of china is moving elsewhere. and in terms of develop case influence said would, how would you like to come back on that? the yes, the following just may say about the most career aspect of things we, we must remember that most career particularly in the statements, is expanded by giving you a chunk of the system of kingdom then has made quite clearly, but it does not want to go to the negotiating type law either with the us or with south korea. and this has been a repeat of freak of the state back to the evenings rhetoric in the past weeks and months. so it's all for you. well and that bite and has made this outreach, but it takes 2 to tango and when those creat just not wants to respond and does not want to come to the negotiating table, then we all want to know impasse. and no 3 has been very adamant recently,
10:57 am
but it does not want to respond to any of the us is coy use, which is the word does it use is um, on calls from negotiations and not something that makes the situation more talitha . and it's something that needs to be borne in mind that well, very interesting discussion. everybody do appreciate your input set so we have time for so thank you very much. nancy snow, edward, how and show you. thanks very much indeed. and the thank you to for watching, you can see the program again at any time by visiting our website out there a dot com. and for further discussion, just go to our facebook page. that's facebook dot com, forward slash a inside story. and you can also join the conversation on twitter or handle is at a j inside story for late in the clock. and the whole team here at out is here. it is 5 from noon. the,
10:58 am
the latest news as it breaks the sun later, right? the same problem, different pops up, the rally with due to coverage after the government signed up, he said we meant with a foreign millions of hex. there's problems in this area where this toy from around the world. margaret is do take your gamble when they 1st talk in these over crowded rick, if you both on fits, just say such a long journey. inspirational women together the largest number of young women and showed the entire nearing performers was the 1st to male z to play it in jordan to senior. well celebrate females and taking traditional outage
10:59 am
in a new direction. they go on stage, it's motivates other girls to join citizen. so jordan and egypt pon outages here across the us, millions of americans rely on conservative talk. radio shows for the use of the detainment diesel fuel issues for real people. the listening post tunes in us is talk radio, evaluating america. there is no room. and that's not how democracy works, is really just acknowledging differences that, that are already there because anything conservative talk radio created, the republican party talked to the, to fox special on that jersey at a time stop pushing today to sun when we talk some entries between former president and illuminate alice hodge. i want to see these things for themselves, and make up their own minds to sweden. this become
11:00 am
a thing to turn your back against announcing groundbreaking stories for most award winning. for my case, it's actually in order to one and from conflict, it's a more efficient when, when conflict sweetness on our $20.00, the 3 year transition until civilian rule. that's the proposal from new shares qu, leaders as a try to stave off military intervention. the hello, i'm kimberly how good this is al jazeera live from the ha also coming up thousands more people leave their homes in british columbia.
19 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on