Skip to main content

tv   The Stream  Al Jazeera  September 14, 2023 5:30pm-6:01pm AST

5:30 pm
and we see these law makers and we know that the kids in the fields don't resemble there's no seal late. that might be part of the problem right there. so right there, they don't care about us in the past 2 years, more than 250000 unaccompanied miners. pip reportedly cross the us border. the vitamin administration has created a task force to crack down on the surge of illegal child labor cases. but with a shortage of field hands in more young migrants crossing the border daily in need of work. that job might be more challenging than ever. john henry and l g 0. raleigh, north carolina. the other that it says al jazeera and these are the headlines. the number of people killed by the student army like flooding eastern olivia has now passed 6000 heavy rain for on sunday, cause to dams, to best in the city of donna, a, one of war. so then to send it on coastal towns. so can officials are now routing
5:31 pm
out any chance of finding survives is certainly is factory walk. and there is what city of donna describes, the chaos here work to win those floods hit and the, the got up and they are around 14 or 15 families that was swept away into the sea. anyone who is in the valley was swept away 9 other people who live directly on the coastal, gone to the sea, destroyed the car, is full. right? we woke up to a real catastrophe. we woke up and couldn't find any one. may god have mercy on their souls. we woke up at around 3 city in the morning. we heard a large bang. anyone who was awakened dead enough for sure. i must have heard it. the water was unbelievable. every one could hear it. when we went outside, there was no most city. it had been raised to the ground. in morocco agencies all still struggling to reach people stranded in the highest mountains, food and supplies. i'm now starting to reach some communities, but it remains a challenge. some of the hardest hit villages affected by the quick are an
5:32 pm
extremely large areas to prominence. human rights activist and call have been sentenced of 2 years in prison for allegedly publishing false information. and the case goes back a decade ago when they released a report accusing bundle dash of security forces. if coming protest isn't 2013 human rights groups say the charges are politically motivated. employees transferring hundreds of migrants away from allow me to do some island because it can't cope with the increasing number of asylum seekers. more than 118000 migrants have arrived initially by boat this year. and they don't have to take him off. ringback what is happening and produce it did baby represents the diesel view or it's political, cultural, social dis in the data but the values because basically as a loan, i don't know with the solidarity inclusiveness, the sharing is basically we have to go it alone. all the rest of the headlines stay tuned to out to 0 the, the stream with global leaders gathering in new york. the ongoing war and ukraine
5:33 pm
is likely to dominate to events. but is the international community able to unite this thing without? is there a comprehensive coverage of the un general assembly? the hi, welcome to the stream. i'm josh rushing. a medical i'm emergency the u. s. has approved a massive plan to drill for more oil and gas and alaska. it's called the willow project. in this $8000000000.00 development teams to extract at least $600000000.00 barrels of oil from alaska, north slope over the next 30 years. listen to what some alaskan natives had to say about the project earlier this month. at a protest outside the white house, i am sad when you want to drill or on my them. when i know that they will make the
5:34 pm
animal sick for the animals that my family needs to thrive on. i have seen bully tactics to keep people quiet. leaders raising their voice that you're telling us we are brainwashed by big green and individuals having their worth as an an and you back person torn apart publicly by their own community and families. the man who lived in the big house across the street behind me campaign for the presidency with promises a fight and climate change. president biden, how do you want to be remembered 50 years from now? 100 years from now? do you want to be remembered and known as the president who put america on a path to showing and stopping climate change, or for helping kind of go phillips, increased profits at the expensive indigenous communities and the rest of the world . so this week the stream is focusing on issues affecting climate change. and today we're going to hear more about the will the project in the debate over continued oil development in the artic with us to discuss this in washington dc. polly dent
5:35 pm
at the cloth, a political correspondent who covers indigenous issues with indian country today. in anchorage alaska neglect. hard to rec, president of the voice of the arctic in, in new p at a that's a pro development group based in the last cuz north slope and boston, we have philip white and assistant professor of history and artic and northern studies at the university of alaska. fair banks. i welcome to everybody. i think we're going to begin with you, cuz i know that those voices we heard at the top are not the only perspective here a year from alaska, from the north slope. so can you tell us the, the upside of this project, what, what are the benefits? it's going to bring their through a lot of benefits through the taxation of the oil infrastructure that turns into revenues for the nurse low bureau that provides for 1st floor living conditions and all of the communities on the north slope. so water and tear projects, police and fire protection, educational institutions,
5:36 pm
anything that municipal government or a city government normally provides in more modern cities. but north slope road does that for us on the north slope and has been doing that for the last 50 years. and to make it clear, yeah, your pro development polly, you've done some reporting with with locals from out there that have a different point of view. what are the concerns that you've heard? so um, uh, the mayor of next took um, uh, has been very outspoken and looks that is the community that is closest to where the development will actually be occurring. and after the will of project is fully completed. the community will be surrounded, essentially by oil and gas development. and the next a community is mostly in new york. um and is about $400.00 um folks who lived there. and now some of the things that they have noticed is a change migration when it comes to the animals that they use for subsistence
5:37 pm
hunting. and the migration patterns have changed on the mayor. rosemary noted that her son has to travel some 300 miles on because of the migration changes of the cariboo, and also noting that the permafrost in her community has been assigned which has really affected the community. and there are a host of other issues that she testified before the natural resources committee last year. so the us has a director of the department of interior this actually it made a person for the 1st time deb holland and she's the one that announced us we actually had the video of her announcing this. the president is taking action to live at new coil and gas leasing in important places in the western architect and the arctic ocean. second to the interior department will propose a rule that will recommend additional protections for more than $13000000.00 acres
5:38 pm
in the area. these steps will protect wild life, including caribou, and polar bears and guard the subsistence rights that are so important to alaska native communities. 3rd is simple a project which is a difficult and complex issue that was inherited. these are existing leases issued by previous administrations. as far back as the ninety's, as a result we have limited decision space, but we focused on how to reduce the projects footprint and minimize its impacts to people and to wild life. hey, philip, listening to the secretary holland. there, there is definitely a total shift on that. 3rd point. it is, you see very reticent to kind of announcing and those are what are some of the politics that went into this and why would that buy them administration that seem to campaign on making climate change a priority? well, why didn't, why did they do this? yeah,
5:39 pm
well that's absolutely right and just to start with the finance campaign promise of um no new uh, oil leasing or development on federal lands and so on. on from that perspective, this looks like a major walk back from the, by the administration. and it really looks like they're trying to save face here and i think that's why we see those. busy other actions, well, we'll have to remember that i find in is a savvy political leader and alaska is congressional delegation. has been very outspoken about wanting to see this project go forward and back congressional delegation, especially these are the cowski and alaska is congress women. mary, they'll talk, are really important for other federal decisions that need to be made for other, especially for senator mccallski, for the judges. that needs to be confirmed. so there's a, certainly a little decision on the by the administrators are, and you can tell that they're, they're not particularly happy about it. but clearly they thought this was the best political decision based on, on the context,
5:40 pm
especially the new york political context of the ukraine prices right now. you know that the, well actually i wouldn't move on, but can you just touch on that for a 2nd? why the ukraine changed the political decision here? yeah. and so, you know, the united states has, historically, you know, we had declining oil production ever since the 1970s because of sweetwater hydraulic fracturing it really created a kind of energy revolution in this country. and so we have been exporting vast quantities of an l. n. g liquefied natural gas to europe, to replace russian natural gas. so united states has played a new more um, you know, muscular role in europe and in global energy affairs. and i, and there is the perception with this project that the united states needs to maintain a certain flow of energy to be able to support our allies. and that, um, you know, you would see the last, the delegation and other site that energy is best coming from domestic resources and from uh, from the state of alaska. so i'm a broker,
5:41 pm
i'm giving this next question to you. i want to share my laptop with the viewers. i'm looking at a report from the i e a. this is the international energy association you, they are very pro energy. they came out with a report about how the, the world can get to net 0 by 2050. and in this report, i'm gonna share this here. it says there is no need for investment in new fossil fuel supply in our net 0 pathway look, do you believe that that new fossil fuel projects will lead the world to the tipping point for climate change faster? but i think that, you know, we're, we're in this transition period and, and you know, by and himself mentioned that we're going to need the resource for at least 10 years. we could argue, i think that it might be longer than that. so the choice to do it domestically, i think it's a good choice. we definitely appreciate it on the north slope because of the economic benefits that projects like this provide to our communities. you know, the only other option is to kind of outsource that to other countries. and i think
5:42 pm
that they're making the right choice with respect to this it. but back to the heart of that question, do you believe new projects will push the world closer to climate catastrophe? a torch clement test, re i i don't think so. i think the us is, is doing a great job as far as you know, the projects to reduce the climate footprint. you know, i think one of the things we could do is produce a natural gas that they mentioned, the tracking down in lower 48 that allowed for the reduction in greenhouse gas emissions within the united states. so i think if we do it responsibly, we can minimize whatever the effects are going to be going forward. well, people are talking about this on social media down this video video on tick tock. this is sunny or granite and i want to share it with the audience. today i am mourning the loss of biodiversity, that increase and permafrost on the continued coastal erosion and global zeroes.
5:43 pm
as a youth, i'm morning, the fact that we're losing years of our lives to dedicate to this advocacy work and a pill bottle that is ahead of us a morning. the fact that we don't have the luxury of previous generations to push this responsibility of a transition away from fossil fuels and contending with where so then climate change on to future generations and the generations that come after us. we will have the time to do that policy and in your reporting how, how do you reconcile? oh man, the, the motions in that video. the concern that that generation has and, and not just that generation about climate change and what's happening and not wanting to just give up, but also in the group. what are pointing out, you know, the, the local economic benefit and that they need that there. how do you balance these so i think it's really important, especially when it comes to oil and gas development. and it is communities,
5:44 pm
one the fact of tribal sovereignty and self determination, which is local. indigenous governments and officials can decide what they choose to do with the land that they occupy. and so i think when we're having these conversations, it is really important to understand the tribal sovereignty. and self determination is having these indigenous leaders decide what they want to do. and part of this is that alaska is a oil and gas state. and so the majority of the state's income comes from oil and gas revenue. and so, and part of that too is that alaska doesn't have a state income tax or sales tax. and those are also part of the conversation and in the north slope borough, the majority of the revenues and tax revenues come from this development and
5:45 pm
projects like zillow and in places that are so i deleted that. don't often have um you know, access to sort of economic development on these projects. you know, it's reconciling both of these of yes, the climate change is happening. and then also, you know, these communities need jobs and tax revenues to continue to uplift and build their communities. and i think 2 things can be true at one. now to if i'm ever got some voices here from youtube right now, we're watching the show. this is, jerry miller says, people liked have a functioning economy where they can afford to live a t r. c 23 me until the when impacts as indigenous people digits, culture native americans 1st. and then a few other people say it's about time we're drilling and the on one, john, 226. as this earth age will be long over by 2050.
5:46 pm
there's a sense of like out the for the places that depend on oil and gas for their economy, even with the report that came out the ip cc report that came out. that said that, you know, we have about 10 years left. but i just read a report about that this morning that showed what saudi arabia and norway pushed back in the negotiations for, for that report to come out. and i had this feeling not living in a place that depends on exporting orland gas that i'm held hostage to the maybe local economic concerns that the future of the the plan, it will be fine is not the future of the planet is the future of people on the planet that i'm concerned about how, how do you see a path board where local economic concerns, white and the good brought up can be reconciled with great or global prices concerns? absolutely, this is, this is
5:47 pm
a great question. i just want to go to what was talked to about few minutes ago with that, with the economics of oil and gas in alaska because, um, you know, so many people have this long standing perception that alaska is an oil state. and basically what happened is after the discovery of probate and 1968, after the construction of trans last the pipeline system, in 1977, the state of alaska rewired its economy to run away, right? we don't have an income tax, we don't have a sales tax, we don't fund our selves like other states. and so over the past few decades, this has been true. but what's really fascinating is that we are actually getting the majority of our income today from earnings on investments from earnings on the alaska permanent fund, right? this is our solver welfare. so we're actually more of an endowment state today than we are and we'll see. and i'd also add that, you know, this willow deal is not a good deal for the state of alaska. we're actually going to be getting less revenue over the next 10 years. because of this well developed over because of the
5:48 pm
way that our oil taxes are structured as a state. so when it comes to transitioning away from that, we've already begun to transition because of the money that we've saved, that we're on gas revenue, we've turned a non renewable resource into a renewable resource in alaska. has some of the best renewable resources on the planet. right, we have phenomenal rent which are phenomenal, some shot during the summer, right when we have almost 24 hours of, of life in different places in the state. and we're phenomenal geothermal resources . so i'm actually valesh that alaska can chart the path. ready towards a sustainable economy while still providing for the needs of its people. i want to bring in another video comment. this is from brenda to bears. she's with keep it in the ground. she's a li coordinator at the indigenous environmental network. that's a i am here at least once, she has a say. and the willow project is the next climate bomb. the building of this
5:49 pm
pipeline is going to lock the us in front of the 30 years, at least to unnecessary fossil fuel emissions. so ecological and spiritual damage brought on by this project is not going to be offset or supplanted. instead is going to put the food security health and identity of 6 the new p. f. villages at risk out there on the northern slope. the knocks it is one of those a new px villages, and they're already suffering from extreme pollution with the existing oil projects . what's going to happen to them when they are caribou disappear? how are they going to supplement their food with local hunting and fishing? with nothing to 100 fish, the will project is only going to devastate because fossil fuels have always and will always increase serious health impacts for in new york and indigenous communities in the region and around the world's indigenous lands and communities are not sacrifice zones. the correct use of phrase their climate bomb. the sector general the united nations. antonio gutierrez,
5:50 pm
also called the report i referred to earlier diabetes. the report this week a how to guide to the fuse, the climate time bomb. what are your think about philip suggestion for all the green energy that will ask that could be producing there? why don't do that rather than extract fossil fuels? or, you know, i think that the base for the reason that i represent that you know, whatever their transition looks like and whatever systems that may be available to put in place that's going to require an investment. we have an opportunity through the revenues that we're going to generate to be able to make those investments ourselves, to be able to decide what a system that we want in place or selves kind of goes back to the idea of self determination, right? we have to force a seat at the table back in the 1970s to build a benefit economically from the development that was going to take place. and then we have an opportunity to, to utilize that to, to generate the revenues, to move our communities to the future. so what do we ask?
5:51 pm
is there enough gas available right now with the current projects to meet the needs or newburgh brought up in one of his early answers that you know, the transition isn't gonna happen for maybe 10 more years, and we're gonna need oil during that time as well. what i would say is that, you know, we have known about climate change in alaska for decades, right. and the formation of the north slope, or up in 1972, fighting for a seat of the table. and one of the cubic meters in that transition was a gentleman by the name of evan hobson and haven't house and was talking about climate change coming from oil and gas back in the 19 seventy's. so we've known about this for a long time. alaska had a governor's div cooper and 1990 who introduced the climate change report to the alaska legislature. so we have known about this for decades. we have not taken the option that we need to for decades, and now we're suffering the consequences because of that. so i think the logic that, you know, it's certainly helpful to have more money, more investment for this transition. but as we look at the global landscape right
5:52 pm
now, renewables especially sore, is the cheapest form of energy that we've ever discovered as she manage. right. the scientists have done their job. we have the tools and technology in front of us, and what we need is the political will. and you know, we really need to be deploying these technologies at scale to be carbonized or economy. all right, here's another comment from youtube. it says, are they ready for another trump error? because biden will lose young voters, especially after going back on his promise to protect the climate. and i want to bring a one more video comment from our community. this is from j, p gay, the director of policy and advocacy at the, in the, in collective. and we are, of course, very concerned about the impacts to the local indigenous community and tribes that live in europe, where the willow project will be built and expanded. not only that,
5:53 pm
but we are really concerned about what this means for indigenous communities across the world. because we know that climate change does not happen in a vacuum is definitely puts us well beyond that $1.00, meaning meaning more catastrophe for vulnerable populations like indigenous communities, real communities and low income communities poly there. and i've got jump and go for. yeah. so one of the things that i really want to make sure is under to the context of this issue, is that colonization and america? same with or without you, we are going to develop this land and the indigenous leaders of the arctic, you know, forcing a seat at the table. i think needs to be a part of this conversation because context does matter. and capitalism and
5:54 pm
colonization has deeply impacted. ready and this communities, and so we see that here today. and so you have indigenous communities who are relying on these oil and gas funds because the federal government, forrest, this development force with or without the voice of indigenous people, this development would have happened. and so when we're talking about that, i think that that needs to be a part of the conversation as well. and then also when we're talking about green energy, you know their conversations now about with the mining the and the holly close, those are due to the next, the more pressure that's tomorrow show on the stream or toward doing lift be um yeah, for people like me to drive an electric car, we've been talking about oil and gas this week, lots of miles my turn to get it with the the lithium question. i'm glad you brought that up. when a good i want to give you a chance to respond to poly, do you feel like this is forced upon you by colonization in the u. s. government?
5:55 pm
you know, i think at the time in the seventy's the, they were going to drill with or without us they were going to extract the resources off the north slope. and then in order for us to provide for our communities, they set up the north slope where our early leaders set up in our slow burrow. and really in the new that that there was going to be the revenue that was made available. we are actually sued by the oil companies as well as the state of alaska and 11 that shoot in court to be able to develop a nurse little girl and have been providing for our communities ever since. and it is an important context that we were, we were forced into the situation that right now with the burrow with the alaska native claim settlement act and were, were utilizing the tools that were made available to us to do the best that we can to support the people, our constituents in the different regions across the state, you know, given the tory so if you had another, another toys like someone was offering you an equal amount of money for green energy product, there would, what would you take that? i mean, if, if, you know, i think that we're open to any ideas to replace the revenue, right. we could replace the energy probably
5:56 pm
a lot easier then we can replace that revenue, right? so it did. you can't have one without the other necessarily because then you just thrust communities back into potential poverty and they might not be able to pay that energy bill doesn't matter where it comes from. so you need the economy, the economy to be able to support the hey real quick, we got less than 2 minutes here. philip, we did a show yesterday about a new pipeline project and you gone to enhance in the what is the rest of we're all supposed to think when they look at the us starting new fossil fuel projects. what kind of wagging the finger at, you know, places like you've got a saying don't add to climate change. yeah, absolutely. i mean, i think this the binding ministration in the us, i think have lost a significant amount of leverage and credibility with this decision. at the same time, we also have to buy new ministers in passing the most ambitious and a and aggressive climate legislation. and us history. ready the inflation reduction . what we can certainly say is that we know there's a carpet. we know there's a certain amount of oil and gas that region,
5:57 pm
but before we exceed these planetary tipping points, right, you often hear about 2 degrees celsius, referred to and with the project, you know, kind of consults has picked us at about $58.00 a barrel which is relatively, i cost way. oh, and this is oil that's gonna be produced. and the 23rd is $24.00 as well under the 2050. and so what we know with this project is that, you know, the, the folks who are developing this are planning on there being a lot more oil and gas in the future. and not keeping to the carbon budget that the scientists say that we need to stick to. and that's going to be our final word out . i want to thank all 3 of our guests for being here with us today. and as poly perfectly set up for us tomorrow, we're going to be talking about new energy. we will look at electric vehicles and what they need to be more sustainable going forward. so i want to thank you for watching today, and hopefully we'll see you on the show tomorrow. the
5:58 pm
the to the team in a world where the news never ends. understanding what's behind the headlines is
5:59 pm
more important than ever. it takes listening to the people behind the news and to the journalist for reporting their stories, accept intimacy that makes every international story local at heart. i will give you that post of the take a daily news podcast powered by the login reporting of al jazeera. find us where ever you get your pod cast from intimate moments to major social changes from man's impact on the planet to the impact of mine on himself that he has with depression. and it's really i to give you self loved the witness award winning films from around an hour, which is the era every use. thousands of monkeys to use twisted into that per se. activity and conservation is say,
6:00 pm
the testings into main 11 east investigate. a booming illegal trade and the scientists lives beyond this on a tree, caught 2 of them on christmas on, which is 0 the, [000:00:00;00] the color that run the strategy of hey, this is and use our line from our headquarters here in the hop coming up in the next 60 minutes of the catastrophic floods in east and to be the focus now shift to delivering a to, to people that desperate to help the off to shock. so still rushing moroccans as relief officials,

18 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on