tv Up Front Al Jazeera November 3, 2023 11:30pm-12:01am AST
11:30 pm
showing any solidarity with those in garza hit even you can't raise the palestinian 5 slide because it's illegal. so this just gives you an idea of the day, the lights, the spacing on the an oppressive occupation. and they're worried that it's only going to get was from here. so i the height of all to 0 occupied east jerusalem. a whole thousands of people have been taking pauses in palestinian solidarity valleys and several cities around the wild. sonya gig or reports the sound of the fury, that's 100 zip codes, deport is stumble to protest against the us forces at interior like at base. oh, good by the intensifying is riley attacks on gaza, who the mounting an immediate cease via as the conflict enters it's full week. there is no sign of the outrage. a base in here, not just that is really ministry attack on gaza, but also towards the government supporting it. and that includes the us,
11:31 pm
a message to the usa is this for the savages at the helm of the united states to go away immediately? i'm not talking about the people, but probably be administrative is a message echoed into jordanian capital. i'm on, my protest is cashed with police offices a day ahead of a planned visit to the country by the us secretary of state. and to me, blink and emotions are running high in jordan. more than half the population is a palestinian origin. although it has a peace deal with israel, it is a us ally in the region. it has to spend a diplomatic relations with israel. it is urging an end to the fighting in human to the support as gab it in the center of sanaa in support of the past indians. despite being more than 2000 kilometers away. these have waited into the conflict, launching drones towards israel, from bangladesh,
11:32 pm
to india. the valleys calling for the protection of palestinian rights have continued in spite of the close trade and defense ties between india and israel. but beyond the political, it is the global public outrage at the cruelty of the war garza that is continuing to increase a tony i go out, is there a well, i want to leave you with some live pictures now from gaza. darkness on the ground that when night's was full and on a day with multiple strikes on civilian targets. israel has been bought at a school run as a you and shelter knowles, and calls us 3 hospitals and goals. i have also been hits and an ambulance convoy, but will have much more often upfront of the $1.00 cost the so many politicians want to be the republican party's candidate for to any stand
11:33 pm
a chance it gets donald trump, if our planet is burning and we're running out of time, why aren't we doing more to deal with climate change? our american politics just getting through the whole life, intuit screen for most americans? for quizzical look us politics. the bottom line. as israel continues is compartment and siege of gaza. tensions in the region are running high with the conflicts red and dry, regional and world powers into the freight. how big is the risk of further escalation? that conversation is coming up. the israel space ground incursion into gaza has raised concerns about the potential spillover of violence into the rest of the region on sunday and running president abraham. right. you see said that israel had quote, crossed the red lines which may force everyone to take action. just this week, humans who the armed forces officially declared that they've entered the war and launch the large number of ballistic missiles and drones and is really targets while his butler and his real have already treated fire over israel's northern
11:34 pm
border. to discuss the geo policy to the current moment were joined by met this executive vice president at the center for international policy and former top foreign policy advisor to us senator bernie sanders were also joined by me that we, i don't know, she's visiting professor at the middle east, the center of the london school of economics. she's also the author of the son, king of form, and repression inside of your radiance. thank you both for joining me today. i'm going to begin with you. a senior master official asked for help from its allies last week, stating we need more in order to stop the aggression on guys that we expect more. i want to note that we're recording right before his but the secretary general has enough of the law is set to speak on the situation, but as we speak now, what do you think will be the consequence of the more involvement from the who these and young man and his bella in iran. hi, i thank you for having me. um, at the moment is room is engaged in war with non state actors,
11:35 pm
whether we're talking about his bottle or how mass and even the who sees. and however, i think it's, we get further involvement by states in the region. then there is the prospect of war and moving beyond the a does a enclave. and also, spitting over to other more by some areas, such as, for example, iraq iran further into the gulf. and it is unlikely, i think that a states wouldn't be involved, especially the ones that had already signed peace treaties with is ro, egypt, jordan, uh, the united ar everetts by rain. so that morocco, etc. these have been very cautious and they may come diplomatic relations with israel for a period of time. but i don't think they are going to a enter war on behalf of the palestinians. and it seems to me that the posted is
11:36 pm
and does the westbank are the ones who are bearing the brunt of this onslaught on their territory and their lives mat, let me bring in on that particular thing about this. who's the question? we still don't have a understanding, at least from a distance of what it means for hezbollah to get involved in. it has been very clear about what is the response. it'll be tangible. but when you start to talk, when you start talking about a young man and who sees the conversation shift a bit, what do you see uh, uh, as the consequence of, of them entering this war uh, of striking is really target waste. as a consequence of it. sure. i mean, i think, you know, 1st of all, i think i agree with fidelity. i mean, i think the, the, the governments in the region and certainly the united states do not want this to escalate or expand beyond gaza. i think what the, who these are trying do is, you know, put pressure on israel to complicate the, the picture for israel. and it seems to me that you're on itself. and let's understand that, you know, the run does not have
11:37 pm
a complete command control relationship with the who these it's, it's so much looser relationship, although the war and human has enabled that relationship to mature a bit. i mean from a runs perspective around is getting a lot of what it wants. right now. it's got the region, the regions people are outraged at global attention is on the is really assault on gaza. and he runs, you know, rivals these other era governments in the region are shown to have very little influence. once again over what israel does. so in terms of a runs own kind of message to the region that we are standing up against the, of the press of united states and it's clients, that message is sounding loud and clear. so it does not seem to me that iran would like to complicate that picture to us defense secretary lloyd austin, has said that it running back malicious, have already made a tax against us forces in syria and iraq. the u. s. has responded by sending thousands of troops to the region as well as warships fighter jets, uh, nuclear powered aircraft carrier. another one is com, is the us gearing up for
11:38 pm
a larger war. people are getting nervous. are they are right to be nervous, but i think this is meant to send a message of deterrence meant to send a message that we do not want a larger war and for very good reason. because of this expands and escalates elsewhere. it, i mean it's all, you can already not control violence of this kind, but if it expands beyond garza, it could get out of there's thousands of ways this could go sideways. and i think i'm secretary austin, as a military man who's responsible for those us forces stationed elsewhere around the region, understands this probably as, as well or better than anyone in the government. but there's 2 ways to look at this, right. you sent of worship. and it says, you know what, this is a sign that they, they are prepared for. they are looking for war. they want war and the other side of it is now we're, we're, we're, we're preparing and nothing of a sufficient defense. so that we dissuade people from engaging, further escalating further. which one is it? well, i'm not sure that the uh us carriers are determined for escalating
Documents
11:39 pm
11:40 pm
11:41 pm
how to do with the critical what is the critically entered and is still in the o. r, y, and the i, the field often assad when the underlines were on their way back to, you know, more and when they arrived at l. shufa medical center for the israel, she targeted directly to the 2nd vehicle. yeah. if you have an awful lot in this coming voice, let them know you know, the better but much. but however, this time they committed a massacre horrific massacre. and due to the board, sure of the whole world. so i show to show you that resulted in the death of 15 persons and over 16 injured people, a bona. judging by the city, the whole world looked good for me. if i should not remain silent in front of those of my security saw. and those facts i left is something that we will state no,
11:42 pm
no care about 69. and as long as the claims of israel, they are not happy as the all cause that those vehicles have been used to help the posting and fighters, the doctor. and they were still a good say to them all with me because they were used by, by thursday night. and i'm just the one that i'm the calling me. that's why the night why doctor and the fish i know not target the fighters killed them and showed the pictures to the whole world. second, full, not the really we have said that israel, the claim that they targeted one ambulance and this calling for and we are here confirming that 2 vehicles were targeted. the not just one thing he called the 1st one was the report started from his that was in the and for the 1st one had one
11:43 pm
driver and a paramedic. and the 2nd one was at the gates of the she for the pickup of my medical center, where a massacre was committed, the results and in the killing of 15 percent and 15 others were injured july 2nd points is this the israel targets as well. and a toddler, gwen since the beginning of the aggression solar city. and so you all have to say 25 of those vehicles filling out the so why did they not show to the world? all we mean that those are because we're used by fighters or they were transporting fighters because i used to, why didn't they show any pictures? so that would show what they are claiming when i can map for some sort of kept there possibly. however, this is just part of a series of lives, of israel that is continuing way might have been much longer this horrific
11:44 pm
massacre. i love you, not a man. somebody that has been committed under the watch of the whole world. at the end, israel has admit to didn't acknowledge this crime. what the, what the hype, the and the search engine is all through. the idea of spokesperson got a be a set up for people who acknowledge that they target to the ambulance her. that you're the little bit i'm, i had been getting this proves that this cronin up a mess up, the sliding. what was pretty me dated one the middle of the lot of gun and was committed solely under the watch into nash, the watch of the international community. in the international community should not remain silent in front of the semester current and not to give the green light. spite silent,
11:45 pm
to agree to israel to continue to come and make it more massacres. why don't we start from the international community should shoulder it's responsibility for a little while i'm out in front of the class, given this spot on the special acknowledgement. and this is crime, this horrific crime that has been committed by accusing directly. the gun is riley during the e mail and make them responsible for this crime. what's to be what's actually in the the what day tony should be brought in on the before international one or and they should be suited for all the crimes. they should have been committed against the policy of the people this, i mean, i was up against my spot on 197271977 massacres that have been committed against the philistines. and since the beginning of the is
11:46 pm
riley aggression is up in latasha, and they are not often as active and for, you know, directly targeting ambulances and colon, what type of drivers, paramedics, and who did the fact that they should be also suitable for committing crimes. and bombing hospitals, as it was the case in the baptist hospital, the in the nation hospital. and as she found medical center, if the international community will not take those actions from after this will be interpreted as given the green light on to commit more crime. so the voucher will be studied as a result, a lot of good farm is done while i'm here at the most part, one of the inside of israel should says about the respect the geneva convention and a respect international humanitarian international law. and to stop those crimes that are being committed and peace be upon you not
11:47 pm
belong a while we've been listening that to dr. ashcroft our crew drive. the goal is the health ministry spokesperson has been speaking outside of shafer hospital cause of law just he's been definitively saying that these really all these claims are false. that it wasn't just one ambulance that's been struck today. but 2 and neither of them as these really ami has claimed were being used by him off. he says in the 1st, the driver was injured, the power, medically the paramedic critically injured. he says these radius and targeted a 2nd vehicle which was of the gaze of the i'll see from medical center. he says that was a horrific monster. got 15 people killed or the 16 people engine. you're watching pictures from the off to most of that event today right now on your screen. now dr . ash rep also said that israel has so far since october,
11:48 pm
7th targeted $25.00 ambulances. and he's been asking why as well, hasn't showed any evidence that those were being used by his law. she's also pointed to the bombings of hospitals and says they should be accountability in terms of international law. while that spring and l correspondent topic i was and he's life for us and con eunice in the southern part of the gaza strip topic. you've been telling us that there is no way safe in the strip and you're also describing to us the scene outside. i'll see for today, tell us little bit more about what happens that yes, there really interest attacks and the goal is this trip. i continued since the beginning of this day, different areas have been massively hit by these but the occupation forces. but now it seems that these but occupation forces were upsetting the movement of this, i'm going to this vehicle and stuff the what target that since the moment that they were they were getting out from the she for hospitals on the, from the,
11:49 pm
from the front gates of the hospital, this area is considered to be very overflowed with people in normal days and now with the number of people who are displaced from the houses. this number has been doubled and compounded with a diversity of people who were also evacuated despite the residents inside this area. now the occupation have a, has destroyed to i'm feeling says that we're targeted. so to this attack. now the majority of this um prevents says, we're really carrying a different critical into people who are no longer can be provided with treatment in the church. we due to the lack of medical supplies and even the require, they are required to be carried out for them. adults medical surgeries that the gaza strip medical sector couldn't really afford it due to the it's very ongoing a block that block. busy of the entry of a central and vital medical supply. so they have a being delivered to the ship. so so right now the, the, i'm convinced vehicles i text is not, is not considered to be the only
11:50 pm
a tug that took place today. it has to be repeated before as those as well, and plants has been destroyed throughout the process of evacuating victims and others were also destroyed throughout the rushing to evacuated victims in different areas. in the church we d, published the minister of housing, gaza strip, has be the occupation. there's most ability of this, i to, according the international community, to be the accountability of the actions which caused it to be a latent violations of nodes of international load. entire capitalizing that with the latest for us, from con eunice in the gaza strip. thank you very much, tara quote, that's now bring in my wonder shara, he's out of there, a senior political analyst, my one. so just on seeing was obviously there are multiple attacks today. on civilian targets, just starting with this one at all. she for, we've had obviously a lot of push back now from the goal is the health ministry, the button of proof by my understanding, in terms of, of attacking and i'm doing so we're talking really any,
11:51 pm
any civilian target the button to prove lies with israel here in the test and showing that this was actually meant to be a military target. absolutely, i mean that's certainly what the experts say. but more importantly for me, that's what the common sense says. because uh, no country and no individual, no general, no soldier can go on and getting spree, no less an ambulance or a school or a church, or a mouse without some sort of a proof that that actually did not thought a good thing. what appears to be something, but i that it's something else and to my mind is there a can use otherwise, the argument that the school shut, those, how much fight those, the most drugs or how much part does kind of get us is hospitalized and so forth. and then just bottom, everything that moves or does not move in gaza. so clearly common sense is not on the size of the criminals, for our bombing ambulances. i think what's more disturbing about this, i don't know, you probably have noticed this our viewers that around the world. i've noticed that
11:52 pm
the last several weeks you got this drone man from far away the most modern of all modern technologies. this is not indiscriminate. these doors come with cameras, satellites operated human. and we've had these threatens. we literally hear them in the background about the respondents. they cover the skies of guys, all right. everything is under surveillance and because it has been is, and wouldn't be the fact that this very most post modern technology right is used against the children against injured individuals, against hospitals, against schools. the fact that you have these f sixteens, the most advanced of own uh, 5 projects. you have these drawings, you have the height, the communications, one of them, the most advanced possible technology being used against the most build of trusted
11:53 pm
. most individuals taking shelter in hospitals and ambulances and school, there's something, there's something i don't know, there's something grow bought the cli, industrially criminal about it does, is living the age of, of, of kenning or industrial scale. and when i say investigate scan, usually, we mean just getting a lot of people moving genocide, but here we are. there's another meaning through industrial is using technology in order to kill individuals, injured doctors, journalists, and so on, so forth with and gaza, which really takes warfare the whole new meaning. that's why when we talk no button about international law, we probably should start using a bit more our own, you know, common sense just to look at the scenes and to justify ourselves on what i think a lot of people are wondering as they see the civilian death toll continued to
11:54 pm
climate and see this unfolding is obviously, israel is coming under a huge amount of criticism for its funding campaign for the women and children that people are seeing dead and dying on their screens. why continue? if you know what you are hitting, why continue targeting civilians or i think the, the, the, the, the operating, the, i'll put it to a corporation award here is disproportion right. is i was saying it's fighting a war. this proportionality means that whatever the objective is you're supposed to apply certain means towards that god for force, you know, to whatever the objective is. in this case, you are using drones. helicopters, ac 16, i guess ambulance isn't schools. again, it doesn't make sense. it's tragic. it's horrible, it's horrifying. it's a crime. it's also in violation of international law. yeah. that kind of disproportionality, this kind of, you know, exacting a certain price at pos,
11:55 pm
but there was an ambulance is under whatever pretext that you don't prove. you don't feel like you're going to need to prove and, and just to take this look the logic a little further to answer your question. have you ever heard of a country that's one, a war or winning a war that was put on trial anywhere in the hague killers, of those countries supported by the united states and what's the nature has never, ever held accountable in any international court. they always get away with it because they win, or they try to win these wars and protect themselves. an interesting one of the things you were leading to that the psychological impact that this has on, on the population, knowing what israel is doing it and how it might get away with it. it's melinda shara, i'm serious senior political analyst. thank you for that. well, let's hear from audiences. he is an international law professor at queens university and canada, who's previously worked in gaza for and run through an agency for palestinian
11:56 pm
refugees. he says that according to the un charter, as well as not according to the right to self defense, infant coupon territory. there is a claim that is being bandied about in the media and by political leaders. leadership especially in the west that israel enjoys a right to self defense under article $51.00 of the united nations charter in relation to the attack that was brought against it on the 7th of october by palestinian paramilitaries. that is false. i would direct all of your re, your listeners to paragraph 139139 of the international court of justice's advisory opinion on the gallon. he's a wall dated 2004. and in that paragraph, the court makes it very clear that israel does not enjoy a right of self defense under article $51.00 of the un charter in relation to a tax that emanate from we in an occupied territory that it controls gas. i use an
11:57 pm
occupied territory, israel easy and effective control over it, and therefore it cannot claim a right of self defense in relation to that. in addition, these attacks are not him suitable, at least as alleged by israel to a state. however, they do have a right to use force to repel attacks against it that emanated from within the occupied territory. this does not qualify as self defense under international law. and that force has to be proportional and necessary to repel the attack. by all accounts, the type character quality intensity of the force used by israel since october. the 7th goes well beyond anything that is reasonable, reasonably proportionate or necessary to repel those attacks of october 7th. that includes the whole wholesale carpet bombing of millions of people in the gaza strip, the legal order of $1100000.00 of them in the northern part of the gas
11:58 pm
a strip to ostensibly go to the door, the selves of the strip, where when they get there on their way there, they're actually bombed by the occupying power. this is a war crime that we call perfect e for which individual criminal responsibility flows. and also we can forget at the start of ation of the civilian population in violations. the laws of worst operation as a tool of worth is not allowed. and we know that these railways have closed off water fuel food and electricity to this population. so none of that qualifies as self defense under international law at all. well that's it for main installs you pay for this bulletin. i'll be back in a moment with much more of the day's news as the situation in gaza escalate. we bring your expertise at dinner, let's say for ease tommy's re u. r. c. he's that the dean, the palestinians have to south south to where the,
11:59 pm
how much has got to comply with international the israel can do what he really likes. and that's the reason why is well keeps behaving. so really i would say this particular operation somewhere between the crime against humanity and genocide, it was really important that there was a jewish boy saying not in our name. you don't believe that this kind of progression makes jew safer. it doesn't make is rarely safer. state with us for the nature of developments on which is a way we understand the differences and similarities of cultures across the world. so no matter what i'll do to bring you the news. i'm current fast. the matter to you. how does era the export $2023.00 the fascination to
12:00 am
join us and let's discover a better world expo. 2023. the hello again. i'm just don't see a tell you. this is the news. our life from the coming up in the next 60 minutes. no way is safe is ready, strikes kill at least 20 people sheltering. and then you, when run school in northern golfing, is there any strikes also target at least 3 hospitals and a convoy of ambulances in the costs of stress video and matches of the optimal. so is there any strikes of jokes of any.
57 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=1186077874)