to all the new years now and former us 1st lady, rosalind content has been on it by family, friends, and presidents at a memorial service in atlanta, the wife of a former us president jimmy carter died last week, aged 96, rob reynolds reports. it was a fitting tribute for an historic 1st lady. rosamond carter's tribute service in atlanta was attended by president joe biden and 1st lady jill bud, former president bill clinton and all of the living former 1st ladies. jimmy carter . the 99 year old former president was there to honor his wife of 77 years. it was a rare public appearance for the longest living president in us history. he entered hospice care at his home in plains, georgia. in february. the former president did not speak, but their daughter amy read from a letter he had written to mrs. carter 75 years ago. while i'm away,

i tried to convince myself that you really are not could not be as sweet and beautiful as i remember. but when i see you, i fall in love with you all over again. during her tenure, missus carter was considered the most politically active 1st lady since eleanor roosevelt. she worked by her husband side in the white house as a supporting partner, attended cabinet meetings and represented the us abroad. she vigorously pursued her own agenda, particularly in improving the lives of the mentally ill. what we witnessed was a 1st lady who saw her role as going well beyond the essential, warm and welcoming host to being a close and trusted yes adviser, in essence and extension of the president himself at once the couple left washington in 1980, she devoted herself to humanitarian causes,

along with the former president, starting an institute for caregivers, traveling to impoverish countries promoting habitat for humanity and a host of other causes. she had met kings and queens presidents, others and authority, powerful corporate leaders and celebrities. she said the people that she met with the most comfortable with the people she enjoyed being with the most with those that lived an absolute abject poverty. mrs. carter will be laid to rest on wednesday beneath the willow tree at the family home and planes. rob reynolds, l g 0. the only use in half an hour upfront is next. stay with us. the

during his visit to israel following october 7th, the tax us presidential biding when the country not to repeat the mistakes the us

made in response to the $911.00 attacks. what is israel doing just that? and why is for us refusing to call forth ceasefire? alas, the director of the award winning film fahrenheit $911.00, author inactive is michael moore and an upfront special the michael moore. thanks so much for joining me in upfront. thank you. thank you for having the course. you, of course, made a very famous movie called fahrenheit 911, which criticized the us as response to the attacks of september 11th, 2001. you chronicled the panic rushed to allow the government to spy on its own citizens. the decision to invade iraq in the country that had nothing to do with $911.00 and the ways that the defense industry profited off the war. israel is now calling october 7th there on 911. what do you make of that comparison? and you see the similarities of parallels to how these relays are responding. well,

it's, ironically, it's a, it's a very apt description in the sense in terms of how the united states responded to 911. and, and how is rooms responding out? i think president by the both when he was there and since he's come back to the united states uh has essentially said don't make the mistakes that we mean that we were very much in a rush toward revenge. we were very, i mean, everybody here. anybody who remembers that day it was frightening. it was a sense of pretty much, i'm guessing how most is really subtract for many years. something like this would never happen. and then it happens in the fact that it took hours, 6 hours, 8 hours, 12 hours before help arrived. so i think he has this

commodities what he does, a lot of people in this, in a sense of, of kind of other horror and fear. human beings do not act well when they come from a place of fear and tear. that's why a lot of times terrorism does its job. i think i but i want to say that i waking up that morning. it's saturday morning on october 7th. and it's never a good day on this planet. when you wake up and you hear the 1400 of our jewish brothers and sisters have been slaughtered it's, it's uh, none of us. i think we live in that world. and so, um, so i think i understand all the initial responses and i understood the response and the desire for revenge. haven't gone through that time. and so, you know,

all the mistakes we made, as you said by 1st and reading and began to stand and reading in rack for what that's an interesting course of the for what the, what was this really about question in regard to 911, let people to say ok, this was maybe just a pretext, uh, you know, for invading iraq with the worry that these really government may similarly use october 7th as a free text to take over more of guys the, to expand in the west bank or maybe go to war with iran could this moment of har and in fear, turn into an opportunistic moment for something else. well, i think it already is. and, and let me just say this, and this is what maybe one issue that most people on the right or the left a pro israel pro palestinian pro human life. um and, and i think i'm guessing just the polls i've seen just it just out of his real

um and then yahoo has to go the, the, the people were not protected. what was he doing? why did had they pulled the army back? why? we know one reason they were pulled back into the west bank was to support the settlers and their violence against the called stadiums. i mean, there is going to have to answer for this is not going to go well for him. and, and i think that it's very hard to trust the things that are coming out of his, his administration. and i, um, um the slaughter that we're witnessing now is so i don't know how to put words to it. frankly. i mean, just what, what's happened? the last few nights. oh really what's happened the last few decades and that i

as an american and i'm helping to fund that united states as the bank. what's every and the funding, michael? i mean it's, that's so important, right? because on the one hand, as you mentioned earlier, president biden says, hey, israel don't make the mistakes we made. we were looking for just this and we made mistakes. at the same time, he's asking for more military aid. you know, he, he said that, you know, innocence being killed is just the price of waging a war. you can't square that circle easily. what do you do? what should that us be doing? well, we should not be trying to increase the flight or mean should that be funding the war i, i think, you know, most americans have no problem with making sure that there are no more is really still in providing for the defense. but that's really not what's going on right now. um, how do you justify the, the, um,

the slaughter of children, children and some of these nights, half of the dad half of the wounded are children. what are we getting back? well, what do we, what are we trying to do? how, what, what did the children do? and how are we defending israel, having more dead children? and anybody who can say right now, you know, especially people, so i support israel and i will, you know, defend israel and then support and fund the massacre of innocent civilians and children. you have no credibility that when you say that you support his really what kind of hypocrisy, that kind of contradiction isn't just what people with governments to, including our government, i mean human rights. why don't put it perfectly. they said the hypocrisy and double standards of western states are flagrant and obvious. and then of course, the us and other wisdom governments have to apply the same principles regarding

russian atrocities and ukraine as they would with quote israel's brutal disregard for civilian life. and god, it seems like we pick and choose when we're going to be outreach when we're going to intervene when we're going to have a moral critique. would it be fair to say that the u. s. foreign policy position is fundamentally hypocritical? it is, but i think what's really at the core always of our foreign policy is what's best for us. and, and, and, and so is real in the, and from the very beginning of the, of the creation of israel and the american government. the american military has always seen this as a good thing for us that we have this base there that we, that we have all the kind of a intelligence apparatus and everything. all the things that is real does basically to make sure that the oil supply is there in the middle east. is that

good? is that going to be? we're not going to be impeded by this. and i think to, and i, 9, i've had, you know, is really friends say to me we, we get that. what's really behind this either, either politically or, or new apparently why. so the united states has been using israel in that way for many, many years. and the other thing that comes to me to mind though is the role of the media plays. i get, i think back to your work. you know, in 911 the media help beat the drum for war. you know, post 911, they beat the drum for war in iraq. they beat the drum for war and have again to stay and they continue to beat those wardrobes. a. similarly, today we see the media adopting pro is real approach pro war approach not as uniformly as, as post 911. there are voices urging caution their social media, which is far more complicated and diverse and sometimes messy. but at least we see more descent than we did 20 years ago as the media learned

a less than how we learned a lesson from before. i think so, i think because of the, the what's still going on back and forth about the hospital. that was bon uh, was it is rarely a racket. was it a palace stay bracket, that'll come all by the way, we will all know the truth of everything you oh, i'm confident of that. but in the meantime, the new york times and the others have had this sort of back away from we've got to make sure we're not, you know, we, we have to say every time anything that comes out of guys i know from the palestinians. we have to say this has not been independently confirmed and which right, we should all know that anyways as consumers of media. but i, but i still hear anybody in the media whenever somebody comes out of netanyahu's miles, whatever his government is saying, it should also be have the caviar attached to it. we have not been able to

independently confirm what benjamin netanyahu would say. and, and so we're in the fog of all this right now. we don't know a lot of what, but wait, but everything that, that he and his government very right wing government has been saying and doing must be treated with a lot of skepticism. absolutely. and it's a right wing government. and so sometimes it's right when governments, you know, right wing media outlets are very gentle. the thing about this case is that it's not just the right wing media. that's not being sufficiently critical. it's everybody. i mean, look at supposedly centrist mainstream media outlets like cnn. i mean, they're still branding their tv coverage is real at war, which seems to be taken inside. very neutral to be a bbc. it headline about and is really tacked on the edge of valley mentioned the massive crater, the strike left, but they ignore the more than 50 people that the gaza and help ministry says we're

also killed up mainstream media mix, all kinds of dubious decisions about how to frame accomplish and you know, very well as a filmmaker, but the way you frame a story is how people understand the story of how have people's perceptions been influenced by the way the media has framed this? well, i think very much so, but again, the majority of americans don't support the slaughter. yeah. and they want the humanitarian aid and now not wanting trucks a day or 50 trucks a day, 500 trucks today is that is where the american people are at. and i want people around the world. what might be listed to this, understand that my fellow americans actually kind of do get this, and when the big graphics come on, the screen is real at wor, um, you know, you just have to stop and think for a 2nd. oh yeah. yeah. the trustees, they have all those fighter jets, they have all those bars. they or, you know, all the, you know, the big house,

city and navy with all those right. it right. when you say the one you're, you're, what do you define? we are, you know, it's, um, there was an attack on october 7th. that was reprehensible and um, and, and so people have a right to defend themselves, but that's not what's going on. now. if you're chewing children in mind, 8 with my money, that's not a war to defend yourself. that looks like something else that looks like that. now there's a, a group of people, 2 to 2 and a half 1000000 people of color that are being pushed on as they say, into the sea, or into the data or to, to, to get rid of them in some way. certainly is what it looks like and you can't wake up every morning and see the bodies of these dead children being pulled from the

rubble. yeah. and i think a lot of what, uh then yahoo is doing is, was very similar to what bush was doing. he messed up more straight. no attention. no. uh, uh, they knew an attack was going to happen. uh, they didn't prepare for it. and, and now, uh then of course, tried to save themselves by, let's go to war let's you know, it's defend america. and, and yet we're not any say for now as americans, and we were back then. and yes, there hasn't been another quote, 911, here in the us. but none of us are safe. if our response is more showing in more depth. well look at, you know, look, look, i'm looking at biden's requests from congress for more money. it seems like more killing and more depth as inevitable binds asked congress and $14000000000.00 for israel's defense. the us already provides israel within $3000000000.00

a year. he's also asked for more money for ukraine on top of the 10s of millions of dollars that's already being spent in the fight against russia. now, what's interesting to me is when by made the case for this spending uh human more than just make a moral argument even more than just make a political argument. you made an economic argument on october 19th, we talked about the number of us states that those weapons would be made it as if the say, this isn't just good for defense, this is a jobs program. what do you think of the argument that making more weapons is also good for the average working american? or we don't fall for that anymore. the majority of the 12, and i'd say a bite. you know, the, the things that he said in the, in the sort of position these take it, i know i, i'm pretty sure what he's doing privately behind the scenes with that and, you know, and i, and i know they tried to slow things down a bit to try to get you maturing 8 in to try and get hostages released. and i would

say, i just want to say to people in gaza, anybody who's holding hostages, release them release from now. it's, it's not just in terms of the, the goodwill that will come from there, but do, because it's just right, it's the right thing to do and know again as these really pressure has informed us when they started to release the 1st 4 hostages a week or so ago, and they would do, i think, were one spokesperson for the idea of say, this is all just p r. them releasing her as teachers. well, you know, what's the thing we learned when we were kids that with you and she was me something, it's quite a sign. it may be what you're doing to. uh and, and it's, it's, it's released the hostages. hold the rug out from underneath the netanyahu. a government that's trying to justify the massacre, trowbridge, i would,

i would just just strongly encourage that. and, and to, and to say both sides have to have a ceasefire to join us to stop. there was a moment last week that i gotta be honest with you, i'm still sitting in my crawl. also for last week the white house press secretary was asked if president biden things anti israel protesters are extremists. rather than answer the question, she called the protests, there's anti semitic, and compare and compare them to neo nazis who marching to charlottesville. back in 2017, there's an obvious divide on the left between support of, of support of israel and supporters of palestinians. but this is a democratic white house calling critics of israeli policy. most of the issues are probably be allies. after some lights, what would you say to the people that depressed secretary make those kinds of claims? my partner, guess team. my producers went down to um,

brand central station in new york city, on friday night, a rush hour. uh, because we, we'd gotten, we heard rumors that people is going to be like a flash drive or people are in a show up there during rush hour to kind of shut brand central down. and when we got there, what it was was, it was an organization called jewish voice for peace and pat inside of brain central. we're well over a 1000 mostly new york jews sitting down and expecting to be interested in the act of civil disobedience wearing t shirts saying a ceasefire now. not in my name. yeah. people i knew people had family members who had been killed october 7th and wanted to make it clear that that their deceased loved one would not want children being killed because they weren't killed. yeah,

because it was um and so the cool, i know i heard i saw that. so i said, so basically you're calling these thousands of jews in new york city, anti semites. i mean really, you're really working the p r machine hard. when you're, when you're calling a fellow, uh jews. uh uh awful terms like that. um. so it's uh, you know, it's just not, it's not gonna work. and i think this is very frustrating for israel is really government. so that, you know, we've had a couple of generations of young people, not just in the us, but in israel and palestine and around the world where they kind of get what's going on now. and, and so you're just not going to be able to make stuff up and, and i'm very disappointed in and present invite for using this language. and but, you know, i gotta say in the back of my had nothing to back this up on. i just think the public way, by just taking this position that, you know, we're

a 1000 percent behind israel and we're going to send as many weapons as possible and this and that whatever. but i think behind the scenes and his phone calls with that and yahoo and just reading some of the analysis of all this pro, it's rarely have certainly been some links. there been some policy experts who have waited on this and said, absolutely that it's not nearly as uniform opposition in the united states in israel as it looks publicly. but there's something in publicly biting. doesn't like that. and yeah, he's made the right or when i was in new york, just the what, i don't know what to 67 weeks ago for the you, when the annual un meetings, you know, and, and yeah, i was upset that he did not get an invitation like zalinski and others that when they were in the us, hey, come on down to dc, come to the white house, all that i didn't didn't want anything. they had a perfunctory little 2 chairs there at the u. s. and they sat side by side for

a minute and then yeah, i wouldn't, and that was, it was not welcome at the white house. you know, i was a supporter, bernie sanders and uh, but i bought it for buying and i have been once now once in one time, many times over, a very kind of surprise unhappy with the things that binding has done since he's been present. they helped the people to help the poor to, to stand with the union. so i've never seen a president go to a union march or demonstration to support the union against the automakers. so i think that that there's will no more in the months or years to come. yeah, i mean if there's a need to speak to that because i, it makes me think about the future or the potential future of the left before you guys want to ask you this. if you were in avatar progressive politics, long before people knew what bernie sanders was or who uh and alexandria will cost you a quarter to as was. now there are pod cast about the end of neo liberalism,

and more people are joining dsa, democratic socialists of america than ever before. the unions are experiencing the highest levels of public support in decades. a, to your point of bernie almost got the democratic nomination for president as a self identified socialist. i mean, there is a vocal contingent in congress right now that identifies this progressive. we're in a different moment. are you, are you satisfied with the gains made by the left in this country? yes or no. i mean, the gains are not far enough. i mean, we saw during the pandemic because of all of the federal support and health for people. poverty amongst children was caught in it. yeah. and i'm not the only one who thought at the time. well, why don't we just keep this, colleen look what we've done just by providing help to those who need it. and you know, and then of course, you know, because he's a more of a, a mater advisors had this, you know, the doesn't kept a lot of that a going,

but i think i think that young people get it. they are the ones behind the new union movement in this country. you know, you've got what, over 30400 starbucks, have been organized, body in the union. and of course they're fighting that. and as they always do, this is all young people doing this. and, and it is young people who are standing up uh for that. how sitting people you stand up for it. you know, they're, they're focusing a lot on the few. the few kind of crazy people that are bigots, you know, a thing like this is real. you know what they've been doing, playing into the hands of bigots, and that's kind of white supremacist support. but that is not this country now. and, and the right wing will not run the show here. again, i really believe in that. i don't believe trucks can they get elected back into the white house?

there are so many millions of americans who have not liked the way that we've gone . and in closing, i just want to say thank you for all the people who stand for peace is real, especially. thank you and, and to all here in this country and i, i'm weirdly optimistic. maybe i shouldn't be, but i, i just don't think netanyahu and his gang are going to get away with this. and i think that the slaughter will end and maybe not soon enough, michael. thank you so much for joining us. personally. thank you for letting me speak. and um, uh it's uh, i think this is the 1st television interview i've been asked to do since the started on october 7th. so my, my sincere agrees and condolences to everyone who's died 1st on october 7th. just nobody who is jewish should have to spend another day on

this or worried about their survival. and then immediately we need to stop the floor in god. um uh the re, the house you just have to be returned and sensible people who care about peace care about each other. have to sit down at a table and, and work this out. and, you know, we say a prayer for all, oh, absolutely. so, but not, no, not another person has to die. indeed, everybody, michael moore, thanks again for joining us. everybody. that's our show upfront. we'll be back next week the as the game on because it continues. we bring you the latest reactions and global

our experience. so jewish person, israel does not represent me, the killing of all those innocent families in israel is terrible. but the response is even worse. it's a genocide, it is up acceptable trouble stages and it seems even more unacceptable to have children of stages. it's all about religion, it's about somebody to come in to get down to stay with us. for the latest developments on al jazeera, it is a tenant object to produce objectives these coverage. many parts of his really media are effectively engaging in propaganda or genocide. what these really military was telling us does not fit in with what evidence they have so far. and yet on the fringes of israeli public discourse, anti war voices persist sale, calling the traitors. the listening close covers how the news is come to watch this

space where the story goes next. the us is always of inside $54.00, right? the world people pay attention to this $1.00 here. and i'll just see this very good . they're bringing the news to the world from here. the for united again, a 14 year old boy is among the latest palestinians to arrive home after being released from and is ready for us. early i must release 12 captains from a gauze of 10 his rays and to tie nationals have now arrived in his route on the 5th day because the alarm diamond jordan, this is obviously a life and also coming is ready for us is around a number of hospitals in janine and they all tried west by dozens of college

demands are resting on the devastating impact israel's funding is having on kansas children. we need to 6 year old palestinian go is now have families songs of.