Skip to main content

tv   The Bottom Line  Al Jazeera  December 10, 2023 12:30pm-1:01pm AST

12:30 pm
supplied westbank, it is on the whole neighborhood when it opens again, i will wait a couple of weeks to check the situation before i return to work is better there. you get paid directly and on time, even though there is racism and i'm afraid of violence against me, which is the best station in ramallah. it's 5 30 am. before the war it would be bustling with workers, taking transports was ro. now this whole the as sold around colombia checkpoint monks a break and the separation will heavily guarded bodies, right? the military. and it's where many palestinians used to cross into israel every day . the foldable at this time of the day at this place, you'd see thousands upon thousands of pallets vivian's crossing the check board to go into israel to can as you can see now it's just a trickle. and the majority of these work is all going deep inside is working in an industrial side very close to where we all now economies rojo. somebody says the
12:31 pm
band is highlighted just how reliant on these well the palestinian economy is even if they want to return to the local labor market. the existing opportunities are very, very few. in fact, there are none. we already had 17 percent unemployment in the west bank. now we're going to have set at $430.00 for our present unemployment. we had a low g, d p, relatively in the, in the west bank. now these, if, if this labor continues, stoppage continues for 12 months we're talking about 25 percent loss and g d p alone because of this effect. and that means additional hardship for millions of palestinians likes all who look south across the valley, up to towns in israel, where he can no longer work. cello strap it down to 0. remo, or in the other world news egyptians are voting and a 3 day presidential election. presidents have been for the c. c is looking to secure a 3rd term,
12:32 pm
a med raising public discontent and worsening living standards. voters will be able to cast their ballots until tuesday and results are due to be announced on december . the 18th. china and the philippines are continuing to blame each other for collision in the dispute. south china sea, the philippine coast guards as a chinese ship fired water cannons to obstructs 3 of fits vessels, calling its actions aggressive and illegal. beijing says a philippine vessel intentionally round, it's ship near, contested as full. this is the latest incidents and a territorial dispute between the 2 countries. you can read much more about that as well as all the latest headlines out of gaza on our website out as a result. com. the bottom line is coming up next. so thanks for watching by the candidate has to expand the tooth and a zillow's fault lines meets those advocating for the change is suicide. but it's
12:33 pm
facilitated to where we decide that it's not the right choice. and critics who believe the government is prioritizing depth of, of providing necessary social and economic support. staff was an 8 worked festival and getting some food to eat or getting stuff for their pain. do you want to die today? a fault lines investigation on al jazeera a. hi, i'm steve clements and i have a question. has the war in gaza unleashed a new wave of bigotry and hate in america? let's get to the bottom line. the as israel's war and gaza rages on with no end in sight, everything that happens over there is affecting people over here. emotions are running high among followers of all major religions, muslims, and many christians. since a sizable portion of palestinians are christian are rallying for the cause of palestine and many jews are rallying for the cause of israel. now both sides are
12:34 pm
reporting a rise of racism here in the us. and we're not just talking about cases of intimidation and harassment. one week end of the war, a 6 year old palestinian american boy was allegedly murdered by his landlord in chicago and an elderly jewish man was knocked over and allegedly killed during protest. i encounter protests in california in vermont 3 palestinian college students were shot as they were walking down the street wearing a palestinian cap here like this one and speaking in arabic. so are these isolated incidents or a rising trend across the us today on talking with me had a want the executive director of the council on american islamic relations, the nation's largest most on civil rights and advocacy organization based here in washington? yeah, thank you for joining us and these are tough times and i just wanna get right into the meat of things. so i don't know you, you, you walked into one adjuster, you through a hornet's nest with your comments that you were glad to see the siege of gaza
12:35 pm
ended on october 7th, the white house deputy press secretary, andrew bates, the new york times said we condemned the shocking anti semitic statements in their strongest terms. what are your reactions to the white house and what were you trying to say? the, i'm sorry, the white house and this goes through my statement and a little bit of money. and the way they knew, but unjustly, and without, without any justification, that's all up. i said, i never said that actually they saw the video they saw on my speed. there was not a 3rd subordinate that so for that i asked the right types to reconsider the position. and here what i said, what i said is the siege on gas or is it leaking? and the processing is the freedom. they deserve the same freedom that we are applauding uh for the your people of your ukraine and other people who
12:36 pm
are under occupation or press. there shouldn't be nothing strange about this. so i always said, and i continue to say that i will fight on this and that isn't in the same way. and the same thing, i'm bigger, i fight the semaphores because both phenomenons of people and those communities, both the george, me again, this and community are targeted because of the, for you, by extreme is i knew jordan, my wife extremist. and we have been fighting this for 3 decades together. so anyone who doubts this, it would be really method of presenting my position and what i stand for. i never meant and i never said actually that i support the violence against civilian people . both is there it is contesting in any way any attack on any civilian and
12:37 pm
innocent people is that that on all it was in fact as it most of them i believe, hurting, and harming civilians is pathetic. and so might be deep as the most tim, my badgers. and also my position as, as about a senior. and as most of us as an either the largest me seems to go right to an advocacy organization. what i meant by that state is there's an indigo, lucky on the people of guessing for 17 years. the people of guys have 2300000 people are not allowed to move to leave at. that's to they cannot go on. so you can do cation, they cannot go and seek medical health, they cannot live their lives normally, like anyone else on this plan. why that kind of thing should be the exception that they should live in an open air prison without having that i to be free. so when
12:38 pm
i say i was happy, i meant that regular kind of thing of residents walk street in the land. that was ethnic liquid and they had, has there ever been a moment where you saw the divisions exploding on college campuses? exploding we're learning, even among the white house staff, inside companies of people on both sides of the line that are, that are not that are feeling pain. but using this moment to move their agendas, has there been any time like this in your past? this is the worst time i've ever seen a boat in communities and people should have the right to freely express their views. no matter how, how much we disagree with them in the civil society, in a peaceful environment where we are people on the weekend exchange views and colleges, universities and schools shouldn't be
12:39 pm
a safe place for many exchanging ideas and even debating, i guess about the silence people because of their views is difficult to democracy and should not be allowed to take place. as we have seen, students have been silence, have been suspended. student organizations have been deactivated and cancel. and this is a serious back on the americans right to freely express themselves. the right to have an assembly and speak through the power. it's an american tradition to silence people who oppose the government. the government indicates upper or so this cloud for and policy is, is, is helpful. the democracy, the more conversation, the more debates we have, the more enlightened will be. and hopefully we wouldn't be equipped to be a force for good to establish fees and prevent
12:40 pm
a conflict and oppression from taking place as we have seen. see what, what i have seen. also this is a new phenomenon. young jewish americans are arising and speaking of their minds in progress of the israeli government and gets up by nature. they are protesting the white houses up. ready which to what's taking place against garza and these voices are new and fresh when i, when i say new and they're not like very, very new. but they have been really a transforming themselves and really angry, searching exchanging views with other people. and they have to can stand that so many americans who are learning more about books taking place against the palestinians, both in the west bank and gaza. and they are taking steps. in fact, 66 percent of the american public believe that this government government should call for a few minutes east fire. unfortunately,
12:41 pm
only 7 percent of the members of congress are heating the cold. so you know, questions to members of congress. why are you around to listening to the american public? i mean, there, they elected you, they paid for your salaries. no other group of people. why the rush, you hit the wrong. and in this genocide that's taking place against the palestinian people on some college campuses. we had a very dramatic hearing in congress with re presidents of us from an diversity mit harbbard and the university of pennsylvania. and since that hearing some of these university presidents have walk back their defense of speech in the sense that they were ask if people are calling for a genocide against the jews, what would they do about that? and these uh, university. presidents said they have a standard of free speech that has to tolerate that. and so i'm interested in whether we need to have a better debate about what constructive and fair and civil debate
12:42 pm
that's maybe deeply felt is. or whether we have to from your perspective, tolerate those that are calling for a genocide of jews which i find outrages. of course we should take a very, very soon and clear stands against any of called even for violence against innocent people. let alone a genocide against people because of who they are. i mean, this is a part of it, but also this is what it is doing to the kind of thing and people see what, what's new, what is more americans are learning about and that dickens. and i think the biggest fear is a, has, is uninformed american public. and that's why the, is there any pro but got the machine is just working hard. they and, and they are, you know, with all the sophistication but their negative is falling apart in front of the images of children being the bodies of children being pulled from the rubble of
12:43 pm
houses, of his adventures. buildings that you know um, kindly is being wiped out of the tooth and destruction the, the, the, the, the, the block, it preventing, the cussing is event to have water, electricity fuel. in this router, while they're now in garza, half of the population are, are homeless. basically now, so people are seeing this and there is no censorship. if the ministry me get decided not to show those images. and then the american people are smarter and they are, they are on social media and they see the reality on the ground. and they are taking the stand and you know, so, but that should not be misconstrued with the right of people to this city. and also to push back against is there any to join inside the policy? i mean,
12:44 pm
if there's any pressure it should be against this administration that has given the green light for the setup is or has to do what they. ready are in violation of all international laws and universe, somebody's uneven americans claims to be the the, the beacon of freedom and, and this chunk champion of human rights, especially this administration who claim that it was center human rights in it's for and policy agenda. we don't see any of that. we see the human edition or the palestinians with the receive dismissing the dismissal of their suffering. and we see that the giving is a noted lines. and now this administration, they feel the pressure and abandonment of the american listened communities. a support for, for by then, and that's why we started to see it shift in tune. not because you know, all of a sudden they can about the product thing and the called the store and the injured
12:45 pm
and so on. but now they started to feel that, you know, their, their, their, the approval rating is dropping, especially among young americans who see that this is a genocide taking place with this up for a moment. and let me ask you about that. let me ask you about the collapse of that support and youth and if you pull most of americans today, their support for president biden has eroded quite significantly as well. my question to you when they say we're not going to support joe biden. in 2024. the alternative, if things go the way they look today is donald trump, it do, they really believe that donald trump will be better in this equation. then joe biden, people should not steer the. those who are angry with this administration about the identity. in fact, this administration shouldn't be terrified from their own behavior from or their own decision. and the break away from their own babies. and correct and have
12:46 pm
a shift in their policy before it's too late. or is it your sense that the power of the american muslim and arab community is going to have greater traction in this selection? and i mean, i just, i'm trying to understand the political footprint, the political sway. this community has. what is your sense of it? of seduce the c uh michigan. uh the size of the community, the swing voters. they are the ones who basically decide. where is this, what were with the said go uh, you know, 4 foot 4 which candidate. and they have done a number of sites. uh, georgia. uh, the front of my prism was looking for about those kinds of boats and something maybe it has more than $60000.00 votes. right. uh, wisconsin, the size of it. you said the community, ohio. excuse me, even in florida. uh nevada. there are a size of them, so can we do that is organized including arizona. and this wisdom can we see is no
12:47 pm
fast up. so if this president is serious about not losing them, maybe it's not too late for him to reconsider. so yes they, they are very motivated on organizing and there's not how to shorten the money and they will not be emotional in that approach to do the responsible thing. but they want to let this administration and anyone who has taken the community for granted that they should think twice before they keep thinking the way they are now . we had, i am appalled by what i've read or some horrific and anti semitic attacks. and also is womach phobic attacks i'm, i'm appalled by some behaviors that have been out there about people expressing views that i would consider constructive, not planned bullying or outrages losing their jobs, essentially being, quote, unquote cancelled on both sides of this equation. candidly. and,
12:48 pm
and i'm interested in the many requests of my understanding is that care has received over 2000 requests for assistance. and as you went, dive down and these can you give us a quick snapshot and it's probably not fair to give this half a quick snapshot, but of what these people are feeling inside the united states in their communities, in their workplaces in their schools. what's going on? what's the temperature from the 1st week of october and then the 2nd, which is almost like a it's a uh, this period of time. we have received a 2171. and i mean the december 2nd. yeah, yeah, yeah. yeah. so yeah, yeah, and then december, 2nd, we received the 2171 complaints and requests for him. and that's like 172 percent of covering the same 2 months of last year.
12:49 pm
so it is, it is a sky rocketing and significantly increase in the cases and this is unprecedented. these cases 34 percent of them are present siphoning and suppressing pretty speech with on college campuses. and universities and schools. uh, you know, the standings is schools organizations from expressing support to the policy is already been expressing a position that they is the policies or even this administration. and that's really, it should be a red flag for all americans when they see the significant attack on free speech for, for americans to express themselves. 22 percent of the present complaints from employment . so many people lost their jobs, the filed or the job of homes have been descended. i c o, as of a corporations work on, i sat before be a and, and, and i'm to kind of thing and feelings by sending emails. uh we stand with is there
12:50 pm
any? uh, so that's really created one sided, a position on, on the 2nd place in gotta sign a completely unfair and created how side work environment for, for tens of thousands of not hundreds of thousands of, of interviews. and some of them protested these statements of the had been filed without any justification. we have seen about 17 percent of these, a $2171.00 elected to hit crimes and hit speech. we have seen the case of what the you want me, the 60 old at the listing and the suburb of chicago, who was stab to this 26 times. and his mother was that 12 times she survived. we've seen embedded in building 10 on vermont.
12:51 pm
if any palestinian students who were shocked and injured, one of them is now a paralyzed from the neck down. we've seen many complaints like this one has many incidents, and this is the fighting. and steve, this is not unrelated or disconnected with what's taking place in, in, in the westbank today. this is david jimenez, zation of the palestinians is completely related to the attacks on the palestinian community and the united states. because you have so many elected officials and media all you're talking about settlers, the settlers in the west bank attacking palestinian residents in the west bank. yeah, yeah. but also, but also here, so many electrical officials and commentators like, you know, have, have to humanize the palestinians. and they have been justifying what's taking place in, in, in the, in against god's up. and that is connected to the impact of
12:52 pm
a sound before we, i'm of the brothers thing and symptom and in this country. so. so this is, this is really making america most of our students and even provide a science supporters in this country and save an unprotected. and it's a very dangerous environment. you had, i have watched you over many years be attacked. and yet you still call for constructive dialogue. you're willing to sit down with people. but, you know, as the president of harvard said, regrettably, you know, she, she felt sorry for what she said. words matter. what is your experience? i won't ask this very carefully, were more there are people on both sides use rarely side those victims of family members of those attacked the nation on october 7th. and now just so many in palestine as they have seen, as you said children, women, others killed, that are in a sense of this conflict. what is your advice to people in a time of rage and frustration,
12:53 pm
and anger about words and how you get from this moment to the other side, where you hopefully get to something that will eventually have to sort this out and get to a different moment and equilibrium that hopefully has more justice baked in into it for the palestinians. but what is your advice on words? i think people shouldn't be mindful of the humanity to of each other. eventually we are brothers and sisters and we are equal in the eyes of god. and we shouldn't be equal in the eyes of egypt. and we have 2 or 3 and each other with big, with the emphasis which will not allow any sense of superiority, falls sense of superiority to become policy and behavior. and to inflict suffering and being on other people just because they don't believe the way we believe or the cultural is different or the language is different or their background is different. if we seem to align our sense with you in
12:54 pm
a better sense, badges of dignity, hundreds, fixed for and just as for old we wouldn't be the humanizing other people and the immunization. because the 1st step towards the genocide, the jews have gone through this experience in europe in many places and the seniors are going through this now in palestine. we need political leaders not to exploit divisions, no matter how legitimate or legitimate to pass the political agent such as nothing yeah. was been trying and accused of corruption. and so they're throwing up the, the, the legal system is, are right, the one that this, this work is done. you might be address it and he will lose your job. we want our
12:55 pm
administration to be a responsible god bless america with think with the sources. we should use the for the sources, nothing the white people not to establish, call on these and reinforce companies. we have to use these sort of sources that god bless the somebody that and the american people who give us that hard money in terms of tax payers, we should trust or being we are invested with this, the resources we should use them to establish peace and equality among the people which would love to reinforce occupations of apartheid. and we should stop dehumanizing the, the kind of thing and people we shouldn't bring. is there a, there's a stimulus to the sam table and ask them to reconcile their narratives and sit for a genuine piece because everyone wants to live in peace. but you cannot live in peace if your neighbor is not in peace. and if you look at your neighbor as a sub human and you can explode them a new concept to get them just because you think that somehow you,
12:56 pm
our problem is something that was never problems to you. i mean, we have to at least couple conflicts from the religious dogma and just be serious a human beings. and 3 people, people with big need to have respect, even if it helps us to give fall of an influence. because that's what humanity requires us to do well in the had a lot co founder and executive director of the council on american islamic relations. i really appreciate you joining us today. thank you. thank you. so what's the bottom line? palestine is real, have ripped open, deep fissures between communities inside the united states, businesses, universities, media organization, even the white house and the pentagon. they're all divided over narratives. they bring to the crisis, islamic phobia is surging, and so is the anti semitism. these are emotional and complicated issues, and we're seeing some folks become vigilantes prior to curtail the rights and the speech of others, while others are using american express speech standard to other outrages and
12:57 pm
irresponsible claims and aspirations. there's just no neat way out of this. the sad truth is that we're seeing so much death and destruction in gaza and it will be a long time before conditions move to a more constructive tone in conversation. we're just a long way from that moment in my view. and sadly, that's the bottom line. the the latest news, as it breaks the lead drive of these really military james, slowed down shop 15 year old bustle, dead, and then shot 8 year old item within debt reports from us and says that it freed all women and children under a sci fi agreement. that ended off to both sides place each other for violations. and the in this journalism leaflets wed dropped by the occupation. what was the informing people to sleep, to roughly district the exploring diverse culture
12:58 pm
exciting political disco. exposing societies for dr. award winning in dense investigations. the get compelling insights into humanity, phones and untold stories from asia were in the pacific. 101 east. on how to 0. power defines how wow we live here. we make the rules, not the people empower investigate exposure and questions. they use them to be just of our around, but the analogy there, while you're looking at that is one of the breach points through which, how much support is came into it as well. warning sirens here is a b s like some slight y'all just has remarkably intensified during the last couple
12:59 pm
of hours. we've seen these as strikes really concentrated on residential homes in residential buildings. is a dangerous times regional spillover. of course, as long as the conversation here isn't inside the hospital, then without oxygen, without electricity, the beated inside, they are dying. for now, less than an hour away from the start of the ceasefire. 50 feet cap sits, will be released over st. periods. one will batch of prisoners when these people want a permanent ceasefire. the the, [000:00:00;00]
1:00 pm
the, [000:00:00;00] the hello, i'm elizabeth veronica and this is the news our life from joe hall coming out for the next 60 minutes. israel pushes on with this war on gaza, pounding the strip for the strikes. i can promise i would love to give up.

18 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on