tv Inside Story Al Jazeera January 5, 2024 2:30pm-3:01pm AST
2:30 pm
not only concerned about the possibility of more clues, and the reason it's worried it good for us with detailed coverage, less than 2 weeks into law. being criticized, behaving more like a number of precedents from the around the world since the start of the war, a vast number of small a voluntary groups have sprung, get to big. the don't have the results is a big organization. the evolves questions retaliation off to, to bloss kim morgan, 18 people during commemorations for an assassination. generally the set to be the worst attack since the 1979 revolution. so how will pet envoy yet and is their best of escalation in the region? this is inside story, the
2:31 pm
hello and welcome to the program. i'm elizabeth put on them. it is one of the worst attacks to hit around and decades. more than 80 people were killed in the southeastern city of cut them on. on wednesday, when to explosives went off, joined a crowd of procession. the timing of the attack is significant that happened during the so many mock in full years since the us assassinated one of yvonne's top generals costs. and so the money the attack is adding yes, another layer of tension in the region. this israel's one gaza, this week's assassination of i'm off come on to 11 on and now this attack in iran. so is there a connection and will the suspicions of different governments and on goods escalate? the violence? we'll get to those questions in a moment. but 1st, this report from katia lopez hold a young of the 2 bombs exploded during the crowded procession marketing for year since the us assess the nation overruns top military commander costs. and so the money to up until his stuff was among the most powerful
2:32 pm
men in advance. sulu money led around the revolutionary guards, codes force, which handles overseas operations, including providing weapons, money, and logistical support to own groups in the region including husband law and tomas . it ran immediately blamed israel for the attack i've won, design is raising without a doubt. you will pay the price to this crime. these crimes you've committed, you will deeply regret the us state department denies the accusations and points to a lack of evidence. the united states was not involved in any way. and any suggestion to the contrary is ridiculous. and number 2, we have no reason to believe that israel was involved in this explosion. in recent years on groups including, i still have carried out
2:33 pm
a tax against civilians and security forces in around in $21712.00 people were killed when i sold targeted a ranch, parliament building, and the 2 other republics. a revolutionary founder that the attack comes at a time of high tensions and the region. israel has not lit up and it's war ongoing, and 11 on capital. the 2nd most powerful commander of how mosque was assassinated on tuesday. and then the parents is rarely strikes. what it is, what does it have to do this estimation of one of the master's top leaders in lebanon, is you have to know the fact that could indeed escalate the conflicting cause that's got it. and now this latest attack and a ran risk escalating an already fragile situation in the region that's been on edge for months, got see a little bit of a yen oh, to 0 for insights toward the
2:34 pm
spring. and i guess and pad on is how some of them professor of literally studies at the university of pet on. and then in ali for the national and founder and director of the center for middle east and globe order. and in bethlehem, i'm on shy with alton, a research fellow of the middle east forum with a special expertise on i so valuable and welcome to all of you, mr. via and from what we know about this attack so far. who operates in this 9? a 2 bombings in quick succession targeting civilians. and now there hasn't been any office of talk on this or an official announcement. obviously there is investigation ongoing to figure out who and how it was pulled off. and but, but so far we don't have any official announcement on the issue. but of course,
2:35 pm
yvonne's original policy and poster has put it in recent decades at loggerheads with the 2 prime suspects in the eyes of the way the ends of those are isis. and it says to organizations and these right, these under back, cuz these are the 2 prime suspects, especially when it went in analysis coming out in different outlets. and i think because these are the 2 parties, but have, it seems inherent interest at this point to hit yvonne with and its internal security. they are being uh, you know, uh, taken as the most probable, uh, you know, a parties that have all this off. okay. miss the 1st one is uh, we are hearing from yvonne in lead. is they not saying exactly who they think it is, but they have said things like the head of the revolution regards. could fools has
2:36 pm
said that they blamed designers, treasury mendez, ally the united states that they're looking to was israel and the united states. but if we look at again at how this attack has been carried out, it doesn't carry the whole marks of past previous attacks by israel does it? that's correct, actually because i mean, i think 1st of all, we should be extremely cautious about the kind of official narrative that we're hearing from do something with public and also state media and it wrong. we're a blaming the usual suspects. um, you know, ease rather than most of the united states by the way. but if you look at past is rarely a, you know, a tops in iran. they were very clearly targeting um, the receipt and its infrastructure fee to military or nuclear. and uh plus um there is also um, you know, the realization of these relative there was
2:37 pm
a white gulf between space that's assigned to new rocks. and i think there is no advertising to execute instructional protection against civilian sooner on that may lead to your run, your society turning against israel. so i think, you know, the probability that these rug was behind this attack is quite low. yeah, and mister, ultimately, i know that you also think that the probability of israel carrying out this attack is low again, when you look at where the bottoms will place from what we know so far about where the bonds were placed. not near the ceremony itself, that was we believe attended by senior regime officials. but you know, where ordinary people who do support the regime, but or do we pay for what, what can, can we some minds from this that the target, you know, wasn't senior ronnie and regime officials e d, the, as i clearly speculate on precise targets,
2:38 pm
but in general from the if you take it from the united states standpoint, then any, the uranium civilian civilian doesn't matter. what was the government don't know any were use very who is a c i o c k is the incident. what they call a rock dice and an app is saved from his mom in the full would you be talking to to do anything in the groups i as in this match is with cause the types they carried out to you, right? um, for instance, uh in the last one the claim died. steve was in october of 2022 and that was targeting in senior officials. those already are the ready and government on times in the way it was just a and inflicting mass casualties. among ordinary people are just some people being c on. this is in the city of c arise. and one thing i actually would add is that,
2:39 pm
um we con, well be waiting for some kind of statement to the is the assignment today. just give bad to say anything about this. yeah, it is. you all the next set on i. so i, i'm sorry to interrupt that, given you are an expert on iso, doesn't the group usually take responsibility pretty quickly when it does carry on to tax? well, this is what i was going to say about this. now i see that they don't always claim every time they do around the well. and that could be for a variety of reasons, because i actually want to point out that there was another type in your eyes as well in august of last year. and the radio is the rest of the operative and sentenced him to uh, i think center this is desiree colton, identifying them as a member of the xining state. it was originally from time to get started. but these, obviously, i just never claim that the tax, i mean it could be the designing states did the website and then dozens claimants
2:40 pm
because it was to say, leave doubt and have the wrong point being. is there other ideas and contributing to this? so why to said the instability i also basically explored or i missed the tensions, especially incredibly high in the region and iran has vowed to retaliate, but they'll have to, it's incredibly important at this stage to find who's responsible, isn't it? just how difficult is it to find to get to the bottom of such an attack? it's very hard and i, i think they are now in they are trying their best to find to find who did it, and then to then get to basically who supported it from abroad. i mean, depending on the uh who is has supported of this farm. and i think yvonne's response will this if it's isis,
2:41 pm
i think yvonne will go after it's leadership in different places in the region of honest on iraq, syria. and this here in the rocky border uh that so i think uh uh, has been the case previously and will be the case moving forward. but if its israel and i hear different bits, i don't to completely roll out these really possibility here because 11 on and the 8 is one of the many speaks about this in his book. these really is a supported part, isn't that committed such crimes within 11 on so you couldn't really rule it out. so i agree. it's a no possibility because the attack seems to be very much administered into what isis usually has been doing and recent years. but you can't prove it's out as well, that these are the possibilities. so if it's a israel, i think that's another issue. they writing a response should be calibrated in
2:42 pm
a way to deter not only israel, but it's back or the main, a fish, anyone's strategic. and you know, conduct in the region that has the united states to deter both and, and that's, i think, is a very complicated and a very sophisticated, a good thing to pull off. because what's at stake is not totally yvonne's internal stability in that case. and just the ones deterrence and determine simple terms is basically uh, you know, backend what in the condition of threats by a pilot projection, yvonne doesn't respond that projection and that conditional threat collapse on outgo. yvonne's determinants will collapse. ok, i think the way it is we'll, we'll find it hard not to respond in one way or another to these here. absolutely missed the phone and measure as you touch the on. you know, some of the problems between the iranian state and society sizes from, i mean,
2:43 pm
there are various groups and yvonne itself is the fight is from below just on there are the, you know, ethnic arab separate shows. they have staged attacks in iran, in the pos would they have an interest due to can carrying out such an attack again, based on past experience, it's not telling me over the last few years, but over the last 4 decades. i think we have to be extremely cautious about um, you know, about naming all those possible attempted traitors. i mean, it could well be that the groups that have been mentioned so far. i've been the try to of this attack would also given past experience could well be that is it, it isn't kind of inside job because there is a long history of structure inside jobs from the very start of the installment resolution to a, just a few years ago remember the r g c a shooting down in the ukranian passenger
2:44 pm
jet and saying that actually it was not to the r g c. so there was a long history. and i think that in all of that, the context is much more important to you. the 1st one initial, when you say an inside job, can you explain exactly what you mean to for sure. so i think, i mean, i, you know, i mean, you should talk about this possibility. um, you know, the, the context is important to context is that these non republic, despite the appearance of being very strong and very stable from the outside has lots of problems both at home, but also in terms of foreign policy. and you know, most importantly, iran is going to have double elections in march of for the parliament, but also the assembly of experts was going to select the next to bring leaders. so there is a lot of complications about those 2, but also there was a resume realization about the lack of social mobilization and photo turn out. and
2:45 pm
the reputation of historically, both the, you know, low bush will turn out this time around as well. so this, uh, you know, this attack, whoever might be the focus, right, to really whatever might be the fact to try to, i think may be used by the iranian states. just for the secure, it ties the domestic jarine up. oh, so, and you of the domestic fluids that i just explained against the backdrop of and still existing, very profound economic price. yeah. so you're saying you're saying that the iranian government might have something to gain, it sounds like from this attack. so when you say inside job, are you implying that elements within the regime itself could have carried out such an attack? yeah, because i mean is i, you know, and then you know, you have to look at that. you're very soberly, you have to look at at the, you know, you have to consider past experience, but those of times we have never known for sure. it would have been the perfect trace. has there been multiple, a circle, tired of subtracts in iran over the last few years, many of which you know,
2:46 pm
have been blamed on divers. um, many of which have been blamed on all of the other usual suspects, but also some of which turned out to be uh you know, have the hands of the around in state as well. so i think i well yeah, well the other guess the because i can see that both of them have something to say about it. mr. ok, maybe i will come to you in just a moment, but if i can get to mr. alton, meaning i know that you have said it's as unlikely that the wrong carried out this attack as israel. so what's your response to what you're hearing that i, yes, i do buying the idea that it was in the radian inside. don't they mean just the timing of beds and the number of people were killed and so it discriminant. and uh and uh, in regards actually to retired. the guys referenced the shooting down and like, i don't really know, evenings intentionally did that. they did that, then they signed to colorado. like for me to present something to no,
2:47 pm
no yeah. you don't think it was okay. um. so again i, i, again, i don't think you can say that the position yet the is bombing state did. and so i, the receiving kind of our investigation happens, although it just seems that it has a whole lot software, but it seems much more like that and then bring it inside job. so we understand that more. okay, mr. if i told him this out, if i can come back, come back to you and look at the symbolism behind the attack itself. you know, what is the message behind attacking the tomb of a man? who was a chief architect of the ronnie and policy across the region. you know, he was, he was the commander of the revolution regards overseas codes force, or the seeing fighters in iraq and syria and 11 on and yeah, and then i mean to, to clarify my previous points. i'm not definitely suggesting that there was an
2:48 pm
inside job, but i'm just as you know, basing my argument on past experience, which i have of showing me very mixed picture about the wide range of possibilities behind the term, subtracts in iran, and currently the situation refer there is a much, much more dire. i explained briefly the domestic situation, but also regionally the, the stronger republic has been uh, interesting, severe blows with the killing of the top r g c come entering syrian but also the killing of ability in the roots. so i think it's at least a welcome. uh, you know, a digression uh from jersey. um that, uh some turbo tax is now it happens uh when it comes to sorting money. i think there's a lot of myths about, you know, the status that it's, that he holds within your honor society. there is certainly a that there has been a period in which many iranians believe that he was a national with euro. but i think this kind of
2:49 pm
a big church is much more contested over the last few years in iran. also given a extreme, you know, wide gulf that is now involved between the bulk of the wrong in society and the regime of the other. or i. so as to whether yeah and i know that you wanted to come in earlier when we were talking about you know mr. thorn initially said that while he's not implying that yvonne elements within the volume regime itself could have carried out this attack the session the it might have something to gain from that it might be a welcome distraction given the immense pressure is it's on the internally and of, of, from international groups as well a while, i definitely with that for you, because i think yvonne at this point more than have a needs, it's deterrence. visa v is relevant. united states given this condition in the region, and i can't do what mr. fentler's on the job is describing to say, well,
2:50 pm
securitized internal because the radians, i mean there's not a public's main legacy, is that it kept iran. it's table in a region into a mall. now a security bridge, the bridge on this scale is a blow to that narrative. how can that be the case? i think that's a one. i mean, based on co public has a lot to do more than it can gain from such an incident. so i think that's uh, i mean, if they went in a position usually talks about a such incidents being internal jobs. well, the, the only incident is the, uh, the app saying that they were late to clear list declared responsibility. and that was an incident. now this can to be an incident, it's a bomb implanted, you know, in the crowd that were commemorating that much force assassinated very,
2:51 pm
you know, celebrated hero and a right nation. and people were, were going there to, to take part in that. and these people are the social base host is not a good public, it's not a good public. i mean, the, for the sake of the argument of it based on the public, even if it does so, which i didn't see any evidence in that it wouldn't hit its own base. all right. what about other groups, mr. alton? they went sorry i missed a for thorn and i shall i can see you wanting to come in here or. yeah, i think, i mean, 1st of all, to clarify the record about the r g c. shooting down to the ukraine and fighter judge according to canadian court rulings, you know, this was probably and then that tensional attack. so there is, in fact, a long history. i mean, instead of my rec site mention to the very beginning of the revolution and also you know, later on. so this is not so you know, as some fantasy here. um, so uh, just to, uh and, and in terms of determines yes, uh,
2:52 pm
the terms is important. but also what is part of the iranian natural security doctrine somehow. uh, also the sun republics security doctrine is the need for crises. you know, it crises can also be a very useful and can be instrumental lies by the states for regional stability purposes. so do this contracts also maybe, right. okay. mr. alton, maybe let me bring you in here. there's some disagreements because the attack was on some southern montes around has to let me bring you in here because there's a difference of views on his, on his legacy. mr. federal emission out saying that, you know, he's, he's not the, he wrote that he was painted to be, what do you make of that? and the groups again, the groups that would be interested in carrying out in the tack on the 4th anniversary of his assassination. yes, we got into
2:53 pm
a positive and so they might need like a z a the really depends who you are in the region. so i mean the, the people's a direct passage log close to your, on these, the images this you wrote, who is important in the fight against the use bonding stage and also fairly rainy and elements and, and celia as well uh, being very high in a very proud to resolve isabel, that's huge encounters with an operations. the other end of the syrian does is all in alaska for example, but then there are others who see and for most of jerry, i was the persecutor of sidney. isn't responsible for mass giving of sydney's whether it's senior year or whether in iraq and or i know so in a symbol runs governance. and so there are the other groups that say for
2:54 pm
example, play on a narrative to balancer. so the persecution near on like age alonzo, and also, uh it isn't moving based in syria or of uranian assuming tags on houses when they come to syrian join use agency, then put out a statement about this use of the sent me using the wrong. so they could also have an interest in doing some kind of like inside that inside the, the don't down and cost them so they might okay. the only thing just been in scale . i don't think. all right, we don't have very long left in the program. so i'd like to ask each of you a final questions to ask for the on, do you think, how much has this attack increase the chance of a why the escalation of violence in the region would you say i think it comes in the time of the original escalation already and that's what the point is, the finger israel, and it's possible by kind of such an incident. so as i said,
2:55 pm
it's your methods or miss durham, innocent of what process used to do. but the possibility of being that if it being backed, or another group being backed by israel, is still there. and that will open the door wide to original escalation. and because if yvonne doesn't respond, it's quite ability and it's a deterrence. will it be at stake? yeah, and if it does, if it responds and i think, well, if it comes to a conclusion that is really is behind it, then we'll see a more escalation in the region. i think this will be a regional, a response, and these are, these will try to attract the united states and picture day goes to ron or possibly other countries to try to put more pressure on your list of for the to do things that as well as trying to drive the united states into a wide, a regional conflict with iran. it is what it is trying to get seems to be united
2:56 pm
states into i think, i mean on your 1st question. despite the fact that chevron claims that there was a link between the 2, the come on explosions and the world as a that it is basically an act of desperation chairs on carried out by using the united states because of the complications of the work. i think that those are 2 distinct reading us here. you're on uh is uh, not suicidal. it's not assigned to regime and also to kind of find revenge that iran had promised after the us drawing killing of selling money. never materialized . so the same caution can be observed within the world garza so neither you're wrong or what are interested in a great wordpress user. and for the united states, i jeopardize reaching something and very quickly mr. alton, they, me, how do you see this incident playing out over the next days and weeks? it really depends on who it really depends on whom the already installed
2:57 pm
responsible. they old is honest, a responsible and sometimes they explains it or whatever. then i think then that doesn't change the wind to read it. don't take their attention escalation of the gods, the war, but it's a separate dynamic. but then if they blame is renelle, i expect some kind of maybe calibrated response of unnecessary a attempt to do on out to with israel and provoke a y divisional, which will be why we're all looking at that around an investigation into what happens so closely or eyes that is a half an hour with an impact on at least i thought i measured in berlin and i'm and job. i've also mimi in bethlehem. thank you very much and thank you to for watching. you can see the program again any time by visiting our website out a 0 dot com. and for further discussion, do go to our facebook page. that's facebook dot com, forward slash a inside story. you can also join the conversation on x a handle as at
2:58 pm
a inside story from me, elizabeth put on them and the entire team here. bye for now. the slaving under the hot sun. collecting a limitless energy, so their own tri, hoses down to. so the panels on his roof for decades, the number line on diesel, shipped in a great expense with crowds from the australian government. the island built itself a so the grid now they can capture and store fully energy they need kind on state fits future of fossil fuels, no renewables, the natural gas from the gulf of thailand, power station funding, co shipped in from australia to transition away from fossil fuels could be relatively easy and china, but the government remains committed to colon. guess where you will never concede,
2:59 pm
it doesn't happen. our country is out enough. we will not take it any more 3 years after protest as storms of the capital. the new rates for the white house begins in iowa as republican candidates once again bethel trump, for the nomination, stay with alpha 0 to the us selection 2024 to zeros here to report on the people often ignored, but who must be hurt. how many other channels can you say? we'll take the time and put extensive followed into reporting from under reported areas. of course we cover major global events, but our passion lies in making sure that you're hearing the stories from people in places like how is fine lydia young region. and so many others. we go to them, we make the effort. we tear straight, unique, respective africans. i'm willing to change in the streets because of the sense of urgency that we have if we don't know more and more lots of voices,
3:00 pm
you don't often hear problem nations do stand with paula spine in the same struggle share of displacement, connect with our community and talking to conversations you find elsewhere, you see where the political establishment is in terms of justifying genocide, brand new episodes of the stream on which is your or the is where the strikes pounds, southern and central regions of gauze or the death toll lines as some of them 22200 people since the will pick up the kind of them or a coil that says out, is there a life from the is are coming up a new reality for garza, israel's defense minister lays out his proposal for its future. not everyone agrees the, the section of states.
21 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=628143031)