tv Inside Story Al Jazeera July 30, 2024 2:30pm-3:01pm AST
2:30 pm
acted by the c i a in 2004, a german citizen was kidnapped and tortured by to see the chain of lead. time comes me into interpretation. a powerful documentary tells us story of how the g of politics, of the post 911 when we were in the life of an in this bill, my suitcase phone, which is here to us, is showing up its military commanded japan. washington says, that's the counter growing threats from china, north korea, and russia. but is this a realistic deterrent for could they provoke more tension in an already volatile region? this is inside store the hello and welcome to the program. i'm how much in room the united states says it's
2:31 pm
re vamping, it's a military command in japan. as the 2 countries face, what they call the greatest strategic challenge from china, us defense secretary lloyd austin says it's the most significant change since the military alliance was formed. 70 years ago. washington and tokyo say they are increasingly concerned by what they call and evolving security environment. the issue of china engaging and course of behavior to change the status quote when the east and south china seas around taiwan and throughout the region. the revamp. coms of china is expanding as nuclear arsenal and russia is strengthening, military ties with north korea. how will this agreement change the security relationship between the us and japan? and how will china respond? we'll discuss all that in a moment, but 1st this report from it to victoria gave me the chinese minutes we drills held around time when they jing believes the self governed dialing this part of china and re unification is inevitable. it's not rude . are out taking taiwan by force,
2:32 pm
the us and japan say such joint sea and directs the sizes are an example of china's increasing the aggressive behavior around the island. as well as in the east and south china sea. they describe the people's republic of china, or po, see as the greatest strategic threat facing the region. we strongly oppose the park . these efforts to unilaterally change the status quo by force in east tennessee and the south china sea. around taiwan. we agree on the importance of upholding peace and stability across the taiwan strait. japan host more than 50000 us troops that take that road is from america, is in the pacific come in and in hawaii. but that's moved in 6000 kilometers away and 19. now is behind japan, the 2 countries have announced a revamped joint command and control structure. the changes that this will be the most significant change to us forces japan sensors creation is one of the strongest improvements in our military ties with japan in 70 years to change as calm as china
2:33 pm
is rapidly expanding its nuclear also. but washington and tokyo also worried about russia's renew, defense ties with fuel yang, going to she had no clue, reaffirmed cool for the computer, the nuclear eyes, ation of north korea. and we also shade our concerns about russia and north korea's military cooperation for japan. the agreement with the us monks a significant shift from decades of pacifism, since world war 2. it's a, been a shift which has been a bit of a tug coming by the, essentially the flexibility of interpretation of the cycle. perhaps this constitution is allowing for this or right to expansion of a potential role deputy soft defense forces in the region. projects say the bolstering of us military bases. anastasia is likely to be seen as a threat by some countries and sub escalate tensions in un or whether you fold
2:34 pm
a tall region. victoria gauge and be desirous the inside story the. all right, let's go ahead and bring in our guess. joining us from badging is victor go, vice president of the center for china and globalization, a leading chinese think tech in tokyo, someone he kinda glitchy is a special advisor at the would you to future study center and then single for evan lex. mamma is an editor at the institute for strategic studies. he also researches indo pacific defense and strategy. a warm welcome to you all and thanks so much for joining us today on the inside story. so when he called, let me start with you today. how significant is this strengthening of the military alliance between the us and japan, and how will it change the security relationship between both countries? it has actually been very long time coming because japan, despite the fact that it's got 3 services of mandatory, there has never been
2:35 pm
a joint operations command. in other words, japanese services have locked. it's no center. japan is a building, it's no center. and united states has now concluded that it is going to build and establish the corresponding command as a theater command. looking after not only japan, but also in this part of the world. because as you'll report or noted, that us in the pack in the pacific command is too far away and quick response is very much necessary. there has got to be a revamping of the us command structure corresponding to the similar changes that have been taking place in japan and bows to expand and re, uh, re a firm and strengthen the joint deterrence capabilities. certainly, that'd be,
2:36 pm
that'd be china. victor. so the us and japan describe the people's republic of china as the greatest strategic threat facing the region. how will china be responding to all of this in the near and the long term? and i think the 2 plus 2 meetings in tokyo and the so called the revamp y'all, the us come out in japan. you are real evidence to show that the bible administration will be recalled is by history as a cold war administration. and people like blank um and the, the secretary of defense of cold war is fortunately, laid out on their way out. and i think by the generates on the 25 it will be called into, i believe yet. because if all the time we use the election, they will be call. and if a couple of harris with when's the election, she most likely will revolve the state department and the secretary the
2:37 pm
department of defense completely. fortunately, this visit is the last for all the cold war administrator position on the president by the therefore, i think we need to emphasize one point. but people in this part of the world does not need a cold war because people do not want to have what we want. jeff peace and stability and cooperation to single out of china as an enemy is completely mrs. jobs. china is a staunch falls for peace. china is a staunch falls for promoting global tre, trying those, but not just the trading nation in the world, trying those but not just the trading partner with more than $113.00 nations in the world, including japan. amazingly, therefore, if any country to single out of china as an enemy, it definitely demonstrates the i that being said,
2:38 pm
all that completely out of their mind. misjudgment, being the most dangerous for haven't you heard victor there talk about the specter of the us presidential election coming up in november. and i want to ask you about how that looms over all of this when it comes to as us as allies in the region. is there a sense of worry about what were to happen when it comes to a disagreement in other potential alliances? if donald trump is re elected to a 2nd term and what exactly the stance will be from comma harris if she is elected as the next president of the us. and i think certainly there is momentum to institutionalize and deep and existing arrangements before and your administration comes in and receive this. whether it's about the long term programs like office with australia and the u. k. or in what be seen in terms of its alliance with the,
2:39 pm
with japan, south korea and the philippines. so it is certainly in the minds of policy makers in the region and among us allies. that regardless of who becomes the new president, we need to institutionalize as much as we could as the best we could. so that whoever comes next uh, wouldn't be able to change all of these things. uh, just because he or she would like to. and this brings us to the issue of, of kamala harris. i do think that she will likely bring in some of the veteran foreign policy hands, whether in the state department or the defense department, and likely those who are familiar with asia as well. so there's some expand if kamala wins, i think we would like to see perhaps a lot more continuity with abided ministration. and yet i do think the tone and style perhaps might be a bit different. i think the reality of the regional secured is that such that some of the momentum that we see on the us l, i, side of things,
2:40 pm
may not tearing into the non us alliance part of the security relationship, particularly in countries in southeast asia. and this is where the us needs to do more work to convince the rest of the region that it is seeking, regional stability and peace. and even if we're talking about geo politics, i want to ask you what are the strategic implications of the us shoring up its military command in japan? and i think it's certainly big in terms of inter operability with japan. we've seen this progress as well. uh, with us allies in other places. so the need to have into operability is a key component for the us disability to deter any regional conflict, whether it's involving china or other countries. so certainly that, that step with japan is a significant one and should not be should that be under estimated. however, i do think that it's going to comes to regional peace and stability. there are
2:41 pm
a concerns outside of us airlines, particularly in countries in the region who are not us allies of what happens to them. are we witnessing a 2 floor regional security architecture for the us and its allies are the top building and those are not us allies at the lower floor? what happens if they can not work better with us? uh we and its allies. so i do think that the momentum, uh that's been going very well on the us and its allies may not carry over in terms of the rest of the reach and, and this is what it concerns about regional tension. and contingency planning comes in because not everyone that has the luxury of its alliance with the united states . that's the only thing i want to look for a moment. and it's sort of the backdrop of, of what's going on. some of the issues at play in japan right now because this reconfiguration of the security relationship between the us and japan. this comes at a time when,
2:42 pm
you know japan has been shifting its defense posture in recent years. japan has, has really shifted dramatically from decades of postwar pacifism. right? yes and no, no, because if you look at the amount of defense budget, which has certainly increased compared to what i did was like 30 years ago, japanese defense spending has grown by 27 percent. whereas chinese defense budget has gone during the same period of 30 years, 3500 percent, meaning $35.00 times as large as it was. so japan should certainly strengthen its determines capabilities, but there is a keen awareness. japan could do nothing alone by itself, which is why japan is very much paying much attention to strengthening its
2:43 pm
alliance relationships and partners with the united states. a strategy of the philippines, vietnam, and india, and so on, so forth. victor of moscow has bolstered its ties with badging in the wake of the invasion of ukraine. how much is all of that playing into this? thank you very much for asking this very important question. but allow me to add one point fairly quickly. first i see what the united states and japan i'll talk to you about on the violation of the japanese constitution, which prohibits the deployment of japanese pulses outside of japan. therefore it is the vehicle as far as this concert fusion violation is concerned. and i think people need your pads are really wake up and to call all the government to take the right measure. rather than being hijacked onto the bandwagon of the united states in its pursuit of geo political. ready all minutes people are at the countries in
2:44 pm
the world. they do not want to be dominated. if japan says it wants to be dominated by the united states, which bomb the to city is with nuclear weapons. be my guest. now you talked about china, russian relations, china and russia, share 4300 killed because long of folder and the border has to be peaceful ever since. 1991 when russia became independent. and we treasure this piece. i've tried quality of cooperation along the china, russian border, and we consider this trunk real peaceful baldor as one of the most important to us all. overall, you'll ration stability. and china and russia are dealing with each other as normal neighbors. countries which want to promote each of those business and trading relations. charlotte does not recognize the wall being ukraine as
2:45 pm
a legitimate war. china wants to have this war achieving ceasefire and wrapped up as quickly as possible. china has always been talking to rochelle the one hand that you create on the other end, about the actual, the subsidy of ending the war and trying that does not provide any weapon of any kind to either russia all to you. ok. that's all i think is true, we'll put china on the right side on history as the only significant in the country in the world today to cause lee called in for peace and sees via the end. the hostility is immune loss a lot more. lot to be say, both in russia as well as in ukraine for volume. the wall is the wrong thing to do, and i've seen property, donald trump has the right thing to say, but if he's elected, you will add the walking 24 hours. i hope it will be able to deliver that as you probably don't want he co victor. there was saying that from his standpoint,
2:46 pm
he believed that this agreement violated the constitution in japan. i just wondered if you had any thoughts about that or wanted to respond well, i would like to say uh that uh, japan needs to change its constitution to make it happen as a just a go has mentioned for the nation to deliver uh, troops outside the nation, but japan's constitution sofa has enabled japanese on forces to defend the nation. only a donation in japan cannot do anything that australia has been doing all the time, but it's a lie and spot know the united states. so it's a go, may have his own interpretation of japanese constitution, but there's been no discussion about to enter in a japan to deliver japanese trips outside of its country. evan,
2:47 pm
i had asked victor about concerns about russia's deepening ties with china. how that is playing into, let me ask you, how worried are the us and japan about russia's renewed defense ties with north korea? and how much is that playing into this? i mean, certainly the renewal of russian north korean ties is a source of concern of for european countries as well as the united states. they have bought that with supplies of all kinds of ammunition and other equipment from dpr k to a restaurant that will allow russia to, to prolong the war and certainly make things a lot more harder to find that that particular ceasefire that we've discussed earlier. however, i think the issue around north korea is also becoming a lot more complicated, not just in terms of it supports the restaurant, but also it's belligerent behavior in the region as well. um, so in that sense,
2:48 pm
the next is, are the conversions between north korea, russia and china does add these, this sense of urgency. i think among us and its allies to sustain the momentum in terms of closing the gas up into operability, enhancing capabilities, but also finding new ways to collaborate in terms of defense, industrial assistance, programs, resilience and others. so i do think the urgency has, has grown precisely because of restaurants, ability to sustain itself now in the war and grow its partnership with, with north korea. but i do think the relationship between russia, north korea and china itself, i think we mains particularly uncertain. we know that there is a pragmatic relationship at this point between the 3, but i'm not entirely convinced that the, that between the 3, the relationship is an equal and an enduring one. so i do thing, yes,
2:49 pm
it actually urgency. but i'm not entirely clear yet that these 3 countries are strong allies in that sense. to victor a couple of minutes ago, you mentioned donald trump and what a 2nd potential trump presidency may mean or may not mean going forward. i want to ask you from, from your perspective, what has happened in the past 24 hours when it comes to strengthening these ties between us and japan. what that is going to mean in the immediate future for the relationship between china and the us as the child abuse this 2222 pos to a region inc talked to a as a result of technol ration as illegal because it violates the constitution of japan, and you may even violate the conditions of all which you're finding out conditionally surrender to china in 1945. therefore, travelers watching the develop, it's very closely and to distinguish the japanese probably noticed i mentioned the
2:50 pm
as the best, the constitution in japan. let me ask us why japan does have this pessimistic constitution because they own collision. literally surrender. it was forced upon japan and japan is prohibited from launching any war of aggression inc. perpetuity . so don't think of all to tinkering with the constitution because no one will allow that. countries like china will never allow japan to reconstitute is constitution to enable laws of aggression by japan. again, in this part of the world, japan should permanent, they remain as a customer base, the country as the conditions upon which japan unconditionally surrender back in 1945 feel rich. if the united states urges japan in the wrong direction, the united states will be held responsible at japan. it follows the jeff jeff us,
2:51 pm
leadership e, venturing out of its country with its military troops. it will again the growth waves as such. look of the united nations chopped up. there are provisions to prevent japan and germany, which condition unconditionally surrender the 1945 from exactly during this. therefore, was you remember what history is? i think you probably will always be welcome as a peaceful nation, as a nation depends upon not being peaceful or religious. whether it's they were being kind of just rama then raising it's made it to realistic. i had again to threaten me. its neighboring countries, especially this rather than countries like china, to which depend on to this, let me surrender here it. i hope this will be the end of discussion about japan. someone he called the joint statement after the announcement, it reaffirmed the us commitment to extended deterrence,
2:52 pm
which includes nuclear weapons. that was once off limits for japan. how big a shift is that of the coverage of new current nuclear weapons over japan? as being here in place for decades. there is nothing new about that. what's happened today is to make sure that the nuclear deterrence extended deterrence is going to be there even more in the future. now responding to mr. gallows. i'm curious allegation, japan made a surrender to the party of the allied powers to which chinese communist party was no part. and then the japanese prime minister made it rob pressure mon, in 1972. and he did, the prime minister, went to china chapman mo said, of course half jokingly, that the japanese imperial immediate terry did
2:53 pm
a great service to the chinese communist party because the comment on party was the enemy number one for chinese companies party at the time. so you cannot have a one sided interpretation of history. now, if i may repeat, china is the only country in the human history that has grown. it's defense budget, a $335.00 times. no nation in the history of mankind has done anything that i liked that in peace time and chinese defense budget now is 5.4 times as large as japan's and a china has not made everything transparent. so a china is met. china may be spending even more than that. so i do wish that the voters, the dividing line between china and japan, china and philippines,
2:54 pm
and china and indonesia and so on. stay and remain prong quail as mr. go said about the line border beat, seen russia and china. the thing of the fact of the matter is a chinese, as they have been pushing envelope all directions to japan, to then cockers, through the philippines and to the vietnam and so on support. evan, it looked to me like you were reacting to a somewhat, somewhat equal was saying that did you want to jump in? yeah, i think it's, it's certainly a key point there, which is whatever regional security tension we now see. it is certainly not without cause, it is certainly not happening without a vacuum. i do think that china should not under estimate the concern and the perception among regional countries including japan, but also india also saw these asian states about china's lack of transparency in
2:55 pm
terms of military spending, but also in terms of its own behavior in the region and we see this as certainly in the philippines over the past year, but that's not an isolated incident with the philippines. china has its own issues with india, as in scott, 12020. yes. things have been relatively quiet with vietnam, but in the past there were certainly a high tension and even conflict with vietnam. so i do think that the history of the region is certainly replete with great powers behaving in a way that creates the impressions of threats and concern. so i do not think it's particularly productive uh to sideline these concerns altogether and blame it entirely on the united states. because i do think one very important piece of concern for everyone in the region is agency and autonomy. and the need to define and defend its own interest in its own concerns. i do think we should not be
2:56 pm
assigning a particular motive to other countries like the united states and others as if these regional countries do not have their own agency and autonomy. and they have and we only have about a minute and a half left. but let me just ask you, is all of this going to allow the us to further strength and relationships with other allies in the region? i think the allies part certainly yes, there is a momentum of building up and washington is certainly going to push that moment some part of their with south korea with i'll stay. ready with japan and yes with the philippines as well. but as i said earlier, that momentum is certainly now starting to move into difficult terrain like techno, logical sharing, cyber security information and intelligence sharing into operability. so darn a whole host of, of, of alliance management and issues that are far from being resolved. but the momentum is heading that way. the challenge for me is not on the line side cuz i
2:57 pm
think it's going very well for now. but whether or not the non part of the non alliance part of the security partnership, truth countries like single floor indonesia, vietnam, and others can build and have that same momentum. that's the part that i haven't really seen. it seems as if washington is basically saying, the train is moving, you either jump on or hop off, but we're moving ahead with our alliances in the future. so i do think this is creating a sense of uncertainty and concern among the rest of the reach and outside of us alliance. all right, well we have run out of time, so we're going to have to leave the conversation there. thanks so much to all of our guests. victor galton, when he kinda glitchy and evan likes mont. and thank you to for watching, because see the program again. any time by visiting our website. i'll just share a dot com and for further discussion, go to our facebook page. that's facebook dot com, forward slash age and side story. you can also turn the conversation on x r handle is at a j inside story. for me, how much in room and a whole team here,
2:58 pm
bye for now, the so long to there's no place like home. except when home is for the part of the lebanese filmmaker documents as likes to one of the country's most turbulent times, the appeal, the anxious and fatal. a witness documentary on this jersey south korea police receive up to 200 reports. while it's every day when, when a is to investigate career, lead from one out to 0 once
2:59 pm
a journey through every story, every step is a narrative, a separation of what we cannot choose when to reach the welcome to send me an extra re designer redesigns luxury losing trusting l. a future today, we create on the counselors reporting exclusive stories explosive results, which is 0 investigations investigative journalism. this is quite chewing, walking through here, sensing that last horrible mind, but of the journey voices from different corners of survival. it's survivable survivor runs for reparations and justice stories from all the angles like this actually music of the way people talk,
3:00 pm
the way we walk programs that open your eyes to an alternative view of the world today. on now to sierra the on the bulk or in doha, the top stories are now just the right. is there any forces have withdrawn from eastern, con eunice software to solve that last it over a week and killed 255 palestinians. another 300 people injured palestinians of slow and he would turn into what little remains. hundreds of homes have been partially or completely destroyed and estimated a 190000 people were displaced from central and eastern, con eunice during the offensive. when we are returning to our home and may god bless us as we can do all the suffering and one love. we do not have any transportation.
27 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on