tv Witness Anxious in Beirut Al Jazeera August 3, 2024 4:00am-5:01am AST
4:00 am
a now the also worried about the threat of diseases. there are some of the media stories, a critical look at the global news media on how to 0 government shut off access to social media. the . i am sort of fights into how the top stories on al jazeera, the united states will send a new carrier groups to the middle east, as well as deploying missile defense vessels and a flights of squadron to the region. washington says it wants to increase support for the defense of israel high. the jury, castro reports this announcement by the pentagon is not only moving assets on air, on sea, but also on land. and it was ordered as a quote necessary measure by secretary of state, lloyd austin. today. it includes sending the u. s. s abraham lincoln battleship to
4:01 am
replace the u. s. s. theodore roosevelt. of course, that is the aircraft carrier with its sum 40 fighter jets, which has been moving from the persian gulf now to the gulf of oman, which is toward israel. the us will also be sending more ballistic missile defense, capable cruisers and destroyers to the region. and an additional fighter jet squadron to the middle east. all of this, the pentagon says, is to increase readiness to in case there is an iranian, or iranian proxy, retaliatory attack on israel. in addition, they're considering just more land based ballistic missile defense systems and sending more us troops to the region to operate these assets. well, the announcement from the pentagon comes out is off the dignitaries from across the middle east bay, the final farewells, one of the regions, most significant political figures. the funeral home us politically. the smile on
4:02 am
a husband held in capsule after he was assassinated into her on, on wednesday, bows him, us on the wrong accuse is row of carrying out the attack. following the assassination of this my and had a, a lots of onset since he looms over. the goal is the strip and the future of see spot negotiations and told that he has moved from data by law. in central garza, the people are very tired, they're waiting for the days where they are going to read night with their families that are separated. they're waiting to dig for the bodies of the missing aside. many members are waiting for the minute they could go outside the cause group and receive their medical treatment. there's a lot of, of, of misery and the loss of depression among the palestinians and the cleaning up some aid hmo me the suffering worse, especially that there's no holes or anything related to the negotiations in the
4:03 am
region right now. is there any forces of arrested dale to be pre show all the ox mos golf the he paid tribute to is my inhaler during friday. prayers for to show it as ray, the soldiers taking shape. i'll come some brief from his home and occupied the east jerusalem. israel argues subsidies some and constitutes in science minutes. meanwhile, is ro has their own strikes in to southern 11 on the latest an air raid on the village of either of shop and the motors their own districts. this comes off to lebanon's has both sides of barrels of rockets towards northern is ro, functions on the border answer and all at some old time. hi, this ca of israel assassinated senior has bowler. come on, just to add shop on site. today us vice president. com, the harris has won enough. the goods votes to be the democratic presidential. no many. while the online voting prices continues till monday, she's already secured more than 2300 votes needed to secure the nomination and
4:04 am
a phone call. message harris said she was honored to be the ticket. i am honored to be the presumptive democratic nominee for president of the united states. and i will tell you the tireless work of our delicate it's our state leaders and staff has been pivotal in making this moment possible for us defense secretary lloyd austin has wrote a plea deal that was agreed earlier this week with a minor accuse of loss of minding the september 11th attacks and 2 of his accomplices, 3 of the 5911 defendants. that's going to know her degree to feed guilty to all that charges, including the mother of nearly $3000.00 people. according to austin, the pre agreements have since been revoked. oh, those are the latest headlines that continues on hey algebra also had the
4:05 am
it is a little fight until we destroy from us as military capabilities and its rude and gaza and bring all our hostages. all since how mazda is attack on october, the 7th. israel is b lay waste to the gaza strip, tens of thousands killed and these rated government now to use the committing genocide. we looked at the history of the conflict. tell us about how we thought here. my guess tonight is the famous. the provocative is really historian benny morris is well documented. many of the crime is committed by israel in 1948, but his critics say he now justifies those crimes. i'm mattie hudson, and i'm here in london's legendary free speech society conway hole. to go head to head with benny morris. i'll challenge him on
4:06 am
a support for the war m garza and i'll ask you more, he thinks accusations of genocide or absurd. tonight i'll be joined by a panel of experts down the leaving a full ma is really peace negotiator and president of the us middle east project deanna boot to the products to the lawyer and former advisor to the yellow and the manual. and of on and is really electra of diplomatic studies at tel aviv university. the thank you for joining me on a head to head. you are a supporter, a defender of israel's current, warren garza, which began and its current form off to the atrocities on october the 7th, which is since killed more than $38000.00 palestinians,
4:07 am
including $15000.00 children, displaced more than a 1000000 people made cause uninhabitable to the un and is being investigated as a possible genocide at the international court of justice. a lot of people around the world think it's a genocide. i happened to think it's a genocide, but you have cool that accusation upset. why as well, i once investigated a real genocide by muslim trucks against the christian communities of turkey around a year, 1900. some 2000000 christians were killed at the time by muslim turks. and that's what the genocide actually looks like. what's happening causes a war to war in which there are a lot of collateral in this a, among a gardens. the worst started of course by the come us from guys up in the giants and massacre. and on october 7th. and the only way to respond to that than any country would have responded to that more or less than the same fashion. i think
4:08 am
for us to try and go after the saw some us. but the, some us was embedded in the population as you know, to use the schools, the, the schools of the hospitals as bases as places where they stock their munition, their guns themselves hid in tunnels, underneath the schools in apartment buildings. and this all involves collateral damage, which of course the from us knew it was going to ignite by killing it. 1200 is really is on the 7th of october i myself have problems with the war as it's being waged. but the genocide is definitely p as in the am here is not to kill as many tell us then, you know, still the definition of genocide. you wrote a book on genocide, the definition of traits, one of the definition it's not find kills not based on number of different. it's also based on intent and on yes or just based on the intent. yes, there's no story to kill and hold or impulse. there's no intent here. that's as far as i understand. i'm not i'm, i just want to just say, i'm not, i'm not, i'm not
4:09 am
a government spokesman. you seem to be, i'm not sending me is a government. how do i know they're presenting the you and i asked a few of you and what i didn't say anything will come to them. i'm just asking about your view right now. the definition of genocide you wrote a book on it is nothing to do with how many people you can. so it's not a numbers. it's also a numbers get the i see, see chief prosecutors off for a restaurant. it's not just for hamas leaders, but for these really 5 minutes to and the defense minister for war crimes and crimes against humanity. and he says, you have mountains of evidence. we've all seen with our own eyes these raised in gaza, committed war crimes on camera, kill on people who are caring, white flags. flo up apartment buildings dropped to 1000 pound bombs on crowded refugee comes time. we at least agree, man, even if we're going to disagree on genocide, the israel is committed numerous of all crimes, since dom oswell crowns on october. the 7th. i'm fairly sure that'd been well. crimes the toward itself is not a war crime as the some us attack on israel, on the 7th october was it was a little crime from beginning to end. the aim was to kill as many civilians as possible,
4:10 am
which they did in accordance with the how much charter which is to kill basically every jew you can get hold of in palestine. but i didn't ask about the game. i asked about the facts that are being committed. as i said, probably they have been as an oil wars, war crimes. you may have to be more. yes. so you would support an arrest warrant for benjamin that know that just to say that why, especially if it hasn't been in the rest bar and that there's been a requirement from the prosecutor so far, they haven't issues. i don't know if you can hold the prime minister responsible with a sergeant that kills several unarmed people intentionally. you don't think these ready f was bombing apartment buildings refugee come small fish these cemeteries hospital this little if someone of us these library honestly, it hasn't bombed as far as i know, hospitals are they have a tax you know, there are no expert agrees with you on that, that's not, that's not true. what you're saying is not true. the only hospital which i remember being on was by a rock, it's final night is make jihad, oh my mistake. oh my god,
4:11 am
i remember. so the drill has read is almost because let me, let me, let me, let me told israel has read his hospitals with infantry. let me ask you this on how much a people in there, how much headquarters inside when those on there also, i believe we've never seen the headquarters, the benjamin that know what a beautiful bundle movie video. but we've never actually seen that from underneath . i'll ship to being several months. we're still waiting for that. so on the 31st of october, according to human rights watch as role, is there any forces unlawfully attacked? a 6 story residential building can a $106.00 civilians, including $54.00 children without warning full strikes completely dom always human rights or from no evidence of amended to talking in the vicinity, making a strike unlawful, indiscriminate under the law miles is brand new authorities. it provided no justification for the of the from us always hides a their own killing. me is really didn't say that they were hiding in the apartment building. i know you said you don't want to just spoke to them and know you're offering a better different the government and i, i don't know, i don't know the particulars of that particular that it could be that there was
4:12 am
a war crime committed there. it could also be that the hundreds of how much fights was in the building and was like along side you would be, you the okay, so the have you ever seen for the district? wait, have you ever seen flips coming off of the goal is to say, which shows how much fighter lit? have you ever seen that? how much all you see a simply any findings the the senior john list? yeah. hi, i'm of the orange under and guess what? we're not allowed in by these are and they are highly naturally are great. we should allow people in your room. let me tell you something about this really air force if we're talking about each mission of this really air force is probably the most accurate and the efficient arm of this really military is checked before and by a lawyer, etc. to see if i'm, if the actual a is there evidence or actual evidence on so glad you're pointing out because it's not a robot operation, it goes all the way up. so we count, indictment and yahoo for these attacks because it's gone off the china come on. so
4:13 am
we agreed you say it's not genocide. can we at least agree that is the genocidal rhetoric and genocidal intent from various members of these. right. the government . yeah, we agree that the rhetoric from that and yahoo and how does all and smoke which it's this is genocide or after some of the ministers, i'm not sure about hotel quotes and i'm not sure about what nathaniel has said. that somebody knows that i'm elect many, you know, the next, i don't know if that's the same as genocide. the shooting every man, woman and child. i the don't cheese. you're good. and then listen to something something really there's something absorbed above this line of questioning. israel was intent on genocide. it's can you like me to hold on? can you let me speak? would you let me talk? can you let, didn't you let him speak just guy. this guy's guy is we are going to have to stop the entire show and you will have to go home if we do not have some order. so many, please finish your point. if there was
4:14 am
a genocidal intent in the war making in the gaza, there would be not 30 solid single. so as incidentally, these numbers are all issued by how much we don't know how to, how true they are. but if there was genocide within 10 by these really government, with these really military machines to commit genocide in gaza, that would not be $30000.00 or $20000.00. and that would be hundreds of thousands of thousands. i'm sure that's, i'm not sure what that is. for that's is called genocide, and that's not what's happening by any we really discuss. that's not the definition of genocide, but okay, let me ask you to know what your definition. the only thing for the genocide convention is different, but at it for now 1948. i like to mention lots of different things that's not carry by 71 because only 19040. and just to mention that sounds the magic, there's only one. there's only one truth to come, us truth sound the same as the 1948, just like you mentioned how much are they? is everything and i'm off. but if there's a genocidal side in this, okay, back to it is how much. okay, let me ask you this just to look at the charter,
4:15 am
read the words there, reads what it says about. otherwise funny i'll say in 10 money, by the way to, to the jews. i mean that's how many i bought from. i've interviewed people from us . i've asked about the child, i'm interviewing you, right? i don't, i want to tell you it's so nice to talk to you. i'm sure they do. is there any minister dicks? i remember the security cabinet. he said, we're not rolling out the guns and that he was referring to the next. but the catastrophe of 1948 when an estimated 700000 palestinians were driven from their homes. you famously documented a lot of that back in the eighty's. you undermined a lot of his already propaganda that they just play sled on their own. so whether it's the 1948, not cool with the 2020 people gauze or not, but the quote victor, for palestinians zionism is not, but it is ethnic cleansing. surely you will, people can recognize that i'm not sure i can recognize that. no. yeah, you keep putting words in my mouth, a design isms in 10 plus to establish as a jewish state in the area quote, palestine is the land of israel initially. design is wanted to establish
4:16 am
a jewish state on the whole land of israel or oil of palestine. 19371938 design and some change and said we can have all of the land. there are lots of palestinians here. let's share it with the palestinians. the 1937, the british appeal commission, proposed the partition of palestine between the 2 peoples living and it's the palestinian said no and continued the war against britain and design this design and said yes to the partition proposal him by po, the international community repeated the ideals of the partition of palestine between the jews and the arabs. in 1947 november the famous resolution 181. the jews said yes to the un partition. resolution of 1947 accepting it. they would get some of the palace find the palestinian arabs will get the part. and the palestinian said no and started shooting the next day, killing jews. so one of the reasons i wanted to interview you because,
4:17 am
because i know some of the history you do know some of the has finally said they all share. but the problem is, i don't know which many more as i'm speaking to because you're saying they wanted to share the land. and yet i have a book here that says on the most basic level, jewish colonization ment, expropriation and displacement design, it's audiology and practice with necessarily an element to lead expansionist zionism was a colonizing an expansionist ideology. that's right there by you any more than. and i think i did you, i really really into the i agree with every word in there. but as i said, desires and change the subjective and go in the 19 thirties and the greens reluctantly a mat resigned to the idea of partitioning the land. and from that point, them designed as a number of times in 3747, the 2008 proposed partitioned in palestine with the palestinians. and the
4:18 am
palestinians consistently, i've rejected the condition on the how much the palestinians. okay. and on the pillow, top the hutch. what are the oh wait, let me check about this. let me ask you this, the truth, luxury basic okay. of the conflict. okay. sign is the only money. let me on the course on a swimming to compromise and what kind of simians always say no, no, yes, go ahead. i wanna read a quote. uh yes, you keep saying lots of positive stuff today, sharing, dividing. i wanna read the quote to you there are circumstances in history. yes, but justify ethnic cleansing is that is not a quote from somebody on the last of it. yes. that is on a quote from a london my defines no quote. yeah. yeah. i don't know your critical, you know, next you're no longer just document ethic, lindsey, you apologize, what is the context of what i put what you're going to try to do the context as you're asked you condemn what they did in 1948 sinus militias. you say no, you're all state perpetrated ethnic cleansing. you say there was circumstances in history that justify ethnic plan. what was the circumstance i'm talking about you say, i know that this time is that sometimes i'm reading or quotes. i know that this time
4:19 am
is completely negative when the choices are things up. think lindsay and genocide. yes. you're not elation of real people. i personally the cleanser. so the jews understood in $48.00 the jews were on the trip of the night. elation by the arabs, and that's in my view. and legitimize justified cleansing arabs from palestine with seduce crescent, with best buy a 2nd genocide. after the 90 genocide, the who to said exactly the same thing about they we pulled in 1994. they were talking about the diamond. no, they said we can absolutely transaction because they're threatening us. no, i don't really have a diagnostic things. no the right, i didn't say threatening. i said the odds of follow spun attacks. the jewish community empower style from 1947 to other than just say like when they were going, they would justify it. what if i'm a crime against humanity, ethnic cleansing is not regarded as a war crime by any a you'll find with it. it's not about a fine, it's not the 100. and then when i pull,
4:20 am
i prefer ethnic cleansing of the other to being that massacred a my, my own people. yes. sure. even if that involves innocent people being driven for them to not ask to come this, if you, if you are on how does that fit? i just wanted to show them that the current bill, of course, is i just want to know your you're mixing up the, the, the times the chronology designs were willing to share the lands. the arabs said no, the arabs attacks them. and from that point on the jews to defend themselves properly, they would have to drive out the arabs in certain areas a from which the arabs were attacking the jewish. and so it was, it was all talking about success in the heat of all. it wasn't ideological, it was pragmatic. even though you yourself say the transfer was inevitable and in, built in design isn't yours? it depends. it depends. what do you mean by transfer attends from what you mean by transfer? you're the one you're from. it depends. no, no, no, it depends what parts of the population were talking about. total transfer. it was
4:21 am
never in the parts of zion. this partial transfer a partial transfer from areas in which the jews wanted to establish the state and part of palestine and from which the arabs, who was a busy attacking the jews. okay, i want to bring in the panel before i do, a lot of talk about with design is i'm is a form of colonialism. if i said to use on is, i'm is something colonial. what would you say to that? i would say the some partial truth in it, but in the on large it's wrong. it's not the correct interpretation. there's a feeling of those words. he wrote a letter to assess or wrote the found or wrote easier and in, baldwin. he said it's something colonial office, so maybe take it out with ok. i can take it up with or to. okay. her to may have said that in order to may he did say in great shape. no, no into in, in, in an effort to ingratiate himself with the great, colonizer a rhodes. it's possible a that, that's not the point. and the point is the sound in the 800 design, the don't allow me to finish them. i do believe their utility. the continuation is designed tenuously and throughout please find to do what tim trump did to bite. wow
4:22 am
. and then what do you know? what are some of these for you? but it's a, you know, more time saying that the events of his sentences, zionism intended to liberate the jews from the an alien nation and oppression in under which they lived in a eastern europe. also later, central europe, by a stablish in a state of the jews of the majority of jews, as jews ruling over themselves, they ended up, they ended up in, in part to realizing that true dream act expensive palestinians. this is correct. okay. what happened is it turned out we lend the point of agreement bringing a panel. we have done a boot to the palestinian lawyer and israel from advisor to the p l. o. at emmanuel nevada is an international relations electro. tel aviv university. daniel levy is the form. is there any piece negotiate a present of us, middle east peace projects, piano. i'm interested in hearing what you have about the genocide. then we started the show to what i've done is i bet anybody adamantly says it's absurd. there's many definitions you're in the way. what do you make of the funny is exactly what
4:23 am
to expect him to be, which is a genocide deny or an a genocide apologist. every human rights organization has been defining this as a, as a genocide, we have the i c j that has come out and said that there is plausible case for genocide and yet worship. believe he is rarely is the only people who say that it isn't a genocide. israel is allowed to be a colonizer, is there, i was allowed to do with it, please. and that house to me is just have to sit by idly and take it. and this is the fundamental problem with design as a, but we tell us citizens are the ones who feel zionism on our bodies. we've paid for it with our lives. we paid for it with our land. this attempt to re define zion as a, we'll go nowhere because, you know, and the nice of the, the same, i know you're into that's relations as well. is there a recognition that then a lot of the world world governments, allies of israel,
4:24 am
as well as the usual human rights groups, are very critical at a minimum the way that as well as the prosecutor, what's going on and doesn't as well. first of all, diana said we're feeling designers and you're right, you're feeling it because the only place in the middle east where arabs are free is israel. and so i was afraid of that. you have diana is because the only country in the middle east where there is freedom is the state of israel from which you benefit. and you should be thankful for it. i am not the only the only country, the only country in the middle east. what else can elect the officials be elected? the judges of the supreme court be present at the university. the only free country in the middle east is red, and if you want to respond to that, i find it staggering. the gentleman to my right is telling the palestinian citizen of israel how she is experiencing the reality under which she lives it's. it's
4:25 am
a staggering moment for me. now. you know, there was different strands designed as okay. there was a culture designed ism, that was a, by nationals, i lived in this could have gone in different directions from the perspective of 202475 plus years in the idea that this is just something. but 9 doesn't match with the reality that has been live. now i would say it's clear what this has been full palestinians, but i would argue it's not doing what was written on the tin for jews is all i don't think either is really jewish or local jewish safety is best served by the actions we see day in day out, steve jobs, if you like to respond to what you've heard from the panel. i think there's a misunderstanding here. there is a separation between israel and the west bank. israel and the occupied territories largely populated by just palestinians,
4:26 am
a and the state of israel. in israel itself, there is a rule of law. there is generally equality the between the jews and the arabs. and you miss representing it when you say that they are persecuted and he's damn right . and but he says, all the arab states are dictatorships which do not allow their citizens any freedom and is really arabs enjoy most of the rights they may be discriminated against. and certain things that they may may enjoy shifting rights, which jews do not have, for instance, not serving 3 years, wasting 3 years in the army, for example, is really out of the don't we don't want to know that yes, it's fine. yeah, sorry. what is your most policies in desperate disobedience really mean if you're, i'm sorry, i'm unfamiliar right for our leaving the should be do in free 1967 zionism in israel. it was not the colonial enterprise in the west bank. there is a colonizing and colonial framework, which is even the part tied like in its actual workings,
4:27 am
but in pre 1967 israel. that was not the case. and for the 1st 100 years or so design isn't. it wasn't a colonial venture. it wasn't on a venture of an extension of an imperial. let me just define colonialism since you're so busy defining genocide. imperialism and colonialism were matched together in which imperial and empire sent its children to dominate and take over a 3rd world country and exploit. this rich is not the real business landfill. 1967, you might have to agree with benny that there was a colonial aspect in a pop tart like aspect to the occupied westbank. no zionism is a national liberation movement that freed its line from arab muslim colonialism. how is your thing is lamb expanded itself from the our peninsula to indonesia, from indonesia to morocco, not from the holy spirit. this was conquest and colonialism. okay. we are out of
4:28 am
time. i'm going to give you on the last web before we go take a break. okay, so now we have a net cloud desire and a net, a power out design, as well as a janet size, and i or genocide apologise. the point of the matter is, is that palestinians have always paid the price for israel's colonial adventures. my family hales for hundreds of years from palestine. and what happened in fort 1948 was my family was ethnically cleansed from palestine, where from many, fell from an immediate and never able to return back to their put to their home. my father died unable to return back to his village because of the colonialism that is called zion as if that is it for paul, one old head to head without special guest, any morris and pump to we'll be talking about what is happening inside of is ready society, we talk a bit more about benny morris has views. i'm gonna hear from, well, i was gonna say patient audience, they've gone away all. but then also i patient tonight that's important to have
4:29 am
head to the, as china rems, up to full patients of north korean, defective human rights group, say they faced imprisonment, torture and even death in the country. in desperation, some involve dangerous journey. $1.00 oh, $1.00 east reveals the north korea's claim to factors on al jazeera, have feelings, of course, that if a gosh to burst, it sparks small villages into that. with a fast assault that these women have decided to take cities. they need to go to town and look for help for the families. they need tense and just about everything is some of the families that have managed to escape are now living here in these little shelters of stick on store their property. they'll find me land as well as their homes house or being something most local authorities believe between 5 and
4:30 am
6000 people. how being affected, afraid this might only be the beginning. the hello, i am certified to to know how the tech stories on al jazeera, the united states will send a new carrier group to them at least as well as deploying missile defense vessels. and a fights of squadron to the region. washington says it wants to increase support for the defense of israel high. the jury, castro reports in this announcement by the pentagon, is not only moving assets on air, on sea, but also on land. and it was ordered as a quote necessary measure by secretary of state. would austin today?
4:31 am
it includes sending the u. s. s. abraham lincoln battleship to replace the u. s. s . theodore roosevelt. of course, that is the aircraft carrier, with its sum. 40 fighter jets, which has been moving from the persian gulf now to the gulf of amman, which is toward israel. the us will also be sending more ballistic missile defense, capable cruisers, and destroyers to the region and an additional fighter jet squadron to the middle east. all of this, the pentagon says, is to increase readiness to in case there is an iranian, or iranian proxy, retaliatory attack on israel. in addition, they're considering just more land based ballistic missile defense systems and sending more us troops to the region to operate these assets. well, the announcement from the can pencil then comes out as often signatories from across the middle east bay. the final firewall is one of the regions most significant political figures. the funeral. so how mazda is politically the smile
4:32 am
and a has been held in council officer. he was assassinated into her on, on wednesday, both from us and iran accuses role of carrying out to be attack us defense secretary lloyd austin has their vote to please deal that was agreed earlier this week with the man accused of most of minding the september 11th attacks and 2 of his accomplices, 3 of the 5 non 11 defendants has got going tomorrow, had agreed to plead guilty to all the charges, including the murder of nearly 3000 people. this was reportedly in exchange for the prosecution, agreeing to not seek the death penalty. according to a memorandum signed by austin on friday, the pre agreements have since been revived. well, those are your latest headlines and news continues here on out to 0. also a head to head, you can also visit our website alda 0 adults. com of the
4:33 am
welcome back to head to head on out to the english. i'm with my guests, benny morris, one of israel's most famous historians. we have a panel of experts and we have a live audience here in london is conway hole, who will be hearing from shortly spending morris. in part one of the show we argued you and i about the genocide of ethnic cleansing about the neck. but can we start putting to benny by agreeing both of us on something that israel seen in recent is a pretty serious, severe, brazen shift to the right. some would say fall right with the likes of bizarre low smote rich and it's not been good. we're in the cabinet, a lot of fanatical stuff lives inciting violence in the occupied westbank, according to some polls. 60 percent of his really do say it's better for that to be segregation between the 2 societies. 48 percent according to one point of view as it goes, supported the expulsion of policy and incidence visit. what is going on in his role is relas turned definitely to the right. it's partly to do a demography more religious people,
4:34 am
a born in more than secular people. a i would say also unfortunately most far the people are born the michigan as the secular people. i would say that in addition to the demographic shift, which is taking place in the last 203040 years in continuous arab terrorism and our reluctance to reach a compromise, as also driven his release to the right. you're also being critical of default, right in his role as we just have to say very critical. you've called netanyahu cowardly and incompetent, but you yourself are being criticized by some on the left button is around and abroad for your own views. and i just want to, to get through some of them with you because you've said what many would say a racist things about palestinians. arabs, muslims, you've called them barbarians. you've said they have no marlene admissions. you said they would be caged. you've said palestinian citizens of israel or time them a 5th call them. oh yeah. yeah. i'm sorry. of the, i mean i goes to just, i know, but the audience me to all the time you say you're
4:35 am
a liberal and you believe in the peace process? a lot of problems to me was that how do we make peace with people who say that liberals on is and they think of us in this way? scratch the credit question of quoting out of context which you are indulging in those who grew up buses and in restaurants in israel. during the 2nd intifada, i'm talking about both come us and felt the terrorists in a i quoted barbarians and they'd be awesome. and i did school. no, no, i called them barbarians and they behaved like barbarians. cool. no i didn't. you do the miller and harlots? no, no. the arrow bold as it is today is bob barry. that's true. barrel grove. i didn't say all arabs about very, as i said, the arab world is barbarian and it's b r as well. well, bump back to look at syria where the regime killed about half a 1000000 people in its civil war trying to suppress an uprising. look at them with the arabs, so busy killing a blacks and dar for looking for libya with their killing each other. the true
4:36 am
booms of funeral corsages, look at the rack. they behave like barbarians. if somebody said to you, and i would say this is on to somebody. if somebody said to you the jews of omarian's, the jewish world as barbarian, i think you would agree that sunday somebody. and if somebody said, well, i know behind me cuz i'm just talking about the ideas. i don't think it would be anti semitic would be false. that's that you don't think you'll be under somebody for me to say a jewish world is marian before. it's not, not necessarily on the some. and when you say these really arabs are a time bomb and there are potential 5th column. this, all of them you didn't say some terrace. i said it was or what is earl's our a minority a which identifies in large measure with the palestinian cause is in the long historical perspective a potential time bomb. yes, i would agree with that. you said there are potential 5th column for us that the potential 5th column. yes. an emissary of the enemy that isabella, this is vicious start and i, i don't remember the using the word and to be able to whether you remember it,
4:37 am
well no is irrelevant. you said the slide is this slide into complete publish. the notation has made them an emissary of the enemy. that is among us is your, is your of the 2nd intifada when the were riots by is really arabs blocking of roads, etc. and they behaved like an emissary of the enemy. this is correct. so it depends on the context you keep quoting things without explaining the context. i'm not sure there was any context for dismissing and taught people as a physical. nobody is ok. so, all right, let's talk about some of the views of fuels which are somewhat controversial. many would say you're not just somebody is that some, you don't really want any facts from you need any explanations of anything. you just explain to them very well you're wrong. do you know your trauma? so you just want to accuse no accusing, i have to go out and i cannot hear somebody in whatever this isn't really an interview. this is a basically bleeding throwing and, and in the 3rd edition, you don't like defending your he's, i don't like defending my use. i'm able to defend my views, make sure that i'm up with these quotations, which are out of context of the don't explain this, the article context,
4:38 am
everything the audience doesn't understand what you're talking about. i just sent you the quote and then the read the and while you're better racist which you readings at the beginning when you to use this. so yeah, you said when you okay, does he hasn't somebody else you said you said when your mother in your hall larger numbers, it's not a matter of money referring to palestinians. israel, it's the societies nature. yes, i would say that's a racist comments. an entire system during the address and ensuring the 2nd then default was set in 2019 but not in the 2nd intifada. somebody told if you can't remember, when you said things in 2019, you said this is not about this is what we're talking about. murder is the society's nature, you're of who the motor rates in israel, you said, oh, explained to the audience what we're talking. i'm sort of bringing you the you said that minute the society exclaimed, let me explain what was going on in the murder rates by is really arabs of their fellow people, basically not of jews, but the fellow arabs is much,
4:39 am
much higher. it's about a 100 or 200 percent higher than the murder rate among jews. the same applies and so that is the killing of women. is the same applies to on the on, on the murders which are called the honor killings. when women shows too much league or looks at the man the wrong way, this is and unfortunately, inherent in arab societies, in general, in the middle east, and among his really arabs as well. that's the context might my part of the context . so making sweeping say no, that's true, let me off the race. let me off. it's the, let me, you are a race we will, we're, we're in the assistance with your race is, is through the race. the reason is actually a race is we're talking about the time you said the right amount. i would love to me don't want to happening community and gauge when we talk kind of about what i'm talking to will come to the already. okay. one of the coming the one last when you can do what you, i'm having last question. it's a, it's a free country. as i say,
4:40 am
let me ask you, this is not just the racism that you've been accused of. you're also being accused of woman. you just recently wrote a har, it's called him in june. we use that israel should consider a new king it wrong to prevent them from acquiring nuclear weapons. not even benjamin netanyahu has said that you've said where he's more responsible as a prime minister to your irresponsible. yes. i mean, you can get into that country. that is not felt certain in the article. you misquote, everything you said i own was for everything you say it was a quest. so tell say what, what the context is place is destroying the reunion. the nuclear facilities. that's the quote then you yes, within your but not destroying you around. as you just said, i said, you think dropping a new come around would have limits not only around on the small nuclear, bombs can destroy facilities like not funds and you know that a new, if not, i mean you've been advocating for 15 years. well, i've been advocating is released and is really strike against the iranian nuclear project, because around says that it's policy is to destroy israel. if the avenue they ever
4:41 am
achieve nuclear weaponry is role will be in mortal you and say that you said both of them that you something no, no, no, no, no, no, no. in 2000 i, you're not telling the truth. you know that you didn't go for the new unit for nuclear spike in 2000 a on or on? no, i didn't. you run a $1008.00. i said, israel, it should destroy the iranian nuclear installation with a nucleus. right? no, i didn't say this is my problem financing. so of course, you know, we're no, no, no, no, i don't. new york time on july, the 18th, 2008 and is really nuclear strike to prevent the uranium from taking the final steps towards getting the bomb is probable. i didn't said support. as i said, it's probable you said they will try it. if it's letting tyrone have its bomb, it was very clear what you're talking about has now explain what is real. does not have this part of its policy in the doesn't the nouns as it's policy, the destruction of duran duran does say that it's policy is to destroy as well. and they are working digital diligently to get nuclear weapons. and if the iranians do achieve nuclear weapons, israel a will be basically will be finished. that's the,
4:42 am
that's ok, radians or email. let me i'm using a nuclear new tactical nuclear weapons to destroy the radian nuclear installations before they achieve nuclear weaponry. make sense to me may not make sense to you just because you're not. this is and it's really she don't care. but a, i'm assuming being so i care about nuclear. i don't know what they care about. i don't know about, well, you just assumed. let me go to a panel here. we have the on a bluetooth process to be annoying. israel from advisor to taylor. we have daniel levy. a for me, is there any piece negotiated the us be at least project? we have a manual yvonne who is the international relations director at tel aviv university . i'm gonna go to bring you in 1st since we got started early, a potential 5th column. this is exactly the problem is that he's a racist 2 thousands these racist views. that's the problem with israel, israel's, this is a side society, a country that is based on this idea of jewish supremacy and anything that they do or say goes, which means therefore that as
4:43 am
a post and in who lives in that country who is not enjoying any benefits of so called democracy, they get to a 1000 tell me how i feel. they get to make statements like we are just call them. and they actually treat palestinians as though they are assist. call him. it's very important method for people to understand that israel came to us is we didn't immigrate to israel. israel's a colonial movement, and as a colonial movement is aimed is to not only get rid of palestinians, but it's too tight to transform the entire placed race. and replace, okay, the manual, i wanna ask you if you recognize the 5th, the penny was agreeing on at the start of the segment about what's happening inside of is rarely since i allow me to respond to that, they are not to said she's not telling the truth, once she's nice thing is not true. first of all, in the jewish country, i mean there are over a 190 states in the world. most of them of nation states. it still is about
4:44 am
supremacy. it is about national south, different termination and freedom. now we didn't come to you the way this is our land. no, it's easy to do. it was at this stage was the entire family. let him finish this point in it. okay. first of all, when you say we've been there for hundreds of yours, the world, palestine, it's an invention of british colonialism at the van to the 1920. it did not exist under the ottoman empire again. so 9, when does it start the story start? it's an, it's a colonial invention. so when you said palestine and you can even pronounce it in our because there's no p and our over the, i'm going to bring you back to my question, then move on. what do you make of those alo, smoke tricks and hit ma, get been given? referring to arabs and the most deem humanizing risk? are you going to deny that as well? like every society we have or the stream is okay. it's
4:45 am
a democracy. i don't agree with them, but we have like every society we have our experience and you're in government. yes . what i didn't vote for this government. i wish they were not in the gulf. okay. daniel hasn't spoken daniel leaving. when i was in design, this youth movement, i'm president of the world unit, your students being pumped with the talking points in the propaganda points. i really think they were more sophisticated and i may be misremembering this high candle, genuinely cannot be lee. the vcs will now, constituents, and these really attempt at defending, i'm putting your best foot forward, but then i look at the reality in his role today. and of course, that's what it should look like. because what's the reality we're leaving it? and let me take 2 snapshots. first of all, it's really not that surprising that we've got to this point when you consider the impunity with which the external community and these roles allies from the west
4:46 am
and the us treat is ro, despite the lead to me, the entire spectrum of violations of international law and of human rights, and yet every time there is an excused as a b to a united nation. then there's more opposite in that respect. don't expect is raised to come up with back to talking points when they don't have to because you're willing to run couple of put them into break complete either on the phone. book 3 people in the panel, 2 of whom are pro palestinian empty zion is that's the purpose of it. yes, that is supposed to be 2 against one. we don't know that we do. what are you working on? yes, we did ask you to watch the show before they made it myself pretty? no, you're not state. oh no, the the
4:47 am
again, the come just to to know that let's go around the audience. we're going to try and see where we've got some hands up. we're going to go to the gentleman, he said ro, the jacket on the just if you could say something more familiar, the rarity perspective in terms of the threat by size from us and these moments movement, which is patience, fluid to produce it as well. that's what it says, it is, jobs, a net, or for both charts. so, if you could explain that with each of the how mazda is a small, a organization was a small army, a of terrorist. and it doesn't represent in my view and exist central threats to israel. but as part of the larger, in a muslim radical arab world, a that's part of it, including your in a, together, they do are present. an existential threats to his role is always not fighting merely the emotions fighting the whole. these is fighting militias in syria and the rock. it's fighting. this is block, orchestrated by the radians at the moment,
4:48 am
which wants to destroy as well. yes. lady here in the 3rd row on the 2nd. my question is to diana al, daniel, because i want an honest and truthful answer given the decade. sloan boutique, altitude against the palestinians by these where the government, without much regard to the international law or consequences, should we have seen the escalations destructive side coming. and what could be the global implications when states disregard international laws to justify and even normalize during the side? genom briefly, we've gotten to a point in this world where the world tells us that nothing can justify october 7th . and yet every thing that is real has done since october 7th can be justified by october 7th. that's a distorted world. and we have to understand what the, what this occupation is. matt is been violent from the, from day one. the next about was violent. and what we're seeing today is a continuation of that and for world order to be restored, we need to have
4:49 am
a system where all states are held to account, not where we get to have a country that says it's time to bomb iran because they might have a nuclear weapon, big secret, israel has a nuclear weapon to genuinely brown jacket and then the gentleman here in the blue jump. and um, i know that were on uh i would just say a rock atari station. what do we think about the site that cats uh, has fun data from us for so long plus the key to cause and palestinians. and also we haven't had one mentioned as the 120 hostages still being kept. what pressure could catch all be putting on from us to release those hostages immediately regardless of all the rest of this project? well, a katara has been supporting the from us for that for at least a decade with money propaganda, etc, etc. probably using alger 0. so in that fashion, in this should and a, i think normal state shouldn't support what the world regards or at least the western world regards a, uniformly, as
4:50 am
a terrorist organization. it's true that how much is holding still holding a $120.00? is there any hostages, women, children, a oxygen arians, a 2 year olds, and whatever that they had to 50 in the beginning, and now it's been reduced to a 120. many of them killed by how much people and many of them killed by my really advisory advisory is also, he's really is also killed. okay. some of the hostages. hopefully they will be released. ok. we'll we, we hope that will be released, and i would just say one thing. what did these really go and pop up, come us for so long and encourage katasha to send money to goes stupidly. how does the ceiling my answer? yes, i'm just wondering. i was going to, so let me ask you want to give a loans of the a. the answer is that the is really government under that. then you all behaved stupidly, and this was part of the incompetence of, of the time you all, i think was incompetence. let's go to the judgement in the blue jump. it's taking a look. and i'm, i'm modern show and i wrote a book called walters genocide, thought i was less than what i'm doing is starting any back to go. so because you
4:51 am
said it's a war, it's on those cultural down nature. not a mouse knew, not may be true, but i mean, the real point is the israel when you present it, that's if you spend the rolls of or so is that a 100 people can be killed for one minutes. and if you do, that's thousands and thousands of times with 2000 pound bombs, you know that the whole of garza is going to be a really, you know, that you're going to destroy that society. and the, the, the only way we can understand that. i know overall sense is not a series of war crimes, which is a one big crime and not a name for about just genocide. so of the i think i've already made the point from us when there's a text as well on the 7th of october. knew that this row would retaliate with bombing and knew that lots of gauze and civilians would die. they were hoping for that because that looks good on west and television images,
4:52 am
but they say the killing a lot of it goes to civilians is good because they go to having their they become markers. so this is, this is a lot of printing. can i could i did i say something wrong? no, no, i just want the wrong. i just want to, i'll follow your logic from us new. that's wonderful. your argument is come, us new. if they did this, we do a genocide, so we did it on the side. no, you miss. like say you knew that we would only chill lots of people they would do. you know, they knew this real would kill lots of a lot of the is over 2 months ago. no. yes. if they knew that going after the come us, they knew that lots of gauze and civilians would be killed. and they were happy with this a because of international pressure, which would result. okay, we're running on time on a take a gentleman in the suit. yes. penny morris. you said that the i c. c should issue in arrest for and against these already prime minister in the is right, a woman a so you'll have to land. but on the 9th of october, they impose the title siege on 2300000 civilians in gauze, depriving them of war to madison food. that is, what are accused of starvation as
4:53 am
a weapon to war, something the story. and then the russian versions were accused of to condemn the, as anybody being a died in gauze of starvation says, yes, this is, this is, this is total nonsense. hold is really, is really and you want to be done. yes, i do go. that's what i want, some of it, it is all just say things that are false. i'm going to let you say that these really government, i think the ministers debated whether to couple florida or a couple of electricity, etc, etc. and they eventually result not to do that and don't. so lots of reporters have been saying and the united nations that goes is on the verge of starvation on the verge of time and the settlement. so that has not happened any how to the how do you know that? hello and stop actually, how do you know that benny and please i don't. you don't have any reports of anyone dying all to be on a ripple. i haven't heard any. so that makes it nonsense because you haven't read any. i haven't heard of any help thing that i'm in of starvation. any of the final
4:54 am
i window is a screwed problem. there are people, food eating and assignment and northern go. i don't know what the word from and means. there is a food problem. there's a lot there's. there's now nutrition. there is this. i have heard. nobody's died. they will say to lars. i know nobody has died of starvation is on your end. as far as i know, i've read quotes, i know that you're restoring your look at the source and you find the evidence. i know, you know, i don't know if i'm in means i haven't seen anything. maybe it's a big claims. you're making some backed up with some evidence in the back it up. please tell me the report in which somebody has died, just thought cindy, cindy, cindy mccain who cindy became is the head of the world food program. she's a window here. what she's, what we don't, she said was the widow send it to john mccain. the most pro is right. you send it through my life. so i said what she said, northern goals are, and a full blown fireman, and that their children, women, and children and skeletal states. that did she say somebody died of starvation? i'm asking you sidney that anybody die of star and then yes,
4:55 am
that being documented cases read the newspapers who really think you might have definitely just quoted before. let's start. here's the assignment a moment ago. i didn't say i said, i don't know what samuel, that's a good get out one. this is the core of the discussion that let's take another question. a gentleman in the green jack has been waiting a long time. my question is to penny. i just want to know if you will, palestinian died and you were born in palestine. would you given circumstances support palestinians that i produce assistance in the phone that that, that i've done that before and i would support palestinian resistance if i was living under is really occupation. yes. which is what the palestinians off i mean we're out of time. i do very interesting question. it's very interesting on, so i do it almost like because i watched the recent discussion, you did and you were telling your opponent, you need to have empathy. you need to put yourself in other people shoes. so let's just continue on the 10th was very good question. i don't. i mean, if you're kidding, goals are right now and you still, you're humbling up by these radio falls. you still your parents incinerated in
4:56 am
front of your you'll starving. what's due, a few of these are all going to be it will probably be very negative, but it might also be negative towards the from us who generated this conflict and lead to that told me being the kid if you, when you see them, i don't think one is ready, but you might think both things you probably you probably think if you're with that probably i would describe the depth a of his parents to and is really bowman to these re lease. but i might on reflection late to think maybe the come us shouldn't have sworn. and so many israelis on the 7th of october, which led to this, i'm genuinely husky. is that your to can you point or is that as a human being? that's how you would feel as a human being. i think i would feel anger towards those with just killed my parents, but i think growing up and on reflection, i might think that the some us had led to this. i might be empathy. i was looking for, but we will. i mean, it's not feel uninstalled, so i'll take it. that's my answer. i appreciate that penny morris. thank you for
4:57 am
joining me on the show today. thank you to our audience in london's conway whole. thank you to a panel of experts who joined the discussion. that's what we have time for. thank you for watching at home. the to there's plenty of residual land, daytime heat in the southern states, the u. s. not feeds into the depths at south west, and here you get some pretty big thunder storms by day. there's also volts on the pacific coast, particularly from the northwest. we haven't quite seen record high bodies, but involved town in wyoming. for example, that has been helpful and you might expect the east coastal east coast stays all looking with no home and weather and ship. it was the heaviest rains like you to be hanging on in south carolina and also in florida. in fact,
4:58 am
if you go science from florida to cuba, hated in jamaica, this whole area could see some pretty tremendous temples in the next day or so. it was a hand to the circulation, but no more than that. it does look fairly. we'd have to say in central america, including most of the southern mexico and that went whether it's still to be had in columbia and at cordele, where pretty big dine pools are a daily event. but you see is a cutoff almost all of amazon areas by drawing there, the chalet, right of the east coast of brazil and stuff these further down towards the southeast. but the biggest storm which is fading away by the end of south today has been coming in for the pacific. so right. and so they're all the way more or less just the sounds eoc are down towards patagonia has been the thing in the, in the in range and the up to meters, snow with a phone and the, the of the 0 world tells the stories of to the thing era writers who challenge
4:59 am
conservative thinking in iraq and zip to see all the just, i mean what are these ideas about iraqi identity divided opinion especially among the political and religious beliefs. and during this, so the and they wrote newspaper columns so popular, they will read that every level of living in society, revel, writers, iraq and zip. yes. or no to 0. the
5:00 am
system even come in as an international inside corruption, excellence award, denominator hero. now the the us will send a new carrier, goes to the middle east to increase support for the defense of israel. the line for me down below this is all just there a lie from the also coming up. a lot of work about funeral prayers will be assassinated. the political lead of almost with an emotional needs from his widow. the parties of.
44 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4e01a/4e01aaeb325918af2f92edf8508171c2e3e4e043" alt=""