Skip to main content

tv   Inside Story  Al Jazeera  September 19, 2024 2:30pm-3:01pm AST

2:30 pm
the fees, well, the minister from bangladesh, with $360.00 homes in britain, jerry looked down. you spent 200000000, just a new agent. your time has vanished point. yet. the only thing you might want to say, i mean, how does your investigates the ministers, millions the mass attacked targeting has fallen members and let him know devices use for communication exploded in german, thousands and 10 and several as well as leaving israel to is the risk of the biggest conflict, this is in 5 story, the
2:31 pm
hello and welcome to the program. i'm elizabeth put on them as well. and 11 on base group has will not have been engaged in cross border conflicts and israel as well. and that's what they've gotten nearly a year ago, concerns of a lot of conflict and now growing off to a series of quota native attacks. targeted has bola members and 11 on tuesday. they came a day after this way, the prime minister benjamin netanyahu said he'd make it a goal of his want gaza to return to thousands of his ratings. displaced by the violence in northern israel, as bella has blamed as well for the page, the explosions that ended more than 2500 people. and as promising retaliation, as well as yet to comment. but it's on a, is deploying additional forces to it's moving forward, 11 on. so what will it has? all those response looked like at is there were risk of a wider conflict. we'll put that to, i guess, shortly. first, this report from the image and kimber sizes of explosions, the coast 11 on,
2:32 pm
and syria. from a cyber attack, the turned pages held by hezbollah members into weapons. but the size of injuries hundreds are in a critical state. somebody using fingers suffering serious abdominal injuries, being blind the range and i'm positive 11 on the among them. well, they report say, his injury is a slight lebanon's hospitals, opinions of loans, and the death toll is still rising. many of those here has been the fighters. who do i some carrying the pages. so the other roles within the group, like medics. and one was a young go. another. how much must the i'm on the son of has been a member of parliament, ali m o r g y s i a. this is a new is really aggression against slip and the resistance will retaliate. a suitable way at a suitable time. has been an official as opposed to the cool base,
2:33 pm
the biggest security breach the group of space in the past year conflict with israel. it's not yet clear how it was car. he died with speculation on whether explosives have been inserted into the pages before they were distributed. has been the members recently still since using pages, because it was believed they were less likely to be tracked than smartphones to. so the so has put a squarely plains, israel's been the we blame the is right, the enemy, they full responsibility for this criminal attack that also homes civilians. the treacherous and criminal enemy will get the fee of punishment for this cowardly attack. but israel has so far remain silent, right? and its powerful ally, the us did not like having any prior knowledge of tuesday's attack. alger is no us involvement in this at all. a sentiment the us has maintained since has blown on
2:34 pm
israel. again, the curse for the conflict in response to the world garza but that hasn't stopped tensions rising and the conflict expanding with both sides. hitting deeper across the israel, lebanese buddha and israel, carrying a high level assassination of a husband, a leader in bay route in july. so many i left all asking whether this strike to have hit the largest number of has been to members and to threaten that security was the one of the attack oldest out of a much bigger conflict. imaging came back out to 0. the inside story the that's bringing, i guess, and they've route, i'm on the honda executive director of the so need concert foundation which focuses on freedom of expression and media development and then the vonage region and washington dc for the us mux of a senior director at the middle east institute and an expert on the politics of
2:35 pm
lebanon, syria, and the border dynamics of the middle east region and, and lol. now and then his call and clock director of research at the c fond group. that's a global intelligence and security, consult and see a very warm welcome to each of you. we have so much to get through, but i want to start with i'm on and be rude. i'm on the people of levon on who have been through so much already. i'm probably full. they have seen it. how are they feeling today? and there is a feeling of theater. and now we're almost sure that we have not seen at all about the future. the next few days might carry developments that can go in any possible direction, including the worst ones. and this situation of fear of uncertainty of not knowing whether our kids would be able to go to school tomorrow or not is something that is pervasive. and you feel it and the way you interact with people, you repeat it. and the jokes, the dark humor that is spreading so widely online. but it's only a facade for us,
2:36 pm
a country that has been read of here. those who are opposed to hezbollah are very much afraid that the, the, the, the minutes in the group is bringing a war onto the country that nobody has asked for. and i have the same time, even supporters of football are now questioning how well protected they are, how secure they are, when it's very important people within the organization could be targeted that so directly and when something as important as the supply chain of one of the most secretive groups is, is exposed and which a lot of great points to pick up on the call. and let me bring you in on what i mom was saying about the supply chain so far. the trail of who made the pages goes cold in budapest. what's your theory of where in the supply chain? israel managed to turn these pages into weapons. yeah,
2:37 pm
well, as you mentioned, i think you know, uh. busy ours are on the budapest, at the moment. uh tie, we go, time to use company involved. i think if you think about how it meticulously planned, this operation must have been. this is something the as early as like when come months ago. and i think on the heels of the assassination of a small and the intent wrong, this is an advertisement for massage. it's a way for them to kind of refurbish their brand, which was tarnished after the attacks of october 7. it's also likely not the end of this campaign, and so i would expect to see more in the coming days and weeks and we can see a tax anywhere from 2 wrong to, to bed room or beyond. i do want to talk a little bit later when you say that this is an advertisement from all side because we have to remember that among those codes as an 8 year old girl and an 11 year old boy that cannot be good publicity for any intelligence agency,
2:38 pm
the death of innocent civilians. but i want to also talk perhaps more importantly about what this does for hezbollah as image for the us. the us government's full, a deputy national intelligence officer on the middle east. so this would easily be the biggest counter intelligence failure that hezbollah has had in decades. would you agree, elizabeth? it's hard to overstate the impact of what on hold it in favor. yesterday, i've heard it be referred to as a digital russian law. as far as his boss, communication capabilities is involved, no military organization can fine, can find it blindly. and what they've done a, presumably the most size is done, is essentially taking out a significant portion of his ball as command and control capabilities. so yes, on its own, this is a very significant blow. but when we take you also in the wider context, clearly israel has to be on more than escalate tory governments and establish that
2:39 pm
in the past 11 months to accomplish whether it is 1st targeted to the southern suburbs of failure to assassinate americans, leader, and 11 and then cubic and bullet on chief of staff and lady july be able to toward my husband was reported response to that by 3 because attacked with significant americans a few weeks ago. and now this so his bullet has been done. cool. military blow a technical blow, but more importantly perhaps, as i'm was highlighting a very significant moral, grow and low. and i think cuz the today, all the pieces of the dilemma, it's a response and response. possibly that might get israel and, and prime minister in particular, maybe not in yet with the projects he's looking for to expand this more. and should their response be limited or not existing at all that further inbox escalation. so it's a very difficult moment for us, but all right, now, and obviously everybody's, they don't see what the secretary general has and most certainly will have to say
2:40 pm
and much of weighted speech tomorrow. i'm on, i want to ask your communications expert kind sizes, a wonderful thing, but how much of the situation are we in now with these pages being weaponized, would you say is on how some national out himself, who made televised remarks earlier this year, telling hezbollah members to get rid of this smart phones, saying that they are more dangerous than is ray the spies. in hindsight, should he perhaps not have publicized those remarks? i don't know if tomorrow us has like a sign that we use as incentives. if i only knew the teenagers after the 2006 to lie or a given the consequences that we know, because this goes, i floss mention beyond just the technical capabilities. it's about identifying who the operatives are within seconds before people realize what happened. images, thousands of images, images were circulating on social media and before people were able to very simple
2:41 pm
open source intelligence to gather data, pictures of information about people. tracking system is very easy. tracking, the movement of ambulances is very open. records of hospitals contain the name, the details personal these days. are patients changing this southern li just to main thing? the secrecy of some of the people might both be boxed easy. so the number of places today on social media in the media, i'm in cost. it's a records and gloves. uh, you know, confusion records where names and details of very important people across such a secretive organizations are made public is not something easy to begin with. even if a decision to actually strike or, or retail. yeah, it is. they can, there are plenty of question marks about other moves or other gaps within the command and control structure that might be exposed as well. so this is today that
2:42 pm
kind of situation that everybody's rocketing with and wondering how what kind of response will happen in the next few days and calling before we talk more about how hezbollah might respond to such an attack. one has also said they believed that it was in response to an alleged assassination attempt on the phone. the top is where the defense official that was released that was revealed by as well on the same day . yeah, that certainly would be the motive for this, but in terms of timing, um, you know, i've heard all sorts of different policies that essentially, you know, when this operation was initially planned for those who planned it believe that as real would be active war. all that more, which has fall and this would be kind of a part of the opening stages or faces of that conflict. i've heard that, you know, there was some rumblings that has low as learning about this and is really sad to ask before the plan was, was out. and,
2:43 pm
and so i think the fact that we're here that we're discussing and that there's all sorts of hypotheses floating around, is exactly what them solved was hoping for, right? because it feeds into this kind of spike game shuttle or uh, you know, kind of overlay that many have been following and look, this is the continuation of the israel is going to more in the shadows with iran in the rounds prophecies. and as we all know, that's been ongoing far before october 7. and for the us we cannot ignore that. the attack came just alice off to is where the announced it was voided and gets aims. and because of war to include its flies against has follow along the northern border. is this attack? do you think parts of the new will go and how would war on it's moving forward to make it any easier for the 10s of thousands of his varies has been displaced from the north to the to a yeah. elizabeth to echo with calling. just said,
2:44 pm
it's very hard to decipher at this point, whether this is the opening salvo of a much broader more that's, that's the comment. certainly late breaking news to this morning. but is there a isn't pack moving tens of thousands of troops from the up to that northern border of atlanta? so there's, there is they're making all the right moves that would have his bottle. even braun, to whom, behind since by law, that israel is in fact preparing for. that's your question. um american diplomacy, american, the american administration has been very clear that israel will not be able to achieve militarily what it has been unable to achieve diplomatic rates. that will more would bring only further devastation on to northern israel, given as well as, or minimal arsenal of rockets and you a these? yes we talk much. is that so? so far about out israel has been able to successfully establish escalation dominance. how has been able to penetrate is by using its superior intelligence
2:45 pm
capabilities, but his bullet is still the most powerful, non state actor in the world. and one that's how massive capabilities to shame. so the american administration here differentiating itself from the israeli position, i was in the room last week when i'm of hochstein a president, biden's n boy on this very issue was having arguments and making the case against israel brought in this war. and i think the fact that he had to travel to israel earlier this week and that this attack literally came on the keels of him. the party of 6 volumes of a kind of daylight that we're seeing today between the american position. and he is really position i'm on it's not uncommon, is it for the israeli government to carry out considerable attacks, whether it's in gaza, whether it's 11 on elsewhere in the beach and just off the american officials leave as well after a visit, we've seen this time and time again, given everything that for the us has said about, has bowlers capability being probably the strongest non state act in the world?
2:46 pm
do you believe that israel does want more was hezbollah and how did people 11 on feet of anxious i'm, i cannot speak for what the state of the government wants, but it's very clear that the current situation, the current status go, is not sustainable for any of the actors involved in this and this conflict. so politically, the situation in the north 1st row is not sustainable, and it's not sustainable either. for the populations in south lebanon, it's an area that there's no completely destroyed tens of thousands of lebanese people are also displaced in the country, the flex, any kind of infrastructure. there are even now discussions as of today the 2026 parliamentary elections and nothing on would it be postponed because of the situation. there are also question marks and robin. i'm related to the timing of any major authority escalation when it's happened before the november 5 elections
2:47 pm
in the us to force the hand of you know, voters into us, especially in case, for example, come with a harrison's polls improve or whether they wait for up with them or, and actually contribute to potentially at the feet of come out of harris and, and have a more sympathetic administration in place. so they, people are reading the tvs when it comes to what happened, what would happen. but what we know is that this attack, sir, they're divided the nice people further, we can social fabric and 11 on the level of social media. this information that was spread, miss publicly minutes after the the, the attack. i couldn't get campaigns against the american university of b routes, medical center, which was hosting for hundreds of the people who were one that was being attacked by a social media campaign, claiming that they got rid of the page years themselves for the doctors in order to
2:48 pm
avoid such an attack as using to the fact that they knew something about that which was complete faith can use. it also was accompanied by a huge campaign to southerly remove from social media, every single kind of picture, an image that came out of the attacks yesterday, while other segments of the police population were kind of celebrating. what was, what happens to a group they believe was responsible for assessing nations and not been on attacks on the syrian people. this climate and loving on is not one but with a lower country to sustain any kind of additional crises. definitely not a large scale or yeah, it's really interesting that you're saying that this has further expos divisions will lead to divisions and the social fabric. because i was listed to liberties health minister earlier. and he was trying to say the exact opposite. he was saying how the end time health care sector, although it's private, how it responded to low cost of the thousands of injuries united. you know that it was a nice thing factor in that and not calling the again the attack itself. i'm on,
2:49 pm
i'll come back to you in just a moment, but i want to ask what your thoughts are on again the attack itself. is it a war crime given the indiscriminate nature of the attack, isabel could not have known that who exactly who would have the pages or that they would be no civilians around when they exploded. and yet they decided to carry, we think, as well as carried out the attack to yeah, so it's a legitimate question i'm, i'm not an international lawyer, so i'll leave the question of more problems to, to them. but certainly, any time, some of someone plans in attack where there's a high likelihood that civilians will be killed, that's certainly something that would qualify or be eligible for scrutiny as to whether or not that's a word from your your right to point out. the innocence were harmed including children, and that's the conversation that i'm having with a lot of folks. but i guarantee you, uh, that's not the conversation that's taking place in telling me more jerusalem,
2:50 pm
where the focus is likely on the quote and put the success of the attack. and again, is this a kind of afraid move to something broader? we'll have to wait and see and has was made it clear that it will respond. in many ways it's forced to respond right because of the operational security or the opposite of this group was compromised. so significantly, it would be an embarrassment to not respond to this would expose as well as we that the truth becomes threading, that needle aware has was response doesn't kind of further escalate and feed into the cycle that goes beyond just 10 for to an end results and something more of a brock. yes it, as i know, you know, you was saying earlier, how has vala is basically damned if it does? and then if it doesn't, it is so hard to get the exact calculation. right. and, and how it responds. but i also want to talk about as long as lack of response so,
2:51 pm
so far, at least after the assassination of hamas leader is mind and the input on, at the end of july, has that involved. and as well, would you say there's no doubt about that, elizabeth? so i mean, i think israel is sort of looking across the chessboard here in the middle east and the message that keeps coming back time. and again, escalation, escalation, uh, from israel is that both are ron and people are just not ready for an all out of war. or at the very least, i do not have a preference for ron for 1st appoint israel, a 1000 cuts at a time rather than a delivery. i'm not taught blow to it in understand that it cannot deliver on the top load. that is, your own is militarily superior. and so therefore, a uses. this is variety of a non state actors as most in groups throughout the region in lot in syria, in iraq, with these young men, to again come at israel, a 1000 tons at
2:52 pm
a time. so time and again, we see iran pulling back from the brain. it's about pulling back from the brain. and therefore we heard the supreme leader and are on only recently talk about the importance or the legitimacy, a tactical retreat. at times when you are strategic, you're brought us a key to objective is, is in danger. so why don't we call that pace for the current choices that you alluded to the down to, to do in dance? if you don't have valuable, take a different path. the us administration has put board an off craft to de escalate the situation. a diplomatic opera now has by that are on have time and again stress that they want the ceasefire in gaza 1st before the agreed to the american diplomatic initiative, it would see his beloved withdraw a certain number of kilometers off israel. the border is there, i would also vacate some of the 13 disputed lines along the border with lebanon. and so there really is a passport for diplomacy. here we don't know yet whether basically the current
2:53 pm
array of options available to chase to choose to take that off rap. i would suspect at a very minimum it will have to undertake of concepts some form of performative action, the state. okay? and again, our hope is that the positive will see will open their act. i'm on with what's it saying about a possible diplomatic, off ramp for hezbollah? is there any chance that they would do that given that they have said they will not stop their attacks because this is about as well as on gaza and bullet remains a very strong doctor when it comes to communication at some point, if they decide to agree to a certain the plastic solution, they would find a way to short go to, to present it, to their audience. they did it when there was a maritime dealer related to, you know, the off shore and oil and gas, you know, exploration initiatives in the mediterranean. it's kind of happen. the most important issues for us are how we still have any society would be able to cope
2:54 pm
with what is coming. because i, you mentioned that earlier. why, of course them ethical sector behaved so and such a noble way and professional way. the pensions wrong, extremely deep. nobody is ready. nothing is ready for a major escalation of the conflict. and that any room for the, for the magic solution must be, must be photos, perhaps the level of damage that yes. so there's a fact inflicted on his bundle, but also on, you know, our publishing run and loving on should be an incentive for a diplomatic solution. but at the same time, there are different parts of the conflict, the level of pressure that should be placed on the nino whole government in order to you know, restrain some of their most extreme ascendancy is, is essential. otherwise, not only the pay the price, the entire region would be in a much more difficult situation. very, very soon i'm calling. we've seen that the us is not willing to use the leverage it
2:55 pm
has with as well to stop the war on gaza. but a war between as well and has below would be much more destructive. do you see it using the leverage? it has to stop that conflict. i often question how much leverage the united states does have over as real. now circle the question that when they give millions of dollars in a to israel bush, maybe i'll reframe and say they're not really do you use that leverage? you're absolutely right. and there are things united states could do, but politically, especially in a, in a year of a presidential election. they're not going to do that. the other piece, this is, as you pointed out earlier, israel conducts these attacks as soon as the us diplomat leaves, as an american citizen, i find that in raging. i think it's an embarrassment that oftentimes the as rarely as act as the senior partner in the relationship danielle who's coming and giving speeches in the us congress criticizing or right to protest. so i'm often offended
2:56 pm
by the way it is realized behavior in that relationship i wish the dynamics were different. but i don't think any politician is willing to, again, 7 weeks out from an election. uh, you know, start taking those steps. unfortunately. do you think calling that as well does want will, would, has paula? i think benjamin netanyahu might want more testable. i'm not sure the idea for the as really people do or i, i am afraid we have run out of time, but i want to thank all of i guess for this fascinating discussion. that is, i'm on the honda for the us, mike sound and call and clock. and thanks you too for watching you can see the program again any time by visiting our website out a 0 dot com. i prefer the discussion to go to our facebook page. that's facebook dot com, forward slash a inside story. you can also join the conversation on x. a handle is at
2:57 pm
a inside story from me, elizabeth put on him and the whole team here. bye for now the, the 200000 south korean children had been assaulted by families worldwide since the 1915th. but in the search for their identity. many us up to have found the train of falsified talk and traffic to 11 east reveal south korea's chime adoption on know to 0. the threats from this going often heard, but rarely seen. think of each by the twins circle up of people's hips around the truck chatted with cameras they per tight. so it's a inst intelligence to display those military law. for example, one of these rhetoric forces use drones in america ways to drones, emulate
2:58 pm
a crying baby or barking dog. so you come out to see what is going on. then your front isn't kills by these drones. when super easy, 20 noise clouts phones as people wait, just cold are really doing a trucks tac toe and split among watkins that open fire. i'm clicking around 112 people. what became known as slower mess. everidge road set. click above is the threats for the lives of people here and the sounds is clear. the minds of the are being watch with no one safe processed in washington dc with a to a, making a painting for unity, for people who are struggling out as a world to meet the palestinian seeking inspiration for striking you in the heart of the american capital the beneficiary dart is a kind of conflict with his plan for universal work succeeds for getting
2:59 pm
the college of home on out his era the the . ringback the, the
3:00 pm
limits to have a dream container, stuff in your own adventure now counter and waives the i'm about to send in doha, the top stories on all the 0, but a 1000 children. a stranded at a school off to is really force is strong, the time of co box, you know, is your name in the occupied west by is really force as far as the 2 times the rifle grenades, into a surrounded house, attending families in the area to evacuate the homes, at least 3 people have been killed and several have been injured. is really media and reporting a number of people have been injured off to being targeted by to and to tighten this as an upper gallery and.

9 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on