Skip to main content

tv   Inside Story  Al Jazeera  October 7, 2024 8:30pm-9:00pm AST

8:30 pm
able to rule out a pre emptive strike on the road on the house of israel, appears to have paused without control visit, with detailed coverage, in spite of increasing threats from mainland china. taiwan is tossing its own political and economic costs from around the world, and they sold them. they terminated country to present the israel spill. in fact, they've st. theresa jews worldwide. hundreds of thousands have left since it lost its war on golf or last year with the violence and hostility only was today. how is jewish conception of israel changing this assigned this model? failing, this is inside story, the
8:31 pm
hello welcome to the show. i'm sammy's. i that it's a yes since this rel style to the mid 3 offensive on garza now it's turning its focus on lebanon prime minister. benjamin netanyahu insist hulu chief, is goals of destroying the groups that threaten the security of his riley's, but also suggests hundreds of thousands of them have chosen to leave and search for safety. somewhere else, official is right. if it gets show the trend of reverse immigration has grown on a scale law seen in decades. the government is aware of the growing crisis and has introduced incentives to attract new immigrants. but will that work? what could be the long term consequences of this exit is from israel. ok, that's why i guess in a moment. but 1st this report. busy from alexandra bios and it's described as the biggest security failure in israel's history. october the 7th. an unprecedented
8:32 pm
attack by him are members of all cosign brigades. the armed wing of the group and other palestinian resistance fighters infiltrated is really territory by air, land, and sea. 1139 is really is were killed that day. 251 people is released and for nationals were taken captive from us coined the operation a locks of floods for retaliation against is really occupation and aggression. but for israel, it was one of its darkest days. prime minister benjamin netanyahu pledged to eliminate the group because of her. so i am and i hope they me come a little bit and it's a little bit slow. the baby will come off, israel's were on god that has since been march fights, indiscriminate killings of civilians and calculated genocide. the violence has sparked this belief shock and outrage around the world. and also within israel,
8:33 pm
that's known for its highly militarized society and supposed security. many is relays, have left the country nearly half a 1000000 in the 1st 2 months of the war alone. and recent surveys found 80 percent of those living abroad do not plan to return. immigration to israel has plummeted down as much as 70 percent in the early days of the war. the jewish, the opera is reporting a growing divide between israelis living abroad and those thing back home. many of whom support the war within is real. tens of thousands of its citizens, but months protesting against prime minister benjamin netanyahu. angry over his failure to reach a deal to bring back the captives and demanding his resignation. the attentions cut to the heart of the very idea of the state of israel,
8:34 pm
founded on the promise being a safe place for the jewish people of the world. it depends on increasing its jewish demographics. the violence and in security of the last year has room that into question and as it struggles to rebuild it, citizens trust in its ability to protect them. the government is facing a potentially existential crisis. alexandra buyers, algae 0 for inside story, the spring and i guess now we have from default of fame and southern israel. i've shut them and it so he's a is riley, quantum mechanics physicist and philosopher in new york. eva, ball quote, the national spokesperson for if not now, a movement of american jews campaigning to and us support for israel is a pop type system and demanded quality justice in the thriving future for old palestinians and israelis. and in london, daniel levy,
8:35 pm
president of the us middle east projects and a formalized by the government advisor, a warm welcome tool if, if i could start with i've shut on. so we look at the author published in places like the times of israel. they refer to a 285 percent increase in the numbers, leaving israel for good off to october. the 7th and a decrease in the numbers of jewish immigrants arriving. are you seeing actual trunk and communities when you look around you? you know, i, i heard about the cases in wasted the leaves and it is the reason so concerned academics expectations high tech people. yes, it gives of waiting on the phone. so is it no reason so panic for the spouse? no, this is a temporary cries, a smooth over comment. here is how i see the problem. as we have somebody to say about 70. yes, we have a stronger than the ads wanted to be strong as we have been stronger. for the
8:36 pm
simple reason defeated, the more advanced moving more stimuli. we have been a democracy. now democracy is compromised and i would have to jump in if it gives me a good one. when you look at reports by several international human rights groups, they might take exception, including is really human rights who's the might might take exception towards like most civilized democracy. in fact, they say there is a, there is a system of a pop type. when you have, you know, the people living without the same rights that jewish citizens enjoy those that high on those that him the, to the jewish i, early on this i solely confessed that we are guilty of apartheid shame. i have the same one. as i confessed that i have for the use ready for us and for the sleeping within us, we have been a democracy, not the best democracy between democracy. this is why we have been stronger
8:37 pm
democracy. it has is now the same thing writing due to the was prime minister we ever had the sending out. that is a temporary crises. yes, i'll be leaving. i heard this. it's not to the degree that should cause us and all but the truth. we shouldn't be concerned, i believe that this has been for i democracy will be of a story. yes. right. and will become candidate come and shouldn't be calm again. a piece seeking concrete. i own a house that they believe in the states. and okay. tuesday of donations. all right, let me bring and how, how is this last year impacted the way that jews out size is ralph view. the country has been a change. eva a yes, i mean i think for a lot of americans use, watching our government,
8:38 pm
the us government use our safety and the safety of jews in israel as justification for sending billions of dollars and weapons to the netanyahu government to enact a genocidal assault on gaza. and drive the entire region toward a broader regional war. sacrificing the hostages and the process as i think for us a lot of people to say, this is not only morally inexcusable and horrifying. it's also putting jews in further danger. and so the question is, is military domination, an unconditional us weapons cannot bring safety if safety doesn't come from decades of apartheid an occupation, what's the alternative? and that's freedom. jewish impulsivity and safety are tied together and that means freedom for past means and a quality in geneva is even let me talk to you as well and present to you, but perhaps the, the opposite opinion as well, which is often put as what else can we do an attack happened,
8:39 pm
people kept his with taken and the perception amongst a least that you have for me is right, the officials is. what else can we do? this is the o'neill. this is the only course of action. how do you view that as a due living outside of israel? i think that for a lot of people, this what they're, what this thing is the collapsing of what they've been taught, which is that this is necessary to be, is really army is the most moral army in the world. and this is all necessary for security. and then you just suppose that with children in gaza carrying their siblings in brace bags, what's worth to the remains of their siblings and is really soldiers, you know, documenting on tape talk the war crime is there any can be all time and so as netanyahu continues this assault on gaza while sacrificing the hostages and dragging the entire region into war, endangering is really is i think people are saying what is the alternative. and
8:40 pm
again, the alternative has to be ending the occupation apartheid and siege that has drag house means is really into this nightmare. daniel levy is design is ideal. the idea of a state that symbolizes security. stability for jews. is that being tested? is it failing? it's hard to offer a positive answer to that question and it goes back much further. of course, there is a notion of scientists and that sounds absolutely inoffensive. there is also actually existing designs, as practiced by the state of these route for several decades. and it has reached something off of a crashing point. perhaps we could call it. what you see today is the
8:41 pm
coming to fruition of the inability to accept and acknowledge palestinian lies palestinian rights for all those decades. and today, what is written on the 10th, which is b c's, the guarantor of jewish security, the shelter of last resort. it's probably the most dangerous place in the world for jews to be today. that broad cost out on to jewish safety everywhere in the world. and it will transition into something good to positivity contributes to jewish life unless it unless it can come to terms with palestinian life, i'm pretty candle the candle. look in that region of the world on the
8:42 pm
vision of more bloodshed and more dislocation and displacement match way. if only we can get back to the lives lost since october 6, but not tobar sick is not something to strive for. we have to address what was going on previously and the business functions of that. all right, let me bring back half shut on because you might mentioned a moment ago that you feel life show on this is perhaps a temporary trend. do you see the challenges facing israel in inspiring jews within the country and worldwide as a temporary challenge? one that can be fixed or is this more of a systemic long term challenge now? or i believe it's going to be amended. i strongly agree with my to us. we have been all the pricing the tell us danielle stop to know that we've been writing the seats . the probably gonna see it's all the pricing for too long. still not a few. a lady general that as
8:43 pm
a say anything about what you're going to watch them, that's the going to have happened. what could we do? i mean i'm crying. my heart is breaking. it's a hot day to day. my heart is breaking. so every, have a senior and casualty happening. i see that your advice might pop. you still have i mean 5 minutes. so that's money. what do you think i will do? what to do to the man? well, do what do you do that then? you know, i mean, the problem is now that we are in a, well, we had remembered that this morning. we saw people cheering smoking last thing. first thing we had to do is to wipe out those some of the smaller the flat though, because we. ringback swelling, if we didn't do that, you have the ones that sony has had on the account. i'm, you know, advocating, of course, war crimes. i trust sony when he told about no arms. i mean,
8:44 pm
you only when you say what you, what could, is the that, i mean, can you know how to not engage in walk even the us president has cold, indiscriminate. it's a bit of bombings, right? i mean, it's, and you know, it's been that it's been that, that person i would like to see as of either of us maybe, you know, i'll tell you and your best man is a unique phenomenon. he sets people come was still centralized. he looks right. he's the man who called the bank that arrested from us. he's been man who preventive the killing or yes, yes. in law at least 6 times. this is what we yeah, we only did from the i don't the night that we have the enemy is bash. those a so now and, and got the best bet she i to just 1911 on in my country and my, my mother that your finance wants to destroy us. and we had that
8:45 pm
a by the government and we are doing a small city is be a meeting that's most of these in the week. i am being pretty shamed and i'm sorry for bass. the yes, i strongly believe in this one. a few. remember, you talked about be we had, he's way way is feel comfortable. you'll see lots of both to return to the way of peace, of having to stay just meetings together. one another, as you'll say, via email out phase of times. usually it's varies an hour of the phase of tide here, attorney if want to, if it's best for us, if you right is not a good place to leave for dues, other states aerospace will not be a good place to be for us. so we have to come for a solution. okay, i'm gonna bring the other guests back here and i want to give you 1st daniel opportunity since i've shuttle. i'm kind of laid down the invitation for you and,
8:46 pm
and eva and what else? the question was very briefly to address it before we move on. what else could have been done on october? the 7th? well i sure because of what we've already heard from, from i've shut on, but i had nothing yahoo not being that one wouldn't have got one's self to that predicament in the 1st place. and yeah, this is why it's so important not to deacon texture lies. it justifies nothing. it doesn't justify decades of the do not of us the rights of occupation. apologize. it doesn't just by what was done on october 7th, it doesn't just fine. what's the done ever since? but there is no scenario where people kept without their rights for decades on and anywhere in history and geography. this isn't about us raising palestinians exclusively. i love the political lab and use a close to them and something 1000 past that. which leaves us with that option that because let me address, is that what our options see?
8:47 pm
why it's option is never to commit crimes and target every one. then have your own president? no, that's it. got the president. that's all from the labor party. it just the week after october 7th. say what is the there is no distinction which civilians. there was no such thing with the innocence, even 8 in the tennis, like so, sammy, israel had an option. for instance of saying we will, we will deal with this. we will open the gates of southern this route and create a space for palestinians from garza to be for a period of time and any one who stays behind then we can see how we address these military vehicles. these route didn't do that. and what is really dropping the minnesota talked about to you. of course, you know, daniels about military. it's a response that has gone off of the sabine discoloration of on this the daniel, i'm going to find on shift the discussion back home trying was. so we don't get too
8:48 pm
far away with what you know, bringing eva back into the discussion and looking at the demographics of demographic changes which are going on. is there a reason to believe that israel is not looking so attractive to professionals any more that there is a brain drain, that is rather is losing professionals and the professional jews outside. i'm not seeing themselves in the environment that exists in these right. the state right now. yeah, i mean, i can't speak as much to the emigration of professionals, but what i will say from the perspective of jews living in the united states is that we are watching our president joe biden say over and over again. if it weren't for israel, not a jew in the world would be safe. while he is sending billions of dollars to the not in yahoo government to escalate regional war sacrifice the hostages and continued to carry out massacre after massacre in gaza and now 11 on. and i think
8:49 pm
what we're saying is everyone deserves to be safe, no matter where they live. and the current approach is just dragging everyone into further and further danger. obviously, palestinians, lebanese people, people throughout the region as well as rallies and jews throughout the world. ok, dragging people further and further into danger on that same ab shalom. are you concerned with what impact that might have on 2 sectors of is riley society, the entrepreneurs, the, the elite, the people who need a stable environment in order to, to innovate and innovation is being very important in his rails history and its economic history. right? is a concern, do you see that this might impact key sectors like the i t industry and so i can understand the impression that you are trying to make that we are losing the
8:50 pm
best people when we are losing some they may return the cautions on making i'm causing him, it has been reported all of these right now. yeah. yeah, sure. but let me tell you on august the ever since the master guy that happened happened ever since it was happened, use the phone within itself. so that we did not believe that we have the young people, the young generation folks to be sold with softball, so strong. so they're both good. so nothing. we have no need, no shapes. we have people, we have, we seen so much a no power within our step. so let me mention these might be out about us. and we love very be they to, to be extremely loyal in making the lawyer ever since the server has had. and remember that for a year and a half doing this have called him to come, you all redeem, we had the government and other governments with 2 young prime ministers. and you
8:51 pm
know, it was another paradigm, but it was the beginning of the whole. and it still the best to do, you know, she is deal of the just it is the dia, a they cut all the time the out which is still strangling us, but need to not stay for an on demand if pricing and charges the man is going to jail for many years for heights raises the many sick. he's wife of psychotic. he's son. i don't know why he's all mean it does hate him. so please understand that the time you all redeem his temper. i yes. ready to be fine. nathaniel is not he is about and that he is. well, that's danielle, know the years later which looks to be which the database is now waiting. i can't promise you that it will not be crossed by the beginning of the by the attendance saves products page. you'll see also and those higher. busy as in, as the extreme right. we have a solid since between us,
8:52 pm
but the whole thing is build their socio question. yes i, i am concerned i'm concerned to see the patient's moving of academics moving uh, i don't think that there are a, this is a such a why some phenomenon. and this is a temporary crisis. we have endorsed by just like that. i believe that we can enjoy this one. okay, thank you. i've show, i'm, let me take that. i've kind of made an interesting observation that daniel, about basically the cloud will, will lift. do you agree with that? do you see that if there is a change of government, if the current prime minister is replaced, will that deal with the, the sort of long term challenges which have posed a challenge to? is riley's feeling secure? will it give them the stability? will it tackle issues like the occupation, we've had a ruling from the well,
8:53 pm
a finding i should say, by the international court of justice on july, the 19th saying that all the patient is illegal, it's going on for fault too long. it's part of what's causing this, the cycle of instability that, that everybody is, is failing with a change in government and you probably minutes to deal with that and the occupation and the, what the international in is, right? a human rights groups. cool. a pol type and this concept of a state that has to be based on the majority one particular religion or ethnicity is all of that going to change or is that wishful thinking? look, i think i've shown say some things that were very important for me as well. nothing yahoo and this, this tilt towards this messy attic regime. this is a danger and the rest of the world is treating this is normal now. so 1st, let's just establish that. secondly, i think it's important to acknowledge that we will be difficulties in this route
8:54 pm
with this out migration with the brain dry with the can only difficulty. this is not about to collapse human ugly. and i think that correct too, is an important corrective and any such collapse, he's not going to go smoothly. so we do have to be very cold because that's what, that's a future for his re choose his own offer, as well as a permanent fixture of this region. however, what i'm not seeing is the political alternative. that was a vote to me is randy paul, i'm it just a few weeks ago. but one's on its members to mess it. opposed to resolution say no to it was the getting state. what not peter bennett, too were referred to offer when they were in government, was the criminalizing of binding of palestinian, and joe's was higher restrictions on the pallets the engine international is going into the west side was the restarting of extrajudicial kings. in the west bank was
8:55 pm
calling every thing to criticize, including that report from human rights switched on to skip special dismissing it all this all type reports as anti semitism. nothing really. other than increasing security cooperation with the co op the policy and you know, already nothing to do to build the spaces of equality on. and that's where these re opposition have the inability to have an alternate to narrative and actually existing design as it is. so stop for that doesn't mean that we shouldn't look for a policy, but we will come together. it's up to me, it's all likely now to be premised on politicians. it absolutely has to be premised on these really choose. i'm palestinians having their ecology. they can go to what happens in the not making good on what has happened in the last year. in these last decades, we need from from red to see action. but the tall be practiced on a jewish as no national state that does not offer equality to its palestinian arab
8:56 pm
citizens who will be and not being treated as people are in the west bank and gaza . right. but they do not have the quality the that's, that's not giving us a weight for the need that what we're gonna, i think we've got about a minute and a half less. and i want to give eva or a chance to come in listening to, you know what we're discussing here and what was saying and bring it back full circle to what we want to focus on in this show. how does that impacts the way that jews see the future and that connection with the state of israel? and does that perception? is it tied only to the sort of events that go on in the occupied palestinian territories and israel or is it also tied to some of the demographic changes going on in the us way, way you are. and the rising and the changing perceptions of things like the civil rights of african americans and, and the racism and the struggle they face and how that is shaping how to use face
8:57 pm
the o. c. the palestinians. yes, i think i for me, and i think for a lot of others in my generation, i was born after the oslo accords. i've never known a real horizon for a 2 state solution. and what i have known is deepening occupation and apartheid netanyahu has been prime minister for the majority of my, of my life. but as daniel said, we also witnessed hertzog um say that there are no instance in gaza. echo this rhetoric of, you know, schumann, animal. busy is and things that the, that and yahoo and you'll have kalonde and those in charge of the current assault on gaza. we're saying that the humanized palestinians, and i think that for american jews who have cost and in peers and college or, you know, meet palestinians as their colleagues, their friends,
8:58 pm
their co workers. i think if you'll extremely clear that there has to be a different answer then unless military domination massacre and das, an occupation apartheid. and that's why we're advocating for equality and justice in order to have a thriving teacher for every single person who lives between the river and the see . all right, i've 5 run out of time. so going to have to time call guests very much for the contributions. i've shut them in for a fame in new york and daniel in london. and thank you too for watching. you can see the show again, any time by visiting our website. i'll just say we're a don't com for further discussion head over to on facebook page. that's facebook dot com forward slash, hey, j inside story can also join the conversation on x l handle. there's that a inside story from me, sam is a that and the whole team here. so now let's go by the
8:59 pm
and they tell us that he's waiting for says do not differentiate between palestinians and the occupied west bank ad international activist majesty rooms weights and areas on the floor was of dollars is hospitalized on me or on no sides . 500000 is released rally for deal to bring back the remaining is really captive the ones as continues and many tell us that the stream from the cells where it goes up prisoners were held to tungsten. every single person, these exhausted seats alone past the limits of their endurance. since its inception, in 1961, the quaint fund has been supporting people's livelihoods, and over 100 countries, by funding projects in an array of sectors ranging from
9:00 pm
infrastructure to health and education. these initiatives ultimately help to eradicate poverty and promote sustainable development the hello i'm elizabeth put on them and this is algebra live from don't ha, with special coverage of the one year anniversary of the october 7th attacks the .

9 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on