tv Inside Story Al Jazeera October 30, 2024 8:30am-9:01am AST
8:30 am
america is a region of wonder, i'm joy, tragedy and yes of violet. but it doesn't matter where you are. you have to be able to relate to the human condition. the. no, it's a lie and it's my job to shed light on how and why the cause of the nation was why the is why bands the united nations agency formality refugees, a deep catastrophe lose for millions of the for many of them old by the on days variety of to what will be the legal, diplomatic, and humanitarian consequences of the band. this is inside story, the
8:31 am
hello and you are very welcome to the program. am hush them about why is why i am fighting was several phones has lost and you attack on millions of policies dining the united nations relief and welts agency or under war from operating in his body control territory. setup to help by the city is forced from the host by the violence of death to land. as is why it was founded. generations of policy is habit, entirely depended on on or to survive receiving health care education as well as by to 8 or was been attacked frequently by is with, with agency stuff and buildings with daily targeted in the general side the world gaza. but even staunch allies of his while a warning that binding under what was spelled catastrophe for millions of protest citizens, it defies you and resolution as and these that for in breach of international. so why is this happening now and kind of be stopped? what will the international community i'm the united nations do with speak to august shortly about the best this report from omega, so sorry,
8:32 am
in the shallow tunnels the day on monday as well as palm and past 2 new laws, effectively binding the un agency for palestinians from operating in the country and areas under its control is rarely politicians claim to 75. usually united nations relief in books agency for palestine. refugees, or one drug has been taken over by him us. the allegations have been totally rejected by the us. i'm come despite and rubbing back. i'm funded by menu, less than governments, including allies, the official owner, as an organization that a terrorist organization has completely taken over. what we've seen in gaza is how come as taking over united nation facility to actually commit to your activities the law is expected to have a disastrous impact on, on for institutions in occupied east jerusalem,
8:33 am
which has been unexpected. it flew cripple the agencies activities in casa, and the 5 west bank with supports more than 2 and a half 1000000 people because is world controls or humanitarian aid entering the region. the us and several of as well as other western allies, have condemned to move. israel must abide by itself, publications, uninsured, unreal, can continue to provide essential services to those suffering and garza, on the west bank. the world was set up in 1949 to support those will forcibly expel from palestine and the state of his route. it was created in 1948. since then, the agency has provided education helped get an aide, becoming a lifeline for nearly 6000000 palestinian refugees in casa, the occupied westbank, lebanon, jordan, and sylvia. the agency says,
8:34 am
as well as actions that in the palestinian people as a whole, besides the services, but the provide school li, your health services protection underwriter, represents the repository, the collective memory as palestinian refugee status is. well, it has had a long, tense relationship with the agency since october last year. it's attacked on the schools, hospitals, and 8 centers, killing thousands of palestinians. and more than 200 stops members in january as well claim that some of them dress tall, participated in the october 7th attack in southern is well, you know this the one for non people for possible involvement. but as well has provided little evidence to beckett's claims, independent investigations concluded that the rest of had a more developed approach to neutrality. then all the similar you,
8:35 am
n o n g o entities as well faces charges of genocide at the international court of justice. in the past year, its forces us getting more than 43000 palestinians, the majority women and children. it's blocked, humanitarian aid, leading to starvation and the rapid spread of diseases in casa. and it's also expanded this for to neighboring countries in the region define international. now the move to band audra, also against international, is just the latest blow in these roads. reelect, comfortable against palestinians. i'm a close, i'm shooting entre 0 inside story. the, the, we're going to take a look of the political, legal and human impacts of his wild decision with today's gas in london, dining and love a is a president of the us middle east projects and
8:36 am
a full may is right, government advisor and also great, but his time is the director of development and humanitarian corporation that norwegian people's aid, who has worked in government formerly west at on or why, and and other people just dental money in a low professor a little after the pool jungle was university. i'm an expert in international criminal justice and human rights. hello everyone. done the when. when you band an organization that was the only hope for millions of palestinians. those are what is possessed and this based on their own homes is this way just tony, the top, the owner was for a shop sort of a long history for the policy and people. well, anyone who looks at this and says, well, i guess this is just the now the security measure, it must be part of what is rarely doing dawes, you know, the to waiting these more and then we move on. unfortunately, that would be gross negligence in terms of paying attention to what is going on,
8:37 am
just the intensity of what is happening in the last year. ease of a whole different order of magnitude. but the attempts to renew over from the equation, the attempt to discredit the united nations is all very long but been changed when it comes to res. route recalls what is being done in garza a little side what's being, being done in the west. fine canal square is parcels a town paid to remove palestinians, the sounds a serious and it is serious from the landscape. the reason the palestinian population needs the number is still refugees is the the original cost which caused the original displacement has not been addressed. and there's no intentional use really side to address it. so the collective punishment, the strong patient, the destruction of just about every seat is not happenstance. the attempt to move
8:38 am
in private security firms, which these ready cabinet. we have critical reports being discussed. the general's plan, a lot of this is the overall one with the decision to prevent both the most capable of providing substance, new palestinians that also provide education, health care shelter. now in the last year of removing that body from the landscape . because the goal here is nothing short, it's all and it's the grid openly by many members of this really got, but i need to reality of actually existing designs. and it's nothing short of changing the entire expense. the one a witched zionism as practiced by the state of his role as exclusive ego. many at the expense of the existence of the palestinian people. that's what this movie is about. let's not pretend it's anything different going. how do we get to this point with his rent, emboldened by the fact that no one cash but the international in actually is not
8:39 am
going to change anything on the ground as well. it's could look like it because there seems to be no limits to look at the around is able to do without any brother really trying to stop them. and most of the see now with the looking up on that it's no less than catastrophic in, in god though, i mean under is the main humanitarian provider in gaza. and as we heard there also a major provider of the social services of, of the education of health and not just in gaza, but of course in the west bank in other countries in the region. and i think one thing that we also need to understand is stopped by blocking under, we're not just looking under in gaza at the is also key in coordinating and supporting the response of other actors such as other un agencies
8:40 am
. but also i in jose uh has more than 30000 people in gaza. they have an infrastructure, they have the districts and they have the knowledge to coordinate such a huge to monitor and response. and there is no way that we can meaningfully replace them, tristan, a. how do you see the legal justification as though it presented by these rather government to impose the bad but it's also one of many things for having to me today. i've seen that to this each on the legislation side of things i don't know full on the international. not. no, it's all it is. it does not have a decent discretion to bond in agency over the united nations. this is happening called plus the international. but before looking at the guy, the t y, the legality of these legislation, please let me put these. so this is showing these legislation to the why the context and one of the context, the so the system of the cut docs by the us,
8:41 am
by these today to solve it, these pretty nice nations. these context includes our talks against the ones that be genet on a case. and you want to see the peacekeeping of me showing the light but not included these blocks on over to so the owner of clemency seen god's asleep and the killing, the most one to stop the bus on that level to see emergency in the gods us the ecos included the complete to be 0 god, the babies way to solve a piece of the binding of the season's over the international cost of justice. so what do we have to think about for so water forming the nation, a loop, us bank, steve, we might be context all on the docks against the do not get the nations by your speed, which is police indeed said by moving the national legal entity over to move to got the system that was created, the doctor, the end of the 2nd world war to prevent the commission on the overdose of 12 feet. is that what the experience you're doing? the 2nd world war? he liked all these context. so with the same article talks against the when i think
8:42 am
1st of all that they should be some legal consequences. what 1st of all, the international community should the united mostly combat and most i talks to be like nations. but at the same time, the united nation, the general assembly, show the, make it to be a range of session and discuss the possibility one seat is the phone with the general assembly. this is a decision that has it pressing down to in the history and the president against the saucy con, tied to a g, which was easy to buy some of the assembly in the, in the seventy's that. okay, danielle, when is why it was established. that was the night before the policy is so a nation came into being and the population was dispossessed. and ever since the hope of the palestinians was that one day, like against the backdrop of and dissolution, the issue of the ref is use has to be to attack of the decision to bend on the why
8:43 am
should it be seen as an attempt by the is why it is to pay the ground for a new political reality once the war is over in gaza? why the issue of prophecies is going to be also shelved as well. the war seal coating itself is paul and a big part of creating that you reality. right? ease the, the hold up in many ways, all of that flavor of the rights of palestinian refugees. those brakes are not going to be dictated by this illegal action on the part of these. right. and is role tried in the negotiations to say we just deal with the $67.00 occupation in the negotiations i took on and you could never reference what happened before that this has to be an end of the claims in order to definitively denied the rights of the palestinian refugees, i'm what professor murray and then lo just said there was so important because this
8:44 am
isn't just about one of the accusations against ross furious. the you instead of a report it reported in april, checked by the full french foreign minister going on. she came out with the there's no verification which is a much bigger type, only very institution, which is ready to be that vote for politician in 1947 was of course the us before the colonized section of view and a very few been the states. but his role has undertaken a berlin, this campaign that is going to a much higher key against the un, because it's the shots of the un, which is real, violates it's the term based on utilization, of course, of racial discrimination. all these conventions which he's will violate, so you'll see the secretary general of the un being cold and on to see might being pass on a known cross. you seen the former is ready to have boss of the to you and say that you in the building should be removed from the face of the standing on the podium at the u. n. and she's reading the shots of all the un. this is not normal behavior
8:45 am
and it should not be treated as such as well as known. and this is why if you go to the website of any of the major is, well pro won't be moved a a back. the atl which seems to be about anti semitism is really mostly spends his time depending as well. questions united regional. you go to any of those websites and you'll see page off the page devoted to discredit team of you. and because that is where the student series is. welcome to hell, the council. that is where you had a phone. well, the general assembly resolution just a few weeks ago, 12626 code define the decision of the international court of justice. that these rules, entire occupation is legal. reparations for refugees must be waived. so this is a much broader attempt to have the mining to natural law and to act as a ro got up. and in this respect, it's not just the damage will that damages mess it to palestinians that's being caused. it is the damage to any ability to have
8:46 am
a rules based system of international grid. someone is involved in humanitarian aid. i worked in gaza, formerly worked on the owner. what is owner? what can it be replaced? no, it cannot be replaced. i mean, of course it has a very particular mandate and, and so you can't replace it with any other organization. i mean, when y'all was mandated to provide a solution for palestinian refugees on to a solution or some place. and you would have to worry now that it's also a part of israel's intent to basically undermine a solution in palestine by the address of course only uh as a as um you an orientation can you can't replace their mandates and you cannot replace them on the ground either because of the position they have not just in
8:47 am
goals of it in the entire region. and we have to be extremely careful. i mean, it comes at the worst possible time. i mean the situation in gaza is this is a monetary, this hoster and we, we have the largest steam things like this and people cannot escape. 90 percent of the population has had to leave their homes and not just once but the time after time of the time. and then in the middle of this, you blog and rob the main you monitor and provider, and you also block all other agencies in their ability to deliver at the scale that we need and also so you have to kind of ask what this is or i want, i mean, what does there can, how are they gonna deal with the requirements from the ice the day that or to israel to take every measure within its power to prevent a or to ensure that the delivery of life saving
8:48 am
a in gaza. so what is their problem? how is this going to happen now? to, to so is that it shows this decision can be overturned and how the way it's live. it's a highly doubtful that the, this, the shauna will be your tongue to buy these. why on the on saw it is because as we have said before, this is passed over and why the and why the blonde box, the s d c. so little for like i was saying that before i'm doing donation, i know the international community showed voting plays a couple of pressure along these very no, sorry, these 2 and 2 we do assign to measure was just to make it clear when they say that these legislation, these are no longer in the nation or no, i look for the saw. so wanted to do this, what it was showing up with the general assembly 3 o 2. would you create the, the stop to shoot these the, you imagine c by also 5 to the method to nation cha, setting but people, a lot of people, one, know, 5. but once you clear this stop,
8:49 am
you should have to do you not get the nation's organizations enjoy privileges in the me only these on the international law and this is this, each on this is josh to install could call us we did the charge that we decided and we did the boat and read it to you over the place he's let so. so just to remind anyone that the recent police wireless also put in place a seizure or the or un uh, owned about pregnancy, sit in the, in the, in the east to get with them. but at the same time, a disability make sure should be uh, delete the, the window and the because in saw so completely these, oh god. so the most of the santa positions are binding the national cost of justice and the maximum would you be should have bought you was met the initial time of filing in particular to the decision. clearly stop machine, the risk of a general siding. the got to sleep, i'm on the police on a man, she was in both the by the magic, the nation, the judges by the international cost of justice. there is one very specific saying
8:50 am
that he's right. and the legal obligation pointing. sure. the basic needs and you want the season, i think the gods us the, the all new organization a board to ensure the such you money, thought m a c stands is based. it gives us about the people that we see. bush on the social going thing. the gods us to the but he's the is the, or the has the best of also be be, be in the st. the before the into the timing of the, of the bad. is it politically motivated in the very narrow is sense hashem, it's the return of these ready polyps after 3 months break. and so this is very much aligned with wherever is really domestic politics is that you did not have a single sign. this member of these re connected vote against this legislation. so all of the day to connect separate times this year and the 5 divisions back. but
8:51 am
noted baptist basic approach sadly to the destruction and the future plans regarding the palestinians ball. even the 1st day back of the parliament, the government kind of course controlled the legislative time table and this was moved forward by coalition policies. so one is not in your doing a yes, there was a january origin provisional measures. the progressive mariano to just refer to one of the 6 was the provision of humanitarian assistance. there was also a letter issued by the us administration just on october, 13th, just 2 weeks. the form which explicitly refers to run as one of the things the us he's going to look at. what does these type this tells you, the prime minister? nothing y'all, when he's done, he's looking up the way the international community has responded for morgan is due to d as a growing body of the international warnings that
8:52 am
bc's a prospective genocide, the war crimes of being committed. and they have seen that despite everything they have done, despite these words, we've heard them again. since this decision we did use, well we can then this is very gray americans. and despite all of the western pals have aligned themselves with what is what is done. i provided to others, and so the question today, and of course the us is actually just around the corner. the question today is a lease might be in his ready pocket and okay, i don't move out to the 90 days before implementation is around trades the salt, but that will be yet another display of weakness 5 international communities. the question is, what is the practical option for be starting to be what we just see a well just calling to make sure what was yeah back to the cold, really the lowest ball of what could be done. well, we see ties to kinetic trade homes, supplies,
8:53 am
weapons transfers will both finally be brought to the table. the action that was referred to earlier in 1974, when south africa no no longer take it c u n because of the crime, it was committee. will we see any of these really change? i feel the also that is going to be negative. i'm what you will see over these days is also this narrative in the west. the media will trucks out is ray, the spokespeople, defenders of this move will explain why some they won't have that feet held to the fire. they don't. apps correspondence is read was probated to that. you haven't even dealt with the re, i mean in the mood and all those 75 of being killed. but the western media will continue to have that people based on these ladies. i'm not usually local journalist, not telling the story as it happens. and there will be this willful ignorance on this link, christy. the response that we have seen so far, not from the mentally,
8:54 am
has to change great any organization other sites, a step in the future will have the same legacy on history and expertise. the overall has what does not relieve the almost 6000000 people refugees in gaza? westbank is doris. i am jewelled 11 and syria is the very difficult situation because under a has a specific expertise. i mean, they have been working with the palestine refugees for many, many years. they know their specific needs, and they are like in general organization that's been able to adjust to developments on the ground. so for anybody to come in and take on this task, it will be basically impossible. and what it will do is it will also on the mind, the ability to actually find a solution. impala fine, because on ramos monday, didn't to assist the refugees until the solution was in place. trusted. what, what,
8:55 am
what, what does it mean for the south african team, which is now moving forward with the ice? is you saying that there is a clear intent on these violates to the pitch away the genocide that he's right is guilty of the genocide in goes. i could this bad provide them with the man to him to for us ahead for the new ruling as well. uh, 1st of all, uh, i mean, i think that nobody has seen the evidence but like devices on the topic on delegation team. but instead of the general side do on that, this is the most book you might be done during the nation. i lowercase all the all the genocide and these the show on by the slide it was already strobe unavailable. i think we'd love the foster navy dance to the commission of glossy, but the genocide being the guys in the gods, us 3 for so because the one over the general signed the ok. so these costs those thing, these cases before the international cost of just these,
8:56 am
these are being bulky, show on salt conditions, over live and you know, the to be slow, you know, the whole the box to protect the, the group, in this case, the product to go based upon a scene of people in the god's us 3, the so the falsity both tasks the most to me to not be pointing because of sleep where there is no safe place to distraction over the highest candice easton and the diet. the task was when we did the talk, so in this case you don't let just let the boxes all boxed over those measures. so booting blazing both by easily, it may conditions of life in the gods as to be possible to pursue it blind. nobody can you glancing as we have clearly seeing in these pasta days or so, but equal the boss of the gods us 3. but the, but equally, would also have the positive battery dens. what is generally the most difficult that it might have to move on the international know when we talk about the general side being faxed will be stored in the corner in positive. all is the end of the
8:57 am
way. i'm sure that this whole topic of the team has included the strong gabby doesn't seem to be 0 god and even needs bus few days. these are they need to have some thinking about thinking, oh, some a man, but some of the government has been providing cost dividends. one of the boat of the over the guns us the today really clearly in bold for asked me glancing you know, got to sleep under construction on the legal sacramento. seem to sleep as one done . you that have less than a minute. could this on their mind, the chances for any of these 5 because one of the key components of any agreement is allowing more 8 into gaza with the band, but it just undermine the chances of a do as well. is there any prospect for a deal then? yes, the opposite to your question would be in the affirmative. the given the no deals on the horizon because that is not the intention to prime minister, not to yahoo. we were told this thing was the obstacle deal. there is no c bar amongst the living and the prospect for date of not going off, which can tell you something about the honesty with which the international
8:58 am
american media has been speaking to this issue. but no, there is no prospect because israel sees no cost for avoiding a ceasefire and the cost to continuing with the criminal. it's going to be quite a few changes might be a that we are in the same rush. so we're running out of time and no facility would have to leave with that, but i really appreciate you inside daniel that they agree about is that does anybody know? thank you. thank you very much indeed and thank you to for watching. you can see the program again, any time by visiting our website. i just see the dot com for further discussion. go to our facebook page, that's facebook dot com, forward slash a j insights slide, or you can also join the conversation on x. i would have that is i j inside folder for me. how show, how about and the entire team here in doha bye for now the to interrogate the
8:59 am
9:00 am
more than a 100 palestinians are killed in an strikes a northern gauze as well as the genocide continued the doing. this is not, is there a life? and also coming up a rescue operation is underway in sit on the, in southern lebanon, off to on his radio strike, kills 7 people. i'm doing fine. and since the diamond forces hundreds of thousands from their homes and just the last week, plus i'm rob rentals in the tube is.
1 View
Uploaded by TV Archive on