Skip to main content

tv   Inside Story  Al Jazeera  December 4, 2024 11:30pm-12:01am AST

11:30 pm
the the . ringback the, the political showdown in south korea president use appeal is under pressure to resign off to his failed attempt to impose marshall opposition. m. p. 's of served a notice to impeach him. i will look, come see whether this test of its democracy. this is inside still the
11:31 pm
hello and welcome to the drug that monday of bako during the past 4 decades. south korea has come far from use of dictatorships to become a fiving mountain democracy. that reputation faces serious press on tuesday night when present use of jo, shop the nation, and much of the world by declaring martial law. he was forced to withdraw his decree hours later, after it was overwhelming, the rejected by members of parliament present you now faces an impeachment motion, and is under pressure to step down both from his own policy and trade unions. what prompted the south could be a leader to take this step that's being cold. i'm the constitutional and an active rebellion of how it will be asian economic powerhouse deal with this extraordinary challenge to it's democracy will deal with all of these questions in a bit. but 1st the support by mohammed how g. 3 the country and the group of the political crisis cells 3 is decades old. democracy put to the tech of resident use
11:32 pm
took your place to the country on the muscle. on tuesday nights, the 1st time one has been imposed in more than 45 years. he accused the main opposition party of sympathizing with north korea. i'm taking part in what he described as i'm to states activities. but the president was forced to reverse this decision only. i was laid off the politicians defied soldiers and forced the way into parliament to vote against the me. okay, we can have j. u after the national assemblies demand to leave marshall marshall, a troops have been withdrawn. i will accept the national assemblies demand and lift marshal through a cabinet meeting. the decision caused both anxiety and confusion among the south korea. and how do you know who i thought this was a joke? then it turned out to be true that you had declared marshall. i got so worried. in the morning, south korea's largest labor union called a general strike, calling you and stuck your offer
11:33 pm
a terrier. i'm demanding to step down the window to speak on behalf of all the farm is young. so gill's regime is even more dangerous than climate change. we cannot turn a blind eye to present in you any longer off the plunging his country into tom. we'll use the future as now hanging in the balance. he won the presidency of 2022 by the closest margin in south korea's democratic history. despite his background as a public prosecutor, he wanted to correct down on corruption. he has suffered very low approval ratings following a series of scandals and with his wife accused of corruption. in january, he scrapped the bill that would afford it has to be investigated of accusations of manipulating stocks in july. she was questioned officer, accepting a deal hand to back as a gift in violation of south korea's and corruption laws. and in october media linked the phone call of the founder of opposing agency to boast of his influence
11:34 pm
over the president's choice of candidates in by elections held in 2022 year. and as also struggled to push his attendance through an opposition controlled parliament. noon is that a tough presidency at present you is that a difficult presidency in so far as the opposition party controls has the majority in the legislature and they have been fighting himself to to now the manual position parts. he says it will now push for you to be impeached and will fall trees and charges against them that would further jeopardize the president school. ready, questionable future habit, haji elders, era for inside story? the okay, let's bring in a guess in washington dc, natalia slab. today is the assistant editor at the career program of the steps. incentive think tank, insult b. j. kid was a professor of international studies at cook university and a former south korean diplomat. and also in dc. does see dr. harvey's
11:35 pm
a photo of korean studies of the economy, the endowment for international peace, hello to all 3 of you. if i will welcome to inside story b. j. i'm going to put a question to you. the perhaps any one mind and career really knows the, the arms of 2 of the by the, to the it is the president himself. what do you think president you was thinking when he declared marshall without even the backing of his own political party? the question still remains as a biggest puzzle in the minds of koreans quote, ordinary credit citizens as well as the analysts. so we do not have a clear answer to that. there are different kind of speculations, but we do not have a clear picture on them. what i can say is, you know, judging from what we're hearing in his announcement of the marshal law, she was talking about all of this political, a pass that was continuously being waged by the opposition party that controls the legislature and national assembly on all fronts, continuously is showing impeachment of the prosecutors as well as judges that are
11:36 pm
trying the legend crimes of the opposition leader and also uh, you know, impeaching some of the important members of the higher the top level leaders of the governments as well as rejecting most of his policy major policy initiatives that he suggested to be, you know, putting into law and then killing most of the major items in the budget for next year. so he was going over all this list of the political attacks being waged by the opposition leader. so that's one factor for sure. and in addition, as you would puerto mentioned, the, the test on the 1st lady herself about the allegations about the start menu, menu collation, accepting of the luxury back on and other kinds over the contacts with the pulling the spin doctors that must have a play. the role in terms of, on the,
11:37 pm
on the side of his personal, you know, the emotional right of it as well. so there were a list of things that might have caused a here's what we now think it's is miscalculation where we do not actually see clear title and the game, the image of his in the game or a clear scenario that he was trying to accomplish. so we're not sure what we talked about it was, it was over by, in the comes the most of the and games. this is the conversation, the continues but duffy, let us talk about some of the specific wording of this declaration of martial. because president, you said that he was, quote, rooting out empty state force is guilty of plotting sedition, seemingly bump him off of north korea. who was he trying to convince him to see it? was there any audience in career that was willing to listen to a message like that to me? yeah, i think it's a really huddling message given it does seem a bit out of step with what the contemporary political culture looks like in south
11:38 pm
korea. the language that we view is the anti north korea or anti state forces to create inside state forces that he's talking about. really harks back to an earlier day. and the 20th century, when korea was under martial law during the military dictatorship, in the 1960 seventy's and an 80. this one of the language was really what was used by the military dictators, 1st pop funky and then tend to want to justify their take control of society and implement some very heavy surveillance across the country. but this is really out of step with in 2024 where the country has really looked beyond the pundents a lot and it's daily political life. it's really a much more global cold country. and so using this language, really, as the target audience is probably a very small segment of the right or older koreans, but that would, this would resonate with the large what we're hearing from south korea right now, is this, this feels like cover for what was really
11:39 pm
a political action as so language from a, a pasta year old, most to natalia says that darcy, can you give us a sense though, of the latent tensions that exist between the ruling policy um, the opposition at the moment, natalia? yeah. so we've seen us to moultrie is few years in office from in sun y'all. now he's been accused and associated with multiple different reports of nepotism, bribery, corruption, and abuse of power overall. so as b j said earlier in the opposition party is really finding him kind of tooth and nail at every turn. and the legislative election back in april kind of solidified his status as a lane dock. when the opposition party won. and an overwhelming majority kind of hampering moving forward with any of his domestic or foreign policy agendas where he was coming closer to china and trying to really solidify korea status as
11:40 pm
a geo political player, especially and try lateral relations with the u. s. and japan. and to turn it to you b, j again, because you, you mentioned some of the postal issues that may have cost a shadow. well, may have influence this decision to introduce marshal know let me refer to some of them. i mean, as wise as we heard in the earlier reports, a, the 1st lady came to and he was an essential the scandal over to a lot of apparently, of expensive humbugs here, allegedly plagiarized ph. d thesis as well. somebody say that some of the tabloids have even nickname to can key on hey, risk to these postal problems really pay a role in doing something such so dramatic as modeling the um, forces of the country feature as well as a person as a natural person present and you might have failed the other way because it was a very personal attack on his only family member. they don't have children. so it's
11:41 pm
just his wife and himself and his wife has been along side with him throughout his career. and what did they got married at the later age, but since their marriage has been cut and you know, together with him very tightly and on his way to the presidency, she was his most trusted advisor, if you will. so the, all these political attacks against her, whether they are true or not, must have been played a big role in chose, of impacting him in terms of causing anger and personal ingredients against this, you know, opposition, there was raising these issues and then i think that's kind of understandable in the way dusting. you've used a lot i think the unit is feeling a lot of pressure as was mentioned in the piece of top there was the recent stalemate, deadlock over the, the budget issue happening in national assembly. i think you took that really,
11:42 pm
really. ready i was really frustrated by that this year we've seen medical for our best buy doctors over his decision to res. uh, enter the entry for, for doctors there's a really severe health care shortage. certainly things like housing, labor. these are things that have been really stressful issues for both the country and him. i'm certainly as a speech i just mentioned, think your, your only direct family member is. it is a pretty uh personal attack. so i think that this is just a mount mounting pressure against the president and it, he reacted in a way that just feels out of touch with what were the tools at his disposal as president of this robust democracy. and the way he is actually just sort of a chain of repercussions since then, the tiny, because several cabinet members, including the defense minister of all for their resignations. i stress of the time
11:43 pm
of recording the president, though it doesn't appear to be going anywhere. the teller, do you think this political bloodletting has diffused any tension to tool around the president's future? unfortunately, i don't think it has. i think the cream public has made it clear how they feel about this move by imposing martial law. because as he said at the top, for these reasons for going forward with a are kind of exaggerated north korea already has a national security law in place that benz pro north korean activities, which is already pretty controversial. some of the specific articles have gone back to the national assembly for review, for on fairly targeting civil society organizations. especially those that focus on the north korean human rights fear and being used as a tool even to intimidate people and prevent them from speaking more candidly or criticizing this inter korean policy on north korea. so while we've had mass resignations, i'm not sure that it will assuage the public at all beach. what if you can help us
11:44 pm
understand who takes over if the president is asked to do indeed resigns before that as well. we have this case before 6 years ago with prison fucking it was impeached at that time. the prime minister mister home took over as the acting president, and he presided over the government for the next 5, a months time until present. when jane was elected as the new president, so did that the pathway is quite clear. we have a clear, a precedent. right. and what is um, also clear, is that whatever the president intended to darcy appears to catastrophically catastrophically backfired. i mean why he attempted to demonize the political left is actually united, some members of his own conservative party of the people power policy with about 190 lawmakers from 6 opposition parties who now want to see him
11:45 pm
a peach. what do you see as being the likely next step? darcy yeah, i think it's, it's, it's, this is why it's so baffling is, but he, there wasn't really a clear pathway for him to carry this out. given the law, the procedure of declaring martial law and just requiring national assembly approval doesn't have the votes and the national assembly, the opposition party has the majority votes. and they also have was facing a lot of conflict within his own party, particularly with the party to the party leader. so the number of votes that you mentioned included not only the opposition party as a 190, but it also included, i think, about 18 members of his own party voting to overturn his declaration of martial law looking for we're and what this means is that it's basically backfire, like you mentioned. so now the opposition party had called for his resignation yesterday at full time. but he, they have put forward a movement,
11:46 pm
a motion to impeach him. he has 48 hours to resign, but it seems like there will be a vote by friday to impeach him. and i think right now he's basically garner the support that this opposition needed to seek the impeachment that they had been trying over the past year. so that's what makes us really a particularly baffling move and maybe suggest his isolation from the general political. okay. so the political community of south korea, so bustling but no doubt particularly b. j in soul. where you are very alarming to see helicopters flying above the presidential palace. i mean, bring it back. no doubt it goes of the pos, i mean, democracy is being hauled, one inquiry hasn't been of the decades of military dictatorship. the last time marshall was introduced was back in 1917. i'd get a sense of what the mood, the anticipation, the fears were where you are of the day as whilst you was announcing the
11:47 pm
martial law. i was watching the tv and i had the chip messages coming into my mobile phones and all our reactions from my students and my friends overall. it was kind of like a laughing stands like, what is it trying to do in this country where people have power has ruled above and beyond the law actually itself. we have this tradition for several decades where people rose up and kicked out the dictators one after another. and it was as recent as 6 years ago when people actually pushed out the sitting president out of her office. and this law proud tradition of people exercising their own power and having a strongly exceptional sense of ownership of the country. it was just unimaginable and think about what the president was trying to do by imposing martial law single handedly at that time last night. so that was the overall reaction and you know,
11:48 pm
just remember is martial law. we made in actually fact only for about 4 and a half hours while he was making this announcement of $12000.00. i'm not sure executive number of people, but they read it to the national assembly to protest and then they were letting the lawmakers into the national assembly. you to have the lawmakers vote against the martial law. all right, so really address to that health the with the real stress of the health of democracy in the country. yeah, clearly i what if we can talk about the international ramifications? clearly, people power piece of one the day on the streets of sol, but we've had comments from the likes of russia, china, japan, the united states, the head of bates. so all of them saying pretty much exactly the same thing that they want seem developments with quote great concern and the toner. what does this test of democracy in korea mean for its international standing?
11:49 pm
of course, a career is very much part of the fabric of everyday life and millions of people around the world from korean calls to kate pump. what does this mean though? because he is international reputation. most certainly in south korea has definitely, as you said, entrenched itself in the fabric of the global community. and i think people in dc especially were kind of shocked at the response from the united states. i think most thought that it would be a stronger condemnation of imposing martial law, especially because in the all of these build ups of try lateral relations with the u. s. and japan, south korea has promoted itself, is a global responsible power with a strong sense of democracy, a strong history of democracy. so i think the global community is a bit shocked and just trying to figure out what the next steps are for south korea . and what that means for international relations, red large south korea has a lot of hands and a lot of different pods. so it will be interesting to see if any countries come
11:50 pm
forward with stronger statements or if they will focus on kind of rebuilding the party and moving forward with more democratic procedures. does say, i mean, what about international security? i'm in the us, have quite a sizable ministry presence. they can create that and they understand around 24000 troops, 9 major bases. do you think this is likely to from, to security via reevaluation from the us. i don't think that the alliance is in any jeopardy from this. i do. i would actually go a little step further from natalia and say, i think in washington, we were a bit just made by the by ministrations reaction to this. and this is something that's been a bit confusing for us in washington. okay. who do watch career closely? june has domestically implemented some uh, policies that were i anti labor or suppressing for media decide. and so for the city of washington dc for this to be our partner, there is
11:51 pm
a bit of a mismatch here. that being said, i do think that us in washington and those who do work on the alliance are very hardened by the fact that this was resolved in as professor consent just a few hours. and i think that showing the strength of korea's robust in institutions to keep this sort of overreach and check, just goes to show that we're, you know, we, we are in good hands. when we think about our security architecture in the region. it's not in jeopardy from a strong man, and so, so i'm trying to overstep. and so i don't think that this is necessarily going to be affecting the broad strokes of our alliance. so results in a few hours. but nevertheless, it seems so close to a significant amount of jitters in career itself. be jeremy. the trade unions clearly worried about all of this. they've lost his indefinite strike. and to present you goes and stop the futures, the tumbled, obviously, markets there like anything like this. i mean, how do you evaluate the economic damage in career with the moment
11:52 pm
a comic damage? i cannot think of any scenario where this will have a real significant impact on the, on the economy. other than perhaps, as you mentioned, the financial market reactions last night, especially the foreign exchange side. or we saw a say see they've been the weakening of korean courtesy for some time, but overall industry and the business overall. we cannot think of any scenario other than that, the possibility of the opposition party. well, not possibly, the, almost certainly the opposition democratic party would probably lead the overall direction with economic policy going forward. the thing is opposition parties of pro is party, but that's the party was. that was the party that belonged to that had previous would present moon and wound government's party. and at that time, you know what to and a half years ago when government was not known as the unfriendly party towards the business. they were doing
11:53 pm
a lot of business friendly stuff. so even though the opposition party democratic party was even for to increase their hands over economic policy going forward. that's not a bad news now. that's not necessarily a bad news for the business as a whole. so economic business, i don't see like significant impact, as i said, sort of, it's potentially a gift towards. so for the opposition, but natalia is this also is some kind of way a gift horse for north career. i guess we could do an entire program on that, but your thoughts and the time you well we've seen that north korea, so i'm pretty silent on the issue. and i think this just shows that they were willing to sit back and look at play out as it was. i think that they felt it was embarrassing for antonio. but we also know that people that come out in north korea and speak with such as conjunctions as this direction young. they never have anything time to say about what's going on in south korea or the us or japan, or anybody who's working against what north korea is doing the international
11:54 pm
community. so we're not really surprised to see that their silence. but in terms of venture korean relations, i think we're going to stay in the course. i don't see any major policy shifts and then uh, weeks coming, no matter who comes into power after you tell us, because we round up this conversation. let me put this to you. is this a little likely to meet a period of full political uncertainty to come in career? well, i certainly think that we can expect continuation of the live scale protests that are gone going on in south korea. i mean, it's a legacy of it's democratization movement in the eighty's. it still has a vibrant, a protest culture, a non violent protest culture. so i think that we can look for that. certainly now with the, the large umbrella career trade union, the case you see you, we can look for, we should look for, for them. especially if they're calling for a up a us, a lot, a large scale strike. that's going to be affecting a lot of the industries and so that's another thing that we can look out. and then finally, as the impeachment, whether present you decide,
11:55 pm
stay resign or appeasement proceeding. so forward, there's going to be a lot of digging for political dirt. all right, let's circle back and give a, b, j. the last words very briefly, b j. when the dust settles on all of this, will there be some soul searching about how to save god even further? the health and stability of could we as democracy very briefly if you would. yeah. the that's a great question. but once again, i think what we have learned so far is once again, the people are part of this country, which is very unique around the world in comparison with other countries and people sense of ownership of the country. so let's show months again. so start searching yes. to make it stronger. definitely, but i think we have gain confidence once again in the aftermath of this, a big political turmoil and big surprise as well. so no flaws in the existing democratic god rails page i uh, you know, as long as people are popular,
11:56 pm
it sits on the palpable law. and if you on above and beyond law, i think that's something we could trust in democracy role by the people trust the democracy role by the people. we have reached the end of our conversation, a pleasure to have all 3 of you on the show on the inside story beach, i came down c drive the holidays and the time the slab de. um, thank you to for watching. you can see the program any time by visiting our website, and i would just say with dot com. and for further discussion, go to a facebook page. that's facebook dot com, forward slash 8 inside story. you can also join the conversation on x or handle is as a j inside story for me in the fall. okay, and the whole team here, i filled out the to leave off church solutions that gives us no hope for future that we have to find creative solutions. not just turn our backs on
11:57 pm
. i don't think that has a number. think about it as a person yourself and that person's shoes. so as you can see for this is my us, my life, or at least in my life, you know, stages we want we want to operate because the women and my country deadlocks suite to come up to on we are not denies all of who we are human beings and deserves to be treated equally. we are walking in their footsteps, our officers whatever has been done before, can be done even better. as long as a human being is doing it. you just have to keep pushing because no one else can see. the vision is key of destruction on a scale never seen before with the risk of nuclear warfare, which is highest and decades. a group of who rush hitler and mega saki. so volume
11:58 pm
has been awarded the 2024 nobel peace prize, which efforts to achieve a world free of nuclear weapons. join us from oslo for an exclusive interview with the witness campaign group in the home. he don't kill and hear that powerful witness testimony. the nobel interview lives on al jazeera, all through a decade of honoring individuals and institutions working and translation between arabic and 40 other world languages. shay come on award for translation, and international understanding is hosting it's 10 towards serve. on the 10th of december 2024 in doha guitar, shea come on the award for translation and international understanding from the arabic language to mankind. the,
11:59 pm
there's no limit to how a dream contains sta in your own adventure, you know, counter everything's a weekly look at the world's top of business stories. what does a rate cost in the united states waiting for the rest of us from global markets and economies? should that be beyond to asked if people have sent a nice time working? that's hard for the answer to understand how it affects the nights counting the cost. oh no, just sierra a face contented story without having to ring a single word. no english can guide us. a simple touch and phone lines. the unconventional vanity of life. witness through the lens of the human eye is walton spies.
12:00 am
witness documentary on out is in the the hello, i'm jessica washington. this is the news and world life from don't have coming up in the next 60 minutes. left wing and right wing politicians in front of your nice house thing. prime minister and michelle bunyan, tense housing displaced, palestinians go off in flames, is really strikes. he's a so called st. so in southern gaza. and a man hunt is underway in new york of the ceo of the u. s. as largest healthcare
12:01 am
company is guns down in the st. george's opposition leader is.

4 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on