tv [untitled] January 19, 2025 8:00pm-8:31pm AST
8:00 pm
and then the moines will start getting bigger and the cautiousness of the suffering then the pain will become more and more real as time goes by. and as they start cursing their life and what is happening to them. and as they also think, of course, of the importance of freedom from occupation, freedom from upon fades and the need for them to establish their own and to rebuild their own gaza strip as wide as the rest of us died. so this is going to be very, very difficult process. that's why sometimes we say so far and up to the siding. this was the easy part. now when people are really become more conscious of how, how rhetoric that reality is free of fear. but burdened with the big the reality, it's going to be very painful to live and to watch. so it's good talk to you more on thankful. putting this, these critical moments into perspective for us around the charlotte observer,
8:01 pm
senior political analyst day. and if you'll just joining us well, come to our special coverage of the seas font in garza now. and it's 7th, our 3 female captives being reunited with their mothers in israel. 15 months after they were kidnapped by him us and held in garza don stine, becca drama government and emily dom already for handed to the red cross. in the assault i, a square in gauze and city, and driven across the border to israel. their ongoing medical assessments, a total of $33.00 out of about $95.00 captives the do to be released in the initial phase of a seas. 5 deal between this route and time. us and buses have arrived at the outset prison in the occupied westbank. they'll transfer an agree, 90 palestinian female and child prison is from this, and the other is ray, the prisons, maybe 2000 detainees are set to be released over
8:02 pm
a 6 week period on crowds of people have gathered in hostages square in tel aviv to support the families of the freed captives and those still a thing throughout the war and gals. tens of thousands of held weekly protests across his route to pressure these right the government to read should deal with him us to bring the captives home. meanwhile desperately needed deliveries of aid of started to go into gaza. the trucks are coming through the wood off border crossing, caring humanitarian supplies, including wall to food and fuel. the seas 5 deal requires $600.00 truck loads of 8 to be allowed into guns daily. and the source code is not mine because they as well as band out is here from operating within the country. so how does that start with the life? is the reaction that to the ton. now i understand those 3 is very, the captives have now left garza and all in is around. right.
8:03 pm
that's right. these really military releasing footage, showing the 3 now former captive leaving dogs the interview goals and being handed over to is really forces. after they were picked up by the red cross in dogs, they will go under an initial identification process and then initial medical check before their air lifted to a hospital in the center of israel near tell a v that's also worth mentioning, that the family members of those 3 women have been updated our by our, by these really military and are waiting for them at the hospital and didn't televi, but what's become known as hostage square. there are thousands of israelis who were watching the speech by daniel her, gar, you confirming that the 3 captives were back in the hands of these really military . there's also been a flurry of statements from his really officials, the defense minister, the prime minister,
8:04 pm
and other people within these really government welcoming the captive is back. but so this was a long time coming. this is something to the family members of those captive se they have been seeking for more than 470 days, pleading with the government for some kind of deal. and now they're saying they want to see the deal all the way through. not just through phase one, where there will be 33 captives released. but up until phase 3 went, all of the captives, both living and deceased will be returned to israel. and come the looking at what we're expecting to happen next. now take us through the release of palestinian prisoners as well, there's a heavy security presence around all sort of present and that's because these really present services said that they're going to do things differently this time
8:05 pm
. then they did back in november of 2023. even though the red cross will be president for part of that when those 90 policy need prisoners, as part of the deal will be released. these really present services that they want to limit expressions of joy among palestinians, most of which will be returning to the occupied west bank. but some of them will be returning to occupied east jerusalem, where there was a heavy it's really police presence back in november of 2023. when there were women and children being released from is really jail. so is really forced to say that this time things are going to be done differently, but as of now those prisoners still have not been released. and i'm the and these critical moments. there's also, we've seen this sort of political tensions and baffles playing out in these right. the cabinet just to approve these dell took us through the reaction that has come since then with statements from people like there's a lot of smoke switch. it's
8:06 pm
a mob been given and where that leaves the stability of netanyahu's cabinets. you have to remember that this is the most far right government in israel's history . and as in yahoo form to coalition with people in the right wing the meaning of the jewish power party, to be some more bend beer and the religious zionism of bedside smelt. rich ben, beer and his party have since step down from the government, submitting their resignation in protest of the deal that was passed within the wider is rarely cabinet. but best on a smart ridge has said that he's decided to remain in the coalition because he's gotten some sort of guarantees permits. and y'all who that his role would ultimately resume fighting and quote, take over the entirety of the gaza strip, which is a little bit difficult to believe that given the fact that this has been a war that's been going on for more than 15 months. and after the cease fire deal was achieved, it's laid out in 3 phases and then the last one,
8:07 pm
an ultimate end to the war. that's something the right wing has been protesting. e some are been be or said. but he also wanted those assurances that his role would go back to war 2 full scale war and the siege of guns the been here was arguing that he didn't want any humanitarian a to go into dollars or this is rhetoric we had been hearing from the right in israel since the beginning of the war, but none the less benjamin netanyahu, whose coalition for now still remains intact because you have to remember there's a new party that's been brought into the coalition. the new whole party of the on side who is now the country's foreign minister. so with the inclusion of the number of parliament members in his party, benjamin netanyahu still has the majority within the is really goodness at which means that he is still going to remain in power. all right, we'll leave with that. thanks so much. i'm the solve hold now the safe side deal was proposed in may of last year,
8:08 pm
but the policies rankled over several closes before reaching a consensus. ben smith breaks down what was finally agreed to a phase one of the sci fi deal. will see the release of psalm is ready to comp tips palestinian prisoners, the gradual withdrawal of israeli forces from central garza a search and humanitarian aid. i'm the return of display spot listings to the north of the strip. 33 is rarely comp tapes will be released over a 6 week period is available for a almost 2000 palestinian prisoners on detaining 600 truck loads of humanitarian aid. a day will come into gauze. israel will withdrawal from the next room, kara door palestinians living in northern gauze. i will be able to go to what's left to that homes. now in the last of the 33 captives are released on day 42 is a riley falls, they will begin withdrawing from the philadelphia, colorado. this is a contentious pos of a deal for these rarely government negotiations. for phase 2 will begin on day 16,
8:09 pm
a phase one is expected to lead to the release of all remaining is rarely captives and more palestinian detainees, as well as a permanency spa. i'm a complete withdrawal of israeli forces. phase 3 will address the long term reconstruction of gaza kata. egypt, the united states will supervise the implementation of a deal which could fault at any time. if i have a side accuses be of a breaking the ceasefire as well. does 0 correspond to need that abraham was in the occupied westbank covering the palestinian prisoner released during the november 2023. c. spice joins me now. here in the studio. so you've been following this, you know, right from the beginning to that and tell us how tense and complicated is this process for releasing palestinian detainees. you know, now as you have been seeing the success from alpha to prison,
8:10 pm
the waiting game begins. yes. the palestinians, the families have had the list of names of who's going to be released to night, 90 palestinians. most of them are women and we have 12, a palestinian young men and children under 19 years of age. but so it must be very nerve wracking, nevertheless. indeed, because you don't know when they're going to be released, and in some of those instances that we've covered it near the alpha admitted to the prison, the list would be only released just an hour before a narisa's. so you have like a lot of tension and emotions boiling amongst families who don't know if their loved ones are going to be the beast or not. so we're talking about families that are not even allowed to show any is celebration. we've heard today from many families there that they've received calls from these really intelligence officers telling them that they cannot show any sign of joy any signs of happiness. remember, these are comedies were welcoming their loved ones home and they cannot show any
8:11 pm
sign the occupation is even telling them how to, how to react to the release of their loved ones. and indeed, we've seen one prisoner who is expected to be reduced to nights. the middle of the item yet she's been questioned over what is really said that the time that they were showing. so it's enjoy upon her release. remember, she has family members were coming from all over at to welcome her and faith and, and, you know, welcome her. so, and then you see her getting arrested. again, she's going to be raised again. but we know that these really made it to the a soldiers are all over there over them. and that city present in and around it's an in the last is why are the we've seen a lot of them chasing palestinians who are welcoming their loved ones with gas making. it's harder as hard therefore turn to this even took over the story. so it's a very tough situation and some of those nights that we were staying near the open military prison. we stayed until 2 and 3 am local time sent me. and just to clarify,
8:12 pm
well, you know, we talked about these people as, as prisoners, that have been plenty of international. and this re, the human rights groups which have talks about prisoners being held. i think bates have them talks about the prisoners being held helpless in conditions of administrative detention with other international human rights groups. calling this administrative detention system as, as a tool of occupation and a pop type that's going on. so talk to us about the conditions and the idea of a due process that exists for these present. you know, article specifically a prisoner who said that she spent 2 decades in jail, but a year from october. the 7th until he has been released was harder than all of his 20 years in prison combine. so you were talking about a situation where prisoners did not have enough food, did not have visitation rights, but when it comes to their families coming and seeing them they, it does not have at all of the what we call as a chief minutes of the prison their movement across the years to have a tv,
8:13 pm
to have a certain situation that could allow them to organize the day to day live. all of these were withdrawn from them, but not only that, we've seen a lot of beating and, and, and torture. and not only that, so i mean, just a few hours ago, the published and in a prisoner's affair said the another posted in prisoner this time a 22 year old has been pronounced dead in his really jail. and we've seen many instances where the prison service would say, oh, they died in the pulsing and say, he must have done it's under torture and abuse. what will on that point, what kind of rehabilitative process is the for some of these prisoners who are being released stupidly, you know, many of them would be going back to gaza, which is a devastated, obviously seen. and some of them emerging from the sort of conditions you mentioned in an internal view and report in march 2024 described palestinian
8:14 pm
detainees being exposed to beatings. dog attacks and even sexual assault. do they get rehabilitative kind of federal pay? what do they return to? what's i mean, i remember you're talking about a nation under images to the occupation and i here must remind our viewers of a story we often talk about. it's a quote from a leading palestinian psychiatrist. look, there's so much of it who says there is no p and p t s d. so california is do not even and cannot have of post traumatic stress disorder because they are already traumatized. they are already, they cannot go back to a place of safety where they can feel that they are ok now and safe. so speaking about the mental health is a big issue for palestinians. the main concern now is that their loved ones do not get rid of that again. and we have been speaking to some of those palestinian families who are undergoing distress,
8:15 pm
who are waiting for the loved ones to be back home. and we've prepared this report, medium or waste has 3 sons in his way to jails, to our expect it to be reduced in the ceasefire deal abdicating and his brother has son or both serving life terms. a prisoner swap is the only way out. so i need to and when i 1st heard i got shocked, i stopped a shaking and suddenly felt those around me started asking what's wrong with you? i said, i don't know. maybe i'm happy. i don't know how i see the 1st ceasefire deal in november. 2023, lost it for a week and sold the release of dozens of palestinian prisoners, women, children, and young men. our joy is not complete. you look at the sacrifice of blood spilled in gaza. he's my eldest son. i am happy to see him here, but it's a painful moment. at least $25.00 of those release have since been very interested,
8:16 pm
including on medicine. my wife is a common practice for the occupying power is room the service to me. it also happened to negative, but of course he was released with more than $1000.00 palestinian prisoners in exchange for is really sold to get out to after 3 years of freedom, he was rea rested, now is now spent the total of 44 years in jail. and is considered the longest serving palestinian prisoner. he married a man in a short time. he was out of jail. yeah. and they planted this orange tree kind of what they sold would be a lifetime or to together show a lot. yeah. new bits instead of coordinate and see i've seen or about the house he left in the year 2014 is waiting for him. and he didn't even get enough time out of jail to taste the oranges we missed and were waiting for it. and i will come to ish,
8:17 pm
the, and $47.00 others who would be arrested in the deal. would it be the least in phase one of the cease fire agreement? phase 2 negotiations are expected to focus on palestinian leaders from different factions like motor one, but a whole fee, but i am habit of deliverables and that's i that. but the release is still being vetoed by israel. high profile or not. less than he is have little say in who makes the final list. with more than 600 people serving or facing life sentences, they fear. it's either now or never knew that pain and dizzy but only is last day and i'll face outgoing us present. and joe biden, welcome the start of the safe spot. gold on the incoming trump administration to see the deal through. and after so much pain, destruction, loss of life today, the guns and guys that have gone silent. this was the deal,
8:18 pm
the outline for the world back in may 31st. now, the reason it has been fundamentally transformed mazda is long time leaders and more as their mos sponsors and the lease have been badly weakened by israel, backed by the united states, has the law on how most of the biggest factors, but significantly weekend of the battlefield. and as the leadership was destroyed, a spring and i'll get somebody to get into james bay's for this moment in time for the world. james, i could say you following what's happening behind the scenes in the world of diplomacy. and this is a seas 5 deal that came about because of intense diplomacy involving 3 mediators. what's the, what is it so far? so good is that cautious hope and optimism it might hold to the, to the end, a very, very fragile, but yes, cautious hope. and optimism from all involved, as you say, it was the junctions,
8:19 pm
it was the cartridge and it was the united states that were responsible for this deal. but it's not a new deal. it's a deal that i've been on the table since may. and prince, if i press the button, was presenting it, then all the laser is really deal because oft up he did that and presented it publicly in may. and it was even endorsed by the un security council. this deal was stymied by is really objections by prime minister netanyahu coming up with a range of different objections about why he couldn't sign the deal. and it was only at the end in the last month that the trump administration, the incoming trump administration, got involved president trump saying that that'd be all hell to play. pay if there wasn't a deal before he comes into office and he comes into office now less than 24 hours from now and he have it. it's come into full just before he comes into the office on the last day of president biden's to as a, the us president. but it's west,
8:20 pm
i think, making the very clear point that they're all nearly 47000 palestinians who died in gaza. and when the deal was 1st proposed, untrusted announced by president biden, there were 56000. so over 10000 people, the majority of them, women and children have died. the didn't need to die if this deal and comes through the president biden. and his speech said, note, there's reasons why i couldn't bring it earlier, but ultimately the us present has total leverage over and is right, the prime minister, because they supply the money. they supply the guns, the, the weapons, they munitions, most of what was dropped on, garza was made and paid for by the united states. so he could have withdrawn that support at least restricted some of it at various points. they hinted they were going to, but he never ever use that power and i suspect somebody that's because he was
8:21 pm
worried ahead of november about the impact on the us election and then possibly often november he didn't have the leverage because by that and he was pretty lame duck, james, i'm glad you mentioned vitamin statements on may the 31st when he presented this deal as and his re the proposal because i'm sure you'll remember on january the 15th 5 and presented it saying this plan was developed and negotiated by my team. it is the something of a struggle between the outgoing and the incoming presidents over who can claim this for the legacy and where does that leave? do we think donald trump's position towards ensuring that he, that this deal goes through to the end so that he has a legacy? and yeah, but the thing is interesting on what level they worked incredibly closely together . 2 administrations who had bret mccook who is representing president biden and see
8:22 pm
what it costs the invoice of presents like trump involved and then it goes the ations that took place in doha. but yes, who claims this full, that historical legacy? and the thing that changed in my view was president trump and the pressure of that mr. whit cost, who is not a known diplomat. he was previously a businessman of properties about a put the pressure that he applied on netanyahu pressure that comes ultimately from president trump. but it goes from a 24 as time president trump now has this file. we know the prime minister netanyahu as well, and that they may not be a phase 2 of this deal. that may just be the 1st $42.00 days of that is around may decide to restart the conflict. i think that puts a president trump in a difficult position. he's made it clear he wants to be a piece make how he relishes that role. he's talked about wanting to win the nobel peace prize, and i think also president trump would come come under
8:23 pm
a great deal of public pressure internationally, of course. but among the american public now seeing scenes of joy on the streets of gauze of to so many people dead. if that change to another bombardment, how would president trump if you suppose it, israel, how would he sell us to the american people? a questions for the new us president to he office on the 24 hours from now and stuff and from james space, i'll get somebody to get it to. thanks so much james. us this take you to daniel leave now is a form is ready to go shapes and presidents of the us middle east project. he joins us now from london. daniel, the few i'm show you follow the polls in israel that even before this prison, the release and sees 5 deal, the polls show that the majority of these, right the public one to the sees 5 bill wanted to see the captives returned home. what do these images now due to the public opinion, to the support base for the government?
8:24 pm
and how does that impact any inclination, any cabinet member might have to try. and scott, for this before we reach the end, it's sammy, this is an emotional day across. so many spaces i've been with your network often during these times. can i just take one moment to acknowledge on this day the remarkable coverage of braves give you one correspondence on the ground. those of us who primarily take on using english for being so reliable and literary plenty of my fluids are a couple of su monopolies including those who have lost their lives. and i think it's very appropriate to pay tribute to them today. now israel, thank the for for full acknowledging that. thank you. i'm sure they'll be grateful . thank you, sammy, we're in the very 1st hours of the family being were united and of course, you know, this is home. so the people,
8:25 pm
it goes up to the palestinian prisoners being released things of the impact in these rep. this is really hard. i see for people who don't follow the means. you shall have to appreciate just how wrapped up in these individual personal stories. so lots of these re, population has been through the course of the 60 months. the population is divided in many ways, but they will the names of the whole stages of the most become household names and every fabric. how that will play out in terms of what really makes it difficult for nothing yahoo to wriggle out of the rest of this deal, i think is one of the biggest on dogs. and it's one of the reasons that nothing. y'all was so reluctant to get to this moment because what was the set in motion today was we will love is extremely fragile. but we also know this is really
8:26 pm
rash. the reason such for geology, there's incredible transparency and clarity to wolf has prevention of deal, and that is nothing yahoo! the x ray governing coalition, you have factions, one section is left and say, well we enjoy restore another direction to say we're staying, but we'll leave if you don't restore war. so nothing young coalition stability depends on came breaking the code. and so we know with the probably started to bring this down the image, i know him because you always want to your point. this is what these by the prime minister had to say last night. it was a key point. let's listen and i want to ask you about it should be lots of philadelphia and that the principle is to maintain the philadelphia axis and the security buffers are and when i say maintaining the philadelphia axis, not only are we not reducing the forces there, we will even increase them
8:27 pm
a little everything that's being resulted, daniel about the agreement says that israel with ultimately fully withdrawal from the philadelphia cardinal that is contradicted by want nothing. yeah. who said last night, how should we interpret that? is that an escape escape routes already being planned? from the implementation. right, so nothing yahoo route when he goes jason's, i'm know now without a shadow of doubt that a deal was that to be done. but we're going to just start with the deal in november of 2023. nothing yahoo chose to break. we know that for several months under the newest circumstances, that has been the possibility of regina do nothing young continued to both the change the reality on the ground. i've thrown your spine was in the works for new obstacles in the way of a deal was this issue of philadelphia, so it well goes into the granular detail of that. there is some,
8:28 pm
some of the d because they're all secured. yeah, next is then map. so which one up between this route and egypt in terms of these rolls read appointment, but we know what i'm saying? for sure. i'm not used to the whole day 50. this is the deal continues be only $42.00 days in a row has to be fully out of the philadelphia, colorado. therefore nothing yahoo is signalling his intention to a show that he owns the 1st phase of the deal. there is no further ceasefire, and you know, if you strip away all the propaganda who the deceit lies from washington and these drugs, other hours, the best going to understanding what has been going on is to actually listen to the state to do tensions of israel's latest from the president and the prime minister, down to cabinet ministers and members of the contests. and they have told us that the fact that they will draw no distinction between to begin and coming back to the
8:29 pm
right off that they have told us a bit genocidal intention. not to you always telling us now that he does not intend to see this through. so he's people have to be held sort of. all right, daniel, what else the time, but thank you so much for your full 10 analysis. that's daniel lady form is ready. negotiate to alright, let's bring you up to speed with some of the live pictures that were monitoring right now. historic moment we've seen 3 is really captives released to mid ton to israel. and a moment of joined celebration for some of those families of the captives and moments of extreme hope for those palestinians families waiting for 19 of the relatives to be released from the alpha prison will bring you more updates on this cease file. and it's hopefully, yeah, the, the latest news,
8:30 pm
even in the face of honest speak of the last it continues to hugh uncomfort and body and resilience. and it's a purest form, with detailed coverage hornsby chewing every day in a buddy aust, conditions to secure these amounts for the, from the hoss of the story. from some people that have killed more than 46000 palestinians. but right scrooge say that, as well as using food as a blessing, to have a sense of building dogs with this. these fire coming after nearly 4 to 7000 people were killed by his radio, tots and western web. how experience or know a try and rebuild their lives at home. many of them destroyed by the funding. how has the street of thousands of people remain unbroken? this is inside story, the
0 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=1884190095)