a 100000 people with that 70 years later, those who survived seek recognition and compensation for the event that define their lights. only to find themselves still cost aside. witness paper sitting on a just either a lack of international actions accounts or a new round of is riley say, you don't. garza raises questions and concerns is the use of salvation as a weapon of will being normalized and is the us still committed to the sci fi deal that health pro cook? this is inside story, the hello and welcome to the show. i'm sammy's. a. then on sunday is well, once again, cut off, much needed food, medicine and fuel into gaza. prime minister venue mean nothing. yeah. whose

government has been clear? the move is meant to pressure him us into accepting a new set of sci fi tons. these terms though conflict with the seas, 5 deal israel agreed to in january. how may i ask, who's calling to move a violation by his route of that deal? but the spines, as well as clear, intend to use the of ation, is leverage the global response as long as they've been muted. while our countries have condemned the blockade, the us and europe do not appear willing to hold israel to the terms of the original agreement. so can as well that will be held to account. and if so, how will put that to our guests in the moment. but 1st, this report from, for the a call at this food distribution point in southern guys that russians are already meter, palestinians here use walk, little they can to prepare meals to break their fast during ramadan. had hope to

mark this lasting months in peace, given the cease fire, but only days into separations, israel. and then it was locked aid and supplies from entering gaza. once again the ash and go ahead the what is this decision? it is an execution. what's more do they want to do to us? when they prevent everything from people, what is left? they destroyed their homes and devastated them. they also prevent food and drink from reaching them. who would accept this? israel is attempting to pressure from us into changing the terms of the ceasefire. both sides agreed back in january. a mass says that's unacceptable. let's think you will if this as i'm lucky. so let's do you mind if we condemn the cheap black malpractice to find that's in yahoo and is extreme is to governments against our people by using humanitarian aid as a bargaining chip in the negotiations. the 1st 40 to day phase of the deal expired on saturday. that soft $33.00 is rated captains for 1900 palestinian prisoners

released. but rather than enter face to israel is backing us proposal to extend the 1st space in exchange for half. the remaining $59.00 captains that would essentially allow israel to avoid negotiating. it's complete withdrawal from guys that districts rebuilding and its future governance to mass is calling on the international community to pressure israel into starting face to discussions as agreed. but the music global response. so far doesn't appear to have softened israel's position. it might come off if her mazda doesn't release the hostages soon . the gates of gaza will close at the gates of hell. will open of us special envoy, steve would cost is traveling to the region to prevent the cease fire from collapsing altogether. but with president donald trump also telling nothing yahoo to do whatever he wants with the deal is rel, appears to have free reign to cut off supplies into gaza. and just the, the, the truth is that we're in a real time and this is not

a lie. we could not find anything to eat. we would not find anything to eat for a week because of this. we wonder if time and could return again. the biggest surprise is that we're in the 21st century and the world allows the spam and palestinians and guys that are still facing is really a tax. and once again, starvation all the way to the world to do something for the car out to 0, inside story the well before we go to one guess let's talk to a seamless, he's the golf. so response lead at ox fam joins us from golf. so good to have you with us so, so 1st of all, just to be very clear. all we now in a situation where israel has stopped absolutely o a by the way talking and the items of food will to clothing fuel getting into gaza right now. yes, unfortunately, we're now um,

we don't have any trucks intern goza, including on the humanitarian items on the trucks. and i thought, agreed also this is fair. since the 3 days we didn't receive any dogs and also didn't, including the fuel and building on the items. we're talking about of coal, so population of more than 2000000 people. how is that impacting that plight? yeah. the and then back is a huge. yeah. and it says that they one of a noise say of, of uh, taking sash decision about the closure and closing of all the borders we and the items or the food is found to be disappeared from the market. and the price is start to be indicated. um we are, we are afraid to that off the maximum. we'd go from this, the closure, we went and fees and you and your check engine, we would face, we'd be able to, would not be able to, to, to have access to for all the basic basic items as

a part of the siege i or the closure of those 2 borders. oh, so sorry to cut to the the, the on the, in the state like a line that they provide the c c or the century class with the, with a look at the state business and see what type of furniture plant status more than $400000.00 individuals in the mid area and also this would impact access to drinking water and the sup all day. and they had washed the meat very, who put that in. and i imagine you probably as an agency, you ask is riley authorities and officials to let you bring a day. and i'm wondering what kind of response to go. what do is ready? officials tell a agencies about why they doing best to a civilian population and, and how long they'll go on with an absolute shut down of any supplies for the civilian population. yeah, a lot of work. we are way out of him with that in norcross and our aim is to

support the need of uh, of people who are in need. and we are coming through of focusing on the support that needs. we would have turned back for themselves to dental. and we are doing our best together with different, into stakeholder and different i and yours. and you and i just as to, to support that a leasing albany slash slash bought the under, under the leads up, located on people on the support very who my dad and this is what we are doing. all right, well the same wish to have that from unc sam joining us from god. so thank you very much and we do hope thank you, let them through for all and some people that mention all that spring in our guess . now have joining us from kind of a key about don. let's go i'm list and contribute to to hall rights, and also world molds of the land, the will for as well sacraments in the occupied territories. 1967 to 2007.

and i'm on jordan, the honeymoon stuff, a senior analyst on palestine, the international crisis group. and in new york, i've been hots professor of law and the judge john newman scholar had dropped because law school will welcome to well, let me start with the highly, you know, it's been several days now. it's a handy since israel announced it was simply cutting off. oh, supplies. oh, supplies of all the basics of life and gone. so we haven't seen the countries which regard themselves as the holders of human rights in the world. take any strong action, any counter measures to that right now, right? well, that's right. i think this row has certainly has successfully pushed the limits as to what american merits outrage us and the solve this wrong cause. but was here, it's not just that these countries have been completely silent. you know, the 1st day of the announcement of the recommendation of 8 or cutting off 8 to

cause or depression from us into accepting an initiative that was completed on disclose time. also to begin with, in terms of extending the 1st phase, we have seen the u activity condemn her mouth, which was incredibly shocking. considering bible definitions from us is not the one that started again, committing a more crime here. it's not the ones talking to 1000000 causes right now, you know. and so to, to not just see that silence from, from instant out from the international community. but more importantly, it actually start to see about condemnation pulling on her mouse and sort of the actual party committing the wall. crime has really rebuilt the double standard that i think many have been trying to, to really highlight of the last 16 months in terms of not just the way that the international community of law to remain silent. the fact that international organizations that should have been a deterrent for the kinds of actions we've seen over the last 60 months, not to mention the self interest of regional states even today with the early excitement going on. this really isn't about necessarily what you know. they can do

to better the situation for causing so costing and what they can do for their own domestic politics and national security. so i think this is really highlighted once again the double standard when it comes to the case of palestinians and especially cause a cave or, you know, i'm wondering how much the government rhetoric has changed on this issue of whether or not it's obstructing a. you might remember in october 2024 as well as on bass of the to the united nations dining down on telling the security council it had quote flood. they've garza with as much aid as possible and quote, denying that israel was obstructing aid. now it's openly saying it's doing it right . there's this been something of a shift in, in the rhetoric to actually i think the, the uh huh. what i see probably in gaza is called between

uh the is ready. uh sorry these and the come us. there's a place where is the a, in a way to control the situation. we know that the how much is using a food and fuel in order to, uh, being charged. and uh, sometimes they even steal a seal fuel and they have their priorities. the people will get to the age 1st and according to the evidence for that mister keys, i mean we, the reports done by even us all pharmacies and statements at the time may that they didn't see evidence of aid being stolen. where is the evidence full that? well, uh the charges have offered you some videotapes showing that

there was 2 lines of uh, chromeboys off the trucks. coming in to la garza and the very uh, last minute it says well, actually uh cutting uh the people of guys uh, which line is relevant to them. and um, there was some, some reports even in the international media that, uh how us is using and they did it before, even before the war. um, the, the agent was use the in way to control guys. uh, so uh, to the, according to my knowledge, there is no feminine garza yet, the problem is water and electricity and that's uh, the wheel humanitarian issue. that can and in

desk of babies, of people who cannot afford to buy if you're in the back market. we don't have so much mr. akiva to jump in again. but we did have reputable organizations. several of them before the seas. 5 deal like hawks from talk about starvation in some parts of gauze and becoming a reality. right. and, and the re, to your point about the reports that we saw in some of the international price, like the washington post investigation directing us to a un finding that some of the misuse of a that was going on by gang said side with games which will operating and is really controlled, tired tree the indicated that either these very socrates were turning a blind eye or actively encouraging the fast of some of this a pointing to it being something that was going on under the watch of these really a pharmacies. i mean, us, however, we try to, you know, these very,

it's always try to spin this. so the, i mean, now is the situation not very clear? that is route is simply cutting off all i the people are not folding victim because of facts devised by anybody, even whether or not that is going on. there is simply no way of coming into the goals or is the issue now? is it not mr. keith well uh, i really believe that uh, the aid has been used as a political instrument. uh, also domestically getting his route. uh, the supply of aid is not popular. uh either you. unfortunately, you can find many as larrys, who uh, have compassion to the senior people. i think i said before, people don't have enough compression for both that but a senior at these very people. um, you know what, what may uh, change the uh,

priorities is the pressure from the cap to families because uh what we heard from right is ready kept. this came back home. is that the how mosque got stalled in that if you use the you go to installing people, you're going to solve. so maybe the pressure would come from here. unfortunately, the is why the government and so now doesn't really see, you know, i spent 2 years for the babies in both in his right hand and i and you guys are okay, let me bring in a bill. um, is there any i'm big you a t n international law about depriving a civilian population of the basics of life? when do you and officials, the latest statement from you and officials talking about israel's move is cutting off of cutting off the age is threatening civilian life at this point. no,

there's no ambiguity. first, as the occupying power and cause a israel as an affirmative obligation to ensure the food and medical needs of the population. in addition, any party to an armed conflict has an obligation to allow and facilitate a much wider range of humanitarian aid. include including shelter, fuel, and other differential goods. as was mentioned earlier, the starvation of civilians as a method of warfare is both prohibited and no more crime. that means starving civilians either as a form of collective punishment, or as a means of pressuring the adversary bill concession. let me jump in and interrupt to you too, but bear with me and be patient. i want to bring to you these re the line that's also a just dropping saying that the causing all side because how my says benefiting from the a. how does that sort of, if i can call it,

defend state with your understanding of international law, if you know if, if you, as the occupying power, think a going in is helping the people, the groups, you'll find thing that so there are 2 problems will really 3 problems with this particular line of art in measurement, israel 1st as the occupying power, there is no exception to the obligation to ensure the food and medical needs of the population. second, the rule that is real appears to be invoking which is article $23.00 of the 4th of july. the convention was intended to create a very narrow exception to the obligation of non occupying powers to allow and facilities humanitarian relief. however, over many years, the narrow exception was abuse and as a result in the 1970s, a new rule was agreed upon by state rendering the old exception obsolete. and so now there is simply an unconditional obligation to allow and facilitate humanitarian relief, with no exception. and that is better,

let me jump in again. adel site. it's also trying to, but if, as, as we're hearing from a key, but he was relaying these right. the government claimed that they think they have evidence that how much these actually stealing some of the aid does that give the occupying power? is there any exemption to give them the right to then console the entire population of 2000000 people from aid? now, and this is precisely why that narrow exception was, was eliminated from international humanitarian law because it allows for the textual and disproportionate cutoffs of aid in response to allegations of minor diversion or use. and there's also a practical reason for this, which is that right, when you cut off aid, the price of food actually increases, so you're actually increasing the value of whatever it remains. so it's actually counter productive as well as being in humane to honey. this is a really a,

it's hard to think of another power level like this in, in, in recent years of an entire population. suddenly losing access to the basics of life and the, occupying power simply coming out and saying it clearly. now, without any attempt, you know, to, to explain, it's a way to disguise it. there are lots of measures that the allies of israel could take if they wanted to re, the pressure the government to change it stands. right. and we only have to look at some of the statements coming out from those western powers when it comes to situations like to crime. that's listening to what the pharmacist of germany just said. stoney a few days ago about a situation in ukraine. i guess we gotten a new era of ruthlessness has begun a heinous time in which we must defend the rules based international owed on the

strength of little more than ever against the might of the strongest. because otherwise, no free country can sleep peacefully. annual which has a strong and a busty. i could just say, always seeing a situation where we see stronger reaction to an argument in the oval office, which was the, the back story or the event that happened before. those comments by the german foreign minister and arguments in the oval office between the us and ukrainian presidents come provoke strong the reaction then salvation of 2000000 people in gauze, all the denial of basics to, to 1000000 people in gaza. well, that's right. and that goes back to the point about double standards that many have been pointing to the last 16 months of this conflict is the way that you can talk about of who was based older, you know, western states when it suits them, are able to condemn such and policies to the conflict, but that has not been the case in, in the instance of cause. and where by we've seen, the western states provide the to come i,

it covers the israel. we've seen them provide the economic support the information on to just to go support in order to enable israel to do what is has been doing in the last 16 months was here. we are now seeing them also provide civil operational support to enable them to do a similar in the west in the context of the west bank, which is where it is always ready. media itself is describing as the creation of many garza as well because if occasion of the west bank regional states, you know, again on ultimately you know, guilty of this in the sense that they have not tried to use any of the leverage they have with regards to the normalization deals, when israel to put sufficient pressure, anything we've seen sort of sticking positive measures, you know, things like a drops sending in medical chromeboys, but really know how much it does, but it's not con, trusted by. for example, what we're seeing over ukraine with us coughing, military aid from ukraine because of an argument in the oval office. we're not seeing the same level of concern. and this of you know,

when it comes to gaza and this obviously meshes that will pallas could use if they wanted to write precisely, there definitely measures that that can be utilized in order to pressure parties to the conflict. both parties to a concert, to reach some kind of sci fi idea, or to put an ends on the financing. and we haven't seen any of those measures. and you know, the, the images that we still coming out of the oval office last week. nothing of the sort was applied to nice and you on here, nothing else here by what accounts by the i c, c and i, c, j is wanted to will, primes is a key, but should we be surprised? the tool was a clear from the stop that the prime minister is very prime minister. didn't want to complete this deal, which had signed onto it. we just remind ourselves of some of the statements that were made, racing right at the beginning of the signing of this c o, the agreement i should say, of the sci fi deal is rails finance minister best allow small storage thing. on

january the 18th quotes, unfortunately, we were unable to prevent this dangerous bill, but we insisted and what able to insure through a government decision that the war would not hand in any way without cheating its full goals for most among them. the complete destruction of how mass and garza was also remember on january the 19th, the 1st day of the seas, 5 prime minister ben, you mean nothing now is saying quote, when i say maintaining the philadelphia access, not only we will not reduce the forces the we will even increase them less also a cable looking at some of those statements. of course the significance of withdrawal of israeli forces was something that was agreed to in the seas 5 deal. when you look at what was said, should it be a surprise to us a tool that it appears right now that nothing you know, wants to try and re negotiate will go for a different deal than the one he agreed to. i was given this to be only

a dealer in town, and this has been the case for many months. actually i agree that this was from day one is ending the war and allowing all the cap case to go back home and the prisoners exchange the loss. i don't know stupid antonio is not in the dues, and he knows that the captain of the only cause and, you know, today the president of the united states is always talking about cost is the landscape doesn't have cost. so how much has to be this crowds human beings, and also starving and die in, in the tunnels? so the portfolio, all the trade off is over chapters and we've done all of the entire goes up

now, and it's right now it's not only violating the out on the military and a distant b, so was much anyhow, will comply with the other part which is which drawing from should i don't see axes and openings, they rough uh term results for a go all kind of goods coming from egypt and egypt is winning even to start the reconstruction of gaza. so d a is just what i thought it's all over the entire process. all right, i do what legal mechanisms exist for address. if a civilian population is so openly being deprived of the basics of life as well. there are several mechanisms at the honey already mentioned. the international criminal court has already issued arrest warrants for prime minister meant nothing . yahoo! as well as former defense minister to launch a centering round to work crime of using starvation as a method of warfare,

jewels to crime against humanity of murder, which involves the death of several children as a result of starvation. the international court of justice has issued provisional measures ordering as well to allow and facilitate humanitarian relief. and israel's failure to do so will likely be taken by the court as an indication of genocidal intent. and finally, there's one with heavier but comes food enough to help people. so god really requires a political will of stage since the obligation of all stage to cooperate, to bring to an end, a breaches of fundamental rules of international law including through sanctions, through arms and bar goes through diplomatic pressure and, and other sanctions. and so really falls on will stage to do their part to bring these bio issues to and i'm right down i think we've got 30 seconds briefly. even though in our plan is, is coming together. i can't convince donald trump, there's an alternative to what he was proposing. what you and officials cooled

ethnic cleansing was difficult to see. even if the architects are able to proactively come up with something tangible, how they'll be able to actually change the 2 most powerful projects to this concept . israel and the us, ultimately, they owned the 2, decides about the future of casa here. so whether they will actually be able to leverage the power that they have, the capacity that they do have is something else entirely. and i think given those, leading this initiative a highly dependent on us aid. so it's, it's very unlikely that we're going to see much come out in the, in the way of anything positive for the palestinians, at least immediately. the right kind of thing called guests for the contributions a coupon. the other help and the honeymoon stuff. and thank you to for watching even see the show again, any time by visiting our website. i'll just here a don't com for further discussion head over to our facebook page. that's facebook dot com, forward slash a inside story. can also join the conversation on x. i'll handle there. is that

a inside story? from me, sammy say that and the entire team here for now to buy the she looked at the image and she was like, you know, the 20th like a terrorist. looks like what is it look like in a world of increasing prejudice? 5 women stand up to discrimination. i know why people hate us and i'm like, no with no. this isn't us challenging stereotypes. seeing that headscarf as a source of strength, faith and identity, and then we say, we will need to get involved in the cause. we are involved in the community. we just don't see it, my job, my choice coming soon on al jazeera, the agriculture revolution promised abundance of visit, damaging the planet to this system is destroying the habitat that tried leeway, exploded. how sacrificing by diversity from maximum view is leading to feed and

security and 1st name on the very existence of leaving me. self seized on able to adapt to climate change reading mode. we so full health plan is on. oh, just the era examining the impact of today's headlines. setting the agenda for tomorrow's discussion. international filmmakers and world class journal bring programs to inspire you on a to z a. the, there's no limit to how a dream contains sta in your own adventure, no counter. and

the a several venue in doha, with your top stories on elsie's 0 us president donald trump has given the longest presidential address to congress in modern history, in the speech that ranged from the panama canal to greenland, and the war and ukraine. it talked about his achievements, criticized his adversaries, and declared that america will be, will no longer. trump also revealed, he would, he'd received a letter from ukraine's president's offering to negotiate peace with russia in sign a minimal deal with the united states. and just a moment we'll be hearing from you or something relevant in moscow. first of all, strap it brings us the reaction from keith some of the loud his voice. he's with respect to, to reaction on that speech is debates as to whether this indeed will.