tv Disclosure BBC News September 16, 2018 10:30am-11:01am BST
10:30 am
theresa may has revealed her ‘frustration' with the continued speculation over her leadership — as the prime minister defends her brexit plan. at least 30 people are killed by flooding and landslides in the philippines — as typhoon mangkhut closes in on hong kong. meanwhile in the united states, storm florence continues to devastate the east coast with ‘epic amounts of rainfall‘. the liberal democrat leader, sir vince cable calls for the creation of a £100 billion sovereign wealth fund to spread britain's resources more evenly. i'll be back with you at 11am i'll be back with you at ”am but now a journey into the controversial world of live animal exports. bbc scotla nd world of live animal exports. bbc scotland investigates the dairy industry. it is a controversial trade. these animals are babies. the age that they are when they arrive is three weeks. i go on the trail of cattle trucks across europe. six days, two ferries, five countries. that was the most stressful journey i think i have ever done.
10:31 am
i discover the bleak choice farmers are faced with. the alternative argument may well be that you just have to shoot this animal. tonight, i investigate the dark side of dairy. it is auction day at one of the busiest markets in the uk. part of today's sale are these dairy bull calves, some just two weeks old. dairy farmers don't want them, because in an industry which relies on milk from female cattle, boys are surplus to requirements. these guys are only between two and four weeks of age and they are absolutely tiny. every now and again, they come up and try and suck on your fingers. in scotland, what happens to these
10:32 am
surplus boy calves is at the heart of a deeply controversial trade. it is one which i am setting out to investigate. galloway, the heart of the scottish dairy industry. this business is all about milk. to get cows to produce it, they need to have calves, but in the vast majority of dairy farms those calves are then taken away from their mums atjust a few days old, so that we can drink the milk. david finlay grew up in that business and it has left its mark. when you take a calf away from its mum, what is that process like, for the calf, for the mum, for the farmer?
10:33 am
well, it is something as a farmer that you just do, you get on with it, it is part of the job and you need to take the calf away because you need the milk. the calf at that point of course knows no better, other than its instinct tells them something is a bit funny, a bit odd. the mother, well, it varies. sometimes theyjust walked over to the feed and start eating and you thought they haven't even noticed. and then there's others that would bawl for days. really? yeah. and that was probably the distressing sight of it. that affects you now, talking about it. cut.
10:34 am
it is notjust that calves are normally taken away from their mothers. male calves obviously can't join the milking herd. in europe, they are often slaughtered around 20 weeks of age for veal, but that is not popular with uk consumers, and the industry says there is no market for them here. so, these dairy calves are essentially a waste product, and that has led to a dark trade. the export of calves to europe. these are irish animals being exported for veal in the netherlands. the images were taken by campaign group eyes on animals. one of its investigators is nicola glen.
10:35 am
she has been looking into the scottish trade, one that saw more than 5000 animals shipped to spain and italy last year. that is a massive increase on the few hundred just two years ago. nicola glen has obtained official journey logs, which establish that almost every fortnight for the last two years shipments of calves have been leaving scotland. they left the port on a p&0 ferry in northern ireland, where they continued theirjourney to the southern island, they caught the ferry in dublin with an onward journey to spain. how long did this journey take? this journey would have taken around six days. the logs say that calves are unloaded and rested several times during the journey, as legislation demands, but nicola glen thinks the journey itself is unacceptable. these animals are babies
10:36 am
and they are not adapted to cope with these sort ofjourneys. the longer the journey, it has been proven scientifically, that more suffering is involved for those animals. campaigners object to long journeys for calves because they can't control their own temperature and don't have developed immune systems. but the alternative to export is potentiallyjust as bleak. right now, farmers in scotland say these animals are worth some little these animals are worth so little that it is either ship them or shoot them at birth. are we comfortable with either of those? we are certainly not comfortable with shooting them, because no farmer wants to shoot anything. we are in the business of trying to produce good food for people to consume. but exporting calves at the age of two weeks old, is that something we are comfortable with?
10:37 am
i don't think we are particularly comfortable with it. it certainly would be the bottom of our list of wants for what we do with those calves. but if we come down to the point where it is that or shooting them, then it is marginally better. it doesn't sound like much of a choice. but if i am to understand the favoured option of export better, then i'm going to have to get closer to the trade itself. all i've got to go on is the journey logs. they show that animals travel on the same boat every two weeks, mainly to spain, but also to italy. i start to watch the port of cairnryan and the roads around it. there is the occasional brief glimpse of dairy calves in trucks. 0ne haulier i notice fits the exact pattern of the journey logs. that's the second time i've seen this truck.
10:38 am
the first time two weeks ago. tonight's the second. so, i'm going to try and follow that truck. two weeks later, i pick it up on the road to the port. this truck is loaded with scottish dairy calves bound for spain. immediately the boat arrives, the truck and its cattle head to an inspection point in larne. and they seem to be checking the cattle. that's the truck leaving now. the journey logs tell me the truck is headed for
10:39 am
one of two control points. a place where calves can be unloaded, fed and rested, but in the dark countryside, it's difficult to follow without being spotted, so i pull back. and the truck disappears into the darkness. um, we've lost the truck, which is not ideal. trying to keep an eye on a control post for 31 hours was very difficult. but we know according to the paperwork where it is due to arrive next, and that's france. it's 10:15am on sunday morning and i'm at the port or cherbourg, in france, and the boat which left the port yesterday is just pulling into the dock.
10:40 am
i'm hoping my truck is going to be on this boat. within minutes of arriving, truck after truck carrying livestock roll off the boat. i am beginning to get a sense of the scale of the trade. since january this year, more than 100,000 cattle have been shipped to mainland europe from ireland. a lot of them to be reared until ready for slaughter, a process called fattening. my truck isn't on this boat. i'm going to have to head into the control post in the hope that they arrive. that's not a cattle truck... suddenly, here it is. the last livestock truck to come off the ferry. the crossing took 17 hours.
10:41 am
the animals weren't unloaded and spent all that time inside the lorry. and they're straight into an overland crossing. 0h, we've got the truck. we've got the truck. 0h! after several hours on the road, the truck pulls into a service station. by law, the driver gets a break of at least 45 minutes every four and a half hours. the animals don't. they're left in the truck, in the heat of the afternoon sun. finally, we get a chance to see what's inside the truck. but there's a surprise. these aren't the calves i know were on board when this truck left for scotland. these animals are older.
10:42 am
but this truck is clearly a key link in the export chain. so i decide to see where they end up. the driver returns from his break and checks the animals. he spots something wrong with one of the cattle. and then does this. he takes a long stick from underneath the truck and then repeatedly pushes it through the bars. as we head further south through france, the temperature rises. the truck is specially adapted to keep the animals cool. legally the temperature in the lorry shouldn't exceed 30 degrees. we know it's that hot outside.
10:43 am
the truck keeps going. near the swiss border, the truck pulls off the route and into an anonymous facility in an industrial site. it parks up and unloads the cattle into sheds, which is just as well. they have been in the lorry for 29—and—a—half hours. the legal maximum is 30. over the next 2a hours, the animals are rested off the truck. that's a legal requirement. this facility is a control point, like the ones i didn't get a chance to see in northern ireland. i keep watch. when they're loaded back into the truck the next evening, there is a worrying sight. the pole is out again and this
10:44 am
time it is clear as day. i watch as the driver repeatedly hits the cattle, forcing them back into the lorry they spent the majority of the last few days in. it is now our fifth night on the road. the driver continues to make the stops he's meant to. as dawn breaks, we are as far east as milan. as we near venice, the truck turns off the main road. previous journey logs have shown calves and other cattle being transported to northern italy from scotland.
10:45 am
finally, six days after starting out, our truck comes to a stop. i don't know if you can see, but our truck is just reversing itself into position to offload the animals. that was the most stressful journey i think i've ever done. and i can only assume this is the final destination because i cannot see how those animals can do any more. and they won't have to. this is their final destination. when i contact the hauliers, they don't want to be interviewed, but they confirm that when the truck left scotland it was carrying calves. they were dropped off somewhere in northern ireland to be shipped on to spain.
10:46 am
the animals we saw, from cherbourg onwards, were picked up in southern ireland, and taken to italy, eitherfor breeding or fattening and slaughter. the company also said the driver used a stick both to ensure the cattle were standing and fit for thejourney, and to protect himself when moving large animals. back home in scotland, i show our footage to someone who has spent more than 20 years highlighting abuses in the export trade. i think as soon as you see people prodding animals with sticks through the slats, that is worrying. that bothers you? yes. it looks like he's notjust prodding but hitting the animal, and that is totally unacceptable. one of peter stevenson's
10:47 am
frustrations is that scottish calves like the ones i have seen face export. calves born in england don't. the uk government is considering banning all export for fattening and slaughter. the scottish government isn't, saying shipping is better than shooting. i think that scotland's reputation for good welfare is being undermined by the scottish government's clumsy attempt to justify this inhumane trade. scotland's position on calf export means the animals will keep on coming here to spain. the journey logs say calves are arriving in catalonia and, according to the paperwork, this is where they're shipped to, a control post run by a company called vilotta. the owner will not be interviewed but is happy to take a call from me. the cattle from scotland that arrives here, or at vilotta,
10:48 am
what is happening to those cattle? it is for fattening? all of them? thank you for your time, i appreciate that. so, all of the cattle from scotland are coming here for fattening and fattening only, he says, before slaughter. the age they are when they arrive here is three weeks of age. spain has a huge agricultural economy, yet it doesn't have enough beef. we have too much. but why must the animals be brought here alive? i travelled to madrid to meet the man who tells me the answer is in the profits to be made along the supply chain. what happens is that we have economic interests in the middle. we have the meat industry, we have transport companies, we have importers and we have exporters.
10:49 am
and everyone is taking money in this business. for animal rights campaigners like alberto diaz, any welfare abuses are bad. but the next step in the supply chain that he is telling me about isn't anything i expected. the vast majority stay in spain, in catalonia, for two months, two and a half months, and afterwards they enter the general market of cows. and in the general market is the middle east and north africa. and in my opinion that is where the real horrible animal abuse situation starts. this is what happens once the cattle leave spain. shipped to north africa, where they will be taken straight to a harbour slaughterhouse.
10:50 am
can we be 100% sure that scottish cattle end up like that? no. but can we be 100% sure that they don't end up like that? equally, no. because this is a massive part of the meat industry here in spain. is it acceptable to say, once an animal leaves our borders, once an animal leaves what we can control, it is ok? i'm not sure if i would say it is acceptable. i think it is the real world at the moment. and we would obviously prefer to be able to control everything but i think we have to be realistic. so if acceptable means,
10:51 am
do we reluctantly accept it, then the answer is yes. the south—west of scotland is key to all of this. not only is it at the heart of the dairy trade, but it also has the most vital link in the export chain — the port. ferry companies elsewhere in the uk won't carry calves for fattening and slaughter direct to the continent. so the only way to export the dairy calves is to move them via northern ireland and then south. i watched p&0 carry the animals from cairnryan to larne. yet its own policy says "we will not ship any livestock intended for fattening or slaughter." but i know the calves going to spain are destined for fattening and slaughter. when i asked p&0 about that,
10:52 am
it tells me it cooperates with the scottish government on the shipping of livestock from cairnryan to larne for onward transportation to the continent. so, p&0 say it is decisions made here at the scottish government which are driving its business. we know the government has commissioned research into animal welfare during shipments, and officials have observed them. i want to know how it views the trade and p&0's involvement in it. p&0 going against their own regulations for that, i mean, that's. .. i wouldn't know how to respond to that. they are laying it at your door. and saying they are working with us? again, i wasn't aware of their own regulations, that that was contrary to their own regulations. can you see yourself in a position where you stop this export? this export? live animal transportation
10:53 am
is something that is important for scottish agriculture, it is important for our island communities. we just need to make sure it is done as humanely as possible and that we uphold the highest possible standards in terms of animal welfare. this is a financial decision for you? it's not as straightforward as that. it's a case of looking at all the information that comes forward and also trying to balance that with our rural communities and agriculture in scotland, because that is vitally important as well. the scottish government says it will take note of any changes in england, but currently the options for calves here remain — shoot them or ship them. but deep in the galloway countryside, another option is taking shape. back on david findlay‘s farm, he is trying to break the mould. you can see coming up behind are the calves. the calves are still with their mothers.
10:54 am
this is nearly five months after calving. and these are dairy cows. so, that is almost unique. this experiment of keeping calves and their mothers together means both less milk and immediate profit for the farmer. they are keeping the milk that they can hold onto for the calf. you have to sit there, presumably, and do that mathematical equation and say, ok, i'm not getting the milk but further down the line... i have to trust in the numbers. and those numbers are based on these calves. when they are 18 months or so, they will go for slaughter, and david findlay will have income from the sale to compensate for what he has lost in milk, and the calves will have lived with their mums until they‘ re weaned. it has already got the attention of the wider industry. if we can make it profitable at current prices, then the question then becomes the one which we are really aiming for,
10:55 am
which is, and it is the one the industry doesn't want to hear, which is, ok, if you can do it... i know, the policymakers won't change anything, the supermarkets won't change anything, nobody will change anything because it is working for them just now. the only thing that will change is public perception and if public perception is changed sufficiently, then the rest will follow. milk means calves. but consumers potentially do have power over what happens to the ones the industry doesn't need. calves born on this farm will have 18 months with their mums before slaughter. calves born elsewhere won't. and there is a massive world of difference. the question i am asking is, are we comfortable with that difference? it still farming.
10:56 am
the end result is still the same. the cattle will go to slaughter. but the journey to get there is just worlds apart. the day after this programme was first broadcast, p&0 ferries said it would cease transporting young calves across the irish sea, destined for continental europe, with immediate effect. hello there. it looks like we will continue with a north—south divide. we had some rain overnight spilling down from scotland and northern ireland and its across the lake district at the moment, very intense
10:57 am
but starting to weaken as it pushes south and east, so it will become light and patchy as it moves into the midlands, down through wales and south—west england but perhaps not arriving in the south—east for much of the day, here we will keep some sunny spells and could see some warmth on sunday afternoon, even after the rain clears we will see some sunshine by the end of the afternoon, breezy in scotland and northern ireland. we could see 2a degrees in the south—east if we keep some sun. 0vernight tonight that dying frontal system moves south—east, a band of cloud by then but it will act like a blanket and prevent temperatures falling too far, prevent temperatures falling too fa r, lows of prevent temperatures falling too far, lows of 16 or 17 degrees so i'll start across the board for monday and monday will start quietly but you can see we have our flight
10:58 am
in the ointment, this is the re m na nts of in the ointment, this is the remnants of ex—hurricane helene, which will eventually bring some windy and wet weather that for many on monday, in sheltered eastern areas it will stay dry and bright. cloud increasing and when strengthening especially by the end of the afternoon, stronger winds in scotland, still quite mild but again highest values of 24. monday night into tuesday, potentially wednesday as well, low pressure will move into the north, isobars squeezing together so winds are likely to stay at gale force, maybe severe gales unexposed north west coasts but still coming up from the south—west so still coming up from the south—west so it's still tropical air maxton and that means the south—east, which may escape the worst of the rain, is likely to keep that humid feel, elsewhere it looks like it will be wet and windy, so to summarise,
10:59 am
u nsettled wet and windy, so to summarise, unsettled for the next few days, increasingly windy, rain for most in the north and west and in the south—east if we escape the worst it will still stay quite warm. this is bbc news i'm rachel schofield. the headlines at 11: theresa may defends her brexit plan, as the prime minister hits out at speculation over her future. this is where i get a little bit irritated. this is not — this debate is not about my future. this debate is about the future of the people of the uk and the furture of the united kingdom. the mayor of london, sadiq khan, calls for a second eu referendum — as he attacks the government's handling of brexit. at least 30 people are killed in flooding and landslides in the philippines, as typhoon mangkhut approaches hong kong. the big problem, although not so much in evidence around here, is smashed windows, smashed glass. we've seen lots of this stuff flying around, and that is really dangerous to try to deal with.
11:00 am
43 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC News Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on