Skip to main content

tv   Victoria Derbyshire  BBC News  April 6, 2019 4:30pm-5:00pm BST

4:30 pm
this is bbc news i'm lukewsa burak. the headlines at 5pm. but labour says it's disappointed that no compromise has been offered. the chancellor insists the defence secretary expresses the government has no red lines in talks over brexit. horror at an alleged sexual assault of a 17—year—old female recruit but labour says it's disappointed by six male soldiers and orders an investigation. that no compromise has been offered. border force officials confiscate medicinal cannabis used by teagan appleby after her mother the key priority is to avoid crashing out with the eu with no purchased it from the netherlands. deal because of the disruption that the developer persimmon has would mean to industry and to the announced an independent review supply chains, and we are determined into its housing quality to make sure there's no crashing out without a deal. after increasing concerns about the defence secretary expresses horror at an alleged sexual assault of a 17—year—old female recruit by six male soldiers the standard of its new builds. and orders an investigation. human rights protesters the developer persimmon has at london's dorchester hotel, announced an independent review owned by brunei where a new law into its housing quality after increasing concerns about makes gay sex punishable by stoning to death. the standard of its new builds. a woman who —— a woman who -- tried to bring and now on bbc news, victoria derbyshire takes a look back at some of the highlights from her programme this week. hello and welcome to our programme.
4:31 pm
over the next half an hour we will review some of the exclusive and originaljournalism we have broadcast over the last week. we are powerless and have to sit back and watch her suffer. it is torture for her and for us. those are the words ofjudy haynes, her granddaughter ayla had learning difficulties. and has been held in secure units known as atus for seven years. in her desperation, ayla swallowed a toothbrush which is still inside her. four years ago, the government and nhs england said it would close at least 35% of the places at atus by the end of march this year and provide alternative care in the community instead. but the department of health have missed their own deadline and now pushed it back. our reporter has been to meet the parents of young people living in atus.
4:32 pm
she's my only child. she is everything to me. she is my life. it is just unbelievable. i am living a nightmare. at age 19 ayla haines was admitted to an assessment and treatment unit, or atu, after struggling with anorexia and other mental health illnesses. her life consists of spending her days from 7:30am in the morning until 9:30pm at night in one room. she hasn't been out of that ward for the past year apart from once, and apart from hospital visits. we haven't been able to see her for the past year. we were only an allowed three ten—minute phone calls a week. ayla has spent the last seven years in psychiatric hospitals. she is currently at a medium secure
4:33 pm
unit 200 miles away from her home on the outskirts of cardiff. her mum says her prolonged stay has had a detrimental effect on her health. she's got a huge bald patch on her head now where her hair will never grow just from all the head—banging that she's done. and that's irreversible. one of the doctors said possibly she is caused more one of the doctors said possibly she's caused more brain damage through the head—banging. so i don't know. i don't see a happy ending, really. she loved dressing up in the village carnival. she's dressed up as a dalmatian. are you worried you might never see her again? yes, very much so. i'm 78 years of age and i've got a heart condition and it's distressing, not only for me, but having
4:34 pm
to watch ayla suffer and watch my daughter suffer. and being powerless to do anything about it. i've tried for seven years and written to so many people for help. and it'sjust not there. there are nearly 2,300 adults and children with autism and learning disabilities living in assessment and treatment units across the country. there was a systemic failure to protect the vulnerable residents who lived here at winterbourne view. time and again, concerns are being raised about the way in which patients are restrained. atus came under increasing scrutiny in 2011 after the bbc exposed the horrific abuse of patients at a residential hospital winterbourne view. the panorama programme led to the government promising to shut down all similar units. the government and nhs promised to close many of these beds. people are spending many, many years in there. they shouldn't be. awful things are happening to people in there and they shouldn't be. in the same way that asylums were closed,
4:35 pm
these places need to be closed, and people need to be supported in the community. people are supposed to be admitted in atus for 9—18 months but nhs figures show the average length of stay is more than five years. having her away from home is obviously very difficult. but why are you so worried? she is so desperate to end it all really. she has a toothbrush inside her because she swallowed a toothbrush. an actual toothbrush? an actual toothbrush. you couldn't imagine this happening to anyone. it is your worst nightmare. e—mails shown to us appear to confirm the incident, a senior social worker at the secure unit told the family injune 2018. nearly ten months on and you believe the toothbrush
4:36 pm
is still stuck inside her? it is still stuck inside her. they said it would pass naturally but that hasn't happened. there is a possibility that it could cause serious damage. we are powerless and have to sit back and watch ayla suffer and it's torture. it's torture for her and it's torture for us. the hospital where ayla is staying has told us they are closely regulated and often visited by the care quality commission. in 2015, the government set a target to move between 35—50% of people with learning disabilities and autism out of inpatient units and into the community. it was called transforming care but the programme has missed its own five—year deadline only achieving around 20% and leaving 2,000 people on psychiatric wards.
4:37 pm
so, today, we are going to see jade and i'm really looking forward to it. we haven't seen her for a couple of weeks. linda and chris are making a two—hour journey from birmingham to nottinghamshire to visit their 27—year—old daughter. before she went into a psychiatric hospital, even when she was ill before she went into a psychiatric hospital she was very, very different, she was vivacious, she was lively, she could engage in long conversations with her peers and with us, etc etc. but since she has been ill that has all disappeared. at age 1a jade hutchings started self harming, which led to her parents being advised that she had to be sectioned. she is currently at a medium secure unit in the east midlands. i wake up in the middle of the night and i'm crying. i'm just crying because i'm so sad. jade is the last thing i think of at night and the first thing i think of in the morning.
4:38 pm
there is no, in a sense, peace in your mind because you're always coming to terms with what's happened to your daughter. jade's not a danger to anyone, never has been. i mean, can you even envisage another situation where a human being is locked up under presumption human being is locked up under presumption of guilt, yeah, on what they might do to themselves or to others? can you imagine a court that would accept that? but it seems to me mentally ill people lose that right, you lose that basic human right to be free. 13 years on, jade's parents are unsure as to when she will return home. they say in a previous psychiatric hospital she was locked in a secluded attic room for hours. in one of the hospitals thatjade was in she was actually locked in a room for nine weeks and it was so awful for her because there was nothing in the room apart from a telly on a high bracket on the wall.
4:39 pm
nothing for her to do. she wore rubber clothes, nothing on the bed, not even a sheet. it was just awful. and we had to go there and it was heartbreaking. jade's family say she is still being held because the authorities believe she poses a risk to herself. birmingham city council, who are responsible for her care, told us it can't comment on her case for reasons of patient confidentiality. well, atus are like the old bedlam institutions in victorian times. labour's shadow care minister says the government has allowed private companies to make millions of pounds by treating nhs patients in psychiatric units that failed to provide suitable care. there have been a0 deaths in these units since 2015 and nine of those were deaths of people under 35. the government must recommit itself and re—pledge to close these placements down. there is even a question of why
4:40 pm
paying five times, for instance, the amount it would cost to have a community placement, is good value for money. it just isn't. this is public money, taxpayers' money. in response, the department of health has told us in a statement: # sitting on the dock of a bay # watching the tide... with the right support outside of inpatient units it is possible to change people's lives. this girl spent 22 months at a secure unit in the east midlands where her family says
4:41 pm
she was repeatedly restrained by staff. it was a very hopeless place. even i'm a child psychiatrist, i couldn't access the right support, i couldn't have a meaningful dialogue with the expert team that were looking after her. i'm aware of so many families that haven't been as lucky, and i live in fear that she may end up back in a place like that. so i do think we won the lottery in a way in the support that we got and the care that she has at the moment. if you've been affected by any of the issues in that report and want some advice, go to the action line. the so—called independent group, that's the 11 mp5, three former conservatives and eight former labour mps who have broken from their party to campaign for a second referendum have chosen heidi allen, the former tory mp who's been in parliament for only four years, as their leader. they've also started the process of registering as a political party to be called change uk,
4:42 pm
which would mean they'd be able to field candidates in elections. i've been talking to heidi allen. let me ask you about things like benefits and so on, so we get an idea about your principles and politics, because you have only been an mp since 2015. is that why you are the leader, because you haven't got much baggage? it is a variety of reasons. as a group of 11, we sat down a decision because forming a party going to the electoral commission, you need a leader. it is about who has the skills to bring people together. i have always worked across party and as apolitically as i could and given the reason we need these new politics is that all the existing structures have failed us, a kind of middle—of—the—road person who worked in business, industry, they are the candidates we want to attract. and with not much political baggage. no skeletons, i hope. are there any skeletons? i don't think so, i am quite a boring person really! should income tax be higher for the highest earners? i want a sweet spot where it
4:43 pm
covers public services and nhs and education. does that mean it goes up? potentially, it could. it was cut by george osborne from 50 to 45%. what could it go up to? i will not put a figure on it, everything we do has to be evidence—based so i would look at the statistics. have you ever taken drug stronger than cannabis? i have never even had a cigarette. should railways be renationalised? i don't think that would get the best service. do you think section 60 powers to tackle knife crime should be authorised or can be authorised by a less senior officer? i think that is a question for the people who know far better than i, which is the police office but far too often in policy areas, politicians get in a way of experts doing theirjob. should shamima begum have been allowed back to the uk? i think we acted too quickly,
4:44 pm
or possibly even illegally, for the home secretary suggested she shouldn't come back. there was a vulnerable woman there. so, yes? we should have been allowed to talk to her and look after her and see if there was a risk still to the uk. next, the world health organization says that the so—called anti—vaxx movement, that's people who reject the science behind vaccinations, is one of the top ten global health threat facing the world this year. in the uk, a growing number of parents are confused about whether to vaccinate their children. many who decide not to are influenced by misleading and inaccurate anti—vaxx material on social media and various websites. so, we took one couple, mark and victoria who were expecting a baby and were planning not to vaccinate that baby, to meet the experts. so there's a little leg. can you see the leg? going to be a footballer. yeah. like many expectant parents, mark and victoria will soon face important decisions about the health of their newborn baby.
4:45 pm
it's a beautiful top lip there. top lip, nostrils. currently, the nhs recommends babies have six vaccinations in the first two years of life, to protect them from 1a diseases such as measles, diphtheria and polio. so it is mostly the internet that we do get our information from. and it's a question of breaking it down. not necessarily asking the question but asking yourself the question — what chemical element's in this vaccine? and then go into that chemical element and find out about that. mark and victoria aren't sure they want to vaccinate their baby. they think the nhs is too quick to offer vaccinations and don't explain any potential risks. they've also been researching the ingredients in some vaccines and they're worried. we're still looking but we are swaying towards not getting the baby vaccinated. on what we know at the moment. on what we know.
4:46 pm
so we've arranged for them to meet drjulian spinks of court view medical practice in rochester to find out more about the immunisation process. first, mark wants to know why there isn't more detailed information in leaflets about vaccines in doctors' surgeries. we can see plenty of space being made for glossy posters saying you should get the flu vaccine, you should get this, you should get that. but there's no facts backing it up. i feel that people always can have more information and, from my point of view, if people ask for more information, i'll try and provide it. and one of the difficulties is that a lot of the anti—vaccination sites will raise very obscure things which it would be impossible to cover in a short leaflet. one of the problems that scientists face is that we tend to use very dry statistics involving large numbers of people. it's difficult to relate to that as an individual person. and often when you find people who are against something, what they do is they personalise it. they say, you know, that person was damaged by it and whatever. what they don't say is the enormous number of people who actually benefit from a treatment, whether it's vaccination
4:47 pm
or something else without any harm coming along. butjust because the poster's there doesn't mean we won't answer questions. the couple also wondered why it wasn't made clear to them that vaccination is optional when their older children were immunised. i would never make out it's compulsory. i would always say it is a voluntary thing. yes, i would very strongly recommend it. but, at the same time, it ultimately is the parents' choice. but i do have concerns because i do believe immunisation protects and it's protecting your child and it's also protecting the children around them, because of this thing of actually suppressing spread of the virus from one child to another. doctors' surgeries are paid by the government per vaccination. and mark and victoria want to know why that is. we've heard some stories about parents saying that, you know, they've chosen not to have their child vaccinated. in some cases, it's involved sort of, you know, social services, or the threat of. so we're just wondering whether gps
4:48 pm
are pressurised to meet targets for financial gain. well, we do have some targets. however, actually, the money involved with vaccination is relatively small. the amount of money we get for a vaccine is about £10. by the time you've covered the costs we have, which is recalling people and paying for nurses and buildings and so on, well over half of that is gone. so, actually, realistically, it's a very small amount of money we get and certainly way short of something that would actually make me want to do something which was putting children in harm's way. most doctors are incredibly ethical about the way they work and i would fundamentally disagree with practices who threaten parents over not immunising. but i have heard, for example, in some cases where children have safeguarding issues, they will look and see whether vaccinations are happening and that's not particularly because of parental choice. it tends to be that parents who just don't get round to vaccinating their children might be a marker that there's a problem in the family. next, mark and victoria
4:49 pm
want to find out more about what's in vaccines, so they're meeting professor beate kampmann, director of the vaccine centre at the london school of hygiene and tropical medicine. i will start off byjust asking, um, why do you think it is acceptable to inject aluminium into a baby when it is being banned in such things as aerosols? alum is a very, very important part of the vaccines, because it actually helps the stuff that's really important in the vaccines, which is the bacterial viral ingredients, to work well in the body. now, you make it sound as if we're giving a massive shot of aluminium to the body. so that's not at all the case. so the concentration of aluminium in it is like a thousandth of what you find in natural environments and what we already have in our bodies as well. and it is actually ingested by the body, probably even in the water in our cups of tea, and it's excreted with a poo. so it doesn't hang around in the body as such and, so far, there's been no evidence that it actually accumulates and causes any sort of long—term damage.
4:50 pm
the information leaflets in vaccine packaging is something mark and victoria want to find out more about. inserts for vaccines are not always offered prior to injections for parents to read. the ones that we have obtained state that they should not be administered if you are allergic to any of the ingredients. but how do we know if the baby is allergic or not? the most important ingredient in that is usually egg. sometimes, some vaccines — for example, the mmr vaccine has traces of that — by the time the baby gets that particular vaccine, you would know if they were allergic to egg or not because they would have had egg in all sorts of products. but what about younger babies? there's no egg components in the other vaccines that they're getting. i think what is important also is that, on the inserts, they have to list not just what's in the vaccine now, but also what was part of the vaccine when it was manufactured and it's not necessarily differentiated in the insert, so you get a whole bunch of stuff that is actually mentioned. but hardly any of it will be
4:51 pm
in the final product. assuming we were to go ahead and have our child vaccinated, it would then have its tetanus, polio, diphtheria. so why, when the whooping cough vaccine is offered to pregnant women, they are not then told that it has tetanus, diphtheria and polio within it as well? i think it's part of the conversation, that people should know exactly what vaccines they are having. i think the reason why it was done like that is because usually the adults don't go back for their tetanus vaccination. usually nobody bothers with diphtheria because everybody thinks it's no longer an issue. however, we've had large outbreaks in a refugee camp in bangladesh, as you've probably heard, from last year. there's lots of diphtheria in russia, so it's a disease that might come back to us. so that's quite a good idea. and then the third one is that the vaccine is already made in this combination. so it's more of an effort to make a vaccine that only has a pertussis component because you would literally make that vaccine just for the pregnancy. i also think that the whole issue
4:52 pm
of knowledge about vaccines between health care professionals, doctors and nurses is not good. i'm glad you've said that. yeah, it's not good. i'm glad you've recognised that. but, you know, if you ask the nurse who's giving the vaccines in the surgery what is exactly in that vaccine, he or she will not be able to tell you. that is exactly our point, i'm glad you've said that. and it's not good enough. thanks very much. so how are mark and victoria feeling? thank you. one thing that surprised me from today is actually how, you know, especially one of the experts was actually quite open in the fact that they don't feel that there's enough information out there for parents to make an informed decision. i think that's the big thing for me. yeah, yeah, absolutely, absolutely. it's nice to have somebody in a professional role that actually, you know, agrees with something you're saying rather than trying to argue. he sleeps like me! we was leaning towards not getting the baby vaccinated, but now we've had this information today, i think we're dead down the middle now. hopefully — well, it'll have to be soon — we will be making a decision.
4:53 pm
in the 1990s, cool britannia was flying high and meg matthews was one of the brand's biggest ambassadors with her then husband noel gallagher. but the former music pr is now campaigning for better awareness around the menopause. she says when the menopause first started for her, she had no idea what had hit her. she's since set up a website aiming to provide information and support for women going through it. what is the menopause? it is a period when your periods stop. i would like to say there is a perimenopausal, menopausal and postmenopausal. postmenopausal is when you haven't had a period for exactly 12 months. menopause is when you have irregular periods and perimenopausal can start in your 30s for some women, one in thousand in your 405, so that's when your hormones are all over the place, you're not feeling quite right, you have wobbly days, you feel depressed, just
4:54 pm
out of sorts. that's why i think people do not know because for me, the menopause was just the menopause. a hot flash and no periods. i had no knowledge of perimenopausal, menopause, postmenopausal. what are you experiencing? what symptoms of menopause where you experiencing? my symptoms were really bad anxiety, couldn't leave the house. really? mine were more mental symptoms. more about my mental state of mind. people say i'm having a middle—aged crisis, that's what it felt like. nothing about the menopause, i haven't had a hot flush, ok. i had the mirena coil, i didn't know i was having periods. you spot when you have a coil so you don't know, it's only when my partner pointed out to me,
4:55 pm
you haven't had a period for six months. i was like, really? all the other symptoms i was going through, there are 3a of them and i have to say i probably had 2a of them. there was a lot of those so that's why i want women to go to my website and if you're feeling out of sorts and something is not quite right, it's probably down to your hormones. lack of oestrogen makes you go crazy. you don't sleep properly. dry mouth syndrome. foggy brain. aching joints. your breasts get bigger. you feel nauseous. you get terrible migraines. everything you don't want to have you can have. you were actually in an aa meeting because you are a recovering alcoholic and someone came up to and said i think you're going to the menopause. yes, i was in a meeting and that's
4:56 pm
why ijust love them so much because i shared in this meeting how you are feeling that day, and ijust said everything how i was feeling that day and when i left this lovely lady stopped me and she just said you know what, i think you have start of the menopause and i was like, really? everything you shared, anxious, anxiety, not sleeping, putting on weight, all these things... this was a fellow recoverer? yes, and i wasjust letting out how my day was, so this lady helped me and she said go and get tested. so i did and i went to the nhs. and then... another thing she told me, there is clinics. 27 in the uk. a few in london. nhs? really? i've never heard of them.
4:57 pm
that's why i'm telling everyone! this lady in my meeting who pointed this out to me, and i went to my gp and i said i would like to go to the menopause clinic and they said, oh... you have to refer me. there you go. that's it for this week. and you can contact us at any time with your stories, e—mail us. and you can see more from our programme online. bbc.co.uk/victoria. we are back live monday morning, ten o'clock, bbc two and bbc news channel and online. thanks for watching. j°y joy across scotland overnight, pockets of rain and drizzle. there could be a few spots of rain pushing
4:58 pm
in the north sea and a few showers clipping the south—west. should not be as as last night, cloud around and temperatures six or 7 degrees. we start the second half of the weekend on a cloudy note, drizzle in scotla nd weekend on a cloudy note, drizzle in scotland particularly in the morning. we should see some brightening and sunshine developing elsewhere. we are also going to develop a few heavy showers heading into eastern parts of the uk and the midlands. the small risk of thunderstorm. warmer across england and wales, 15 to 17 degrees, chilly for much of scotland and north—east england.
4:59 pm
5:00 pm

48 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on