this is bbc news. the headlines... a royal source tells the bbc that david cameron's remarks about seeking the queen's support today at 5:00... displeasure at buckingham palace in the scottish independence vote after david cameron reveals have caused "displeasure" he sought the queen's help ahead at buckingham palace. of the scottish independence referendum. judges at the supreme court will rule early next week on whether borisjohnson's decision to suspend parliament in the run—up to brexit was lawful. the former prime minister told the bbc he suggested her majesty "raise an eyebrow" about the prospect of scotland the death of pc andrew harper. voting for independence. prosecutors drop a murder charge against a 20—year—old. three teenagers appear in court not asking for anything that would be in any way improper or unconstitutional, charged with murder. butjust a raising of the eyebrow. the queen then urged people to "think carefully about the future". its 6am on thursday the 19th of september. the other main stories and coming up, john humphrys on bbc news at 5:00... has presented his final on whether borisjohnson‘s decision edition of radio 4's today to suspend parliament in the run—up programme after 32 years. to brexit was lawful.

let's catch up on all the support and we are joined as we have heard, it is not a simple let's catch up on all the support and we arejoined by let's catch up on all the support and we are joined by gavin. afternoon. after two noon to you as question and we will now consider well. former newcastle united and england carefully all the arguments forward peter beardsley has been suspended from all football—related activity for 32 weeks for making presented to us. the government's racist comments to players. beardsley left newcastle lawyer once the supreme court after a 14—month club justice not to stray in what he investigation earlier this year. he called one black player calls forbidden territory and a "a monkey" while newcastle's under—23s coach, and joked political minefield. about climbing trees. an independent football association the death of pc andrew harper — panel said his remarks "were obviously racist prosecutors drop a murder charge and wholly unacceptable". against a 20—year—old man — beardsley said he was "surprised and disappointed" by three teenagers appear in court the panel's findings. charged with murder. he's been ordered to complete a face—to—face education course. the rugby world cup gets underway tomorrow. it's six o'clock on thursday japan play russia in the opener 19th september... at 11.45 in the morning. and coming up —john humphrys has presented his final all the home nations are in action edition of radio 4's today in the first few days. england start their tournament on sunday. they play tonga in sapporo right programme after 32 years. in the north ofjapan, and they've held their first training session there this morning. mark wilson and joe thockanasiga are both back in full training and eddiejones names his side it's 5:00 — our main for that opener tomorrow.

story is that a source at buckingham palace has told new zealand start the defence the bbc there is an "amount of displeasure" at david cameron's of their title against south africa admission that he actively sought and things have got a little heated to involve the queen in the scottish independence referendum. between the coaches. she later said people should "think very carefully about the future". the snp leader, nicola sturgeon, said mr cameron's revelation steve hansen says that the springbok‘s rassie erasmus has demonstrated "the panic in the heart been trying to put pressure on the refereejerome garces of the uk government" ahead the frenchman has refereed five of these fixtures, of the referendum five years ago. including the 2015 world cup semi—final, with the all blacks winning every one. our political correspondent erasmus says that officials have historically favoured the all blacks. helen catt reports. arsenal will rest mesut 0zil for their europa league match it was a referendum at eintracht frankfurt which kicks david cameron won. off at 5.55 this evening. in 2014, scotland rejected 0zil has played just over an hour independence but the former prime minister wasn't always of football this season, confident it would be victory making his first start he was staring in the face, in sunday's draw at watford. and he's now revealed that when the no campaign started trailing in the polls he turned targetted by car—jackers. to the queen for help. there are five british teams i remember conversations i had in the europa league. scottish champions celtic are at rennes, there's with my private secretary and i had the arsenal fixture. wolves came through six

matches in qualifying with my private secretary and he had to reach the group stage, they start against braga. manchester united against astana with the queen's private secretary, is the first competitive match not asking for anything that between an english and kazakh side. would be in any way improper or unconstitutional, rangers play feyenoord. butjust a raising of the eyebrow, even a quarter of an inch, would make a difference. europe's solheim cup winning captain shortly afterwards, the queen told catriona matthew says golf‘s well—wishers in aberdeenshire governing bodies need to do more she hoped people would think very to combat slow play. carefully about the future, team europe beat the usa a comment widely reported and taken by the finest of margins at gleneagles but there's been to show concern for the union. criticism over the pace at the scottish parliament this of play, with some rounds morning, the first minister at the weekend lasting six hours. addressed the admission. rory mcilroy was amongst the critics, saying he found it hard i think the revelations, to not get frustrated. if i can call them that, from david cameron today say more about him than they do anybody else. slow play is a problem in men's and really demonstrate, i think, the panic that was in the heart and lady's golf but i think really, of the uk government in the run—up i am a quick player so it to the independence frustrates me no end. referendum five years ago. the only solution is for the referees to stamp down on it, the palace has not commented they have to start giving out a few on david cameron's remarks, but a source there has told the bbc there is "an amount of displeasure". penalties and players will speed up. by convention, the queen is kept out of politics and conversations with her private, but david cameron does have form.

speaking after the same referendum in 2014, he was overheard saying meanwhile, mcilory is four over par the queen had purred down the line on the first day of the pga championship at wentworth. when he spoke to her englishman matt wallace leads the way. he finished seven under par, about the result. a shot clear of henrik stenson. robert kubica is going to leave the williams formula 1 team he said that was a mistake at the end of the season. he only returned to f1 for which he had apologised, full—time this year, eight years after he was almost and said perhaps he'd already killed in a rally crash. the pole has secured the team's only point this season, said too much. as they prop up the constructors championship. that's all the sport for now. you can find more on all those boris johnson might have appreciated him saying a bit less, stories on the bbc sport website. specifically when speaking that's bbc.co.uk/sport. about his motivations we will see you a bit later on. thanks gavin, look forward to it. during the eu referendum campaign. more now on the supreme court in the end, ultimately, hearing wherejudges i think he put what was good will rule early next week for his political career ahead on whether borisjohnson's decision of what he actually thought to suspend parliament in the run up was right for the country. to brexit was lawful. not a charge mr cameron ben brown is in westminsterfor us. would accept about himself. he maintains his decision to hold the eu referendum was the correct with more on the hearings. the 11 thing to do but some of his former colleagues disagree. we started a series of meetings supreme court justices with more on the hearings. the 11 supreme courtjustices are now about whether to offer considering the judgement. supreme courtjustices are now considering thejudgement. it is supreme courtjustices are now considering the judgement. it is a judgement they know will have huge a referendum on europe,

and i was against because i thought implications for the prime minister and the government but also for this it would split the conservative party and put business offside, having done so much work country's unwritten constitution and to get them on side, the balance of powers between the and fundamentally we might courts and the government and lose the referendum. parliament. lady hale presiding if he follows convention, interventions like this are likely to be reasonably rare judge said that "none of this is from david cameron but what he said this week may have already added easy" and they will reach their decision as soon as human a more upheaval in turbulent times. possible. this is what she had to say at the end of three days hearings. i must repeat that this case is not about when and on what terms the helen catt, bbc news, westminster. united kingdom leaves the european union. the result of this case will not determine that. we are solely concerned in a moment we can get with the lawfulness of the the view from westminster prime minister's decision with our chief political correspondent, vicki young, to advise her majesty to prorogue but first our royal correspondent, nicholas witchell is outside parliament on the date in question. buckingham palace for us. as we have heard, it is not how unusual a reaction from the a simple question. palace is that? it is unusual and i and we will now consider carefully think from this pleasure we can read all the arguments which have been presented to us. it was a sharp displeasure and this comes from the queen herself. they but we also know that this case must be resolved as will not use that word without quickly as possible, reflecting her thoughts. i would and we hope to be able to publish our decision imagine she feels pretty let down by

david cameron. however, we should early next week. thank you, again, one and all. not assume david cameron was the the court is now adjourned. sole instigator of putting the whole thank you. idea into the head of the queen that she might say something. we know she president of the court and one of ca res she might say something. we know she cares deeply about the country of the 11 supreme court justices which he is head of state. this is president of the court and one of the 11 supreme courtjustices who are now considering thatjudgement. the only subject she has made a semi let's chew over what they will be political speech in 1979 when she trying to decide now for some we have two legal experts. told the house of commons that she here with me now is drjoelle grogan, a senior lecturer was crowned queen of the united at middlesex university, and i'm alsojoined by professor kingdom. younger members of the jeff king, legal adviser for the house of lords constitution royalfamily at kingdom. younger members of the royal family at the time of the constitution committee. scottish referendum were also expressing unease and wondered if there were some way in which their feelings might be registered. david —— constitutional affairs committee. first of all to you jeff king. the cameron comes along and says what he judges were worn today by the said. that might have been government's moyer not to stray into significant or decisive in persuading the queen that it was ok to say something. we have this what he called "forbidden territory and typical minefield was quote but supposedly impromptu remark which do you think they will?” was quite deliberate. 0n the face of and typical minefield was quote but do you think they will? i think that the judges will be extremely

it, the head of state urging people cautious when they decide what is a to think carefully about the future. but in the heart for the scottish justice of both question or a referendum it was taken to be think question appropriate for them to carefully about the implications of answer and will only make a legal separation. the reason they are view if the evidence so clear that displeased over there of course, this reopens what the queen said at it supports the legal finding. they the time of the scottish referendum are precisely the time she has been will steer clear of extremely broad drawn into such a highly questions and exercise some controversial, prorogation of restraint. you will probably only parliament. 0ver there, they are get a judgement on the merits if the uncomfortable about both of these evidence is credible. and joe well, things. thank you. vicki young in let's put that to you. do you think westminster, we have heard david cameron say there was nothing this is compelling for what you've heard? i will echo jeff a lot and improper in asking the queen to what he has just said. the raise an eyebrow or a quarter of an eyebrow. but what is the reaction in heard? i will echo jeff a lot and what he hasjust said. the key question, the two key questions is westminster on that? it is highly two parts which is first, the court be asked and answered this question? unusual. if you think about the and i would say they see might they relationship between the head of state, the queen and her prime have been convinced. i am also ministers. it goes back to 1952, saying that i am not a betting woman and this is not a bet. to my mind it winston churchill, the first prime seems they would append convinced minister for winston churchill, the first prime ministerfor her. winston churchill, the first prime minister for her. those weekly

audiences they always have, meeting but then convinced by the merits, in buckingham palace and it is based they may be convinced that they on discretion. you hardly ever hear could answer the legal and difficult a word coming out of those questions. but if they got to that conversations. that is what is at port of understanding —— point of the heart of that relationship, the understanding, could then have queen can give advice if you want to enough evidence of a bad motive do, she can talk about her wealth of willfully misleading for another experience over all of that time. reason or and this is the key one the other point though, as you say, for me, establishing that there is the convention is she is kept out of such a dreadful constitutional effect that it is offending those politics and in this sense, it sounds as if david cameron may be fundamental principles of democracy pushed her a little bit too into all of the parliament? back to jeff of that. he sounded as if he king. if we go on the hypothesis for regretted talking about it, because just a moment professor king that it is not the done thing for a prime actually they say this is a matter minister to talk about what the queen has said to him or her. but for them, they do say that the prime minister has acted unlawfully in the current prime minister was asked suspending parliament, what would whether he thought david cameron had put the queen in a difficult they then do, what do you think they position? not only do i not comment would lay down in a course of on conversation i may have held with action? it is incredibly difficult her majesty, but i don't comment on to tell. i can clarify what the conversation she may have had with options might be. this is about the anybody else. i just conversation she may have had with anybody else. ijust don't think i should go down that route. sometimes

question of remedies. they could snippets to emerge from the declare the ministers advice, the prime minister is advised to be conversations between politicians and the queen and it was reported unlawful, or they could quash the that when boris johnson went to see order in council and quashing it the queen for the first time as means to extinguish it means that parliament is not effectively prime minister, he came back to prorogued right now. the difficulty downing street and said to one of the advisers that she said to him, i with quashing the advice that's presented is that it puts this don't know why anybody wants this job. thank you both very much. current status of parliament and makes an uncertain and it would not i am joined now in the studio be clear whether parliament is adjourned or what status it and what by dickie arbiter, former press spokesman for the queen. before we talk about the events of mps need to do to reconvene. does the actual referendum year in 2014, the queen need to issue a let's talk about now, what do you proclamation, does the premise or make of david cameron saying these issue any advice? that is the issue things at this point? david cameron quashing the queens order which is looking for publicity to sell his create the prorogation. the thorny book because the publishers have issue presenting that the prime minister's advices unlawful is that paid a lot of money and amazon have discounted it by 30% and the it is not clear in legal doctrine publishers want their money back so weather that has the knock on effect they will use any means to get as of making the queen's order also unlawful. unlawful. — — much publicity as possible. ouch! of making the queen's order also when we are hearing from the palace, unlawful. unlawful. —— unlawful. this would create a lot of problems.

an amount of this well you know buckingham palace and it operates, joelle, if you were a betting woman, what would you say if they do go is it sharp displeasure coming down the road of saying that the prime minister has been unlawful directly from her majesty?” what follows ? prime minister has been unlawful what follows? if they say that it is is it sharp displeasure coming directly from her majesty? i do agree with him. it has gone unlawful, i think they might unwritten convention where prime exercise a degree of caution to ministers do not discuss what has been discussed with members of the declare it to be unlawful. but then royalfamily been discussed with members of the royal family and he been discussed with members of the royalfamily and he has donejust leave it probably to the executive that. not just once, royalfamily and he has donejust that. notjust once, several times. to make the next steps exactly as jeff has set, the difficulty with if you remember the results of the mandatory order is that the clearing that one or the other organs of scottish referendum, he called the queen and he claimed she purred down state, the government or even the the telephone. absolute nonsense. to queen have to do something, that suggest to a private secretary he might ask the queen to raise an ta kes queen have to do something, that takes us into very difficult eyebrow, even by a quarter of an constitutional waters. jeff king inch, it is nonsense and he is in speaking of constitutional waters, is all of this because we have an cuckoo land to even suggest that. to unwritten constitution and there is drag the cleaning totally this huge grey area and in a sense unheard—of. this comment she made perhaps it is time for the supreme going to church or at church, then court to make a judgement? you have to think carefully about the future, is a perfectly anodyne statement. you say that, but perhaps it is time for the supreme court to make ajudgement? on clarifying on what some of these

according to, and he is a former great areas are? yes. the essential prime minister, he had a conversation with her private debate amongst many scholars and secretary, he had a conversation politicians and think tanks is with her majesty and his private whether there is something virtuous secretary had a conversation with about the british constitution in which it allows those grey areas to her private secretary, you say it is cuckoo land, but obviously be resolved through portable contest or whether there is something conversations did happen. they say defective about it and that it they happen. don't you believe him? weaves so many grey to say he asked the queen to raise defective about it and that it weaves so many grey areas open and allows the executive to take advantage of the situation in every case. my own view is i tend more to an eyebrow by a quarter of an inch, isa an eyebrow by a quarter of an inch, is a bit far—fetched. if someone the latter. that's an area that is would have asked her a question and contested in politics and it will continue to be so. and joelle from she ignored it, they would have been middlesex university, if we have a screaming headlines, the queen snubs written constitution and it says parliaments can only be prorogued or the scots. she was asked about the suspended for say two weeks or three weeks, it is all way down, would referendum and it was a bland, you that make life so much simpler? this have to think about the future. the will be the great question i hope huge constitutional questions into which the queen has become embroiled for a generation of constitutional in recent days, notjust this one lawyers inspired by this. a written but the question that is currently constitution wouldn't necessarily solve these questions unless all of before the supreme court, how do you

the details were laid out. thanks to think, as somebody who knows her, both of you. and professorjeff king this impacts her sense of her own role in an unwritten and great and joelle from university college constitution? she will be feeling london. chewing over some of those very let down by her prime keyissues london. chewing over some of those key issues which the 11 supreme ministers, firstly by david cameron court justices are key issues which the 11 supreme and now boris johnson, courtjustices are going to be ministers, firstly by david cameron and now borisjohnson, dragging her into prorogue in parliament, not discussing and gathering amongst themselves although they do all have just for a week, but several weeks. ideas i am sure and we heard from some of their questions during the she will feel let down. all the three days and perhaps got clues as prime minister she has had, none of to which way they may be leaning but them have put her in this sort of they will be talking amongst position. she will get out of it themselves and trying to come up with that reticle judgement early because she is very pragmatic and she doesn't necessarily question but next week. that is the latest from here at westminster. back to you for she doesn't necessarily question but she will hope the politicians can get her out of this and get some thank you. something sensible, whether it is an providing care for people with learning disabilities a nswer to and autism is one of the many something sensible, whether it is an answer to brexit or whatever. the challenges the nhs david cameron thing will blow over, in england is facing. people will buy the book or they the government wants more people to receive treatment in the community, won't buy the book. dickie arbiter, thank you forjoining us. rather than in hospital. but the latest figures show over 2,200 people were being treated as inpatients turning to the question we were last month, despite government pledges to end such treatment. discussing with dickie, this 0ur social affairs correspondent

alison holt spoke to one family question of the second big about their experience. constitutional issue. the supreme court has this is tom. completed its hearing into whether borisjohnson acted he's now 13 years old lawfully in suspending parliament. and he is autistic. the judges have said they hope to publish their ruling next week. his experience over the last three years spells out the desperation summing up his case and failures faced by too many against the government, lord pannick said the suspension people with learning disabilities or autism. should be lifted as soon as possible. you're going to see tom this weekend. but the government's senior advocate yeah. in scotland, lord keen, said the courts should not be each weekend his mum, dad or his grandmother travel dragged into politics. from their home in shropshire my colleague ben brown to the other side of the country to see tom. he has been away from home is at westminster this afternoon. since age ten, struggling with anxiety and new medication. we should get bad judgment from the he had a crisis which local health 11 supreme court justices we should get bad judgment from the teams struggled to cope with. 11 supreme courtjustices early next week, as you say. we are assuming he was being restrained monday or tuesday. it is only the by people, basically. second time by the way, in the and we heard his screams and shouts history of the supreme court that we have had such a big panel, 11 judges and distress from the car park. considering this hugely important constitutional, legal, political question really. this is the grey it was very upsetting, wasn't it? yeah. it was. area of the unwritten constitution but again, they had to restrain tom between the grey area between that and the law and politics. lady hale, because he was so out of control

and they couldn't basically... president of the supreme court judges saying none of this is easy. the couldn't let him harm himself. they will have to wrestle over this the wall, this was my therapy, when tom was... over the next few days as to whether ..admitted to hospital. borisjohnson did over the next few days as to whether boris johnson did break over the next few days as to whether borisjohnson did break the law, acted unlawfully when he suspended in that situation, the family found 01’ acted unlawfully when he suspended or prorogued parliament for five the only place tom could go weeks. lord keen, for the was an adult mental health hospital. government, warned thejudges, don't he ended up being there for six stray into forbidden territory, months and he deteriorated. don't stray into this political he refused to use the toilet, minefield. let's get this report on he refused to wear shoes, he refused the third and final day of these to eat with a knife and fork. hearings at the supreme court, the highest court in the land, here is richard lister. it was a complete regression. and it was a display of anger. it seems at times, an argument he was doing these things to express without end but those who gathered outside the supreme court today how upset and angry he was. intent on either stopping a coup of the latest official figures show stopping the eu, knew the arguments 2,255 people in these specialist inside at least, would end today. assessment and treatment units, but not before one former 245 are children. conservative prime minister had the they are slightly fewer opportunity to offer a damning than a month before, but still a long way short assessment of the actions of boris of government targets. johnson in suspending parliament.

in over three months, more his lawyer said it was inescapable than 10,000 restraints of patients, that the real reason was to avoid over a third against children. scrutiny of brexit and the eventually, tom was moved government had not told the truth. to a residential home. he is doing much better, the reasons set out in the documents but finding enough places in the community as part put before the court by the prime of the problem. minister, cannot be true... he said three years on, he's still more than 160 miles from his family. i would not wish it on anybody, what we have been through. suspending parliament was motivated by mrjohnson's political interests. i would not wish it on my worst enemy to be truthful. the court also heard from raymond mccord. he won't brexit could we have genuinely struggled threaten the good friday peace these past three years. agreement. in many ways, he speaks we need to put more value into these children with autism and other learning disabilities. for them the silent majority in people's attitudes need northern ireland. who wants a to change, politicians‘ attitudes need to change. they matter, their lives matter. nhs england says it is committed peaceful and prosperous future which to supporting people like tom can only be based on the good friday in the community and is doing agreement and that delicate all it can to reduce the number of patients in specialist hospitals. constitutional settlement, which has been achieved. the lawyer for mr but for families, the pace of change remains too small. mccord outlined the possible impact # may you stay...# of brexit on northern ireland but the justices intervene, alison holt, bbc news. of brexit on northern ireland but thejustices intervene, saying they we re thejustices intervene, saying they were not there to judge the merits

of brexit. now don't abuse our the case against a 20—year—old man who was accused of murdering pc politeness and don't abuse lady andrew harper has been dropped. hale's patients. this case is purely with the latest, our home affairs about whether the queen prorogue correspondent tom symonds is at the old bailey. parliament on the false advice from mrjohnson. but the government insisted this was all politics and tom. yes, andrew harper police not a matter for the court. this is forbidden territory. it is a matter between the executive and co nsta ble tom. yes, andrew harper police constable was killed in the line of parliament. and if parliament takes duty. he responded to a call about a stolen vehicle in berkshire last exception, they have the tools month. he was hit by a car and drag available to address the matter. but along the road for some distance and there is challenging that view say he died of his injuries. four people parliament is senior to the prime minister and he cannot be allowed we re he died of his injuries. four people were charged with his murder and one free rein. that the executive, of them was jed foster who were charged with his murder and one of them wasjed foster who is 20 yea rs of them wasjed foster who is 20 years old. in fact after he was charged, his lawyer made quite a junior partner, cannot claim illegally, unfettered power to close strong statement saying that he denied being involved at all. today down the senior partner for as long ata denied being involved at all. today at a hearing at the old bailey, the grand prosecution service of as the executive likes. for whatever prosecutors said it was dropping that charge of murder and another reason it likes. it is not a simple charge of theft againstjed foster.

question. we will now consider it said that it carried out a full carefully, all the arguments that have been presented to us. we also investigation after taking an know this case must be resolved as initial decision to charge under something called the threshold test quickly as possible and we hope to which relies on there being some be able to publish our decision evidence. 0nce which relies on there being some evidence. once they had all the early next week. the job done, the evidence, they realise there was no grounds to continue the prosecution lawyers left and now it is for the against him. the prosecutor in court court to decide whether and how to said, "he should not and cannot intervene. richard lister, bbc news. continue to be charged." that leaves three defendants leaving —— facing joining me now is our home affairs correspondent dominic casciani. murder charges. they will go on he has been inside the supreme court for the last three days watching the trial in march of next year and a fourth defendant thomas king who is proceedings. thejudges one by the government's lawyer not to stray 21 charged with conspiring to steal into forbidden territory. is this a quad bike. tom, —— many thanks for more about boris johnson into forbidden territory. is this more about borisjohnson and suspending parliament, is it about the balance of powers between the that. courts, parliament and the a court has heard that 17—year—old government? absolutely, it is so jodie chesney was stabbed big, this case. if the court rules to death by drug dealers against a prime minister, it is not in east london after her friend just political egg on his face, it bought cannabis from a rival group. four people are on trial is not just potentially at the old bailey for her just political egg on his face, it is notjust potentially a career ending moments, given there will be

murder. the jury was told miss chesney was knifed in the back as she sat with a group of friends calls for him to resign if he loses. in a park on the evening it will possibly define, to a much of march the 1st. the old bailey heard that hours greater detail, the nature of the earlier one of her group had relationship between the prime unsuccessfully tried to buy cannabis from one of the defendants minister, the government and and turned to another parliament. that is why there is so local dealer instead. the four accused are all from east london and all deny her murder. much at stake and why lady hale said at the end, none of this is easy. the head of counterterrorism policing in the uk has warned that lord keen in wrapping up for the far—right terrorism is the fastest growing problem his officers face. government, he talks about don't walk into a political minefield, assistant commissioner neil basu, said a third of the terrorist plots don't walk into this forbidden territory. the judges are foiled in the last two and half don't walk into this forbidden territory. thejudges are being asked to decide a political years have come from the far—right and these now form about a tenth question. but on the other side, of his officers' caseload. lord pannick who led for gina miller effectively, it is the close partnership between m15 and counterterrorism policing said you are looking at this through the wrong end of the telescope. this in the rest of the uk intelligence community that have disrupted now is about a junior partner, the prime 22 plots since 2017, minister. he is depriving the power seven of which are right—wing of the senior partner, parliament. terrorist plots — suspected to be that methodology. parliament is being denied the right to sit and ask questions of the so, effectively, it's the might of those two services working executive. it is a critical moment together that makes a real

and that is where the legal standard difference in stopping attacks. comes from, that the court can now having that, looking fully resort to to say that the parliament at this ideological threat has been deprived of its rights. i of right—wing terrorism, think it is a very, very tense couldn't be more important to me. situation. if the judges to stray into what was described as forbidden neil basu. the canadian prime minister territory and they do say boris justin trudeau has apologised johnson acted unlawfully, what after a photograph was published by time magazine showing him wearing "brownface" — follows ? that's skin—darkening make—up, johnson acted unlawfully, what follows? and that, i think the at an arabian nights thrust of the debate says the party 18 years ago. with an election due next month, his political rivals have been justices have got over the idea on quick to criticise him. whether or not they can decide on the case. it looks like we are in 0ur north america correspondent david willis reports. the case. it looks like we are in the territory of how to decide the the photograph appeared in a school yearbook 18 years ago. case. 0n the government side they are saying if the prime minister now, it's come back to haunt loses it should be for the prime canada's prime minister. minister alone to decide what to do pictured in robe and turban, brown paint on his face next. the scottish side of the case, and hands, isjustin trudeau. the event — an arabian nights gala which was before the court of at the posh private school session in edinburgh, they are saying the order to quash in vancouver where he was teaching at the time. prorogation should stand which means mps could just come back in. lord i dressed up in an aladdin pannick, for gina miller came up costume and put make—up on.

with a third option and he said declare it unlawful but then let the i shouldn't have done it. speakers of both houses of i should have known better, parliament decide what to do next. but i didn't, and i am really sorry. how to manage this. it is quite a clever tactic because in essence he publication of the picture comes just a week afterjustin trudeau is trying to tell the judges, you launched his re—election campaign. can makea is trying to tell the judges, you can make a lawful declaration and political rivals have been swift against the prime minister. you can side with us, but leave the politics to condemn his actions. well, it's troubling, of how to resolve this extraordinary and it's insulting. constitutional clash to parliament any time we hear an example itself and that is why there is so of brownface or blackfacing, much to play for. dominic, thank you it's really making a mockery for your thoughts and analysis. so of someone for what they live and what their lived experiences are. the 11 supreme court justices i think he needs to answer for it. for your thoughts and analysis. so the 11 supreme courtjustices now have to consider theirjudgment. we gather they will sit in a room, rather like a jury and thrash it out he needs to answer the question why he did that. amongst themselves. clearly they will have some very strong ideas a politician of the instagram age, justin trudeau had carefully already from all the submissions cultivated an image as a champion they have been hearing over the last of canada's racial and ethnic three days. back to you in the minorities, a progressive on issues ranging from gender equality to indigenous rights. trudeau had just started to pull studio. ahead of his main rival in the polls with little over four weeks to go to the election. what this will mean for his

the government says that re—election prospects confidential documents that "reflect remains to be seen. the ideas the uk has put forward" on brexit have been shared david willis, bbc news, washington. with the european union. it comes after the prime minister of finland — the country which currently holds the eu's rotating presidency — said britain must put forward fresh brexit proposals, in writing, before the bank of england has the end of this month. left interest rates borisjohnson has said this unchanged at 0.75%. afternoon that progress is being made in talks with the eu the bank's monetary policy but he does not want committee, which was unaminous to "exaggerate" the extent of it. in its decision, signalled prolonged brexit uncertainty was likely to keep rates lower for longer. we want to come out in such a way but it said the uk would avoid as to protect ireland, make sure there isn't a border, falling into recession this year. a hard border of any kind, in northern ireland, his voice has been the familiar and make sure that we protect sound of breakfast radio the good friday peace process. now, we think we can for millions of listeners over do that, and we think the past 32 years — but no more. we can find a way forward. this morning, john humphrys we think we can solve that problem. presented radio 4's today and i think we are making some progress. programme for the final time. you heard jean—claude juncker david sillito reports. yesterday, i think it was, say that he doesn't have any emotional attachment to the backstop. now, that is progress because they weren't saying that a month ago. it's 6am on thursday, 19th september. the final today forjohn humphrys, a chance to reflect back on more than 30 years over to damian grammaticas as the bbc‘s interrogator—in—chief. in brussels. you are sitting here how is the eu likely talking on the radio...

to react to these papers? his domain, the today programme on radio 4. let me finish the question. let me make this point. his reputation for a terrier—like they have said they received them persistence came from a career and welcome them, but they are injournalism going back decades. making clear, these are only documents and even the uk side says i am telling you things have changed. these are what are called a manifest fact. non—papers. they are not a detailed, legal text of the measures that the over the years, he covered events such as the aberfan disaster... these are the little cards uk believes could be put in place as which could one day replace a safety net, as a backstop for the cash in your pocket. he left school aged 15, ireland. they do not address what still in his 20s when he found himself in the thick of it the eu really wants and i have to say, having heard borisjohnson's clip, the eu is probably pretty in the indo—pakistan war of 1971. clear that this is minimal progress. we haven't been here seven, it is something to talk about but eight minutes, in that time, three strikes, the third one not nearly what they want. they do coming over now. there's the big guns... also, we are pretty clear as well, ..overhead. the uk proposals at the minute, do not, as the prime minister was first, the news withjohn humphrys. saying, keep the border entirely open or in the eu's view, protect and then, in 1981, he became

the peace process. in their view, the face of the nine 0'clock news. there can be no checks at all in fierce warning to the government... six years later, he moved to radio. northern ireland and ireland and that border has to function as today tony hall, lord hall. and be as open in the future. that is part of the real problem, what today it was the bbc‘s current director general being grilled. the uk government is suggesting is you can't sack me now. when you go around westminster, limited form of open border but talk to people in whitehall, they want to be on the today would require customs checks and programme, but the second question, others in northern ireland. so for who will do the interview? there is an acronym, abh, the eu side, i think it is still a very long way away from real anyone but humphrys. progress. damien, thank you. that's because john has a tenacity, his desire to represent the listener. last night the bbc broadcast he has definitely combative. an exclusive report into the threat of abuse and exploitation facing what is happening? some of our most the second it was brought vulnerable teenagers. these children are either in care to my attention last night, i immediately started... or have recently left, brought to your attention?! do you not read papers? but are still supposed to be supervised in what is known this interview pretty much ended as semi—independent living. george entwistle's time as director—general at the bbc. tonight we look in more detail at the impact of drugs, have you ever regretted going too weapons and organised crime far with a politician? oh, yes, many times. on their lives. our special correspondent, have you ever said sorry afterwards?

ed thomas reports. yes, interrupting is fine, inevitable, unless you want a party just a house where people profit political broadcast. from young, vulnerable children. i never really had any support. all i had was basically a bed. but when you get angry, which i have done once or twice, everyone who was involved, and i mean only once or twice, whoever did what they did, that is absolutely unforgivable. someone has to pay a price he has over the years upset for the pain. politicians and divided listeners, last night, we revealed serious but at the end, a glimpse concerns over the safeguarding of teenagers in unregulated homes. of the softer side ofjohn humphrys. i am more proud than i can say that tonight, we hear the stories you have put up with me for so long. of vulnerable children exposed to weapons, drugs thank you and that's it from me. and organised crime. good morning. applause a lot of drug dealing, david sillito, bbc news. people bringing in acid. time for a look at the weather. this teenager lived in the home run good luck to john. by a company called centurion care. good luck tojohn. i hope he will knives, samurai swords, everything. i don't know how they even get it enjoy the relative why in. and here past all the cameras. terrified, he locked is chris with the weather. we will himself in his room. how do you know it was acid in the bottle? have a gorgeous day for many parts because i opened it up and smelt it of the uk. skies look at this with and it burnt my nose.

what was your reaction when that happened ? the sunny weather for the vast i nearly dropped the whole bottle on the floor. majority of the country. this and what did you do? weather watch picture was sent to us put it down and went straight into my room and barricaded the door from the conway area in wales. thanks for sending that went in. it because i didn't feel safe. he says strangers were coming and going from the home. was not sunny everywhere. we had every ten minutes, the door was going, more in the way of cloud across like going in and out, scotla nd more in the way of cloud across scotland and cleared the mainland in and out. going round the corner, but it continued to roll in across doing their drug deals, or whatever and coming straight back. shetland. we could see the odd spit that house was basically just a drug deal house, of drizzle tonight. certainly it has been greater here at times during but i had to live there the day in scotland. but many places the day in scotland. but many places the cloud did clear and break. because i couldn't go anywhere else. 0vernight tonight, it will be a dry centurion care told us, night for the vast majority but they worked with police to prevent drug dealing and all staff had there is a few mist and fog patches safeguarding training by the local authority. quite likely to develop across west england into southern and central of the eight young men whose stories scotla nd england into southern and central scotland and northern ireland as well. temperatures between seven and we followed in centurion care, 10 celsius so that is quite cool in towns and cities but then we've learned that four were sent temperatures on the countryside go or have returned to prison down and lowered to two celsius. a since leaving their homes. 0ne family agreed to let us talk to their son inside prison. chilly start to friday. in mist and fog taking a wile to thin and whiffed into low cloud before fed? clearing away. then sunshine across

you weren't eating inside there? the board. even in shetland we should see branch or whether arriving here as we had to the afternoon. it should have more sunshine. highs and lows of today, 21, 20 two celsius across the country. and into the first part of the week and it will get warmer still. wind will come from a like many unregulated homes, it's down to the young person to manage their finances and food. southeasterly dragging this air from france and boosted temperatures. emmanuel repeatedly disappeared there could be a few mist and fog because he was involved patches initially and the onshore in county lines drug dealing. winds be making things field fresh on the coast. but away from that, sunny skies until the afternoon will how did they get you in the home, how did they find you in basildon? be start to see showers break out in could you have said no? western areas. still ahead of those showers, 24 degrees in cardiff and in london. warmer than it should be in the middle of summer than it should be in september. it will change for the second half of the week and for some low pressure will move in and this area of rain will did you ever ask the staff extend its way into the uk. but inside centurian care for help? emanuel was jailed for possession with intent to supply there is some uncertainty about how heroin and crack cocaine.

far this band of rain will get on centurion care said they felt all children were safe and secure sunday. wales in south—west england across their placements. most likely to see rain. the north—east of the uk will mostly we tracked down one centurion care worker who knew keep its dry and sunny weather for many of the children involved. some in between you could see some it was completely out of control. absolutely manic, wild. rains but the details are uncertain. before the rain arrives, 23 celsius like some people had but the trend to fresher conditions drugs in the house. for northern ireland and across there were some people that ended up parts of wells and south—west england is a good one and then next having like large amounts of cash week it turns quite wet and quite and there was nothing you could have really done about it because other windy. staff members didn't do anything about it. this confidential council briefing we have obtained on centurion ccre says some workers were known to police for arrests that didn't lead to charges. centurion care says, it's not of these disclosures on any of the workers' enhanced dbs checks, which were available at every local authority inspection and no concerns were raised. andy says a girl reported being taken from one of the homes,

given alcohol and drugs before having sex with a man who occasionally worked in the home. police said there was not enough evidence of any crime was committed. the confidential briefing says today at six — the man had several convictions and had been previously the palace hits back investigated, but not after david cameron's revelations about the queen and the charged for an alleged sex scottish referendum. mr cameron tells the bbc he called the palace in 2014 and asked for the queen's help. offence involving a child. centurion care said the contractor not asking for anything that would be in any way improper or did not need to be dbs checked. his role was known to the local unconstitutional. authority, they cooperated butjust a raising of the eyebrow. with the police and there was no further action. these homes were closed in 2017 and the company dissolved in a highly unusual move after serious safeguarding buckingham palace has concerns were raised. made its displeasure all too clear. tonight, across england also tonight — there is around 5000 children in unregulated homes. major versusjohnson, tory versus tory in the supreme court — the former prime minister says suspending parliament was illegal. many highly vulnerable, part two of our investigation all facing the same risks. i am outraged. into the plight of vulnerable i'm outraged and upset in equal measure about what i've just seen. teenagers in unregulated homes — dame louise casey led concerns they're exposed to weapons,

an investigation into rotherham council after hundreds of children were sexually exploited in the town. it's not a loophole, it's a scandal. i want those homes regulated. how urgent is that? tomorrow. the shame is, it's taken the bbc, the same way it was in rotherham, it took the media to lift the lid on it. she fears young people aren't being protected in unregulated homes. that house was basically just a drug deal house. you are exposing their voices, which i can only hope means it's listened to in a different way. it's time for whitehall to wake up to this, it's a disgrace. if action isn't taken on the back of this programme then we are colluding in letting groomers, predatory paedophiles go after those children and that's our responsibility and that's why i find it so upsetting. across england and wales, there's been more than a dozen so—called organised and complex abuse investigations

into failures to protect children in unregulated homes. the stories of those children are unlikely to ever be heard. ed thomas, bbc news. time for a look at the weather. we arejoined by we are joined by chris. beautiful picture behind you? yes, that is conwy in north wales. it has been a glorious day in most parts of the united kingdom. we have had thick cloud across the northern isles of scotland and there could be some drizzle tonight. clear skies initially overnight and mist and fog patches will develop in northern ireland, north—west england, central and southern scotland. chilly night, seven to 10 degrees in the towns and cities but in the countryside it could be down as 2 degrees on friday morning. mist and fog taking time to play but another day of glorious and clear blue skies. we should get brighter skies in shetland through

the afternoon as well and it is a warmer day with temperatures moving into the low 20s. it gets warmer into the low 20s. it gets warmer into the low 20s. it gets warmer into the first part of the weekend. many mist and fog patches clearing to give lots of sunny weather. as far as the temperatures go we should with 24 degrees in london and cardiff so a lovely start to the weekend. across western areas in the afternoon we will start to see some showers breaking out late in the 00:31:23,602 --> 4294966103:13:29,430 day. that is your latest weather.