Skip to main content

tv   BBC News  BBC News  September 24, 2019 11:05pm-11:31pm BST

11:05 pm
the courts traditionally allergic to politics and stay well away, but the other side's legal dream came true. the ruling today speaks volumes. this prime minister must open the doors of parliament tomorrow. mps must get back and be brave and bold in holding this unscrupulous government to account. thank you. so what next? immediate calls to new york, 3,000 miles away, for the prime minister's audacious move condemned by the court... prime minister, are you going to resign? ..to be a reason to resign. prime minister. thank you very much, anthony. for some of his allies, though, it's no emergency. there's been a court case
11:06 pm
in our country this morning, which i think some of you may have picked up on... another chance to suggest the establishment is trying to stop him. i have the highest respect, of course, for ourjudiciary and for the independence of our courts, but i must say i strongly disagree with this judgment. and we in the uk will not be deterred from getting on and delivering on the will of the people to come out of the eu on october 31st. borisjohnson, have you embarrassed the queen? but one number ten source told me the supreme court has made a serious mistake extending its reach into political matters. attacking the judiciary, when downing street and him are under attack themselves. back across the atlantic, every politician's trying to peer into the future. the opposition sniff opportunity. the supreme court has just announced its decision. cheering the labour leader's conference in brighton disrupted and delighted by the news.
11:07 pm
and it shows that the prime minister has acted wrongly in shutting down parliament. it demonstrates a contempt for democracy and an abuse of power by him. and i invite borisjohnson, in the historic words, to consider his position. johnson out, johnson out! "johnson out," they chanted. one member of the government told the bbc the prime minister should quit, but that's far from widespread in tory circles at this stage. instead, mps replacing the tourists in the house of commons, taking their seats on the green benches themselves. there are still quite a few tourists in the chamber. i'm just talking to colleagues and trying to find out what exactly we are going to be doing,
11:08 pm
but we need to go back to holding the government to account. i'm just in a taxi going back to parliament, parliament should never have been suspended, it was not suspended, and therefore we should be back in there doing ourjobs, holding him to account. the official invitation on this crazy day was issued with customary formality — last—minute pomp in the rain. i have instructed the house authorities to prepare not for the recall — the prorogation was unlawful and is void — to prepare for the resumption of the business of the house of commons, the house of commons sits tomorrow, and that it does so at 11:30am. but once mps have raced back here tomorrow, what will they actually do? the alliance of former tories, still rebels, might try to take control again after the government's approach went so wrong. that advice was clearly very poor, and i think some of his advisers are going to have to leave. they are still coordinating with the opposition parties.
11:09 pm
he does not want to be held to account, he doesn't want to have to answer questions about his disastrous brexit policy, and in doing so, he was prepared to mislead the queen and indeed to mislead the whole country. if boris johnson won't do the decent and honourable thing, then i think parliament has a duty to come together to force him out of office through a vote of confidence. there's no sign of that, though. i know him well, he's not going anywhere. and look who is in boris johnson's corner. it's just another day at the office. well, tomorrow is another day in parliament... a place in power he might have dreamt of for years, but after only two months it's proving harder than perhaps he thought it looked. let's go to westminster now and our political correspondent jessica parker. jessica, we know that horacejohnson is now coming back new york but do
11:10 pm
we know what his strategies?” is now coming back new york but do we know what his strategies? i think laura was alluding to it there, to try and crack on plan us. —— boris johnson. even though plan a has been spectacularly derailed but boris johnson seems to be sticking to his guns. yes, he has except in the government has the ruling that parliament must be unprorogued but he still says he wants to get a deal with the european union at the summit on the 17th of october, he is sticking to the 31 october deadline to deliver brexit do or die so he seems to be fairly bright and breezy about the whole thing. that is despite the highest court in the land finding the prorogation was unlawful and an awful lot of opposition mps saying he should resign. it will be interesting to see whether he does return to westminster tomorrow to face the
11:11 pm
music and make a statement to mps, will he face a grilling, what will they try and do to put rush this government? how difficult do you think they will make life for him? very difficult. i am sure you remember a couple of weeks ago today, in the early hours of the tuesday morning. it turns out parliament wasn't tuesday morning. it turns out parliament wasn‘t pro— tuesday morning. it turns out parliament wasn't pro— road at all and there were scenes of acrimony, cries of shame. —— prorogued. at one point, they tried to stop the speakerfrom point, they tried to stop the speaker from leaving and point, they tried to stop the speakerfrom leaving and held up signs saying "silenced" and for those mps who feel they are being silenced, they will try to make an awful lot of noise. what is going to happen tomorrow, we don't really know if we're looking at vote of no confidence but lots of questions will be lobbed at government, not just on the prorogation of parliament, that will come up but
11:12 pm
perhaps on brexit and thomas cook, there are all sorts of issues that have come up there are all sorts of issues that have come up over there are all sorts of issues that have come up over the last couple of weeks that mps might want to hold the government to account on. weeks that mps might want to hold the government to account onm there any sense that dorisjohnson could try to turn the situation to his advantage and say that we are going to leave the european union, i am the only person who can deliver this, despite all the obstacles?” think obviously politicians in the face of adversity also always try to turn things to their advantage. will downing street try and turn this into a people versus parliament issue in the event of a general election? if a general election happened after the 31st of october, and say boris johnson happened after the 31st of october, and say borisjohnson had been somehow forced to delay brexit against his will, although time is running out to do that. yes, it's
11:13 pm
possible, they will use that as a kind of establishment. we in the conservative party. borisjohnson has tried to dodge parliamentary scrutiny. they will put to a test and a general election, it looks like it will be coming around the corner. so what does this mean for the relationship between courts and government — and what impact could it have in the future? our home editor mark easton reports. what you're watching never happened. it may look as though, in the small hours of september
11:14 pm
the 10th, the royal commissioners attended the house of lords to suspend or prorogue parliament, but today the most senior judges in the land said the ceremony was void and had no effect. ..to prorogue this present parliament. when the royal commissioners walked into the house of lords, it was as if they'd walked in with a blank sheet of paper. parliament has not been prorogued. this is the unanimous judgment of all 11 justices. this was a constitutional thwack on the nose of government, delivered by the judiciary on behalf of the uk parliament. thejustices made it clear this judgment was a one—off, but its implications will echo down british history. around parliament square in westminster, there are hidden power lines, a triangle of authority joining the houses of parliament, the government — focused on 10 downing steet, and the judiciary and the supreme
11:15 pm
court. today the justices explained that a fundamental principle of british democracy is that the prime minister is accountable to parliament. they also stated that the courts had supervised the lawfulness of government for centuries. established in 2009 to replace the law lords as the uk's most seniorjudicial body, today saw the supreme court beginning to flex its constitutional muscles. this is probably the biggest day in the history of the supreme court so far. with this unanimous judgment, the judges have really set down a marker about their role as a constitutional court, as a check on government and as a defender of parliamentary sovereignty. and although this will have some repercussions for brexit, it's really much bigger than that. this is about how our parliamentary democracy works. cool booing traitor! the supreme court is crossing the line, meddling in politics, downing street has suggested. but the justices were adamant they had a responsibility
11:16 pm
to question the motives of the prime minister, pointing out he'd failed to submit a witness statement to explain under oath his reasons for suspending parliament. the only evidence the supreme court says it's had was this memo sent by nikki da costa, boris johnson's adviser, recommending suspension. borisjohnson ticked yes. this was not a normal prorogation in the run—up to the queen's speech. this is a completely proper constitutional procedure. whenjacob rees—mogg, as leader of the house of commons, went to balmoral to advise the queen to suspend parliament — advice she was bound to accept — the process was unlawful, the justices said. and in a direct criticism of borisjohnson, thejudgment suggested he ignored constitutional responsibilities in favour of party political interest.
11:17 pm
it is not clear to us that any step is needed from the prime minister, but if it is, the court is pleased that his counsel have told the court that he will take all necessary steps to comply with the terms of any declaration made by this court. tomorrow morning, parliament will sit once more, its sovereign place in our democracy restored and enhanced. but it won't be a fresh dawn. today's judgment means it opens its doors as though the prime minster had never closed them. mark easton, bbc news, parliament square. the labour leaderjeremy corbyn has addressed his party's conference in brighton a day earlier than scheduled in response to this morning's supreme court ruling. mr corbyn called on borisjohnson to resign as prime minister and insisted that labour was more than ready with a range of policies for government. 0ur chief political correspondent vicki young reports. # 0h, jeremy corbyn... he wants to be prime minister.
11:18 pm
they're desperate for him to be prime minister. and many here think that day has just come closer. it's been a difficult conference forjeremy corbyn, but today he got plenty of new material for his hastily rescheduled speech. tomorrow, parliament will return. cheering the government will be held to account for what it has done. borisjohnson has been found to have misled the country. this unelected prime minister should now resign. cheering and there was more. he thinks he's above us all. he's part of an elite that disdains democracy. i will tell you this.
11:19 pm
i don't think he is fit to be prime minister. applause so what is mr corbyn going to do next? he could hold a vote of no confidence in boris johnson, but for now, he's reluctant to act. this crisis can only be settled with a general election. that election needs to take place as soon as this government's threat of a disastrous no—deal is taken off the table. cheering labour's disagreements over brexit have been on full display at this conference. they agree they want a second referendum, but mr corbyn‘s top team is split over whether they should say now that they'll campaign for remain. labour will end the brexit crisis by taking the decision back to the people with a choice — a credible leave alongside remain. that is not complicated. labour is a democratic party that trusts the people. but it's policies mr corbyn
11:20 pm
wants to focus on. labour would scrap prescription charges and introduce free personal care in england. there would be a £10 living wage and a huge renationalisation programme, plus a new system to provide affordable drugs for the nhs. and we will create a new, publicly owned generic drugs manufacturer to supply cheaper medicines to our nhs. mr corbyn said he wanted to put government on the side of the people. go forward to win an election for the people of this country. cheering things are going badly for the prime minister, but it's not been plain sailing for the labour leader either. here, the crowd absolutely adore him, but back in parliament he's a much more divisive figure. he can't unite the opposition
11:21 pm
parties behind him, and that makes getting rid of borisjohnson a whole lot harder. butjeremy corbyn‘s convinced there's an appetite for change. vicki young, bbc news, brighton. there will be much more on the front pages and we will be taking an in—depth look at them. that's with our reviewers jo—anne nadler and stephen bush. that's coming up after the headlines at 11:30pm. in washington, democratic members of congress have launched an impeachment inquiry into president trump after he acknowledged withholding us aid to ukraine and pushing the country to investigate joe biden, the frontrunner for the democratic presidential nomination next year. but president trump says the withholding of the funds was not done to put pressure on ukraine. let's get the latest from washington and our correspondent david willis. david, i know we've been talking, we be hearing from democratic members of congress and the last hour or so. what have they been saying? well,
11:22 pm
it's an historic move, rebecca, no question about that and nancy pelosi, the house speaker, speaking from the speaker's balcony, said that donald trump had betrayed the oath of office and broken the law. this present must be held accountable. resisting calls from members of her own caucus to bring impeachment proceedings recently, for the simple reason that she thought they could rebound on the democrats and only serve to increase support for president trump amongst his base at these latest allegations, of a telephone conversation with the president of you came ——of the ukraine seem to have turned things around. more than two—thirds of the democrat caucus is in favour of impeachment and nancy pelosi has joined them.
11:23 pm
in favour of impeachment and nancy pelosi hasjoined them. reaction has been swift. resident trump has called this a witch—hunt and presidential harassment. we also heard from the minority leader, in the house, kevin mccarthy, saying the house, kevin mccarthy, saying the speaker does not speak for the american people and as for mitt romney, the utah senator who over the weekend said this would be troubling in the extreme if the allegations against donald trump proved to be correct, he has now gone on record saying, the speaker of the house has got a bit ahead of her skis and she should have waited until a transcript of this controversial telephone conversation is made available which president trump says it will be tomorrow. tell us trump says it will be tomorrow. tell usa trump says it will be tomorrow. tell us a little bit more about what it is he is alleged to have done and why this telephone call is so crucial. what is alleged to have done is effectively leaned on the leader of a foreign power, in this
11:24 pm
case, ukraine, withholding aid money, hundreds of millions of dollars in aid money that is destined for ukraine, approved by congress to go to the ukrainians. that was withheld and the suggestion is that the president used that aid money as leverage or some sort of dirt to be dug on his political rivaljoe biden, the democratic frontrunner for the democratic presidential nomination. resident trump says he did nothing wrong, that this was a perfect conversation, as he is put it, but there are certainly enough suggestions here that there was wrongdoing for the democrats now to launch treatment settings. they are unlikely to be ultimately successful given that republicans hold the majority in the senate. but if there is a vote to impeach president trump, he will be only the third american president to have
11:25 pm
been formally impeached by congress. ijust wonder if been formally impeached by congress. i just wonder if you would been formally impeached by congress. ijust wonder if you would remind us what the actual process of impeachment involves. it's very interesting because in this case, nancy pelosi has said there are already six different enquiries that are going on involving different house committees into the conduct of president trump. those enquiries will continue and articles of impeachment will be forwarded to the housejudiciary impeachment will be forwarded to the house judiciary committee, impeachment will be forwarded to the housejudiciary committee, it's all a bitarcane, housejudiciary committee, it's all a bit arcane, bear with me, housejudiciary committee, it's all a bitarcane, bearwith me, and housejudiciary committee, it's all a bit arcane, bear with me, and they will vote on them and if that boat is passed, there will be a vote of the entire house on whether to move to impeach president trump. —— vote. 0nly to impeach president trump. —— vote. only two presidents in previous history have been impeached, bill clinton and andrewjohnson, of course, but both of them, despite being impeached, then served out their entire term in office. always good to talk to you, david willis in
11:26 pm
washington, many thanks. a major operation is continuing to bring more than 150,000 people back to the uk after the collapse of the travel operator thomas cook. according to the civil aviation authority, 0peration matterhorn has organised 7a flights today, repatriating around 16,000 passengers. flights will continue until the 6th of october, as our transport correspondent tom burridge reports. repatriating150,000 people is complicated, but resilience at this turkish airport. the manchester flight is full, right? still in her thomas cook uniform, unsure if she will be paid. but in kefalonia tonight, a long and miserable weight after a government—run rescue flight was delayed and then cancelled. and people still on thomas cook holidays are having trouble too. hotels like this one are owed money by a company which has collapsed.
11:27 pm
last night, staff demanded that guests, who had already paid for their entire holiday, cover the unpaid bills. fa ct caught up in it all, graham and claire. it wasn't a pleasant scene. so there was a bit of aggression from one of the reception staff, demanding money. 0bviously, they are quite worried about not being paid themselves. government advice is not to pay because of cover from the atol travel scheme, but in another part of spain, guests were locked out of their rooms until they did. we went out for dinner last night and came back to the hotel and we couldn't get into our room. so we had to go downstairs to the lobby and the lady said, basically, give us 340 euros and you can get back into your room. so that was what we had to do. it's money she can claim back.
11:28 pm
but other customers gave money to staff out of work during one of the last thomas cook flights after a collection organised by a passenger. it's now likely that thomas cook's german airline will be rescued by a loan from the german government. but in britain, an entire operation is grounded. there will be a probe into the company's demise. tom burridge, bbc news. heavy rain has led to six flood warnings across england, with more areas told to prepare for possible problems. in london, the heavy rainfall affected a number of roads with flooding also reported in southampton, birmingham and liverpool.
11:29 pm
now it's time for the weather. hello there. deep potent area of low pressure which the remnants of what was hurricane umberto, particularly across parts of england and wales, one of two locations. london and the home counties as well, some minor running on some of the roads there, particularly through tuesday morning, when a spell of heavy rain moved through. this is the culprit, this area of low pressure, which ought a swathe of wins. it will be slowly clearing away and be between weather system so it should be a little bit quieter and more settled through wednesday afternoon. wednesday starts pretty unsettled. tending to ease down clear away into the afternoon. the hang back of
11:30 pm
cloud and rain we've seen through central and southern scotland and northern england should ease, so we should see lighter winds and more sunshine. it might feel a touch warmer, with 20. a short—lived fine spell. the next area of low pressure will sweep through during wednesday night to thursday morning. wet and windy weather should clear from eastern areas through thursday into the afternoon, and improvement with sunshine appearing but quite lost three, plenty of heavy and thundery showers pushing into western areas. temperatures around the seasonal average. as we in the week, it remains unsettled. we started the week and low pressure. all tied in with the jetstream. it will be moving across the north atlantic, west to east, barring weather systems at us. signs of it as we end the week, diving further south. the next area of low pressure for friday might induce something cooler to the northern half of the country. this
11:31 pm
feature is going to bring a spell of wet and windy weather as we

48 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on