tv HAR Dtalk BBC News September 30, 2020 12:30am-1:01am BST
12:30 am
this is bbc news. the headlines... the republican president, donald trump, and his democratic rival, joe biden, are preparing to go head to head in theirfirst televised debate, before the us presidential election in november. there will be no studio audience but the prime time event is expected to draw tens of millions of viewers. the family of breonna taylor — who was shot dead by police in kentucky — has called for the release of transcripts by the grand jury, which decided against prosecuting the officers involved. breonna taylor's death in march has become a key issue in protests over police brutality and racism. walt disney in america has announced plans to lay off almost 30,000 employees in its theme parks division.
12:31 am
that is it from me. coming up now, hard talk. welcome to hardtalk with me, zeinab badawi. the economic fallout of covid—19 has been tough, and now with new waves of the virus, restrictions on economic activity are being reimposed in many countries. the european union is the world's second wealthiest and largest economy after the united states and accounts for a large portion of the global economy. it has suffered badly from coronavirus. how confident is it of making a recovery? well, my guest is the european commissioner for the economy, paolo gentiloni — who until 2018 was prime minister of italy.
12:32 am
commissioner paolo gentiloni, welcome to hardtalk. there are 3 million covid—19 cases in the european union and there have been around a quarter of a million deaths. how worried are you that these new waves could cost more lives and livelihoods? well, indeed there is an extremely high level of uncertainty. i think we will never forget this 2020 — the human costs and the economic consequences. as far as the economic consequences are concerned , we are in a contradictory situation, because the recovery
12:33 am
is under way since a couple of months after a terrible second quarter, but the speed of the recovery is losing momentum exactly because of the uncertainty of these new contagions. this could take a very long time... and so how the situation could evolve... yup. ..will we have after the new contagions also new hospitalizations? these are the question marks for politicians, entrepreneurs and for our families. as you just said, the recovery has been rather faltering. jeffrey 0kamoto, deputy md of the imf says coronavirus crisis is lasting longer than originally thought and that it would take some countries years to return to growth. do you agree that it could take years for some eu countries to see proper recovery? well, we will have more
12:34 am
accurate forecasts at the beginning of november, but what is sure now is that after the second quarter of very, very difficult and after the speed of recovery we had injuly and august, things are now slowing down. and then it is very clear that we have a very different situation. among european countries, some more affected — less than 18% of gdp, or less affected, 4%, —4%, and among economic sectors, we have some economic sectors, i mean travel, tourism, entertainment that will take a long time to recover. 0k, will it take years? all in all, i think it will not be able, probably, at the end of 2021, to be again at the level of gdp we had at the end of 2019.
12:35 am
so your forecasting that the european union economy is shrinking by about 8% on average, correct, 8.3%? but my question is, could it take years for a proper recovery in some countries? that's the point. i know that you've just outlined that this is doing this and this is doing that, but could it take years? well, what we know is that we will have in 2021 a rebound that, for the moment, the different forecasts are predicting around 5%—6%, so at the end of 2021, we will not be again at the level of growth that we had before the pandemic. european union leaders have got to be really bold, haven't you? and really reimagine the economic landscape
12:36 am
in the european union. the secretary—general of the united nations told me on hardtalk last month that the coronavirus pandemic present an opportunity to build back better, more resilient, more green and more inclusive. do you agree with him that you need really bold thinking? absolutely. i don't think that our goal should be to go back to normal, and indeed, the effort that the european union is doing with this unprecedented economic funding is exactly to try to build a greener, more resilient, more competitive and more inclusive society. and i think that this is a common goal, and i have to say that what we were able to decide in such a short
12:37 am
time after the crisis for the experience of the european union is really unprecedented. are you doing enough though, commissioner, because let's just take jobs — that's a huge, huge worry for everybody. a co—study suggests that 60 million jobs are at risk. we've got unemployment across the eu roughly 7%, but for young people, it's as high as 17%. so, do you think collectively you are doing enough to get people employed? i think the first reaction was, of course, a reaction to support companies and jobs to avoid losing companies and jobs. and these efforts were more or less successful in the european union because of the large amount of schemes that we have two support jobs in companies. completely different from other parts of the world
12:38 am
where you have a sad increase of millions and millions of unemployed, but we know that this relatively low increase of unemployment rates is hiding a different reality. the different reality is that we are in many cases losing some more precarious jobs, especially for younger people, and we have a massive drop in hours worked. so, yes, the unemployment is not skyrocketing, thanks to this scheme of support, but at the same time, behind this picture, we have more precariousjobs that we are losing and we have a massive drop in hours worked. so, the autumn will be absolutely decisive to keep jobs and have selective measures to keep the economy going.
12:39 am
but how? can ijust say, john hurley from the research arm of the eu says, "europe has been successful at dampening "the initial effects of the crisis," as you have just outlined, commissioner. "but in all likelihood", he says, "unemployment is "going to come home to roost. "there is going to be a shake—out and it's going to be fairly ugly." he's right, isn't he? there is going to be mass unemployment because at the moment, we are propping up these jobs, they are kind of zombie jobs, as the 0ecd describe them. well, of course i'm concerned about zombie companies and zombie jobs. but i'm concerned mostly on companies and jobs. so i think that it was the correct choice to act immediately and to give a general support. now, we have to make this support more selective in the next month and we need
12:40 am
also a soft landing from a general support to companies and jobs to a more selective one. i think if we are able to do this, we will avoid a massive unemployment crisis. and this is something that all european nations are working on. so, how will you decide? let's take the aviation industry for instance, that's taken a real knock. for example, an airline in germany had 22,000 jobs lost. are you saying that, perhaps, europe turns its back, for instance, on the aviation industry and says, "look, "let's look elsewhere, the digital economy "or whatever," to really have proper qualityjobs? well, of course, we will have a transformation. i don't think that the level of crisis that we are now seeing in some sectors, you were mentioning aviation,
12:41 am
but it is also tourism in general, sport, entertainment, i don't think that this crisis will last. but, of course, in these sectors , recovery will be much slower. so, these sectors need to be strongly supported for a longer time than others. at the same time, i think we decided something at the european level on our state aid rules that made possible for member states to support these sectors in crisis with public money — which was, as you know, something that our competition rules didn't allow until six months ago. so, we enabled countries to support these sectors. sure. we will have transformation, we will have green jobs,
12:42 am
we will have jobs connected to digitisation, and we will lose somejobs... but that's going to... ..for sure. and so the necessity... sorry to interrupt you here... but that is going to take time, isn't it, commissioner gentiloni? we have seen recently, for instance, restaura ntuers in marseilles in france protesting against the measures which have meant their restaurants have been closed down, affecting their livelihoods. in may, we saw protests, protesters burning tires in barcelona, in spain, because a car plant was being closed there. how worried are you about social unrest as the reality sinks in? of course, i'm worried. we saw some demonstrations that you are mentioning in marseilles and barcelona. we saw them also in germany.
12:43 am
of course, this is a very delicate balance to strike between personal freedom, safety and economy. at the end of the day, i think that the european response to this crisis has been able in these recent months to strike a good balance. we had transparency, we had safety, despite the deep humanitarian crisis, and we had also a level of cohesion in our countries. but you are right, the risk in the months to come is that uncertainty could create social unrest. we put on the table several tools also to strengthen the support to job assurance schemes, upskilling of workers
12:44 am
also at the european level, and this is what we have to do in these times to help workers to upskill and be able to find a newjob or to be stronger in keeping theirjobs. all right, and the anger is also animated in part by those who resent the restrictions on theirfreedoms. we have seen in london, for instance, protesters saying and clashing with police because they are saying, you know, "we don't want these restrictions, we don't want "all the spacing and the masks and the rest of it." how can european leaders carry their citizens with them and there is a real risk of anger spilling over on the streets, isn't there? there is this risk, but i am definitely confident on the strength of democracy, liberty, our political system
12:45 am
based on transparency and the rule of law. i don't think that this is a time for managing this crisis in an authoritarian way. we know that our systems means also a lot of public discussions may be of differences among different institutions and regional institutions in our countries, and differences among european member states. but at the end of the day, i think the european citizen knows that we have transparency in how we manage the safety crisis and how we are re—strengthening our economy. all right. and this is, i think, a winning card for the near future. 0k. you have mentioned how the european union has responded to the coronavirus pandemic, you have set up this recovery fund — 750 billion euros.
12:46 am
the european central bank which is of course the central bank of the euro zone of the european union is asking for this fund to be made permanent. is that something you could consider, because, you know, you are going to need to stay with this for quite a while. could it be permanent? well, we didn't decide at the moment to have permanent funding. we decided something unprecedented — someone called it a hamiltonian moments. a rubiconian moment. but apart from labels, i think we did indeed take important decision, an unprecedented one, and the experience of the european project shows that when you take an unprecedented decision, if the decision produces good results, then you will repeat it. but until now, we didn't decide
12:47 am
a permanent initiative. is it a good result, though? because, i mean, there are net gainers, and there are those who also stand to lose, like austria, denmark and holland. is it fair that some countries are putting money into this fund, and they don't have as much say about how the recipient countries can spend it? because this has been a big area of dispute with the dutch saying, "look, if money is going "to italy or whatever, we want to see how they are "going to be spending it." is this a fair system? for sure, the commission will look at the way this money will be spent. we the commission, we are not financial intermerdies raising or lending money in the markets and then transferring it to governments. we will do this according to our priorities, the green transition, the digitisation, our recommendation
12:48 am
to different countries from the netherlands to italy. but i don't think we will have winners and losers. this is not the crisis of ten years ago, this is a crisis affecting everybody and putting at risk our single market. in countries like the netherlands, austria, the countries that you mentioned are big winners of this single market. so it's in their interest, not only for solidarity, but for economic interest to keep the single markets strong. but how do these countries spend the money? i mean, spain is due to receive about 140 billion euros and the spanish government sources have said that — told reuters — that this is not a crisis of money, it's a crisis of ideas. it's difficult for these countries to actually spend the money on proper programmes that assist economic recovery. there is real worry about this.
12:49 am
well, we here in brussels, we established — with the agreement of member states— a very clear framework for this unprecedented spending. so, it is clear that we have two big priorities, the green transition, 37% of investment should be linked to the green transition, and the digitisation of our economy. at the same time, we have recommendation for each member states. so, i think the guidance is very clear. it is not easy to spend such a huge amount of money in such a limited time because we are dealing with few years for this spending. just a quick response. but i think we either take this opportunity in a few years or we will not be able to make the changes
12:50 am
you were mentioning. you don't want to go back to normal, we want to use this moment for greener, more resilient... you've made that point. ..mmre competitive economy. yeah, sure, you made that point. just very quickly on this, as a former prime minister of italy, will you be tough on italy? because roberto from milan university says, "there's an enormous risk italy will be unable to spend this "money or we will spend it on useless things, "and in that case, we are heading for debt "crisis in a few years." will you be tough on italy? we will be tough... all right, 0k. ..on every single country. tough means that the ownership of the proposal is of national countries... 0k. ..but we are guaranteeing that the framework and the common targets are in these programme. 0k. we will do this for every single country, and of course, for italy, which is the country receiving the larger amount of money, not in relative
12:51 am
terms, but in general terms. all right, just very quickly on this, the president of germany's central bank is warning that this should remain a clearly defined crisis measure and should not open the door to permanent european union debts. you've got to make sure you're not reallyjust signing huge amounts of debt to the eu for a very long time. correct? well, you know, you were mentioning before that european centre were saying we need a permanent initiative, and now we are rightly mentioning the german governor, ——european central bank saying we need a permanent initiative, and now we are rightly mentioning the german governor, saying that this should be a one—off measure. i think that we have the duty to guarantee success to this extraordinary operation. if success will be there, then we can discuss the future of this initiative.
12:52 am
all right. for sure, success doesn't mean a level of debt without any control. we suspended our stability packs, or our fiscal rules, until the end of next year. this doesn't mean that we are not considering the importance to keep deficits and debt in the right path. and could it lead to greaterfiscal union within the european union? because you need a kind of concerted response on fiscal policy. just very quickly on that. yes, this was a strong recommendation coming frequently from the ecb. we can't have only a common monetary policy, we need a fiscal common policy. this is perhaps a step in this direction, but i repeat, we should concentrate on this initiative and not on the consequences that it could have in the european
12:53 am
project and building. right. this is a discussion for after the crisis, not for now. got to ask you briefly on brexit of course. talks have taken place this week between britain and the european union, and there is an eu leader summit in mid—october hoping to have progress. david frost — the uk ‘s brexit chief negotiator — says, "a deal is very much possible, but equally very farfrom certain." how confident are you of a deal, commissioner? well, i know that talks are ongoing this week, and so it's difficult for me to comment on these talks. what is sure is that the eu has always been committed to trying to find a deal. we did it in good faith, at the same time, it's clear that what we already agreed should be implemented — so that the withdrawal
12:54 am
agreement is not an option, the protocol for ireland and northern ireland should be implemented, as president from the alliance that a few days ago... and just very quickly, when you said back in february about the coronavirus, as the virus was hitting your own country, italy, "no need to panic." that kind of attitude hasn't really left the eu in a very strong position to recover as quickly as possible, has it, commissioner? well, i think that we need to reassure our citizens that we are doing all things possible, not only to find a vaccine, but also to manage this crisis. commissioner paolo gentiloni, thank you very much indeed for coming on hardtalk.
12:55 am
thank you. hello there. most parts of the country enjoyed some sunshine on tuesday — temperatures reached 21 celsius in kent. today, though, we are going to find cooler and wetter weather arriving across the uk, and sunshine will be in short supply. and that's because all this cloud has been massing out in the atlantic and is now starting to stream in, and these weather fronts are bringing with it some outbreaks of rain that will push their way eastwards steadily through the day.
12:56 am
now, ahead of that rain, it's a milder start to the morning. temperatures in double figures in most areas. but the winds could be quite strong and gusty through the irish sea first thing, and we have got a wet start to the day across many western areas. some early brightness perhaps across eastern england, but the rain will push steadily eastward through the day. some heavier rain over some of the western hills. and while some western areas may well turn a bit brighter in the afternoon. there will still be some heavy showers around as well — so not a straightforward clea ra nce. temperatures will be lower — 1a degrees in scotland, northern ireland, highest temperatures in the southeast before that rain sets in from mid afternoon onwards. that rain does then move away overnight. thay weather front takes the rain into the north sea. then behind the outcome of the air gets cooler. so, temperatures will be lower still, i think, on thursday. may be still quite damp in the northeast of scotland for a while, there will be some sunny spells elsewhere, some showers likely to break out, particularly across more southern and western parts of england and into wales, perhaps into northern ireland
12:57 am
as well. at the winds will be lighter, there will be some sunshine at times, but the air is still on the cold side with temperatures only 12—15 degrees on thursday despite the sunshine. as we move things into friday, where we have got the threat of some heavier rain coming into southern parts of the uk, together with some strengthening winds, gales, possibly even severe gales as well. looks a bit drier and less windy as you head northwards into scotland and northern ireland, but it's still on the chilly side. some uncertainty as we head into friday and into the weekend as well, because we've got a potentially rather nasty area of low pressure, and essentially over the weekend, we are going to find low—pressure dominating right the way across the uk. so the weekend forecast doesn't look particularly appealing. it's going to remain on the chilly side, there will be a lot of cloud around, some strong winds and some rain at times.
1:00 am
this is bbc news with the latest headlines for viewers in the uk and around the world. i'm mike embley. just one hour until trump and biden go head—to—head in their first live televised debate — but have us voters already decided who to back in november's presidential election? why was no police officer directly charged over the death of breonna taylor? the deliberations of a us grand jury will be published on wednesday. walt disney in america plans to lay off almost 30,000 theme parks workers — as its resorts struggle through the coronavirus pandemic. and — as the number of coronavirus cases passes the1 million mark worldwide, we'll find out what medics
43 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC NewsUploaded by TV Archive on
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f2d40/f2d4082f6fabd1ab2783beaed630e6c6f67a1c49" alt=""