tv HAR Dtalk BBC News December 25, 2020 12:30am-1:01am GMT
12:30 am
a post—brexit trade deal. ot follows months of tough negotiations. it follows months of tough negotiations. both sides have hailed it as a success. much of the detail is still to be made public. the european commission president ursula von der leyen described it as a "good, fair and balanced deal". she said she hoped for a continued close relationship in the years to come. the treaty is set to come into force in january. prime minister boris johnson said the uk has "completed the biggest trade deal yet", taking back control of our money, borders and, laws. the main opposition labour party says it will support the deal when it comes before parliament. but decribed it as a "thin agreement". those of the main headlines here on bbc news. now on bbc news — it's hardtalk with stephen sackur.
12:31 am
welcome to hardtalk. i'm stephen sackur. my guest today has made a unique contribution to our understanding of humankind's closest relatives — the primates. in particular, the chimpanzee. jane goodall was in her 20s when she began her meticulous observation of chimpanzee behaviour in africa. now, she's in her mid—80s, a world—famous conservation activist. so what hope is there for saving the primates and so many other species from mass extinction? jane goodall, welcome to hardtalk. well, thank you.
12:32 am
thank you for inviting me to hardtalk. it is a pleasure having you on the programme, and it strikes me this year is a rather remarkable anniversary for you. it is 60 years from the beginning of your work in what we now call tanzania, your observation of the chimpanzees in the forest. when you consider the 60—year span of time, what is your overriding feeling when you reflect on what has happened in those six decades? well, the world has changed, there is no question. it has changed rather dramatically. when i first arrived at the gombe — now the gombe national park, it was part of the great equatorial forest belt that stretched from the western parts of east africa right across to the west african coast, and when i flew over gombe national park, which is very small, in 1990, i was shocked to see a tiny
12:33 am
island of forest and it was surrounded by completely bare hills, more people living there than the land could support, too poor to buy food from elsewhere, chimpanzees now isolated from other remnant chimpanzee groups in the area, and right across africa, chimpanzee numbers have dropped, forests have disappeared, there is the live animal trade, mothers shot to sell babies. the bush meat trade, because in some african countries, people think chimp meat is a delicacy. so that is also adding to the depletion of chimpanzee numbers right across africa. even in that answer, you have given us such a sense of the enormous environmental pressures that the chimpanzees have been under over those 60 years. i want to go through this from the beginning — i want to start by having you take us back to 1960,
12:34 am
to the young jane goodall in her 20s with no real scientific academic training, but certainly, amazing gifts for natural observation. how unusual was it for you to be given the role, the responsibility of going out into the forest and undertaking this scientific observation? well, it was absolutely unique. you are right, i had no scientific training at all. ijust did biology in school. i left school at 18, we didn't have money for a university or a college. and so when i arrived in africa, it was simply because from the age of ten, i had dreamed of going to live with wild animals in africa and write books about them. and i was fortunate to meet with dr louis leakey, the famous palaeontologist, and i think he was really impressed by how much i knew about african animals from the reading i had done. you know, when i grew up, there was no tv, so it was reading.
12:35 am
and so he offered me a job as his assistant, really, and then he became, i suppose, more impressed because he saw that i really, really had this thing about being with animals and watching them and could cope with the bush. and so he gave me this extraordinary opportunity. i mean, iwould have studied any animal, and it was chimpanzees. and, interestingly, louis leakey, i think, encouraged you to run with this idea that meticulous observation of the chimpanzees might reveal new sort of connections between their behaviours and human behaviours. is that something that, when you went out into the forest, you were actively looking for? well, i wasn't looking for it, but that's the — he sent me because he believed, as everybody does now, but he was ahead of his time — he believed there was a common
12:36 am
ancestor, chimp—like, human—like — ape—like, human—like, rather — about 6 million years ago, and because he was searching for the fossilised remains of our earliest human ancestors, he felt that if jane sees behaviour in chimpanzees today that is similar or maybe the same as behaviour in humans today, maybe that behaviour was also present in the common ancestor, brought with us on our two separate evolutionary pathways, and he felt that would give him, for the first time, some way of imagining how those early ancestors might have behaved. you adopted techniques, which i think we can now say were groundbreaking. you immersed yourself in the life of the chimp troupe — i don't know that is actually the right word, but the group of chimpanzees. you were with them every day, you encouraged them to get very confident in your presence and you didn't observe them with sort of scientific detachment and give them numbers as so many scientists
12:37 am
have done in the past. you engaged with them and related to them in a much more intimate way. i certainly did. i observed them. it took a long time before they trusted me enough for me to really get close, but, you know, that is how i had studied the animals around my home in bournemouth all my life. so i knew, given time, that they would come to accept me. did i have time? we only had money for six months, and they kept running away every time they saw me. but then finally, one of them — i named him david greybeard — and he accepted me better than the others, and i saw him using and making tools forfish for termites. that was the turning point. that was when leakey was able to bring in the national geographic and send a photographer and filmmaker. and so gradually i was able to get to know the chimpanzees as individuals, each with their own personality. i could see their minds working to solve simple problems.
12:38 am
and i could witness their emotions, like happiness, sadness, fear, grief. and all of this, when i was sent by leakey to cambridge university to do a phd in ethology — this is when the professors told me i had done everything wrong. yes, naming the chimps isn't scientific and i shouldn't talk about them having personalities, minds or emotions, because those, they said, were unique to humans. but even though i was nervous, never having been to college, i had been taught by a wonderful teacher as a child that this wasn't true, that in this respect, these erudite professors were wrong. and that teacher is right here behind me — i hope you can see him — it is my dog rusty. and you cannot spend meaningful time with any animal — a dog, a rat, a pig, a chimpanzee — and not know
12:39 am
that we are not the only beings on the planet with personalities, minds and emotions. and i was also told you mustn't have empathy with your subject. scientific observation should be sort of remote and cold and objective. but this is absolute rubbish, because only when you have empathy, you see something you don't understand, and you just have this feeling as to why it is happening. and so then you can stand back as a scientist, which is what cambridge taught me, and check whether your intuition is right or wrong. jane, as you say, national geographic were very eager to send, first, a photographer, then a full camera crew to record what you were doing in the forest, and many films have been made over the years using material from that period, but there was some archive footage that wasn't seen for very many years, and it has all been pulled together now in an extraordinary film. we just want to play a little clip from the archive,
12:40 am
12:41 am
it was absolutely thrilling... ..to have the chimpanzees so close. what strikes me from that clip, jane goodall, is that there was a degree of real intervention in what you were doing. you were sort of laying bananas out increasingly close to yourself so you could get closer and closer to these creatures. some may look at that and say that you were, therefore, interfering in a way that made their behaviour is not entirely spontaneous and natural. some have talked about the degree of aggression that you encouraged as they ended up fighting for bananas. did you, at the time, worry about that degree of interference? no, because, you know, there was no protocols. there were one or two field studies of primates, they all had feeding stations — or almost all of them
12:42 am
did — and i wasn't... what i was interested in right from the beginning was the behaviour of the individual. that was also discouraged by the science. . .scientists. but all the chimpanzees i was learning about had the same kind of situation, so i wasn't so interested in what they actually might have done if i wasn't there. admittedly, it did increase the aggression, and when i realised that, we stopped that feeding. the key finding — and there were many, and we will talk about several of them — but the key finding that still resonates through the world of primatology and animal behavioural science today was your observation, and it comes back to, i think, david greybeard, the name you gave to one of the chimps, his use of a stick as a tool to capture termites and of course then to eat them, and it wasn'tjust the use of this tool, it was the shaping and modelling of the tool to make
12:43 am
it as effective as possible as a collector of termites. when you observed this tool behaviour, did it immediately strike you that this was something of a breakthrough? well, i knew it was a breakthrough. i knew that we were supposed to be the only tool—using, tool—making animal on the planet, and it was professor 0sman hill who defined us as ‘man, the toolmaker‘. so i knew it was a breakthrough as far as science was concerned. i knew that this was a breakthrough, and it really did change the whole course of the events, because david was carefully selecting grass stones, pushing them down into the termite hole, pulling them out slowly, eating off the termites, but he was also reaching out and picking a leafy twig, and to use that, he had to carefully strip the leaves — that was the toolmaking. and of course now we know they make tools in other ways as well. but it was very exciting.
12:44 am
however, if the scientists had bothered to go into the field and talk to, for example, the indigenous people living in the forest in congo, they would have told them, "well, of course chimpanzees use tools. we have seen it." well, i sincerely... well, i actually believe, because chimpanzees are so like us biologically — we share 98.6% of the composition of dna and many other similarities and composition of blood, immune system, anatomy of the brain and so on — along with hugo's film of chimpanzee behaviour, the similarity and non—verbal communication, kissing, embracing, holding hands, patting one another on the back, then it sort of forced science out of that very reductionist way of thinking about our relationship with animals. i want to talk for a moment, not about chimpanzee behaviour
12:45 am
but human behaviour. as a young woman you were a pioneer in working in this field in the early 1960s. looking back at some of the reporting of the time, the associated press, for example, began a report on what you were doing in tanganyika with these words: "a willowy blonde with more time for monkeys than men told today how she spent 15 months in the jungle to study the habits of apes." there is no way they would have written about a male scientist like that. well, no, but it didn't offend me back then. ijust wanted to get on and study the chimpanzees. and when there were reports that jane's famous only because of her legs, it was a different world and women did not feel less threatened than as they do today because feminism, you know, had not begun. this was just after world war ii. and my feeling was at
12:46 am
the time — at the time — was that if my legs have helped me get onto the cover of the geographic, thank you, legs, because that's given me the opportunity to go on studying chimpanzees, which is what i want to do. so...oh, today, it would not be acceptable. let's reflect on where we are today. you referred to it earlier in the interview, about the degree of pressure that there is on communities of chimpanzees and so many other wild animals, particularly in africa right now. i think the figures suggest are that there are around 170,000 chimpanzees in the wild today. at the turn of the 20th century, it is believed there were more than a million. do you think we humans have completely failed chimpanzees and so many other species? well, we're certainly failing them, but in the same way, we are failing our own future generations of human beings. we've been, for a long time, stealing the future of our children, grandchildren,
12:47 am
we are still stealing it today. we have terribly harmed this planet. this has led to the climate crisis, which, if we do not get together around the world and do something about it soon, will lead to the end of life on this planet as we know it, and that includes us. it's our disrespect to nature, of the natural world and of animals that's led to this pandemic, this covid—19 pandemic and it has led to climate change. and so this is why i left gombe, which the best days of my life were there, out in the rainforest, learning about the interconnection of all living things, how each species has a role to play in this wonderful web of life which we call biodiversity. learning as i travelled around the world raising awareness about what was going on in africa, about what we're doing to the planet, and we won't go into that now, but i think probably everybody
12:48 am
listening knows what we're doing to the planet. but i think, if i may, i think it is important to ask you this simple question. thinking of gombe in tanzania, where you did so much work, and so many other places in africa, what would you say to those — perhaps local people who would say, "well, jane goodall, her work is amazing, but let us not forget, jane goodall is a white woman with a lot of privilege, coming into our communities and now telling us that we must not deforest, we must not seek out bush meat, which we can sell in the marketplace to feed our families and keep ourfamilies alive. she's lecturing us in a way which doesn't reflect the hardships and reality of our daily lives and, therefore, her message about conservation is not one that we can easily accept"? well, what i would say to that is that's never what i did. and when i realised in 1986 that the forests across africa
12:49 am
were going and that chimpanzees were decreasing in number, along with other animals, the first thing i felt was important was to find out more about it. so i scraped together a bit of money and managed to visit, i think it was six range countries where chimpanzees lived, where they were being studied by then. and what i learned about was, yes, the plight of the chimps, but also, the plight of so many of the african people living in and around chimpanzee habitats, and it came to a head when i flew over the tiny gombe national park, which is, as i have said, by 1990, it was just a small island of forest surrounded by completely bare hills. people struggling to survive, too poor to buy food from elsewhere. and that's when it hit me. if we don't do something to help these people find ways of making a living without destroying the environment, we can't even
12:50 am
try to save the chimpanzees. and so, the jane goodall institute began our community—based conservation programme, which we called tacare, and it was very holistic and it was not a group of arrogant white people marching into the villages and telling people, "you've messed things up, this is what we will do to make things better for you." no. it was a small group, seven i think, local tanzanians, they did not even have a degree so they were not threatening, and they were hand—picked, they went into the villages and sat down with the people and asked them, "what do you think we could do to help you?" and that's where we began. better education for the children, restoring fertility for the overused land to grow more food, and better health care. so we started in that way with just the 12 villages and a tiny grant
12:51 am
from the european union. and i have looked at the amount of work that your institute has done along with other organisations you've set up such as the roots & shoots organisation, particularly focused on young people in communities. you have done extraordinary work. but it seems the more you have turned from research to activism, and you travel all over the world with this message, the more uphill the struggle seems to be. are you feeling, in your ninth decade, very bleak about where we are? well, first of all, this expression, "think globally, act locally" — don't. because if you think globally, you are so depressed. you cannot help that today. but if you think, "wwhat can i do as an individual, right here in my own community?" this is the premise behind our roots & shoots programme that i began in 1991 with 12 high school students in tanzania. and it basically was telling
12:52 am
them that what they did each day would make a difference. and so it started with these 12 high school students, it's now in 65 countries, we have kindergarten members, university members, everything in between. and that's my hope for the future. because everywhere where i was going when i could travel — i haven't been able to travel because of this silly pandemic — but i was...there were young... there were children and students coming up, "drjane, we want to tell you what we've been doing to make this a better world." so enthusiastic. jane, a last question. 0ver your left shoulder, i see beautiful pictures of some of the chimpanzees who were part of your studies. do you think chimpanzees have a future? there are people who talk about the real possibility of the extinction of wild chimpanzees. well, it's what i am going to fight for for the rest of my life. i don't know how long that is.
12:53 am
but we have got some quite large areas, and because of this tacare programme that i told you about, i talked about the bare hills around gombe. fly over it today, you won't see bare hills. the forests have been allowed to come back, the villagers have become our partners in conservation and they understand that protecting the environment is notjust for wildlife, it's their own future. they need the forest for clean air, clean water, to regulate rainfall and climate. and that programme is now in six other african countries where jgi is studying chimpanzees. so there are large areas of forest and the villagers are beginning to leave corridors where the chimps can move from one community to another, which they must do to avoid inbreeding. so, i have great hope, but we don't have long to do it, and seeking funding...
12:54 am
gombe‘s 60 this year, 60th anniversary, we were going to use the 60th anniversary for galas and to raise money, but that is all now put on hold because of covid—19. but nevertheless, i do have hope that the young people, because of this brain that's coming up now, finally, with ways of living in greater harmony with nature, because of the resilience of nature — give it a chance, it comes back — and because of what i call the indomitable human spirit, the people who tackle what seems impossible and won't give up and very often succeed. i have to say, that is a wonderful and uplifting note upon which to end. jane goodall, i think you very much indeed for being with me on hardtalk. well, thank you too. it was a stimulating conversation. thank you.
12:55 am
hello. the weather is giving us a calm and mostly dry interlude for christmas day, a very chilly start with a touch of frost in places, but a fine day for the most part, with some spells of sunshine. where we have had some showers, particularly across eastern scotland and eastern england, there is the potentialfor some ice on untreated surfaces through the first part of the morning. certainly a chilly start, with temperatures well below freezing, so a frost in many places, but that means a fine and a sunny start for most. still, some of the showers just draped across the eastern side of england, a fairly brisk wind here, and one or two showers, too, for parts of pembrokeshire and the west of cornwall.
12:56 am
but for much of england and wales, we will see some spells of sunshine through the day. just a bit more cloud into the north west later. certainly for northern ireland and scotland, things will be clouding over, and we'll see some rain into western scotland. the winds strengthening here. but that's where we will see the highest temperatures. 9 degrees in stornoway. pretty chilly day elsewhere. and then as we head into christmas day night, into the early hours of boxing day, you can see generally more in the way of cloud. some outbreaks of rain, more of a breeze, so not such a cold start to the day on boxing day, most places well above freezing. but boxing day will generally be a cloudier day. there will be some bits and pieces of rain around and some quite heavy and persistent rain getting going across parts of western scotland, into northern ireland later as well, the winds really starting to pick up here. it is going to be a milder day for most, but this will be taking us into actually quite a rough spell of weather through saturday night. it comes courtesy of this area of low pressure. it has been named by the met office, it has been named storm bella. it is going some really heavy
12:57 am
rain, which could cause some flooding but also some strong winds. a met office amber warning is in force already for parts of southern england and south wales, gusts of 70 to possibly 80 miles an hour, but more generally across england, wales and the far south of scotland, we'll see wind gusts of 60 miles an hour in many spots. a lot of rain through saturday night into the early part of sunday morning. that could cause some flooding. most of that rain will clear during sunday morning, to leave brighter skies behind, but some showers too. and with some colder air digging in, some of those showers will turn wintry, top temperatures between two and 7 degrees. that's all from me. happy christmas.
1:00 am
i'm freya cole with the latest headlines for viewers in the uk this is bbc news. i'm freya cole with the latest headlines for viewers in the uk and around the world. a deal is done — the european union and united kingdom finally reach a post—brexit trade deal — after heated negotiations. both sides hail the agreement a "big success". we have completed the biggest trade deal yet worth £660 billion a year. a comprehensive canada billion a year. a comprehensive ca na da style billion a year. a comprehensive canada style free trade deal. it is fair, it is a balanced deal and it is the right and responsible thing to do for both sides. a quiet christmas in bethlehem, as pilgrims are told to stay
35 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC News Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on