tv The Papers BBC News April 25, 2021 10:30pm-11:01pm BST
10:30 pm
but first the headlines. families are told to buy their own oxygen as india hits a record number of new coronavirus cases for the fourth day in a row. the uk is sending more than 600 pieces of medical equipment to the country in a bid to help — including oxygen concentrators and ventilators a senior minister declines to say whether borisjohnson was ever lent money or sought donations to help pay for the redecoration of his downing street flat. england's biggest football teams — and the sport's governing bodies — will stage a four—day boycott of social media from next friday — to campaign for social media companies to crack down on online abuse. and, as la gears up for tonight's oscars, we go behind the scenes at the ceremony�*s new venue — union station.
10:31 pm
hello and welcome to our look ahead to what the the papers will be bringing us tomorrow. with me are polly mckenzie from the think—tank, demos and the executive chairman of the cicero group, iain anderson. tomorrow's front pages, starting with... i'm starting with. .. always i'm starting with... always so envious at how tidy your i'm always so envious at how tidy your homes are. i'm always so envious at how tidy your homes are. the ft leads with calls from some credit suisse shareholders to remove its risk chief over archegos and greensill fallout. uk aid shipment begins itsjourney to india — the metro reports on the aid being sent to india to help it fight its wave of coronavirus infections. also reporting on aid being sent the india — the guardian leads on downing street ruling out an urgent inquiry into pandemic mistakeswhile the express reports calls from mps for the prime minister to �*plough
10:32 pm
on in winning the war against covid' and rise above attacks by his former aide dominic cummings. also with number ten — the mail leads with reports on claims borisjohnson said he would rather see bodies pile high in their thousands than order a third lockdown. the widening gap in wealth leads on the front of the yorkshire post. and a flat renovation on number ten. a flat renovation on number ten. so let's begin... the metro race to get aid to india. but in sending quite a bit of equipment and. india but in sending quite a bit of equipmentand. india is but in sending quite a bit of equipment and. india is saying he needs help from other countries too. yeah, for me, this is the most important story right now. the race to get aid to india. the sense that perhaps we just waited too long to support and get support to india.
10:33 pm
the numbers are truly horrendous. 350,000 cases just on saturday, at least 2700 deaths, there may be more. just watching earlier some pictures of the funeral pyres, tragic, tragic scenes. but help is on the way it would appear. hopefully not too little of ventilators and oxygen i think that really needs to be all of our focus and the focus in terms of international aid right now. fix, international aid right now. a situation where a hearing right now is somebody in delhi is dying every or minutes. there's a black market in oxygen cylinders, unimaginable. yes, the footage that you've been showing _ yes, the footage that you've been showing in— yes, the footage that you've been showing in others have been showing and the _ showing in others have been showing and the pictures are just horrible. i thihk_ and the pictures are just horrible. i think lots— and the pictures are just horrible. i think lots of people fell for what the indian — i think lots of people fell for what the indian government fell for was a
10:34 pm
believer_ the indian government fell for was a believer earlier in this year that india _ believer earlier in this year that india had — believer earlier in this year that india had conquered it. their astonishing stories of really high antibody— astonishing stories of really high antibody levels of particular among city populations. and this wave has 'ust city populations. and this wave has just almost— city populations. and this wave has just almost come out of nowhere. since _ just almost come out of nowhere. since mass — just almost come out of nowhere. since mass gatherings in february and a _ since mass gatherings in february and a whole series of missed opportunities for the government to take steps. they have been slow and vaccinations— take steps. they have been slow and vaccinations even though indian factories— vaccinations even though indian factories are making vaccinations for the _ factories are making vaccinations for the whole world, actually. it's absolutely — for the whole world, actually. it's absolutely devastating to see oxygen and people —— dying and cues waiting to be _ and people —— dying and cues waiting to be seen _ and people —— dying and cues waiting to be seen. patients having to ration— to be seen. patients having to ration oxygen. as our footage of the boss on _ ration oxygen. as our footage of the boss on a _ ration oxygen. as our footage of the boss on a ward having to tell his doctors — boss on a ward having to tell his doctors to— boss on a ward having to tell his doctors to ration the amount of oxygen— doctors to ration the amount of oxygen they were giving to patient so as_ oxygen they were giving to patient so as not— oxygen they were giving to patient so as not to waste it. yes oxygen they were giving to patient so as not to waste it.— so as not to waste it. yes it is on the guardian _ so as not to waste it. yes it is on the guardian as _ so as not to waste it. yes it is on the guardian as well _ so as not to waste it. yes it is on the guardian as well talking - so as not to waste it. yes it is on | the guardian as well talking about the guardian as well talking about the need for all countries to pull together. even pakistan is offering
10:35 pm
together. even pakistan is offering to help out. we know the enemy that's existed between these two countries. ., that's existed between these two countries. . ., ,., countries. yeah, the thing about coronavirus— countries. yeah, the thing about coronavirus as _ countries. yeah, the thing about coronavirus as this _ countries. yeah, the thing about coronavirus as this is _ countries. yeah, the thing about coronavirus as this is the - countries. yeah, the thing about | coronavirus as this is the invisible enemy~ _ coronavirus as this is the invisible enemy. which has nothing to do with politics _ enemy. which has nothing to do with politics it's— enemy. which has nothing to do with politics. it'sjust the enemy. which has nothing to do with politics. it's just the fact that this is— politics. it's just the fact that this is a _ politics. it's just the fact that this is a disease that crosses borders _ this is a disease that crosses borders. it can get any of us. and absolutely, — borders. it can get any of us. and absolutely, countries are rallying around _ absolutely, countries are rallying around and it's great to see. the reality— around and it's great to see. the reality is— around and it's great to see. the reality is there are shortages now of tots _ reality is there are shortages now of tots and — reality is there are shortages now of lots and lots of these supplies. there _ of lots and lots of these supplies. there witi— of lots and lots of these supplies. there will be deaths in the thousands, unfortunately. perhaps coutd've _ thousands, unfortunately. perhaps could've been avoided if there'd been _ could've been avoided if there'd been more planning as it was for the first wave _ been more planning as it was for the first wave last year. the independent, _ first wave last year. the independent, this - first wave last year. the independent, this story | first wave last year. tie: independent, this story labour demands legal inquiry into pms flat. you may have noticed on my social media timeline a lot of people saying that they very much care about this story after an interview i did with alastair campbell yesterday. clearly there is a lot of outrage amongst some sections of the
10:36 pm
population. but were not getting any answers yet from downing street. they say there's nothing to see. irate they say there's nothing to see. we are not they say there's nothing to see. - are not getting many answers. labour calling today for the electoral commission to look into this whole affair was up i think they were also planning to table a question in the house of commons this week to also try and get some answers. and tomorrow the cabinet secretary who is going to be in front of a committee of mps look, he's going to get asked about this as well. we are all waiting for number ten to respond in any substantive way. there is on the front page of the newspapers yet again. it was run pretty much every day, this story
10:37 pm
sends dominic cummings wrote his explosive blog on friday. it'sjust going to run and run and run this until number ten responds and probably up until the time that dominic cummings himself is due to appear in front of a parliamentary committee at the end of may. find committee at the end of may. and poll , not committee at the end of may. and polly. notjust _ committee at the end of may. and polly, notjust the committee at the end of may. and polly, not just the flat issue committee at the end of may. and polly, notjust the flat issue but also how contracts have been handed out was up what those conversations were between borisjohnson and for example, sirjames dyson. yes. were between boris johnson and for example, sirjames dyson. yes, the controversy — example, sirjames dyson. yes, the controversy around _ example, sirjames dyson. yes, the controversy around james _ example, sirjames dyson. yes, the controversy around james dyson - example, sirjames dyson. yes, the | controversy around james dyson who wanted _ controversy around james dyson who wanted to _ controversy around james dyson who wanted to make sure that his employees and potential he himself would _ employees and potential he himself would not be liable for tax if they came _ would not be liable for tax if they came to — would not be liable for tax if they came to help out with the uk is in a way the _ came to help out with the uk is in a way the least controversial of a series— way the least controversial of a series of— way the least controversial of a series of controversies that are stacking — series of controversies that are stacking up. there's lots of wider questions — stacking up. there's lots of wider questions about public procurement. who got—
10:38 pm
questions about public procurement. who got these covert emergency contracts— who got these covert emergency contracts and there's a mess over the pms _ contracts and there's a mess over the pms flat with just seems, contracts and there's a mess over the pms flat withjust seems, an extraordinary unforced error. live in the _ extraordinary unforced error. live in the fiat — extraordinary unforced error. live in the flat as it was or make the case _ in the flat as it was or make the case for— in the flat as it was or make the case for the _ in the flat as it was or make the case for the taxpayer to find decent living _ case for the taxpayer to find decent living accommodation for the prime minister. _ living accommodation for the prime minister, perfectly good case to be made _ minister, perfectly good case to be made there. but you try and do it under— made there. but you try and do it under the — made there. but you try and do it under the table, to try and manipulate to get luxury living on somebody else's dime when you know the political regulationjust strikes _ the political regulationjust strikes me as a weird kind of cavalier— strikes me as a weird kind of cavalier approach to decent public management. the cavalier approach to decent public management-— cavalier approach to decent public manauement. , ., ., ., . management. the guardian, outrage number ten — management. the guardian, outrage number ten rules _ management. the guardian, outrage number ten rules urges _ management. the guardian, outrage number ten rules urges inquiry - management. the guardian, outrage number ten rules urges inquiry into l number ten rules urges inquiry into pandemic mistakes. they say they're too busy dealing with the pandemic in its current phase to even look at what the decisions that were made earlier in it. i what the decisions that were made earlier in it— earlier in it. i think the fair is that early — earlier in it. i think the fair is that early on _ earlier in it. i think the fair is that early on everyone - earlier in it. i think the fair is i that early on everyone assumed earlier in it. i think the fair is - that early on everyone assumed that there _ that early on everyone assumed that there would be a public inquiry and we would _ there would be a public inquiry and we would learn from it. i think the
10:39 pm
danger— we would learn from it. i think the danger is — we would learn from it. i think the danger is it's currently too early to have — danger is it's currently too early to have a — danger is it's currently too early to have a public inquiry. once the pandemic— to have a public inquiry. once the pandemic is— to have a public inquiry. once the pandemic is really over people, the government may start to say it's too late, really. _ government may start to say it's too late, really. it's all water under the bridge _ late, really. it's all water under the bridge let'sjust move on to planning — the bridge let'sjust move on to planning for the next line. the next pandemic, — planning for the next line. the next pandemic, i— planning for the next line. the next pandemic, i hope there isn't one. we are in— pandemic, i hope there isn't one. we are in this _ pandemic, i hope there isn't one. we are in this unfortunately lee and they will— are in this unfortunately lee and they will never be a good time to have _ they will never be a good time to have a _ they will never be a good time to have a public inquiry because it's always— have a public inquiry because it's always going to require a lot of work. — always going to require a lot of work. a — always going to require a lot of work. a lot— always going to require a lot of work, a lot of effort. but the reality— work, a lot of effort. but the reality is, _ work, a lot of effort. but the reality is, it does have to happen if you _ reality is, it does have to happen if you want— reality is, it does have to happen if you want to learn the lessons. i think— if you want to learn the lessons. i think it _ if you want to learn the lessons. i think it will — if you want to learn the lessons. i think it will be much better for the government to set out a provisional timetable — government to set out a provisional timetable. a course respecting the fact that _ timetable. a course respecting the fact that if— timetable. a course respecting the fact that if there is another wave of this— fact that if there is another wave of this pandemic, a problem with vaccine _ of this pandemic, a problem with vaccine lasting long enough, who knows, _ vaccine lasting long enough, who knows, of — vaccine lasting long enough, who knows, of course that will be changed _ knows, of course that will be changed. instead of saying well, not now, _ changed. instead of saying well, not now, please come back laterjust feels _ now, please come back laterjust feels like — now, please come back laterjust feels like a — now, please come back laterjust feels like a way to antagonize the families— feels like a way to antagonize the families of people who died from covid _ families of people who died from covid who— families of people who died from covid who quite understandably want
10:40 pm
to be fogged off. let�*s covid who quite understandably want to be fogged off-— to be fogged off. let's go to the metro. there's _ to be fogged off. let's go to the metro. there's been _ to be fogged off. let's go to the metro. there's been this - to be fogged off. let's go to the | metro. there's been this protest to be fogged off. let's go to the i metro. there's been this protest in hyde park where police came under attack from protesters who oppose the lockdown.— attack from protesters who oppose the lockdown. yes. i'm afraid i 'ust don't aet the lockdown. yes. i'm afraid i 'ust don-t get this. fl the lockdown. yes. i'm afraid i 'ust don't get this. just i the lockdown. yes. i'm afraid i 'ust don't get this. just looking i the lockdown. yes. i'm afraid i 'ust don't get this. just looking at h the lockdown. yes. i'm afraid ijust don't get this. just looking at the l don't get this. just looking at the scenes in hyde park, eight police officers attacked today. i saw earlier reports i mean, really quite offensive stuff of people comparing the lockdown to genocide as well in the lockdown to genocide as well in the second world war. it's completely beyond me. this is a public health emergency. it's killed over 100,000 people in this country and wejust been over 100,000 people in this country and we just been talking aboutjust incredibly tragic scenes coming out of italy. these people are utterly
10:41 pm
irresponsible. i'm glad it's on the front page because it's just crazy. particularly as we are so close, so close with the vaccines to being able to actually get out of lockdown. and to some extent we are moving out of lockdown. it’s lockdown. and to some extent we are moving out of lockdown.— moving out of lockdown. it's 'ust be ond moving out of lockdown. it's 'ust beyond me. fl moving out of lockdown. it's 'ust beyond me. yeah, i moving out of lockdown. it's 'ust beyond me. yeah, there i moving out of lockdown. it'sjust beyond me. yeah, there have i moving out of lockdown. it'sjust i beyond me. yeah, there have been a lot of conspiracy theories expounded at these protest too. that covid is at these protest too. that covid is a hoax, that we are all be in had. i a hoax, that we are all be in had. i haven't had my vaccination yet but my husband has. so apparently he's now being _ my husband has. so apparently he's now being shipped by bill gates which _ now being shipped by bill gates which strikes me as an extremely expensive — which strikes me as an extremely expensive way... it's an odd conspiracy— expensive way... it's an odd conspiracy idea that the entire covid — conspiracy idea that the entire covid thing is in order that we get chips _ covid thing is in order that we get chips injected. since when does software — chips injected. since when does software company giveaway technological devices are free? it's alljust, _ technological devices are free? it's alljust, every part of it is
10:42 pm
madness. of course these protesters have the _ madness. of course these protesters have the right to protest, to have their— have the right to protest, to have their views — have the right to protest, to have theirviews. like have the right to protest, to have their views. like you and i disagree profoundly— their views. like you and i disagree profoundly with those views. of course — profoundly with those views. of course in — profoundly with those views. of course in an open side and democracy they have _ course in an open side and democracy they have the right. they have no right _ they have the right. they have no right to _ they have the right. they have no right to beat up the police. rioters. _ right to beat up the police. rioters, protesters have resort to violence _ rioters, protesters have resort to violence should be dealt with extremely severely. because it doesn't — extremely severely. because it doesn't matter whether your views are good, — doesn't matter whether your views are good, bad or indifferent, there is a limit _ are good, bad or indifferent, there is a limit and that comes when you are landing — is a limit and that comes when you are landing blows on police officers who are _ are landing blows on police officers who are simply trying to maintain a peaceful— who are simply trying to maintain a peaceful protest was up it's unacceptable.— peaceful protest was up it's unacceptable. peaceful protest was up it's unaccetable. . ., unacceptable. european banks plan to slash business — unacceptable. european banks plan to slash business travel. _ unacceptable. european banks plan to slash business travel. deal— unacceptable. european banks plan to slash business travel. deal for - slash business travel. dealfor airline recovery helped lots of businesses realising they don't need to fly people around the world for meetings anymore. covid has proved that. . ., ., , meetings anymore. covid has proved that. . .,.,y , ,, that. technology has stepped in. that's completely _ that. technology has stepped in. that's completely right. - that. technology has stepped in. that's completely right. i - that. technology has stepped in. that's completely right. i know. that. technology has stepped in. l that's completely right. i know no business that is just about to send people on a plane to go to an
10:43 pm
international conference or get together. we've perused just as you say, we can cut carbon footprint, allow you to spend more time with yourfamily allow you to spend more time with your family without necessarily getting our plane. the problem of course for the airline and the wider travel industry. because of course business travel for a very long time now has been an absolute driver of growth and profitability. you take away that business travel, take away those international conferences and the airlines are going to be in a real problem for some considerable time. no, i'm not surprised to read that story, i'm seeing that in business absolutely everywhere right now. but it poses a real question as the viability of an awful lot of airlines. �* , , ., ~ airlines. let's finish with the york shire post- _ airlines. let's finish with the york shire post. lovely _ airlines. let's finish with the york shire post. lovely to _ airlines. let's finish with the york shire post. lovely to have - airlines. let's finish with the york shire post. lovely to have that i airlines. let's finish with the yorkj shire post. lovely to have that on the programme tonight. inheritance dividing it rich and poor.
10:44 pm
apparently inheritance is going to become even more important in the future. ., . become even more important in the future. . . , ., future. the archer post is a fantastic — future. the archer post is a fantastic paper _ future. the archer post is a fantastic paper but - future. the archer post is a l fantastic paper but reporting future. the archer post is a i fantastic paper but reporting a story— fantastic paper but reporting a story of— fantastic paper but reporting a story of absolute central importance. its research by the institute — importance. its research by the institute for fiscal studies which looks— institute for fiscal studies which looks at. — institute for fiscal studies which looks at, we have this ridiculous housing — looks at, we have this ridiculous housing price bubble that's been going _ housing price bubble that's been going on— housing price bubble that's been going on for basically 40 years. with— going on for basically 40 years. with this — going on for basically 40 years. with this housing that is no use of continued — with this housing that is no use of continued in fact only the house anymore — continued in fact only the house anymore. at which point it becomes a hu-e anymore. at which point it becomes a huge kind _ anymore. at which point it becomes a huge kind of— anymore. at which point it becomes a huge kind of social impact actually. because _ huge kind of social impact actually. because inheritances, we think there are £1_ because inheritances, we think there are £1 trillion locked out that's going — are £1 trillion locked out that's going to — are £1 trillion locked out that's going to be passed on in the next ten or— going to be passed on in the next ten or 15— going to be passed on in the next ten or 15 years by people passing away— ten or 15 years by people passing away at — ten or 15 years by people passing away at the end of their life. usually— away at the end of their life. usually passing it on to children who might be in their 505 or 605 for home _ who might be in their 505 or 605 for home it's _ who might be in their 505 or 605 for home it's not there to be tran5formative at all. and yet it will change as the iss tran5formative at all. and yet it will change as the 155 is reporting social— will change as the 155 is reporting social mobility, opportunity. if your— social mobility, opportunity. if your parents or grandparents didn't own a _ your parents or grandparents didn't own a house, there is no chance that you will— own a house, there is no chance that you will at _ own a house, there is no chance that you will at all — own a house, there is no chance that you will at all. we've just got to
10:45 pm
rethink— you will at all. we've just got to rethink both the way we tolerate these _ rethink both the way we tolerate the5e ludicrous hou5e rethink both the way we tolerate the5e ludicrous house prices that make _ the5e ludicrous house prices that make hou5ing unaffordable for people and are _ make hou5ing unaffordable for people and are more just way of ensuring that everybody gets a good start, it's not _ that everybody gets a good start, it's not depended on whether your parents _ it's not depended on whether your parents were rich or not. tiers; it's not depended on whether your parents were rich or not. very quick comment but _ parents were rich or not. very quick comment but people _ parents were rich or not. very quick comment but people protective i parents were rich or not. very quick comment but people protective of l parents were rich or not. very quick. comment but people protective of the money they've amassed, the assets they have that mass was that they say we paid the tax on it already why should we pay again when we die? the debate over inheritance tax has been with us as long as i've been around politics. it may be as polly says because these saving for lots of people has gone through the roof. because we've not been able to do very much for the past 12 months. maybe this is a moment for policymakers to think about what we do about that store of savings in order to try and create something fresh and new for those new generations who are rather trapped at the moment.— generations who are rather trapped at the moment. thank you very much. the will at the moment. thank you very much. they will be — at the moment. thank you very much.
10:46 pm
they will be back _ at the moment. thank you very much. they will be back again _ at the moment. thank you very much. they will be back again at _ at the moment. thank you very much. they will be back again at half - at the moment. thank you very much. they will be back again at half past i they will be back again at half past seven for another look at the front pages. coming up next someone will tell me. it's click. hey, welcome to click. we are going to start with a quiz this week. were going to play a game of guess the famous face. using possibly the freakiest faces that you've seen in a while was up they are pretty disturbing, are they lara? thea;r disturbing, are they lara? they certainly are. _ disturbing, are they lara? they certainly are. they _ disturbing, are they lara? they certainly are. they have - disturbing, are they lara? they certainly are. they have to i disturbing, are they lara? tie: certainly are. they have to say the end result isn't quite the scariest. the process is actually making them.
10:47 pm
okay. this may very well be something you can unsay but here we go. fik something you can unsay but here we to. :, , , ., , something you can unsay but here we to. :, , ,., , go. 0k who is this and who's this and who is _ go. 0k who is this and who's this and who is this? _ go. 0k who is this and who's this and who is this? right _ go. 0k who is this and who's this and who is this? right for - go. 0k who is this and who's this and who is this? right for that i and who is this? right for that while ou and who is this? right for that while you ponder _ and who is this? right for that while you ponder it _ and who is this? right for that while you ponder it let - and who is this? right for that while you ponder it let me i and who is this? right for that while you ponder it let me tell and who is this? right for that i while you ponder it let me tell you that this is what happens when you ask nai to generate fake faces based on other faces. ask nai to generate fake faces based on otherfaces. are ask nai to generate fake faces based on other faces. are you ask nai to generate fake faces based on otherfaces. are you ready? to come the answers the first one is a blend of lara and me. so odd. i think it's more you than me honest. i think it's more you than me. okay. the next one is chris fox and omar. and this is how our laws and our kitty. i think the really odd bit is seen the progression of one person to
10:48 pm
another. :, , , ., ., , another. now, this is a really weird fun thing that's _ another. now, this is a really weird fun thing that's come _ another. now, this is a really weird fun thing that's come out _ another. now, this is a really weird fun thing that's come out of - another. now, this is a really weird fun thing that's come out of the i fun thing that's come out of the really serious issue that were going to be talking about for the rest of the program. about for the rest of the programme, and that is the fact that computers have got much, much better at recognising faces — but not all faces. especially faces that aren't white. 2020 highlighted many inequalities in how we treat each other as humans. inequalities in who could afford to shelter from the virus and who had no choice but to physically go to work. and inequalities in how we are treated by the authorities. the killing of george floyd, the protests that followed and this week's conviction of derek chauvin have reminded us all that racism still exists in our societies and we all need work together to truly root it out. and it is against this backdrop that we are going to be looking at biases in technology — an industry which has often
10:49 pm
been criticised for coding our prejudices into its products. so it needs to get things right right? people fixing the world has been looking at how you can create facial recognition systems that work for everyone. you know those passport gates at the airport? the you know those passport gates at the airort? , :, ., airport? the thing is for me that often don't _ airport? the thing is for me that often don't work _ airport? the thing is for me that often don't work as _ airport? the thing is for me that often don't work as well - airport? the thing is for me that often don't work as well as i airport? the thing is for me that often don't work as well as they| often don't work as well as they should — often don't work as well as they should. sometimes he could take me 5hould. sometimes he could take me several— 5hould. sometimes he could take me several goe5 before i finally get 5everal goe5 before i finally get through — 5everal goe5 before i finally get through. and sometimes they don't seem _ through. and sometimes they don't seem to _ through. and sometimes they don't seem to work at all. it's a little bit annoying and i'm not sure why it's going — bit annoying and i'm not sure why it's going on or why. at least the issue _ it'5 going on or why. at least the issue at— it's going on or why. at least the issue at the _ it's going on or why. at least the issue at the gates i5n't affecting my livelihood. i travelled to meet
10:50 pm
facial recognition is slowly seeping into everything we do. while it can be a convenient way of interacting with tech for some, it has been creating problems for others. you know those passport gates at the airport? well, the thing is for me, they often don't work as well as they should. sometimes it can take me several goes before i finally get through, and sometimes they don't even seem to work at all. it's a little bit annoying and i'm never quite sure what is going on, or why. but at least the issue at the gates is not affecting my livelihood. uber introduced this face—recognition technology. they sent messages out, saying that "occasionally we are going to ask you to take a selfie of yourself". they compare against the profile picture you have got on there. so it is quite dark and i had a cap on and i took a selfie and i got an e—mail about 11 o'clock, saying "your account has been deactivated due to not being recognised. we have chosen to end our partnership with you. i hope you understand this." you know, iwas shocked at the time — i did not know what to do. sahir has since sent dozens of messages to uber eats, and he has got a similar generic response each time. he asked for his case to be
10:51 pm
reviewed and whether it would be acceptable if the mcdonald's manager where he usually picks his deliveries up from could vouch for him. he got nowhere. so all of these messages were sent by you? mmm—hmm. and that's the first message that got back? yeah, but as you can see, it's a generic message. uber says it believes the picture provided to its system... ..an assertion sahir denies. when he pleaded with the company to be able to appeal the decision and asked for a review of his file, uber told him the decision was final. five months on, sahir is still waiting for a response to his letter that he sent to holland, where uber�*s appeal team is based. since we have taken on his case, uber has agreed to share the image captured on the night of the incident. so 22 of our members have been dismissed by uber eats for substitution, and that is through a facial recognition software system that uber eats use. of that figure, 12 of them were bame and four of those were from a brazilian—portuguese heritage. we've since spoken to another
10:52 pm
union who have said that their members, too, have faced similar issues. so basically, uber launched a new system to check the real—time id. they have blocked my account for — on that time. it's very bad for me because i have no other source of income. in a statement, uber said: these stories show us just how crucial it is to get this right. these systems have got to be robust and they've got to work for everyone. a key part of the problem is often within the data sets these algorithms have been trained on. they are often built from images scraped from the web — images
10:53 pm
of celebrities in the media or pictures on social networks. even our data sets predicting a wedding dress will show, you know, the western christian wedding as the prediction for that, because it's very heavily influenced by western media. so as a result of that — of course, western media, it is not very diverse, does not feature people of colour in a lot of tv shows. the problem of doing it this way is no way to the diversity of the people. that's overly white and overly male. so now some companies are hoping that al could solve the problem. using the might of generative adversarial networks. or ganz for short. to see how it works we even embarked on a little experiment. these are the faces of the clique team which we fed
10:54 pm
directly into an off the shop ganz software for video. on the right is the image of the person the software already knows. and we are on the left. the algorithm starts by comparing the facial features it knows to the new image that is looking at. after hundreds of iterations it's able to look up what makes that facebook the way it does. at least mathematically, anyway. once we have this digital replica that we could start playing around with different features. we can fiddle with age, ethnicity and mixed faces. but most importantly create people that don't exist at all. this technology is used to create large databases of faces which is then used to trade facial recognition systems. by creating faces in this way isn't eat now. if you want to create something that works and treats everyone more equally the real images you feed into the ganz have to be representative for life.
10:55 pm
after all we wouldn't be looking straight into the camera in the real world. this is a photo shoot by generate a photo shoot in the us. a company specialising in a company specialising in creating gan images. it spent several months taking pictures of thousands of people. these models were specifically chosen for their diversity, but they are also being captured doing all sorts of things. so do you think that gans can totally eliminate bias in an area like facial recognition? totally is probably a very strong term, but i think they can mitigate significantly, yes, i think so. i would say that if you do collect more real data,
10:56 pm
if you are able to do that, then you should do that. this technique should optimise how these systems work, but what is more important are the people behind the code. the reality is that technology always reflects the biases that exist in society. and just changing facial recognition tools to make them more accurate isn't going to change that. how did it feel back in october when you realised that you were going to lose your livelihood? it was horrible, i can't even explain it. sleepless nights, things were going on in my head. "what am i going to do now, how am i going to survive?" photos ju5t stories like sahir�*s show us just how important it is to have people on the other side that you can easily talk to and reason with. ethical debates around how these technologies are used and deployed need to continue, and life—impacting decisions shouldn't be left to machines alone.
10:57 pm
and we have much more on the subject of ai and we have much more on the subject of al bias _ and we have much more on the subject of al bias in _ and we have much more on the subject of ai bias in the full—length version _ of ai bias in the full—length version which you can find on iplayer~ — version which you can find on iplayer~ as _ version which you can find on ipla er. : , , :, version which you can find on ipla er. a version which you can find on iplaer. ,, , , iplayer. as ever you can keep up with the team _ iplayer. as ever you can keep up with the team on _ iplayer. as ever you can keep up with the team on social- iplayer. as ever you can keep up with the team on social media. | iplayer. as ever you can keep up. with the team on social media. at bbc click. thanks for watching will see you soon. hello. the sunny, dry theme to the april weather continued through the course of the weekend. this was the picture in wiltshire on sunday, so similar to many areas, blue sky overhead butjust quite dry and in fact quite cracked ground. some parts of southern england has
10:58 pm
seen barely any rainfall throughout the entire month so far. now this week a return to some scattered showers. we won't all be seeing them, but there is, thankfully, a little bit of rain in the forecast. and things turning a bit colder as well. we've got a small, slow—moving area of low pressure moving in from the north, slowly slipping south over the next few days. so monday morning, then, starts off on a bit of a milder note. particularly for scotland where we've got more cloud. still likely to see a frost across parts of england and wales, particularly in the north. monday morning, then, initially quite a bit of cloud in the south but that will tend to break up so quite a lot of sunshine coming through. there will be more cloud for scotland with some patchy showers heading in and they will be heavier during the course of the afternoon for parts of eastern scotland. one or two into northern england and northern ireland. further south in the sunshine it's also less windy than recent days as well, so we are losing that biting easterly wind. still a bit of an onshore breeze making things cooler around the east coast, but further west temperatures for the likes of cardiff and belfast are up to about 16 degrees on monday. and then as we move through monday night into tuesday this area of low pressure still with us as it
10:59 pm
moves its way south we will start to see some showers rotating around that area of low pressure. so hit and miss scattered showers on tuesday, but they will probably avoid east anglia and the southeast where we could really do with a bit of rainfall around. staying quite mild in the south, up to about 16 degrees in the sunshine, but turning colder from the north as the winds start to come in from a northerly direction. just seven degrees or so for aberdeen. into wednesday i think the focus of the showers probably for wales and the southwest of england. fewer showers around elsewhere, perhaps one or two around these east coasts where it is, again, going to feel chilly. just seven degrees for the likes of aberdeen. but could well be 15 or 16 for southern parts of england and wales too. but as low pressure drifts off towards the near continent that's going to open the doors for these cold north or north easterly winds, once again coming down from the arctic. so temperatures in the cold side towards the end of the week for thursday into friday, just about getting into double figures by day but do be prepared if you've got gardening plans, we could well see a return of frosty nights. bye for now.
11:00 pm
this is bbc news with the latest headlines for viewers in the uk and around the world. international aid is being sent to india as oxygen shortages drive up the coronavirus death toll. we report from delhi. we've seen body after body being brought in. it's hard for anyone to keep count, but what workers have been telling me is that the real scale of deaths caused by covid—19 in india is a lot higher than what official numbers reflect. the missing indonesian navy submarine is found split into three pieces on the sea floor. this is the scene in los angeles where celebrities are arriving for this year's oscar ceremony. it's scaled down, but still the biggest most glamorous night
29 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC News Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on