tv HAR Dtalk BBC News May 9, 2021 11:30am-12:01pm BST
11:30 am
the labour leader sir keir starmer is preparing to reshuffle his team after the party's disappointing performance in the elections — he's already sacked his deputy angela rayner. nicola sturgeon warns the westminster government against using legal arguments to prevent a second independence referendum, after a fourth consecutive victory for the snp. disruption continues on some of britain's busiest rail lines, after small cracks are found in some high speed trains. now on bbc news, it is time for hardtalk. welcome to hardtalk, i'm stephen sackur. month by month, us president joe biden is shifting away from trump—era foreign policy positions. but how dramatic will the pivot be? in the middle east, there are signs of a changed
11:31 am
approach to the region's two oil—rich adversaries saudi arabia and iran — more pressure on the saudis, more engagement with tehran. my guest is the influential boss of saudi arabia's al arabiya english news channel, mohammed alyahya. have the saudis forfeited america's unstinting support? mohammed alyahya in dubai, welcome to hardtalk. thank you for having me. it's a pleasure to have you on the show. would you accept that life has
11:32 am
become much more difficult for saudi arabia under the presidency in washington ofjoe biden than it was under donald trump? ithink, you know, us—saudi relations have always had their ups and downs and, you know, disagreement between the united states and saudi arabia has never reached 100%. the disagreements that we saw under the obama administration are very similar with the disagreements we're seeing today, that — notjust saudi arabia, but other regional actors have with the biden administration. namely, it is, you know, appeasing the iranian regime, returning to the flawed nuclear deal and the consequences that it had on the region. so — so, you know, as a result of this administration's middle east policy, saudi arabia does not have it easy, gulf countries do not have it easy. but i think the actors in the region that will suffer,
11:33 am
i think, the most as a result of the biden administration's middle east posture — as we see it right now at this time — are countries like iraq and syria and lebanon and yemen, where an empowered iran, you know, can cause more destruction, can cultivate its proxies even more, undermine state institutions in those countries even more. so, you know, the more billions we see going into iran's pockets and the rgc�*s pockets — the revolutionary guards in iran — the more suffering we will see in the region, concentrated in areas outside the gulf. yeah, interesting. i ask you about saudi diplomacy and you choose to train yourfire on iran — i guess we might have expected that — but nonetheless, surely saudi arabia has to learn some lessons, and learn them quick? and one lesson that surely is coming from america right now is that saudi's war in yemen has been an absolute disaster. so is saudi ready to reverse course, reassess? saudi arabia has already done that and, you know, i — i disagree with the characterisation of the war
11:34 am
as a saudi war. it's fundamentally a civil war in yemen between the government there — the legitimate government, backed by un resolution 2216 and by the united kingdom and the united states — on one hand and the iranian—backed proxy, the houthi militia. saudi military operations in yemen are not nearly as frequent as they were in the past. today, saudi arabia has put a ceasefire agreement — a comprehensive one — on the table right now that the houthis are yet to accept. and we can see that the iranian—backed militia in that country, ansarullah, houthis, after the foreign terrorist organisation designation was lifted by the biden administration, did not wait more than one day to march on marib and to consolidate those gains in yemen, and lob rockets into saudi arabia and escalate. and that was a predictable development after the signals that came from the white house. i mean, the iranians consolidated their gains
11:35 am
in syria, lebanon, iraq, right after the 2015 nuclear deal was signed by president obama. so it's not a secret what an empowered and wealthy revolutionary guards and tehran is capable of doing. well, again... crosstalk. they see a similar iran—us policy and they're acting the same way they acted before. mr alyahya, the geopolitics of all of this is important, but maybe even more important is the humanitarian aspect. the world food programme chief david beasley says the situation right now in yemen is, quote, "hell. absolutely horrendous. there are 16 million yemenis who are deeply food insecure. many of that number are facing a very real threat of famine." now, the international community wants saudi to end its blockade of key ports to allow humanitarian aid to flow in much quicker and more efficiently. is saudi arabia ready to do that? irrespective of talk of a nationwide ceasefire, is saudi ready to lift that blockade?
11:36 am
of course. i mean, saudi arabia is the number one provider of humanitarian aid to yemen, both directly and through united nations organs, and it's been doing that even before the war started. and the humanitarian situation before the war was also a dire one, it's not come as a result... crosstalk. saudi arabia — forgive me, saudi arabia is still blockading key ports. it is stopping aid getting to places it needs to be. will that blockade... crosstalk. is your news channel — is your news channel reporting the truth about this? of course it's reporting the truth about this. we have people on the ground in yemen. almost all yemen's ports are actually open right now. some airport, there are restrictions on there, and there are some restrictions on hodeidah. the problem with hodeidah right now is that it's one of the most important places for the iran—backed houthi militia to take hold of, in order to continue its ground offensive. saudi arabia has repeatedly
11:37 am
offered the un to take full control of hodeidah, including its port, and that hasn't led to anywhere that is workable yet. but again, saudi arabia does have a full—fledged and comprehensive ceasefire agreement on the table right now that includes opening all ports. that was answered by iran, by its houthis, with a brutal offensive on marib — one of the cities that is not yet under houthi control, but is deeply threatened by the houthis. and, you know, one thing that's important to mention that we don't see nearly enough, especially in western media coverage of the war in yemen, is the humanitarian situation of people that are living under the rule of houthis, in sana'a and taiz and elsewhere. the reality of the matter is that after ali abdullah saleh — who was not a saint by any means — exited this alliance with the houthis, after they executed him at the behest of iran, we saw no limits to the brutality of the houthis. we've seen systematic rape in theirjails, we've seen assassinations ofjournalists, we've seen assassinations of civil society members.
11:38 am
i mean, living under houthi areas has been nothing short of hell. listen, i want to stop you... crosstalk. i want to stop you because it is important that this is a question and answer session and you are saying very interesting things. and there is no doubt that the humanitarian suffering and the violence is on both sides of the front line in yemen — no doubt about that at all — but i'm just wondering for you, as a news channel majority owned by the saudi state, whether you report the truth about the scale of saudi bombing of yemen, the impact it's had on civilians across the country, the unbelievable figures, frankly — more than 20,000 air strikes by the saudi—led coalition since the war began. human rights watch documenting at least 90 apparently unlawful saudi—led coalition air strikes. do you tell the truth about all of this on your saudi—owned channel? of course.
11:39 am
i mean, some of the most detailed and around—the—clock coverage of the yemen war — especially when the majority of the fighting happened, which is not the past year — was covered on al arabiya and representatives of the houthis were on the channel, representatives of iran were invited as guests on the channel. you know, if you ask any arabic speaker that does watch al arabiya, it's probably one of the only places to go to understand the conflict, to hear points of views of people from both sides of the conflict and the geopolitical consequences of that. the biden administration has ended its support for the saudi—led coalition�*s offensive. it is reviewing all saudi arms sales. you obviously have close links to the saudi government for all sorts of different reasons, many of them journalistic. is it your view that the very top leadership in saudi arabia now understands that this
11:40 am
war has to be brought to an end very quickly? well, it's important to note that this is not saudi arabia's war. the reality of the matter is that was a war between the legitimate government in yemen, abdrabbuh mansur hadi's government — which is backed by un resolution 2216, backed by the united kingdom, by france, by the united states, to name just a few countries — and on the other side, an iran—backed houthi militia that has acted and conducted itself in a very criminal fashion, that has weaponised aid. and as we mentioned, you know, has systematic abuse, torture, rape in its prisons. so for saudi arabia to withdraw will not solve yemen's problems. saudi arabia is in close cooperation today — from what i understand, speaking to officials — with the united states. saudi arabia has drew back a lot of its military operations in yemen today. and just to clarify —
11:41 am
what happened today is that the united states has suspended offensive military aid to saudi arabia and yemen. 0r military support rather, it's not aid because — and what we're seeing is that defensive capabilities in saudi arabia are still supported by the americans. now, the line between defensive and offensive is still a matter of contention, but the reality is that saudi military operations in yemen have come almost to a complete standstill. yeah. crosstalk. that sheds light on something more important here. that's an interesting fact — that was an interesting fact. saudi's stopping... crosstalk. yeah. you allude to it... saudi stopping the war is not a panacea to yemen's problems. you allude to an interesting fact — that offensive operations have been scaled back — and i would put it to you that there are clear signs the saudi government, of course led by crown prince mohammed bin salman, is fundamentally changing its message because of the pressure from the united states, not least its message on iran. if i look backjust a few years, mbs was likening the supreme leader ayatollah
11:42 am
khomeini in iran to hitler. and now we learn that just a few weeks ago — just a few days ago, in fact — saudi officials were having meetings with the iranians and recently, mbs said, quote, "we do not want for iran to be in a difficult situation. we want iran to prosper and grow." it sounds like the tone is changing. i mean, i don't think there's a real change in what the saudis or other gulf partners in the region hope to see from iran. i think the descriptions of iran from the past are still accurate. but, you know, saudi arabia and other gulf countries and arab countries in general would love to see an iran that leverages its strength. iran is a very rich country. it has 80 million people in its population. it has ski slopes, it has beautiful areas by the caspian sea. it has industry, it has a rich
11:43 am
heritage, rich history. iran has every single ingredient to be a leading actor in the region that leads by example, that works towards economic prosperity, that adds value to its neighbours and also receives value from its neighbours. crosstalk. mr alyahya, i don't think we need to be talking too much about iran's ski slopes. i think what we need to be realistic about is that despite everything saudi arabia has tried to achieve in diplomatic terms, the us is determined to try to rejoin the so—called jcpoa — the agreement on iran's nuclear programme. that is very much alive. saudi arabia doesn't like it but is going to have to learn to live with it. that's the truth, isn't it? of course. of course, and that will be difficult for saudi arabia because an empowered iran is a national security threat for saudi arabia. it's also a national security threat for israel and various other arab governments. but, you know... crosstalk. are you saying — hang on. are you saying the americans are idiots, then? that they don't even understand what's in their own
11:44 am
national security interests? no, no. i mean, there have been many policies that have backfired and were poorly constructed and they were drafted by people who are not idiots. i mean, to call every you know, author of a bad policy an idiot, i think would be a very tedious job, stephen. let's talk about saudi arabia's broader international reputation — now, i'm thinking not so much about diplomacy and geopolitics. i'm thinking about the way people around the world have come to see saudi arabia. now, you are a very senior saudi journalist. would you share with me the feeling that the murder, the brutal murder ofjamal khashoggi in the consulate in istanbul, which was perpetrated by saudi officials who, according to american intelligence, were operating under orders from the very top, that has done immense and lasting damage to saudi's reputation, yes? i would agree, i would agree,
11:45 am
and i knewjamal khashoggi, and he was a dear friend, and i think that his murder was a huge shock in saudi arabia before it was outside of saudi arabia, and it's something that runs against the history of saudi policy and its conduct. and that's why we saw, you know, the insistence on completing the investigations and trials into the people that were responsible for this, swiftly and thoroughly. and that's what the saudis have embarked on. but the investigations haven't been completed, have they? they haven't gone to the very top because the people who carried the can for this were relatively low—level functionaries and officials. and, as i say, that us intelligence document makes it quite plain that authorisation of this operation, murderous operation, went to the very, very top and clearly involved the crown prince himself. so the intelligence document
11:46 am
was just repeating what any, you know, basic analyst with exposure to saudi arabia would tell you. of course, the people that were involved were government officials. they were people that were close to decision making circles. and that's what made the crime even more egregious than it is. so there was nothing really new in that report. there was certainly nothing that, you know, condemned the crown prince himself. essentially, there was nothing new in it. forgive me, but the conclusion that the crown prince approved the operation, the conclusion, as was in the document, the crown prince approved the operation, the murder. you're telling me that that's not significant? that's not true. what the report said was that it was unlikely that the crown prince didn't know about the operation because of the proximity of the people that were involved in it. that's not a conclusion. that's an observation that many people have made and many people can make and continue
11:47 am
to make, but that's in no way evidence. that's no way a conclusion that would hold up in any court of law. well, as you've pointed out to me, you're a seniorjournalist. and not only that, you're a real friend, were a friend of the late mr khashoggi. i'm sure you are much more aware of me of the degree to which jamal khashoggi himself feared that his end would come in this sort of way. he had told people, i don't know if he told you personally, but he described in his newspaper column how he had been informed by saudi al-qahtani himself, a very key lieutenant of crown prince mbs. he'd been told that he was no longer allowed to tweet, not allowed to write, not allowed to talk. qahtani had said to him, "you cannot do anything any more. you are done." now, you're a saudi journalist, you're a friend ofjamal khashoggi, and it sounds to me like you don't want to accept that this goes to the very top of the state which now owns your channel.
11:48 am
no, it's not about accepting or not accepting. i'm not going to sling mud without any shred of evidence, and that's what we've been seeing a lot of throughout this time and the coverage ofjamal khashoggi's murder. the reality is jamal khashoggi never told me personally that and any observer that sees the politicisation of jamal�*s case would understand that all sorts of leaks, all sorts of hearsay has been peddled and spread in this case. we saw it with the leaks in turkey, we saw it with the leaks in the united states. we saw it everywhere. i mean, this was a political football that didn't last just for one week, two weeks, three weeks. it lasted for many, many months. what we can go by is the facts of the case, the realities of the case and the trials that happened, and for... see, i'm very interested in the way you, because you are a senior commentator and journalist, as well as running the channel al arabiya
11:49 am
in english, you characterise saudi arabia as being, if i can put it this way, in tune with a sort of modernising, reforming trend across parts of the arab world. this is a quote from you. "young people are much more "in tune with other young people these days "in other parts of the world. what these young arabs "are rejecting is antiquated, archaic theocratic ideology, "which they've been spoon—fed, controlled by groups "like iran's revolutionary guards." that approach no longer works, you say, but who are you kidding? i mean, saudi arabia is no reformed, modernised society. it is still run along deeply authoritarian, ideologically conservative lines, is it not? no, no, it's not. i mean, it was. that might have been a fair characterisation ten years ago, but if you ask anybody that's visited saudi arabia ten years ago and visited today, they would tell you that they see two different countries. the reality is that today young women in saudi arabia
11:50 am
have the right to drive. they have the right to, more importantly than drive, you know, live alone without recourse. they can travel without the permission of male guardians. they can attend university and choose their majors without the permission of male guardians. they can take jobs, choose their careers without the permission of male guardians, and that's more than what women can do in other gulf countries and other arab countries, certainly more than women can do in iran. all that happened in lightning speed. and that's a reflection, of course, of the government's will to reform, but also of what i mentioned in the article that you cited — young people are ready for this. you know, the myth that saudi society was conservative and wouldn't accept these changes and had to move slowly was shattered very, very quickly in saudi arabia. this new saudi arabia you're alluding to doesn't seem to match the saudi arabia that i see. let's be very specific. you run... hang on. have you visited saudi arabia? when was the last time you visited? yeah, i actually visited
11:51 am
the king abdullah economic city to see this sort of modernisation programme taking flesh. as it happens, that city doesn't really seem to have gotten very far, but i'm more interested in basic statistics. you tell me, as a saudi journalist, how many political prisoners are there in saudi arabia today? i can't give you a numberfor that. why not? because, you know, the issue of political prisoners is an extremely politicised one. excuse me, you've just told me... hang on, hang on. you'vejust told me... many, many, many... you've just told me this is a modernised, reformed saudi arabia where rights are respected, not least of women. surely in this modern, much more democratised saudi arabia, you, as an investigative journalist, working as a boss of a news channel, could find out how many political prisoners the kingdom holds. but that's a loaded question, that's an extremely loaded question, because many of the people that you would consider political prisoners are in fact not political prisoners, but prisoners who have been tried and convicted of
11:52 am
various other crimes. you know, you can take the example of one gentleman who was tried and convicted recently who was in yemen trying to cooperate and join al-qaeda in that country. and he was described by the state department as an aid worker. he ran a twitter account that condemned saudi arabia's support for the anti—isis coalition, saying that this will open saudi arabia for attacks and sympathising with isis. you know, many people would consider that free speech and consider it freedom of expression for him to go and support al-qaeda in the arabian peninsula. that's important to consider that the entire al-qaeda contingent in saudi arabia, almost all of it has moved to yemen. so, you know... the thing is... the thing is you can read the amnesty international reports, the human rights watch reports. you can see that there are still many individuals who have done nothing more than dissent against the government who are locked up.
11:53 am
we know that for a fact. you may not want to acknowledge it, but we know it for a fact. when you told me that women have these extraordinary new rights in saudi arabia, the truth is a woman in saudi arabia cannot file a lawsuit on her own today. they still, women still need permission from a male relative to marry or live on their own. and those women who disobey their "guardian" can still face arrest. so i'm just wondering why you portray it... that's not true. women can live on their own without the permission of their guardian. i never said they couldn't live on their own without permission. i just said that those who disobey their guardian can still face arrest. all of this is true. i just wonder why you as a journalist do not present the truth about what's happening in saudi arabia today. is it because you're owned by the saudi state and you know what happens to journalists who speak out against the leadership in saudi arabia, because yourfriend was jamal khashoggi? you know, i think these are
11:54 am
very low blows and unbecoming of the bbc, frankly, but the reality of the matter is that there is a long ways to go still in terms of women empowerment in saudi arabia. there's still a long ways to go in terms of legal reform in saudi arabia. many of the problems that we've seen have been long—standing. you know, saudi arabia's taken baby steps in introducing women's education in the country over the past years. today, we're seeing improvements in women's rights happening at a much faster rate inside saudi arabia. you know, the reality of the matter is that it is still a work in progress, and it's one that is happening at varying rates on several different files. mohammed alyahya, i'm sorry to cut you off, but we do have to end there. i thank you very much indeed forjoining me on hardtalk. thank you.
11:55 am
hello. some pretty lively weather heading our way through the week ahead. low pressure dominating means there will be some fairly frequent showers but it also means we're going to be pulling in air from the atlantic so in contrast to last week much milder, we'll lose that risk of overnight frosts finally. here is the low in question. for sunday, with the centre of the low closest to northern ireland and scotland, here's where we'll see the most frequent showers. much of england and wales will have a dry afternoon. there's a lot of mild air getting pulled up on the southerly wind right the way across the uk but some particularly warm air through the afternoon for east anglia and the south—east of england. we could see temperatures here in the sunshine up to 20 or 21 degrees. always a bit more cloud further west, the tail end of that weather
11:56 am
front could bring some heavier showers to the south—west and wales as the afternoon comes to a close. northern ireland and scotland certainly getting the heaviest of the day's showers, some rumbles of thunder possible, some more persistant cloud for the north—west of scotland, some pretty blustery winds as well. but still milder than yesterday. temperatures in mid—teens. now, through the evening and overnight where we've got that warm, muggy air across the south—east and east anglia, we could see some very heavy showers breaking out. further rumbles of thunder and local downpours moving into the early hours of monday, those look like they could even close in on the coast of the north east of england. a mild night, though, temperatures 11 or 12 degrees here but across the board we're frost free with temperatures no lower than six or seven even across the more sheltered parts of scotland. the low still with us on monday potentially pushing out some more persistent rain out towards the north—east of scotland. i think that will head towards the northern isles, though, this area of heavy rain
11:57 am
as monday shapes up. towards the west, the low centre still rolling away to the west of ireland, that means lots more showers for northern ireland and scotland through the day. a little more hit and miss across england and wales but there will be the odd sharper one. still breezy, a little cooler in the south—east but temperatures around average for the time of year which is doing a lot better than we have done in the last week or so. and that really sets the tone, then, for the rest of the week. it stays showery and our temperatures will sit in the mid—teens.
12:00 pm
this is bbc news with the latest headlines for viewers in the uk and around the world. the labour leader sir keir starmer is preparing to reshuffle his team after the party's disappointing performance in the elections — he's already sacked his deputy angela rayner. when the leader of the party on friday— when the leader of the party on friday says he takes full responsibility for the election result— responsibility for the election result in_ responsibility for the election result in hartlepool in particular and then— result in hartlepool in particular and then scapegoats angela rayner, i think many— and then scapegoats angela rayner, i think many of us feel that was unfain — nicola sturgeon warns the westminster government against using legal arguments to prevent a second independence referendum after a fourth consecutive victory for the snp. the people of scotland have voted for the snp on the strength of offering when the time is right an independence referendum. the priority at the moment is not court cases, it's not
26 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC News Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on