tv The Film Review BBC News October 15, 2022 11:45pm-12:01am BST
11:45 pm
hello and a very warm welcome to what is the last ever film review on bbc news. i'mjane hill and with us, of course, for ourfinal fling is mark kermode. hi, mark. hello. we won't end with a whimper, but with a bang — we have halloween ends. does it, though?! we have a new version of all quiet on the western front. emily, inspired by the life of emily bronte. that makes me livid. and for the king crimson fans, in the court of the crimson king. yeah, it's quite a striking mix you got for us. it is, so let's start with halloween ends. please, please, please let this be over! so, a few years ago, david gordon green and jamie lee curtis did something interesting with the halloween franchise, they updated halloween with added ptsd — hooray, something interesting! and then they spoilt it all by saying it is a trilogy,
11:46 pm
so then we had halloween kills, which is just back to the usual stuff, plod, plod, plod, plod, stabby, stabby, plod, plod. now, halloween ends which has a usual plodding stabby stuff, but with some added nietzschen about you look long into the abyss and the abyss looks back into you. and some nonsense about it takes a village to raise a child and maybe evil is being passed on. here's a clip! alison is not equipped for this relationship and i will not let her get hurt, so stay away. you started this! you brought me in, you invited me! but you're the one to blame. if i can't have her, no—one will. you want to help alison? let her live her life. she has me now. now, on the positive side, it's got an interesting opening seven minutes.
11:47 pm
there is a bit at the beginning when i went, this is great, anything happened, i hadn't expected that, great, and then it's... oh, no, it's that film again. and remember, with the first halloween, good, very cheap movie, it was all to do with tension and suspense and building on that stuff and some genuinely scary moments. here — no tension, no suspense, no scary moments, no shocks, no surprises. compare this to, for example, smile, which is currently doing terrifically well at the box office, which is a kind of quiet, quiet, bang horror movie, but it does it well. this just feels like patience—testingly dull stuff. the only thing that's worth saying about it is it should never have been a trilogy. you got away with the 2018 thing, hurray. halloween ends, please, let this be the end of it. i never, never, never want to hear anything about michael myers ever again in my whole life. but you just know a few years on, it will be halloween begins again,
11:48 pm
the curse lives on. i don't know how you make a horror film that's not scary. in fact, it's a horror film i could watch if it's not scary! all those times i have said to you, you should go and see a horrorfilm — don't, don't! stay away from this one. on a much more serious note... absolutely. all quiet on the western front, which is a new adaptation of the �*20s novel, which was the best picture winner in 1930, the adaptation of it. this is a netflix—backed german production, which is germany's entry for the 95th oscars. directed by edward berger. he said it's a physical, visceral, very modern film that's never been told for my country's perspective, never been made into a german language film. we now have the chance to make an anti—war film that will truly touch audiences. it is in cinemas now and on netflix on the 28th. i think it's worth seeing on the big screen because i think it is visually really, really impressive. it's... not unlike 1917, it puts you there in this absolute
11:49 pm
hellscape seen through the eyes of these incredibly young men. and i think it's genuinely, properly harrowing. you watched it — what did you think? genuinely harrowing. i thought it was brilliantly made. it looks fantastic. it's stunning to look at. worth seeing... but it breaks you, it breaks you, as it should. we all know how many young men lost their lives in the first world war, but it again makes you think about the horrors, what they lived through. clearly, all the ptsd that they didn't even have a name for back then. it's not an easy watch. of course it's not an easy watch, but it's beautifully made. and nor should it be an easy watch, and i think that's the point. i think it's really well made, terrific score, incidentally. very, very powerful. and i think worth seeing on the big screen, but it will be on netflix on the 28th. i would agree with that. and great central performances, a newcomer, as the main young soldier, and he's terrific. i think the whole thing is really, really well done and the fact that they are using very modern techniques, applying them to an old story, but making it completely relevant, much in the same way that i think 1917 did. so, to emily, which is an imagined
11:50 pm
life of emily bronte, with a terrific central performance by emma mackey. the film begins with charlotte bronte saying to emily, "how did you write wuthering heights?" she is kind of shocked by it, and then the film flashes back to speculate about where that came from. we see the young bronte sisters telling each other stories, we see brother branwell dazzling emily before going off the rails. we see the growing struggles between the sisters, and we see the arrival of a handsome new curate, who insists that he loves the rain, but not as much as the girls. here's a clip. giggling look, he does like the rain! he loves it! the sounds of it. the smell of it. from now on, we shall call him miss celia amelia. i'm a fool. no, you're not. i'd rather be a fool| than not live at all.
11:51 pm
you're an embarrassment to us. do you know what they call you in the village? - stop it, charlotte. no! they call you the strange one. and you are. mother would be ashamed i to see who you've become. every time i come home, i see more and more what you are becoming. i i won't let you drag me down. i won't! i'm going to make something of myself. charlotte... so, this is written and directed by frances o'connor, who of course is an actor—turned—director. making her directorial feature debut and i think she does a terrificjob of it. the first thing to say is, in much the same way as andrew dominik�*s blonde is not a biopic about marilyn munro, this is not a biopic about emily bronte. this is much more an imagined life, it's an attempt to put on screen the emotions and feelings of the writing, and to do it in an inventive way that perhaps lets you into the real—life character more. but it's not factual, it's not tied to factual detail. i thought it was great, partly because it's really vibrant, it's a really, really lively film. biopics, particularly
11:52 pm
about writers, can often be, "and then i sat down and wrote something by candlelight "and it was very hard...the end." what this does is it kind of take creative liberties. the performances are universally great, again, another very good score. you feel the landscape, you get a sense of what's inspiring her as a writer. but there's also — i'm delighted to say this — an element of horror in it! is there?! there is! in emily bronte? exactly. i know the correct way is we should say gothic, ok, but, no. gothic and horror are basically the same thing. and there is a sequence in it involving putting on a mask during a parlour game, which kind of then turns into a seance, which i think is one of the creepiest things i've seen in a very long time. so, for the last time, i'm going to say this to you — it's not a horrorfilm, and it genuinely isn't, but it has things in it that i thought were properly creepy in a way which i found
11:53 pm
really exciting. and i have to say, i did not expect to like it anything like as much as i did. i thought it was really inventive. interesting. and i really, really enjoyed it and i think you'll like it too. and just a smidge of horror. iwill watch, i promise. a really interesting choice you have for us as our last one. prog ahoy! this is a film which is in cinemas on wednesday the 19th, just one day, and then one day streaming on saturday the 22nd. in the court of the crimson king, a documentary about king crimson, who are the musicians�* musicians, the band that people look up to and worship and idolise. theirfans, hardcore fans, literally feel like their lives have been changed by king crimson. 50th anniversary of the band, robert fripp, who is the kind of mainstay of the band, agreed to let toby amies, who made the man whose mind exploded make a documentary. i have to say that one of the things that comes across is that most of the members of the band, including robert fripp, have not found being in king crimson an easy experience. here's a clip. the overview of my personal involvement in king crimson is that it's been incredibly unhappy.
11:54 pm
in a word, wretched, i would say, from 1969 until 2013. singing now, i don't know if you are a big king crimson fan. i'll tell you what i love about the documentary — on the one hand, it is about the pain of making art, it's like if you're going to take music this seriously, it's not a lot of laughs. but the documentary is funny, because toby amies is a very sharp filmmaker who understands how to put something together in a way that, even amidst great sadness and great darkness and huge amounts of conflict — i mean, huge amounts of conflict — i found the film really entertaining. i think that no matter what you think about king crimson, you could enjoy this documentary. what's interesting is that i'm afraid i knew nothing about king crimson. i know an awful lot now. i was fascinated by some of it. it reminded me of whiplash.
11:55 pm
oh, that's interesting. because robert fripp is such a hard task master, clearly brilliant, but, you know, would you want him as your boss? and that reminded me of that whole theme in whiplash, where do you... he practices every day, but where does that cross over into just taking it too far, let the perfectionism, all of that. we saw him practising there and there is a moment in the documentary where he's had a really long day and he says, "i've got to go and do two hours practice now," and toby, the director, says, "can't you just give yourself the night off?" and he says, "you wouldn't ask an olympic athlete that." ok, that's right, on the one hand, but on the other hand, just give yourself a night off! yes, just enjoy it! you will still be able to... but i think what makes it work is that there is humour in there amidst all the angst and the torture and it does also accept the fact that they are remarkable musicians. yes, remarkable. and that is a really interesting choice, i think, on which to end. thank you. it has been an absolute pleasure and a privilege.
11:56 pm
although i've sat here since 2018 and i still haven't got to the end of a horrorfilm, have i? well... i'm nothing but a disappointment to you, mark. no. i think what you've done, which i've been really impressed by, is that you've listened to my trying to sell horror movies to you and i think you've decided, "horror is not for me," which is perfectly fine. horror is definitely not for everyone but thank you for putting up with all the times i've tried to tell you... the amount of times i've said to you, "it's not a horror movie" when, honestly, it was. but it's been a real pleasure, i've really, really enjoyed our conversations. and if it's encouraged anybody to go and see something they wouldn't have seen otherwise, then great. i was trying to think of something profound to say at the end and i was thinking of, "here's looking at you, kid", but i think it's better to say this from lock, stock and two smoking barrels, "it's been emotional." mark, bless you, thank you very much indeed and thank you for watching and i hope you continue to enjoy your film going. bye—bye from both of us.
11:57 pm
hello. the weekend started with plenty of showers, some heavy and thundery in places, gusty winds. as one area of low pressure begins to pull away from the uk, there'll be fewer showers around for part two of the weekend. for much of the uk, for much of the day, it'll stay dry. this is that area of low pressure pulling away. however, this is another one moving in towards the southwest later in the day, so there will be some wetter weather pushing north again by sunday evening. let's look at how sunday begins. and still some showers around, especially in scotland, some heavy ones in the west. temperatures a little lower than this in rural parts. a cooler night across southern areas of the uk. the showers in scotland will tend to fade away and they'll still be around the northern isles in the afternoon. but as you can see, though, elsewhere in the afternoon, for most places, it'll be dry, there'll be some sunny spells. cloud increasing in northern ireland and indeed southern england, south wales, so you could see a few showery bursts of rain heading in later in the afternoon.
11:58 pm
and by evening, it'll be turning much wetter in northern ireland as this moves north. temperatures pretty much where they're going to be over the next few days, around 12 degrees in glasgow, 18 in london. very wet on sunday evening in northern ireland. we'll see some wet and windy weather pushing north across the uk overnight and into monday morning. the winds picking up again through irish sea and adjacent coasts and into western scotland, with gales in places. a much milder night, especially across wales and england. closer to that area of low pressure on monday, it's northern ireland and northern england that could well see some showers, but it'll be scotland bearing the brunt of some heavy downpours once again. for much of england and wales in the afternoon, actually, it'll be dry, broken cloud and sunny spells and not as windy as it still will be across the northern half of the uk. temperatures on monday may well be a degree or so higher in places. as we go into tuesday, this latest area of low pressure pulls away. then there's a ridge of high pressure settling things down. there is another area of low pressure, though, sitting to our southwest. and whilst on tuesday, most places are looking dry, just the odd shower here and there, cloud mayjust start to increase across eastern
11:59 pm
scotland, northeast england. the breeze will pick up later towards the southwest, closer to that next area of low pressure, which will gradually on wednesday start to feed some outbreaks of rain in from the southwest, whereas many places will actually have another dry day. but wetter weather becoming more widespread again towards the end of the week. that's your forecast. bye for now.
12:00 am
this is bbc news, i'm lewis vaughanjones with the latest headlines for viewers in the uk and around the world... gun shots are heard after a huge fire breaks out at a prison in iran's capital, tehran. state media reports at least eight people injured. as the uk's prime minister fights for herjob — the new chancellor signals he'll make major changes to her economic policy. we have some very difficult decisions ahead, difficult decisions on spending, which is not going to rise as much as people hope and i am going to be asking all government departments to find additional efficiency savings. in northern turkey —
12:01 am
627 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC News Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on