tv HAR Dtalk BBC News November 21, 2022 12:30am-1:01am GMT
12:30 am
welcome to hardtalk, with me, zeinab badawi. my guest is president salome zourabichvili of georgia, who's on a visit here in london. her country, which was part of the soviet union, shares a long border with russia, and its capital tbilisi is just a few kilometres away from thousands of russian troops and tanks stationed in two pro—moscow backed separatist enclaves in
12:31 am
georgia. so how should georgia manage its relations with russia whilst at the same time pushing for closer ties with the west? president salome zourabichvili, welcome to hardtalk. thank you very much for welcoming me. what was your reaction when you heard about the russian—made missile dropping on polish territory, killing two people? very worried. like, i guess, the rest of the world, but maybe even more worried. and i think with my team, we spent the night listening to the news and what was
12:32 am
happening, although in a way it was going against my feeling that the nuclear balance is working so well even today that this line that is protected by nato is something that everybody is very careful about. and i was not thinking beforehand that russia deliberately would dare to touch any part of that territory, but everything can happen and there can always be a miscalculation. and there have been a number of miscalculations by the russian leaders, so nothing was excluded and so very worried. regardless of whether it was a miscalculation, you know, you didn't know, as you said, what exactly was behind it. but it has highlighted fears, hasn't it, in your neighbourhood? i mean, georgia has a border of nearly a thousand kilometres with russia. you have russian troops and tanks stationed very near your capital in the two pro—moscow backed separatist enclaves,
12:33 am
south ossetia and abkhazia. you're a small nation of barely four million. your army is about 37,000. i mean, russia, if it wanted to, could take georgia in an afternoon. do you think it might want to absorb you? 0h, russia has always wanted to absorb georgia. that's a long dream of the russian empire first, then of the soviet union that in fact incorporated the independent georgia in 1921. in 1992, �*93, what people did not know that much, russia was completely involved in the fight of the separatists against georgia and was actively militarily involved. 2008 was the latest manifestation of these attempts by russia. so we know that, we're living with that and we've been living
12:34 am
for a very long time. first of all, georgia, one has to know, has also lived many centuries with many invasions by different empires and has resisted all of that. and that's maybe a miracle or it's resilience, i don't know. but do you think russia would invade georgia? do you think that there's that possibility? no, i don't see think so. i think that the example of what happened in ukraine, even if we don't have, let's be very clear, neither the army nor the depths of territory, nor the human resource or the military resource that ukraine has. but i think that what they have now been encountering in ukraine, and they know the resilience of the georgians individually to that type of occupation. so i don't think that, but i think that there might be, if and when. and we're seeing already the humiliation of russia and the fact that it's losing this war in many respects and it has made many miscalculations, that at one point in time, for internal
12:35 am
reasons, it might be tempted of making a point over georgia where it's easier to mark some points. so i think that we have to be very careful. at the same time, i would say that that should not, in no way, determine our actions, our words and our orientation towards europe. because nobody... so vigilance needed. vigilance, but nobody will ever prevent russia attempting something if russia thinks that at that point in time it's in their best interest. but there are things that we can do to make sure that we do not favour, or make it easier, let's say. i'll ask you about that in a moment. butjust one parallel with ukraine is the donbas region, which russia's really consolidated its hold on the breakaway republics there.
12:36 am
and you've got these two separatist enclaves that are pro—russia, south ossetia and abkhazia — represents about a fifth of georgia's territory. those are lost to georgia forever, surely, aren't they, madam president? you can ask any georgian and no georgian will answer yes to that question. and i think that this what has been a question of principle for all georgians to say that's not finished. we know history and things change over history. i think that today, like never, we think that we are entering a different world of geopolitics. i think that in these enclaves, in these separatist regions, the attitude towards russia has changed a lot since the invasion, the aggression in ukraine. looking at the way russia
12:37 am
is behaving towards the people that russia was calling brothers or even russians. really? i mean, do you think that's the case? because, i mean, if you look at abkhazia, 60% of its budget comes from russia. even more in south ossetia. 90% of people there have russian passports. and i tell you what daur kove, the self—styled former foreign minister of abkhazia who stepped down last year, he says, "the georgians do not understand one simple thing. "we do not need them." yeah, that's the position of the separatist government. but the budget that you were mentioning, russia has just told the separatist governments that they will reduce drastically the budget. they're trying to occupy some lands, which is a question of principle for abkhazians, that they want to own their lands. and those parts of abkhazia that are really independentist, they might not dream of rejoining georgia, but they certainly do not dream any more to rejoin russia. but they may not rejoin georgia, is what you're saying? but if georgia is... that would be a way for you, though, wouldn't it? if georgia is the way
12:38 am
to prosperity, if georgia is the way to europe, if georgia is the way to democracy, that might become, and i think is becoming more attractive to the younger generation of abkhazians... to look at that, and we have to work in that direction, we have to show in all respects that the russian propaganda that georgia would be tempted, given the circumstances, to try a military measure against those regions is a russian lie. because georgia wants one thing. it's to reunite with those citizens that are our citizens and not to reunite only with territories. all right. but nevertheless, you say that, you know, perhaps ties are loosening in these two separatist enclaves in georgia, but you've got to pay more attention to your neighbourhood, haven't you, president zourabichvili? because i know you are very pro—western.
12:39 am
in a previous career, you were a french diplomat and you perhaps are tilting too much to the west. i mean, russia is an important economic partner for georgia. you have lots of russian tourists who go. you've got georgians who work in russia who send remittances. 27% of georgia's oil imports come from russia. so for economic reasons and also for the fact that you've got them so close, surely you need to have more of a balancing act and notjust rush into the arms of the west? i think that the strength of georgia, has been over this 30 years, we've been always in this situation. as i said, it started in �*92, immediately after the independence and russia... after the break—up of the soviet union. ..tried to use this first frozen conflict, then occupied territories in order to stop our path towards europe. and it has not been able to do that. and i think that's the strength of georgia and that's the resilience of georgia to be
12:40 am
able to continue on its path towards europe, towards nato, without being deterred by russian action. that doesn't mean that we have to look for confrontation. yeah. we have to be cautious, but we have to know where we are going. that's the point i'm making. you've got to be cautious. i tell you what laura linderman at the atlantic council eurasia centre, a think tank, says. she says, "the georgian government is looking at "the situation in ukraine in terror that they will be next "and so they are trying to walk the line "of not overtly antagonising the kremlin "while still using this historic moment to formally "apply for eu membership "and do as much as they can for ukraine." that is the right approach, isn't it? yeah, but not too much caution. i think what is important is for russia to know. not too much caution where? what do you mean? not to give the impression to russia that we are so scared that we want to defer to all russian pretensions that can happen. i think what is important
12:41 am
in order to prevent any attempt or any dream by russia of doing something is for our european partners to consolidate our path towards europe. and in that sense, i think that we have to have a positive answer to the candidate status. i don't think that we can afford a second no, because that would give the wrong message to russia, that suddenly georgia has become a grey zone, not a country determined tojoin european union and nato, but a country that is considered by the europeans of being of a different category. so i think that we have to be very clear. clarity is our best defence. and do you think that the government... because of course, as head of state, you are not head of government. that's the prime minister. do you think that the ruling georgian dream party, which backed you as president
12:42 am
in 2018, is not perhaps doing what you're suggesting sufficiently robustly? well, i've not always shared the same rhetoric. and i understand that when you are a government, you maybe have to use a different rhetoric. head of state is a different position where you can be probably freer. but i was listening just beforejoining you here to the intervention of the prime minister in the parliament today, which was a long intervention and questions, and he was very clear about the candidate status, about our orientation. sure. and i think that's what it should be. that's the prime minister of georgia, irakli garibashvili. that's right. but you have slightly differed with them. for instance, you wanted greater support for ukraine, and georgia has notjoined the european and american sanctions on ukraine. and prime minister garibashvili earlier this year dismissed sanctions as unproductive. he says, "we sympathise with everyone, "but we must
12:43 am
protect our country and people first." that's where i differ from the rhetoric, because the facts are very different. georgia has joined the international financial sanctions. we have banks that are overly compliant, because they know that they need to keep their reputation. and the country has been applying all of these sanctions, as well as, we have been part of all the international resolutions concerning ukraine and blaming russia in the un and in all the otherfora. sure. so that's where i'm saying that it's a question of rhetoric. i would never say that we are not part of the sanctions. we do not have national sanctions, and i don't know what they could be, but we are very much part of the international community in terms of financial sanctions. because president zelensky of ukraine has really been quite cross with georgia, saying that they haven't, the government hasn't shown sufficient support. he withdrew his ambassador in disapproval, and so on. yeah.
12:44 am
i mean, so you are president of georgia, but you're... you seem to have more sympathy with president zelensky of ukraine... i have good relations... ..than your own government. ..with president zelensky. i think that president zelensky, in his international diplomatic... ..has been sometimes very cross with different countries. sure. not only with georgia. we have a separate issue in...with ukraine, in that we have some georgians in the... ..leading in the elite of ukraine, that are playing a little bit of georgian politics, more than ukrainian politics. 0k. all right. but you see... to say it lightly! you see eye to eye with your... with the government? not on everything. there are always nuances. but i think that all in all, what is important is that they reiterate also the solidarity with ukraine, the orientation of georgia towards the european union. we have to become members. and nato. yeah. that's our ultimate aim, and we have no other perspective. 0k. so georgia signed an
12:45 am
association agreement with the european union in 2014, and thisjune, the european union considered applications from georgia alongside ukraine and moldova. did not grant georgia candidate status. you have called for pro—eu rallies in georgia. you've attended them yourself. you're very firmly pushing georgia towards that western european camp. so how disappointed were you when that decision was made? i was disappointed. the georgian population was disappointed. but at the same time, i think i understood and we understood that there was a specific situation of ukraine. ukraine got us where we are, with the european perspective and at the door of the candidate status, which was not expected at this stage in our relations with the european union. and it's clear that it has a link with the political situation, with the military situation of ukraine and the sensibility of...
12:46 am
and of moldova. and maybe in the last year or so, our positions on certain european recommendations and on the charles michel document that we had agreed on... charles michel is head of the european council. all of that did not make all the conditions for this granting to be immediate. yeah. but as i said before, what is important now, we have 12 recommendations of the european union, and i think that it's vital that in 2023, georgia is granted the candidate status, which doesn't mean membership. we'll have other criteria, more things to fulfil, more reforms to make. but in a strategic manner, it's important that the eu says georgia is part of this trio which we have created, and not something outside that could be an attraction for russia to play games.
12:47 am
yeah. that's what you were referring to at the beginning of the interview, that you feel that georgia has ways of ensuring that it is in the european camp as a kind of antidote to possible russian aggression. but you're not doing great on that score. as you said, the european union gave georgia 12 conditions. one of them, for instance, is over the appointment of supreme courtjudges to the supreme court. it's felt that there's too much political interference. around 20 were appointed in one go in a process that the european union said lacked credibility and integrity. do you think the government of georgia, the ruling georgian dream party, which has a very, you know, clear majority in the parliament, is serious about wanting tojoin the european union? i think they're working on it. i think that we are not perfect. i think many countries today are not perfect in these democratic achievements.
12:48 am
and i certainly am one that is pushing on all these directions so that we deliver what we have to deliver. but again, i would say that today, tomorrow, the decision of the eu has to be a more strategic one than one based formally on the criteria. not to say that we push aside the democratic reforms, that it's not important. sure. but i think that at this moment, what is predominant is the strategic issue and the risks of giving to russia the wrong message about georgia. all right. do you think the european union really wants georgia? because i tell you what the former deputy chair of the ruling georgian dream party, tamar chugoshvili, said in august, who says, "the party's leadership "has been stating repeatedly that the eu "has never intended to grant candidate status to georgia. "no matter what the authorities do, "such status will not be granted." does the eu want you? you want the eu, but do they want you? i think i know the eu a bit more than many. and you they do?
12:49 am
you think they are genuine? i think that they are genuine. they have given the candidate status to countries that, if we look at the strict technical reforms, maybe have not done even as much as georgia. i think that today the geopolitics is changing, that the black sea, that used to be really a wall and geography matter, the geography doesn't matter any more. the distances have been reduced. and it's very important for the european union that the black sea and have on the other side of the black sea a country that is democratic, that is european, pro—european, and that's where the new transit lanes, the new connectivity is going to happen in the next decade. 0k. i want to ask you, cos one of the eu recommendations cited was the lack of respect for the privacy of communications in georgia. you said, "i will veto every bill which will be adopted
12:50 am
"in the wrong direction in the coming six months." and injune, you vetoed a bill for the first time that would have extended the scope of state surveillance. are you going to continue doing that? doesn't it put you in a difficult position? no, i don't think so. as long as there is a majority, my vetoes are going to be overruled. i know that. but you want to make a mark? i want to make the point. 0k. i think that we have to... i'm a form of monitoring, moral monitoring, that we are really trying to... but it puts you at loggerheads with the government. 0k. so you also want to join nato in georgia. you're a very close partner. you know, you spend 2% of your gdp on defence. you gojoin nato missions and so on. but i tell you what the special representative for the caucasus for the nato secretary general, he said, and his name is javier colomina. "whenever georgia is ready to access nato, "it will do so, although i do not think "there is a possibility to integrate "just one part of georgia." so while you've got abkhazia and south ossetia, not part of georgia because they are pro—moscow, you're never going to be able
12:51 am
tojoin nato and enjoy it security umbrella. well, we never say never, because things, again, i think that nobody would have expected the world to look the way it looks today. nobody would have expected russia to be so close to really lose a war with one of its neighbours. so i think that things are changing so fast that we'll never say never. yeah. we are getting prepared forjoining nato. we're having exercises with nato, including after the war started in ukraine. we had military exercises on our soil. so our caution is caution, but we still do whatever is necessary. but it's a big obstacle. you accept that? it's an obstacle. but germany. there are examples in history. so, as you say, never say never. 0k, we'll say, but it's not going to happen very quickly that you're going to enjoy nato�*s collective
12:52 am
security umbrella. i want to ask you about the former president of georgia, mikheil saakashvili, who left georgia in 2013 after he lost the elections. of course, he was the leader of the rose revolution and so on. he went to ukraine, rather strange story, and he was tried in absentia on six counts of abuse of power and sentenced to six years in prison. october last year, he returns to georgia and is promptly put in prison. he's been on a series of hunger strikes. and i want to tell you what the independent council of doctors who examined him in february this year said, "he has neurological diseases as a result of torture, "ill treatment, inadequate medical care "and a prolonged hunger strike." you have the power as president to pardon him. why don't you? i don't. i don't have that power. but you could push for that. you were foreign minister in his administration. no, i don't have the power because for one very simple reason is that the sentencing is not closed. he is still being judged. and that's the law in georgia, that pardon can intervene only when everything is finished.
12:53 am
so would you pardon him once everything's finished? that's. .. that's another issue. i've explained at length in georgia why i wouldn't do it, because it's a factor for major polarisation. people have lived under his regime and there is not practically one family in georgia that has not experienced what it meant to have that type of autocratic regime. so i don't feel that i have to become an instrument for more polarisation. but at the same time, i'm the head of state, where i don't want an ex—president to die in prison or to suffer irremediable consequences. and so i've been very close to monitoring all the medical. and there is, in fact, i was waiting for today that there would be a new conclusion of the international medical team that has been examining him, but it's not yet out. i've been saying publicly in georgia that i think
12:54 am
that he should be extradited, or i don't know... ..to be able to receive additional... he's in a hospital since six months. yeah. but that's a decision that has been... ..that has to be taken by the court. president salome zourabichvili of georgia, thank you very much indeed for coming on hardtalk. and thank you very much to you for receiving me. hello there. i will take you to the other side of the atlantic first of all two eastern parts of the united states particularly this footage that came from near the
12:55 am
great lakes of the weekend we saw over six feet of snow fall in some spots of upstate new york. enough to cover it well and truly been the snow that's coming its way what i'm interested in the cooldown place here and how it is going to fight the warm air in the south east of the united states that temperature contrast is what fires up a particularly vigorous jet stream which will be piling across the atlantic throughout this week picking up areas of low pressure developing them pushing to our shores. southern and western areas which will see the heights of the rainfall totals to speak. 0ne heights of the rainfall totals to speak. one such area coming into monday is the rainfall totals speak. 0ne into monday is the rainfall totals speak. one such area coming into monday is double centred loan some of the strongest winds around cornball touch run 70— e—mails power. with it some very heavy rain the winds flipping from the south—east throughout the day. through good part of the day in northern ireland and into the afternoon midlands and you think they will get progressively wet as well. across northern england, far
12:56 am
north of england after a frosty and in places froggy start should be a dry and in places froggy start should be a drawing bright day for many. it will feel cold here in the breeze that breeds strengthening throughout the day. the breeze will strengthen a bit further through monday night to tuesday and even colder air across scandinavia working to the north of scotland in the northern edge of our double a centre. fizzling out though, i break the ring in the morning shower read into the afternoon certainly been better than some will see on monday. 0n the far north scotland with that cold air in place snow in a real wintry mix here. call 26—7 cooler the breeze. chill your evening and to the day will follow but into the starting wednesday the next system works its way in. breeze to push that through a couple hours of heavy rain across much of england and england and wales and then into the afternoon across the north—east of scotland. following on etc to ground. elsewhere at the wrinkle clear, sunshine and showers some heavy
12:57 am
and forces the day but it will fuel on the cool side. a collective following that the next system pushes there is to get into thursday. i break start to western areas but turning wet and windy from the west. when stronger on thursday pushing gale force across many western districts. he flexible season rain in the leader of the day. that will happen a bit further into friday, low pressure to the south of iceland coming around that but a ridge of high pressure builds close to iberia promises further northwards winds falling later showers becoming fewer throughout the day. longer jar spells showers fewer throughout the day. longerjar spells showers most frequent in the north—west but in the sunshine elsewhere, compared to what we will see to the next of the week pleasant. temperature is nudging into the low teens in the something counties. into the weekend it is back to the atlantic include spousal winds and rain gradually spreading its way in from the atlantic across many
12:58 am
areas but then comes the big uncertainty because as we go into the following week, it looks like you could be a battle between what will be a developing area of high pressure across scandinavia and still the atlantic lowe's which one will win and decide whether it will be wet or dry and a little bit cooler. 0f it will be wet or dry and a little bit cooler. of course we will keep you updated.
1:00 am
welcome to newsday, reporting live from singapore, i'm karishma vaswani. the headlines: the qatar world cup kicks off with a star—studded lavish opening ceremony in doha — after months of criticisms and controversies surrounding the tournament. it is walking a fine line between presenting itself as one of the world �*s biggest stages is an outward looking welcoming country and maintaining its cultural, religious and conservative identity stop. but it was disappointment on the pitch — with qatar becoming the first host nation ever to lose its opening game — being beaten by ecuador 2—0.
1:01 am
34 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC NewsUploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=2094120530)