Skip to main content

tv   Fault Line  BBC News  March 11, 2023 2:30pm-3:01pm GMT

2:30 pm
after criticising the uk government's asylum bill. the corporation's director general, tim davie, insists the decision is to uphold impartiality rules. but the opposition labour party accuses bosses at the bbc of bowing to government pressure and says it's a mess. the us treasury has moved to reassure investors after the largest bank failure since the financial crash of 2008. the collapse of silicon valley bank triggered a share sell—off in other banks linked to the tech sector. officials in the german city of hamburg say the gunman who shot dead seven people at a jehovah's witness meeting hall was a former member of the religious group who left on bad terms. business leaders in the uk are warning that companies are facing a cliff edge in their energy bills from april, which could see thousands go under. you're watching bbc news. now it's time for fault line: the un and the quake in syria.
2:31 pm
screaming. the earthquake strikes. un aid arrives in turkey immediately, but take several days to reach northwest syria. bbc news arabic investigates. un teams are supposed to deploy within 48 hours of a request. in northwest syria, that didn't happen. what matters in terms of responding to an earthquake is time and what the sort of, the immediacy of the response. and the un just stood there, like completely paralysed. in this film, we ask, "what took the united nations so long?" to deliver humanitarian aid across an international border,
2:32 pm
we need either the consent of the government or in the case that we have in syria, a binding security council resolution. on monday, the 6th of february 00.47am, an earthquake of magnitude 7.8 strikes near gaziantep in southeast turkey. across the border in syria, strong tremors are felt. hundreds of buildings collapse.
2:33 pm
as the hours pass, the scale of the disaster becomes apparent. rescue teams are overwhelmed. in turkey, a major aid effort gets under way. rescue teams from around the world rush to help. in syria, the earthquake hit several cities controlled by the assad government. it also strikes northwest syria, the last pocket of territory controlled by opposition groups. buildings here have been weakened by years of conflict. sara kasim is a localjournalist who's reported from northwest syria for the past few years. she's been alongside the rescue team since the first moments of the earthquake.
2:34 pm
this is just one of the buildings after being completely destroyed. and the civil defence members are just trying to save civilians under the rocks. it's quickly clear that this is one of the worst natural disasters of the century. in the government's controlled areas of syria, on the day of the disaster, planes carrying aid arrived from iran and algeria. more soon follows from the uae, libya, egypt and iraq. but in northwest syria, there's no airport, no international rescue teams and no aid. the un says that, in order to save lives, response must begin within the first 72 hours. it's a race against time.
2:35 pm
ahmad hajji and his five—year—old son were lucky enough to be rescued from the rubble last. from the rubble. one of his other sons, abdul rahman, is missing, but he believes he's still alive.
2:36 pm
coughing. it's 7th of february 2023. here we are today in one of the neighbourhoods in the countryside of aleppo because of an earthquake which hit north of syria yesterday. still, people are working
2:37 pm
and the white helmets, the civil defence members, are working to remove the rocks and to see if there are any victims. this is one of the buildings. two days ago, people were living here, but now they are victims of the earthquake. in turkey, president recep tayyip erdogan addresses the nation. the epicentre was turkey. and immediately the president of that member state of the un put out a request saying this is too big for any one country. we need all the international help we can get.
2:38 pm
none of that happened in syria. a team from britain is one of the first to arrive. well, we sent it immediately into the region and 77 uk - search and rescue experts, together with the top level| of equipment and their sniffer dogs, arrived in turkey fast. _ when natural disasters strike, the united nations plays a vital role in coordinating international relief efforts. the un carries out search and rescue through un dac, its disaster assessment and coordination system. there's a wire start buzzing to make sure that we try and get _ an assessment team very quickly into wherever the problem lies . so we can try and get as quickly as possible the right resource l to the right place.
2:39 pm
the un also organises emergency medical teams, known as emt, through the world health organization. on the 6th of february, the world health organization had put out an emt global alert for the turkey earthquake, and they were calling on emt teams to self—identify and put themselves forward for consideration for deployment for turkey. the un was quick to respond to turkey's call for help. across the border in northwest syria, it was a different story. no—one could send search and rescue teams because northwest syria is not under government control, is not recognised. you can't request intergovernmental help the way the syrian government was able to. the way that turkey was able to. this is head of the volunteer
2:40 pm
syrian civil defence group known as the white helmets. un dac teams can deploy anywhere in the world within 12 to 48 hours of a request, usually by a government. the un humanitarian coordinator in syria was begging the assad regime to give access. to some in northwest syria, it seemed like no—one was listening.
2:41 pm
during the crucial 72 hour window for rescue, no international search and rescue or emergency medical teams came to northwest syria. what matters in terms - of responding to an earthquake is time and what the sort of like the immediacy- of the response. and the un just stood _ there like completely paralysed. the un's headquarters in new york. stephane dujarric is spokesman for the un secretary—general.
2:42 pm
the way it works is that a national government is responsible for asking for help. right? we have an integrated system where we co—ordinate international rescue teams. but if there are no international search and rescue teams in an area, one can understand that there is really not much coordination of those teams to be done, according to the website. according to the website, un dac teams can be deployed anywhere in the world at short notice and i'm quoting the website, "within 12 to 48 hours of a request for assistance "from the united nations resident or humanitarian coordinator "or by the affected government". so i'm trying to understand where... who is responsible for the delay? there was...i mean, i think we're going around... we're going around in circles here. there were a number of teams which were sent to southern turkey. there was one that moved as soon as we got the visas into syria, into aleppo.
2:43 pm
we go where we're able to go, we go where there is... for the coordination, where there is international aid to be coordinated. it's day three. the death toll in syria now exceeds 2,500, with nearly 11 million affected by the earthquake. 4 million syrians depend on aid agencies for survival. but the border crossing, the only entry point for un aid to northwest syria, is reportedly blocked and unusable. took three days for the turkish authorities to reopen the border crossing because, as you well know, this earthquake hit not only, of course, millions of people, but it impacted the
2:44 pm
humanitarian operation itself, the humanitarian infrastructure that was in place. however, others maintain that the bab al—hawa crossing remained open.
2:45 pm
so one thing you said earlier was that turkey took three days to open up the border. can you just elaborate on that? well, i mean, let's give... let's understand the situation. southern turkey was hit by a devastating earthquake, right? tens of thousands of people died. roads were blocked. i mean, it's not a matter of blame. it's a matter of fact. it took it took time. to clear the roads. it took time for people, for humanitarian workers, whether turkish workers, international workers, or others who were there, to actually bring themselves back to a working state. when they had to deal with their own families, they had to deal with their own houses having been collapsed.
2:46 pm
sarah was at bab al—hawa. she witnessed the tragic consequences of the earthquake. the cross—border operation followed the un's failure to agree with the syrian government on how to get aid to the rebel—held territories in 2014. to the rebel—held territories. in 2014, the un security council authorised aid to be delivered through four border crossings. however, in 2020, russia used its veto to reduce the number of crossings from four to just one. at bab al—hawa.
2:47 pm
karsten weiland is a former political consultant for the un. he studied how the syrian regime has politcised humanitarian aid. so, we have a debate in the security council every six months, again to discuss the conditions under which the un is allowed to deliver cross—border aid into syria. and that's the occasion where the russian side imposes new conditions on the delivery of humanitarian aid. valerie amos is a former head of the un's office for the coordination of humanitarian affairs. i and others have been deeply frustrated about the lack of movement sometimes by the security council. over many, many years and decades. we have seen the way that countries have used humanitarian aid as a proxy for a conflict that they're having
2:48 pm
in a particular country. this should not happen. this should be about people in need. it is supposed to be delivered in a neutral and impartial manner, principled humanitarian aid that is, and not as a condition. you can deliver more humanitarian aid, and in turn, bashar al assad gets more recovery or reconstruction. and so that is trading unequal things. you trade... you start trading humanitarian aid, which is supposed to be unconditional with things that are not humanitarian. and this is taking place every six months. the un says that like any other organisation, it has to operate within a framework, its charter. the united nations is made up of 193 states who guard their sovereignty jealously. the secretariat had the authority from the security council
2:49 pm
to deliver aid cross border. we did. we appealed for more border crossings. in the end, the syrian government gave the permission to use two more crossings. we used that opportunity as quickly as we could. we've delivered about 500 trucks worth of aid now since the beginning of the quake. four days after the earthquake, the death toll is still rising and is now 17,000 in total. in northwest syria, many hospitals are now too badly damaged to operate.
2:50 pm
time is running out for the rescuers, but still survivors are being found. earthquake aid has yet to reach the opposition held area, where conditions are now worse than any seen during 12 years of war. at last, five days after the quake, a convoy of 14 un aid lorries arrives at bab al—hawa. but even then, it wasn't the urgently needed search and rescue equipment.
2:51 pm
i'm here at the bab al—hawa crossing point... two days later, martin griffiths, the un's head of emergency relief, makes an extraordinary admission. writing on twitter, he says the un has so far failed the people of northwest syria. they rightly feel abandoned, looking for international help that hasn't arrived. eminent lawyers, professors, retired judges of the international court ofjustice, and former un legal officials, they've all agreed that, under international law, the un doesn't need the consent of the syrian government or even a security council resolution to deliver cross—border aid.
2:52 pm
for us, it is clear, it's been our long—standing position from the secretary... from the secretariat, that in order to deliver humanitarian aid across an international border, we need either the consent of the government, or in the case that we have in syria, a binding security council resolution. are you saying that what they're saying essentially is wrong? what i'm saying to you is that, you know, we can have academic discussions for weeks, months, and years about international law. there are thousands and thousands of international law experts, all i'm sure many very imminent. our position is that it has not delayed our work. but in that instant, what was delayed was earthquake related aid equipment. no? and that's what they needed and that's what they didn't get
2:53 pm
based on the un stance and their interpretation of the law. to blame the law for any hampering of delivery of humanitarian aid from our position is wrong. we operate within a given mandate, and that's the charter of the united nations international law. and that's the charter of the united nations, international law. the united nations is made up of 193 states, who guard their sovereignty jealously. it's now three weeks after the earthquake. omar hadji and his son abdel rahman were finally reunited.
2:54 pm
the devastation has stripped omar�*s family of everything they'd worked so hard to keep during the years of war.
2:55 pm
ahmed hadji and abdel rahman are left with the daunting task of starting yet again from scratch. michael walsh, the emergency aid adviser, thinks that if the international community doesn't learn from the crisis in northwest syria, it will only happen again. the key issue here is that we knew there was going to be a northwest syria years ago when we started talking about the need for a process of deploying emergency medical teams into active conflicts and complex humanitarian emergencies. there has been a northwest syria case. there will be another
2:56 pm
northwest syria case. we have to learn the lessons that we see on the ground today in northwest syria and find a solution to this problem. hello. in the aftermath of that winter
2:57 pm
storm that we had thursday and friday, very heavy snowfall, hilly parts of the uk have been left with a winter wonderland, this overlooked the peak district and this weather picture could have come straight from the alps. this is in snowdonia caked in snow. the nasa satellite picture shows extensive snow cover across wales, northern england, northern ireland, southern and northern areas of scotland. snowdonia has seen the greatest snow depths. 22 centimetres of snow lying on the ground this morning, not far behind was the staffordshire moors with 20 centimetres of snow. more snow to come over night but most will see milder air pushing on. for some time, snow over the hills of northern england and scotland. about 200 metres elevation, some centimetres possible but quite high up, but 400 metres you could be looking at 5—10 centimetres of snow. because it is higher hills, the risk of disruption is certainly less than
2:58 pm
it was compared with the weather system that went through on thursday and friday. heading into the second half of the weekend, strengthening south—westerly winds set to move in across the uk dragging in milder weather. a bright start for many on sunday but cloud thickens across western areas and through the afternoon, outbreaks of rain move in. the wettest weather across parts of northern ireland and western scotland. look at these temperatures! 10—14, it will be a lot milder. monday, the same area of low pressure brings this swathes of strong winds across the country, tightly packed isobars. blustery day for most on monday. outbreaks of rain tending to ease to more showery conditions but lots of showers across western areas. those showers and outbreaks of rain driven in by gusts of wind in excess of 50 miles an hour and you could see tree branches brought down. for most, mild with temperatures 13, 14
2:59 pm
degrees. in scotland, we are starting to see cold air return and they will be some hill snow across northern areas. that colder air pushes south into the middle part of the week, dropping the temperatures. again, more snow across the high ground in northern scotland.
3:00 pm
steve barnett this is bbc news broadcasting to viewers in the uk and around the world. to viewers in the uk i'm lucy grey and these are the latest headlines. the bbc apologises for changes to sports programme schedules after presenters and pundits pull out in support of presenter gary lineker who was told to �*step back�* after criticising the uk government's asylum bill. the bbc director general insists impartiality rules need to be upheld. but the opposition labour party accuses bosses of bowing to government pressure. as editor—in—chief of the bbc i think one of our founding principles is impartiality and that's what we're delivering on. thank you very much. the bbc is not acting impartially by caving in to tory mps who are complaining about gary lineker.

40 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on