Skip to main content

tv   HAR Dtalk  BBC News  September 18, 2024 11:30pm-12:01am BST

11:30 pm
but generally in the north of the uk it will stay largely dry.
11:31 pm
now on bbc news — it's hardtalk. welcome to hardtalk, i'm stephen sackur. today, i'm in tuscany, italy, at the home of one of the world's most famous photographers, oliviero toscani. now, you may not be familiar with his name, but you've almost certainly seen at least some of his work. for decades, he's photographed fashion and famous faces, but he's perhaps best known for his extraordinary advertising campaigns where he's used images, provocative images of sexuality, illness and death to promote brands, but also to get all of us to confront uncomfortable truths. he has combined glamour with a social conscience, but has he sometimes gone too far?
11:32 pm
oliviero toscani, welcome to hardtalk, and thank you for inviting me into your home. i must begin by asking, how are you? because we know that you've been struggling with illness. lately, not so good. lately... you know, i belong to a generation that's forever young. yes! and then, it was like that until two days before i got to 80. i was working like before. then you got up in the
11:33 pm
morning, and you are 80. and suddenly you felt your age. yeah. let's begin by going back in time. when do you think, as a boy, as a young man, when did you first understand the power of photography? well, my father used to be a photographer for the corriere della sera. the big italian newspaper. at that time, there wasn't any television. and, of course, it was during the regime, the fascist regime. mussolini was still alive. yeah, and in italy, the photography was conditioned by that. but my father had a relation with, i think, keystone in london, and he used to send pictures that normally would have been censored here. and he had a relation with that
11:34 pm
british photo agency. news agency, yeah. yeah, and then now he started to be a photographer, you know, because they asked him, they wanted to have documents from italy. so he did a lot of pictures for them. did yourfather give you yourfirst camera? yeah, it wasn't kind of...property... ..the camera were laying around the house. just everywhere, yeah. i wasn't impressed by the camera. you know, i have to tell you that i went to art school, and i finished in 1965. i also passed by the royal college of art for a semester. in london. yeah, and then i realised that
11:35 pm
photography was changing. there wasn't any more reportage. cartier—bresson, the magazine were closing. a lifetime. television was there. right. so i said, yeah, we have to do something else with photography. and in the meantime, they started to be interesting. the glossy paper like vogue, i think, and fashion magazine and design magazine. and, of course, this period is the 1960s, the late 1960s — they called them the swinging �*60s, when music, art, culture... i was there. ..was changing so rapidly. and you were part of that. now, there was a moment
11:36 pm
of euphoria about... new possibilities. yeah, new life, new vision. and, of course, we had the sense of future. now there isn't any sense of future. and when you think of future, we get afraid. but it strikes me there was something a little different about you. because although you were mixing with celebrities, with mick jagger and all the most famous musicians, all of the fashion models in paris and milano and london, you seem to have had a sensibility that wasn't seduced just by celebrity and fame. you wanted something else. yeah, you know, itell you, i was telling you that for me, photography is a media.
11:37 pm
it's not that i am a photographer because i like black and white picture. you know, i'm not an artist. i think photography is a media, is a sociopolitical action. and that's the way i always try to use it. also, when i did pictures of, you know, fashion or advertising, every picture has got a political message. every one, even a postcard. see, what interests me about you is that i think from a young age, you were very political. and i think it's fair to say you were of the left. you know, you had strong opinions. and yet you entered the world of advertising, which is the most capitalistic form of communication.
11:38 pm
advertising is... it doesn't really touch me. i never actually did advertising — that's the point. but you were paid a lot of money by some of the biggest brands and businesses in the world. i never need advertise the products. no, never, i refused. so, let's talk about benetton. because you had a very long relationship with benetton. hejust called me. yeah, so for decades and decades, you have worked with benetton. at the very beginning of the relationship when they said, "you know what, oliviero, we love your work. "we want you to be our creative director," did you say to them, "0k, "but i refuse to actually use photographs of your clothes, "i want to do it different"?
11:39 pm
did you say that to them? benetton never spoke like we... he said... we spoke... no, he never asked me for anything special. i always proposed something. and he said, "this is the right way to do it." you know, when... you mean that the company always supported you? no, the company was my biggest enemy. all the manager was — they hated me. so who was your big supporter there? luciano benetton. just mr benetton himself. yeah, very interesting, huh? and, you know, when i did propose whatever, everything was shocking. when i told luciano, do you think the young people are more interested in a sweater or in ideas?
11:40 pm
you were in control. you could say to them, "i'm going to build you a campaign, "but i'm not going to show a single piece of clothing." and let's talk about some of the pictures. you know, you would use deeply controversial images. you know, you would address the issues of racial diversity, you would address issues connected to illnesses like hiv/aids. one very famous image is of a man who is desperately ill, dying from hiv/aids. it's not a picture that you took, but you adapted it a little bit and you used it in a benetton advertisement. to most people, it's an image that is — it's very sad, it's deeply depressing. and these are not emotions that one associates with advertising.
11:41 pm
i mean, how does it work? how do you believe it works, that that helps... what does? i associate with advertising stupidity. glamorous girls, richness, big car, success, all that. but that is not the world. this is just lies that is told to the public to make them stupid as the advertising people are. so your motivation, i guess, was to make people look directly at the world as it is, with all of its problems. i realised that so much money was invested in advertising that... for what?
11:42 pm
do you remember any big advertising of that time? but you remember mine, right? everybody... everybody remembers yours. even the ones who hated it. that's very true. how come? what's your answer to that — how come? why? because i did involve them in the — in something they were not so used to be. er, you know, the pages in magazines used for advertising, for me, they were information, first of all. you know, like, because it's not that you go, you see something, you go and buy it. no, you see something, and you get an idea. you had particular targets that you mocked with your messaging,
11:43 pm
your communication. one of your targets was the catholic church. i mean, basically, religion generally. i well remember one of your big posters which featured a priest kissing a nun. yeah. you live in italy, you are italian, you know the nature of the church here. that's why i can speak about that. were you deliberately trying to provoke them? no, you know... ..i don't find provocation a bad thing. i mean, the art, if it doesn't provoke, is illusory.
11:44 pm
it's not... has got no sense. when you think, really big art always did provoke something, did provoke a reaction. did provoke a discussion. art has to provoke interest. some people watching and listening to our conversation might think to themselves, "well, in the end, "mr toscani allowed himself to be used by benetton." because, in the end, whatever your desire, to send a political message in your advertising, the bottom line is you were selling product for benetton and you were very successful. i mean, these ad campaigns, as you say, they are remembered even today.
11:45 pm
benetton sold an awful lot of clothing thanks to you. so do you believe benetton was using you or were you using benetton? well, i think i used benetton. really, at the end, yes, because i did something that was never made before. luciano had the courage to do it. luciano benetton? si, i never saw that before made by an entrepreneur. they are all afraid to lose their money. they're afraid not to make enough income. they will speak about money. we never spoke about money with luciano, never. do you ever think that, in your desire to confront the most difficult subjects and to get people to think in a political way, do you ever think you went too far?
11:46 pm
i'm thinking, for example, of one particular advertisement. it was not for benetton. it was for another fashion business. anorexic? well, i'm thinking of the... i think it was in 2007, your big poster using the anorexic young woman. and the title on the advertisement was "no. "anorexia". but the fact is, that was an advertisement for a fashion business. but it did help a lot of girls who were anorexic at the end. did it really? yes. it upset an awful lot of people who believed that you were exploiting a human being in a very vulnerable position. you can't please everybody. if you please everybody, you don't please nobody. if everybody likes what you do, that means that they've got no interest. no interest.
11:47 pm
so you should be unpopular sometimes. that young woman, she died a couple of years after the advertisement. i just wonder whether that made you feel... ..in any way regret for having used her in that advertising campaign. well, i could have used another 20 girls like that. i mean, that was not... the last thing i want it to be is that girl has a name. now, if i would redo that picture, i would put a mask. would you? yeah, because it's not a question of a name of a person, especially now.
11:48 pm
itjust — it takes a certain kind of humanity who...the disaster of... ..anorexia. as you reflect on this career, and we've talked a lot about advertising, do you regard yourself as an artist? no, i think i am a photographer, that i use photography to express what i think should be said. you once said — i read this in an interview you gave many years ago — you said, "photography is powerful. "sometimes it is more powerful than armies." but surely your life, your commitment to sending messages with pictures says the opposite. because you've sent these messages about racial diversity, about confronting illness and death with compassion, and many human
11:49 pm
beings are not listening. you haven't changed people's minds and behaviour. well, you can say... now, for example, with the sickness, i had a lot of people that i don't even remember who they are or that i never metjust like that, and they thanked me for what i did. really? yeah, a lot. i didn't have bad... ..email or anything like that. i was very impressed about that. but just think about your own country, italy. for all of your messages about the importance of looking beyond people's skin colour, the country today is run by a government which is committed to a very tough policy on migration and immigrants.
11:50 pm
fascist — fascist government, totally. well, of course, they would deny they are fascists. i call it fascist because it is a fascist. do you feel deeply disappointed with italy and the way it has changed in your lifetime? well, of course, but it's not finished. i still hope for the future. i still hope that it will be changing. and i think there are the possibility to change it. at the beginning of the interview, i asked you about your early years in photography, and you talked about the �*60s and about that optimism and the energy and the possibilities for change. do you feel as optimistic and as open to the possibilities
11:51 pm
for change today? well, not in the same way, but... ..i'm still living, thinking, hoping that tomorrow is better than today. that's it — but what to do? i'm not one of those that is crying on the destiny. your own destiny or the destiny of the country, or the destiny — no. we have to be understanding, and we have to be there. we have to learn what was going on. we have to learn how to answer to certain things that
11:52 pm
sometimes they are new, that we are not prepared to deal with. no, i am not afraid. now, mrtoscani, in your entire career, you have always looked directly at human beings as they are, and you have been very honest in recent months about your own situation, because doctors have told you your illness is terminal. they cannot cure you. life is terminal. life is terminal! tell me, because you've been so open and honest with people, tell me how you are feeling today about looking with that steady eye at death. well, i shouldn't be complaining
11:53 pm
because i had an incredible life, for a long time, and i was never sick of anything like that. everything came suddenly one day. one day, i wasn't any more forever young. and i'm not afraid. that's how it is. there are people who left much earlier than my age, so... ..i accept my destiny. and then i must say that i was lucky enough for not complaining. i had a good life. i travelled all over the world. i met interesting people. i had a really incredible life,
11:54 pm
it's true. if there's one image, or maybe a couple of images, that you look back on that you took, you captured, that feel most important to you or express your feelings the best, what would they be? i never thought about that. probably...the picture of the hand with the rice. because it's so primary. i like when everything is away, i take away. i don't like baroque. keep it as simple as possible. not simple, complex, but... there's a simple, but it's not simple to make complex picture. i understand, yeah. yeah, to be able to take away,
11:55 pm
take away, take away, take away. to make a picture that everybody will say, "i could have done it." yes, but you didn't. well, we have to end there. but, 0liviero toscani, it has been a pleasure to talk to you. thank you very much indeed. thank you. hello there. thursday promises to be another unusually warm september day for large parts of the uk — although in the north of scotland, it may not be quite as warm as it was on wednesday,
11:56 pm
when aviemore got above 25 celsius — some 9—10 degrees above the seasonal average. but notice, lake vrnwy languished at 14 celsius because, in those parts of mid wales, we saw a bit more cloud lingering for a good part of the day. some of that cloud returning from the east, as well. so england and wales seeing a pretty cloudy start, actually, in some places, but that cloud tending to retreat by the afternoon towards the east coast. some cloud rolling onto the coast of eastern scotland. elsewhere, though, some good spells of sunshine, just a very, very small chance of seeing a shower across southern counties of england — but it really is only a very small chance. now, where you're exposed to the breeze along the north sea, temperatures may only get to 17—18 celsius — compare that with 25 in parts of south—east england. and then, through thursday night, we do it all again, we bring more cloud back in from the east. may turn a little bit misty and murky in places. that cloud will hold the temperatures up — 15 celsius in london as we start friday morning, maybe 8—9 in aberdeen and glasgow — a little bit cooler, where we start with
11:57 pm
clear skies overhead. but the focus of our weather does start to shift as we go through friday. we start to turn our eyes to the south, with this developing area of low pressure — and that will start to bring some showers and some thunderstorms across parts of southern england, perhaps getting into the midlands, perhaps into the southern half of wales as we go on through the day. eastern scotland, north—east england holding on to a lot of mist and murk, and low cloud — that will peg the temperatures back. conversely, western scotland and northern ireland should see plenty of sunshine. now into saturday, those showers and thunderstorms in the south perhaps becoming more frequent, pushing a little bit further northwards. still rather cloudy for coasts of eastern scotland and north—east england. western scotland and northern ireland seeing plenty of sunshine, but those temperatures generally down just a little bit by this stage. and then, by sunday, our area of low pressure really makes its move, bringing showers or longer spells of rain, particularly across england and wales. the odd shower and some extra cloud in eastern scotland, but generally in the north
11:58 pm
of the uk, it will stay largely dry.
11:59 pm
12:00 am
welcome to newsday. reporting live from singapore, i'm steve lai. the headlines... exploding walkie—talkies kill at least 20 people and injure hundreds more, in a fresh wave of attacks across lebanon. hospitals are again overwhelmed. in my past 25 years in practice, i never removed as many eyes as i did yesterday. meanwhile, israel's defence minister declares the start of a "new phase" of the war with a focus on the northern front against hezbollah. a ukrainian drone attack — is reported to have triggered an earthquake—sized blast, at a russian ammunition depot. we have a special report from somalia — one of the world's poorest countries — as it deals with climate change and conflict.
12:01 am
the entire country has emitted as much carbon dioxide

31 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on