no budget, no government, signalling the frances presents tonight— signalling the frances presents tonight with the group looking on nervously. the french prime minister— on nervously. the french prime minister was ousted in a no—confidence vote afterjust no—confidence vote after just three — no—confidence vote afterjust three months in the job. a man under_ three months in the job. a man under ne — three months in the job. a man under ne dunlap way in manhattan. what does the resurgence of the civil war and syria _ resurgence of the civil war and syria mean for russia and iran. good evening. we are seeing a good _ good evening. we are seeing a good so — good evening. we are seeing a good so france, — the tower of rebirth — good so france, — the tower of rebirth ih — good so france, — the tower of rebirth in notre dame. but quote _ rebirth in notre dame. but

quote on _ been gunned down in new york city. (boxed chief executive brian thompson was fatally shot in the chestjust before 07:00 est (midday gmt on wednesday outside the hilton hotel in midtown manhattan, where he had been scheduled to speak at an investor conference later in the day. the 50—year—old was taken to the hospital, where he was pronounced dead, officials said. a suspect fled the scene and remains at large, the new york police department said. (sot) the new york police department said. prime minister beck for reason that the — prime minister beck for reason that the ends of the debate. but already rejected the budget. 0ut but already rejected the budget. out of the chaos that would follow, the rally would see a route to power. in the end, the vote wasn't even close. translation: mr; end, the vote wasn't even close. translation: my dear colleagues. — close. translation: my dear colleagues, the _ close. translation: my dear colleagues, the session - close. translation: my dear colleagues, the session has i colleagues, the session has started again. he is the result of the vote. the majority for

the adoption is 288, 43 3i. the majority for the adoption of the motion, 288, four, 331. the majority required the first motion of ascension is adopted. we don't need to adopt the second one. the conclusions of the mixed commission on the project are considered to be rejected given the adoption and given article 50 of the constitution, the prime minister must present the resignation of the government to the president. 331 mp5 out of 574 voted against the government. the rallyjoining forces with the left bloc, the new popular front. let's cross to paris. our colleague mark lowen is standing by with all the reaction. thanks very much indeed. france has been thrown into political turmoil and economic instability in uncharted

territory. not since 1962 has a prime minister been brought down by a vote of confidence in parliament. that is what has happened to barnier. there are questions over whether france will be able to approve a budget for next year. it has a very high deficit and debt at the moment. the question is over france's security. europe is facing more and there's don from going back to the white house, a time when europe will be called to step up and provide a... and yet france. the european union's second most powerful country has just been thrown into a massive political crisis... one of my colleagues who is also from france, just remind our

audiences why this happening. is a historic day. the main reason is we got back to... taste reason is we got back to. .. we mi . ht reason is we got back to. .. we might need — reason is we got back to. .. we might need to _ reason is we got back to... we might need to come back to you because we are having some problems with the microphone. with me to discuss a little farther joining me now is jacques myard, honorary member of parliament and former publical member in the national assembly. and emmanuelle auriol, professor of economics at toulouse school of economics. fa rry farry good of you to join us tonight. it is someone in congress that we've got all this political chaos in france in the very week that fritz is dividing the rest the world to a party to reopen notre dame. not ideal. a party to reopen notre dame. not ideal-— not ideal. and you said it was a very unfortunate _ not ideal. and you said it was a very unfortunate because i not ideal. and you said it was a very unfortunate because ofj a very unfortunate because of the time we are going to re—up on notre dame france. i think

it will go on for a couple of weeks. i think in fact, we are heading for regime crisis. i tell you abuse those who overthrown, what they want? they want to get rid of macron. will do every step, everything to push him out. because they may the next government once more, cc, we are intruding a very difficult time unfortunately. it doesn't mean... we are maybe going to bewley pilgrim with no government and they are pretty proud of it. ijust met a belgian banker who said that he does not have any government for five months and they'll

maybe like f1 christmas. you are old enough to remember the fourth republic. fifth was wrought about because the fifth was supposed to be unstable. we have no elections untiljuly, so what does micron do you in fact, it would trace the new the socialists to the... and as well as the renaissance to maintain a new government i then know that this is a real

challenge her they'll be able to do it. at this acc say think on you to tell the retail, but elicited will have a.

hundred 2024 was not month by many french people will be taxed more than 300,000 will be taxed. ~ , ., taxed. while they were not taxed. while they were not taxed in the _ taxed. while they were not taxed in the new— taxed. while they were not taxed in the new budget i taxed. while they were notj taxed in the new budget so there — taxed in the new budget so there will be some change like that _ there will be some change like that in— there will be some change like that. in some sense, you could say it— that. in some sense, you could say it is— that. in some sense, you could say it is hot— that. in some sense, you could say it is not a bad thing because _ say it is not a bad thing because it's not great because of att— because it's not great because of all of— because it's not great because of all of these automatic adjustments as provision. what about the interest _ adjustments as provision. what about the interest on _ adjustments as provision. what about the interest on that - about the interest on that whopping tech?— about the interest on that whopping tech? that is the big roblem whopping tech? that is the big problem actually. _

whopping tech? that is the big problem actually. this - whopping tech? that is the big problem actually. this is - whopping tech? that is the big problem actually. this is the l problem actually. this is the confidence of our credit. and today— confidence of our credit. and today we _ confidence of our credit. and today we saw the interest rate of the — today we saw the interest rate of the long—term debt of france rising _ of the long—term debt of france rising again. last week it went above — rising again. last week it went above the _ rising again. last week it went above the level of greece and how— above the level of greece and how it — above the level of greece and how it is _ above the level of greece and now it is above italy and spaih _ now it is above italy and spain. so we are in very, very bad position because the amount of debt— bad position because the amount of debt we have and the need to have _ of debt we have and the need to have to — of debt we have and the need to have to bear means that if the interest — have to bear means that if the interest rate hikes a lot we witi— interest rate hikes a lot we will be _ interest rate hikes a lot we will be poor and we will be even — will be poor and we will be even further to close our debt deficit — even further to close our debt deficit and to become again, so it's weakening us and very dangerous for us especially for the budget eyesight. has been many a year in france when the so—called republican front has existed. i talk about

the republican front is that the republican front is that the main political parties have joined to minimise the far right. i noticed that mr barnier was criticised because he negotiated a fairway with marine is that a fair criticism fizzy though i don't think it is. this so—called though i don't think it is. this so-called republican front, as... _ this so-called republican front, as... it's— this so-called republican front, as... it's cynical. front, as... it's cynical because when you see the former interior members sure —— minister, there is nothing opening to him. it was something that has shut the french. the so—called front,

while fact, the cynical allies that would not last. i think it is a very bad thing for democracy because in fact, they're really cheated the score and this is why i think the so—called front will i— again, because it really turned down a genuine majority, even if it was for the opposition, because i think this is what you want —— what she wants. because le pen wants to present to go. she has a chance to come to go. she has a chance to come to power and of course that depends on the french and not on so—called allies, which are cheating the genuine score. i would like something they have

something because what i fear now is that we are going to have germinal, in the euro zone, because france would be endangered and so would the eurozone. endangered and so would the eurozone— endangered and so would the eurozone. �* ., y ., ., eurozone. before i let you go, in terms _ eurozone. before i let you go, in terms of — eurozone. before i let you go, in terms of forming _ eurozone. before i let you go, in terms of forming the - eurozone. before i let you go, in terms of forming the next l in terms of forming the next government, the last election people, people voted for the rally. yet there are more politicians who represents vote sizing of two sides that can't work with one another? i work with one another? i believe it is still ungovernable. we have one extreme right and left, and in fact, a united to make the...

and very unstable. of course... so we carry on, but this is something we could have done without them particularly. i'm a bit concerned by the consumption of the sport. france people say even more because of this. so, that will because of this. so, that will be slower for in the back i believe the parliament is responsible for that. .

that. extreme right and left. go talk to — that. extreme right and left. go talk to you _ that. extreme right and left. go talk to you tonight. - i think we sort out mark's sound issue?— i think we sort out mark's sound issue? the political drama perhaps _ sound issue? the political drama perhaps impacting | sound issue? the political. drama perhaps impacting our microphone as well and i'm glad we have a better quality. big unknown territory for this country now thrown into political instability and economic instability as we are hearing from your panel. and i've just seen a flash that president macron is planning to speak tomorrow at eight o'clock in the evening. let's bring in pierre antoine don't need from bbc french. what is available now? ., , . �*, .

now? 24 hours, that's what he said, now? 24 hours, that's what he said. and _ now? 24 hours, that's what he said, and that's _ now? 24 hours, that's what he said, and that's probably - now? 24 hours, that's what he said, and that's probably what| said, and that's probably what will happen— said, and that's probably what will happen irr— said, and that's probably what will happen in the _ said, and that's probably what will happen in the most- said, and that's probably what will happen in the most likely| will happen in the most likely from — will happen in the most likely from eight _ will happen in the most likely from eight p:m.. _ will happen in the most likely from eight p:m.. he - will happen in the most likely from eight p:m.. he will- will happen in the most likelyi from eight p:m.. he will name will happen in the most likely. from eight p:m.. he will name a new— from eight p:m.. he will name a new prime — from eight p:m.. he will name a new prime minister, _ from eight p:m.. he will name a new prime minister, likely- from eight p:m.. he will name a new prime minister, likely from| new prime minister, likely from what _ new prime minister, likely from what we — new prime minister, likely from what we have _ new prime minister, likely from what we have been _ new prime minister, likely from what we have been hearing. - new prime minister, likely from i what we have been hearing. some coutd _ what we have been hearing. some could please — what we have been hearing. some could please irr— what we have been hearing. some could please in a _ what we have been hearing. some could please in a way— what we have been hearing. some could please in a way the - could please in a way the themselves— could please in a way the themselves by... - could please in a way the themselves by... if- could please in a way the themselves by... if the l could please in a way the - themselves by... if the prime mihister— themselves by... if the prime minister could _ themselves by... if the prime minister could ride _ themselves by... if the prime minister could ride your- themselves by... if the primej minister could ride your horse will be — minister could ride your horse will be fine _ minister could ride your horse will be fine. so, _ minister could ride your horse will be fine. so, try— minister could ride your horse will be fine. so, try and - minister could ride your horsel will be fine. so, try and maybe defy— will be fine. so, try and maybe defy someone _ will be fine. so, try and maybe defy someone who _ will be fine. so, try and maybe defy someone who could - will be fine. so, try and maybei defy someone who could please tittte _ defy someone who could please little bit — defy someone who could please little bit more _ defy someone who could please little bit more to _ defy someone who could please little bit more to the _ defy someone who could please little bit more to the far - little bit more to the far right— little bit more to the far right or— little bit more to the far right or left. _ little bit more to the far right or left. that's - little bit more to the far right or left. that's the i little bit more to the far - right or left. that's the best aluminium _ right or left. that's the best aluminium i— right or left. that's the best aluminium i have. - left for from the national

rally— left for from the national rally of— left for from the national rally of marine _ left for from the national rally of marine le - left for from the national rally of marine le pen i left for from the nationali rally of marine le pen the left for from the national- rally of marine le pen the does your— rally of marine le pen the does your party— rally of marine le pen the does your party now— rally of marine le pen the does your party now want _ rally of marine le pen the does your party now want the - rally of marine le pen the does your party now want the post i your party now want the post visit _ your party now want the post visit btue — your party now want the post visit blue good _ your party now want the post visit blue good evening. - your party now want the post visit blue good evening. no, | your party now want the post i visit blue good evening. no, in fact, _ visit blue good evening. no, in fact, witt— visit blue good evening. no, in fact, will he _ visit blue good evening. no, in fact, will he to _ visit blue good evening. no, in fact, will he to address - visit blue good evening. no, in fact, will he to address is- visit blue good evening. no, in fact, will he to address is the i fact, will he to address is the denial— fact, will he to address is the denial wheh _ fact, will he to address is the denial when moving - fact, will he to address is the denial when moving to - fact, will he to address is thei denial when moving to protect frehch— denial when moving to protect french citizens. _ denial when moving to protect french citizens. our— denial when moving to protect french citizens. our approachi french citizens. our approach is a _ french citizens. our approach is a delicious _ french citizens. our approach is a delicious about _ french citizens. our approach is a delicious about being - french citizens. our approach| is a delicious about being able to streamline _ is a delicious about being able to streamline services - is a delicious about being able to streamline services now- is a delicious about being able to streamline services now we expect — to streamline services now we expect from _ to streamline services now we exoect from the _ to streamline services now we expect from the next - to streamline services now we expect from the next move i to streamline services now we expect from the next move is| expect from the next move is not only— expect from the next move is not only will _ expect from the next move is not only will be _ expect from the next move is not only will be polite - expect from the next move is not only will be polite with i not only will be polite with the rally. _ not only will be polite with the rally, but— not only will be polite with the rally, but will- not only will be polite with the rally, but will also -

not only will be polite with the rally, but will also tryi not only will be polite with. the rally, but will also try to understand _ the rally, but will also try to understand all— the rally, but will also try to understand all points - the rally, but will also try to understand all points and i understand all points and chided _ understand all points and chided oh— understand all points and chided on board - understand all points and chided on board— chided on board michelle mariela played _ chided on board michelle mariela played to - chided on board michelle i mariela played to constant contact and yeah yeah will you on , ., , contact and yeah yeah will you on , . , . ., , on this was in october. the roduct on this was in october. the product was _ on this was in october. the product was the _ on this was in october. the product was the the - on this was in october. the product was the the party l on this was in october. the - product was the the party from the macron �*s party wanted two phone is barnier the will were taking really on board important proposal that we take both thought we tailed several weeks ago a council proposal to

replace a budget to we had 57 proposals. we presented in this town and said this is really no have any thoughts also 6% presented with i think everybody step nine now because it through them like this is the legacy that we inherited. that's a problem. we have already become office and we

cannot become us before. non—students is your traditionally and i will he his favour is that president macron seriously taking this in consideration it will respect us ok we already have time but thank you very much indeed. aye christian, thank you in london both of short break.

you're going back. if you are

to look at french debt and the ten—year german bonds, you will see it's at its largest since 2012. that goes all the way back to the great crisis, and we know what 1551 00:21:13,040 --