tv HAR Dtalk BBC News February 28, 2025 12:30am-1:01am GMT
12:41 am
12:42 am
that a british government or a british prime minister is. now, that means that in the united kingdom, our constitution is very much better at dispersing power than the united states�* constitution. the united states�* constitution does not disperse power. a parliamentary system means that there are many more people that you've got to convince if you want to get away with departing from some convention. a good illustration of that has occurred just in the last few years. borisjohnson was lost the confidence of parliament
12:44 am
12:45 am
and none of these mps... ..have any right to interfere. ..and parliamentary democracy. weren't impressed and booted him out. yes. let's turn to a different arena, one that you know well which, of course, now controlled by china. who cares so deeply about democracy, would take government and go and sit on the court of final appeal in hong kong, when you know full well that, ultimately, which is very far from a democracy. that's. . .that�*s the position now.
12:46 am
12:47 am
12:48 am
so i mean, the appeal that you're talking about, i think, was the appeal which he... yes, exactly. which restrict the granting of bail to people arrested under it. on the actual elements of the offence. westernjudges. i wonder if you now do deeply regret it? no, i don't. i mean, some politicians in the uk called you china's useful idiot. well, i dare say. a fig leaf for authoritarianism. i'm afraid that's wa—... sir iain duncan smith, a former leader of the tory "by autocratic, abusive laws coming from china."
12:49 am
decide to resign in 2024, you said, "in the hope that the presence of overseas common lawjudges .."and the complacence of the local judiciary." you got it all wrong, didn't you? in the end, you made a serious misjudgment. no, i don't believe that's right. i decided... that the judiciary was capable of maintaining reasonable were capable of standing up to china. in which the 47 democracy activists, of whom 14
12:50 am
by the constitution of hong kong, and then you, when you saw all this happening, let's just end with a thought about international law. in the international criminal court, the international court to respect the rule of law, universal human rights, do you think, as you look at the world today, that that hope is dead in the water as well? no, i don't. of the international criminal court or the international court ofjustice. i do have a problem about the human rights convention,
12:51 am
with the domestic law of signatory states. sorry, do you mean the european convention on human rights? which is a very political... absolutely. inside the european court on human rights. are you now telling me you think that we should leave it? i do not... that britain should leave it? quite clear on this for quite a while now. the strasbourg court, was capable of reform. i think we now need to have a regime of human rights
12:52 am
makes up the law as it goes along, and that is makes law in a democracy, because it's a system of making law into which elected legislatures have do you... that's quite different from things like the between states — i'm fine with that. to regulate the internal legal affairs of member states. let's end with a big—picture thought about democracy. democracy may well end up as a phase in history rather than its natural destination. that is an extraordinarily bleak thought for those who, let's say, in 1989, when the berlin wall came down, for the human condition.
12:53 am
12:54 am
hello there. it's a quiet weather story to tell over the next few days, with high pressure building in from the west. that's where we had the best of the sunshine on thursday — it's the 1st of march over the weekend, the first day story is perfect for it, with high pressure dominating, keeping things largely fine, dry and, at times, quite sunny.
12:55 am
12:56 am
12:59 am
1:00 am
0 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC NewsUploaded by TV Archive on
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f2f73/f2f73bfc07b815ccd3f050c506aacf56d723425b" alt=""