net-trade in belarus, how beneficial is it for people and businesses, what role does it play in economic development, from safe household purchases to promoting domestic products on foreign platforms. we will discuss e-commerce with competent experts right now. today we have experts in the studio who are well versed in the development of e-commerce. alexey bogdanov, minister of antimonopoly regulation and trade, andrey kartun, first deputy minister of economy, kirill karateyev, first deputy general director of the company for the development of the veliky kamen industrial park, vyacheslav dragun, director of the association of online trade enterprises. dear guests, good evening, we are glad to see you in the studio.

security council or state control committee on august 11, we celebrate the thirtieth anniversary of internet trade, it was then that the first purchase was made on the internet, one american user bought a compact disc for $ 12.48 paid for it online with a bank card. 30 years have passed, this sector is actively is developing, i propose to discuss it today.

of course, it should be noted that in belarus online trade is developing today, well , by giant strides, it has already reached 8% of retail turnover. the number of online stores has exceeded 30,000 according to the trade register, and this is simply a gigantic growth that has occurred in belarus over the past 5 years. all services are developing , including it’s great that we have a banking service without cashless payments, it’s all attached and...

asking someone to sell something, everything is met in a civilized manner here, buyer-seller, each is protected to their own degree, all transactions are transparent, so of course a sea of ​​opportunities opens up for consumers. kirillo yuryevich, do you use online stores, let's go, well, online stores, probably, like all of us, mainly if there is a delivery point nearby, but not everyone, here alexe igorich, was unlucky, so a little, but i hope to rectify the situation, well, look, of course, it is convenient that if ... you can quickly pick up,

well, most people use it, so i would still tell you, probably about the chinese experience, that's exactly the use, because this industry is developing colossally there, we will of course talk about this, but as a user you see that there is already a countdown not even in hours, you use belarusian services, well, that is, those that, when you come to china on a business trip, for example, you have very little time, a meeting, everything is scheduled, well, you have a good job, there are many, many business trips, and from belarus you use chinese platforms?

it's scaling, that is, of course, it is difficult to find such an offer in a stationary trade, that's why it's very convenient for the consumer, the only problem is of course to protect your rights, but we with the ministry... andrey mikhailovich has already correctly noted that electronic commerce is a broader concept than just online trade. well, alexey igorevich, he has already voiced some statistical data, we are also preparing for the transfer, we have selected some. based on the results of the twenty-third year, we refer to belstat, naturally. based on the results of the twenty

-third year, the volume of online trade amounted to 5.8 billion rubles. not a small amount. the share of online trade in retail turnover is about eight. both in the world and here, we note in comparison with traditional retail trade, well, here the experts are divided, at least what i have seen, yes, the market is certainly huge, if you take it on a global scale, it is somewhere around 6% of the world gdp, it is estimated,

this is somewhere online trade, yes , it will remain, well, of course, there is a transformation here, one trend is

a sneaker store, for example, and there some world leader offers you a new a model of sneakers, you can pay for it online and it will be delivered to you directly, augmented reality, you go into a real store with glasses and see both the advertisement for these sneakers and the cost, ways to purchase them, kirill yuryevich, well, we know that china is the world leader in e-commerce today, according to the number of users in the world , well, the data varies, but about 2 and 7 billion people. who regularly use the services of online stores there, all these related services, of which almost a billion there 900 i think 75 million - these are users from the people's republic of china, in terms of transaction volume, in other parameters, china is the leader, and this is not

disputed today, what are the trends there, here are the trends in e -commerce, i'll tell you, we just mentioned tiktok, in china it is an analogue, of course, we need those who have a lot of their own subscribers, then you can hit the jackpot on billions in sales, as there are also facts, when literally billions are made on lipstick in a few minutes, on all the others

products, we are still of course just learning this, for example, our girls and boys who study in china or work will work for us, yes, that is, we need to generally explain what it is for the consumer and so on, its advantages over others and so on, but

the most important thing is to get verification, for example, again, returning to our experience, the national pavilion, what is it, this is first of all, when you showed all consumers of the tiktok platform that you are a verified, authorized store, then there is, for example, to get a tick, for example, the belarusian national pavilion - this was the most difficult, the most bureaucratic procedure, we got it thanks to this , the user sees a blue tick with a flag, that's it, that means , and nowhere separately worked out exactly the concept of what modern online trading is, after the adoption of the law was

adjusted, practically in a new edition there was a resolution of the council of ministers number 31, which is called on the rules of distance trading, where we already in accordance with the latest trends have worked out all possible methods of implementation and the most important thing that we want to achieve is what a colleague said, in china it was necessary to get verification that this store is really real. so our legislation stipulates that you can advertise, explain on social networks, but this is not a sale, you must have a store registered in the trade register, or an online platform in one form or another, a marketplace, aggregators and so on, but it must be state registration, that's it so the main task was to bring online trade closer to traditional offline from the point of view of two positions, consumer protection and, therefore , bringing. national regulators

that ensure order in this segment too, as we see in the example of china, this is a dominant factor that cannot be bypassed, well, developing the topic of china, i would also like to note for our viewers that this... this sector is so developed that even if you live in a multi-story residential building, having, for example, some kind of store downstairs, so to speak, grocery or a cafe that produces rice, noodles, whatever, it is easier and cheaper for you, and it is more convenient to order it through delivery, a courier will come, lift it from the first floor to the tenth for you, than to go down in slippers and buy it, this is also an indicator of convenience and profitability for both consumers and sellers and, of course, the work of the national regulator,

but it must be emphasized that the need to develop online trade, our president noted at the general meeting of belkoopsoyuz. the head of state aimed at the participants meetings on mastering new forms of delivery of goods from the manufacturer to the buyer. moreover, this segment is gaining popularity , it is important for our trade to keep up with modern trends and apply best practices. let's listen. look how the internet and e-commerce have developed over the past few years, over the past year, according to belstat , goods worth a billion 100 million dollars were sold through this system, this market segment is growing by an average of 20%, i know what you thought, well, the internet, old ladies there and so on, but there are children who... can order from a person, and you can

make a delivery according to this order, okay, start this, start without harming yourself and see, and for me it will be important, as an economist who is used to believing specific facts, let's see what happens as a result, so to speak, of this experiment of yours in the belarusian union of trade unions, i will not talk about it for long, but you should know that we have the internet... almost 8 million people use it, well, the tasks are clear for both the belarusian union of trade unions and for domestic trade in in general, alexey igerich, well... developing this message of the head of state, we understand that this is a promising sector, i mean e-commerce, and it should work, you have already noted here, not only be profitable and work for the benefit of the consumer, the seller, but it should be profitable for the state, that is, there should be order,

transparent rules, so that the interests of our state are not violated. you have already noted that on july 11, amendments to the law on trade and public catering came into force, and we are preparing watched the programs, there is a large block of changes concerning online trade, and if we systematize it like this, or at least in a thesis, what is the essence of these changes, what are they aimed at? well, the most important thing is, of course, what we proceeded from, we, as a regulator for the protection of consumer rights, saw the main complaints that have come to us over the years from users of online platforms of various online stores, modern online platforms, marketplaces, aggregators, and so on. most of all, this concerned those questions that we have embodied in changes to the law. the first thing that means is that it is necessary to convey

information to the consumer about the site itself in the most detailed and high-quality manner, that is, if earlier the online store did all this, yeah. then in the modern form of aggregators and marketplaces this was not done, now they are obliged to fulfill this by providing complete information about themselves as a site that promotes the product through itself or sells it itself, secondly, it must fully describe the product, not just post a photo, but describe it completely, that it is necessary, among other things, to indicate the expiration dates of the goods, the shelf life, if an expiration date is set for such goods, well , besides, of course, here are modern marketplaces, it is simply like... to place complete information about the seller in case of violation of consumer rights , that is why their duty today is to facilitate and organize the relationship between the seller, the manufacturer, the consumer, and not just stand aside, besides, he is also

obliged to make a special window in his service where a citizen can.

if we talk from the state's point of view, then of course it is such a very important tool, let's say, on the one hand, satisfying domestic demand and all the needs of our population, well-being is growing, that is , conditionally, people spend more, and we must , so to speak, if not push them, well, create all the conditions for them to spend their money, they went to the currency market or saved it somewhere... under the bed there, yes, but for the manufacturer this is certainly, this is now becoming one of the most important promotion channels, here are our large manufacturers of industrial goods, unfortunately.

of all manufacturers, we are what i said about dry milk and everything else, these are all our famous brands, for example, by the way , chocolate, kommunarka, spartak are selling very well in china , last year spartak sold a little more than 33 of its sales in china through our platform, here it did through our platform, however, it was an intermediary, a chinese dealer who is already selling to us, but again over direct we work with channels, this is a solvable situation, but in the fact that we take on this function, yes, i will add that the government sees this issue, and - have already been repeatedly brought up, well, not figures yet, but brought up - that means requirements for the need to increase the share of the presence of our goods on various internet-online platforms, yeah, for our part, we have started work... together with the chamber of commerce and industry, with the marketing center on the following project: we got together with the two largest marketplaces, which we have in the post-soviet space

increase their presence, this concerns more the export of our goods, so we selected them and passed them through the chamber of commerce and industry and through the marketing center, the information is accumulated and sent for registration on cards to these two largest sites on the internet, they mark the card about... just exactly the trading platform, i mean marketplay, it is in principle, probably capable, allowing for this seller, well, to really check this

product, well, the real one, they do this, i as far as i know, some sites, they specifically value their reputation, quality, they impose requirements on manufacturers or distributors or whoever sells certain regulatory requirements, if you like, yes, we must understand that... the development of online trade is a stable global trend. today, it is almost a quarter of all retail sales on the planet. what path has online trade taken, what is spurring the rapid growth of e- commerce in our country abroad. and what do people prefer to buy online on various continents. reality and forecasts in our section context. please. i suggest to start by going back to 1994, when one then future american entrepreneur decided. to offer internet users to order goods sitting at a computer screen, they say that this is how the first online store appeared, and the first goods posted for sale on the internet

were books, they are easy to store, transport, they cannot spoil, the logic was such that even if the new idea did not work, the risks were small, who i would have thought back in the nineties that this small online bookstore would become a global giant of online commerce 25 years later , and in ninety-nine, today it has been exactly 30 years since the first online purchase. during this time, online commerce has gone from $12 in revenue to $6 trillion. it is predicted that by the twenty-seventh year , the volume of the online retail market will approach the $8 trillion mark, which is every fourth retail purchase. why is commerce moving online so quickly? pros, if think, as much as you like, perhaps, we are all online shipaholics to varying degrees of dependence. they provide the opportunity to compare prices, delivery conditions, see photos, reviews, and so on, plus a large number of pick-up points. say, you go to the neighboring house after work and pick up your

purchase. many chinese resources today generally offer to try on the thing you like virtually in one or two minutes. today this works everywhere, after all, we always thought before, how can you buy glasses, a coat or a bag without physically trying them on, for example, maybe not will suit the light, model or size, here with the delivery of goods, their storage, packaging allow you to save significantly on services for the creation, introduction of sites and so on. one way or another, according to some estimates, the total number of internet sites in the e-commerce sphere is approaching. 28 million, and the number of users who buy something online reaches 2.7 billion people, this is almost a third of the world's population. a few more illustrative figures: a third of buyers order anything online at least once a week. clothes, 13 cosmetics and perfumes, less than ten spare parts, car accessories, and then in descending order electrical appliances and building materials. and in general, the share

of online trade in retail is. slightly above 8%, today it is provided by slightly more than 30,000 online stores. an important point is that everything is smooth with shopping, the legislator, understanding the growing weight of online purchases, regulates this area of ​​the letter of the law. remember, attempts to introduce into this story not only about speed and comfortable responsibility, so that online shopping is a joy for everyone, both sellers and us buyers. and sellers and buyers. and the state, alexey igorich, right? dear experts, but i want to return to the experience of china again. kirill yuryevich, yes, we have already discussed that china is the leader in terms of the level of development of e -commerce and so on, but here are our export aspects that we discussed, whether we manage to promote our products on chinese platforms, and what attracts chinese buyers the most, well, we started working on this topic 2 years ago, it's been 2

years now, as... namely, the promotion of the republic belarus of our main brands and for this we in such simple forms, well actually, how social networks work, short video messages, videos, we convey to the chinese viewer that there is such a country, our customs, our experience, our combat heroic past, that is , everything-everything-everything, the whole life, here already, probably, about half a thousand different videos we have recorded on this account and thus we attract subscribers and interest in belarus, belarusian products. today we have about 3 million people, these are constant subscribers of our platform, and some of them are already direct buyers, well, also according to statistics, out of these 2.7 - this is 1 million of them, first of all, juices , sea buckthorn juice, birch juice, alcohol is also in demand, sparkling wine, red wine, a little less, strong alcohol, and

online trading is allowed in china.

work not only there, as it were, with banks and so on, to conclude also the corresponding agreements with the same manufacturers, if you offer your services for sale, to achieve the necessary prices, so that in general to have some margin to come out on top, because well, no one talks about it, but the costs are really serious , that is, you need to pack the goods, take them to a warehouse, either your own or to a marketplace, build all the logistics,

that's absolutely right, yes. that is, think about it, let's say, if you really come from a region where and so on, an order can come in, that is, you must have a corresponding agreement with the pick-up point. either with the post office, that's not an easy job, of course, another online store, you know, you can open it there, say, in 15 minutes, take some website project, there are plenty of them there and some, but another thing is who will buy from you, if you have some kind of unsaturated online store, how do you organize logistics, because a modern consumer really needs speed, convenience and so on and price, well, someone may not need price, but...

their presence in our country, is it possible, in your observation, that our online stores are successful with them compete, or will they continue to dominate and capture the entire segment of online trade? what do you think? well, from the consumer's point of view, of course it is profitable, since this is a certain diversity in the forms of trade and it is convenient for users, it should be, from the state's point of view it is also profitable, since these are taxes. and one of the largest online platforms has today become the largest taxpayer in belarus, it is profitable for us from the point of view of the fact that consumers, that offline trade also stretches for the same prices that are in the internet, for the same services and so on,

all this also develops offline trade, traditional trade to a certain extent, so that it does not stagnate in place, whether they will capture the market or not, well, it is difficult to say, since not only these two largest russian online platforms today. we also have belarusian ones, they are also actively developing today, and here we need to develop, compete and move this direction forward, including our producers or aggregators, such as, for example, belgus food industry could create its own national platform or bellicpro could work on this topic, that's what the belarusian union of trade unions, for example, should do , we need to work on this today, if we sleep through this moment, then of course those who work more actively in this market will seize it. what do you think are the problems, are there any chronic , maybe serious problems that need to be addressed, that need to be solved, and what do we need in order for the internet trade sector and electronic trade in general

commerce in general developed more dynamically in belarus, for example, we are already preparing amendments to the legislation on consumer protection, where we will provide for payment at points of issue only for non-cash payments. well, what's the point of having a cash register there, what's the point of having a safe there, it will be done on such platforms with a linked card, well, no, there is no point in this, so we will also develop here, so that it is in a more civilized format, as an idea, as a direction, after all we need to work on demand, because what does this mean, that is, on the digital literacy of our people, again let's take china, the example of china, they work with older people to master the rules, well, behavior on the network, yes, how to use a smartphone.

constantly, well, once a month, once every two months with our manufacturers, potential suppliers of goods on their site, training seminars, how to properly introduce yourself there, how to advertise, how to promote products and so on, that's the idea that we also work with consumers it really does have a place to be, an interesting idea, interesting, it all needs to be implemented, developed, vyacheslav leonidovich, you, as the head of the association of online trade enterprises, do you see problems that require urgent solutions. and there, there are quite a few of them, the fact is that i will not reveal a secret that in many countries of the world delivery is paid, here is the return, nothing is free, it all goes into the cost, we understand this, so that it always goes where it needs to, here it is necessary

, in general, as if not to interfere with this not introduce any restrictions, that's the first thing, the second point is that the same online stores that are trying to enter , say, a large... online platform are faced, well, naturally, one on one, like our manufacturer in china, yes, no one there actually guides him, so they immediately offer him a standard contract, sign everything, even if you have any doubts there, or you have any doubts, you are free, yes, you are free with us, that's absolutely, yes, please, go wherever you want, that's why i think that here too there should be some specific rules so that they don’t go too far, because each platform has its own rules, and of course it’s difficult for a marketplace with a trillion-dollar turnover to set any conditions or protect its rights,

well, on which we kind of found an understanding with the ministry of antimonopoly regulation, they supported us, defended us in the government, these are jewelry, for example, biologically active additives, veterinary drugs, household pyrotechnics, yes, they, they really received support on today, online and online trading can be used to make sales, but there are still a number of positions

that belarusians do not need yet. the trend for online shopping is gaining momentum.

more than 30 thousand online stores are registered in belarus, most of them in minsk and the minsk region. do all sellers operate within the framework of the law, what is most often purchased online and how is it proposed to improve the sphere of online shopping. a survey from the streets of minsk, in oks populi, the voice of the people on the main tv channel of the country. let's see. i i generally like it. to touch, to feel, to try on, it's the same as comparing an electronic printed book, we are from russia in the 70s online shopping when offline, so why is it like that, because it's convenient, it doesn't take much time, it's a large selection of goods, we don't waste time going to the store and so on and so forth, plus to everything, when you come to the store, there is no list of reviews that you can read and evaluate accordingly, i buy everything, things for myself, for children, shoes, sometimes we order groceries, household appliances, furniture, i like football player. i shop more on the internet from another country and there yeah beads gloves without

clothes everything is processed quickly instantly literally maybe a month everything already arrives it is in their interests to somehow provide convenience to the client abroad lived in the usa for a long time 6 years lived yeah well i have seen a lot it was more convenient via the internet through websites to do all this delivery is convenient there the return system works a little differently i order mainly but if something is needed urgently, then of course, a shopping center, often it is impossible something return, return of goods brought from abroad, costs more than the goods themselves, i buy only in certain stores, knowing the goods, knowing the seller... i already clearly understand my size, for example, i like to come to the store, look, touch, as they say, try on myself, and there, as they say, the goods arrive, i have already paid, they have already sent it to me by mail, they should have sent it, but i have not received anything, most often these incidents probably happen in unverified stores, that's right,

i buy things more often in shopping centers, but i just find it more convenient than ordering, if we are talking about organizing work in general, specifically online, what do you want? maybe it was of poor quality, spoiled, maybe something was broken, expiration dates do not match somewhere, we mainly buy cosmetics in stores, because many times it happened that it came absolutely not original, when you buy in a specialized store ... but we heard different opinions, basically people are satisfied, but one of the main issues that worries everyone is the quality of the products and the safety of these transactions,

we cannot ignore the issue of safety, many are afraid of online shopping, this is a fact, it must also be accepted, first, it is necessary to study the website itself , the internet resource, whether there is information on it about the seller, about the product, about the terms, about the expiration dates, if a person is already completely afraid and the regulation of trade, which in general regulates this area, well, again, here there is an element of consumer protection behavior, conditionally in a regular classic online store you can first

they will bring the goods, you will look at them, make sure that this is all that you need, and then you have the right to pay either in cash or...

of course, and strive to reach world figures, that is, its share will grow, and for this our manufacturers, our suppliers of goods need to catch up with all modern standards, and for this it is necessary to improve the system itself, including the system of payment and delivery of goods. of course, this will be a fast-growing high-tech industry that will accumulate all the advanced digital technologies and not only digital ones - in themselves, which will allow the consumer... to simplify interaction with manufacturers, with sellers, use new services, not only delivery, we sometimes even, now we don’t even know what other services will offer us trade, but really, as colleagues said, on the one hand, the consumer

allows him to get more and more satisfaction from purchases, well, and for the manufacturer , of course, this is a chance to quickly enter the market and either even... give what he couldn’t there some exclusive thing, he couldn’t sell it there in piecemeal mode, now this is an opportunity for him, i see, probably, that in the near future they will increasingly use artificial intelligence technologies, this concerns the whole world, well, and directly our country, because this is for sellers and for store owners, this is a reduction in cost in the future, when artificial intelligence will help the consumer to evaluate whether the item is suitable, not suitable, answer all questions, optimize delivery, well...

gomsilmash, the chief designer of skb, valentin shurynov, equipped these today units with modern computing equipment, but this is not enough today. today, a number of enterprises of the ussr ministry of automotive industry are automobile plants, factories that supply components.

complex units of machines and machine tools. the country's industry today does a lot well and quickly enough. for example, a modern tractor comes off the mtz conveyor in less than 3 minutes. but it took years to design and so-called industrial development of these machines that are needed in the national economy. a new factory was created for the grain growers and unsweetened patatokomishla equipment, spare parts, mineral fertilizers. the rural gas department has established the overhaul of preventive maintenance and repair of machines. the dispatch service is responsible for the countries of the rural gas department. then everything is so simple,

as if everything was flourishing here before, as if there was no swamp at all, it seems that only hands created everything, their sons and grandchildren will remember them forever.

suitability, dignity in russian, in our country, or rather, in no way, no longer in our country, but abroad, there is a certain group of characters for whom dignity is when you are humic druhkom, and then your rebellion dvar under the boot, you whine, howl, nasalize, run away, leave, dirty diapers, and then live in a taxi and wash in the river, in a dirty polish river, a lie is not the truth, and the truth is always, one, my name is grigory azaryonok, this is ... the secret spring of politics, hello , well, the fact is that august 9 has arrived again, belarus is fine, a calm, ordinary friday, the father with the peasants, the people worked a shortened day, and went to finish the last month of summer, and there those who took a nap like a child's surprise, oh, there they celebrated the day of expiration, they remembered the 2020 elections, picked at their sores,

cried, but continued to eat. cactus, although they generally feed on feces, but about them later in another life, as a joke, here is a really important event that happened this week, the father met with the ministers of internal affairs of the cis countries and he addressed with the conduct of a special military operation in ukraine, that many and leaders, that these security forces are sinful, that it should not be categorically, began some kind of benefit for themselves in to look for this. you know, guys, based on my experience, i will say that life is so stormy now, very changeable, many are looking for benefits, including moving away from our common, created in soviet times , development trends, some will stay away from russia, there it is under sanctions, we are somehow afraid of getting under sanctions and

so on, well, we are looking for our own benefit, do not do this. once again, i emphasize, life is very stormy, changeable, who knows what will happen to us tomorrow, to our countries, will we have to turn to the same russia for help? and recent events show that no one needs us, neither russia, nor you and i, and so on, we need to stick together. this is a union, it is very important that it is heard, there will be no. no one will have a separate happy farm, if someone among us still, unfortunately, believes in the world of pink ponies, then very big disappointments in life await him, very big ones, if someone thinks that they will sit here on their little pole and rejoice, fenced off, and good uncles from abroad will still help, buy and sell investments they will drive us, oh, how wrong you are, the world has entered

its bestial phase, its wolfish... stage, there will be no habituation anywhere, there will be sanctions, wars, terrorist attacks, murders, and we either accept the challenge of fate, or look terrible death in the eye openly, or we are simply undressed, raped, killed, that's all. we see very well how today they are trying to quarrel and split our countries from within. we are under the pressure of illegal, absolutely illegal unilateral economic sanctions. a permanent hybrid war is being waged against our peoples, each country the cis has already experienced at least one color revolution, which is essentially an attempt at a coup d'etat. the situation may develop in such a way that any of our states cannot do without this unity, and if we do not understand this today,

the separate ones will deal with us, but if russia collapses, we will... once again in armenia, kazakhstan, kyrgyzstan, uzbekistan, and as far as we are informed, they have not left the sore spots alone in your countries and... will constantly play on this, look, i have already warned, only union, only force, only will, only sovereignty, genuine, and, by the way, i would not be happy about these

articles in the new york times, yes, everything is written correctly, but we knew without the americans that the fugitive scum are thieves and worthless, and yes, they will be dumped, and yes, the 2025 elections will be calm, they... the owners understand that now, when we are bristling, it is useless to jerk around with us, but why, it is better to come to us, start economic vas-vas, and after that warming, and after that convergence, and after that various people will start to slowly move in activists, and then they will even invite you to their table, well, in the end they will cut you, slit your throat and laugh, remember the older people? "hunch, hunch, the women rented elevators, the crowds shouted, clapped, greeted, the stavropol combine operator melted, broke into a smile, gave in, gave in, gave in, now

the russians and ukrainians are chopping each other down in the kursk region, may you even be cursed with water, you filthy judas, now to the snowstorm, the security forces also noted him, our glorious pro-government agent, so he is active..." participant in the night riots from august 9 to 10 and poster poster of protest leaflets. 34 years old, individual entrepreneur, i live in the city of minsk, on the night of august 9-10 from august 10 to august 11, 2020, i participated in unauthorized mass events in the area of ​​pushkinskaya street and kalvariyskaya street. in addition, in october 2020, i, together with my comrades, pasted protest symbols on lanterns on

yakubovsky street with the aim of creating a protest mood in the city of minsk. i completely repent of what i did and consider such actions unacceptable. then it seemed like a funny adventure. now it turns out against me. please don't do that. but there are those who didn't go out into the streets, shouted from their balconies and wrote nasty things online: you can't escape fate, even if 4 years have passed, even if 44 will pass, it's your choice, in 2020 i was at protests, and also while visiting a friend, i shouted protest slogans out the window in public, as well as slogans:

if only there were fights now, destroy.