tv Anderson Cooper 360 CNN August 1, 2011 11:18pm-12:00am PDT
11:18 pm
sheet and start delving into the bill, you'll see that there's nothing in the bill that would garner the support of any of the great religions of the world and by that, i mean everything that we're supposed to do to take care of the elderly and take care of those that are unable to take care of themselves and also dealing with our children, those things were not protected and although there are some so-called fire walls in there, this new super congress of 12 will have some enormous powers. and keep in mind, social security, medicare and medicaid, are not off the table. it's been delayed in terms of when that subject will surface. but it's a bad bill. i voted "no" after 250 something votes had already been registered so i knew that the bill was going to pass and, in fact, i said earlier if the bill needed my vote i would vote yes
11:19 pm
because i wasn't willing to try to make a point and at the same time drive the economy off into the abyss. but make no mistake, i don't know of a single democrat who voted for this bill who thought it was a good bill. not one single democrat. >> i know you said that the consequences of default would be catastrophic but it's interesting you say you would have voted for it if your vote was needed to make it pass. a critic could say well, then, that your vote is sort of about politics because you knew your vote didn't really matter so it was a safe vote to vote "no" on? >> no. it really wasn't about politics because i made that statement before the vote and i thought it was a bad bill. i talked about the fact that it was a bad bill.
11:20 pm
so the safest and easiest political vote was to vote yes. i mean, i stand in favor with the white house. i get kudos from folks who just wanted to get it out of the way but i registered a protest vote. >> some democrats today in a meeting with vice president biden, reports that some of their complaints were saying the republicans were negotiating like terrorists. how would you characterize the tenor of the debate and the willingness of some in the republican party to try to get what they want?
11:21 pm
>> well, you know, i'm disappointed in the way the debate went. we had a fact-free debate. but let me say this. i want to give kudos to the tea party members because they pretty much had their way. >> they won, you're say >> i don't think there's any question that they won politically. i think the american public and, in fact, the world probably won because we didn't blow up the u.s. economy and bring down the world economy with us. >> do you wore are you moving forward about the ability to govern and get compromise and get things done moving forward? >> it all depends on whether or not the individuals who won come to the conclusion that they can win every battle if they're willing to send everybody off a cliff. and if they think that that's the way government is supposed to work, i think that's going to continue. >> congressman cleaver, i appreciate your time. thank you, sir. >> good to be here. >> congressman cleaver disappointed. there were poker analogies all day or was he making the best of a much weaker political hand. was he making the best of a much weaker political hand? we have paul begala and eric erikkson who justory himself away from "the bachelorette." a sugar-coated satan sandwich?" >> yes. and congressman cleaver is also
11:22 pm
reverend cleaver. so he knows of which he speaks both legislatively and spiritually. democrats are furious because -- they make a good point. instead of even-steven, 50/50, which is what most fair-minded people do. what president clinton did when i worked for him. we're getting all spending cuts in priorities and programs in the main democrats strongly support. there's a bigger thing at play here, too. there's by bigger thing at play here, too. and i think congressman cleaver referred to that and it's this
11:23 pm
obsession on the debt ceiling. it's an artificial contrivians. it takes away from jobs and growth. i got an e-mail from willie nellson who said a lot more people are worried about a ceiling over their head than they are a debt ceiling. i think he's right. he's a -- >> i love that willie nellson has your e-mail account. >> i live a weird but blessed life. he's my hero. i'm from austin. if you don't belief in willie and you're from austin -- >> who doesn't believe in willie? >> i talked to rand paul and we'll play that in just a moment, and he says, we were willing to compromise. we compromised willing do raise the debt ceiling. that wasn't really a compromise by republicans. that wasn't really a democratic issue, was it?
11:24 pm
>> for a lot of republicans, anderson, it actually was. and you and me and paul may scratch our heads over that but a lot of these guys ran on not raising the debt ceiling and a lot of them, particularly in the house, viewed themselves as replacing people who were willing to lose to vote for obama care and willing to lose to not raise the debt ceiling and we may say that's not how washington worked but they genuinely believed it. paul being from austin, that's where you can get the burger between the two krispy kreme donuts. i think that's the satan's sandwich. >> is that fair? we were willing to compromise and raise the debt ceiling but i don't understand when that became a democratic position? >> we have been raising the debt ceiling for generations. >> right. republicans and democrats? >> right. from either party. now, i will say, an admission against my party's interest, with when he was in the senate barack obama voted against raising the debt ceiling when president bush was president. >> he acknowledged and said that was wrong and that was political. >> correct. i think there's some principle at stake and in that sense i respect the tea party and the other conservatives. i don't agree with them and i think they would have done great damage to the country but at least they show they have the courage of their convictions. i wish the democrats would come forward with a jobs' bill. i hear the president and vice president today, were telling congressional democrats we get this done and then we pivot to jobs and i sure hope so. and it better be a pretty robust jobs' program because we have a long-term deficit problem. no doubt about it but we have a near-term growth crisis and we'll never pay off this deficit with 14 million americans out of work. >> so did the president get crushed here? earlier we heard john king say maybe this was a win for obama. a think a lot of tea party people feel it was a win for the tea party. do you think the president won here? >> it depends on whether you're looking at policy or politics.
11:25 pm
policy, probably not and he'll get hurt by his base. if you look at mother jones they were all lamenting that this is maybe a rejection of the american people of the government. but politically i think he did win because he gets the issue off the burner before january. people will have forgotten about this by march. the deficit commission, by the way, to answer your question from earlier with gloria, this will be the 19th in 30 years. the first one was when it was $1 trillion. now we're at 14. he'll get all this off the back burner by march and people will have forgotten about this. this election is going to be about jobs. not the debt ceiling or diplomatic relations with foreign countries it will be about jobs. if the unemployment rate goes down he'll probably get elected but if it goes up, maybe not. >> do you think this was a win for president obama? >> no, no i don't. i think having worked in the white house my heart goes out to him. he was working with folks who he believed would harm the economy to assume their political agendas. but this is the problem. the commerce department, president obama's own commerce department says in the last quarter, austerity measures by state, local and federal governments, spending cuts by government, reduced the gdp by 1.2%. so there's no doubt this is contractioniary and we're doing it when the president needs new jobs, not shaving jobs off of our payrolls. >> but anderson, i think there's a larger issue here. no one really is talking about this. if you go back to 1999 which was the best revenue the federal government has probably ever seen it only went up to 21%. the last time that happened was the end of world war ii in 1945. but the federal government is now spending at 25% of gdp and it seems pretty impossible to close the gap. forget, go back to the '50s and '60s, tax rates in the 70% and now we're down to 30% and tax income has been pretty steady in the federal government with the extent of the recession but even if it goes back up it won't close the gap. so at some point the government
11:26 pm
has to say, we can't keep running perpetual debt. we're at $14 trillion. if this plan goes through as they plan we'll add another $12 trillion. >> that's a good point. most of that spending, almost all of it was automatic spending increases caused by the recession. but why then just seven or eight months ago in december, did we have all the so-called experts that thought it was wonderful, this bipartisan agreement to increase the debt by $858 billion in the form of tax cuts, which apparently have done very little to stimulate our economy since the economy is still flat. so we need to cross both those lines the other way. in other words, we need more revenue, higher taxes, i hope on the rich, and, yes, less spending. >> but we've got to wrap this up.
11:27 pm
>> i have a question for you. if 49% of the country doesn't pay taxes and 51% already do i still have a hard time understanding what their fair share is. it's looking more and more like the middle class, at some point we're going to have to raise taxes, too, if we go that way, instead of cutting spending. >> but you're just talking about income tax which is a rich person's tax. poor people pay payroll and gas and excise tax and all kinds of taxes. working people are paying their fair share. i'm not worried about that. but warren buffett, one of the richest men on earth said, there's a class war going on and my class is winning and i think mr. buffett is right. >> paul, your southern accent has gotten more southern over the course of this interview. >> it's from the e-mail from they make a good point. instead of even-steven, 50/50, we're getting all spending cuts in priorities and programs in the main democrats strongly support. >> that's a good point. most of that spending, almost all of it was automatic spending increases caused by the recession. but why then just seven or eight months ago in december, did we have all the so-called experts that thought it was wonderful, this bipartisan agreement to increase the debt by $858 billion in the form of tax cuts,
11:28 pm
which apparently have done very little to stimulate our economy since the economy is still flat. so we need to cross both those lines the other way. in other words, we need more revenue, higher taxes, i hope on the rich, and, yes, less spending. >> but we've got to wrap this up. >> i have a question for you. if 49% of the country doesn't pay taxes and 51% already do i still have a hard time understanding what their fair share is. it's looking more and more like the middle class, at some point we're going to have to raise taxes, too, if we go that way, instead of cutting spending.
11:29 pm
>> but you're just talking about income tax which is a rich person's tax. poor people pay payroll and gas and excise tax and all kinds of taxes. working people are paying their fair share. i'm not worried about that. but warren buffett, one of the richest men on earth said, there's a class war going on and my class is winning and i think paul is right. >> paul, your southern accent has gotten more southern over the course of this interview. >> it's from the e-mail from willie nelson. still around, coming up, kentucky's junior senator, rand paul, plans to vote "no." why he's not willing to compromise on the debt ceiling. he said he's willing to compromise. we'll figure it out. an accident doesn't have to slow you down. with better car replacement, available only with liberty mutual auto insurance, if your car is totaled, we give you the money for a car one model year newer. to learn more, visit us today.
11:30 pm
responsibility. what's your policy? but not in my neighborhood. ♪ [ female announcer ] we're throwing away misperceptions about natural gas vehicles. more of the vehicles that fuel our lives use clean american natural gas today. it costs about 40 percent less than gasoline, so why aren't we using it even more? start a conversation about using more natural gas vehicles in your community.
11:33 pm
and a moment everyone, no matter which party could embrace, congressman gabby giffords to cast her vote. debbie wasserman schultz joins us with a behind-the-scenes look. more on tonight's breaking news on the debt deal. the latest, the house voted to pass the agreement reached yesterday by president obama congressional leaders. final vote, 269-161. liberal democrats for the most part and tea party republicans joining in opposition. house majority liter eric canter downplayed this. >> i feel like we accomplished a lot by passing that bill. it is the beginning of a process but we'll change it. it also, i think, sends a signal
11:34 pm
that we can work together to try to produce results and right now it's about trying to address this economy so people can get back to work. >> the bill raises the debt ceiling through the end of 2012, calling for more than $2 trillion in savings over the next decade. president obama reluctantly endorsed the compromise and said nothing publicly today. senate vote is expected around noon. earlier i talked to kentucky senator, paul reason, who plans to vote no. you plan to vote against this in the senate. you're unwilling to participate in a congressman that can pass through congress and get signed by the president. your critics say your choice not to compromise is not -- is
11:35 pm
compromise a dirty word? >> we've offered several compromises. i was part of a group that orchestrated a compromise called "cup, cap and balance." which would have given the entire $2 trillion the president requested in exchange. >> the cut cap and balance i understand the idea behind it but it's not something that can really get passed but that's not really a compromise. >> there is an argument about when it's right to compromise and when it's right to make a deal.
11:36 pm
we offered to come halfway in the sense that we offered to raise the debt ceiling. but there were times in the 19th century when people were asked to compromise over many things that were just plain wrong. so i think it's god to stand up for what you believe in and i had's good for america to balance the debt. >> agreeing to this isn't that a moral obligation? >> i'm not saying we don't pay our debt. what i'm saying is this will increase our debt. we're at $14 trillion, this will take us up above $16 trillion and that's adding to our debt. >> but in this plan we're still cutting $2.5 trillion in debt?
11:37 pm
>> yeah. see, that gets into the whole talk about what we're cutting again. they're talking about cutting against a baseline that adds about 9 to $10 trillion so when you subtract two you're still adding seven so there's certain semantics to this argument that i think are lost on the american people a lot of times. to my mind, i came out of the private world, if you spend more and add more debt you're not fixing your problem. to put this in contrast, if you had a real cut, 1%, the penny plan, over about six years your cut one penny out of every dollar you would balance the
11:38 pm
budget but i don't think that's that unreasonable. >> according to sources they say democrats were venting anger about republicans saying they negotiate like terrorists. what they're saying is a small group of tea party republicans, a powerful group were willing to hold the full faith and credit of the united states essentially, hostage. were willing to risk the full faith and credit and not realize at a certain point, we're not getting what we want to we have to compromise. is that fair? >> not really. some people argue that by adding $2 trillion more in debt to our country that that threatens our
11:39 pm
country more than a temporary inconvenience of not raising the debt ceiling. >> has this been a victory, you think, for the tea party? >> in some ways, yes. we didn't win the legislative battle. i didn't get what i want. but i'd say that the public debate now, everyone comes up to me and says, whether they're with me or not, they say the debate is all about cutting spending and before it was more about where are we going to go with the earmarks. >> is there any scenario that you believe raising taxes on the wealthiest americans which according to a lot of polls
11:40 pm
americans seem to support, as part of a plan to get toward fiscal health, would you in any way, be able to vote for something like that down the road? >> i've been having this dialogue. we get painted as people who are not talking. i talk with democrats every day. in fact, the democrats say the rich need to pay more of their fair share and bear more of the burden. i can accept that premise. i think we could come together on that premise and then the question is how should they do it? by paying more taxes or maybe we can get the rich to pay more by saying they should pay more for their benefits. the reason we don't want to do it for the most part is we think it will hurt job creation. >> look at approval ratings of congress people it's about as low as ratings of journalists and that's not very good. the is this debate a sign that government works or doesn't work? but from your perspective on the inside, what sign is this? >> on the debt ceiling i would say there's that debate. think how great it is that no one is shooting each other and the nice story of gabby giffords came back today.
11:41 pm
well, i mean, think about it compared to other countries where there's violence involved. people's freedom so express themselves is suppressed. we shouldn't complain about bickering and that's freedom of speech and you guys in the media, you really want to protect the first amendment and so do i. that's what debate is about. it's first amendment expression. we won't always agree but we're not at each other's throats so to paint us as that is an improper. >> and paul begala and eric erikkson, editor and chief of red state.com. >> while he was speaking i think that illusion to the 19th century is slavery. he's compares a fight over an
11:42 pm
artificial debt limit to probably the greatest sin in american history. that's a little much, at least for me and i was struck at what a different type of republican we have in the senate. years ago, the leader was dirkson. he said, i'm a man of fixed and unbending principals and the first of those is flexibility. that's how deals got down. that's how the civil rights legislation got passed, helping a democratic president, lyndon johnson. that era seems long gone to me to hear senator paul speak. >> eric, that's interesting, i think last week it was said that it's counter constitutional. all the bitterness on the house floor stopped by an inspiring moment to welcome gabby giffords. she returned for the first time since she was shot in the head seven months ago. i spoke with her friend and colleague, debbie awasserman schultz. she'll give us a behind-the-scenes look. ♪ let me make you smile ♪ let me do a few tricks ♪ some old and then some new tricks ♪ ♪ i'm very versatile
11:43 pm
♪ so let me entertain you ♪ and we'll have a real good time ♪ [ male announcer ] with beats audio and flash, you can experience richer music and download movies straight to the new hp touchpad with webos. [ martin luther king jr. ] i still have a dream that one day on the red hills of georgia, the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood. i have a dream today! [ male announcer ] chevrolet is honored to celebrate the unveiling of the washington, d.c., martin luther king jr. memorial. take your seat at the table on august 28th.
11:46 pm
and isha is following other stories. >> new deadly violence in syria targets the city of hama. this video shows the city under fire by syria security forces. reports of at least a 52 people dead including four children. that and much more when "360" continues. it was just an incredibly inspiring moment and really touching on the house floor. had nothing to do with the vote happening and put the whole vote in perspective or the debate that's been so contentious. not about politics but a person. when representative gabby giffords returns to the house floor for the first time since she was shot on that dark day back in january. she was welcomed back and applause, a lot of applause, listen! [ cheers and applause ] >> she looked great. nancy pelosi calls giffords the
11:47 pm
person per sonification of courage. she was fighting for her life in intensive care. she wasn't moving the right side of her body and still has trouble standing and speaking more than short phrases. this is a triumph for her family and her and her friends. her friend and colleague, debbie wasserman schultz helps her into the house, you see her on the left, that's her husband on the right, mark kelly. i spoke with congresswoman wasserman schultz a short time ago. just a remarkable moment today. among all this bickering to have a moment like this and see congresswoman giffords there. incredibly close friend of yours, obviously, what was it like for you to have her on the floor? >> absolutely incredible. when i got the call from mark that gabby had been following the negotiations and wanted to be able to be in the chamber to cast her vote, if it was pivotal, she wanted to make sure
11:48 pm
that she could help stave country from default and make sure that she was there on the most important vote that we'll are probably cast this congress for her constituents. it was the most overwhelming. it would be hard -- my heart -- all of our hearts were so full. you've had some grizzled hardened members with very hardened hearts that everybody just melted when she walked in the chamber. it was so incredible. >> so you found out, what, yesterday, last night? >> yeah. mark called me last night and told me habby had been following the debate and really important for her to be will and she wanted to be sure, especially she was a deciding vote and then she decided that it was important for her to cast her vote and make sure her district had a voice in the chamber. >> how is she doing? she looks good, she looks strong. she looked, you know -- i mean, she looked like she belonged there.
11:49 pm
>> exactly. she's doing incredibly well. this is the most determined, focused, hard-working person we've said for months. months ago i said that she would make a triumphant return to the chamber and today she did. and, you know, she has a long way to go in her recovery. she still has to work at rehabilitation so she's not ready to come back full time but this was an incredible step for her and a fantastic day. in an otherwise tough few weeks. so gabby giffords is the consummate public service and her district is forge as she set the example today for having her represent them. >> you answered my final question which is -- this is not for good. she's not back for good. >> no. she has a lot of work left to do to continue on the road to recovery but she's making remarkable progress. she's very determined to come back and i've been able to visit with her a whole bunch since the shooting. she's made more and more
11:50 pm
progress each time. it's amazing that america and her colleagues and constituents got to see how much progress she's made. it was something that after such a tough debate, after so much was at stake for us to have gabby melt our hearts a little bit so we can move on and hopefully, start to work together a little bit better. >> it was certainly one of those moments in the newsroom where everyone just stopped and i'm sure the same thing on the floor of the house and kind of puts things in perspective. >> really, it does. you should have seen -- i was watching the members faces as i was helping to walk gabby into the chamber and it was just jaws dropping and smiles and tears and just -- it was -- i think it was a shot in the arm that the congress and the house needed. the shot in the arm that the country needed after a very tough time. we got a lot in front of us and a lot of work ahead of us,
11:51 pm
hopefully gabby's return today, even if it's just brief, will help us all come together. that's the civility that i know is so important to her and hopefully, her return sets the tone. >> i hope she got a sense of the outpouring and i hope it gave her a shot in the arm as it did everyone else. >> she did. she thought it was incredible. still ahead, new brutality in syria. 52 people, including four children, killed yesterday by the government. military accused of firing on its own people, even as they try to pull victims to safety. we've seen this before. specialists, lots of doctors, lots of advice... and my hands were full. i couldn't sort through it all. with unitedhealthcare, it's different. we have access to great specialists, and our pediatrician gets all the information. everyone works as a team. and i only need to talk to one person about her care. we're more than 78,000 people
11:52 pm
looking out for 70 million americans. that's health in numbers. unitedhealthcare. when your eyes are smiling... you're smiling. and when they're laughing... you're laughing. be kind to your eyes... with transitions lenses. transitions adapt to changing light so you see your whole day comfortably... and conveniently while protecting your eyes from the sun. ask your eyecare professional which transitions lenses are right for you. [ owl hooting ] things aren't always what they seem out here. like that big fella over there. cost way less than i ever dreamed. i don't tell my friends just how affordable it is cus to them i'm still the big roller, the big cheese, ya know? oh, emmitt. baby, what you doing? y-y-yeah! [ clears throat ] [ deep voice ] yeah, babe. in a second. takin' care of some business. it's surprising just how affordable an rv vacation can be.
11:55 pm
megared softgels are small and easy to swallow with no fishy smell or aftertaste. try megared today. ahead, a judge ordering casey anthony to return to orlando. we'll tell you why. in syria, a bloody 48 hours as president assad escalates his crackdown. the city of hama, a major target. take a look. video reporting to show hama under fire. at least 52 people including four children were killed. dozens more reportedly died in other attacks across the country. hospitals are said to be overwhelmed. video, it was people outside one
11:56 pm
of them with foreign journalist barr from syria. we can't independently confirm the reports. another video reportedly shot of a group of man trying to recover a wounded man on the street and appear to come under gunfire. watch this. keep in mind, this is the holy month of ramadan. there were reports of machine guns firing from tanks and at least six more people were killed. the video of the tank was purportedly shot on the outskirts of the city of what may. the president called the attacks on demonstrators horrifying. major medical. ...but it helps pay the doctors. pays the doctors, boyyy! [ quack ] oh yeah? what about your family? ♪ we added aflac, so we get cash! it's like our safety net... ♪ to help with the mortgage or whatever we need! so my family doesn't feel the pain too. ha! [ male announcer ] help protect your family at aflac.com. [ pigeons ] heyyy! hooo!!!
11:57 pm
[ male announcer ] an everyday moment can turn romantic anytime. and when it does, men with erectile dysfunction can be more confident in their ability to be ready with cialis for daily use. ♪ cialis for daily use is a clinically proven low-dose tablet you take every day so you can be ready anytime the moment's right. ♪ tell your doctor about your medical condition and all medications, and ask if you're healthy enough for sexual activity. don't take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. [ man ] do not drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache, or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than 4 hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, stop taking cialis and call your doctor right away. [ male announcer ] ask your doctor if cialis for daily use is right for you. for a 30-tablet free trial offer, go to cialis.com.
11:58 pm
desperate for nighttime heartburn relief? for a 30-tablet free trial offer, for many, nexium helps relieve heartburn symptoms caused by acid reflux disease. talk to your doctor about your risk for osteoporosis-related bone fractures if you take multiple daily doses of nexium for a long time. possible side effects include headache, diarrhea, and abdominal pain. other serious stomach conditions may still exist. talk to your doctor about nexium. if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help.
179 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN (San Francisco) Television Archive Television Archive News Search Service The Chin Grimes TV News ArchiveUploaded by TV Archive on