out now that steve jobs is gone. that's it for "reliable sources." we're off next sunday when cnn will have live dedication of the martin luther king memorial in washington that was preempted by the hurricane a few weeks ago. we'll be back with another critical look at the media. "state of the union" begins right now. in the two months since she won the iowa straw poll, michele bachmann has fallen from the top tier to the bottom. rick per ru herman cain has gone from the bottom tier to the top. rick perry blew up his catbird seat and continued to slide, and mitt romney has gone from weak front-runner to, well, weak front-runner. today the race to the white house with republican presidential candidates businessman herman cain and congresswoman michele bachmann. then, the economy, the jobs bill and 2012 with moody's

analytics chief economist mark zandi and veteran political journalist ron brownstein of the "national journal" and peter baker of the "new york times." i'm candy crowley, and this is "state of the union." herman cain and michele bachmann were on this show the day after the iowa straw poll in august. she won, he was fifth but unbowed. >> this campaign has encouraged and our momentum continues to grow. >> in an august quinnipiac poll, bachmann ranked third among republicans with 12%. cain just 5%. now in a cbs news poll of republican primary voters, she sits between ron paul and rick santorum with 4%. he's tied for first with mitt romney. herman cain is big league now soaking up the limelight on "the view" and the "tonight show" promoting his book "this is herman cain." still many the topsy-turvy universe of 2012 politics, getting to the top and staying there are wholly different things.

with me now, republican presidential contender herman cain. >> thank you, candy. >> thanks for finding time for us between "the view" and the "tonight show." appreciate it. couple of topics have been in the news and i want to play you something that pastor robert jeffress, head of the southern baptist convention and senior pastor at a church in texas, had to say about -- was sort of aimed at mitt romney. take a listen here. >> yes. >> the southern baptist convention, which is the largest protestant denomination in the world, has officially labeled mormonism as a cult. i think mitt romney is a good moral man, but i think those of us who are born-again followers of christ should always prefer a competent christian to a competent non-christian like mitt romney. >> is mitt romney a non-christian? >> i'm not running for theologian in chief. i'm a lifelong christian. what that means is one of my guiding principles for the decisions i make is i start with

do the right thing. i'm not getting into that controversy. >> but it still will beg the question that you dodged a direct question which is, is mitt romney not a christian? >> he's a mormon. that much i know. i am not going to do an analysis of mormonism versus christianity for the sake of answering that. i'm not getting into that. i am a christian -- >> even knowing it will look like you're dodging it. >> if that's what it looks like i'm dodging it because it is not going to help us boost this economy. you know that's my number one priority. >> on a more general note, is someone's religion a valid campaign issue? >> i believe it is a valid concern, but i don't think it necessarily should be a big campaign issue. what i believe people want to know, what are your guiding principles and what are your values? because your guiding principles and your values will impact how you make decisions. that's what i believe it is.

so just focusing on religion alone is not enough to determine how that person will make decisions. >> and we should add here for folks that have not followed your campaign all along, you have from time to time talked about muslims and the nature of islam and have expressed reservations about having a muslim in your cabinet -- >> extremists. extremists. not peaceful muslims. you have peaceful muslims and you have extremists. i have nothing against peaceful muslims. jihadists and extremists are the ones that i'm careful not to infiltrate my cabinet when i become president. >> that's a differentiation you did not make before. >> yes. i did not make that differentiation before, but that was the intent of the comment. >> in your book "this is herman cain," you wrote that the obama white house disconnection with the american people is "absolutely unbelievable." so i want to ask you about your connection with the american people. >> yes. >> the idea of a surtax on millionaires to help pay for a

jobs bill, you are opposed to it. >> i am opposed to it because it is a distraction and it doesn't solve the problem. if they were to put a surtax on everybody making over a million dollars, if they were to double it, it doesn't solve the problem of too much spending and the problem that this economy is not growing. the economy is on life support. so it doesn't solve the problem. all it does is it fans the flame of class warfare. >> well, this isn't something that he's doing sort of in a vacuum. this would be to pay for the jobs bill. and i am assuming there are things within the jobs bill that you would agree to. >> very little. this jobs -- this so-called jobs bill is a sneak a taxes bill. i went through it. there are 84 sneak attacks that nobody talks about. so the focus on this millionaire surtax is a distraction for people not to look into the body of the bill.

it is loaded with sneak taxes that will impact everybody. >> as i understand it this would be substituting for the president's way of paying for it. i guess my point here is that when abc news and "the washington post" asked people do you support or oppose raising taxes on people making over $1 million a year, 75% of americans said raise them. we're in a big deficit situation, separate this from the jobs bill. but you oppose it. >> i oppose it because number one it doesn't solve the problem. >> doesn't that make you seriously out of step with the american people? >> no, no, no. >> that's my point as you accuse the president of being. >> no, no. the american people are being deceived with this class warfare stuff, and i'm not going to perpetuate it because that poll says it. the same people that took that survey i challenge them to tell me what's in that jobs bill. i challenge them to tell me what percentage of the taxes are currently being paid by 50% of the taxpayers. 97%. you see, d.c. has a definition of fairness, and webster has a

definition of fairness, and the president keeps talking about, well, in all fairness -- when he's not sharing with the american people. if the american people knew the facts about how the taxes are being paid, i think they might have a different opinion. one other thing on this note. here's the other thing. to talk about the millionaire's tax is just fanning class warfare because the people don't have the facts about how the tax structure breaks down in terms of who pays what. >> well, but you would not dismiss the notion that some people in middle-class tax bracket do pay more of a percentage of their income and certainly they pay a larger percentage when it comes to social security payroll taxes than do rich people. >> yes, i would acknowledge that. are you absolutely right. >> so this is trying to correct that in part. it corrects what's seen as an inequity, that rich people pay a smaller percentage in some cases of their income than do middle class people. >> i love you, but it doesn't.

and the other thing is -- >> i'm sorry, it doesn't? >> it doesn't make that correction is what i'm saying. if you look at the details of his so-called jobs plan, it simply doesn't. this is what they say it does but in fact it does not. here's the other thing it does not do -- it doesn't do anything to help bring down the national debt or the annual deficit. it does not because it's so miniscule. >> why wouldn't it bring down the debt if you tax people more? it goes into the treasury -- >> because this administration continues to spend more. they want to tax more, but they are not putting caps on the spending. that's why it won't do any good. >> let me move you to your plan. >> okay. >> "999." i know you love to talk about this. this would be -- your plan would be to have everybody pay 9% of their gross income and the only thing you could deduct would be charitable contributions. >> correct. >> 9% corporate tax rate. it is now at 35% just for purposes of comparison. >> yes. yes.

>> and then a 9% sales tax or consumption tax. >> yes. >> so the criticism of this has been, a, it won't raise enough money, as much money as is needed, and, b, it is really regressive because i would pay the same amount for a blouse in taxes as someone making $10,000 a year, and that's regressive. it's not fair. >> let me start with the first one about how much revenue it will raise. the people who are saying it will not be revenue-neutral? they are absolutely wrong because they did a static analysis. we had this done with the dynamic analysis with an outside independent firm so they are making an erroneous assumption relative to regression. no, it is not. if you take a family of four and $50,000 or $25,000, start with the fact that if they're getting a paycheck they pay 15.3% in the payroll tax like you pointed out earlier. >> social security -- >> exactly. social security and medicare.

so that 15.3% becomes 9%. that's a six percentage point differential. now let's take someone making $50,000 a year. make it $25,000 or $50,000. it doesn't matter. you now have -- they will pay in taxes based on standard deductions, exemptions, a family of four will pay over $10,000 in total taxes. go to the "999" plan. they're going to pay $4,500. they have a $5,500 gap to apply to the sales tax. if the person applies that to both new and used goods, they will come out just fine. >> is there any exception, as you see it, in this consumption tax? would you except for clothing perhaps? except for food? would food be a consumption -- >> no, you don't have to do that. >> no food.

clothing? >> no. because that six percentage point difference makes up for a lot of the sales tax that people will have to pay. here's the thing that people don't -- >> i'm sorry. i think i misunderstood you. >> okay. >> you would make an exemption for food and clothing? >> no. >> no exemptions. >> you don't need those exemptions. >> a poor person is paying the same amount of tax on groceries as i am. does that sound fair? >> yes. because of the other point i'm about to make. if they need a car or home or other hard goods that are used they pay no taxes. so they have an opportunity for them to leverage their income. the assumption made by the critics is that they're going to spend all of the rest of their money on new goods. no. that's not how my parents did it. they knew how to stretch a dollar. to say it is regressive is based upon erroneous assumptions. >> hold it right there. we'll be right back with herman cain. up next, we'll take a closer look at what shaped herman cain into the kind of candidate he is today. only& superpages®.

online. on your phone. or in the book. go to superpages®. and let the good guys save the day. ask me. if you think even the best bed can only lie there... ask me what it's like... when my tempur-pedic moves... ...talk to someone who owns an adjustable version of the most highly recommended bed in america... ask me about my tempur advanced ergo. ask me about having all the right moves. these are real tempur-advanced ergo owners! find one for yourself.

check out twitter. try your friends on facebook... see what they have to say...unedited. it goes up... ask me what it's like to get a massage ---any time you want. ...it goes down... ergo...nomics... ergo...nomics... tempur-pedic brand owners are more satisfied than owners of any traditional mattress brand. (in chinese) ask me why i never want to leave my ergo. ask me why i'm glad i didn't wait 'till i was too old to enjoy this. start asking real owners. ask me how to make your first move... find out more about the tempur advanced ergo system! call the number on your screen for your free dvd and information kit. to find an authorized dealer near you, visit tempurpedic.com. tempur-pedic. the most highly recommended bed in america. but think about your heart. 2% has over half the saturated fat of whole milk. want to cut back on fat and not compromise on taste? try smart balance fat free milk. it's what you'd expect from the folks at smart balance.

to understand politics, you need to know where the politician comes from. in segregated atlanta, herman cain grew up poor, he says, "but i didn't know it." sometimes he didn't have money for lunch. his father held three jobs, his mother cleaned houses. cain graduated second in his high school class, was the first in his family to go to college and later earn a graduate degree. working at a series of jobs, he eventually took over and turned around the faltering godfather's pizza chain. he was asked this week what he thought of anti-wall street protesters. >> don't blame wall street. don't blame the big banks. if you don't have a job and you are not rich, blame yourself. >> 17 years ago as ceo of godfather's, cain went to a town hall meeting with president clinton and told him that the cost of health care known as hillary care would force cain and other ceos to lay off workers. >> first of all, mr. president,

with all due respect, your calculation on what the impact would do, quite honestly, is incorrect. >> five years ago when friends were expecting herman cain to move happily into retirement, he was diagnosed with stage four liver and colon cancer and given a 30% chance to live. he beat the odds and has a doctor's letter showing he is cancer free. >> if god gives you an opportunity to stick around here a little longer, it's not to try and improve your golf game. >> herman cain on herman cain when we come back. she won't eat eggs without hot sauce. she has kind of funny looking toes. she's always touching my hair. and she does this dancing finger thing. [ male announcer ] with advanced technology from ge, now doctors can diagnose diseases like breast cancer on a cellular level. so that women, like kristy's mom, can get personalized treatment that's as unique as she is. [ kristy ] she's definitely not like other moms. yeah, my mom is pretty weird. ♪

add listerine® total care for more complete oral care. ♪ it works in six different ways to restore enamel... strengthen teeth... freshen breath... help prevent cavities... and kill bad breath germs for a whole mouth clean. so go beyond the brush with listerine® total care, the most complete mouthwash. now get all the benefits... without the alcohol. new listerine® total care zero.

aspercreme breaks the grip, with maximum-strength medicine and no embarrassing odor. break the grip of pain with aspercreme. we are back with republican presidential candidate herman cain. i want to play for our audience something that you said friday. you were addressing the values voter summit and the subject was racism. >> i have achieved all of my american dreams and then some because of the great nation, the united states of america! what's there to be angry about? >> and i would say to you, an unemployment rate for blacks that is far higher, almost 6% higher -- 7% higher than for

whites. a percentage of black incarceration in the nation's prison systems that is far greater. a lack of -- and for all of your skills, is there not some luck in that? i want to ask you that. but i would tell you that minorities, especially african-americans, can name a lot of things that speak to a certain amount of racism that they can still complain about. so i wonder if you are taking your good fortune and superimposing it over everyone else when it doesn't really apply? >> luck is when preparation meets opportunity. that's what i've done all my career. secondly, i don't believe racism in this country today holds anybody back in a big way. is there some -- are there some elements of racism? yes. it gets back to if we don't grow this economy, that is a ripple effect for every economic level, and because blacks are more

disproportionately unemployed, they get hit the worst when economic policies don't work. that's where it starts. grow this economy and it's going to help everybody to get jobs and to get back into the work force. >> at this very moment the black jobless rate is 16%. for everyone it is 9.1%. the black teen unemployment is 44.2%. that can't just be random luck, can it? >> it is not random luck. >> or bad luck. >> it's failed economic policy. >> but what accounts for the gap? >> the gap is due to a number of factors. one is a differential in education. two is a concentration of a lot of blacks in certain areas like the city of detroit where the unemployment rate there is 14% versus the 9.1% we have nationally. so if you have a city like detroit where they have lost 25% of their population, economically they've done nothing but go down, down, down. if we do not boost this national

economy, you're never going to be able to close that gap. so there are a number of factors that cause that differential, but we must start with feeding this economic engine which is why i have proposed the bold "999" plan. and, in addition to that, we are developing an empowerment zone feature off of the "999" platform that i will be announcing shortly. >> but can you be surprised if african-americans look at you saying, i'm -- became the ceo of godfather's pizza, i didn't have any -- you grew up poor but had a loving family, sounds like to me. >> yes. >> others are not so lucky, and they need help. you've been critical of the entitlement society. who -- what do you think americans, black americans, white americans, latino americans, what are we entitled to as a society? >> we are all entitled to an opportunity to be able to go

after our definition of the american dream. everybody's definition of the american dream is different. you are owed the opportunity for a level playing field. >> and do blacks have a level playing field right now with whites? >> many of them do. many of them do have a level playing field. i absolutely believe that. not only because of the businesses that i have run, which has had the combination of whites, blacks, hispanics -- you know, we had a total diversity. but also because of the corporations whose board i've served on for the last 20 years. i have seen blacks in middle management move up to top management in some of the biggest corporations in america. they weren't held back because of racism. no. people sometimes hold themselves back because they want to use racism as an excuse for them not being able to achieve what they want to achieve. >> let me ask you quickly about your campaign.

>> yes. >> and read you something that comes from a conservative iowa radio host who told "the washington post" on friday, i think he, meaning you, "is at this point not a viable candidate in iowa. the race appears to be about raising his profile and not running for president. he has not surrounded himself with the best people and he's not serious about running for president. also the crystal ball comes out of the university of virginia center for politics had this to say. "will the republican party especially in light of chris christie's decision not to run opt for cain who has never held public office, who lost his only prior election in 2004 gop u.s. senate race primary in georgia? almost certainly not. a cain nomination would be an aberration of historic proportions. american political parties typically don't nominate people without previous office holding experience for president." you add to that the fact that i'm told you have not been back to iowa in some time. you're out an a book tour and you don't look like a serious presidential candidate. convince me.

>> i would say get ready for an aberration of historic proportion, and here's why. i give dozens of speeches a week. i have been speaking -- and i've been to iowa 24 times. the perception that i am not focusing on iowa is simply a misperception. when i give speeches to rallies, town hall meetings, whatever the audience, no matter how big or small, and i get to my lack of having held public office, i get a spontaneous applause. i'm saying this, candy -- that people who are criticizing me because i have not held public office, they are out of touch with the voters out there. this is why i won that florida straw poll. this is why i won another poll that just came out yesterday, the midwestern republican leadership poll. that one maybe hasn't hit all the news wires yet. what i'm saying is the disconnect isn't between me and the voters. disconnect is between the people

who aren't connected to the voters. i'm not concerned at all because the people are saying they like the fact that i have not held public office and they love my concrete, specific ideas about how we need to fix this economy and the other problems. >> herman cain, "this is herman cain," your book out there. but you will eventually get back to iowa. >> i will. it is on the schedule. and i can promote a book and campaign at the same time. >> thanks so much for your time this morning. >> thank you. up next, michele bachmann asks voters not to settle for anything less than a true conservative. we'll ask her about that and the future of her presidential campaign. where do you go to find a super business?

you know, the ones who do such a super job, they're backed by the superguarantee®? only superpages®. wherever you are, wherever you're going, you'll find the super business you need. so next time, let the good guys save the day.

get the superguarantee®, only at superpages®. in the book ... on your phone or online. each day was fueled by thorough preparation for events to come. well somewhere along the way, emily went right on living. but you see, with the help of her raymond james financial advisor, she had planned for every eventuality. which meant she continued to have the means to live on... even at the ripe old age of 187. life well planned. see what a raymond james advisor can do for you. two of the most important are energy security and economic growth. north america actually has one of the largest oil reserves in the world. a large part of that is oil sands. this resource has the ability to create hundreds of thousands of jobs. at our kearl project in canada, we'll be able to produce these oil sands

with the same emissions as many other oils and that's a huge breakthrough. that's good for our country's energy security and our economy. joining me from the critical primary state of new hampshire, congresswoman and gop presidential candidate michele bachmann. congresswoman, thank you so much for being here. want to start out with some of the things that are in the news

beginning with the pastor who was introducing and supporting governor perry in texas who said that governor romney, who is a mormon, is not a christian. i want to know if you agree with that statement. >> you know, this is so inconsequential as far as this campaign is concerned. we have religious tolerance in this country, and we understand that people have different views on their faith, and i have a very sincerely held believe on faith and i think we just leave it at that. >> the thing is, it is not so inconsequential, is it? in a primary on the republican side where conservative christians have quite a lot of say-so, particularly when you of move south into south carolina and places like that. so it is not inconsequential for someone to call a major candidate in the republican party and the primary season not a christian. >> well, again, i have a very strong sincerely held faith. i talked about it as the values voters, and the candidates can

have the faith that they want. but the beauty about america is that we do have tolerance for each one's faith, and that's where it's at. >> just -- because i gave herman cain the same opportunity, you know that by not answering the direct question, do you think mitt romney is a christian, you leave open the possibility that people are going to say that you dodged the question, the direct question. >> no. i think what the real focus is here again is on religious tolerance. that's really what this is about. i think, again, to make this a big issue is just ridiculous right now because every day i'm on the street talking to people. this is not what people are talking about. i was very open about my faith, very clear about my faith. it's very important. but i don't think that i'll be judged based on my faith as president of the united states. i think i'll be judged based upon the good ideas that i have to turn the economy around and have job creation. >> so let's talk about turning

the economy around. the rage this week has been a surtax on millionaires. anything they make over $1 million would be taxed an additional 5.6% or so. am i correct in assuming that you think that's a bad idea? >> it is a very bad idea because remember, that's on top of all of the other tax increases that president obama is putting on this same group of people who are the job creators in this country but on every american, because we can't forget obama care itself is a huge tax increase and the dodd/frank bill, which does to financial services what obama care does to health care, also comes with increases in fees which are exactly the same as taxes as far as people's pocketbooks are concerned. so this is a very bad idea. >> well congresswoman, here is the problem i think some people have. the unemployment rate is 9.1%. there is the feeling that the government needs to do something

to break this logjam, and the idea of let's repeal regulations and environmental regulations or this or that because it is so costly to business doesn't seem to be catching fire. and yet when you ask americans about a surtax to help bring down the deficit, more than 70% say good idea so you seem -- and other republicans seem out of step. >> well, it isn't out of step to actually turn the economy around. what's out of step are all of the agendas that president obama has put into place. if we could wind the clock back to the time of the $700 billion bailout, i opposed that bailout. and had government not intervened with the trillion dollar failed stimulus and the obama care bill and dodd/frank and all the interventions that president obama put into place, the economy would have turned itself around. because what president obama doesn't seem to understand is that government doesn't create jobs. the private sector does. we need permanent solutions in the private sector.

failure has been that government -- we've had government-directed gimmicks and temporary fixes. that's what doesn't work. we have a proven record of 2 1/2, 3 years of what doesn't work. now we need to engage what does work, and that's permanent solutions in the private sector. >> let me just put out there that a lot of people think the president's stimulus program did work and saved us from losing more jobs, but i want to move you on -- >> certainly did not. there's nothing that's more provable, and that's the fact that it didn't work at all. it was a complete failure. >> well, the economy is creating jobs now -- not enough jobs and the white house will admit that, but it is creating jobs -- >> not because of the stimulus. >> okay. let me move you on because i know that's an argument that happens a lot on the campaign trail. and i wanted to ask you what you make of these wall street protests, these anti-wall street protests. do you see any anger in there that you can understand and that you relate to in any way? >> well, i went by one of the

protests in washington, d.c., on friday and i saw a lot of signs from after from unions that were there. so i don't know how spontaneous these protests were but it steams me their anger should be directed at the white house, because barack obama's policies have put us in one of the worst tailspins economically that we have. maybe that's why the protests that i saw was within shouting distance of the white house. >> let me ask you about -- you've been saying for the past couple of weeks that this is an opportunity for republicans to nominate a true conservative. some of the value voters -- i assume you would think -- are true conservatives. they had a straw poll. you were in fourth place, tied with mitt romney. herman cain was up the list. i wanted to ask you since he seems to be the one with the rising poll numbers at this point, do you consider herman cain a true conservative? >> sure. i think herman cain is a conservative. i think he's doing a great job, and i think that in this race

right now we have an opportunity to be able to elect a candidate who could do it all, because there's no question in my mind that barack obama will be a one-term candidate. i see that everywhere across the united states that i'm going. people are very disaffected by the president and by his policies, and now we're looking for someone who has the answers and someone who has the experience to be able to put those answers forward, and i think i'm that candidate. >> does herman cain have the experience, and is mitt romney a true conservative? >> well, again, i'm here to talk about me and my candidacy. i've got 55 years of experience. strong experience in the private sector, and also i think what sets me apart from all of the candidates in the race, for five years i have lived, breathed and fought against these out-of-control policies on the front lines in washington, d.c. i have a proven record that i have stood up in the gale-force winds of washington. i fought against obama care,

against dodd/frank, against the bailouts, against all of what has contributed to the joblessness in the united states. i understand this issue from the inside. we need a president who's been on the inside who understands. but i also have extensive private sector experience as a federal tax lawyer and as someone who's created my own business as well. >> let me ask you in our final moments here, in talking about your campaign, the last time we spoke you had just won the iowa straw poll. since then you came in dead last in a florida straw poll. you came in fourth at the value voters summit yesterday that we know. it appears that your campaign is imploding. what has -- why has there been such a downfall in the national polls as well as in the state polls for you? >> well, your assessment is completely inaccurate. it is not true at all. we're just starting a kick-off today of four days here in new

hampshire, and we've got a wonderful experience in iowa, and we've been in south carolina, florida, we've worked very hard an we have very strong numbers in those states and we're looking forward to continuing that. but i'll be doing several town halls today in new hampshire, and we look forward to it. and let me correct you -- we did not participate in the florida straw poll. we didn't participate at all so the ranking is completely inaccurate. >> well, then let's take new hampshire which they just put out a poll. your favorability there was 29% in july. it is now something like minus 18%. do you feel that anything has gone wrong in your campaign? what accounts for at least the trajectory of these numbers? >> i think we are doing a good job getting our message out on job growth and on turning the economy around. that's what we're working on. we're not focusing on the day to day. because as you have seen with many of the other candidates, candidates go up, candidates go down, and what we're very concerned about is making sure that the message gets out there,

because it is not about any one of us, it is about turning the economy around and creating jobs. that's my focus, and i think that's why i won the all-important iowa straw poll. that poll is the only poll of all the ones that you've mentioned where anyone in the state can participate. it's the most reflective of an actual primary election or caucus, and that's why we were excited to win that poll. >> congresswoman, thank you. just quickly. are you planning to run for re-election in your district or have you decided come what may -- >> candy, i am running to be president of the united states. >> have you ruled out running in your district? >> candy, i am running to be president of the united states. >> fair enough. thank you so much. congresswoman michele bachmann, good luck to you there in new hampshire. >> thank you, candy. after the break, we'll talk to our panel about the latest jobs numbers and how the economy could shake up this election season. [ junior ] i played professional basketball for 12 years.

today i own 165 wendy's restaurants. and i get my financing from ge capital. but i also get stuff that goes way beyond banking. we not only lend people money, we help them save it. [ junior ] ge engineers found ways to cut my energy use. [ cheryl ] more efficient lighting helps junior stay open later... [ junior ] and serve more customers. so you're not just getting financial capital... [ cheryl ] you're also getting human capital. not just money. knowledge. [ junior ] ge capital. they're not just bankers... we're builders. [ junior ] ...and they've helped build my business. you know, the ones who do such a super job, we're builders. they're backed by the superguarantee®? only superpages®. wherever you are, wherever you're going, you'll find the super business you need. so next time, let the good guys save the day.

get the superguarantee®, only at superpages®. in the book ... on your phone or online. so i took my heartburn pill and some antacids. we're having mexican tonight, so another pill then? unless we eat later, then pill later? if i get a snack now, pill now? skip the snack, pill later... late dinner, pill now? aghh i've got heartburn in my head. [ male announcer ] stop the madness of treating frequent heartburn. it's simple with prilosec otc. one pill a day. twenty-four hours. zero heartburn. no heartburn in the first place. great.

aspercreme breaks the grip, with maximum-strength medicine and no embarrassing odor. break the grip of pain with aspercreme.

joining me here in washington to discuss the politics of a recovering economy, we hope, mark zandi, chief economist for moody's analytics, peter baker, white house correspondent for "the new

york times," and ron brownstein of the ""national journal."" times up. let's start with this surtax on the rich. from a purely economic point of view, good idea? >> well, you think we need to extend and expand the payroll tax holiday for workers. that's the president's proposal. that's vital i think to keep the recovery going because if that doesn't happen the tax rates are going to rise for everybody. in this weak economy that's a problem. and it has to be paid for, and i think a surtax on millionaires is a reasonable way to pay for it. it is going to hurt. you raise taxes on anybody, it has negative consequences. >> to the economy? >> to the economy, sure. yeah, on the margin. but i think of all the different ways you can think of to try to pay for this thing and it has to be paid for in the long run, this seems like the most reasonable way to do it. >> so from a political basis, someone made an interesting argument that once you define "rich" as a millionaire, it then becomes hard to come back and say -- and let's stop the bush tax cuts on someone making $250,000. have they walked themselves or backed themselves into a corner

on this? >> it depends on what counts as rich today and where you stand and where you sit. look, president obama with this idea of looking after millionaires on taxes partly trying to make up to his base what happened last december when he agreed to the extension of the bush tax cuts across the board, including for the wealthiest 2%. liberal base upset about that. he's coming back around saying i agree that the wealthiest are not paying their fair share. >> but millionaires has a great ring for the campaign trail. >> if you look at all the options for reducing the deficit, the only one that polls well consistently is raising taxes on the affluent, even at 250,000 and above. this goes to a larger issue for the president which is whether voters in 2012 will make their judgment on him mostly retrospectively or prospectively. because all the assessments of his performance looking back over these three years have been deteriorating and are pretty difficult shape at this point. when you compare his plans for creating jobs or reducing the deficit to republican plans he

looks much better. this is part of a larger effort, this millionaire surtax which of course was a senate democratic idea, it is part of a larger effort to say we want the voters to be looking forward, we want this to be a choice not a referendum. not always easy to do for an incumbent president especially in hard times. >> let me ask you about the housing market. just from purely an economic point of view, can we have any kind of big recovery if the housing market is still in the tank? >> no. i mean, housing is so key to recoveries. it provides a lot of juice coming out of recessions because it is a very interest rate sensitive sector. rates come down, people go out and buy homes, build homes. house prices rise. >> create jobs for people -- >> absolutely. so we haven't seen any of that. it is largely because of the fact that the housing market was the crux of the matter. that's where all the speculation was, that's where all the overbuilding was, that's a lot of now the foreclosed properties a result of all this, so we had to work through this further to get the housing market on more solid ground and the economy moving forward. >> yet we hear about jobs programs and don't hear about

housing programs. >> remember harry truman said give me a one-armed economist? then say "on the other hand"? no. that was -- >> that was good. >> if you do look at the states, we've looked at census data, did a 50-state report by the states that have seen the biggest job loss and biggest loss in income are those that have been at the epicenter of the housing crash. so this is clearly at the center and there is really no solution. solutions they've offered have been disappointing i think the number of people able to take advantage of it. there is a counterargument that says rather than trying to keep people in their homes they should let foreclosures go through and let the market bottom out. but it does seem in many ways the agenda that they put forward gets to the edges of this. there's other work for people who do constructions, infrastructure, rehabbing schools. it doesn't really resolve the core problem of creating a viable housing market and all the economic engine that it provides. >> the problem for president obama is time is running out. right? he's had three years at this point and under the best case

scenario, he waterboarded mark zandi and other economists to say what's the most optimistic scenario? the economy will still be in bad shape a year from now. what he has to hope for is that everything is trending in the right direction, that something comes along because of his jobs program or some other factor that shows some job improvement. even if unemployment is still above 8%, he has to argue things are better, not worse. >> and will he be able to argue that? >> well, i think if policymakers do a few right things over the next few months, not only, unfortunately, here in the u.s. but also in europe because europe is a very large problem as well, i think the economy should be moving more clearly in the right direction a year from now. but it is a close call. under the best of circumstances, i don't think we're below a 9% unemployment rate. >> that would be extraordinary. no president since roosevelt in '36 had to deal with anything like that. >> little more on this when we get back. we have to take a quick break. oy some camouflage pants but i couldn't find any. [ rimshot ]

thank you, thank you i'll be here all week. in fact, i'll be here for the next 18 years. [ rimshot ] is this really necessary? come on ma, laughter is the best medicine! i'm just glad i stocked up on the real stuff. tough crowd. [ male announcer ] get low prices every day on everything to prepare for cold and flu season. we're so confident in our low prices, we back 'em with our ad match guarantee. save money. live better. walmart. backed by the superguarantee®? with find a businessarantee. only& suonline.s®. on your phone. or in the book. go to superpages®. and let the good guys save the day. but they also go beyond banking. we installed a ge fleet monitoring system. it tracks every vehicle in their fleet.

it cuts fuel use. koch: it enhances customer service. it's pretty amazing when people who loan you money also show you how to save it. not just money, knowledge. it's so much information, it's like i'm right there in every van in the entire fleet. good day overall. yeah, i'm good. come on in. let's go. wow, this is fantastic. ge capital. they're not just bankers. we're builders. they helped build our business.

we are back with mark standi, peter baker, and ron brownste brownstein. let me start at that end of the dabl about mormonism. we had this preacher who said that romney is not a christian. i think you saw at the top of the show both herman cain and

michele bachmann would not say that's not right. >> right. >> didn't want to talk about it and sort of went around it. is this an issue? this was not good for romney or perry for different reasons. for romney, the problem in the republican primary about his faith really has never gone away. if you look at the results from 2008, he ran poorly among evangelical christians, especially in the southern states. never topped out above 20% of the vote among that group. only 11% in south carolina. that's 45% of the total republican primary vote for evangelical christians. not a great moment for rick perry either because the biggest concern he faces in the republican primary are the concerns among voters outside of the south about whether he can sell beyond the mason/dixon line. that is reminder if you nominate rick perry there's a lot of cultural baggage or cultural association that comes along with that that may not play as well in, say, bergen county, new jersey, as it does in plano. so i think this was not a really good 24 hours for either romney,

because it reminds evangelicals about some of the things they won't like about him, or for perry, because it reminds the more secular parts of the party why they may be hesitant him. >> romt knee has to hope this is already baked in, all poll numbers already assuming these people won't for him because they know he's a mormon. >> and the social issues, not just the faith, yeah. >> and look how quickly they want to get away from that. the question is how much will this conversation continue to dominate two, three months from now if it's dealt with this early on and people move on? probably good for him. i think the question we ask in polls, would you be more likely or less likely to vote for somebody if they're a mormon, is taken in isolation. it doesn't assume a real person they've gotten to know. romney has been on the scene for about four years and people have gotten to know him good or bad. >> still be a surprise if he gets a hot of evangelical votes, especially in the south. >> in the primary. >> in the primary. >> he's not going to run on his

mormonism but on his business experience. can he? is that a positive for mitt romney? >> i think so. it's certainly to his strength. he's an excellent business person, highly successful. he helped finance a lot of companies, successful companies, and he learned about their business, helped them with their business. i think he has a very good background with respect to the economy broadly. yes. now there's also the dark side to -- >> just fired a lot of people. >> that's part of the economy, too, because there's winners and losers and we need both for economies to be successful. i think he's seen both sides and hopefully that makes him the better president. clearly that's his strong suit. >> dealer's choice. two questions in our final two minutes. one, how does a politician make use of these anti-wall street protests that are out there? and, two, given what mark says, which is he still sees 9% unemployment, basically a not great economic picture in 2012, maybe a little more growth than we're seeing now.

but how does that bode for the president. >> question one, post 2008 faith collapsed in the private and public sector, wall street, big banks, corporations, and. in 2009 and 2010, republicans were able to turn the animus toward government. this is an attempt by the left to begin to kind of equalize that scale. obama has to be careful with it because his coalition has changed. the democratic coalition is more upscale than it used to be, and populism is not always a slam dunk. on the other question, like peter said, he has to argue trajectory. he wants to make the argument. things may not be perfect now but we are moving in the right direction and do you want to go back to the policies that ran us into the ditch. he needs, however, some tailwind, some evidence that things are getting better to make that argument compelling. >> the first question, president obama has to be able to find a way to tap into that energy without taking ownership over the most extreme elements of that movement the same way republicans don't want to own everything that the tea party might necessarily stand for. in terms of 2012, what's interesting for obama is the

challenge is exactly opposite of 2008. in 2008 he won because he represented what seemed to be a positive force, hope, change, and so forth. in 2012 because the sxhi is still going to be bad, he'll have to say the other guy is worse and it is a campaign that will divide rather than unite. >> just a yes-or-no questions since they violated the rules of picking one question. and that is will the president have anything in the economy he can run on a year from now? >> i think so. i think it really matters on the trend line. so think, you know, late next year, coming up to the election, stock prices are rising, we see more green on our screen than red, if house prices have stopped falling and start rising, and we see some stronger job growth, i think that's something to run on. >> mark, peter, ron, thank you. up next, a look at the top stories. then on "fareed zakaria: gps" a discussion about the achilles heel of the economy. that's at the top of the hour. o. like an apricot... or a prune. and i like both, i just don't want to look like one. covergirl and olay simply ageless foundation

has regenerist serum and floats above lines and makes you look younger. you will look so young people will be like "how is that baby driving a minivan?" "who let the baby into the bar?" and so on. can your anti-aging makeup do that? ♪ simply ageless from olay and easy, breezy beautiful, covergirl.

> time for a check of today's top stories. new york mayor michael bloomberg says the occupy wall street protesters could destroy the jobs of working people. the protests are taking place in more than a dozen states. in southwest pakistan, four men torched two tankers