tv Anderson Cooper 360 CNN June 25, 2013 10:00pm-11:00pm PDT
10:00 pm
we'll be right back after this break. that's all for us tonight. anderson cooper with the george zimmerman trial starts right now. good evening. welcome to our special continuing coverage. self-defense or murder, the george zimmerman trial. every night this week, we'll be digging deeper with the best legal team around and frequently with the principals in the case themselves. tonight, powerful emotion at testimony about trayvon martin's final moments and a legal battle over the 911 tapes. from six months before the 911 tapes that were recorded before the shooting, recordings the state believes will speak to george zimmerman's state of mind to his unjustified suspicion, they say, of trayvon martin. first, the latest on everything that happened today from martin savidge who joins us now. what new evidence did we hear today in the courtroom? >> reporter: it was photographs,
10:01 pm
anderson. i've seen all the photographs in this case, but i had not seen these before. these were photographs of the body of trayvon martin laying on the ground. i don't care who you are, they have a strong impact to see a young person you know lying lifeless on the ground. so clearly it would impact the jurors and it impacted everyone else. we saw the gun that george zimmerman used, that's the cal tech 9. and then we saw the sweatshirt, very powerful. that's not a piece of evidence to the family, it's an icon. it represents the racial profiling they believe george zimmerman is guilty of. >> the sergeants gave very emotional testimony about finding trayvon martin on the scene. tell us about it. >> reporter: yeah, this was another one of those aspects that humanizes trayvon martin, because he's not there. so we hear these accounts. this was a first responder as he
10:02 pm
frantically describes trying to revive the young boy. and listen. >> did you see any movement from trayvon martin's body as you approached him? >> no, sir, i did not. >> did you hear any sounds coming from trayvon martin? >> no, sir, i did not. >> did you attempt to see if trayvon martin was still alive? >> yes, sir. >> how did you do that? >> i attempted to take his pulse. >> have you had training in that? >> yes, i have. >> did you detect a pulse on trayvon martin? >> no, sir, i did not. >> and mark o'mara grilled an eyewitness toward if end of court today. >> reporter: legal experts say that was the most important point of the day. this was a witness who lives in the complex. what she had described was she heard returning and on the stand day, she heard running from the left to run. that implies a chase, not
10:03 pm
self-defense as the defense is trying to say. so listen how mr. o'mara went after this witness. >> when was the first time you ever told anybody that you heard or saw whatever it was, movement from left to right outside of your back door? was it today? and if so, just tell us. >> i don't know if it was just today. >> okay. i'll ask it this way. could it be that the first time you mentioned this new piece of evidence was just now as you testified? >> it could be. i don't know. >> reporter: this touches upon a sore spot for the defense, because they maintained in the past they believe that in discovering the witness didn't tell them everything. the fact that she jumps out and
10:04 pm
says left to right, they had never heard that. in the minds of the defense, it might have reinforced their colonel. they're going to go aggressively after all of these witnesses. >> we'll talk to mark o'mara later on tonight. our legal team will be with us throughout the night. jose baez will be here, mark geragos and sunny hostin. powerful testimony we heard today in that court, sunny. >> absolutely. i think what was most powerful were the images themselves. they just spoke so loudly. i've seen so many crime scene photos, but i even gasped when some of those photos came up. and they came up through the testimony of one of these officers who was just the classic officer. he was dressed up. he had a s.w.a.t. team plate on his shirt, and he started
10:05 pm
talking about how he was trying to save trayvon martin's life, trying to breathe for him. >> i want to play some of that right now, the officer on the stand. >> did you hear anything when you were performing cpr on trayvon martin? >> yes, sir. >> what was that? >> bubbling sounds. >> what did that indicate to you? >> it meant either air was getting into or escaping from the chest in a manner it was not supposed to, sir. >> what did you do upon hearing those bubbling sounds from trayvon martin's chest? >> i called out to the crowd that was gathering nearby, and i asked for seran wrap and vaseline. >> what would be the purpose for seran wrap and vaseline? >> i was going to seal the chest wound. >> what did you do next? >> i laid him on his back. >> did you continue cpr after you laid him down? >> yes, sir, i did. >> and was rescue called to that
10:06 pm
scene? >> yes, sir. >> did they respond? >> yes, sir. >> and did rescue take over the cpr efforts after they arrived? >> yes, sir. >> what did you see the rescue personnel do to treat or assess trayvon martin? >> i watched them hook up the leads to the ekg machine to trayvon martin. >> was trayvon martin pronounced dead at the scene? >> yes, sir. >> what are they trying to do? >> it's a murder case. you have to prove that he died. it's as simple as that. every juror, as well as every spectator knew that he died of a gun shot wound. but it's so much more vivid and real when you hear that officer talk about seran wrap and vaseline. it lends an immediacy and frankly a tragedy. you think of this boy dying on the floor like that. you know, sure, it doesn't tell
10:07 pm
you anything about whether it was self-defense or whether it was murder, but it gives a vividness that the prosecution wants and the jury won't forget. >> mark, the defense really didn't have much to ask this police sergeant. what's the thinking when there's very little cross-examination? is it just that not a lot to dispute or just to get the person off the stand? >> jeff just said it. the prosecution wasn't proving anything. this was an emotional ploy to get in this -- to deal with stuff that has absolutely nothing to do with the evidence. the only part of this case where they dealt with the evidence is when mark o'mara surgery dismantled that witness who had the ah-ha memory today, and you know, when you introduce this segment where you said that they've been complaining about it all along, i frankly had never seen the hide the ball nature of these prosecutors in this case has been astonishing,
10:08 pm
breathtaking. and today was another example of it. >> you think they're exceptionally hiding evidence? >> absolutely. hey, there's already an osc contempt on the prosecution that the judge put over to the end of the case, because she didn't want to make a circus out of it now. they caught the prosecution basically with their parents down on turning over discovery. >> what is an osc? >> order to show cause rae contempt. as to whether or not she's going to sanction the prosecution for some of their discovery abuse. today, this is just infuriating, where all of a sudden they put a witness on, they know what the witness is going to say. they didn't turn that information over. in florida, unlike other jurisdictions, we don't get depositions in criminal cases. so all of a sudden this key piece of information, this witness has a miraculous memory on the day of trial.
10:09 pm
spare me. >> jeff? >> first of all, you say that the evidence isn't relevant. of course it's relevant, mark. they have to put this evidence on. a defense attorney may not enjoy listening to it, but it's relevant evidence. >> there is no relevant evidence to the methods by which -- >> these are crime scene photos. >> you could stipulate that he died. everybody knows it's a tragedy. >> the prosecution doesn't have to stipulate. >> what's the relevance of this? >> they're crime scene photos. since when are crime scene photos irrelevant to a murder case? >> crime scene photos are relevant. however, this idea of seran wrap and this ghoulish nature of the bubbling and the gurgling, that's pure histrionics. >> the crime scene tech nick who took the photos of his head also
10:10 pm
took the stand. >> that's a picture you took, correct? >> that is correct. >> and you see that sort of lump on the top right of his head? >> yes, i can. >> and you saw it that night too, right? >> yes, i did. >> 67 shows blood dripping behind mr. zimmerman's left hear, is that correct? >> that is correct. >> this would be of his right side again, closer to the front. you see that lump? >> yes, i do. >> and do you see the abrasions in the temple area? >> yes, i do. >> and you saw them that night, too? >> that is correct. >> this is the back of mr. zimmerman's head in exhibit number 74. you see the lacerations? >> yes, i do.
10:11 pm
>> you saw them that night as well i take it? >> yes, i did. >> there were over two dozen photos of bruised and bloodied george zimmerman. how effective do you think that was, jose? >> i think it's effective to a certain point. what they're doing is they're taking the defense's best evidence head on. they've already admitted during their opening statements that, at some point, trayvon martin was on top of george zimmerman. so what they're showing this jury or what they're attempting to show the jury is basically this. we know there was a scuffle. we know at some point trayvon martin was getting the best of george zimmerman. and despite all of this, we still think there's a second degree murder charge here. and i think they're doing what they have to do and what they should do, not hide from it because there's going to come a point where the defense is going to hit them over the head wit. >> because it was the prosecution that put those photos into evidence. >> it's all about stealing the thunder.
10:12 pm
>> and it's relevant. i want to know mark -- >> let me explain something to you, sunny. >> please do, mark. >> there is a difference -- you know i love you, sunny, but there is a difference between somebody stipulating and saying i'm not going to dispute there is a death, whereas somebody is disputing whether or not it is self-defense, where self-defense, where you do have to put on evidence and the state has a burden. i know this is a technical question, but that is the law. >> what i find interesting about those head wounds is i don't know as a juror, do i think of those as big wounds or little wounds? they don't look like someone who is in the risk of dieing? >> particularly a head wound which -- heads plead a lot. >> it's almost a shaved head, so it's not like his head would protect him. so is a jury going to say there was a big struggle or say those look like minor scrapes? >> yesterday in the court when the defense was saying it's not
10:13 pm
true that trayvon martin wasn't armed. he was armed with the concrete sidewalk which he repeated slammed george zimmerman's head into. the question is, do those wounds indicate that? >> well, how many -- >> they certainly don't look like fingernail scratches. >> how many times do you have to be hit over the head until you realize you're in a deadly situation? >> i defended murder cases where somebody fell once against a curb and was killed. you don't have to get hit on the curb more than once to die. >> stick around, we'll talk more throughout this hour. i want to dig deeper into the fight over those phone calls that george zimmerman made to authorities in the months prior to the shooting. the prosecution wants them in. would they work just as well for the defense? and later, my interview with one of the key players, mark o'mara. he joins us coming up. i'll ask about his co-counsel's
10:14 pm
knock knock joke yesterday and much more when our special coverage continues. la's knowny for its traffic, congestion, for it's smog. but there are a lot of people that do ride the bus. and now that the busses are running on natural gas, they don't throw out as much pollution to the earth. so i feel good. i feel like i'm doing my part to help out the environment. as well as they could because they don't take it with food. switch to citracal maximum plus d. it's the only calcium supplement that can be taken with or without food. my doctor recommends citracal maximum. it's all about absorption.
10:16 pm
your next trip is calling you. saying, "dan, schedule a 5 o'clock meeting at a hilton garden inn." or "dan"... hey, dad. ..."explore your family tree at a homewood suites." [ family ] hi, dan. or "put your feet in the sand at a waldorf astoria." never stop vacationing, dan. book during the great getaway for great rates at our ten top hotel brands. travel is calling you to hiltongreatgetaways.com.
10:17 pm
he's coming to check me out. he's got something in his hands. i don't know what it is. >> that's part of the 911 call that george zimmerman made just minutes before he shot trayvon martin. jurors will hear that recording. the prosecution also wants them to hear six other 911 calls that zimmerman made before that deadly night to report suspicious people in his neighborhood or people he thought was suspicious. the prosecution says it shows his growing frustration at folks breaking into things in the neighborhood. here are some of the highlights. >> hey, our neighborhood got burglarized or robbed today, and my wife saw one of the kids that did it. and we see someone that matches his description in the neighborhood right now again. >> is he white, black or hispanic? >> black.
10:18 pm
my wife talked to detective walker and gave him a description of the guy we see now. hi, there is a break-in, in my neighborhood recently and two youths that match the description of the people -- my wife i.d.'d them and saw them. they're back in the neighborhood. >> what do they look like, white, black or hispanic? >> two black males in their teens. we had our neighborhood watch meeting yesterday and officer buchanon came out and told us to report anything suspicious. i was just calling because we've had a lot of break-ins in our neighborhood recently and i'm on the neighborhood watch. and there's two suspicious characters at the gate of my neighborhood. i've never seen them before. i have no idea what they're doing, they're just hanging out, loitering.
10:19 pm
>> mr. zimmerman, can you describe the two individuals? >> two african-american males. they look -- i know one is in a white impala. >> how do they look to you? >> mid to late 20s, early 30s. >> i'm with the neighborhood watch and we've had some burglaries and vandalisms lately. >> is he white, black or hispanic? >> mark, we talked about this in the 8:00 hour tonight. this cuts both ways. you could say well, this shows a concerned citizen, a concerned member of the neighborhood watch. >> well, anderson, you're the one that brought it up and couldn't agree more. i don't know why the defense is
10:20 pm
fighting to keep this stuff out. with this jury demographic, it's almost turned on its head. you have the defense looking for kind of prosecutorial types. and in this case, i think a lot -- this kind of guy who is constantly out there, calling and making reports and worried about the neighborhood, there's a lot of people that embrace that. and i don't know why, if they're going to denigrate him because he's one of these, you know, concerned citizens, i think that could backfire on them. >> for the prosecution, they're saying this shows a growing frustration on his part at what's happening in the neighborhood. >> i think they're inadmissible, because it suggests -- the prosecution is putting them in to show that he's an obsessed wannabe cop, but we don't know whether he actually saw these people. we don't know whether these were
10:21 pm
actual suspicious characters around. and the court does not want to get sidetracked into mini trials about whether there were in fact two suspicious characters months earlier. if i were the judge, they should keep the whole thing out. >> i think it's relevant to state of mind. the government has to prove depraved mind and what was inside george zimmerman's head if they're going to get a second degree murder conviction. >> wasn't that his job? >> he's talking about suspicious black males. when you use the same language over and over again, i think it shows what is in your head and i think that's relevant to this case. >> the problem is -- i'll tell you another thing what's going to happen if these tapes get admitted. one of those prosecutors is going to call that 20-year-old kid that works in their office and they're going to -- in their closing arguments they'll key in on the specific times that he mentions that they're black
10:22 pm
males, black males, black males and played as the last one, the one when he calls on trayvon martin. i think that's what they're going to use it for. they'll try to ram it down their throat and show some type of pattern to go along with their theory of the case, which is profile, profile, profile. >> how long does the judge have to rule on something like this, mark? >> before they want to call the witness. so that's what they generally do. harking back to sunny, the problem is, if you want to show that these calls are a depraved mind, you better hope that you're not -- that the calls and what he's doing does not resonate with one of those jurors. because if one of those jurors say yeah, i would be doing the same thing or i wish my husband or son was doing this, that's going to completely backfire on them. >> it could be a double edge sword, and we can agree on that, mark. >> i want to play the 911 call where the operator asks zimmerman if he's following trayvon martin. let's listen. >> are you following him?
10:23 pm
>> yes. >> okay, we don't need you to do that. >> okay. >> a few weeks earlier, there was another 911 call that zimmerman made where he did not want to follow a suspicious personal. let's listen. >> he's going up to the house and then going along the side of it, and then coming to the street. and then going back to the side of it. i don't know what he's doing. i don't want to approach him personally. >> jeff, do you read anything to why he chose not to follow this person? >> i think this is all inadmissible. if you're charged with robbing a bank, you don't get to put into evidence all the banks you didn't rob. so i think the judge should keep the evidence focused on what the evidence is. i don't think that tape should come in, i don't think the other tape should come in. i think they're just sideshows that create distractions about evidence that's not before the jury. i think obviously the one where the 911 operator says don't approach him, that's key evidence.
10:24 pm
the rest of it is just a distraction. >> i want to play a clip of the woman who helped start the neighborhood watch program in zimmerman's community. >> do you address specifically what a neighborhood watch person is to do if they see someone acting suspicious? >> yes, i do. >> if someone is acting suspicious, you call 911. >> do you tell them to do anything else at that point? >> no. they're the eyes and ears. >> in that instruction, is that also part of the written materials? >> yes. >> all right. >> what do you tell volunteers about following someone they believe is involved in criminal behavior? >> we tell them don't do that, that's the job of law enforcement. >> what do you tell about neighborhood watch participants about confronting someone? >> not to confront us, let the police department do the job. >> she gives slide presentations to people who want to be in neighborhood watches. one of them says not the vigilante.
10:25 pm
clearly the prosecution is laying the ground work for this idea that he's some kind of vigilante. >> i thought that witness was somewhat helpful to the defense. later on in her examination, he said she found george zimmerman to be meek and thought he was helpful and she wanted him to be in even more sophisticated neighborhood type watch program. and that sort of cuts against this notion that the prosecution is putting forward that he was this initial aggressor. she actually described him as meek. so i don't know that witness was as helpful to the prosecution as i think they thought she would be. >> i thought it was a defense witness they called out of order. you watch that, and what the prosecution thought they were
10:26 pm
going to get in this was, okay, he violated these neighborhood watch rules. that isn't a statute. it's not a code section. there's nothing wrong with that. you may get drummed out of neighborhood watch, but you're not going to boot strap that into a murder. and as sunny says, the stuff that the defense got out was exactly what you want, if you're the defense lawyer in this case. >> when you combine that testimony with the 911 operator saying don't approach him, that's pretty bad. that's a very bad piece of evidence for the defense, don't you think, mark? that 911 tape. >> when they say don't approach, that's a bad fact. i'm not going to dispute that. but this woman, when you talk about this woman and what she brought to the prosecution, the burden clearly outweighed the benefits for the prosecution. >> when george zimmerman called 911 when someone's garage door
10:27 pm
wasn't opening. does that indicate to you anything? >> he called constantly. it hasn't come in yet, but he called dozens and dozens of times. and i think that's why, jeff, i'm going to disagree with you again, i think it's relevant to his state of mind. all these calls over and over again. they're telling him not to take the law into his own hands and be a vigilante, but why is he calling so much? >> i guess a key question is how much should someone's past actions be allowed to place in a case like this? >> in florida, we have what's called williams rule. it's generally used for prior bad acts. but these are somewhat good acts, so it's a little different. however, the theory behind it is it goes to show motive. and in this case, i think that's what the prosecution is trying to use it for, motive. however, they're supposed to give the defense prior notice of this, and it doesn't appear that
10:28 pm
was done in this case. so i do think at times -- >> surprise, surprise, surprise. >> especially in mr. zimmerman takes the stand, he's going to be questioned about these prior calls, like that call where he didn't want to follow those times, but did he have his gun with him at that time. >> jose, what are the odds that zimmerman is going to take the stand? >> never. >> i'll give you 50-1 odds and you can lay as much money as you want. >> i'll take that bet. >> zimmerman will never get within five feet of that stand. >> he took the stand during the bond hearing. >> you're so sure because it would be a disaster for the defense? >> there's no way they're going to put george zimmerman -- remember, we talked about the only thing that he could do to lose this case is fall on his head. if he falls on his head and hits it and lets this guy tell more knock knock jokes, maybe they'll put him on the stand.
10:29 pm
>> he doesn't need to, because he's given so many statements already. it's almost like the conrad murray case. >> mark o'mara is coming up after this next break. i'm going to ask him about that knock knock joke, whether it was planned or not. and you probably noticed how different george zimmerman looks different these days, more than 100 pounds difference. we'll be right back. i'm the next american success story. working for a company where over seventy-five percent of store management started as hourly associates. there's opportunity here. i can use walmart's education benefits to get a degree, maybe work in it, or be an engineer, helping walmart conserve energy. even today, when our store does well, i earn quarterly bonuses. when people look at me, i hope they see someone working their way up. vo: opportunity, that's the real walmart.
10:30 pm
let's see what you got. rv -- covered. why would you pay for a hotel? i never do. motorcycles -- check. atv. i ride those. do you? no. boat. house. hello, dear. hello. hello. oh! check it -- [ loud r&b on car radio ] i'm going on break! the more you bundle, the more you save. now, that's progressive. every day we're working to and to keep our commitments. and we've made a big commitment to america. bp supports nearly 250,000 jobs here. through all of our energy operations, we invest more in the u.s. than any other place in the world. in fact, we've invested over $55 billion here in the last five years - making bp america's largest energy investor. our commitment has never been stronger.
10:32 pm
10:33 pm
your co-counsel got some attention yesterday for a knock knock joke he told as an opening statement. was that something the two of you had discussed before hand. what did you think about it? >> we had not discussed it. i would note it didn't work the way he wanted it to. >> the state had wanted to have some audio experts, what they said were audio experts testify saying that -- on that 911 call that according to these two experts it was not george zimmerman's voice yelling for help.
10:34 pm
they were not allowed to testify because essentially the fbi and others said the science just isn't there yet, the techniques aren't there. that must have been a key ruling for you. >> well, you know, yes and no. obviously on the surface it looks like a key ruling, but we have to back up a little bit. we had our witnesses, experts who would say that it was george zimmerman. so i was not worried about the idea of having a sort of spectrum of experts to say everything across the board, but what we realized once we found out about the case, was that no expert could have a firm opinion about whose voice it was. even two of the state's experts, the two that the state pulled off of their witness list the week before the hearing, those witnesses said they thought it may have been trayvon martin on the first scream or two and believe or thought it was probably george zimmerman on the last scream or two. it sounds like a huge thing for the defense that we kept out this evidence for our client.
10:35 pm
that's absolutely untrue. the evidence that would have come in, had it come in, would have been across the board. mr. owen, who again has the financial interest in his little magic machine would have said what he said and that was only a tendency and mr. rike, who here states nobody else hears in the universal was not let in because nobody else could recreate his supposed test. so i would almost have encouraged letting those people in front of a jury just so we could have shown them for who they are. >> interesting. i want to play this back. >> please don't go off focus here. >> object, he's badgering the witness. now he's coming up with some fanciful thing. >> stop this right now.
10:36 pm
i have told counsel before, first of all, no one talks over the other, the court reporter can only take one person down at a time. i will not have any speaking objections in the courtroom. what is your legal objection? >> he's harassing the witness, your honor. >> overruled. i don't need a comment, i just need you to show the counsel. >> are those just the ups and downs of a trial, the judge establishing her jurisdiction? >> it's her domain, she knows her rules, i should not be speaking my objections. nobody should. it's difficult for lawyers not to talk. and this case is sort of packed with emotions, both outside the courtroom and inside the courtroom. but she's going to run the courtroom properly. she was right when she told me to back down. and i take her advice to heart and her rulings.
10:37 pm
>> was there anything in the prosecution's opening statement, the 30-minute or so opening statement that surprised you? a lot of people paid attention to their use of george zimmerman's words, really the first things out of the prosecutor's mouth after saying good morning. >> you know, people say i look like joel osteen and now he's trying to sound like him, i guess. you know, that shock value, it's funny. not to keep mentioning the bizarro case, but generally speaking you have defense attorneys who will try to some maneuver to try and impassion the jury. here we have a prosecutor saying what he's saying frying to emotionally charge the jury against mr. zimmerman. >> how concerned are you about the presence of trayvon martin's parents in the courtroom? several times, because of testimony, graphic pictures, they've gotten up, his mother, his father today. apparently jurors are watching that, are seeing that. does that concern you?
10:38 pm
i know you wanted the zimmerman parents -- george zimmerman's parents to be able to be in the courtroom. they won't be until they have testified. >> this is a tragedy for both families. i said that since the first day you and i talked. and if they need to leave the courtroom i'm fine. what i don't want is any type of maneuver or show boating or something that would suggest to try to impact on that jury. as long as they stay away from negative impact on the jury, both the martin side and the zimmerman side, then we'll have a good, just verdict based on the evidence. >> it's probably too early to ask this, and you probably wouldn't answer even if you did know, but have you planned to take george zimmerman take the stand? >> i've always said that's a dynamic decision we have to make only once we look at the evidence the state presents. this has always been a case as every criminal case where the state has to prove their case. in this case, they have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt not only that the crime was
10:39 pm
committed, and that it was in fact a crime, but george did not do so in self-defense. they have to disprove self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt. if i think they ever get to that burden, then we might consider whether we have to present any case on. >> good to have you on. thank you. >> sure. >> if you listened during that interview, you could hear mark geragos laughing. just about everybody is saying george zimmerman won't take the stand. george zimmerman's appearance has changed radically. his lawyer says he's gained more than 100 pounds. will this play a role in the case and the way the jury perceives george zimmerman and the physical altercation he had with trayvon martin? that's next. a shooting star! make a wish! i wish we could lie here forever. i wish this test drive was over, so we could head back to the dealership. [ male announcer ] it's practically yours. test drive!
10:40 pm
[ male announcer ] but we still need your signature. volkswagen sign then drive is back. and it's never been easier to get a jetta. that's the power of german engineering. get $0 down, $0 due at signing, $0 deposit, and $0 first month's payment on any new volkswagen. visit vwdealer.com today. the healthcare law gives us powerful tools to fight it... to investigate it... ...prosecute it... and stop criminals. our senior medicare patrol volunteers... are teaching seniors across the country... ...to stop, spot, and report fraud.
10:41 pm
you can help. guard your medicare card. don't give out your card number over the phone. call to report any suspected fraud. we're cracking down on medicare fraud. let's make medicare stronger for all of us. enjoy an unforgettable breakfast at an embassy suites, or lead a victory dance at a hampton. get great rates at our ten top hotel brands during the great getaway. book now at hiltongreatgetaways.com.
10:43 pm
there's no way not to notice that george zimmerman looks a lot different now than the night he shot trayvon martin. his lawyer says he's gained more than 100 pounds. in a trial with something like this, how much weight a defendant gains can be analyzed from all different angles. >> reporter: this is george zimmerman when he was first questioned about shooting trayvon martin. he was 5'8" and weighed 194 pounds. that was february 26, 2012. back then, zimmerman was fit. just look at his mug shot and his early court appearances.
10:44 pm
but watches a his look changed over the last year or so. his body ballooned. zimmerman's lawyer says he's gained about 120 pounds. does this look like the same man to you? we asked patty wood, a body language expert, to tell us what she sees. then and now. >> this is a skinny george zimmerman. >> yeah. >> reporter: what do you see? >> here we see he's very comfortable. see how he elongates his torso? he's very proud and feels very powerful and strong. >> reporter: even in shackles, that's very interesting. so he's very comfortable in his body. do you see that same attitude? >> yes, obviously his walk is tilted. but again, notice how elongated he is. often i see in this situation, downcast, shoulders over, very, very burdened. in this case, he's not. he's feeling really comfortable in his body. >> reporter: when we showed patty the heavier set zimmerman
10:45 pm
who now weighs about 300 pounds. >> he's agitated and much more upset. what's remarkable is he's actually comfortable with the excessive weight. so that tells me that he's comfortable and not feeling guilty. >> reporter: how does she think the jury will respond to the more plump george zimmerman? >> weight gain, excessive weight, we have a lot of negative connotations to it. so it can work against him. on the other hand, before he looked like a lean, mean, fighting machine and very young and fit. so why did he need to pull out a gun? so it may work for him in an odd way. >> reporter: that's led to speculation the weight gain might be a deliberate strategy. but on piers morgan, zimmerman's attorney explains the weight gain was less about strategy and more about stress. >> he's gained an enormous amount of weight, over 120
10:46 pm
pounds i think, because he is sitting in a house, stressed, trying to deal with the moniker that's been put on him that he's the most hated man in america for taking the life of somebody when he felt he needed to. >> reporter: fat or fit, during the next few weeks, george zimmerman, along with the rest of us, will be on a steady diet of courtroom drama. randi kaye, cnn, atlanta. >> joining me again is sunny hostin, jeffey toobin, jose baez and mark geragos. mark, downey this matters at all how the jury perceives him and any altercation he had with trayvon martin? >> actually, i'm of two minds of this. yesterday, i was thinking the geez, he looks so big and somebody else commented he looks like he could roll over and crush trayvon. then somebody said today, you know, he doesn't look as
10:47 pm
threatening this way. he looks like a combination of the pills bury dough bow meets the michelin man. so he looks fit and athletic or at least to some degree in shape in the one picture. so maybe this is a less threatening zimmerman. i don't know that it's calculated. i don't know that anybody can gain that much weight on purpose that quickly, in a year. >> sunny, jeff, what do you think? >> i was standing next to him in the courtroom. he's massive. he's at least three times my size. when you looked at the -- >> we get it, he gained a lot of weight. >> when i looked at the crime scene photos today with the jury, trayvon martin was pretty thin, tall and thin. and the jury is going to see that when they see the autopsy photos.
10:48 pm
i suspect they're going to have to compare and contrast the two images, a very large man, and a young, thin, tall boy. >> hasn't paula deen had a bad enough week? do we have to do this? >> jose, it's interesting. we've seen transformations in high profile cases. you look at the jodi arias case where she went from blond to this mousy brunette with glasses and no makeup. when you're representing someone as a defense attorney, how much focus do you put on a client's appearance during a trial? >> you put a lot of emphasis. but to suggest that this is a defense strategy to put on 120 pounds is ridiculous. it's somewhat of a negative connotation, because they may forget from time to time that he was much lighter at the time. and you don't want to add to the confusion that's already there, and if it benefits him that he
10:49 pm
was much thinner and he was in an actual dogfight with trayvon martin, as opposed to being able to roll over and crush him, i think you want to get rid of that confusion that may be there. but i think all of this is much ado about nothing. but if i had to go one way or the other, i would much rather have him thinner. >> it's interesting how per -- perceptions -- it was later on that you started to see trayvon martin as a 17-year-old, as a young man. you know, i'm not sure how that played or impact it had. i don't know if that was conscious on their part. but mark, physical appearance does matter? >> absolutely. jurors are -- they are focused like a laser on the defendant. everything is all about the defendant.
10:50 pm
one of the reasons you rarely put your client on the stand is because jurors will inevitably, all they care about after the defendant has testified is what did he say or what did she say? everything is based upon the client. if you get the jurors to have some kind of empathy for the client, they feel like they're walking in their shoes, if they feel like they have something about them resonates with them, then you have a winner. if they don't like or it's been effectively demonized, the client has, that's recipe for a guilty verdict. that's what it's all about. >> there are studies -- there's tons of studies that tell lawyers, you mentioned jodi arias with the glasses. there's been studies that show that people who wear glasses at trial are more likely to be acquitted. so i mean, i happen to think the facts have something to do with that. but there's certainly some lawyers pay a great deal of
10:51 pm
attention to this. i agree, you have to -- for me, i think your best -- you're showing the best part of your client, whether it's something that, for example, with casey, we wanted to make her look young, we wanted her to look like she was, which was a 22-year-old girl. so i think that when it comes to these specific things, you want your client to look their best but you don't want to overdo it. >> we have to leave it there. jose, mark, sunny, jeff, thank you very much. we'll be right back. more ahead. the kyocera torque lets you hear and be heard even in stupid loud places. to prove it, we set up our call center right here... [ chirp ] all good? [ chirp ] getty up. seriously, this is really happening! [ cellphone rings ] hello? it's a giant helicopter ma'am.
10:52 pm
[ male announcer ] get it done [ chirp ] with the ultra-rugged kyocera torque, only from sprint direct connect. buy one get four free for your business. only from sprint direct connect. where we switched their fruits brosand veggiestand with produce from walmart. it's a fresh-over. that's great. tastes like you just picked them. so far it's about the best strawberry i've had this year. walmart works directly with growers to get you the best quality of produce they've ever had. all this produce... is from walmart. oh my god. i'm shocked. (laughing) i know where i'm going to be shopping for strawberries now.
10:53 pm
get 2 full pounds of strawberries, just $2.98. backed by our 100% money back guarantee. walmart every day we're working to and to keep our commitments. and we've made a big commitment to america. bp supports nearly 250,000 jobs here. through all of our energy operations, we invest more in the u.s. than any other place in the world. in fact, we've invested over $55 billion here in the last five years - making bp america's largest energy investor.
10:54 pm
our commitment has never been stronger. what makes a sleep number store different? what makes a sleep number you walk into a conventional mattress store, it's really not about you. they say, "well, if you wanted a firm bed you can lie on one of those. if you want a soft bed you can lie on one of those." we provide the exact individualization that your body needs. welcome to the sleep number summer closeout. where you'll find great savings on the extraordinary sleep number bed, as we make room for our latest sleep innovations. this is your body there. you can see a little more pressure in the hips. take it up one notch. you get that moment where you go, "oh yeah" ...oh, yeah! and it's perfect. they had no idea that when they came to a sleep number store, we were going to diagnose their problems and help them sleep better. and now, save $500 to $800 on the closeout of our memory foam and iseries bed sets. plus, free shipping-for five days only! once you experience it, there's no going back. don't invest in a mattress until you find your sleep number setting. but you won't find the sleep number bed in an
10:55 pm
ordinary mattress store. only at the sleep number store, where queen mattresses start at just $699. sleep number. comfort individualized. randi kaye has the latest on the stories we're following. >> cnn projects that democratic congressman ed markey has won the election to fill john kerry's seat. kerry stepped down to become secretary of state with about a year and a half remaining in his turn. edward snowden is thought to be somewhere in the press customs transit area in moscow. russian president putin says russia woman hand him over to the united states to face charges. but putin says the sooner
10:56 pm
snowden picks his final destination, the better for him and russia. the fbi is investigating the theft of $1.2 million from a swiss enter national airlines flight from zurich to new york. investigators don't know when the money was stolen. $100 bills were missing from a bank container stored inside a larger cargo container. >> that's it for us. join us tomorrow night for more of the george zimmerman tomorrow night. "i'm part of an american success story," "that starts with one of the world's most advanced distribution systems," "and one of the most efficient trucking networks," "with safe, experienced drivers." "we work directly with manufacturers," "eliminating costly markups," "and buy directly from local farmers in every region of the country." "when you see our low prices, remember the wheels turning behind the scenes, delivering for millions
10:57 pm
10:58 pm
the 401(k). insurance policies. even money he's invested elsewhere. we're building a retirement plan to help him launch a second career. dave's flight school. go dave. when people talk, great things can happen. so start a conversation with an advisor who's fully invested in you. wells fargo advisors. together we'll go far. enjoy the whole family at a homewood suites, schedule a 5 o'clock meeting at a hilton garden inn, or hit the links at a waldorf astoria. get great rates at our ten top hotel brands during the great getaway. book now at hiltongreatgetaways.com.
11:00 pm
good evening, everyone. an emotionally powerful and significant day in the george zimmerman trial. we'll bring you the testimony about trayvon martin's final moments and hear from george zimmerman's lead attorney. edward snowden, nsa leaker, is at the airport in moscow, but not in russia. how is that possible? and later the high wire act that ahead tens of millions on the edge of their seat. he made it, but now nik wallenda has something bigger in mind. we begin with the powerful testimony at the george zimmerman trial. so powerful that trayvon martin's parents could not bear to hear it. it's centered on what happened in the seconds and minutes after george zimmerman shot trayvon
145 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN (San Francisco) Television Archive Television Archive News Search Service The Chin Grimes TV News ArchiveUploaded by TV Archive on