Skip to main content

tv   Erin Burnett Out Front  CNN  December 12, 2013 4:00pm-5:01pm PST

4:00 pm
era of bipartisanship in washington? right now 18% say yes. and 82% say no. that's sad. the debate continues online at cnn.com/crossfire. erin burnett "outfront" starts erin burnett "outfront" starts right now. -- captions by vitac -- www.vitac.com next, breaking news. the budget put to a vote. nancy pelosi doesn't seem very happy about it. >> so this morning you told your members, embrace the suck. >> then a north korean purge. a member of kim jong-un's own family executed for treason. and a man known as the fake sign language interpreter fighting
4:01 pm
back. is he telling the whole story? you think to yourself that they said i am not, i am like, i'm speaking rubbish. >> good evening. the house votes to approve the bipartisan budget deal which brings us one step closer to avoiding a shutdown. a rare break from gridlock. mental of democrats and republicans have hang-ups about the bill as it heads to the senate. is this likely to reach the president's desk soon? >> reporter: probably next week. the senate is going to take this next week and given what just happened in the house, almost surely pass it.
4:02 pm
this really is, it feels bizarre, i have to tell you, on capitol hill. there is such a different vibe, a different atmosphere than we have seen so much months and years gone by. not only did a majority of republicans and democrats vote for this budget in the house. a majority of the majority. meaning most republicans voted yes for this despite a lot of pressure from conservatives outside and even from within the republican caucus here saying that this budget which would go ahead for two years and make sure that the government doesn't shut down, doesn't go far enough with regard to keeping the core conservative principles and attacking the major contributors to the debt and deficit like medicare and medicaid. >> last night we had congressman hills on and he was very dead set against the bill. and then as we mentioned, all the conservative groups. the club for growth, et cetera,
4:03 pm
saying nobody should vote for this. obviously a lot of division within the republican party. you had a chance to ask house speaker john boehner about it. what did he say? >> reporter: really interesting. he made pretty clear that his frustration with the outside groups is not a one off thing. i asked whether or not this is a turning point given the fact that he has, his hands tied so often by these outside groups with his striving to, for compromise with democrats. listen to what he said. they've had a lot of sway that your members have made over the last couple years. does this mark a turning point? are your members at your behest going to be more focused on maybe compromise and less on what the outside groups are pressuring them to do? >> when groups come out and
4:04 pm
criticize an agreement that they've never seen, you begin to wonder how credible those actions are. i thought it was my job to stand up for those who want more deficit reduction. stand up for the work that chairman ryan did. >> so it's not just the fact that the house just passed a bipartisan budget. it is the fact that the speaker is openly standing up to the groups that really made things difficult for him and also contributed to some of the gridlock here in congress and that may be something we'll see different in the next year. >> dana bash, thank you. earlier today i so that with house minority leader nancy pelosi about why she backed this bill even though she wasn't entirely happy with it. pelosi and a lot of other democrats say they're upset because it doesn't extend long term benefits which are set to
4:05 pm
to have and pier and it doesn't do anything about job creation. she had some choice words even though she was advising them to vote for it. >> so this morning, you told your members, embrace the suck. that's a quote. >> yes. >> that's a quote. >> that's a quote, yes. >> first before i get to the substance of the bill, where did you get that from? >> i think it really captured the moment. wouldn't you think? >> i'm not criticizing it. it seem to summarize what you think of the legislation. >> not just the legislation. it is the whole process and the fact that we don't have unemployment insurance. those kinds of things. at the end of the day we need to have a budget. where it came from, and i was impressed when i heard it was from patrick murphy, a former congressman. he was telling us one time about what it was like to be in iraq. he was the head of a unit in iraq and em, you would be there, you would have like a 30,
4:06 pm
40-pound pack you had to carry around all the time. it was 130 degrees. you couldn't take a shower for a month. it was awful. what we decided was that our approach would be -- >> you won't say it. >> embrace the suck. okay. >> so then you roll with it. right? so that's what i was saying to them of i used patrick's story about how they coped there to say, i understand every concern you have about the procedure, the this, the that, what's in, what's not. the fact is we have to get the job done. >> you don't want to look right at the camera and say embrace the suck? >> you'll be using it. i'm telling you. you'll be using it. >> you were very critical of the fact that unemployment insurance benefits were not extend for i think it is 1.3 million americans. you called it immoral. >> i think it is immoral that we have in our circus peel work hard, play by the rules, are unemployed through no fault of their own. it is a safety net for our
4:07 pm
system as much as it is for individuals. and this is just the start. it will be, that number will more than double in the next six months if we do not honor our commitment to unemployment benefits. >> you said you haven't given up on that. do you think senate democrats negotiated a bad deal? or do you think this is just the best any democrat could have gotten? >> i think that they took it to a draw. >> other democrats are opposed to this bill even though you'll vote for and it you said other democrats won't let it go down. >> again, how do you register your concern by voting for it? moving it along? so they can have a straight-out discussion of our value system. whether it comes to raising the minimum wage, whether it come to unemployment insurance, whether it come to passing an immigration bill. passing back ground checks. the list goes on and the list goes on. >> and democrats will not let it go down. >> it won't go down. >> let's talk about what they've
4:08 pm
been able to achieve. as strict matter of math, it is one of the least productive congresses in american history. >> that's unfortunate. the american people have needs and responsibilities to them. so it is not only just the number bills. it is the unattended to responsibilities that we have that are not being addressed. republicans have never missed an opportunity to miss an opportunity when it comes to creating joks. job creation is an answer to so many problems our economy faces. and we have to pass legislation that invests in growth, produces jobs. the immigration bill and all these things, we have the votes on all these issues. we have strong bipartisan support. we need speaker to give a signal to take it to the floor. >> speaker boehner has an unruly group of tea party republicans.
4:09 pm
how have you been able to cajole, convince the feistier progressives in your caucus as speaker and as minority leader in a way he has not been able to do with tea party republicans? >> there is a very fundamental difference. first of all, we do not have the equivalence. there is nothing equivalent in the house democratic caucus to the tea party. for many reasons. most importantly, they are here to undo government. president george washington cautioned when he left office against political parties that are at war with their own government. while we don't want any more government, we need government. that's what they're here to undo. >> one of the thing i have always found kind of charming about you and speaker boehner is you really do seem to have affection for one another. >> we have a good rapport. >> you like each other. what do you say to him when it comes to how he has led his
4:10 pm
republicans this year? and congress? >> i think that we all have to make some very difficult decisions about how to bring bills to the floor that may not have a majority of the votes in our own caucus. i say let them vote for whatever they can vote for but make sure they can vote for or against whatever we need to do. that's what i have tried to convey. these are not ploys or interparty bickering. these are philosophical differences. what is the role of government? what is the public/private partnership. you want just the private side without the public part of it. those are legitimate debates of the history of our country. but now the party is dominated by people who do not believe in government. and they don't believe in government. they don't believe in science and they don't believe in the presidency of barack obama. so it is a trifecta. those people have hijacked the
4:11 pm
name republican which has made such a valuable contribution to our country, the republican party. but they've taken it over the cliff. >> the 2014 mid terms, right around the corner. it seems as though democrats weren't as strong a position. and then there were some bad stories about the health care.gov webb. and the rollout. if you like your plan, you can keep your plan. according to polls, democrats are not in as strong a position as they were after the shutdown. >> in the districts we have to win, we feel very confident about where we go in and what our opportunity is in those districts. and i think some of the more recent polls will show that that was turbulence that we went through but it wasn't a brick wall that we could not get through in terms of the website and the rest. the website was unfortunate for the american people. the impact it had on politics is incide incidental. our case is about the same
4:12 pm
thing, the jobs, the economy. our case is focused on women. when women succeed, america succeeds. women make 77% the same as men in the same job. valuing work, paid sick leave is really important for women to succeed in the workplace. for families to succeed. and advancing early childhood learning. >> i've heard some progressive advocates say they're concerned about the obama care rollout. not just the website but also things like, if you plan your plan, you can keep your plan not being true for people because it undermines the argument for progressive advocacy in government. it says sure, democrats can go out there and say these things. if the actual implementation isn't what it was sold as, that could hurt liberal politics. >> well, you know what? don't spend a lot of time on
4:13 pm
that. the affordable care act will be a giant plus over time. and what is important is not what it means politically but what it means personally to the american people. as a policy and as an improvement in their lives. so while some may say that, and i don't disagree with any of it. we want government to work. the government that we have to work, the rollout was, i don't even know if disappointing even comes close to the word i would use. the fact is we're getting over. that it is transform i have the. it stags right there with social security, medicare, with affordable health care as a right, not a privilege. it is really going to be great. >> our thanks to minority leader nancy pelosi. still to come, a purge in north korea. a member of kim jong-un's family. and a teen gets no jail time because his wealthy parents
4:14 pm
never taught him right from wrong. is affluenza a real condition? and a big story we're following. the cost flights about to go way up. there's a saying around here,
4:15 pm
you stand behind what you say. around here you don't make excuses. you make commitments. and when you can't live up to them, you own up, and make it right.
4:16 pm
some people think the kind of accountability that thrives on so many streets in this country has gone missing in the places where it's needed most. but i know you'll still find it when you know where to look. see who does good work and compare costs. it doesn't usually work that way with health care. but with unitedhealthcare, i get information on quality rated doctors, treatment options and estimates for how much i'll pay. that helps me, and my guys, make better decisions. i don't like guesses with my business, and definitely not with our health. innovations that work for you. that's health in numbers. unitedhealthcare.
4:17 pm
breaking news out of north korea. the uncle of kim jong-un has been executed for treason. a special tribunal found his
4:18 pm
uncle jang song thaek guilty go calling him a traitor for all ages and a despicable human scum who was worse than a dog. this is reportedly kim jong-un's uncle being led away from what is seemingly the tribunal to be executed. he was head of the top military body, considered one of his nephew's top demts. jim, what are you hearing about the execution and how is the u.s. responding? >> well, u.s. officials say they cannot confirm it but they don't doubt he. the u.s. spokesperson for the state department calling it another example of the extreme brutality of the regime and some in the u.s. have been specking this. once he was accused of plotting to overthrow the government in addition to womanizing, drug urgs going to expensive restaurants, you know, real crimes. once they put that out there it was hard to back off from anything like this. so they had kind of seen this coming. >> i guess the question is, is this just a family squabble?
4:19 pm
or is it somebody disappointed with a top aide? >> is there a larger geopolitical significance? >> it is significant because he is so senior. the second most powerful in the country. and a family member. kim jong-un's uncle. and it followed a year ago. two out of the three most powerful people taken out in a year. you have a concern that north korea lashes out. the leadership to show its strength might light off a nuclear bomb or attack south korean military forces or a sign of how much on pins and needles the region is. this statement just release bid the south koreans, we're fully prepared for any regional conflict or full scale war. no abnormal activities detected. they have to say that kind of thing because they know that's the kind of regime this is. if there is one positive in here. the u.s. and china's view of
4:20 pm
north korea are converging. they have been over the last couple years. this will add to that and might lead the some cooperation. it is a bad sign for our already -- >> absolutely. thank you so much. gordon chang is the author of the book, nuclear showdown, north korea takes on the world. thank you. can you remember another time when someone in the family has been executed? what does this execution tell us about the state of the regime? >> in the history of north korea, no kim family member has ever been publicly executed. now, some have been shuffled off to foreign countries, some have disappeared. what we are seeing is unprecedented. and what is important here is that jang song thaek, the guy who was executed, has hungs of supporters throughout north korea. those supporters know they will either be executed or sent off to a death camp. that mean they very well might fight back. this is a regime which will go
4:21 pm
through medieval intrigue. this is richard iii with nukes. >> this said that he was executed for treason but when he was removed from his post, he was accused of drug, you're womanizing, being bribed by the enemy. what do you think is really going on here? >> yeah, the bribe by enemies is really important. that's a direct reference to china. and i think that what we're going to see is north korea be even more untethered from beijing. u.s. policy has always been to rely on china to press its best friend, north korea. i don't think china has really that influence anymore. what we have is a blood feud. when you have executions, you're going to have more executions. this is just going to ripple throughout society. and that is why this is important. north korea is going to be even more isolated, more dangerous than it has been in the past. >> it mentioned the north korean news agency mentioned womanizing
4:22 pm
a few days ago. is that a crime in north korea? >> what's going on here is that jang song thaek is known to have introduced kim jong-un to his wildfire his wife comes from a dance troupe. if you remember two months ago there was a story about how this dance troupe has disappeared. largely because it made a sex tape. there are all sorts of stories going on in terms of intrigue within the kim family as to what is actually happened. but we do know that jang song thaek's wife who is kim jong-un's aunt has had a very strained relationship with jang song thaek and is the one who finally turned on him, making it acceptable within the regime for kim jong-un to execute jang song thaek. this is getting very, very complicated. essentially what we have is a family feud that has international implications. >> as you said, shakespearean
4:23 pm
with nukes. >> a wealthy teenager kills four people while drunk driving and he gets no jail time because he apparently did not know right from wrong. it is called affluenza. the woman who popularized the term joins us. plus, this sign language interpreter is being called a fake. he will tell his side of the story to cnn. does it add up? [ male announcer ] this is karen and jeremiah. they don't know it yet, but they're gonna fall in love, get married, have a couple of kids, [ children laughing ] move to the country, and live a long, happy life together where they almost never fight about money. [ dog barks ] because right after they get married, they'll find some financial folks who will talk to them about preparing early for retirement and be able to focus on other things, like each other, which isn't rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade.
4:24 pm
[ male announcer ] if we could see energy... what would we see? ♪ the billions of gallons of fuel that get us to work. ♪ we'd see all the electricity flowing through the devices that connect us and teach us. ♪ we'd see that almost 100% of medical plastics are made from oil and natural gas. ♪ and an industry that supports almost 10 million american jobs.
4:25 pm
life takes energy. and no one applies more technology to produce american energy and refine it more efficiently than exxonmobil. because using energy responsibly has never been more important. energy lives here. ♪
4:26 pm
the back lash is growing over the rich kid defense. a story we first brought you yesterday. ethan couch, a wealthy 16-year-old who killed four people while driving drunk will
4:27 pm
avoid jail because his defense team said he suffers from affluenza. according to one psychologist, his privileged parents never taught him right from wrong. never taught him there would be consequences. the best remedy for this rare condition which took lives of four people according to cnn affiliate, a $450,000 a year rehabilitation center in newport beach, california. let's get to jesse o'neal, a person who popularized the term. she said she suffered from affluenza and now counsels others who have it. and from dr. drew on call, both of you, thank you for being here. when you hear the details of this case, do you think this 16-year-old is suffering from affluenza? >> yes, do i. he definitely has an inability to delay gratification, loss of future motivation and most of all a false sense of entitlement.
4:28 pm
>> what's the difference between affluenza and being a spoiled kid? >> well, they're a lot of the same qualities. money provides cushion or a band-aid so children are not held accountable for their bad behavior. that way they don't develop character. >> dr. drew, i grew up in philadelphia where there are probably a lot of kids who commit crimes who were raise in the dysfunctional households and were not caught the consequences of their actions. but they were poor, not rich. what do you think about affluenza? >> well, those kids had poor floonsa. or we can make up any other term we wish. these made-up terms. you won't find they will in the psychiatric manuals. they're clever. there are all sorts of term we can make up for horrible parenting. what disturbs me is that a made-up term becomes a seemingly sort of a justified defense for
4:29 pm
somebody killing other people. the time for this kid to have been treated for whatever the circumstances was before he killed other people. the treatment he's getting is good. the problem is it is too late. once you have killed people because of your psychiatric condition, the justice system steps in. and that's what must happen. giving this kid treatment should have been done long ago. >> jesse -- >> i agree with that. i do think that affluenza plays a big part of it and i agree. but it doesn't really matter what word you use. but i do believe that money and the effects of affluence on children, particularly second and third generation, are profound and it is somethingle psychologists and psychiatrists in this country ignore when they have wealthy clients. >> do you -- obviously, it is one thing to have affluenza and quite another to use it a as defense in a murder trial. have you ever heard of such a thing? >> no. i never have. and i have very mixed feelings about it. i certainly think that it added
4:30 pm
it to the child's dysfunction. to use it as a primary defense seems a little overboard to me. so i have a lot of mixed feelings about it. i would like to see a test case where there is a child that is rather than going into the legal system, is given treatment. but i'm not sure this particular case with four people being murdered is the case that i would choose. >> dr. drew, the psychologist who testified for the defense said when ethan couch was 15, he was caught with a naked 14-year-old girl and was never punished. he was allowed to drink at a young age. he began driving at 13. playing devil's advocate, if this child was never disciplined, never told any limits srgs it possible that he may not have known right from wrong? >> well, and he was intoxicated, at a. so in that moment he may not have known it. but this is not an insanlt defense they're going for. this is a justification for murderous behavior.
4:31 pm
let's remind ourselves. we're talking about two things this kid, i believe, that is in the diagnostic maneux addiction of some sort. alcoholism or something else. >> i agree with that. >> and a personality disorder which is an an to do personality disorder which are very difficult to treat. particularly in an unmotivated patient. we've got a kid who has had no consequences still. we're taking him to newport beach and giving him a curby treatment. maybe in prison under a five-year program. maybe then we could have gotten through. to say we'll just gloss this over for six months in newport. >> a lot of it depends on whether the treatment center has any knowledge of affluenza and how it affects kids. if they get with a therapy heist understands the effects of money and how it pertains to the other addictions and how it weaves in and out of their lives, one of the personality traits of affluenza is often a loss of
4:32 pm
self-identity. the children frequently are raised by surrogate care takers or on their own which is what i understand happened with this young man. so they have no self reference. they have no self-identity. >> i don't disagree with that but that is a dynamic issue. that is not a diagnostic construct. >> i'm not sure it has to be diagnostic construct. it can be -- >> i'm sorry. >> is it in the dsmi? >> they don't have to be in the dsm three or four or five or whatever we're up to. you're saying you can make your own diagnostic construct and therefore your own treatment plan. >> i think one of the things that is missing in today's treatment programs is the knowledge of how our cultural affluenza. our addiction to money and the effects that it has on our children and our culture and our spirituality are ignored. >> no disagreement.
4:33 pm
>> and if there's one set of parents out there that the interview that says no, i'm not going on give that you new toy, i'm not going on send out that expensive trip. you're going to stay here and faye consequences of your behavior. then this interview has been worth it. and whether that's in a -- >> no disagreement. >> whether it is in those terms or not i don't recollect care. >> you said you suffered from affluenza. tell us about your experience. >> well, may grand father was secretary of defense under dwight d. eisenhower. and prior to that he was president of general motors. and his six children were raised with a great deal of money. my grand father was a great man. did he wonderful thing for the country. but what i noticed when i went back to do my masters degree in psychology in counseling was that the next generation, rather than using the money always for good, oftentimes struggled with using the money in dysfunctional
4:34 pm
ways. that was passed down again to my generation. and so when i looked at that, i decided to do my thesis on it and then turned it into my book, the golden ghetto, the psychology of affluence. >> how did it manifest itself in your life? what were, what did you do that -- >> i would say -- >> you suffer from this. >> i would say i was given things rather than attention. certainly bought out of the consequences of my behavior, much as what's happening in this young man's case. i agree with dr. drew that put hg i am in a cushy treatment center in newport, california, is not the answer. i do think that affluenza plays a part in it and i don't think that our legal system is set up to deal with it. >> all right. thank you so much for joining us. great debate. i appreciate it. still to come, the cost of
4:35 pm
flying is going up. why congress is to blame? plus, the man known as the fake sign language interpreter talks to cnn. he claim he is legit despite hallucinating during the memorial. every day we're working to be an even better company - and to keep our commitments. and we've made a big commitment to america. bp supports nearly 250,000 jobs here. through all of our energy operations, we invest more in the u.s. than any other place in the world. in fact, we've invested over $55 billion here
4:36 pm
in the last five years - making bp america's largest energy investor. our commitment has never been stronger. i get times are tight. but it's hard to get any work done like this. then came this baby -- small but with windows and office. it runs my work stuff. ...and i can use apps like flipboard for news, or xbox video to watch the shows i'm never home to see... and i can still get work done at the same time. excuse me, do you mind if i... yep. ♪ honestly, i wanna see you be brave ♪ ♪ [ male announcer ] laura's heart attack didn't come with a warning. today her doctor has her on a bayer aspirin regimen to help reduce the risk of another one. if you've had a heart attack, be sure to talk to your doctor before you begin an aspirin regimen.
4:37 pm
4:38 pm
♪ there'll be the usual presentations on research. and development. some new members of the team will be introduced. the chairman emeritus will distribute his usual wisdom. and you? well, you're the chief life officer. you just need the right professional to help you take charge. ♪
4:39 pm
the house just passed the teal that may help avoid the shutdown but anyone who flies should be prepared to pay up. congressman paul ryan who hemmed craft the bill defensed the higher fees in an interview with me. >> before 9/11, the person getting on an airplane paid for all their security when they paid for their ticket them covered all of it. since 9/11, that person is paying for less than 40% of the security and the nonflying public, the nonflying taxpayer is six diesing the rest it. we think that the user should pay for the service that's they're using instead of making some hard working taxpayer that never used those services paying for it. >> does that math really add up? that's tonight's money and
4:40 pm
power. and tom forman is here to break it down. >> of all the proposals in the budget deal this probably has the greatest potential on affect greatest number of regular americans in a direct way. meaning anyone who flies and that's a lot of folks. the department of transportation says 736 million time passengers boarded u.s. airlines in 2012. obviously a very heavy traveled business person could know for many of those. and the security is expensive. in fact you're already paying for it. if you take a flight you may notice a security fee is tacked on to your particular price. $2.50 for a one-way trip. $5 for a round trip. look at the numbers. $2.50 over here going one way. over here. $5 for a round trip. the proposed change would jack that fee up. it would more than double. it would go to $5.60 for a one-way ticket and $11.20 for a
4:41 pm
roundtrip. that may seem like relatively small am if you're taking one flight. if you fly many times over the course of a year, this could add up. supporters would say as congressman ryan said, let the people who 90 the most shoulder the burden for the airline. >> assuming that the house bill goes to the senate, passes, goes to president obama's desk, how much is this going to bring in? >> this deal if it is approved by the senate. the bottom line on this is it is going on generate, according to the congressional budget office, $13.4 billion over the next ten years. that's a pretty good chunk of change. if you get all the flyers out there, they will contribute a lot to this. however, when the congressman said let's have just the people who use it pay for it. we already have schools of people who don't have students in school pay for it. we have a lot of people paying taxes for the good of all and security is about all of us.
4:42 pm
not just people using part of it. that will be the argument from the people pushing back. and just because we were curious about it. we decided to do some math of our own. if you added one penny to the comment of every gallon of gasoline based on all the gasoline that sold in 2012, over ten years you would get exactly the same amount of money, jake. so i'm sure that these debates will go on even if the senate does approve this. there will be the constant fight of revenue. >> thanks. higher fees, that doesn't even take into account the higher fees that the taxpayers might see because of airline mergers and the like. that's another subject for another day. still to come, this sign language interpreter is being called a fake but he says that's not true. he'll give his side of the story to cnn. >> plus an idea that will make your wall 8 lot lighter and that's a good thing. i'm beth...
4:43 pm
and i'm michelle. and we own the paper cottage. it's a stationery and gifts store. anything we purchase for the paper cottage goes on our ink card. so you can manage your business expenses and access them online instantly with the game changing app from ink. we didn't get into business to spend time managing receipts, that's why we have ink. we like being in business because we like being creative, we like interacting with people. so you have time to focus on the things you love. ink from chase. so you can. is caused by people looking fore traffic parking.y that's remarkable that so much energy is, is wasted. streetline has looked at the problem of parking, which has not been looked at for the last 30, 40 years, we wanted to rethink that whole industry, so we go and put out these sensors in each parking spot
4:44 pm
and then there's a mesh network that takes this information sends it over the internet so you can go find exactly where those open parking spots are. the collaboration with citi was important for providing us the necessary financing; allow this small start-up to go provide a service to municipalities. citi has been an incredible source of advice, how to engage with municipalities, how to structure deals, and as we think about internationally, citi is there every step of the way. so the end result is you reduce congestion, you reduce pollution and you provide a service to merchants, and that certainly is huge. to help secure retirements and protect financial futures. to help communities recover and rebuild. for companies going from garage to global. on the ground, in the air, even into space. we repaid every dollar america lent us. and gave america back a profit. we're here to keep our promises. to help you realize a better tomorrow.
4:45 pm
from the families of aig, happy holidays. to buy an all-new silverado. this interior is incredible! the nav is perfect for my long trips up north this time of year. how far up north? akron. akron's nice. mm. [ male announcer ] chevy's giving more this holiday season, chevy's giving more during the calendar year end event. trade up to the all-new 2014 silverado all star v6 for a total value of $5,250. see your local chevy dealer today.
4:46 pm
what if you were convicted of a crime you didn't commit? what if no one believed you were innocent? even your sob? the incredible story an innocent man sent to jail for killing his wife and his fight to clear his
4:47 pm
name. watch "an unreal dream" right here on cnn. the sign language interpreter at nelson mandela's memorial who has been called a fraud around the world for making up jibberish signs is blaming on it a skits friendic hallucination. he said he saw visions of angels flying into the event and that he's had a history of violent incidents in the past. in a separate interview with david mckenzie he defended his performance and said his schizophrenia was the inspiration for wanting to become an interpreter. >> what sort of disability do you have? >> me, i'm suffering from schizophrenic which is controllable and under -- i'm under treatment. >> can you show me some of the signs? >> what are you --
4:48 pm
>> i don't know the signs. >> people that i was interpreted for them, they said i'm not -- i'm speaking rubbish. but if i was speaking rubbish and then there was nothing that had been done and then it is only now when something has been done and then i must again make another sense, you want me -- you want me -- >> i'm just asking if you can show me some of the signs. >> people have complained before when you interpreted for president zuma before. >> listen. listen. i've never, ever in my life have anything that i've interpreted wrong. you can go through all the media of south africa. interpreting through all the media of south africa. even if you look at my portfolio
4:49 pm
for a very long time. >> who employed your company for this? >> that one is a question of my company to answer it. >> but it was a government event. so presumably someone from the government employed them. >> i've told you that i cannot talk on behalf of anc. i cannot talk on behalf of government. i am here on behalf of interpreters. people that should answer that question. >> we couldn't find any sign of sa interpreters in the phone book, anywhere. they said, where's the company based? >> you should ask yourself the same question. >> how could a self-described schizophrenic said he was having had a loose nations be allowed to stand feet from president obama and feet from other dignitaries? mary ellen, you just saw this man defending himself.
4:50 pm
defending his performance. many calling him a fraud. do you think he could have been a security threat? >> i definitely think he could have been a security threat. this is what we call in the bau and the secret service ask does this person pose a threat, for example, to president obama. and what you do is you have to go into their background and you look at criminal behavior, but you look at mental health history. mental health history alone is not enough to say he's a security risk, but what he's saying is he had hallucinations and as he described them, he had hallucinations. he was hearing voices, seeing angels, he was feeling threatened. he was feel income a situation where it was dangerous. he could have acted out in a very violent way towards whoever was standing next to him. does that make him a security risk? , it does. >> is there any way the secret
4:51 pm
service or fbi could have known this? we know that when you go to a foreign country, things like the interpreter and security, really, is left into the host country's hands. >> right, i got to be honest with you, in the secret service is wonderful at threat assessment. i mean, those folks are really, really good, but if your hands are tied and the vetting process is done by the people in the host country, then there is no use to run mary ellen o'toole's name in the data system in the united states if i spent my entire life in south africa or another country. i'm not going to pop up. if the vetting process was done over there. from all indications, that vetting process really compromised the security. >> a lot of people in the deaf community and those who are hearing challenged were very offended by this. i interviewed oscar winning act stress marley yet on the show. here is what she had to say.
4:52 pm
>> each language shares facial and presentations and to see someone standing there with no movement, no facial expressions that one incorporates into sign, indicates he has no understanding of the culture, no understanding of the language. i knew exactly right then and there he wasn't authentic at all. and it was offensive to me. >> her and thousands of others spotted him as a fraud immediately. some of those people took to social media that moment. is that something that the fbi would have been paying attention to? >> well, we certainly will be paying attention to it at this point. i don't know if people were looking at it at the time, but here is what's important to point out. was his skill set substandard, below par? it could have been based on what experts are saying. the real question for the secret service and fbi, we address a different concern and that concern is did he pose a threat, a security risk to president obama and the other world leaders? not whether or not he was a good signer.
4:53 pm
here is a point -- >> it's not that he was a good signer, it's his signs were non-sense. >> here is something to take a step further is that if you have someone who presents -- who is really a fraud and don't get vetted, if the secret service isn't dotting the vetting, why are you going to this trouble to commit this fraud to sit next to the president? who else is involved? maybe the signs are indicating to other people to take some kind of action. so when we vet people over here, i mean, we do a very thorough process, particularly if you stand that close to someone like the president of the united states. >> lucky that nothing happened. mary ellen o'toole, former senior profiler with the fbi. coming up next, a new idea that puts your credit cards, debit cards, loyalty cards, everything on one card. [ male announcer ] at his current pace, bob will retire when he's 153, which would be fine if bob were a vampire.
4:54 pm
but he's not. ♪ he's an architect with two kids and a mortgage. luckily, he found someone who gave him a fresh perspective on his portfolio. and with some planning and effort, hopefully bob can retire at a more appropriate age. it's not rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade. [ male announcer ] if we could see energy... what would we see? ♪ the billions of gallons of fuel that get us to work. ♪ we'd see all the electricity flowing through the devices that connect us and teach us. ♪ we'd see that almost 100% of medical plastics are made from oil and natural gas. ♪ and an industry that supports almost 10 million american jobs.
4:55 pm
life takes energy. and no one applies more technology to produce american energy and refine it more efficiently than exxonmobil. because using energy responsibly has never been more important. energy lives here. ♪
4:56 pm
energy ♪ives here.
4:57 pm
(train horn) vo: wherever our trains go, the economy comes to life. norfolk southern. one line, infinite possibilities. well, according to george costanza, a fat wallet is a good thing but it evolved from a stack of bills to a larger stack of debit cards, credit cards, gift cards, loyalty cards, basically, a lot of plastic. a new idea aims to change it up once again with a single coin, possibly making your fat wallet a thing of the past. dan simon has the story. >> reporter: this is a coin. it's an idea that makes sense.
4:58 pm
an electronic credit card, visa, american express and all the rest can be stored and gift cards and reward cards and works at the atm. the device won't be available until next summer. presales shattered initial expectations just minutes after this company video went viral. >> this is a business launch, so i'm going to expense it on the business card. >> reporter: we went to the company's small san francisco office. in terms of thickness, it's the same as a credit card. >> to meet the guy that came up with the product called coin. >> we feel like we might have built something people love, and that excited us and gave us purpose. >> reporter: he says coin evolved out of a previous startup that failed. it was a payment solution that involved no cards, just smart phones, but the fact is he says people like cards, and there is no learning curve. the price will be $100, but for those who ordered early, it will be half. >> what do you think is the very
4:59 pm
best thing about this product? >> i think the very best thing about this product, is it improves what you already use. >> reporter: this thing along with the company app is used to get the card's on coin and a toggle switch allows you to select the card you want. >> that's visa, that's discover, that's master. >> five is the rail were the company says it has built in protected features, it's paired with your phone. if the two get separated, you'll receive an alert. >> see that? the coin uses a low power blue tooth signals that know when your phone is near. >> reporter: there is a work around if your phone battery dies or you lose it. it's not clear how the credit card companies themselves will feel about it, and whether they will embrace coin. >> $29.29, please. >> reporter: same for merchants.
5:00 pm
but this idea of combining the old with the new may allow you to ditch your card-filled wallet. dan simon, cnn, san francisco. and our thanks to dan simon, thanks for joining us. i'll see you tomorrow starting at 4:00 p.m. eastern on the lead. lead. "ac 360" starts right now. -- captions by vitac -- www.vitac.com he wasn't just a relative, he was the mentor. at one time his number two guide, the second most powerful person in the country is being called a trader to the nation. a sensational murder trial squeechs to a halt before closing arguments begin. why the newlywed accused on pushing her young husband off a cliff eight days after the wedding cut a deal with prosecutors. the sentence many are calling a 16-year-old ethan couch