Skip to main content

tv   Forensic Files  CNN  March 3, 2014 11:00pm-11:31pm PST

11:00 pm
this at a time when catholic schools are closing. anderson? >> randi appreciate the update. thanks very much. for 12 long years, the murder of a young hospital worker went unsolved. police had their suspicions but little proof. but an old, used tissue told a story far better than any eyewitness. >> from the moment she was born, laura wynn was fighting the odds. >> she weighed 1 pound and 14 ounces, 3 months premature, but she was so determined to live that she made it. and they took her home. and she was blind in one eye from the incubator at that time
11:01 pm
and she also had paralysis on her right side. >> as laura grew up in poplar bluff, missouri, she slowly overcame these physical challenges and emerged as a gifted student. >> she worked that paralysis nearly completely out, and she never let that disability blindness ever hold her back from her desires of what she wanted to be and what she wanted to do. >> laura's dream was to work in health care, to help others as she had been helped. and she achieved that by becoming a hospital pharmacy technician. >> she was a sweetheart. the people that she associated with there were pretty much her friends as well as her co-workers. nice girl. nice girl. >> laura's friends looked out
11:02 pm
for her professionally and personally. and when she didn't show up for work one morning, they called her mother. >> so her mother said, well, i'll go down and check and see. so the land lady opened the door and let her in. and when she went in, she found laura. >> laura had been murdered on her bed, strangled with her stocking. laura's eyeglasses were on the living room couch. without them, she was literally blind. it appeared she'd been attacked in her living room and murdered in her bedroom. >> this was a crime of power and control. and she was hit in the head on her blind side. >> at first, the motive appeared to be robbery. >> we discovered that there were several items missing from the apartment. her purse, her -- some of her underwear, some shoes, some clothing.
11:03 pm
>> but there was no sign of forced entry. did that mean laura knew her killer and let him in the apartment? in retracing laura's steps on the night of her murder, investigators discovered that she left her job at the hospital around 6:30. then went to her usual hangout. a local bar where she had a few drinks and talked with friends. laura's neighbor recalled seeing her get out of her car and walk into her apartment around 11:15. and laura's neighbor remembered something else. he said that a man walked up to laura as she unlocked her apartment door and walked in with her. >> well, he told me that the reason why he didn't call police is because he thought maybe she was just sneaking a boyfriend in her apartment. >> but according to laura's friends, she had no current boyfriend. the neighbor described the man
11:04 pm
as white, medium height, around 160 pounds, but he didn't see the man's face. unfortunately, the description matched about half the population of poplar bluff, missouri. honestly? i wanted a smartphone that shoots great video. so i got the new nokia lumia icon. it's got 1080p video, three times zoom, and a twenty-megapixel sensor. it's got the brightest display, so i can see what i'm shooting -- even outdoors, and 4 mics that capture incredible sound. plus, it has apps like vine -- and free cloud storage. my new lumia icon is so great, even our wipeouts look amazing. ♪ honestly, i want to see you be brave ♪ ♪
11:05 pm
this is the first power plant in the country to combine solar and natural gas at the same location. during the day, we generate as much electricity as we can using solar. at night and when it's cloudy, we use more natural gas. this ensures we can produce clean electricity whenever our customers need it. ♪
11:06 pm
11:07 pm
laura wynn's autopsy yielded several surprises. a 2 1/2 inch constitution over laura's right ear indicated she'd been hit hard enough to incapacitate her. >> what could have caused it? it was blunt trauma, something that didn't lacerate the skin. so it was probably a smooth surfaced, hard object. >> but the cause of death was strangulation. and the amount of force was excessive. >> the ligature itself would have done the job over a period of a few minutes if that was the intent, but that wasn't good enough. the emotions got high enough that he had to lay his hands on her neck and squeeze and crush two cartilages.
11:08 pm
>> she had also been sexually assaulted. investigators found no foreign fingerprints in laura's apartment. but underneath laura's body was a clue, a used paper tissue. there looked to be biological evidence on the tissue. unfortunately, at the time, the sample was too small for dna testing. investigators also found two foreign hairs in laura's living room. >> these were sent to the lab and found to be pubic hairs of an african-american. >> but this didn't match the description given by the eyewitness who said a caucasian followed laura into her apartment. >> if you know anything about hairs, hairs fall off of people all over their body every day. she also had a friend who was an african-american and had been in her apartment and readied her apartment when she moved in.
11:09 pm
>> police interviewed laura's african-american friend. and he had an airtight alibi. he was with friends on the night of the murder. with no solid leads, police turned their attention to the bar laura visited before she returned home. when investigators questioned patrons of the bar, they found laura got into an argument with sam freeman, a 26-year-old veteran of the u.s. army. >> laura accused him of hustling these two young men playing pool. whatever happened wasn't something that came to blows, but there was a disagreement over a pool game, and laura had confronted him. >> candace shipman was working the bar that night. she said the altercation was minor. >> just got a little loud. then they quit. then it seemed okay. normal stuff that would happen in a bar. >> several bar patrons said freeman left the bar about 20
11:10 pm
minutes before laura did. and his parents said he came home a short time later and stayed there the rest of the night. investigators also discovered there was another man in the bar that night. laura's ex-boyfriend, robert mcswain. >> she loved him. she was head over heels in love with him. she was just smitten. he could do no wrong. you know, and it was an on again/off again relationship. >> friends said laura hoped to marry robert, but he wasn't interested. mcswain's friend said he went directly home from the bar on the night of the murder, and family members backed up his alibi. >> he stayed at the house the rest of the night, never left. his mother and sister were also there at that time. >> police now were at a dead end. no one else at the bar that night matched the general description of the man presumed
11:11 pm
to be the killer. >> it was a hurt that there was just no closure to it. because we just kept thinking someone's out there and we just don't know who it is. and not only that, but it was the hurt of losing her and giving her up, when she was such a worthwhile person and she was so good to everybody. and we just couldn't see any sense in it. >> months passed, then years, and laura's family lost hope that her killer would ever be brought to justice. ♪ ♪
11:12 pm
nothing says, "you're my #1 copilot," like a milk-bone biscuit. ♪ say it with milk-bone. [ female announcer ] some people like to pretend a flood could never happen to them. and that their homeowners insurance protects them. [ thunder crashes ] it doesn't. stop pretending.
11:13 pm
only flood insurance covers floods. ♪ visit floodsmart.gov/pretend to learn your risk.
11:14 pm
11:15 pm
when clifford morris turned in his badge after a 35-year career, one case haunted him -- the brutal murder of laura wynn that had gone unsolved for 12 years. on his last day on the job, he handed the case file to one of his most trusted colleagues, detective tim davis. >> i asked him to look into it again. i know he's a good forensic man. and told him to go ahead and reinvestigate that and see if he
11:16 pm
couldn't come up with something. >> and davis did just that, looking for anything that could be reinvestigated. >> it was never a closed case. up to that point, all the proper things that needed to be done were done. >> detective davis decided to go back and reinterview everyone who was in the bar with laura wynn on the night she was murdered. and his interview with candace shipman who was bartending that night provided an important lead. >> she informed me some things then she thought was pertinent to the case that she wanted to share. >> shipman said there was more going on between laura and sam freeman that night than just an argument about the pool game. >> sam flirted with laura. he tried for her affections.
11:17 pm
she just didn't seem interested at all. so i think there was a little jealousy. she just put him in his place. >> and shipman recalled something else that night that she never forgot. she remembered that sam freeman was drinking an italian liquor, galliano. >> he collected bottles, odd shaped bottles. when she poured the last of the galliano, he asked for the bottle because it's an odd-shaped bottle, and she gave it to him. >> witnesses reported seeing freeman leave the bar with the galliano bottle. this was significant because of the wounds on laura's head. >> just a pattern that was consistent with the size and shape of that bottle. >> and that wasn't all. eight years after laura's murder, there was another incident at the same bar involving sam freeman and a galliano bottle. candace shipman was again the bartender.
11:18 pm
and sam freeman came in, ordered some galliano, and chose a song from the jukebox. >> he was sitting at the bar and staring me right in the eyes singing "only you know and i know." hairs stood up all over my body. ♪ only you know and i know >> i was convinced -- i was convinced that he'd gotten away with murder and was flaunting it in front of me. >> now, 12 years later, freeman was married with two children and worked as a supply sergeant for the national guard. >> he was even attempting to run for city council. i thought that all was a bit brazen with the way i felt and the things i knew. >> with a warrant, investigators found a galliano bottle in freeman's home. freeman said this bottle was a recent addition to his collection, not the one given to
11:19 pm
him by the bartender on the night laura was murdered. but police confiscated it anyway. apparently freeman filled the bottle with colored water for display purposes. but he didn't fill it to the very top. a lab technician swabbed the entire bottle and, on the inside near the top, was a microscopic stain. a phenolphthalein test showed this was human blood. but after 12 years it had degraded. >> there was not enough to do a dna profile on. >> but why was human blood inside the bottle? investigators were determined to find out. [ male announcer ] at his current pace, bob will retire when he's 153,
11:20 pm
which would be fine if bob were a vampire. but he's not. ♪ he's an architect with two kids and a mortgage. luckily, he found someone who gave him a fresh perspective on his portfolio. and with some planning and effort, hopefully bob can retire at a more appropriate age. it's not rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade.
11:21 pm
11:22 pm
11:23 pm
when human blood was discovered inside the galliano bottle in sam freeman's apartment, investigators suspected he was responsible for laura wynn's murder. according to witnesses, sam freeman and laura wynn argued on the night of her murder. laura accused sam of hustling
11:24 pm
some young boys in a game of pool. afterwards, freeman had a few more drinks and asked the bartender if he could have the empty galliano bottle for his collection. at 10:45 the bartender announced that it was the last call for drinks because the bar was closing at 11:00 p.m. according to witnesses, that's when sam freeman left the bar with the galliano bottle since he knew laura would have to leave at closing time. laura lived only a short distance from the bar. when she got home around 11:15, prosecutors believed that it was freeman who forced her inside and struck her in the head with the galliano bottle. he then took her into the bedroom, assaulted her, then strangled her to death with her own stocking. the evidence suggests he used a tissue to blow his nose, but
11:25 pm
left it near laura's body. he then stole some items and fled. that was the prosecution theory, anyway. the problem was they had little in the way of forensic evidence. >> i'm a worrier. everybody that knows me will tell you i worry about every single case. i'm never a prosecutor who says this is a sure thing, slam dunk. >> so when investigators wanted to know whether any of the evidence contained dna that was too small to be tested when the crime occurred 12 years earlier. >> there has to be some type of skin cells embedded in these nylons, unless the suspect wore gloves. >> the knot was chosen as part of the dna analysis because i thought that there could be a chance that he could have touched the knot while he was
11:26 pm
tying the knot. >> dna specialist jason wycoff swabbed the stocking looking for any of those skin cells. >> the swabs were treated with a solvent to free possible dna. and then replicated so the sample was large enough for dna testing. just as they suspected, they found a dna sample. >> i noticed that the profile was characteristic of a mixture of at least two individuals and the mixture had male and female gender characteristics. >> the female dna was that of laura wynn. the source of the male's dna was not yet known. wycoff analyzed the paper tissue found underneath laura's body with an alternative light source which revealed a bodily fluid, possibly mucus. he then cut a tiny piece of tissue and put it into a
11:27 pm
detergent that dissolved everything but the complex molecules. a pcr dna analysis once again provided useful information. >> the majority of the dna appeared to have male gender characteristics. >> the last step was to collect a dna sample from sam freeman. >> when we first informed mr. freeman of why we were there and who we were, it was like at that instance he had just went into shock. his demeanor totally changed. that, i couldn't describe, only other as maybe the face of fear. >> before taking his dna sample, investigators asked freeman if he had ever been inside laura wynn's apartment. >> did you ever date her? had you ever had sex with her? had you ever kissed her? did you know where she lived? he stated no, no, no, to all these questions.
11:28 pm
>> but the dna from sam freeman's saliva sample matched the skin cells on the ligature and the mucus on the tissue. >> the only way possible that sam freeman's dna could have been at the scene in the home was the fact that sam freeman was there and was the killer. >> after 12 long years in september of 2005, sam freeman was arrested and charged with laura wynn's murder. prosecutors believe the motive was clear. >> here she is, this woman -- small woman -- dressing him down in front of all these guys and here he is mr. military, mr. macho man. he wasn't going to put up with it. i think he was embarrassed, rejected, spurned, and he got the ultimate last say with laura wynn with this crime. >> during the trial, freeman's defense attorney pointed to the two foreign hairs in laura's
11:29 pm
apartment as proof that someone else killed laura. and also reminded the jury that the eyewitness' description didn't match freeman either. >> i mean, they argued reasonable doubt which was a smart argument to make. >> but prosecutors maintained that the dna evidence was concrete proof. >> i think what happened here was that sam freeman didn't realize in 1992 he could leave a piece of himself at the scene other than semen, blood or fingerprints. but he did. >> in september of 2006, a jury found sam freeman guilty of first-degree murder. he was sentenced to life in prison without parole. >> i want people to have hope and never give up. never give up on justice. that some day it'll come about. >> if it had not been for the proper collection and
11:30 pm
preservation, it doesn't matter how much someone does 13, 14 years later in an investigation, if you don't have the evidence, you don't have a case. it's usually easy to figure out how a criminal enters a crime scene. but in this case, it was far from clear. it looked like the killer vanished in thin air. and perhaps he had. >> getting into medical school. it's the hope and dream of thousands of students who apply each year, then pray they'll be accepted. michael andrade was one of those hopefuls. >> he really wanted to be a doctor. he really wanted to help people. just recently, my mom told me, she used to tell him, don't worry, michael, all your hard

371 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on