tv Forensic Files CNN March 10, 2014 11:30pm-12:01am PDT
11:30 pm
incredible. >> it the police had not done such a really outstanding job in pursuing this for so many years, that cannon would probably still be walking free. >> they know that her atm card had been used, and she looked very calm. >> she's alive now. maybe she'll be alive five minutes from now. >> but police soon lose the trail. >> investigators use the only tools they have to find the victims. >> they need to act quickly in order to try and save their lives.
11:31 pm
it was a saturday morning on a hot summer day in greenville, north carolina. the hayes family stopped at a local store for some snack food before going out for the day. as jeremy hayes and his brother-in-law went inside the store, his wife ginger decided to change the baby's diaper. when the men came back outside, the car was gone. at first, jeremy assumed it was a joke. >> ginger was up to her old tricks again, playing pranks and had moved the car around in the parking lot. so they looked around in the parking lot. >> jeremy called ginger's cell phone. but there was no answer. that's when he called police. >> i didn't know what had happened. i didn't know what in the world could have happened to make her just leave. >> are you sure this was a carjacking? >> i don'tnow what's going on. >> we receive add callerier.
11:32 pm
>> you have them? >> no, sir. >> the police told jeremy there had been a witness, a mail carrier who had called police a few minutes earlier saying he saw a kidnapping. >> there's a redford focus. there's a girl bent over. a guy came up behind her and it looked like he took her and took off. >> he observed a black male push a white female into a vehicle from the back seat forwards the front seat. the black male ended up getting in the driver's seat. the vehicle was seen heading north on memorial drive. >> they realized this family was in danger. they had to work very, very quickly. because they knew they were minutes away from the moment that this family was taken. >> the police put out an all points bulletin on the car. >> everybody in the area is looking for this car.
11:33 pm
>> the missing woman was 25 year old ginger hayes. her son nicolas was 11 months old. >> i was extremely worried about what happened to them, you know. i was really close to her. and that was pretty much the only thing i was thinking of was i hope they're okay. i hope they're okay. >> police checked ginger hayes' credit card and learned that someone used it at a supermarket less than an hour after the kidnapping. police checked the store surveillance tapes and saw ginger hayes and an unidentified man. >> it was a white female and a black male going through the line that matched the register receipts of ms. hayes' card transaction, the time frame of it. >> the man fit the general description given by the witness but was careful not to show his face to the security camera. >> he's always kind of looking down. you don't get a real clear shot
11:34 pm
11:36 pm
11:37 pm
ginger hayes and her 11 month old son nicolas were kidnapped from a parking lot in greenville, north carolina. >> this was broad daylight on a saturday morning. nobody expects a crime of that nature to happen in a time frame like that. >> i didn't have any clue what anybody could have done. you know, car jack, kidnap, you know, god forbid murder. >> 45 minutes after the kidnapping, surveillance video showed ginger and an unidentified man going through a grocery store checkout line. >> it gives you that little bit of hope. you know, she's alive now, maybe she'll be alive 45 minutes from now or an hour from now, et cetera until you have time to find them. >> but the baby wasn't in the surveillance footage, leading police to believe that the
11:38 pm
perpetrator had an accomplice. >> i knew my daughter well enough to know, and i had seen her with nicolas enough to know that had he not been in jeopardy at that point in time, she would have fought like a wildcat. >> investigators were hopefully that robbery was the kidnapper's only motive. >> he probably promised her freedom and her child wouldn't be harmed. >> several hours later, police found the hayes car in a suburban neighborhood, 45 miles from the kidnap site. >> inside were the baby's toys. the car was parked in front of a home that belonged to a home with a criminal record, 24 year old timothy evans who had previous arrests for robbery and assault. >> timothy evans did roughly fit the description that was given to us as a black male with a
11:39 pm
stocky build and about a medium height. >> police con verged on the home and took evans in for questioning. >> he claimed that he didn't have anything to do with the car. that he was asked to watch the car for someone else. >> evans led police to andre edwards, the man he claimed left the car in front of his house. inside, police found edwards, along with several others. >> there were four other people taken into custody besides timothy evans. they had no idea what this black male may have looked like. so they took everybody in, trying to sort things out. found on elizabeth pitman was a cellular phone and some jewelry which was later identified as belonging to gyp injure hayes. >> police asked the only eyewitness to the crime, the mailman, to pick the perpetrator
11:40 pm
from a lineup. he chose 31 year old andre edwards, a known crack addict and career criminal with more than 40 arrests. >> he immediately picked him out and said that's the guy i saw push the young lady into the car and take off. >> but edwards denied any involvement. >> if you tell us where jen injure and nicolas is now they could still be alive and you won't be in as much trouble as you are in. he said i don't know anything you're talking about. >> i mean, they were racing against time. and it's rare that you find were your suspect before you find your victim. >> then investigators tried getting some information by asking another way. >> whatever story you have to tell me to allow me to find the child alive, then tell me that story. let's just save the life. you don't have to tell me that you actually did it. just tell me a friend of mine you immediate to tell me you need to go look here.
11:41 pm
but he wouldn't do anything to. >> shortly after edwards' arrest, police got a call from a man named cd thompson. he'd been walking his dog 50 miles from the kidnap site. >> immediately, i felt a lump coming to my throat thinking that we have two deceased victims. >> thought it may be a baby doll because i was near an area where people have dumped trash over the years. i saw flies around it, and the way my dog was reacting i knew it wasn't a baby doll. it was a human being. >> there police found ginger hayes dead from multiple blows to the head. 30 feet away was her infant son nicolas lying face down in the dirt. >> i was very shocked. the emotion was already set. i'm going to have to deal with the demise of a child, which was one of my greatst fears. >> but as the sergeant got
11:42 pm
closer, the baby started to move. >> he started to crawl. you went from fear to this is great. >> the baby, wearing only a diaper was severely sunburned, but otherwise unharmed. he was airlifted to a regional burn center for treatment. >> the hospital medical doctors at the burn center in chapel hill estimated that the baby probably would not have survived the night, given the degree and severity of the burns to the body from the sun. i basically call it a miracle that the child is alive today and probably wouldn't have been if mr. thompson hadn't been out there walking his dog that afternoon. >> i don't know what purpose god may have for nicolas, but i don't believe it was just luck. >> ginger had been brutally murdered.
11:43 pm
>> to find out my nephew was alive was awesome and that ginger was not was incredibly hard to deal with. [ male announcer ] this is karen and jeremiah. they don't know it yet, but they're gonna fall in love, get married, have a couple of kids, [ children laughing ] move to the country, and live a long, happy life together where they almost never fight about money. [ dog barks ] because right after they get married,
11:44 pm
11:47 pm
two innocent victims chosen at random. >> she was changing her baby's diaper. and because of her taking care of her child, ultimately, she becomes a victim. >> a suspect, andre edwards, was in custody, after the only eyewitness, the mailman picked him out of the lineup. >> i actually told him that both nicolas and ginger was deceased and to see what his reaction was to that. no emotions. i tell you, i don't know what you're talking about. >> but there was one problem. how did the mailman get a good look at the perpetrator since the abduction happened so quickly? and the mailman told an incredible story. he had seen this same man earlier in the day, before the abduction. he was on foot in a nearby neighborhood and seemed to be following the mailman as he made his deliveries.
11:48 pm
the mailman said every time he thought he got far enough ahead of the man he seemed to catch up. >> the fact that the mailman is doing his route. he's stopping several time, and he keeps seeing this person is odd. red flags are going to start to go up. and that's what happened with this mailman. >> initially the mailman was concern thad he himself could potentially be a victim because at each stop he made the black man would always catch up to him. >> so the mailman saw this man's face before the incident in the parking lot. but police still needed forensic proof. so investigators examined the stolen car for blood, both inside and out. but they didn't find any. then they dusted the interior for fingerprints. >> a potential advantage to processing a rental car is that a rental car is normally cleaned after each use before another customer takes possession of the
11:49 pm
vehicle. >> 17 partial fingerprints and 19 partial palm prints were found that did not belong to jeremy or jen injure hayes. fbi analysts compared them with fresh prints from andre edwards. >> his fingerprints and his palm prints came in contact with this vehicle numerous times. >> now andre edwards, you know, said he didn't know anything about the car. very quickly, they were able to prove that he had been inside of it. >> that meant edwards was lying. but it didn't prove he was a murderer. the medical examiner estimated that ginger was murdered about two hours after she had been kidnapped. the cause of death was blunt force trauma. she had also been sexually assaulted. >> the medical examiner could
11:50 pm
actually see the curve in her skull when she performed the autopsy. she alerted them to start looking for something that looked curved in nature. >> at the crime scene, the area was littered with discarded tires. all were covered with brush except for one just 20 feet from ginger's body. >> when they looked at it, they thought they saw what might have been blood. they thought they saw what might have been some hair on the rim of the tire. >> the tire rim was rusty, so that may have actually led to the amount of hears that were recovered when it was processed. if it had a smoother finish, any more transferred hear hairs may have been lost. >> there were head injuries. would you assume that those hairs were broken off during an assault, during an attack. >> the hairs were died brown.
11:51 pm
the physical characteristics of the die and the hairs themselves were consistent with hairs collected from ginger hayes. >> the harris recovered from the tire rim exhibited all the same microscopic traits as the hair coming from the victim. >> during questioning, investigators noticed some dark brown stains on edwards' shoes and clothing. those stains were blood and the dna profile of that blood was compared to the tire at the crime scene. the results left no doubt. >> certainly, the presence of the victim's blood on the subject's clothing is suggestive of certainly an interaction between these two individuals. >> semen recovered from the rain kit provided the final proof. dna testing showed it was from andre edwards.
11:52 pm
andre edwards was charged with murder, attempted murder, rape and carjacking. but his lawyer claimed he was impaired because of drug addiction. would the jury believe it? capital to make it happen? without the thinking that makes it real? what's a vision without the expertise to execute it... and the financing to make it grow? whatever your goal, it can change more than your business. it can change the future. that's why, at barclays, our ambition is to always realize yours. where their electricity comes from. they flip the switch-- and the light comes on. it's our job to make sure that it does. using natural gas this power plant can produce enough energy for about 600,000 homes.
11:56 pm
just a week before her death, ginger hayes and her son nicolas got to spend a week with her mother and father while her husband jeremy was away on a boy scouts trip. it was a week her family will always cherish. >> so it was just, it's indescribable, the joy that you feel when you have that child and the grandchild, and you're just getting to watch, it's like watching a flower bloom. you can't put word does that. >> just one week later as ginger was innocently changing her son's diaper in the parking lot of a store she came face-to-face with a crack addict who needed money and didn't care how he got it. >> the word senseless was thrown around a lot. what he did, was really for no reason. >> edwards was driving his girlfriend's car and it ran out of gas.
11:57 pm
he walked through residential areas where the mail carrier first noticed him. edwards stopped at the same strip mall where jeremy and ginger hayes stopped to get snacks. edwards saw the car running with the door open and decided to steal it. he probably didn't know that there was a baby in the back seat until later. edwards drove to a store 45 miles away and forced ginger to withdraw 100 from her debit card. investigators believe edwards may have had an accomplice watching the baby in the car at the time. edwards drove to a secluded field, assaulted ginger, then beat her to death with a discarded tire. investigators found blood spatter on his shoe, his shorts and the tire. he left the baby in the field, apparently willing to let him
11:58 pm
die from exposure. edwards parked the car at a friend's house, unaware that he'd left dozens of fung fingerprints behind. >> you can almost see the timeline being laid out, just based on forensic evidence alone. >> edwards alawyer claimed their client was so impaired by his client's drug addiction he didn't know what he was doing. >> his whole defense throughout this whole process had been oh, he couldn't have understood. he didn't have intent. but the result of what happened was a woman lost her life. and a family was changed forever. >> he knew well enough between right and wrong that when he sat in the interview room he didn't admit to a crime he knew he shouldn't admit to anything. >> in february of 2004, andre id wards was convicted of charges ranging from robbery to kidnapping to first degree murder.
11:59 pm
he is currently serving life without parole. elizabeth pitman who was in possession of ginger's cell phone and jewelry claims she was given the items by edwards at the picnic and was not charged. today, nicolas hayes is a healthy grade school student. although he has permanent scars from the sunburn. his father says he has only vague memories of what happened. >> told me that the monsters were going to get him. he said, asked him about what he meant. and he said well, mommy holds me, but the monsters hit mommy. >> the blood on his shoes, the blood on his shoes and hat all matched ginger's blood. there was no question as to whose blood was found on his shirt, his shoes or his pants. >> nobody could look at it asieh, it was somebody else.
12:00 am
i think one of the investigators put it so well during the trial saying there aren't enough people in the world for it to be another person. that's how accurate the testing was. they knew it was andre evans, guilty. up next, a young boy witnesses a terrible crime. the chief suspect, virtually turns himself in. >> he appeared exactly like the composite sketch. >> we have him with no alibi. >> but forensic tests failed to tie him to the crime. >> i couldn't believe they were going to let him walk to possibly do this to somebody else. >> could forensics provide the answer? >> the laurel village mobile home park was home to 32 year ol
847 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on