Skip to main content

tv   Anderson Cooper 360  CNN  March 13, 2014 8:00pm-9:01pm PDT

8:00 pm
>> i've had kids shot over the summer. i hate the summer. i can't wait for this to be over. >> violent fourth of july, a dozen dead. >> you still enjoy the mayor's confidence. good evening, everyone. there is no other way of saying it. in the disappearance of malaysia airlines flight 370 developments today could change everything. as we speak u.s. naval assets taking part in the search, and ships from the 7th fleet and navy aircraft are redirecting their focus in a totally new direction toward the vast open waters of the indian ocean. at the same time investigators are reexamining everything they thought they knew about what could have happened on and off the flight deck and where the boeing 777 with 239 people on board could be. experts are even considering the possibility it could be intact on the ground after a hijacking. and if that last scenario seems unlikely, you should know that tonight it is possible.
8:01 pm
that's because according to investigators, everything is on the table. in fact, officials now believe the plane might have been sending out electronic signals or pings four to five hours after its radar beacons stops transmitting. tonight we've just learned that u.s. officials believe the radar beacon or transponder was shut down separately from the system that continued sending out the empty pings 14 minutes apart. that could be extremely significant. american investigators telling abc news that the two modes of communication were quote systematically shut down, which makes for a very big hour ahead starting with our jim clancy. >> reporter: 2200 nautical miles. that's how much farther u.s. officials say malaysia airlines flight 370 might have flown after losing contact early saturday morning. investigators now believe flight information from the boeing 777's engines continued to broadcast automatically for as
8:02 pm
many as four hours after it went missing. but malaysian officials are denying this, at least publicly. >> those reports are inaccurate. the last transmission from the aircraft was at 0107, which indicated everything was normal. >> reporter: in a hint the focus of the search might be shifting west, india has dispatched two ships to the eastern indian ocean, and u.s. ships involved with the operation are steaming toward the same area to help with the expanding search area. >> it's my understanding that based on some new information that's not necessarily conclusive but new information, an additional search area may be opened in the indian ocean. and we are consulting with international partners about the appropriate assets to deploy. >> reporter: the malaysian military said wednesday an unidentified plane turned up on their radar 200 miles northwest of the island of panang. adding to the theory flight 370
8:03 pm
made a sharp turn, recrossing the peninsula before disappearing. malaysian officials have been careful not to speculate if this blip is in fact the missing jet. officials have come under criticism from other countries for giving confusing statements and withholding critical information. today they pushed back. >> malaysia has nothing to hide. we have spared no expense and no effort. we have followed protocols as stipulated by the international civil aviation organization since the incident began. >> reporter: adding to the already growing mystery, aircraft and ships sent to an area where three chinese satellite images showed what appeared to be large floating objects off the coast of vietnam. they found nothing. six days in, 43 ships and 40 aircraft are desperately scouring tens of thousands of miles around the clock. both on land and at see. and refuse to quit until this mystery is solved.
8:04 pm
>> we're going to talk to a navy commander shortly. jim clancy joins us from kuala lumpur. so have malaysian authorities given any comment since early this morning since this new information has come out that it wasn't actual data being sent to the satellite but rather a series of pings? >> reporter: well, they haven't made any direct comment yet this morning. still very early here. but they're going to be pressed on this again. cnn reported on wednesday that a high-level air force source has told us that that radar track showed this plane heading out, making a sharp turn coming back across the coast of malaysia, peninsula of malaysia and heading straight toward the indian ocean. that's on radar. i'm not sure about all the talk about the data being sent back, but the radar record is clear, anderson. and officials here have not disputed that. what they have said is they were
8:05 pm
waiting for the ntsb and faa to look at all the radar records. they've got multiple radar stations that were tracking an unidentified aircraft on that flight path right after flight 370 simply vanished into thin air. anderson? >> jim, stay with us. i want to bring more voices to bear on this conversation. chief national security correspondent jim sciutto and barbara starr broke the news about those data pings. richard quest is also here. jim, let's start with you. the shift west to searching the indian ocean, it's not just one clue, correct? but a compilation of multiple clues. >> reporter: that's my understanding. it is these pings, that's one. new information on the pings. the idea they were not sending data about the engines but they were at least giving a location of that plane. and what analysts did, they looked at all the other planes in that area which had transponders on as planes would normally. this one does not. and they determined that this plane had no corresponding transponder and therefore
8:06 pm
concluded this must be the missing plane that had turned its transponder off. you talk about other clues. it's my understanding they've pieced together several clues which makes them turn their direction to the west, to the indian ocean. the other one being the key information really that radar track that they've had from the malaysian air force for some days now that showed the plane going north and taking that southwesterly turn. and remember, they've had time now over the last couple of days to further analyze that radar data. i've talked to experts. they say that reading this radar data is more art than science. you got a lot of noise out there. and they analyze the pings from the radar. and they've gotten more confidence that that is tracking this particular plane. they combine that radar data with the pings that we're talking about now, satellite data, as well as a sense of the range that circle you're seeing now on the map based on the fuel in the fuel tanks of that plane. that's where they get this search area. it was traveling southwest. it could have turned which would expand the search area. but as you say, exactly right,
8:07 pm
anderson, it's a combination of clues that leads them in that direction. >> richard, what do you make of these developments? >> it's extraordinary. nothing ever seen like this before. that search area looks horrendous when you put it as one big circle. but of course, if they have got these pings they are following a series of not so much tracks but they can narrow it down. they are not going to be willy nilly searching the entire spectrum of the indian ocean. they will have a much more defined area within that ocean of where they expect it to be. and what we're really getting to grips with here is, clearly we are seeing the u.s. authorities, the ntsb, the faa, the experts who have now got the raw data and are now bringing to bear enormous experience in interpreting this art not science routine of looking at what is out there. that's really what we're looking at now. >> it's not u.s. officials looking really at their own data or their own -- from our
8:08 pm
understanding is, it's they finally got their hands on the raw data from malaysian authorities. >> we haven't been told exactly whose data but that's a fair assumption we're talking about the data that is there. also don't forget, a lot of this data is about satellite information is often about but it's not recognized for what it is. and they don't get to grips with it until several days after. what i think is going to be crucial in the hours ahead is how the malaysians explain the fact that they have been saying until now there's been no data at all. and how they can say as they did this morning that there was no a class data that boeing and the americans and rolls royce haven't said anything. clearly there has been an element of information which has not been revealed or made public. >> jim, you're on the ground there. in terms of officials there who are leading this investigation, is coordination getting any better? is transparency getting any better? >> reporter: in all fairness,
8:09 pm
the malaysians have said yes, there is a radar track that shows this plane traveling west into the indian ocean since early on. on saturday. they dispatched a c-130 to search that area on the northern end of the strait of malacca. the reason is as they explain it, they did not know for sure whether this was flight 370. now, in the middle of the week when we asked them about our source and the way that this plane was headed, they said they had to reconcile that, they had to get all of this data together. they could not be sure and they were not willing to dismiss the search in other areas just based on this once radar track that they had. but clearly early on they were concerned enough to send a plane up and search in that area. >> jim sciutto, let's talk though about these new developments. potentially very significant that the systems were shut down or shut off separately, which makes it -- it makes it more
8:10 pm
likely from a lot of people who have spoken on this that the plane was affected by some kind of human action. you've been checking with intelligence sources. what are officials saying about that possibility that they were intentionally shut down, and are they still holding out the possibility that those were just mechanical -- shut down automatically somehow? >> reporter: they're holding out every possibility at this point. because they have to, right? they haven't determined anything definitively. they're still gathering the clues. from the beginning i've had a consistent view read from intelligence officials when it comes to the terror angle them saying we have nothing to indicate terrorism but we haven't ruled it out. but that's just one explanation, of course. mechanical failure or something, a plane suicide -- a pilot suicide rather like we saw with the egyptair flight. i brought and i have here the device that shows how easy it is to turn off that transponder in there which would take a human decision but it's very easy. just flip the switch. transponder's off. but that requires a human being
8:11 pm
to do that. and the idea it would happen separately these two systems obviously adds some weight to that theory. but they haven't concluded that's the explanation. >> the second system i understand we'll talk to experts about this coming up is there's a circuit breaker that could be used to turn off the second form of transmission device. but again, minutes apart, it seems, at least some 20 minutes or so. we'll talk more about that coming up. jim appreciate it, richard quest as well. we should take a quick moment to say we are exploring a lot of scenarios tonight. we're doing our best to try to delineate which are plausible, which are possible and which are likely. with that in mind i want to bring in airline pilot ron brown, national security analyst fran townsend, former white house homeland security adviser and current member of the dhs and external advisory boards. aviation journalist and former ntsb member john golea. appreciate all you being with us. ron, you've flown in the region for years. what does this new information tell you?
8:12 pm
>> well, this new information is kind of going pack to what i said to you last night. remember i said there's three factors, the airplane, the crew talking about the pilots and an outside force intervening. remember i said to you that when you program the fms, which is the flight management system to make a flight, it's going to fly that flight unless some human being changes that flight pattern. so when you lost the transponder, which last night i told you specifically that somebody turned it off. who did, that's another story. but it was turned off. >> you're saying it couldn't be mechanical failure. >> exactly. you're 100% right. it was not mechanical failure. it was a human being turning it off. >> and you say you can know that definitively why? >> well, because you have two transponders.
8:13 pm
if one stops working, you go to the second one. so to have a redundant system and both of them not operating, that means it was done by some human being. >> john, you also think if this new information pans out that human intervention is involved here. >> certainly the sequence of events leads one to believe that there was somebody sequentially turning things off in that airplane. i mean, there's just no other conclusion. i agree with several of the previous witnesses saying that. >> john is there an explanation of why a human doing that that is not malicious, concern about some sort of a short? is there reason why somebody on board that aircraft wouldn't turn off that transponder, shut down the circuit breaker for the other means of communication? >> the only reason i can think of that anybody would do that would be if there was smoke in the cockpit and it was suspected to be an electrical fire. they wouldn't make an
8:14 pm
essentially a left turn. they would make a u turn. they would go to the nearest field. so very very unlikely in this scenario. >> fran, what do you make of this? sorry, go ahead, ron. >> what he was talking about is understandable. but the acars was still working. and the individual that had the transponders turned off had the knowledge of that machinery in the cockpit but did not have the knowledge of knowing that the acars would still be working and how to pull the circuit breakers to stop them from transmitting. that's the reason for four hours that you got signals. so this is really a point of somebody in the cockpit that had knowledge of how the airplane works but not enough knowledge to know how to stop everything and keep the electricity on. because you need the electrical system working so the airplane
8:15 pm
can fly. you can't turn it off like you can smaller old airplanes that were piston-driven where you could actually turn off the electrical. you can't do that in these modern jets. >> fran, what do you make of this? the mind obviously immediately turns to terrorism as a possibility. just based on if these devices are being shut off, with time apart and shut off according to both these gentlemen, it would be a human being doing that. >> that's right, anderson. and so i think we're beginning to get a sense of confidence, if you will, in the ever-changing fact pattern here that it was human intervention, that this was not a catastrophic event. but that doesn't necessarily lead me to believe it was an act of terrorism. i mean, the director of cia earlier this week said he hasn't taken that off the table. and i think you just need to know more. what you want more than anything is the cockpit recorder.
8:16 pm
you know, it sounds to me -- it's reminiscent of egyptair 990 where the pilot intentionally downs the plane. but in that case when we got the flight data recorder you heard the screaming in the cockpit, you heard the other people trying to stop it. in this instance where the flight -- where these were both turned off, not at the same time but separated by 15 minutes and the plane remains in the air, you can only imagine -- we don't know but a scenario where one of the -- the copilot had left the cockpit to use the restroom or some other reason. if an individual had wanted to take control and locked himself behind a reinforced cockpit door, he would have had the time alone in the cockpit to do the sorts of things that we now understand happened and fly that plane for four hours or more. but a terrorist would have had a target. they would have flown it to a place. they would have wanted -- they wouldn't have just taken the plane for the sake of taking it and then downing it. they would have had a reason and they would have had some target
8:17 pm
in mind. and certainly with four hours in the air there were plenty of potential targets in the area that they could have flown to. >> ron, is it possible given that there was about seven hours of fuel on board that this plane could have gotten somewhere to actually land? can you land a plane without large numbers of people knowing it or some sort of ground base radar picking it up? >> in that part of the world, that is very possible. now, understand this. with the fuel that was on board, it can be anywhere from sri lanka or colombo up to pakistan and bangladesh. the whole indian east side coast, that airplane had quite a range. and i think in all honesty that a captain that has the responsibility of everybody's lives on board would do his best to make sure that everybody stays alive as long as possible. and if someone was forcing him
8:18 pm
to fly that airplane, he would do that and he would go anywhere he needed to go to make sure everybody stayed alive as long as possible. now, me being in that situation, flying an airplane, i'm thinking about the people that are behind me. because their hearts are in my hand. and it's my responsibility just like a heart surgeon. and you think about those people back there. and you try to make sure that you take care of them the best that you can. >> ron brown, appreciate you being on. jim golio as well, fran townsend. let us know what you think. follow me @anderson cooper @ac360. usually on day six of the search the grid is smaller, there's general sense of where to look. this thing just expanded exponentially. got a whole lot larger. up next we'll dig deeper into the electronics behind today's news. there's all different systems that a plane uses to communicate. primary radar, secondary radar,
8:19 pm
adsb system, acars system. we're going to look at all of that, all the different ways a 777 can communicate with the outside world and how jim sciutto demonstrated those can be silenced. later what it takes to locate wreckage at sea. why other searches succeed and why this one could be the most challenging one yet. ameriprise asked people a simple question: can you keep your lifestyle in retirement? i don't want to think about the alternative. i don't even know how to answer that. i mean, no one knows how long their money is going to last. i try not to worry, but you worry. what happens when your paychecks stop? because everyone has retirement questions. ameriprise created the exclusive confident retirement approach. to get the real answers you need. start building your confident retirement today.
8:20 pm
predibut, manufacturings a prettin the united states do. means advanced technology. we learned that technology allows us to be craft oriented. no one's losing their job. there's no beer robot that has suddenly chased them out. the technology is actually creating new jobs. siemens designed and built the right tools and resources to get the job done.
8:21 pm
8:22 pm
a seven day cruise to alaska or the caribbean from just $549. that's seven days to either marvel at mayan ruins... savor the very best local flavors... or sail in glistening glacier bay. with a cruise line voted best in alaska. a seven day cruise to alaska or the caribbean from just $549. call your travel agent or 1.888.book.now for this limited time offer. princess cruises, come back new. malaysian airlines flight 370 may have been sending transmissions for four hours after ground controllers lost contract. then two communication systems were turned off 14 or so minutes apart. that said the 777 is packed with devices for talking if you will with the outside world or communicating with the outside world which is not so easy to make them in so many words shut down or shut up. tom foreman's been looking into the electronic angle. he joins us now. walk us through this.
8:23 pm
how could a plane like this not just disappear but also leave no trail of communications? >> reporter: it is not easy, anderson. these things are flying communication stations. look inside the cockpit of this plane. it is packed with ways to communicate. we've talked an awful lot about the transponder system right down here, the radio down here. there are a lot of ways to communicate. if i can bring in a model of the plane itself we can talk about where they are on the plane and why these are so effective in normal times. start with that radio system we were just talking about there. if you look at the nose of this plane in the cockpit you find the radio. it's a normal radio system used all the time. they used it right before this plane disappeared. and yet not a peep afterward. if you had a big fire, if you had some kind of depressurization, the masks that the pilots would wear up there actually have microphones built in that they can key easily to send a message out. and yet not a peep. on the underside of the front of the plane, the avionics bay, that's where you'll find the
8:24 pm
equipment that runs these transponders we're talking about that basically talks in radar terms. a radar hits the plane and says i see a plane. this essentially responds and says yes, you do see a plane and the plane is malaysian air and this is where we are and this is where we're going anderson. right up front you have a lot of systems communicating with the ground. >> there's obviously the flight data recorders. but at this point they're not any help, right? >> reporter: they're not any help at all right now. the flight data recorder is a fantastic piece of equipment. let me roll this plane around and show you where that's located. the flight data recorder is in the back of the plane. and you can take a close look at it there. that's the voice recorder located back there as well, the lines run back to it. that system will record virtually everything this plane is doing, every position of every control, every movement it makes, every buffet of wind it feels. but you're correct. they're no good until you can get to them. that's why you have to look at things likes the acars system transmitting information from things like the engines,
8:25 pm
spinning it out so people can see fuel consumption, things like that. the question of course, anderson, as you're asking tonight what are you getting from acars. >> tom, appreciate that. i want to dig deeper on that now with john hansman, who is a professor of aeronautics and astronautics at at m.i.t. and mary skiavo, who currently represents transportation accident victims and their families. you just heard about the radar one of the most obvious ways of cmmunicating, radio, primary radar and secondary radar that transponder we heard about. can you zero in a little bit on the adsb system and also the acars system? and just explain those how those work? those are the other ways of communicating. >> sure. so what the adsb system is, it's another way for air traffic control to know where the airplane is. so the airplane navigates with its gps or other navigation systems.
8:26 pm
and once a second it broadcasts out a little e-mail message that says here's my location. here's my location. here's my location. that's being used commonly around both the u.s. and around the world as a backup or a new sort of surveillance system to back up the radar. what the acars system is is actually an airline internal communication system. originally was sort of like a simple text message that you could get from the cockpit. but over the past few years it's been automated so things like automatic engine reporting is put onto the acars' link. acars can use one of two frequencies. the normal voice frequencies when you're line of sight over land. but if the airplane is equipped it can link the information up through a satellite link. it only does it at a low period or not very frequently because it costs a fair amount of money to actually get the satellite working.
8:27 pm
>> the acars system can be turned off manually through a circuit breaker, is that right? >> yeah. you would pull a circuit breaker. there's not a switch in the cockpit for it because it's on all the time. it's for an automatic system. but if there was a fire or a problem you always have a circuit breaker so you can disable the system. if you knew what you were doing you could pull the circuit breaker on that. you'd have to have a fairly sophisticated understanding of the airplane to do that. >> mary, at this point you like everybody else is not ruling anything out. what at this point are kind of the data points that you're really focusing on? >> well, i think for me and looking at it from an investigator's eye, you want to look at what makes sense, what fits together the pieces of evidence. what do we really have to suggest one thing or another. and from work on the air france, rio to paris flight and other cases, one of the things that jumps out at me is the
8:28 pm
possibility of something other than a terrorist act, a catastrophic occurrence in the airplane that would take out the initial communication system, which would explain the turn back, and the garbled communication that one of the other pilots, i guess it was a japan pilot reported. and then the spooling down of the systems. one by one losing the systems. so we can't say right now that they were turned off. we can say that they stopped transmitting data. and i think that in terms of evidentiary purposes is what we can say. and so in this case it might actually be better to hope for a hijacking where the passengers might be somewhere traded for ransom, et cetera. but here another scenario would be a catastrophic event, for example a breach of the cabin, loss of preshization where you'd only have literally 30 seconds to get on your oxygen
8:29 pm
mask if you were the pilots, and that the plane then goes on because this 777 is such a marvelous plane. the 777 will shut down systems if it's losing power, it will shut down systems and try to keep itself flying. it will keep its control surfaces and keep its engines. that's what makes the plane so great. >> professor, do you agree with what mary just said, or do you focus more on human intervention in this? >> well again, we have to keep all hypotheses open. it's hard to find a credible hypothesis where you have the sequence of events that we have here. if there was a problem on the airplane where you had let's say a cockpit fire or something like that, or depressurization, it could explain losing the transponder. it doesn't really make sense to head off in the direction the airplane headed off on. so they would have either done
8:30 pm
180-degree turn and gone back to kuala lumpur or perhaps diverted to the closest airport. so now -- but we do have to consider the possibility that yeah you could have had depressurization. the crew could have tried to get the airplane back and then become incapacitated. the airplane as mary says will continue to fly in whatever heading. so if they had turned their auto pilot into heading mode and tried to turn back around it could continue to go off in that direction. so that's still a possibility. i think intentional action is probably the high higher probability. >> we're going to get an update from the u.s. navy commander who says today's news is really a total game changer. even he says he has never seen anything like this. it's rare for a search to basically just explode in terms of the size of the search area now this far into the search. plus insight on how these
8:31 pm
searches proceed and what makes them work when they do. we'll be right back. [ male announcer ] this is joe woods' first day of work.
8:32 pm
and his new boss told him two things -- cook what you love, and save your money. joe doesn't know it yet, but he'll work his way up from busser to waiter to chef before opening a restaurant specializing in fish and game from the great northwest. he'll start investing early, he'll find some good people to help guide him, and he'll set money aside from his first day of work to his last, which isn't rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade.
8:33 pm
8:34 pm
8:35 pm
transmitting. we've seen several new leads in this story fall apart over the past week. there were satellite images yesterday that the chinese released. they now have come back and said oh, that wasn't the crash. and when planes were sent out nothing was found. this much we know for sure, that six days not one piece of debris. not one piece of debris has actually been found. fit did end up in the ocean, what would the debris field even look like? we want to look at that now with pamela brown. >> reporter: it was called a miracle because u.s. airways pilot sully sullenberger pulled off the seemingly impossible, safely landing his packed passenger jet in one piece on the hudson river. most of the time, though, the wreckage is not in one piece. debris scatters, some of it sinking, some of it floating. >> life jackets could be in there. seat cushions. anything in the bins that floated. so it's certainly possible that substantial pieces of lightweight debris, not aircraft
8:36 pm
structure, could be found floating six days if the aircraft struck the water. >> reporter: air france flight 447 crashed into the atlantic ocean in 2009. in this case, floating debris led search crews to the wreckage five days after it went down. the debris field was relatively contained. that shows it broke up when it hit the water before it sank 2 1/2 miles to the ocean floor. in 1996, twa flight 800 exploded in the sky near new york. debris scattered far and wide. investigators had to map out several debris fields. the cockpit sank, but the fuselage and wings scattered far because of how high up the plane was when it exploded. >> initial pieces of floating debris just give you a clue where to start looking and listening for the pingers, the transmitting devices that make a ping sound that the sonar picks up that are on the recorders. >> reporter: in the case of the
8:37 pm
1996 hijacked ethiopian plane, when the pilot tried ditching the aircraft in shallow waters it broke into three segments with the fuselage floating and the rear section submerged. in the case of the still missing malaysian flight 370 investigators are trying to cover all their bases, conducting searches by air, space and sea. pamela brown, cnn, washington. >> we're going to talk to one of the u.s. navy commanders involved in the search coming up. joining me right now is david gallo director of special projects at woods hull oceanic institution led the search for air france flight 447. put into context for our viewers how staggering this expanded search area is now. >> it took me by surprise. because now it's akin to me that if you were looking in the waters off new jersey that all of a sudden now we're going to be looking off the coast of oregon. so it's really been a game changer to hear that. i watched your graphic when you showed that search circle where
8:38 pm
the plane could be. it goes all the way from the arabian sea on one side in the west all the way on the east to the deepest parts of the world's oceans, the marianas trench where jim cameron made his dive. so we're talking about a whole different set of circumstances here. >> and i've been talking to people on twitter throughout the day. so many people are saying with all the satellites up there in the sky in this day and age, where you can locate a lost iphone, how could it be this far into the search and no satellites have spotted this aircraft, particularly if it was flying for four to five hours? is there simply not that much satellite coverage over say the indian ocean? >> it's a horrible situation. because you've got to believe that maybe someone knows something. given all what you just said, someone must know something that they're not talking about. because it's hard to imagine that that could happen, that a plane could fly so long. but there's still not a shred of evidence that that plane has impacted the water or crash landed any place in that search area.
8:39 pm
>> folks like yourself, ocean graphic experts, at this point there's not much you can do in terms of looking for sunken wreckage or debris that's submerged because nobody has any real kind of area to go on. >> yeah. it's frustrating. in one sense you could say that knowing where the plane isn't is a bit of knowledge, too, so you could begin surveying. but where do you begin surveying when you've got a search area, a haystack that's this big? where do you begin looking for the needle? one thing we can be doing, probably should be doing is making sure that we know everything about the currents that we can and the winds for the past week to ten days around the indian ocean. because any kind of debris, if it's found floating in the water, we're going to have to backtrack that. people can do that with very sophisticated models. backtrack that to find out the x marks the spot to where that plane should have impacted the sea. >> and just very briefly, the depths in the indian ocean far far deeper than in the gulf of thailand which was like 296 feet or so.
8:40 pm
>> yeah. you're talking now in miles, in some places miles. in other places shallow. but most of it miles deep. >> incredible. david gallo, appreciate your expertise. thank you very much. up next i'll speak with the u.s. navy commander on board a ship helping in the search. still ahead we honor the missing on board that flight. (vo) you are a business pro. seeker of the sublime. you can separate runway ridiculousness... from fashion that flies off the shelves. and you...rent from national. because only national lets you choose any car in the aisle... and go. and only national is ranked highest in car rental customer satisfaction by j.d. power. (natalie) ooooh, i like your style. (vo) so do we, business pro. so do we. go national. go like a pro. but when we start worrying about tomorrow, we miss out on the things that matter today. ♪
8:41 pm
at axa, we offer advice and help you break down your insurance goals into small, manageable steps. because when you plan for tomorrow, it helps you live for today. can we help you take a small step? for advice, retirement, and life insurance, connect with axa.
8:42 pm
8:43 pm
the search for flight 370
8:44 pm
expanding into the indian ocean. u.s. navy commander william marks is on board the "uss blue ridge" which is helping in the search. he joins us by phone. commander, yesterday the "uss kidd" was sent south. is there a specific location it's being sent to? >> we do have a third specter that was coordinated with the government of malaysia. it's not too far northwest out of the strait of malacca. right there kind of at the entrance. i should point out that's the "uss kidd." you only can search so much area with a ship. now what you have to factor in there are the helicopters. now you're looking at a couple hundred miles at least we're bringing in a p 8 poseidon. that's our newest patrol aircraft. that's flying out of kuala lumpur. that can fly upwards of 1,000 miles if needed into the indian
8:45 pm
ocean. >> so that obviously allows you to extend and basically continue working around the clock. >> it does. we had a p 3 flying throughout the night last night. the p 8 which again is our newest and best patrol aircraft is flying into the theater today. and that will get a few hours during the daytime. but that's the real game changer with their advanced search radar and extremely long-range. >> i've heard you describe the shift west as like moving from a chess board to a football field. can you explain that? >> yeah. i think that's true. you had a relatively defined and relatively small search area in the gulf of thailand. we had 40 ships from 12 international countries, 30 to 40 aircraft. and quite frankly if something was in the gulf of thailand we would have found it. we covered every inch. but what do you do?
8:46 pm
you can't possibly cover the entire indian ocean. so you have to be smart about it. >> this obviously grueling work for your crew, for all the crews on board. how big a concern is i mean physical fatigue, mental stress at this point? >> it is. it's always a concern. and we're watching out. we have about 700 u.s. navy sailors there right now. we have flown in a chaplain and grief counselors to make sure they are mentally prepared and have all the support they need. and it's physically demanding. running a ship, aircraft, that's a 24-hour a day job. >> one hopes day after day that the search gets to a narrower and narrower place. the reverse has happened as more conflicting information has come in. it's now wider really than ever before. have you ever seen a search like this? >> no, i personally have not. we do have helicopter pilots that have been involved in search and rescue exercises.
8:47 pm
but even those on the east coast of the u.s. and other worldwide, i like most of the world really have never seen anything like this. it's pretty incredible. >> commander marks, i wish you the best. thank you. >> very welcome. thank you. back with us aviation journalist and former ntsb member john golio. you just heard from the commander, major shift westward along with the indian navy now being asked to participate in the search. what do you make of that? the commander describing this as shifting the search from the chess board to the football field. >> the search area certainly has gotten wider. but what's frustrating in this whole endeavor, this should have been four days ago. this delayed start into this process is really crazy. you can see now how quickly things are developing since we've included the international community in the efforts to find this airplane. the radar data that's all of a sudden we're getting lots of information off the radar data.
8:48 pm
we've got lots of things to explore. it may not be the answer. we may not find it. but we have more opportunity and more leads to follow. >> that could have been done days ago? >> yes. it should have been done from the very beginning. the very beginning. they should have mobilized. the international community is always willing to jump in and help. the united states through the ntsb and state department and all the agencies we have, french, brits, dutch, very experienced in accident investigations. these are people you should call upon. and they're willing to come and help you. but they were slow in requesting and slow in putting them to work. >> i want to go back over the ways planes communicate. i think it is confusing for our viewers. i certainly find it confusing. it is normal my understanding now is that when a plane is going over a large body of water it's normal in a way that it drops off radar, that at a
8:49 pm
certain point controllers are just kind of projecting where the plane should be, correct? as it moves from one radar station to another, correct? >> there are huge gaps in the radar coverage around the world. and especially over open water. in the north atlantic just every day there's hundreds of flights that go from new york or boston to europe and back. there is a pretty big chunk of the atlantic ocean that there is no radar coverage. and we use other means to communicate. that flight boeing when they built the 777 put satellite communications on board the airplane. >> that's the acars system? >> right. well, it's more. acars on steroids, actually. because we've had acars on domestic airplanes and they don't have the reach, radio reach. so the technology has been moving forward to make sure that we can keep track of our airplanes. because it's less expensive to have the airplane tell you where it is than it is you try to build radar stations all around the world to spot the airplane. >> i want to ask you one other
8:50 pm
question which may be a dumb question, but it's on a lot of people's minds i know because people have been asking me about it all day long. people are asking, you can find a cell phone. you can track down a cell phone through satellites these days. would it be possible to do that on any of the passengers' cell phones to somehow get a gps location from any of the passengers' cell phones if they're out there? >> no. what's wrong with that you're not getting the signals from the satellite. the cell phone's getting the signals from towers. in this case the towers can be equated to a radar tower as well. and you need multiple hits on the tower in order to pinpoint where the device is. so we just in the middle of the ocean and there are no ground base signals. it's the airplane's got to tell us where it is. and with the technology, the commander said it right. we've got some tremendous technology. if the air ship is in the water, if the airplane is in the water, it's likely going to be found.
8:51 pm
for years the united states and the soviet union played a cat and mouse game with submarines. the technology that was developed as a result of that is phenomenal. >> so if it's in the water it will be found. >> yes. >> let's hope for that find it one way or the other. certainly those families just want some information. john golio, appreciate you being with us and sticking around. as we said the loved ones that vanished. each day we do learn more about the people, the 239 people on board flight 370. as so much focus has been on the aircraft we want to focus on the people on that aircraft. their stories coming up. plus an airplane emergency in philadelphia. what went wrong when 360 continues. [ male announcer ] this is the cat that drank the milk... [ meows ] ...and let in the dog that woke the man who drove to the control room [ woman ] driverless mode engaged. find parking space. [ woman ] parking space found. [ male announcer ] ...that secured the data that directed the turbines that powered the farm that made the milk that went to the store that reminded the man to buy the milk that was poured by the girl who loved the cat. [ meows ]
8:52 pm
the internet of everything is changing everything. cisco. tomorrow starts here.
8:53 pm
8:54 pm
the internet of everything is changing everything. ...return on investment wall isn't a street... isn't the only return i'm looking forward to... for some, every dollar is earned with sweat, sacrifice, courage. which is why usaa is honored to help our members with everything from investing for retirement to saving for college. our commitment to current and former military members and their families is without equal. are you still sleeping? just wanted to check and make sure that we were on schedule. the first technology of its kind... mom and dad, i have great news.
8:55 pm
is now providing answers families need. siemens. answers. nearly a week ago 239 people got onboard flight 370. a red eye to beijing. for the families waiting for answers is simply excruciating. >> six days of searching, six days of waiting, six days of anguish for the families of the missing. in kuala lumpur, this father waits for any news of his 29-year-old son. he tells airline officials he doesn't want compensation from them, he just wants answers. this man waits for news in beijing.
8:56 pm
his cousin is missing. we just want them to search quickly and let us know what's going on, he says, dead or alive we want to know as soon as possible. the family of firman siregar also wait for answers. this is his grief stricken mother. the 24-year-old studied electrical engineering in indonesia and was on his way to beijing on board flight 370 to start a new job at an oil company. 30-year-old huang yi works for a semiconductor company based in austin, texas. she was on the flight with 19 other colleagues when it disappeared. friends describe yi as kind, lively, a good listener and devoted to her 5-year-old daughter who still waits for her back in china. patrick francis gomes's family pray for him at their church in malaysia. he is the in flight supervisor for the missing plane, a job his daughter says he took very seriously. she also described him as a quiet person but with a sense of humor. 76-year-old liu rusheng was one of the oldest passengers on the flight. he was in malaysia to attend an
8:57 pm
art exhibition with his wife. lu is an accomplished calligrapher. he had several heart attacks and accidents in his life. in an article in 2006, he wrote after having escaped death several times i enjoy and treasure life even more. 239 treasured lives remembered by loved ones as they continue to wait. the question tonight is where are they? what happened to them. coming up an emergency evacuation of passengers on a plane at philadelphia international airport. we have details on that ahead. ] you've never watched her like this before. but something about spending this time together -- sailing past ancient glaciers in alaska -- makes you realize how old time is and how short life is. she can take all the time she wants. princess cruises. come back new. [ female announcer ] plan your seven-day cruise from just $549. call your travel agent or 1-800-princess.
8:58 pm
bob will retire when he's 153, which would be fine if bob were a vampire. but he's not. ♪ he's an architect with two kids and a mortgage. luckily, he found someone who gave him a fresh perspective on his portfolio. and with some planning and effort, hopefully bob can retire at a more appropriate age. it's not rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade.
8:59 pm
9:00 pm
there was another aviation mishap today. fortunately no one was hurt, passengers aboard a u.s. airways flight bound for ft. lauderdale, florida were evacuated at philadelphia international