Skip to main content

tv   Erin Burnett Out Front  CNN  April 10, 2014 4:00pm-5:01pm PDT

4:00 pm
next breaking news. cnn just learning health and human services secretary kathleen sebelius gone. we are live at the white house. and breaking news on malaysia airlines flight 370. we are standing by at this hour for confirmation of a new ping. officials say this could be from the black box. it's being analyzed at this instant. plus, we now know the last words from the cockpit came from the captain. let's go "outfront." good evening, everyone. we are following two major breaking news stories tonight. the hunt for malaysia airlines flight 370, and the news just breaking now from the white
4:01 pm
house. embattled health and human services secretary kathleen sebelius is resigning, gone. this news just coming in to our own jim acosta. i want to go straight to the white house. athena jones is there for us. athena, what more can you tell us? people have been calling for her head. it seemed like she might have survived, but no. >> that's right. hi, erin. all along during the disastrous roll-out of healthcare.gov, secretary sebelius was under an enormous amount of pressure and the administration stood by her, repeatedly in briefs. you heard from white house press secretary jay carney that the administration had faith in kathleen sebelius. the word here is she wanted to wait until they could announce these positive numbers. you'll remember a week ago the administration was able to say 7.1 million people ended up signing up for health insurance, despite that rocky start, that rocky roll-out to healthcare.gov. and even this morning, we heard from secretary sebelius on capitol hill saying that another 400,000 people have now signed up. so bringing that total to 7.5, which is a number that many
4:02 pm
people, many people doubted the administration would be able to reach. so she can point to that as a success. we should mention that kathleen sebelius is the only person who served in this role as hhs secretary for this administration. she was sworn in april of 2009. and she'll be replaced by sylvia matthews burwell, who is the current director of the office of management and budget. erin? >> before you go, athena, the bottom line here is they just wanted to wait to do this so that those who have been critical of healthcare.gov and obamacare wouldn't have been able to spike the football too early on? >> right. one last thing that the critics could point. to kathleen sebelius was able to show that this positive number, and then bow out. erin? >> athena, thank you very much. appreciate it. we're going to have more on that breaking story throughout the out with kathleen sebelius out at hhs. now to our other top story tonight, the breaking news coming in in the search for
4:03 pm
malaysian airlines flight 370, michael holmes monitoring the search. he is in perth. joe johns in kuala lumpur with the breaking news on the investigation. at this moment, they've got a fifth possible ping and they're analyzing it as they think it could have come from the black box. this is a new ping. they're look agent it at this moment. they're hoping to that that analysis any instant at this hour. the navy supply ships cesar chavez en route. as for the investigation, this is amazing. officials tell cnn, officials now say it was the pilot, who spoke the final words to air traffic controllers, "good night malaysian 370." earlier in the investigation that. >> said the copilot said that. he had been having earlier communications. so this would have been a change to the pilot. the source says there was no sign of stress in the captain's voice. we're going to have much more on that breaking news coming up and a friend of is the pilot out front later this hour. i want to begin with the breaking news from perth and michael holmes. what is the latest there, michael?
4:04 pm
>> yeah, erin, that latest ping coming from a sonar buoy. these planes that have been out there, this is really an added tool to the ship that has been towing around that ping locator. what the planes do, they can carry up to 84 of those things. and they've been peppering the ocean near the ocean shield vessel where which picked up of course the four pings since last saturday. these buoys drop a line a thousand feet down into the ocean, and they listen. well, it seems one of them got a hit, a ping within the frequency range. all the data recorder. and according to researchers, has the potential from being from a man made source, their words. now this is preliminary data, in many ways experimental technology. as you said, sent off for km examination. a dozen ships again out over the ocean, scouring. interestingly, the ocean shield joined now by a british naval
4:05 pm
ship, an oceanography ship, the hms echo. it's going to work with the ocean shield to look at the ocean floor. it casts a two-mile wide echo ping down to the ocean floor, hoping to get a ping back from the wreckage. so it's a big development to get that out there to help the ocean shield while other ships are looking for wreckage several hundred miles away where expert says it might have drifted. erin? >> thank you very much to you, michael. those first planes out of the gate are from new zealand tonight. we're going to be joined by the commander in charge of the search live in a moment. i want to go to joe johns in kuala lumpur first with the latest on the breaking investigation. they've been saying for weeks they thought it was the copilot who had the final words of communication because he had been tacking to air traffic control before that. now they're saying it's the pilot. how did they figure out that out, and how important is this? >> honestly, it's very fundamental, erin. it's voice communication at its most basic level. our understanding that police
4:06 pm
replayed recordings of the tower conversations to five other malaysian airlines pilots who knew the captain and copilot of the missing plane and would have been simply familiar with their voices. a source tells cnn there were no other people detected, no other voices detected inside the plane. no signs of duress detected. it seems like everything was normal. so it only adds to the mystery ooh of what went on in that cockpit as the plane disappear, erin. >> all right, joe johns, we'll see you in a few moments. thank you. >> i'm joined on the phone by kevin mcevoy from the royal new zealand air force. good to talk to you again, commander. searchers have been desperately trying to analyze that ping, picked up by a sonar buoy all night and day. any idea when we're going to get the results and know what they have? >> no. the acoustic event that happened, you say the ping was picked up after a royal
4:07 pm
australian air force orion dropped some sonar buoys and they picked up that. and that data will be analyzed overnight. so we're anticipating with the search later on today, potentially, there will be some feedback and some refeignment of the area for the search. and more importantly, for the recovery. >> your planes obviously going airborne at this hour, going out again. where are you searching right now? >> so we're already airborne. we're over the first off the group today. we're searching in the area which is removed from the subsurface search. the area where the pings are going on that the ships are looking in will be different from the area that the majority of aircraft are looking for. the aircraft are mainly looking for debris on the surface. other than the australian orion, which is specially equipped,
4:08 pm
dropping those specific s sonobuoys. >> obvious, there are pings. you haven't seen any debris. >> it's a very, very, very challenging search. it's a very large area. day 35 of the search. a lot of time has passed. and that brings its own challenges in terms of where the event happened. the drift from the ocean currents so far. so in some respects, it's not surprising that it's so difficult to find debris on the surface. it's also very, very deep. four and a half kilometers deep. it will take some time for some of that surface to reach, for some of that committee brie to reach the surface. so not surprising. you know, it is a very challenging search that's been going for a long advertisement. and our crews are focused, professional, and they're motived to find something and have some closure for this
4:09 pm
event. >> all right, but commander, you feel optimistic tonight? >> we're always optimistic. we go out looking for a positive result from the day. we'll search in the area that we've been tasked to. it will be according to the most credible evidence, all of the data, all of the information available to the search coordinates. and we're always going out there with the crews motivated, professionally trained, looking for the debris or listening for whatever that may be. difficult challenging search for them in terms of the environment. >> right. >> difficult seas. we've always got our fingers crossed. >> thank you so much. we appreciate you taking the time. their planes the first one out of the gate tonight. >> thank you. >> those planes are hunting out front. next, breaking news as we're standing by for a confirmation that a possible fifth ping has been detected and what it tells. an exclusive look at the cutting
4:10 pm
edge technology so crucial to the search. plus, sources now telling cnn that flight 370 made a drastic drop in altitude. so here is the question. why was the plane flying below 5,000 feet? and we now know the last words from the cockpit came from the pilot. his close friend out front. we have exclusive pictures you've never before seen of the captain. (dad) well, we've been thinking about it and we're just not sure. (agent) i understand. (dad) we've never sold a house before. (agent) i'll walk you guys through every step. (dad) so if we sell, do you think we can swing it? (agent) i have the numbers right here and based on the comps that i've found, the timing is perfect. ...there's a lot of buyers for a house like yours. (dad) that's good to know. (mom) i'm so excited.
4:11 pm
what do you mean? your grass, man. it's famished! just two springtime feedings with scotts turf builder lawn food helps strengthen and protect your lawn from future problems. thanks scott. [ scott ] feed your lawn. feed it. that's why i got a new windows 2 in 1. it has exactly what i need for half of what i thought i'd pay. and i don't need to be online for it to work. it runs office, so i can do schedules and budgets and even menu changes. but it's fun, too -- with touch, and tons of great apps for stuff like music, 'cause a good playlist is good for business. i need the boss's signature for this. i'm the boss. ♪ honestly ♪ i wanna see you be brave ♪ honestly to truck guys, the truck is everything. and when you put them in charge of making an unbeatable truck... ... good things happen. this is the ram 1500.
4:12 pm
the 2014 motor trend truck of the year and first ever back-to-back champion. guts. glory. ram. why relocating manufacturingpany to upstate new york? i tell people it's for the climate. the conditions in new york state are great for business. new york is ranked #2 in the nation for new private sector job creation. and now it's even better because they've introduced startup new york - dozens of tax-free zones where businesses pay no taxes for ten years. you'll get a warm welcome in the new new york. see if your business qualifies at startupny.com
4:13 pm
cozy or cool? "meow" or "woof"? exactly the way you want it ... until boom, it's bedtime! your mattress is a battleground of thwarted desire. enter the all-new sleep number classic series. designed to let couples sleep together in individualized comfort. starting at just $699.99 for a queen mattress. he's the softy. his sleep number setting is 35. you're the rock, at 60. and snoring? sleep number's even got an adjustment for that. find your sleep number setting only at a sleep number store. know better sleep with sleep number.
4:14 pm
breaking news in the hunt for missing malaysian flight 370. searchers now say there is another possible ping that could be from one of those crucial black boxes. now this signal was picked up by a sonobuoy. a plane flies over, drops it in the ocean about and it picked up the signal. so it's different than the ones the ships have been towing along the surface. we're hoping for results any moment. i want to go to david maddingly to talk about the sonobuoys. planes flying over, dropping these down into the water you. actually were on the u.s. exclusively, the most sophisticated jet the u.s. has, the poseidon p-8 with this technology. and you saw it in operation. how did it work? >> well, these devices are actually not made to track pings
4:15 pm
from a black box. they're made to track submarines. what we're seeing in the indian ocean is an experiment by the australians that could be paying off here. these buoys are not very sophisticated devices. they're parachuted out of airplanes into the water. part floats on top, transmitting radio signals. part deploys sensors under the water and can go very, very deep. the australians actually had to modify their buoys to listen for that high frequency of pings that is being emitted by the black boxes. and what they've done we're told is they've added equipment to what is similar for listening to the high-pitched sounds of marine mammals. it's not the same thing. it was just similar. it was a gamble. they didn't know if it would work. they still don't know if the signals they're hearing are coming from the missing flight. but if this is the right signal, the buoys will not only help them hear it, it will help direct them to it. >> that's a pretty incredible thing. you're saying they weren't even developed to do this.
4:16 pm
they sort of sound like they're perfect. >> well, these buoys do have their limits. they only have about an eight-hour shelf life with the battery. once they're done, they sink in the ocean and they're finished. ship movements, propellers, everything that makes noise in the water can make listening for that ping very difficult. that's why we're waiting for this very painstaking analysis that is going on right now. >> so who is the leader in this technology? >> australia right now is taking that gamble. they're modifying the equipment. the u.s. navy will only tell us that they are not using their sonobuoys to listen for the black boxes. they're not doing an acoustic search. i got a firsthand look at those devices on board a p-8 jet a couple of weeks ago. the navy tells me they are using them just as they were before, to track the ocean currents, the movements in the water. they're very secretive and sensitive when it comes to protecting the capabilities of their technology. they don't want people to know exactly what frequencies they can and cannot hear.
4:17 pm
because tomorrow they may have to use the same equipment to go tracking a submarine. >> it's very amazing just in all of this, the technology that we have, even the surface of this that we now realize exists. david maddingly, thanks to you. i want to bring in richard quest and miles o'brien into this conversation. richard, this is stunning when you think about this, in this day and age, right, you haven't had wars like this in a long time. the technology intended to be youed for that purpose is out there and it's so sophisticated. and it's amazing. >> and they keep having to refine it and adapt it. and you need look no farther than that inmarsat satellite. many of those satellite systems were similarly designed for warfare. originally. and now being adapted again and again and again to take advantage of these new situations. because they really are -- the clock is ticking on those pingers. we know there are days left, if that. therefore, what i'm guessing and
4:18 pm
assessing is that angus houston is now throwing everything he's got, sonobuoys, the echoes going up there, every bit of craft he can possibly get is heading to the area. >> and of course he is the man in charge of the search. >> yes. >> miles, it is pretty stunning. with all of this that is happening, that there still has not been a single piece of debris. everyone says a cyclone or a typhoon came through the area so the stuff could have spread like flotsam and jetsam. fine. don't you think one piece would have been seen on shore by somebody or a bet or something? >> or the snorkelers near the area of the pinging where they might have found an emergency card from a seat back or an air sickness bag or something that wasn't quite floating, but was suspended in the water. it's extraordinary. it just keeps taking me back to this idea of an intact ditching, which as extraordinary as that sounds, you know, given ocean swells and everything, maybe, just maybe happened here.
4:19 pm
>> you think it did, richard? you would expect to see one of those. >> the idea, miles, you'll agree i think that when first you talk about an in-water ditching on an ocean, anyone who has covered these things looks as if you're mad. you're absolutely mad to be even thinking, the idea. it breaks up. the plane breaks up. we've seen it again. but then you have to come to this conclusion there is nothing there. therefore, there has to be at least mainly intact down below. >> and miles, also to the question, i know we're going to talk more about this. but the question is, is there any way that the scenario you're talk about could have happened without human intent? >> i think it could be very unlikely on autopilot that would happen. sometimes when you fly a paper airplane, instead of landing on its nose, it lands smoothly. i suppose randomly that could have happened.
4:20 pm
to me that would require a skilled pilot who really knew how to time the swells, which is something we actually train for. we don't do it as pilots, but it's something you think about, you get tested on. and there is a way of doing it, of navigating the swells. you want to come on the back side or parallel to them. it can be done. i don't know what the sea state was that morning. that's something we should try to find out that is a key thing to know. i got to say this. that boeing 777 is a hearty aircraft. if a pilot was very care informal a ditching procedure, it could have been sully event. >> since we have gone down this road, if i may, the 777 had been designed and there were modifications and there were attributes of its architecture, such as the engines shearing off, the flaps not being -- the flaps would not impede it, the undercarriage coming in in the format of the underbelly of the
4:21 pm
aircraft in case of water. >> in case of water. but we look at the distance here, we're talk mortgage than 14,000 feet below the surface. a few miles. the empire state building looks like a speck. this is huge. this is deeper than the titanic. what about the pressure level? yesterday somebody was explaining to me as putting a cadillac escalade on top of your fingernail. could it be intact down this with that kind of pressure? >> have asked that question a million times. everybody says it's the metal. yes, if you put a tin can down there, it will crush. but for some reason you put the titanic down there, it doesn't crush. miles do, you know the answer to that question? >> i think it's a question. the pressure differential is the key. as long as there has been a breach, i think you'd find it intact. >> no, because i can't help feeling that it still would have crushed whatever -- >> like a window would have popped out.
4:22 pm
>> the window pops out. the water rushes in. it equalizes the pressure. it's equal pressure on both side of the aluminum skin and therefore it would stay pretty much intact. >> and there is also new composites these 777s. >> there is not a lot of composites. >> not much. >> that's what i was hanging my -- >> but not a 777? >> not many. >> weigh in, please, viewers. still to come, the breaking news, as we with trying to find out, waiting right now, analysis of that ping could come any moment. and what caused the plane to go down to 5,000 feet during the flight for a period of time. plus, outfront tonight, you will see exclusive new pictures of the pilot. you've seen him before, but not like this. we're going to see them and hear directly if his friend later this hour. ahhh. beautiful day in baltimore where most people probably know that geico could save them money on car insurance, right? you see the thing is geico, well, could help them save on boat insurance too. hey!
4:23 pm
okay...i'm ready to come in now. hello? i'm trying my best. seriously, i'm...i'm serious. request to come ashore. geico. saving people money on more than just car insurance. bob will retire when he's 153, which would be fine if bob were a vampire. but he's not. ♪ he's an architect with two kids and a mortgage. luckily, he found someone who gave him a fresh perspective on his portfolio. and with some planning and effort, hopefully bob can retire at a more appropriate age. it's not rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade.
4:24 pm
it's just common sense.
4:25 pm
4:26 pm
breaking news in the search for malaysia flight 370. sources tell cnn it appears the 777 disappeared from military radar for about 120 nautical miles as you see there as it went across malaysia. according to a senior official with the malaysian government, the absence from radar means this, that this plane likely plunged down below an altitude of 5,000 feet. that that enabled it to avoid radar. let's talk what in would have felt like. so martin, how would 24 have felt? how dramatic of a drop, given what we know about how this was flying from up around 30,000 feet down to 5,000, how quickly it happened, how would it play out the cockpit? >> well, let me just say this
4:27 pm
first, erin. this new information doesn't really play out well in the simulator. it doesn't quite add up. but given that, let's say this. we don't know exactly what the rate of descent was. all this tells us is that at some point, it flew under 5,000 feet for 120 nautical miles. it was at one point 35,000 feet. but it was also crossing the malaysian peninsula. so it had plenty of time to descend normally. but if it went down really strongly, we have got time to take you from 35,000 to 4,000 feet in the live shot. but let's just give a taste of what a desperate kind of dive down would be in an aircraft like this. and mitchell is going to nose us over and send us into a very steep and soon you'll probably hear the alarms. you can already see that's the ocean that is going to be racing towards us. remember, this would have been nighttime. but for the purpose of this, we wanted you to see. you've got the sink rate alarm that is going off. we're descending at over 15,000
4:28 pm
feet a minute. so this would be very severe, very harsh on the aircraft, very noticeable for any of the passengers, who would be scream agent this point. and it is very, very sharp. but then you level off. and we're just dropping below 5,000 feet now. so we went from 10,000 to 5,000 fairly quickly. the question is why did they do this. and it's been reported that, okay, they were trying to fly or were flying below radar. but i think so, come on, mitchell, you know, any pilot knows. >> if you're at 5,000 feet, if you're at 4,000 feet, you know you're on radar there is no way you're going to think you're not that. >> is not a level that takes you below anybody's radar. the other thing we'll point out real quick is we're over the straits of malacca. it's one of the busiest shipping channels in the world. and for an aircraft of this size, jumbo jet to be flying at 4,000 feet above this heavily traveled waterway and nobody is sort of saying wow, did you see
4:29 pm
that plane go over or did you hear it? it would be quite a commotion. so there is just a number of things that don't make sense. they weren't avoiding radar and they would have drawn a lot of attention to themselves. so maybe they were struggling with something in the cockpit. >> martin, thank you very much. and also, maybe of course, i know we have sources saying this. but you all may remember following the story so closely, at one point we were told this plane flew up to 45,000 feet. we haven't heard much more than that. all the levels we've heard, take them with a grain of salt. up next, what the malaysian government really knew about the plane's path right after it disappeared from radar. and of course we're waiting. an analysis of the ping could come any motel. plus, exclusive new images of the pilot. one of his close personal friends is bringing them to you "outfront" tonight.
4:30 pm
anybody have occasional constipation, diarrhea, gas, bloating? one phillips' colon health probiotic cap each day helps defend against these digestive issues with three types of good bacteria. i should probably take this. live the regular life. phillips'. live in the same communities that we serve. people here know that our operations have an impact locally. we're using more natural gas vehicles than ever before.
4:31 pm
the trucks are reliable, that's good for business. but they also reduce emissions, and that's good for everyone. it makes me feel very good about the future of our company. ♪ [ female announcer ] some people like to pretend a flood could never happen to them. and that their homeowners insurance protects them. [ thunder crashes ]
4:32 pm
it doesn't. stop pretending. only flood insurance covers floods. ♪ visit floodsmart.gov/pretend to learn your risk.
4:33 pm
breaking news tonight in the search for flight 370. at this moment, searchers analyzing a possible ping detected by sonobuoys. those are buoys a plane drops into the water, then they pick up a ping. this is the first detected that way, and the analysis is going
4:34 pm
on at this moment, as i've been saying. we're awaiting it at this instant. they say it's consistent with the black box. at the same time, there is new information raising serious questions about what malaysian officials knew and when they knew it about the plane's path. joe johns is outside in front in kuala lumpur tonight. >> reporter: today more than a month after the flight disappeared, we're just learning that malaysian search aircraft were dispatched soon after its plane was reported missing. the search planes were headed for the strait of malacca and the south china sea where malaysian authorities had initially focused their search. the search aircraft took off before authorities corroborated data indicating that the plane turned suddenly westward from its original course. but our source says the air force did not inform the rest of the malaysian government until three days later, march 11. >> i'm suspicious of the information that they've provided. i think the most likely scenario is that they detected them on
4:35 pm
military radar. they scrambled the jets, and either couldn't locate it or some other problem developed. >> reporter: and the malaysian government denied in a tweet that any malaysian air force aircraft were scrambled. that comes on a day when several other significant developments in the investigation. we're learning the plane disappeared from military radar for 129 nautical miles after it made that left turn and crossed over the malay peninsula. a senior malaysian government official and a source involved in the investigation tells cnn the plane must have dipped in altitude to between 4,000 and 5,000 feet, a possible sign the pilots were at the controls. what is clear now, mh 370's captain, zaharie shah, not his copilot, was the last person on the jet to speak to air traffic controllers, telling them "good night malaysian 370."
4:36 pm
there was nothing unusual about his voice which betray nod indication he was under stress and no third voice is heard. and erin, you know, these new details suggest a familiar scenario in crisis management, the kind of thing we've heard before. that in the early hours of the crisis, when things were most confusing, when flight 370 disappeared, the malaysian military could have been acting on information that civilian authorities didn't get access to until later. >> joe johns, thank you very much. live from kuala lumpur. i guess it's tomorrow morning when you about this it. out front now, miles o'brien, richard quest and arthur rose benburg, another pile. on this issue of the pilots communicating, it could have been one of the most crucial things if it ends up being that's the story. most of the pilots have been told up this point the person communicating with air traffic control was the copilot. now they're saying from this voice analysis that this final
4:37 pm
crucial communication was from the pilot, not the copilot. so put that together. was what does that mean to you that they switched to his flying? how unusual would that be? tell me. >> it means we don't know. i've got the transcript here as released on the day. it doesn't say. the source says it was the captain. the source says it was the captain. the source also says it with us the copilot who had been doing the radios on the ground. >> right. >> that can be explained away because of malaysia airlines. there is a rule, the captain is taxiing, therefore the copilots would do the radios. you get into the air, the copilot fly, the captain does the radios. >> it wouldn't surprise you this would have happened. by the way, let's note one thing about this copilot. this was his first time in this plane without a trainer with him. >> no, no. it was his first time. not quite. it was the first time -- >> without -- >> without a third member in the cockpit. without a check airman. >> right. >> so he had certainly flown with the captain before. >> but the third person was not
4:38 pm
there. >> it's irrelevant. >> would that change the likelihood of him being at the controls? >> no. because he was an experienced or a semi experienced. he had 2,000 odd hours on 737. >> are you surprised? >> you are going to be shocked, but i do not agree with you for the following reason. you have to look at the facts in the context of the accident sequence, which began at 1:0 when acars reported everything okay. 11919 was the last communication. two minutes later, the transponder is off. and now we start the turn and maybe a descent, maybe a climb. we don't know. but here is the thing. the final communication, if you buy into what we're now being told was the captain talking, in the context of the accident sequence, i think puts the captain right shack in the middle of the intentional deliberate act of flying this airplane.
4:39 pm
now, before you jumped -- >> his fingers are going. >> before you jump at that. >> miles wants in too, richard. finish arthur, then miles. >> you cannot analyze facts in isolation. they must be analyzed in the context of an accident sequence, which is a 14-minute period when this communication between the captain. >> miles, what do you make of this, though? this possible switch in who was communicating? >> arthur knows well that it could very well be the case that as they leveled off, the first officer was doing the p.a. announcement for the people. and so the captain got on the radio to answer the call. it happens all the time. >> we're now at our cruising altitude, enjoy your flight. >> exactly. exactly. it would be customer for the captain. it was the first leg. it is the captain's discretion always who is the flying pilot. it would be customary for the pilot to take the first leg. it could be as simple as a pa
4:40 pm
announcement. i don't know. >> i'm not sure what i'm disagreeing with. i'm merely saying with don't add one and one together and come up with three. >> i'm going to add one more fact to this. >> oh, do you have to? >> the final communication, good night malaysian 370 without the frequency to the vietnamese controller, which was different from the custom and practice of what had preceded it, looking at it in the context of the accident sequence, a simple explanation why he didn't repeat back that frequency, he never intended to tune into it. he never intended to transfer to vietnam. >> oh, come on. one plus one equals a half a dozen. i agree with you about the series of events and the series of incidents and the series of fax. and you have to take the totality. where i do disagree with you, arthur, is your insistence on always wanting to come up with the answer as a result of that. >> i say you have to look at facts in context. you cannot look in facts in isolation which you love to do.
4:41 pm
>> miles? >> let me say one more thing. if it was in fact the captain who made that call, how many times do you think he had done that radio handoff between kuala lumpur and ho chi minh city? 18,000 hours. he had that frequency already in the radio. he knew it was coming. but just a casual handoff i'm guessing. >> wasn't he the pilot in charge of pilot training at the airline, a person setting an example. >> you're right. >> that you would want to do everything perfectly? >> it was not a standard response. you're supposed to say the frequency. there is no question about it. but i don't know, arthur. you might be taking ate little too far. i don't know. >> at a critical time in this flight, all these anomalies suddenly appear. i think they stand for an important facts in a sequence of events which lead us to an inescapable conclusion which is my opinion and has yet to be established.
4:42 pm
>> richard, we were talking with miles earlier, which is now, again, we don't know, because we don't know if the plane is even there that we're looking for, though the signs point to it would be. if you take this event happening and eight hours later a plane that may be intact, which is very difficult to do without a human, when you put those together, do you think that's fair to do? >> you're cheerleading now. >> no, i'm saying if these two things are the case, which at this point it might be, what would you do with those facts? >> i would prefer to leave that aspect of the inquiry into the investigation. >> until we have the voice recorder. >> for a moment or two further reflection. because you can't prove it. and neither can i. but what we do need to do is get down there and get the boxes. >> all right. well, thanks very much. and by the way, just imagine on that voice recorder if it is two hours of silence. it keeps taping over itself. unless it was a person and they wanted to make a statement. >> or he said some final thing before the final act.
4:43 pm
>> if it was intentional. thank you. our set is tense here tonight. still to come, breaking news in the search for the flight. we're awaiting that analysis of the fifth ping from the black box i said could come any moment. and next, a close friend of the plane's captain outfront with exclusive never before season images of captain zaharie, and video you have to see. hillary clinton dodging -- well, you'll see. [ male announcer ] this is karen and jeremiah. they don't know it yet, but they're gonna fall in love, get married, have a couple of kids, [ children laughing ] move to the country, and live a long, happy life together where they almost never fight about money. [ dog barks ] because right after they get married, they'll find some financial folks who will talk to them about preparing early for retirement and be able to focus on other things, like each other, which isn't rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade.
4:44 pm
4:45 pm
4:46 pm
4:47 pm
and now let's check in with anderson with a look at what is coming up on ac 360. hey, anderson. >> breaking news obviously. australian officials are analyzing sonar data, specifically, a possible fifth signal to determine if the sound is from one of the black boxes on the flight. a live report from perth on the progress ahead. other potential significant new information tonight. sources telling cnn that 370 dipped dangerously low, as low as 4,000 feet after crossing back across the malay peninsula. we'll take you back inside the flight simulator and ask our aviation experts what, who could and would fly the 777 so recklessly. and equally important to investigators, why. i also had my conversation with sara bajc. she says she is keeping hope alive. that's all at the top of the hour. >> looking forward to seeing you and sara. sonobu the new details coming in
4:48 pm
tonight about what happened inside the cockpit the night the flight vanished. sources are telling cnn now that captain shah was the last person to speak to air traffic controllers, earlier we were told it was the co-pilot and he had done some of the communication earlier in the flight according to sources. this is important information, and tonight we have information from the opposition party, he knew captain zawahri well, and they even listened to karaoke together. captain shah was a friend of yours, what can you tell us about him? >> well, i first got to know him quite well around april, may
4:49 pm
2013 that was the time of the last general elections in this country when i ran as a candidate. as a member of parliament. he was one of the several hundred volunteers in my campaign team, and he followed me around in the campaign trail a couple of days. subsequently, we met a few times at social events organized in my constituentsy, he is a person that is easy to like. >> we have pictures that you just provided us. the first time anyone has ever seen them. what did you do together? i mean, we have some pictures of you singing together, tell us what it was like socially with him. >> sure, as i said, he was a fun kind of guy, easy to be with. easy to interact with.
4:50 pm
and easy to like. so that photograph of us, karoking together was at one of the social events end of last year. organized by my youth wing in the party, in the constituency. so he was up there singing and i got pushed to join him. and there we were, both of us trying to sing "hotel california" quite badly. that, too. >> now, we know the captain was married with three children, and a grand child. there are reports of course that his wife was staying with relatives. did the captain ever talk -- >> no, unfortunately, we never did. i never really met the family. when we met -- as i said we met at the social events organized by the party within my
4:51 pm
constituency. and we talked most of the time with the other members, national politics, issues, we would group about the country and what we could do to change it. because that was our bond in the party, talking about the reform that this country needed. that malaysia needed. >> today, sources have said that captain zawahri was the last person on that plane to talk to air traffic controllers. earlier they said it might have been the co-pilot but now they say it was him. is it possible the captain was responsible for the plane's disappearance from what you know of him as friend? >> the captain that i know would never have put the lives of his passengers in danger. or his plane at risk. that is not the man i know. so i can't imagine for one minute that the captain would do
4:52 pm
that. something obviously went wrong on that plane and we still don't know, we don't know the answer. but i mean, the man i know wouldn't be doing that. not deliberately. >> all right, well thank you very much, i appreciate your time tonight. >> thank you. >> we've heard this again and again from people who knew that captain that he was impeccable, kind, warm, and a wonderful man. still to come, somebody throws a shoe at hillary clinton. and we're going to show you because we're just getting video. they think salmon and energy. but the energy bp produces up here creates something else as well: jobs all over america. thousands of people here in alaska are working to safely produce more energy. but that's just the start. to produce more from existing wells, we need advanced technology. that means hi-tech jobs in california and colorado. the oil moves through one of the world's largest pipelines. maintaining it means manufacturing jobs
4:53 pm
in the midwest. then we transport it with 4 state-of-the-art, double-hull tankers. some of the safest, most advanced ships in the world: built in san diego with a $1 billion investment. across the united states, bp supports more than a quarter million jobs. and no energy company invests more in the u.s. than bp. when we set up operation in one part of the country, people in other parts go to work. that's not a coincidence. it's one more part of our commitment to america. their type 2 diabetes... ...with non-insulin victoza. for a while, i took a pill to lower my blood sugar, but it didn't get me to my goal. so i asked my doctor about victoza. he said victoza works differently than pills, and comes in a pen. and the needle is thin.
4:54 pm
victoza is an injectable prescription medicine that may improve blood sugar in adults with type 2 diabetes when used with diet and exercise. it is not recommended as the first medication to treat diabetes and should not be used in people with type 1 diabetes or diabetic ketoacidosis. victoza has not been studied with mealtime insulin. victoza is not insulin. do not take victoza if you have a personal or family history of medullary thyroid cancer, multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2, or if you are allergic to victoza or any of its ingredients. symptoms of a serious allergic reaction may include swelling of face, lips, tongue or throat, fainting or dizziness, very rapid heartbeat, problems breathing or swallowing, severe rash or itching. tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. serious side effects may happen in people who take victoza including inflammation of the pancreas (pancreatitis) which may be fatal. stop taking victoza and call your doctor right away if you have signs of pancreatitis,
4:55 pm
such as severe pain that will not go away in your abdomen or from your abdomen to your back, with or without vomiting. tell your doctor about all the medicines you take and if you have any medical conditions. taking victoza with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. the most common side effects are nausea, diarrhea, and headache. some side effects can lead to dehydration, which may cause kidney problems. if your pill isn't giving you the control you need... ask your doctor about non-insulin victoza. it's covered by most health plans.
4:56 pm
. hillary clinton dodging something during a speech in las vegas today. take a look and listen. >> in about two -- what was that? a bat? was that a bat? that is somebody throwing something at me? is that part of cirque desoleil.
4:57 pm
my goodness, i didn't know solid waste management was so controversial. thank goodness she didn't play softball like i did. >> the woman who threw the shoe, you saw her, we don't yet know who she is. and season two of "inside man" premieres. he takes a job as a paparazzi. this is awesome. he stopped by to tell me about it. here is the question, do you read all of those celebrity magazines? >> i did research for this magazine, i don't know if i'm particularly in the target audience -- it is nice knowing that stars are just like us. it is a good thing to know. >> being the paparazzi, getting those pictures, i remember seeing one of them on the beach in barbados, and thought really, that is a tough gig to go to
4:58 pm
these locations and take pictures of people, is it hard or easy? >> well, you think it is going to be easy, you have to have good skills to be a paparazzi, and be able to act fast. i was asked to camp outside of lamar odom's house, this was in the middle of his alleged drug meltdown. you start to feel a little dirty time sometimes. >> and what about the paparazzi who do this for a living? did they also feel that way, or did they feel immune to it? >> well, i think there are guys who have a code of ethics, who will not take pictures of kids, they have kids of their home. there are others who will take a picture of somebody at their lowest, they will do it. >> and physical altercations. when you see one picture, i see it in all the magazines. so it is not the same guy taking the picture. there are six guys --
4:59 pm
>> hundreds of guys, i was called to go to the airport because kim kardashian was flying in from paris. and i'm there with probably 60 others, you're fighting to get a shot, getting knocked out of the way. >> do they buy into it, hey, i'm getting into kim kardashian -- or, oh, i -- >> every person has a dollar sign, they look at the face and that is just a dollar sign. >> i can't wait to see this. >> yeah, it is good, you will like it. >> check it out. anderson is next. we should be on the air at 6:00 as predicted. >> choose to go. go where no one has gone before. >> the skies over baghdad have been illuminated. >> where no one else will go today. you can go in search of answers, only to find more questions. you might discover something unfamiliar. half way around the world.
5:00 pm
or uncover something unexpected far closer to home. sometimes you might need to look back to see how you got here. and where you might be heading. and just when you think your journey has reached an end you will be surprised to find it is only just beginning. but you will keep going because it is your journey. wherever it goes. good evening, everyone, 8:00 p.m. here on the east coast of the united states, 8:00 a.m. off australia's west coast, breaking news in the missing flight 370, a string of developments that raised questions and some hope. we're waiting for word from officials about a possible ping sound from the water. now, that will make five pings if it is