tv Erin Burnett Out Front CNN April 18, 2014 4:00pm-5:01pm PDT
4:00 pm
tweet the show @cnnsitroom. please join us monday on "the situation room." watch us live, or once again, you can always dvr the show so you won't miss a moment. that's it for me. thanks very much for watching. i'm wolf blitzer in "the situation room." "erin burnett outfront" starts right now. next, breaking news on missing malaysia airlines flight 370. a new flight path and a sudden climb in altitude. we now know the plane had four emergency locator transmitters set to signal in a crash. none were triggered. were they intentionally disabled? and more breaking news. the captain of the ferry that sank off the coast of south korea under arrest tonight. why wasn't he at the helm hen the ship went down? we're live live at the scene where more than 300 children are still missing. could they still be alive? let's go "outfront." >> good evening, everyone.
4:01 pm
i'm erin burnett. "outfront" tonight, we begin with the breaking news in the search for malaysia flight 370. a change this the flight path at a possibly dangerous altitude. a senior malaysian aviation source telling cnn that the plane had crossed into vietnamese airspace when it took that initial turn. so giving us more detail on exactly when that happened. at that point, the plane then climbed to 39,000 feet, which is at the upper end of its safe flying altitude. the plane maintained that altitude for about 20 minutes over the malaysian peninsula and then began the descent to about 4,000 feet. not all the detail you need to know, but more than we had known before. and from there, investigators believe the plane then flew for another six hours. another major development today is that the best hope for finding that plane, the bluefin 21 is about to finish its sixth mission. the fifth dive was aborted shortly after launch due to problems with the navigation system. we've had now several of these missions had to be cut short due to technical issues.
4:02 pm
we're going to get an update on the search in just a minute. but first, i want to go to nic robertson who broke the story about the missing plane's flight path, is in kuala lumpur tonight. nick, 39,000 feet, turning in vietnamese airspace. let's start with those two things. why are those so significant? >> well, again, it's more detail over and above that that we'd already got from officials here. the fact that it was actually fully in vietnamese airspace when it made that initial turn, and it was only after it had completed the turn that it began the climb to 39,000 feet, these are details that we didn't have before. investigators really are not any closer to solving why the plane climbed to this height, this particular point on its return journey. but, again, it's just a piece of information they will use to try to put together the complete picture. one thing it does tend to show them, but already they have more information that points in this
4:03 pm
direction. the aircraft at that point wasn't going through a sort of a structural mechanical issue that was causing it to rapidly lose altitude in any way. it was able to make a controlled turn and then make a controlled climb, and then sustain that climb for 20 minutes before making a controlled descent to about 4,000 feet out over on the other side of the malaysian peninsula. so it's useful information for investigators. how much further forward does it take them, really they say they need the black box to complete the picture, erin. >> interesting that nick is using the word control for the ascent to 39,000 and the descent to 4,000 feet. nick, you have also learned the plane was equipped with the four emergency locator transmitters. i know people assume it might have been. you were actually able to confirm this. these are designed to transmit a plane's location to emergency satellites when they're triggered by a crash. ie if it lands in the ocean or something. they should have been triggered, but they weren't.
4:04 pm
>> they weren't. there is one on the rear door, one on the forward door, one in the cockpit and one in the fuselage. the ones in the doors appear to be part of the sort of emergency exit inflatable exit if you will that becomes an emergency life raft. so they're supposed to on contact with water, they're supposed to begin transmitting, transmitting to satellite, transmitting on other frequencies as well that could be picked up by aircraft or by ships. the satellites have a relatively good coverage of the earth. the fact that they didn't pick up any of these transmitters is perhaps for the investigators an indication here that they -- that the transmitters didn't go off. and that in itself according to the source i talked to is perhaps an indication, and we discussed this in some detail, perhaps an indication that the aircraft landed in a controlled way. we know that 737 landed on the hudson river in a controlled way. and therefore, when the aircraft
4:05 pm
sank, water hadn't started coming inside in sufficient quantity to trigger these transmitters to come on. and perhaps by the time the water came in, the aircraft was sinking, therefore the frequencies they were transmitting on the signals weren't strong enough to reach the satellite. i mean, these are the types of conclusions and the analysis that investigators will be placing on this information now. but the source i talked to said it was odd. those were his words. it was odd that none of these four transmitters had come on, erin. >> nick, thank you very much. with 107 very important reporting coming out of kuala lumpur. richard quest is with me along with aviation analyst arthur rosenberg. let's just start with the emergency locators because that's what nick finished his reporting on. they didn't activate. so obviously that could mean a controlled landing, as he said. it could also mean they were manually turned off. that even possible that you could manually disable those or not? >> the location of the elts.
4:06 pm
>> the emergency locators. >> they're not just sitting there. he talk about it being in the slide, the evacuation slide, because the evacuation slide in the doorway at the rear and the front, that is also used as a raft. >> right. >> so it's not the sort of thing that you would have easy, ready access and would be able to disengage in an easy manner. i think that -- why the elts did not go off is one of the conundrums of this story. >> and so then that would mean, if richard's pointing out here, it's almost impossible to go manually turn those off. >> right. that would mean a controlled landing. >> we've talked about this a lot, actually. and i think one of the biggest conundrums that we have is how did four elts not go off. >> right. >> now, one thing you have to understand is they're designed to trigger with a certain amount
4:07 pm
of deacceleration. so if the plane hits something hard and suddenly stops. >> they go off. >> the elt is supposed to go off. the second mode of operation is if it's dipped into saltwater. that's going to complete a circuit, and it's going to go off. so here, if it didn't go off, four didn't go off. and by the way -- >> that means you have to open the possibility. i know as tiny as it may be, that it's actually not sitting in saltwater. >> but you also have to -- i'm just -- i'm just stating based on what he said. >> you also have to understand that the faa has determined that are there are a lot of times when elts do not go off for a variety of reasons. and it's actually a fairly high percentage. i've read, today i looked this up. it's almost as high as 25%. >> because of just malfunction? >> the elt is a fairly not precarious, but it's a fairly temperamental piece of equipment. >> but all four of them? >> certainly when you're in this part of the ocean, which is the
4:08 pm
most remote part of the world, where satellite coverage, it's not like the transatlantic where there is an enormous amount of satellite coverage. >> yes. >> and then you have the other option which is to bring us back to reality, the plane goes into the water and sinks relatively fast. >> quickly. >> and the elts don't work in deep water. >> that would explain it then. so now let's talk about the issue quickly of the altitude. so there have been various reports. you take them all with a grain of salt because all have been coming from military radar which was not near the plane. but this is again hearing 39,000 feet. 39,000 feet down to 4,000. using the words controlled on both ends. again, we know things change. but let's assume this ends up being accurate what the malaysian authorities are saying. controlled to 39, control to 4, what do you take away from it? >> here is the bottom line with that. it's really very simple. if the plane went from 39,000 feet down to 4,000 feet over about 30 minutes, that's a
4:09 pm
controlled descent of less than 2,000 feet per minute. the people sitting in the back, the passengers may not even be aware of that. >> but wouldn't you feel it in your ears? >> with a gentle rate of descent and with the pressurization system set to automatic, and half of them are probably sleeping, you probably wouldn't even notice. and you add that on top of the fact that the left turn was basically a standard rate gentle turn. >> very, very gradual. >> they may not have noticed. >> they may not have noticed. >> so you're assuming intent here. intent on the up and down. intent on the up and down may not mean mal intent. let's go with the issue of intent. what would be the point? >> i have absolutely no idea, frankly. i mean, we can make an argument it's to avoid oncoming traffic in the opposite direction. if you knew that the air weways went to 37,000 feet so you went to 39,000 feet to be out of the way of the traffic.
4:10 pm
we know there was an issue with altitude. >> yes. >> but there were so many issues with altitude that i suspect we have to leave it on the back burner. >> very quickly, if you were trying to kill people, wouldn't you go higher than that? why would you go down? >> no, no, no. if you're at 35,000 feet and you're looking too kill people, to go to 39,000 feet gets you no bang for the buck. >> right. >> if the captain released the pressurization valve at 35,000 feet. >> he could do it right there. >> its same effect you're going to get at 39,000 feet. >> and all you do is just in the cockpit. >> so this whole -- i wanted to be able to make that point. you can do whatever you're going to do with pressurization without an altitude change. >> it a conundrum that adds to many more conundrums if that is the plural in what is a unique set of circumstances. >> all right. "outfront" next, after another glitch, breaking news. the bluefin-21 is underwater again right now. we can confirm from you an update from the official with the search is next. plus, you're looking at ooh
4:11 pm
live picture of our david mattingly inside a sub. he is going down right now, being lowered to the bottom of horseshoe bay in vancouver. coming up, david is going to show us how to cut through debris and get to a plane's black box. even watching those bubbles start to go up as you're going underwater here makes me start to feel very, very nausea. we also have breaking news in the ferry story. the captain of the ferry that sank with hundreds who are still on board tonight is now formally under arrest. how did he manage to get out when most of his passengers didn't? and a scenario for how tonight people on that ship may still be alive. [ male announcer ] what if a small company became big business overnight? ♪ like, really big... then expanded? ♪ or their new product tanked? ♪ or not? what if they embrace new technology instead? ♪ imagine a company's future with the future of trading.
4:12 pm
company profile. a research tool on thinkorswim. from td ameritrade. a research tool on thinkorswim. predibut, manufacturings a prettin the united states do. means advanced technology. we learned that technology allows us to be craft oriented. no one's losing their job. there's no beer robot that has suddenly chased them out. the technology is actually creating new jobs. siemens designed and built the right tools and resources to get the job done. ...and let in the dog that woke the man who drove to the control room [ woman ] driverless mode engaged. find parking space. [ woman ] parking space found. [ male announcer ] ...that secured the data that directed the turbines that powered the farm that made the milk that went to the store that reminded the man to buy the milk that was poured by the girl who loved the cat. [ meows ]
4:13 pm
the internet of everything is changing everything. cisco. tomorrow starts here. but there are some places even mr. clean doesn't want to lug a whole bunch of cleaning supplies. that's why he created the magic eraser extra power. just one eraser's versatile enough to clean all kinds of different surfaces and three times more grime per swipe. so instead of fussing with rags and buckets, you can get back to the great outdoors, which can be pretty great.
4:15 pm
back with our breaking news on missing malaysian flight 370. it's now saturday morning in australia. it's been 43 days. the planes are taking off now. still they have not seen any visual clue that has been confirmed to be from the airplane. the underwater search is also continuing right now. we can confirm the bluefin 21 is on its sixth underwater mission. the fifth mission aborted shortly after launch due to problems with the navigation system. so far the bluefin has not found any wreckage. commander kevin mcevoy of the new zealand air force begins the search coverage tonight for our program joining me via skype. good to talk to you again, commander. do you have any new leads at this point? >> no, unfortunately, day 42 yesterday and day 43 today, there is nothing new to hand. lots of stuff that we did see
4:16 pm
yesterday, but unfortunately none of it was linked to the missing airline. so another day today. another eight or nine search aircraft. and in a couple of communications and control aircraft going up. so the crews will be out there again going their all today. >> i know they've got to be exhausted as you're implying there has been absolutely no break for these people on this effort. but have they -- are they still seeing things with the same level of enthusiasm and excitement this might be it, this might be it, or do you start to feel the sense of you might find nothing? >> you know, i think it is the crews have one thing, the unsung heroes of this operation are actually the maintenance teams who are putting the aircraft up there day after day after day. so we often talk about the aircraft and the air crews. but don't forget the maintenance and all the support people but from an air crew perspective, it is discouraging when you have
4:17 pm
come back attend of the day in one respect that you have found nothing that is associated with the search. but it is also encouraging. because the fact that you have been out there searching and found nothing actually means that you can discard that area and move on to another area. so it's sort of a highs and lows. but the crews will be focused again today. we've actually from a new zealand perspective, we've actually got a no flying day today, and we'll be out again tomorrow. but the other crews will be out there today. >> thank you very much, commander. and we wish you luck. richard quest is here with me again. so it took two years to find air france, even the actual plane itself, even though there were life jackets and they knew where it was immediately. they're pretty sure, i know people are saying off the record they're indicating they're incredibly sure it's down there. so do you think there could be a breakthrough? all of the sudden we hear tonight, the bluefin finds it or do you think we're in for the long haul? >> well, those two options that you have just put forward are not mutually exclusive.
4:18 pm
it could happen exactly like that in the next few hours. of course it could. we get an e-mail saying there is a press conference and angus houston stands up and says we found something. by the same token, as he has warned many times, as abbott has warned, as everybody has warned, they may find that they can't find it there. >> all right. so i understand that. but should they be -- what else can they do at this point? >> nothing. >> right now they're flying out, they're flying out. they're going to get exhausted. it's going to become a pointless cause. >> at some point. and that is what the malaysian transport minister said when he meant recently. >> you're talking about the bathrobe guy. >> when he said they're going have to regroup. when abbott says they're going have to regroup, what it means is they have to come back together and look at the evidence, decide are we in the right place. >> are we in the right place. >> well, you got four pings, one here, one here, one here, and one here. these are the four.
4:19 pm
>> okay. >> okay. so you've got four pings. it's about 20 miles, four miles, seven miles. at the moment, they're around here. they're looking here. they believe the second ping is the most promising area. now once they have really mowed the ocean and they determine that's it, they're going to obviously look at the other ones. but after that, they have no choice. they have to start going back up otowards the sixth and seventh ping, that 300 miles further up before they can determine that this is what. that bit is the bit that costs the hundreds of millions of. >> again, you're look along that arc of the last partial handshake. >> exactly. until they are absolutely certain that this bit isn't relevant, you're not going to regroup and decide to go on the next bit. >> all right. richard, let's hope it's in the next few hours. >> a few day, a few weeks. don't tie yourself to a time scale like this. >> i want to find it.
4:20 pm
thank you, richard. >> thank you. up next, a live update from our own david mattingly inside a sub that could be used to salvage a plane. you're looking at him there on his way down. a thousand feet beneath the ocean surface. how changes is the operation? he is going to show you exactly how it happens. that's next. plus, hundreds still missing after the ferry capsized in south korea. tonight, why one of our experts thinks that, yes, some of them may still be alive right now. salesperson #1: the real deal is the passat tdi clean diesel gets up to 795 highway miles per tank. salesperson #2: actually, we're throwing in a $1,000 fuel reward card. we've never done that. that's why there's never been a better time to buy a passat tdi clean diesel. husband: so it's like two deals in one? salesperson #2: exactly. avo: during the first ever volkswagen tdi clean diesel event, get a great deal on a passat tdi, that gets up to 795 highway miles per tank. and get a $1,000 fuel reward card. it's like two deals in one. hurry in and get a $1,000 fuel reward card and 0.9% apr for 60 months on tdi models. man:scott: aye, or...ott? a mornin' of tiny voices crying out, "feed us"!
4:21 pm
man: i don't understand... scott: your grass, man! it's a living, breathing thing. it's hungry, and you've got to feed it with scotts turf builder. that a boy, mikey! two feedings now in the springtime strengthens and helps protect your lawn from future problems. get scotts turf builder lawn food. it's guaranteed. feed your lawn. feed it! anncr: visit scotts.com/goyard for the chance to win a $25,000 backyard makeover. ♪ ...work with equity experts... who work with regional experts... that's when expertise happens. mfs. because there is no expertise without collaboration. and that's epic, bro, we've forgotten just how good good is. good is setting a personal best before going for a world record. good is swinging to get on base before swinging for a home run. [ crowd cheering ] good is choosing not to overshoot the moon,
4:22 pm
4:23 pm
could mean less waiting for things like security backups and file downloads you'd take that test, right? what are you waiting for? you could literally be done with the test by now. now you could have done it twice. this is awkward. go to comcastbusiness.com/ checkyourspeed. if we can't offer faster speeds or save you money we'll give you $150. comcast business built for business. breaking news in the hunt for flight 370. the air search resuming at this hour. and we are now waiting for an underwater drone to finish its
4:24 pm
sixth mission to locate the missing plane. if any debris is found, the next step could be a manned mission, sifting through hundreds of tons of wreckage on the ocean floor three miles down. right now our david mattingly joins us from inside a submersible at the bottom of horseshoe bay in vancouver. down a thousand feet. we've been watching you descend, david. it gives people a sense of how claustrophobic -- it may not be a strong enough word. walk us through how difficult the process would be from where you are right now in the incredibly compressed space to retrieve the debris. >> getting down here is a story in itself. but once you're here and encounter all the conditions, and remember, we're talking about working two, maybe three miles down at the bottom of the ocean, we're talking about problems with visibility, problems with current. it would take a long time to get down there, would limit your amount of time to work at the bottom. and it's going to be very slow and tedious as you go about this. and what we're going to be
4:25 pm
trying tonight is actually showing how you would cut through debris. if you're looking for the black box and it's obscured by cables and wires and things like that, which could be very likely, this is what the end game would look like. take a look. i want you to see right back here, we actually have to manually prime the pump before we can use a cutting device out here. we have a couple of them out here. on your left, that thing that looks like a vinyl record, that's actually a circular saw that can be used to cut the wires and metal that is down here. also, on your right, you can't see it very well because of the murky water, but that's only about two feet in front of us. that claw right there has a cutter that can cut through metal as well. and that's what we're going to demonstrate for you right now. phil nuytten is with me, a deep water dive expert. how difficult is it to do the most simple tasks down here?
4:26 pm
>> it's slow and tedious, as you say. tedious is an excellent word. you have to take every step so very slow. once you have completed one step and one move, of course the movement of the vertical thrusters particularly stirs up the bottom. and you're liable to have a big dust cloud about a secure you. you have to wait for that to calm down before you can move again. so it's step by step by step. >> and it takes a little while to geta claw ready to cut. we ready to go? okay. we're going to cut to an outside camera. look to the right that shiny device to your right that is holding the pipe, that's the cutter. go ahead. >> so i'm going to make hpu is up. so we're going to cut that. and then i'll pull this -- in this case, it's a cable that we're cutting. it could just as easily be a small member. >> and while you're talking, we're still waiting for the system to be primed so we can do that. >> that's right. >> just one cut is taking quite a while for it to transpire. >> what we're doing now is we're
4:27 pm
manually cutting it. we're driving the jaw. >> do you see that? >> okay. good enough. here we go. okay. so there we have. >> and that was it. that was just one small cut. i've actually listened to the stories of divers who went down to the bottom and were involved in the salvage of twa flight 800 that crashed off the shores of long island years ago. and they were talking about how diving into that water is like diving through razor blades. of course, at the depths we're talking about in the indian ocean, no human being can go down there, except in a vessel sort of like this. and there are dangers involved in that as well. now, the razor blade analogy isn't really a concern when you're in a sub like this, right, bill? >> that's true. >> the idea is you could get tangled while you're down there. >> that's the big problem is entanglement or the potential entanglement. the actual steel and what not is not going to penetrate to the
4:28 pm
steel. this is highly shielded hull. but we're always concerned about debris falling on you. wires tangling up in the manipulators and that sort of thing. and the only concern we don't have is with the umbilical as a remotely operated vehicle with that. so thank the good graces for that because in the debris, it's a terrible place to have an umbilical dragging behind or above you. >> in a manned vehicle like this, there is only six in the world capable of going to that kind of depth. if you get tangled up down there, i wouldn't want to be the person on the bottom waiting for one of the other five vehicles to arrive. >> no, i agree. certainly they won't deploy any one of those vehicles unless there is a standby. either a shandon anderson standby with a manned sub or a remotely operated vehicle capable of making that depth. >> all very complicated, and as you see, erin, a very, very slow process down here for anything you want to do. >> it was incredible to watch that. but just to imagine being down there and getting caught.
4:29 pm
i don't know, just an instant, maybe could feel the terror you would feel. thanks very much to both of you. "outfront" next, breaking news continues. 270 people, mostly high school students are still missing at this hour after that ferry capsized off the coast of south korea. is the captain responsible for the tragedy? and the tragedy eerily similar to the costa concordia" disaster. two passengers who are among the last to make it off that sinking cruise ship are "outfront" tonight. we'll be right back. ♪
4:30 pm
[ banker ] sydney needed some financial guidance so she could take her dream to the next level. so we talked about her options. her valuable assets were staying. and selling her car wouldn't fly. we helped sydney manage her debt and prioritize her goals, so she could really turn up the volume on her dreams today...and tomorrow. so let's see what we can do about that... remodel. motorcycle. [ female announcer ] some questions take more than a bank. they take a banker. make a my financial priorities appointment today. because when people talk, great things happen.
4:31 pm
4:32 pm
4:33 pm
i'm looking at you phone company dsl. go to comcastbusiness.com/ checkyourspeed. if we can't offer faster speeds or save you money we'll give you $150. comcast business built for business. so breaking news. the captain of the capsized ferry in south korea has now been arrest and charged with causing the accident that has so far killed 29 people. of course, as we told you, 270 are still missing. this is new video of the captain in handcuffs tonight. he was among the first to make his way off the sinking ship on thursday morning, leaving behind mostly children. we have new and frightening video of what it was like inside that ship as it was going under. you can see right here passengers clinging to walls. they had gotten on their life jackets. but for many of them, obviously, that didn't seem to be what was
4:34 pm
enough to save them. they're trying to balance, to escape. 270 are still missing. their families are praying for a miracle. they are more anxious, and they're angry at the pace of the rescue effort. we begin our coverage with kyung lah out front live in jindo, south korea. kyung, what is the latest you can tell us. i know there are so many families right standing where you are. >> reporter: they are. you can see them right over my right shoulder. they're just gazing out at the sea. the rescue operation isn't anywhere they can seattle. it's 12 miles away. but they have maintained this 24-hour vigil ever since the ship capsized. the latest that we're hearing from the coast guard is divers have now reached the ship. they have laid down search lines. and beginning a difficult day of going in and out of the various areas of the ship. the captain of the capsized ferry going before cameras today, after he and two other crewmembers were charged by
4:35 pm
police. he faces five charges, including negligence leading to sinking the ship, abandoning the ship, and causing bodily injury resulting in death. the captain says he was in his bedroom when the ship started to sink, and it was the ship's third mate who was at the helm. the third mate identified only as park says i made mistakes. for some reason, the steering turned so much faster than usual. and for the first time we're hearing what was said when the ship radioed for help. >> minutes later, the dispatcher asks there are no injuries? the ferry replies currently it's impossible to confirm. okay. please put on the life vests and get ready as people may have to abandon ship.
4:36 pm
yet crucial minutes pass before they notify the coast guard. once they arrived the captain, who you see in this video, abandoned ship while hundreds of his passengers hang on for dear life. video from on board the ship shows students growing more afraid. the water rising, and the extreme tilt forcing passengers to walk on the wallace while helicopters hovered above. on land, families overcome with emotion. peering into the distance, wondering, hoping that their children are still alive, even as the ship slipped completely beneath the surface. adding to the heartbreak, the high school vice principal who was able to be rescued was found earlier today hanging from a pine tree. >> kyung, what more have you learned about the vice principal, the one you said killed himself by hanging from the pine tree? >> well, one of the biggest concerns here is survivors
4:37 pm
guilt. whether the survivors because there are so few of them, if they're going to take these extreme measures. one of the risks here in the korean culture is that the suicide rate is one of the highest in the world. if you look at the who list year after year, it ranks in the top ten. so that is a big concern. and what happened with the vice principal is that he reportedly said he simply couldn't take it, that he was one of the adults who was supposed to protect the children. and he survived and so many of his children still are missing. >> all right, kyung lah, thank you so much for reporting live from jindo on saturday morning in south korea. "outfront" now, former navy s.e.a.l. and william doherty, a retired captain with the merchant marines. great to have both of you with us. this ship now completely under water. it's been four days since the accident. they said the bow was sticking out of the water so that would mean that there is air pockets.
4:38 pm
now it's completely underwater. so people are saying gosh, are we crazy to hope that any of these 270 people are alive. you say no, it is not crazy to hope for miracles. >> it's a large ship there are a lot of people under there. and if they are able to accomplish three things to this point, number one, they survived any kind of an injury from either when it hit whatever it hit or capsized, number two, they're in an area where they have breathable air, and number three, they are able to get enough of their body. so hypothermia. if you're fully submerged, your body temperature goes down 25 times faster than you and i sitting here in the same temperature. but if they were able to get the majority of their body out of the water, so if they're in one of the small state rooms and they're standing on top of something, they're going to be able to keep that core temperature up to survivable level. >> so everyone has been saying that you would have hypothermia and die. but you're saying no, as long as it doesn't go too high on your body, there could be a lot of people alive. >> literally, if they're standing on a chair or something that basically has only their legs in there, yeah, they've got
4:39 pm
the core above that, they're going to be able to stay out of a state of hypothermia long enough, hopefully for us to get somebody in there. >> which i think for a lot of people watching may think gosh, it is crazy to hold on to hope. it does give hope. when you look at the ship, it doesn't show any visible signs of damage, at least when you saw it. the man who was at the helm said he made a mistake, but he didn't make a sharp turn, and that the steering quote/unquote turned so much faster than usual. what do you think happened? >> i mean, first off, my heart goes out, my prayers go out to the families and the victims. but, you know, the hull appears to be intact. and the gyro fin stabilizer is still deployed. they're out. at a high rate of speed, 20 plus knots, if they had made a drastic course change, it's very possible that those fin stabilizers become counterproductive. in other words, rather than
4:40 pm
keeping the vessel upright, any drastic course change with the stabilizers out there could have caused an excessive list. if that excessive list caused the vehicle and cargo to shift down below, it's very possible that the center of gravity of the ship shifted dramatically and at that point in time it was a done deal. the ship was going to capsize. and regardless of what you did to try to compensate for it, it would be too late. >> once you reach a point of no return with something this size, it just happens. but how easy is this? people take ferries every day. south korea is one of the most sophisticated countries in the world. it's shocking to think that this could happen. these kids were going on a school trip. >> it is. look, i always say in a survival situation, it's what you do before the disaster. this was going to be a 14-hour cruise. take 15 minutes and figure out what are my two closest exits, where is a lifeboat, and where is my life preserver. combined with the fact that
4:41 pm
clearly really bad decision making was made on the part of the captain or the third mate. and then you add that to a culture that if somebody in authority tells you to do something, high school kids do it. terrible sort of chain events causing all these kids to stay inside that ship. >> i want to ask each of you about the captain. he has now been arrested. they say he was one of the first to leave the ship. tell me how that happened? i mean, that happened again with the costa concordia". i mean, this seems to be the first thing that these guys do is save themselves. >> look, they say the captain goes down with the ship. you don't necessarily want a captain dieing with a ship. but he has a responsibility for the safety of everybody on board that ship. and whether the ship is under way and it's in good waters and everything is fine, he is managing to get everybody off, he is managing an abandoned ship. he has to be there and take care of that. and this guy didn't do that. he was one of the first off. that's kind of unforgivable,
4:42 pm
basically. >> william, how do you think that could have happened? is there any way to explain that, that he thought rescuers were nearby or it is just as awful as it sounds? >> well, there clearly was a lack of training, drills, and organization with respect to emergency procedures. you know, i teach safety management at the massachusetts maritime academy. and the first thing i tell everyone is that in every emergency situation i've ever been in my life, my first instinct is to run. it's the training, the drills, and the team work that you develop through that that tells you we can manage this situation. when the leadership cuts and runs, it leaves a vacuum that is almost impossible to fill. there should have been crewmembers going to the life raft stations there should have been crewmembers mustering the passengers. so you know your head count. if there are people, there should have been other crewmembers searching the vessel
4:43 pm
to find those people. the captain should have been passing honest and clear information on to everyone as to the situation. not telling them to just sit. >> all right. well, thanks very much to both of you. i know we should emphasize by the way our understanding is there were lifeboats with the capacity for twice as many people who were actually on the ship. the lifeboats were not a problem. we still don't know the cause of the horrific accident, but today it was reported that major renovations were made to the ferry as recently as last year. obviously that means it would have taken a whole lot of trips before this one. but the bottom line is those renovations would have increased the ship's weight by over 180 tons. tom foreman is out front. it is possible the changes were a while ago, but relatively recently, that they could have contributed to what happened here? >> hey, erin, you might very well ask, even if they did add extra weight to this boat, what difference would that make? because it wasn't crushed down
4:44 pm
into the water. it rolled over. it capsized. well, weight could still play a role in that. think about this. every ship has the basic buoyant structure, the thing that keeps it stable. and then it has the center of all of its weight up above that, all of its mass above that. if you add enough above that, if you put enough up here, you can actually raise that center of weight. and that makes a big difference. because if you raise it enough, it becomes the difference between holding a bowling ball on a short stick where you can control it, or holding one on a long stick where that weight can really shift a lot. if that happens, you can wind up in a circumstance where this really wants to fall over this way if you turn all of the sudden or hit something. and this, in that circumstance wants to shoot up this way. those two forces. capsize the boat. that applies to weight built on to the boat. it also applies to the possibility of any kind of a change in the cargo in the boat. that's one of the reasons they want to get the cranes in right now. because if they get the cranes there, they can attach to it the boat, not so much because
4:45 pm
they're going to be able to raise it, but because maybe that can stabilize it, and they can get investigators down there to figure out what really did happen. >> thanks. and as cade said, get people down there to see if there really are a lot of people who are still alive in that ship tonight. "outfront" next, life or death. eerie similarities between this tragedy and the italian cruise ship disaster, the costa konco d concordia. and one man doing everything he can to live forever. morgan spurlock is "outfront" right here to talk about his quest for immortality. and when you put them in charge of making an unbeatable truck... ... good things happen. this is the ram 1500. the 2014 motor trend truck of the year
4:46 pm
and first ever back-to-back champion. guts. glory. ram. all stations come over to mithis is for real this time. step seven point two one two. verify and lock. command is locked. five seconds. three, two, one. standing by for capture. the most innovative software on the planet... dragon is captured. is connecting today's leading companies to places beyond it. siemens. answers. and his new boss told him two things -- cook what you love, and save your money. joe doesn't know it yet, but he'll work his way up from busser to waiter to chef before opening a restaurant specializing in fish and game from the great northwest. he'll start investing early, he'll find some good people to help guide him,
4:47 pm
and he'll set money aside from his first day of work to his last, which isn't rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade. cozy or cool? "meow" or "woof"? exactly the way you want it ... until boom, it's bedtime! your mattress is a battleground of thwarted desire. enter the all-new sleep number classic series. designed to let couples sleep together in individualized comfort. starting at just $699.99 for a queen mattress. he's the softy. his sleep number setting is 35. you're the rock, at 60. and snoring? sleep number's even got an adjustment for that. find your sleep number setting only at a sleep number store. know better sleep with sleep number. but add brand new belongings from nationwide insurance... ...and we'll replace destroyed or stolen items with brand-new versions. we take care of the heat, so you don't get burned.
4:48 pm
just another way we put members first, because we don't have shareholders. join the nation. ♪ nationwide is on your side ♪ take this simple test. press your tongue against it, like this. it moves! do you feel it? it can happen with every denture. these movements may irritate your gums. but you don't have to bear with it. you can try fixodent plus gum care. thanks to its formula, your gums become one with your denture.
4:49 pm
this helps stop movement and helps prevent gum irritation so you can keep enjoying life. [ apple crunches ] fixodent. and forget it. we are just getting a report right now about what is being called a potential security threat on board a delta flight, flight 1500 landed safely, 150 passengers were on board there and are now being interviewed by the fbi. our breaking news coverage continues on the south korea ferry disaster.
4:50 pm
the captain who fled the sinking ferry now under arrest. he has been charged with abandoning the ship and causing the accidents, 270 still are missing as the search is desperately continuing tonight. it has been four days since the boat capsized off the coast of south korea. it is now under water. the boat situation similar to the costa concordia, in italy, 2012, among the last passengers to escape they join me tonight. georgia, when you see these pictures of the south korean ferry, you know there are all of these children on board this ferry, we're praying that a lot of these people are alive in air pockets on that ship. what goes through your mind? >> oh, it is so devastating and so sad. it is -- for us to be able to witness this again after the
4:51 pm
costa concordia, it is just unbelievable. we would have hoped that this would never happen again. we know what it is like to experience something like that. and our prayer and our hope is that this would never happen again, and look where we are today. it is such a tragedy. >> i mean, dina, it is horrific. i mean, you obviously escaped. you and george were among the last to get off of this ship. when you see the video of the water filling up on this ship. it has been four days. you think about what you went through on the costa concordia, do you think it is possible there are survivors? >> i don't know, four days in that area, and if they're breathing the same air that is in that pocket, and we're talking a lot of people. i hope there are survivors, but to be honest i don't think that there could be in that situation. >> i mean, it is just so horrible. part of the reason they are trapped, whether they are still alive now is that they were told not to move.
4:52 pm
that is what they were told, to stay in their cabins, don't move anywhere. they did what they were told. you received similar orders, did the people on the costa concordia do what they were told? >> that is exactly what happened. they were told to go back to their rooms. back to their cabins. and we, of course, have cruised a lot. and we knew not to do that. but everybody on there, the people that did die on the costa concordia, the people that were hurt did go back. they followed the orders. and this is what is so tragic. is that unfortunately, you're not getting accurate information. again, there was no leadership and no one there to do that. so people thought they would follow the command of what was given. and there are so many similarities between what happened on this ferry and what happened on the costa concordia. but this was two years ago on the costa concordia, and we were hoping that there would be change. because we can't have this happening to every vessel that
4:53 pm
has the potential to put passenger safety at the front. >> i know, dina, when you had a chance to get off the costa concordia, you thought it was over, you were going to die. obviously it changed you forever, you are changed now from when it was before that. what do you think it may be like for survivors who have spent four days under water? >> like i said, it is a new way of living, surviving. at first you get the feeling, okay, we're alive. it is great. but all of a sudden it starts to hit you later on and things happen. and it is not quite normal. you have to start living a new normal, as they say. and it is a difficult road to go on. but it -- you know, we have had nightmares. >> ptsd. >> ptsd, health situations.
4:54 pm
it is little things that happen. and it keeps on continuing. it never ends, the situation. >> and i would like to add, too, it is not just the victims that are there, but it is the families that suffer, too. and we always tend to forget them and they're the ones that are suffering, too. and they're going to have a new normal, too. and they need to seek help immediately. and they need to become part of the new national victims help line system, to tell their stories because it helps to be heard. >> all right, well, thank you so much to both of you. as the parents clutch their cell phones and are just praying for their children to be alive. still to come, morgan spurlock comes "outfront." makes it like two deals in one. salesperson #2: actually, getting a great car with 42 highway miles per gallon makes it like two deals in one. salesperson #1: point is there's never been a better time to buy a jetta tdi clean diesel. avo: during the first ever volkswagen tdi clean diesel event, get a great deal on a jetta tdi. it gets 42 highway miles per gallon.
4:55 pm
and get a $1,000 fuel reward card. it's like two deals in one. volkswagen has the most tdi clean diesel models of any brand. hurry in and get a $1,000 fuel reward card and 0.9% apr for 60 months on tdi models. [ male announcer ] when fixed income experts... ♪ ...work with equity experts... ♪ ...who work with regional experts... ♪ ...who work with portfolio management experts, that's when expertise happens. mfs. because there is no expertise without collaboration. mayo? corn dogs? you are so outta here! aah! [ female announcer ] the complete balanced nutrition of great-tasting ensure. 24 vitamins and minerals, antioxidants, and 9 grams of protein. [ bottle ] ensure®. nutrition in charge™. [ bottle ] ensure®.
4:56 pm
4:57 pm
you gotta reel it up now,buddy. it.creel it up.t up, [father] reel it up,you got him on there.bring him in. is that a bass? [boy] yeah,i got a big bass. [father]bring it up.keep reeling.keep reeling.c'mon, where is he? whoa! you caught that all by yourself? [boy] yeah! [father]how old are you to catch that? [boy]three! [father]you're three years old? show me how many fingers that is.
4:58 pm
we now have more on the breaking news, a potential security threat aboard a delta flight en route from detroit to denver. we now have pictures where the plane has landed. you can see emergency vehicles, passengers on the plane who are being interviewed by the fbi. anna, what are you hearing? >> reporter: well, erin, we talked to people at the denver international airport. the plane landed safely, there was a potential threat on board. what happened, we don't know. but again, the plane landed
4:59 pm
safely. all the passengers are safe. we do have a twitter picture starting to see some of the passengers tweet on the plane about the experience. one guy said, we are all okay. all bags and things on plane, crazy situation, a lot of confusion among everyone. and as you mentioned, erin, those passengers are currently being interviewed by the fbi. that plane landing just a little over an hour ago now, here in denver, again landing safely. it was a 737 aircraft. we know it was carrying 151 passengers and six crew members. the plane landed. it was directed to a remote location, we're told from the airline spokesperson. and the passengers were de-planed and next they were taken to another remote location for an interview with the fbi. so it is still an ongoing situation as we try to learn more about the potential threat on board. but again, everybody on board landed safely and now are being
5:00 pm
interviewed by the authorities, erin? >> anna, thank you very much, we appreciate it. and we'll continue to cover the story because again we don't know what the security threat was. obviously, something that merited it going to a special location and the fbi interviewing the other passengers on board. this and other breaking news continues with anderson. good evening, everybody, 8:00 p.m. in new york, 9:00 a.m. in south korea, and the sunken ferry and criminal charges against the captain who abandoned ship. also, more information on the tracks of the flight 370, and the equipment that apparently failed to work. and later, avalanche on everest. a wall of snow buries 12 mountain guides, and there are rescue efforts on the way. but tonight we begin with south korea, where divers are
306 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN (San Francisco)Uploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=151356496)