Skip to main content

tv   CNN Tonight  CNN  April 21, 2014 9:00pm-10:01pm PDT

9:00 pm
active runway. >> i'm sure there are many examples on and on we could get in here. i'm sorry i couldn't get all of you in the last seg m, but i appreciate all of you joining us and will see you tomorrow night. i'm don lemon, thank you there's breaking news in the ferry sink. an apology. judging by the grim events and more crew members arrested it's hard to imagine anyone is in a forgiving mood. all hopes were riding on the bluefin-21. fading hopes it will succeed. what if it doesn't. what then? plus the ambulance ride was the easiest part of this 16-year-old's trip. he apparently spent the night from san jose to hawaii inside the wheel well of a boeing 767 in subzero temperatures with so little oxygen most people can't survive three minutes. the question is how on earth did he survive a trip across the pacific ocean at altitudes that reached 38,000 feet.
9:01 pm
tonight we begin with break news out of south korea. an apology issued moments ago from the operator of the ferry that now sits under water with bodies of so many people still on board. statement reads in part quote we apologize to all the people grieving for the loss of their loved ones. we apologize to people who had injuries major minor due to this accident. it goes on. once again we beg for forgiveness from the victim's families and pray for the dead. the company saying we prostate ourselves. on the water divers and recovery crews spent a grim day bringing body after body out of that sunk jennifery back to shore. 87 bodies have been recovered so far. many of them high school students on their way to a field trip when the ship capsized.
9:02 pm
>> translator: the conditions are so bad my heart aches. we're going in thinking there may be survivors. we have to come back with nothing we can't face the families. >> speaking for the families and all south koreans, south korea president says she's filled with rage and horror at the incident and the fact that the ship's captain was among the first to leave. >> translator: the actions of the captain and some of the crew are absolutely unacceptable, unforgivable actions that are akin to murder. >> along those lines police arrested four more crew members today bringing the total to seven. as for that captain he face as series of charges that could send him to prison for life. he's defending his order to delay the evacuation saying the cold water and strong currents would have made rescuing survivors difficult. others say telling people to stay below deck made it impossible. ship to shore radio transmissions underscore the dilemma with officials urging evacuations and ships officers
9:03 pm
expressing reluctance asking who will be available to plug passengers from the water? >> the captain should make decision for people to escape. we don't know the decision. that's not what i meant. if passengers escape can they be immediately rescued. >> patrol ships should arrive in ten minutes. >> when this all began the captain wasn't at the helm a third mate was. the captain says he plot ad course then threat bridge, a dangerously narrow course that authorities say was taken excessively fast with a sharp turn that endangered the ship which brings us to south korea where kim li joins us. you're outside of the exclusion zone. take us through what you can see from where you are. >> reporter: well, let me have you just take a look at this. on the yellow sea, on a boat, as you scan this horizon, anderson,
9:04 pm
check this out. the number of ships that are on the water. you can see a helicopter flying towards us. then these smaller boats you're looking at, these are where the divers get on them from the larger marine vessels, they get into these smaller boats and that's how they dive down. we see a couple of them skimming the surface back and forth. those buoys you're looking at, you see the crane and then large buoys, they are off white. those are where divers have the guidelines and they go all the way down underneath the sunk sunken ferry. we're trying not to interfere. you can see those orange vessels are going back and forth. and this is extremely difficult, dangerous work. these divers cannot see in front of their very own faces, but this has been going on throughout the night.
9:05 pm
when we arrived here about 12 hours ago you could see there were lights on that kept going in and what is driving these divers, when you speak to them, anderson, what we hear again and again is that they just cannot bear the idea of so many 15, 16 and 17-year-old children being under the water. they are holding on to hope that there may just be a miracle, that there may indeed be an air pocket they can find some survivors. >> this is going on around the clock? they are working, even diving at night under these conditions? >> reporter: they are diving at night. even under these conditions. the scary part is that they are not quite able to access the most dangerous parts of the ship because they are worried for their own safety. what they are use cigarette rope to go hand by hand underneath the water, inch by inch and they are going into the vessel. we have heard from the maritime
9:06 pm
police that they were able to get inside the vessel at 6:00 a.m. local time so they spent about three hours now underneath the water. i can see it very closely with my own eyes what they are doing is that when they find the bodies they bring them up, almost 90% of them are wearing life vests just like me, this is a standard life vest here in south korea and then they are brought to the surface and then brought back to shore. it's extraordinarily solemn and very, very difficult for them. >> a lot of these kids were wearing life vests they are still in their life vests when they were found. talk about the investigation. there were a number of develops over the weekend and on monday as well. >> reporter: when you listen to the radio transmissions, especially, there's a lot of confusion and there seems to be a lack of leadership. so that's what investigators are focusing on. a, did they have a plan. b, did they follow it. then why did the captain tell everyone to stay inside?
9:07 pm
why deissue the toward stay in their cabin? so there's a question of he in intelligence -- negligence. many people aboard this vessel tell us they heard a large boom. well it didn't hit anything. if you look at the topographical map there's nothing, no rocks that will just out and hit a vessel. they are looking whether the cargo was placed correctly and whether the ship was engineered and balanced appropriately for such a trip. anderson? >> i appreciate the reporting. thank you. more now with merchant marine captain jim staples, retired coast guard rescue instructor, mario vetoni. captain staples let me start with you. we still don't know what cause this ship to do what it did. you've been looking at the route.
9:08 pm
how complex of an area is this that it was operating in? >> well, we do know there's a lot more traffic where he was. that's one of the concerns you have as a captain. you want to keep your vessel out of the traffic. that's why they have the separation schemes outside of the islands, that's where you want to operate, that's where you should be operating. if this captain had a lot of local knowledge for the area it would be reasonable for him to be in that area. the thing i fine unreasonable is for him to leave somebody who is so inexperienced on the bridge by themselves. >> a third mate. >> in an area that's known for a lot of traffic. >> this is a very narrow area. >> it's about two miles wide. it is narrow when you're talking larger space especially when there's a larger traffic scheme that's just outside of that area. those are mandated by imo the way the vessels should be transiting. >> to keep receiveding away from one another? >> correct.
9:09 pm
>> the idea they were going too fast in a narrow area razes concerns >> it depends on the kent, which way he was going. he did have a lot of speed. that could be, okay, what if he was trying to compensate for the current. the concern is the inexperience of the third mate, heavy traffic area and her being alone. that's a concern. >> march jobs we know there was only one raft actually deployed of the 46 that were on board. that seems clear that they never actually staged for an evacuation. isn't that something that you would normally do or should do? >> i'm sure it's something they should have done and it probably is in their safety management system and procedures to do that and whether they made that decision at all is unclear. but they started the -- when they had them put their life jackets on there's no harm at all in acting like you're going to evacuate. that's one of the clear mistakes they made. the captain said the water was cold and where are the rescue
9:10 pm
boats. it doesn't cost him anything to have them stand on deck and be ready. >> to stand near the life rafts even if you won't get in them. >> that's it. to get to their muster stations and to stand by. if the ship wasn't in trouble the biggest inconvenience they were standing out in the cold. that's what should have happened first. >> it's very difficult question to ask and very delicate. knowing what you know and what we know now does it seem likely there could be survivors still at this point? >> you know, anderson, i don't think so, unfortunately. i sort of thought it was right around the three to four day mark and once you get past that probably not. in addition to what you're dealing with hypothermia, 50 degree water. the other troubling thing a lot of these people were in the cabins, let's say i'm in an air tight room 10 x 10, i'll have
9:11 pm
three days of oxygen. that's not the problem. carbon dioxide poisoning after a day and a half. if these divers are trying to utilize their time the best they can they are trying to look in the larger spaces and completely disregarding the cabins which, you will recall, is where a lot of the passengers were told to stay. >> such a nightmare to think about it. talking about the third mate, is it unusual to have an officer with less experience, you know, on the bridge at being the one in charge? >> no. usually you'll have a third mate standing in the 8 to 12. inexperience would demand how much captain should be there to supervisor mentor the officers. how to bring the younger generation up and do things right. you have somebody very inexperienced you want to make sure you're there and teaching them the right way to do things. the inexperience is something to be concerned about especially a captain going through a narrow
9:12 pm
area with a lot of traffic and a lot of current. something to be concerned about. >> was there any way to prevent this ship from sinking to the bottom? there was time -- do you think that was a mistake? >> last time we spoke friday they had these three large cranes on scene. they were on scene for several times. the time would have been better spent to utilize those cranes to maintain the ship where it was at. basically on the surface. stabilize it. and then can you continue the diving operations. now that the ship is on the bottom of the ocean, divers need go down to 160 plus feet just before they are able to start the search. you know, that said now they have to deal with even more impaired visibility because of the silt and sand. i don't understand the decision not utilize the cranes at an earlier time. >> they had up to 500 divers going down on this ship, all at once.
9:13 pm
how do you coordinate something like that? it's got to be a huge challenge. >> it's a massive operation, and certainly their supervisors are being very careful with their safety. that's a lot of divers on scene and they can get hurt as well. it's a very dangerous operation. i'm sure they have a plan. it's hard to take a guess what they are doing from this side of the world. certainly it's systematic and they have a plan. i would like to see them use the cranes first. i'm not there. i imagine there's a pretty good reason why they didn't pull that off. the thing about the water tight spaces in the area where they were on the ship the fourth and fifth deck where the cabins are these aren't mandated to be water tight spaces. this is another problem. if there was air, is it still there because the air is always trying to get out and these spaces up higher on ship are not necessarily as water tight as spaces in the engineering spaces. >> we got to go to a break. we're getting some new information.
9:14 pm
death toll has risen to 95. next more on this captain in particular and others who abandoned ship when so many others cannot and other officers did the opposite even paying with their lives. we'll talk about through and what it takes to do the right thing. soon there could be big changes in the search for malaysia airlines flight 370. more ahead. all we do is go out to dinner. that's it? i mean, he picks up the tab every time, which is great... he's using you. he probably has a citi thankyou card and gets 2x the points at restaurants. huh the citi thankyou preferred card. now earn 2x the points on dining out, with no annual fee. go to citi.com/thankyoucards i'm d-a-v-e and i have copd. i'm k-a-t-e and i have copd, but i don't want my breathing problems to get in the way my volunteering. that's why i asked my doctor about b-r-e-o. once-daily breo ellipta helps increase airflow from the lungs for a full 24 hours. and breo helps reduce symptom flare-ups that last several days
9:15 pm
and require oral steroids, antibiotics, or hospital stay. breo is not for asthma. breo contains a type of medicine that increases risk of death in people with asthma. it is not known if this risk is increased in copd. breo won't replace rescue inhalers for sudden copd symptoms and should not be used more than once a day. breo may increase your risk of pneumonia, thrush, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking breo. ask your doctor about b-r-e-o for copd. first prescription free at mybreo.com improving everything from booking to baggage claim. we're raising the bar on flying and tomorrow we'll raise it yet again.
9:16 pm
hot breakfast options. hampton, enjoy our free you did a great job. it looks good! then fuel up with up to 9,000 hhonors bonus points
9:17 pm
on a long weekend stay. make every stay more rewarding and feel the hamptonality. add vanishing deductible from nationwide insurance and get $100 off for every year of safe driving. we put members first. join the nation. ♪ nationwide is on your side >> welcome back. the death toll in the ferry accident in south korea rising to 95.
9:18 pm
a total of seven crew members including the ferry captain are facing charges. the captain for abandoning ship after causing to it capsize and sink. sadly there have been others like him in the past. and captains who have gone down in history to safe lives. and others who safe lives and go down with the ship. >> reporter: he's blamed for one of the worst maritime disasters of all time, but to some captain e.j. smith a hero. he turn in for the night aboard the "titanic" when his crew told him they hit an iceberg. april 1912 and the "titanic" was on its maiden voyage. when the ship stoortd sink off the coast of canada captain smith ordered the crew to prepare lifeboats. >> they gave an order for all passengers put on life preservers. >> reporter: captain smith ordered women and children be evacuated first. and helped save more than 700 people.
9:19 pm
he was on the bridge as the ship disappeared, lost among the 1500 people who perished. decades later in 1956 an italian vessel the andrea dompb ria collided with another ship off nantucket. the captain made a series of errors in dense fog and heavy traffic. yet when it began to sink the captain tried to make sure all the passengers and crew were evacuated. 46 people died. he wanted to go down with the ship and pay for his mistakes. but his officers talked him out of it. the captain was the last person off and never commanded another vessel again. the tale of another italian ship ended very differently. in 2012 when the "costa concordia" ran aground off the coast of italy 32 people died. the captain got off the ship with hundreds still on board. he says he fell and tripped into a lifeboat. listen as the coast guard ordered him to return to his
9:20 pm
ship. [ speaking italian ] >> reporter: the captain is currently on trial. among the charges he's facing, abandoning ship with passengers still on board, manslaughter and causing maritime disaster. we did some checking and found there isn't any international maritime law that says a captain must stay on a sinking ship. many countries like south korea have their own law or follow the safety of life at sea treaty adopted after the "titanic" sank. it doesn't require that a captain stay on board but it does say the captain is responsible for the vessel and his passengers. that same treaty also says passengers should be allowed to evacuate within 30 minutes. remember, the ferry took more than two hours to sink off of south korea. but the passengers were told to stay in place, a warning that may prove to have cost hundreds of lives.
9:21 pm
randy kay, cnn, new york. we're back again with captain james staples. in your mine, what are the obligations of a captain to oversee an evacuation. >> he's down by duty and honor. that's his responsibility to make sure that the passengers, the paying passengers are safe to get off that vessel. that's his duty. that's his training. that's his knowledge. that's what he's there for. >> is there an argument that some could make that well it would be easier to oversee the evacuation from off site from not being on the ship itself. >> i don't believe that's possible. you need to be there in command to understand what's going on. not only with the people getting off the vessel but what's happening with the vessel itself. >> i know you say it's 100% the captain's responsibility but not 100% his fault. can you explain that difference? >> we have to look what happened here. it may be a mechanical problem that happened with the vessel.
9:22 pm
maybe something going on with the sms, the safety management system, the training. we know there are some problems there. we understand he wasn't the permanent captain on this ship. fearing how many trips he made on this vessel, his knowledge of the area we need to look at that to see how much of a blame you can pinpoint. >> even if it's not 100% his fault for the incident, the aftermath of it it's his responsibility. >> it's his responsibility. >> he's the captain. >> he shoulders all the responsibility because he's the master. >> it's really -- i mean it's kind of harkens back to another time but i mean how much training does a captain of a ship have? is there a universal course of training? >> that depends. it took me about 12 to 13 years before i was sailing captain so i had quite a bit of training and the training was reinforced through the maritime institute where we go, every time we're off ship we go back to get some type of training to reinforce that. some of the training now is the
9:23 pm
simulator training, very similar to what airline pilot dose. they are regulated to be in flight simulators every nine months that they have to go in and go through training on flight simulators. there's no regulation right now in the maritime, so there's a good possibility that nobody sailing the ship has ever been in a simulator, depending on what nationality or what flag you fly under. something was not seen. it's a great thing to do. >> i appreciate you being here. thank you very much. honor and duty. we've been talking about a captain's duty to perform, to protect the people who trust him or her with their safety and ultimately their lives and if this particular captain failed to live up to that trust there's countless others who are filling a no leslie kraed responsibility. they are recovering bodies, boefds children risking their lives to bring them home.
9:24 pm
>> reporter: the first police boat returns from the search site. parents waiting. bracing. they return one by one in identical plain white bags. behind the screen initial inspection. a blanket to cover. a short march back to land. parents rush to the white tents to identify their children. you must have said daddy saves me weeps this father. no one is immune to the sound of losing a child. as the families leave the tents
9:25 pm
so too do the stretchers empty, returning to the gurneys that await the next boat. another group of someone's children, another march back to the tents. 13 return in this group, but more than 200 are still missing. gurneys on the left side of the dock, divers board ship to the right to continue the search. to bring the rest home. cnn, jindo, south korea. >> so much lost. we'll be right back. day, everyd. olive garden's signature favorites, just $10 including creamy fettuccine alfredo, and our classic lasagna. plus unlimited soup or salad and warm breadsticks. signature favorites, just $10 all week long, at olive garden. improving everything from booking to baggage claim.
9:26 pm
we're raising the bar on flying and tomorrow we'll raise it yet again. salesgets up to 795 highwayal is the passamiles per tank.sel salesperson #2: actually, we're throwing in a $1,000 fuel reward card. we've never done that. that's why there's never been a better time to buy a passat tdi clean diesel. husband: so it's like two deals in one? salesperson #2: exactly. avo: during the first ever volkswagen tdi clean diesel event, get a great deal on a passat tdi, that gets up to 795 highway miles per tank. and get a $1,000 fuel reward card. it's like two deals in one. hurry in and get a $1,000 fuel reward card and 0.9% apr for 60 months on tdi models. ...and let in the dog that woke the man who drove to the control room [ woman ] driverless mode engaged. find parking space. [ woman ] parking space found. [ male announcer ] ...that secured the data that directed the turbines that powered the farm that made the milk that went to the store that reminded the man to buy the milk that was poured by the girl who loved the cat. [ meows ]
9:27 pm
the internet of everything is changing everything. cisco. tomorrow starts here. the internet of everything is changing everything. [ female announcer ] some people like to pretend a flood could never happen to them. and that their homeowners insurance protects them. [ thunder crashes ] it doesn't. stop pretending. only flood insurance covers floods. ♪ visit floodsmart.gov/pretend to learn your risk.
9:28 pm
9:29 pm
we're at a critical moment in the search for flight 370. bluefin-21 drone could wrap up its work by mid-week. so far it has not found a trace of the aircraft. officials haven't said what the next step will be, if this first path of the narrow ship zone turns up nothing. search is now in it's 45th day and as many as 10 aircraft on 11 ships scoured the ocean today.
9:30 pm
beijing, chinese relatives of the relatives lashed at a diplomat when they were told that a briefing they were expecting today wouldn't happen. what do we know now about the search going on with the bluefin. it was in the water again today. it's about 8:30 in the morning now. >> reporter: yeah. it was in the water and they are saying it's being completed now. they haven't done the entire data dump but saying there are no contacts at this point but it will go back in the water sometime today. beforehand it was three quarters of the way done with this current search area. we'll find later on how much they've gotten through. >> the u.s. navy is saying they are preparing for a longer term search. do we know what a longer term search would look like if it comes to that? >> it's a very good question. the navy said it's beginning a conversation with everybody involved, all 26 nations it seems and talking about
9:31 pm
literally the months ahead. if they hit nothing in the next few days they will start talking about the months ahead up and through july. it may mean bringing in more auvs, supply ships back to refly, it may be just as much as going back to the drawing board and figuring out other places for the bluefin to search. right now everything is up for discussion and they are having a very serious broad discussion about what this search is going to look like going forward if they don't hit something this week it seems likely it will grow to a much larger broader search. >> thanks very much. i want to bring in the panel. joining me is richard quest, david gallo and mary schiavo, a former inspector general for the department of transportation that now represents families and victims of transportation accidents. richard you're over in kuala lumpur. these reports the malaysian government is issuing death certificates does that make sense?
9:32 pm
>> the difficulty is insurance payments need to be made out to various members of family. of course normally you can't make a payment until you have a death certificate and you can have a death certificate until you have either a court order or body. what they are doing in malaysia now the life assurance association of malaysia announced it will now start to consider making payments to relatives to next of kin even though there's no certainty of what's happened. that's really a reflection of the reality, anderson. that this search goes on for weeks, possibly many months more. not only do interim payments have to be made by malaysia airlines, any compensation is to be paid under the montreal convention but any insurance payments have to be made for life insurance and that will require either a change in law or a rewriting, a reunderstand
9:33 pm
reunderstanding of the law. >> if it turns up nothing then what? >> if they were thinking if you remember this was the bull's eye, i think it might be time to make the bull's eye a bit bigger and expand that area. >> would that mean bringing in more under water vehicles? >> possibly. i don't think they need to do it if they focus on this area. one or two others. if they look at other areas that are hundreds of miles away they need to bring in more vehicles. >> the malaysian government is asking families of the passengers to come up with a compensation package and present it to them. does that make sense to you? is it common for a government to ask families to do that? >> no it's not. the government usually sets up the structures and a parameters but here there was an airline with an insurance company.
9:34 pm
they have to present documentation like richard said they have to present death certificate, evidence of income and family members and who was related to whom. but usually they don't do that but the families need to, if they are going to be tasked with that they need to present a masterful plan. they need to demand a lot. >> richard there's a request from families to get independent analysis of the plane data. would an independent analysis would it be helpful at this point? what do you make of that? >> here's the list of questions, anderson that the families have provided or have asked for. there's some 26 questions. i'll give you and example. number 18, what is the statistical probability of the inmarsat calculations being accurate? is the elt within a froebtd compartment. lots of very, very detailed questions. for example, can malaysia government specific the rights
9:35 pm
of next of kin. what it is telling us is that as far as the next of kin is concerned, they really break down into several groups. those who still believe that there is hope of finding alive. those who want to know what their rights are moving forward. and those who also want to question the validity of the search areas. now, they match across each other in many ways. but the difficulty some would say unwillingness to provide information or answers to these questions has finally led malaysia to announce that the technical experts will be provided in beijing to answer some of they questions. >> mary, it surprises me. some of the questions that richard read out they are not -- i mean they are good questions and i would think those are questions that the families would have been able to get to answers to long ago. whether or not the elts were in
9:36 pm
water tight compartment, that is a perfectly good smart question to ask. it's kind of amazing to me that malaysian authorities have not provided those answers yet. >> yes. it's a mistake on the part of the malaysian authorities to realize, to fail to realize families need information, want information, they spend every waking hour researching it. you know, just pestering everyone and researching the world for answers and if they would give them tans or tell them we don't know this or go out the seek find answer, the elt questions are great. i can think of many more. when last did they change the batteries. what system monitored the elt. there's so many questions like that that are logical, sensible, really good questions for the investigation. the malaysian authorities would answer them i think they would find the investigation is furthered as is the relationship with families.
9:37 pm
but that's very typical for accident victim families, they research everything, they are very smart and they know much about the plane. >> david gallo, mary shaf jobs richard quest i appreciate you all being on. drilling down on how a teenager could have possibly climbed intoe a wheel well of a big jet and flown from california to hawaii. apparently happened yesterday. raises a lot of questions not the least of which how in the world can you get your body in there. how could you survive that kind of altitude and those kind of freezing temperatures. [ crickets chirping ] but did you know that the lack of saliva can also lead to tooth decay and bad breath? [ exhales deeply ] [ male announcer ] well there is biotene. specially formulated with moisturizers and lubricants, biotene can provide soothing relief and it helps keep your mouth healthy, too. [ applause ] biotene -- for people who suffer from dry mouth.
9:38 pm
everything looking good. ♪ velocity 1,200 feet per second. [ man #2 ] you're looking great to us, eagle. ♪ 2,000 feet. ♪ still looking very good. 1,400 feet. [ male announcer ] a funny thing happens when you shoot for the moon. ahh, that's affirmative. [ male announcer ] you get there. you're a go for landing, over. [ male announcer ] the all new cadillac cts, the 2014 motor trend car of the year. ...we'll be here at lifelock doing our thing: you do your connect to public wi-fi thing protecting you in ways your credit card company alone can't. get lifelock protection and live life free.
9:39 pm
add vanishing deductible from nationwide insurance and get $100 off for every year of safe driving. we put members first. join the nation. ♪ nationwide is on your side
9:40 pm
9:41 pm
breaking news. story of a california teenager who managed to expose serious airport security flew. tonight officials in san jose say they do not plan to pursue charges against him. the 16-year-old was found wandering the tarmac at the airport in maui dazed and confused after surviving a flight from san jose inside the landing gear wheel well of a boeing 767. a stow away who beat very grim
9:42 pm
odds. the plane reached an altitude of 38,000 feet. wheel wells are not pressurized and temperatures outside of the plane were as low as 75 to 85 degrees below zero. as unbelievable as all of this sounds, authorities says surveillance video shows the teen climbing over a fence at the san jose airport and approaching the jet. now before we get to how someone could possibly survive such an ordeal we'll tackle another question how hard is to it get inside a wheel well. >> reporter: anderson, this is southern california aviation airport in victorville, california in the desert where airlines all over the world bring their planes they are not using any more. we'll demonstrate how someone would get in a wheel well of an aircraft. this is a boeing 767 that used to be used. this is the door that's closed. there's a way to get in. here's how the process starts.
9:43 pm
someone who wanted to get in the wheel well gets on one of the two tires. step on the bars right here. climb to the top right here. this right here is where an opening would be to climb into the landing gear wheel well. once someone climbs through that hole they end up here. i'll show you what happens after they climb through the hole. again, in this area, this is the wheel well area. we're told there's only one place to sit where you could possibly survive because when the wheels move in the two huge wheels they come right here there's no room except for right here in this spot. this is where he would have to sit with knees close to you, two tires right here and this is the only place where you could possibly survive. nothing stupider in the world to do but this is where you can do it. >> people have died during this, in the past.
9:44 pm
the idea that this is something that people can do. this is just the strangest thing i've heard in a long time. this california teenager is not the first to try to do this. 147 have tried this. 25 have survived. how is point? dr. robert shany a professor at the university of washington medical school. i find this just hard to believe but i mean authorities don't seem to be doubting the essential story here between the cold and lack of oxygen, physically how is this possible? >> well, anderson, i'm having a hard time believing how it was done as well. if he actually made the flight in that wheel well, of course the atmospheric pressure, the temperatures are comparable to what they are outside. both of which one presumably should not survive. there's one hypothesis that as
9:45 pm
he ascend and the oxygen was so low he passed out but his body was cooling at the same time, his metabolism was dropping, his need for oxygen was dropping and we do this in medicine quite often, but the problem i have with that is that when he got off the plane he wasn't still extremely hypothermic. it doesn't quite all match. >> yeah. for all we know he was somewhere else in the aircraft. i don't think this has been proven yet. authorities don't seem to be, you know, at least publicly doubting the elements of the story and he was in san jose, he did end up in hawaii. are you talking about some sort of like hibernation state a body goes into? >> well, certainly that can happen, and mammals hibernate. most hibernate with normal body temperatures. there's some ground squirrels in the arctic who get their body temperatures just below freezing.
9:46 pm
humans don't do that. but company have drop his body temperature, as i said, and that drops his need for any or some oxygen and he was able to survive the lack of oxygen. i won, the brain-damage that we would have anticipated, the kidney failure, all the thing that could have happen, it's still a very strange story to me. >> anyone being at that altitude in an unpressurized environment, altitude is incredibly painful among many other things. if, again this, is true, could we have done irreparable damage to himself? >> absolutely. >> brain-damage? >> absolutely. yes. years ago on mount everest we made measurements of cognitive function of people who were climatized. the brain doesn't come back the same. we have somebody 30% higher than mount everest and no
9:47 pm
climatization and i can't believe his brain wasn't affected. i'm surprised he was conscious. >> again, i find this hard to believe he was actually in that wheel well the entire time. hopefully we'll know more in the next several days. i appreciate your expertise. thank you very much. >> thank you, anderson. coming up the running of the boston marathon. what an incredible day today. incredible moving day for so many. ks. go! it's chaos out there. but the m-class sees in your blind spot... pulls you back into your lane... even brakes all by itself. it's almost like it couldn't crash... even if it tried. the 2014 m-class. see your authorized dealer for exceptional offers through mercedes-benz financial services.
9:48 pm
♪ abe! get in! punch it! let quicken loans help you save your money. with a mortgage that's engineered to amaze! it's where you email, yshop, even bank.e here, but are you too comfortable? these days crime can happen in a few keystrokes. american express can help protect you
9:49 pm
with intelligent security that learns your spending patterns, and can alert you to an unusual charge instantly. so you can be a member of a more secure world. this is what membership is. this is what membership does.
9:50 pm
hot breakfast options. hampton, enjoy our free you did a great job. it looks good! then fuel up with up to 9,000 hhonors bonus points on a long weekend stay. make every stay more rewarding and feel the hamptonality. so, what'd you think of the house? did you see the school rating? oh, you're right. hey, babe, i got to go. bye, daddy. have a good day at school, okay? ♪ [ man ] but what about when my parents visit? okay. just love this one. it's next to a park. [ man ] i love it. i love it, too. here's your new house. ♪ daddy! [ male announcer ] you're not just looking for a house. you're looking for a place for your life to happen.
9:51 pm
zillow. new line she catches up with both women to see how the past year changed them and made them stronger. >> we first met erica last jam. she lost one name in the marathon bombing. the of learned badly broken. during that visit she asked us to find a woman she called a job. >> that is her right there. and then she is holding my hand right there. and then this is my right leg.
9:52 pm
she heard me screaming for help and she said my name is john and i am not going to let you go. and she stayed with me. >> after our story aired we found her, we now know is amanda. days later we reunited them in baltimore on rare erica had started rehab. >> my gosh. >> look at you. >> so glad we found you. >> i have thought about you every day. >> thank you. >> did not know how to get a hold of you. >> since that emotional reunion, they have stayed in touch through a busy year. >> is that okay? >> in october she got her prosthetic leg. enabling her to walk. something she was not sure she would never do again. >> i had a moment or the
9:53 pm
realization hit that my legs are never going to be the same as they were before. and i broke down. >> at time she has lain on amanda, who visited her last october, joining her at the baltimore marathon where erica was the starter. >> it felt like an old friend being here. she stayed with us. i painted her nails and it was like my and coming to visit. crazy how you can meet someone in such an unusual circumstance and not even know each other's names. but feel such a strong connection. >> another of us could sleep that night. so caught up in the emotion of seeing each other. >> the boast kept busy. she get to need two of her favorite teams, the baltimore ravens and the baltimore orioles, where she throughout the first pitch. amanda throughout the first pitch at her hometown baseball
9:54 pm
game, too. she is not want to be called a hero but if it weren't for her, erica might not have turned 30 this year. >> did you appreciate this birthday more than others? >> i definitely think i did because i almost wasn't here for it. and you never think that you might not see your next birthday. >> erica is most at ease in her classroom where her elementary students call it her super hero lead. >> what is different about me? what am i sitting in? >> wheelchair. >> after 18 surgeries, she is thrilled to be teaching again. >> they became my babies and my kids and they had a very big piece of my heart, it was hard to be away from them and it was like i was not completely full. >> a year later, she is now
9:55 pm
closer than ever to feeling full again and amanda is just a phone call away. randi kaye, cnn, baltimore. >> later tonight to see people that put their lives together, watch this cnn special report back to boston at 10:00 p.m. eastern here on cnn. we will be right back. deliciou! choose one option from the wood-fire grill, one signature shrimp dish, and a pasta like new lobster mac and cheese. three choices all on one plate. just $15.99. for a limited time only! you can build it any way that you like, pick your three favorite things. it is spectacular! i'm nathan tavernaris and i sea food differently. ♪
9:56 pm
led to the one jobhing you always wanted. at university of phoenix, we believe every education- not just ours- should be built around the career that you want. imagine that.
9:57 pm
9:58 pm
trwith secure wifie for your business. it also comes with public wifi for your customers. not so with internet from the phone company. i would email the phone company to inquire as to why they have shortchanged these customers. but that would require wifi. switch to comcast business internet and get two wifi networks included. comcast business built for business.
9:59 pm
u.s. analysts say massive strikes appear to be attacking operatives in yemen. killed dozens of members and al qaeda and a joint operation with the u.s. suspected u.s. strong strikes hit and al qaeda training camp in the mountains. the officials in the ukraine are proof russian forces are operating there. cnn showed what ukrainian officials said argument that looks similar to russian forces. the cnn cannot confirm. at least one company is canceling its climbing
10:00 pm
expeditions after 13 people were killed last week. it sends international sherpas there and it is not looking to profit. >> that does it for us, this special report is now. the following is a cnn special report. >> to me there's something inherently powerful of a still image. it's an image frozen in time. >> the images we'll always remember, of five days we can never forget. >> this was like the worst thing i've ever seen in my life. >> stories of a gravely wounded mother and daughter. >> i remember thinking, like, it's too much. i'm going to die. >> and a man instantly losing both legs. >> next thing you