Skip to main content

tv   CNN Newsroom  CNN  April 22, 2014 11:00am-1:01pm PDT

11:00 am
dow jones up at least today. that's it for me. thanks very much for watching. i'll be wack, a special two-hour "situation room" later today 5:00 p.m. eastern. newsroom with brooke baldwin newsroom with brooke baldwin starts right now. -- captions by vitac -- www.vitac.com sdplrkts great to be back here in the studio with you. i'm brooke baldwin. top of the hour, the death toll keeps ticking grimly upward divers bring bodies to the surface. a total of nine crew members are facing charges, including the ferry's captain. when asked about the ferry's lifeboats, crew members said it was hard to get them as the ship rolled over, and began to sink. that's what the crew says. today divers finally reached the ferry's cafeteria. because the ferry sank in the morning, many of those passengers onboard are believed to have been in that part of the ship. that's where they wanted to get to see if there were any
11:01 am
survivors. authorities are still calling this a search-and-rescue operation. although i have to point out, no survivors have been pulled from the frigid waters alive since right after the ferry went down last wednesday, and conditions for divers are worsening by the hour. >> translator: the conditions are so bad, my heart aches. we're going in thinking there may be survivors, when we have to come back with nothing, we can't even face the families. >> 121 people are confirmed dead. another 181 are still missing. and most of the bodies recovered, we're now told, were wearing life vests. now that we know, will, that these search teams have gotten into the ferry's cafeteria, what is next for them? >> reporter: well, sadly, brooke, it's horrible to say, but likely what we expect to happen now in the coming hours is to see more of these shifts
11:02 am
coming back to shore, bringing with them the people who were in that cafeteria, trapped in the cafeteria as the water was rising. so many of these young students were in there having breakfasts, visiting with their friends. likely looking forward to the class trip they were sailing out on, when all of a sudden things started to happen. they knew that something was wrong with the ship. we know that there were students in that cafeteria, brooke, who were making calls to emergency services before the ship even reported its official distress call. >> we have learned too well that the first emergency call came in actually not from a crew member onboard that ferry, but from a passenger. do we know who from? >> reporter: isn't that remarkable. yeah, 8:52 a.m. a voice described as a young boy, very shaken up, called, and he said, i think there's a problem with the ship. i think we're sinking. that was 8:52. three minutes before the official may day came from the
11:03 am
ferry. we know 20 of those calls were made by students on that ship. many of them frightened, scared about what was going to happen as the ship was going down. we know that most of the people who made those calls are now still on the list of the missing. which makes it so much more tragic. >> will ripley for us in south korea. will, thank you. a quick reminder at the top of next hour, i'll be talking to a woman with an absolutely stunning story. she's a mother, a wife, on the costa concordia, knows too well the notion of fighting rushing water, gravity, and fighting for her life. she thought she was going to die six times. her fury over what's happening with this ferry at the top of the next hour. now this. we are in a critical moment in search for flight 370 now. it may be time to actually go back to the drawing board. a tropical cyclone today forced authorities to suspend air searches over the indian ocean. but it's the search under the
11:04 am
surface that's really the chief concern right now. here it is, the u.s. navy's underwater drone, the bluefin-21. it is potentially hours away from wrapping up its search of the suspected crash site. and still, nothing. no trace of the missing jetliner. and now cnn has just learned exclusive new information coming out of australia here. officials are working out what those next steps of this investigation will be. let me lay out for you the key focuses of the three key areas. one, you have the handling of debris, who gets it, where does the debris stay. also, the care of human remains, if and when they are found. and then this one. potentially widening the search area, if the bluefin's final hours come up empty. all of this according to martin dolan, chief commissioner of the australian bureau.
11:05 am
fred, nice to have you on. and here i just have to ask in the final hours, potentially of this underwater drone, bluefin-21, how much confidence do you have in this piece of technology? in mapping the area? what is next? >> well, the bluefin-21 is a great, amazing piece of technology. we just have to remember there's a lot of other acoustic systems in play there trying to make that system work. you have not only the sonar, which we've seen operating in dramatizations of, but you also have these positioning systems. they almost act like taking the gps from the surface, and projecting that down and using acoustics to get through all those layers. and then figuring out where the bluefin is on the seabed. then there's other technology called basically acoustic modems
11:06 am
that allow the operators there to send virtually text messages, get status messages, send texts down to the vehicle. and get updates from the vehicle. but all of that technology is really used for something where you know -- you have an area where you believe is well defined. >> that's the thing. they think they have this area, but again, there has been no debris. this is based upon science and triangulation, that they think this is the area, but so far, i mean, i've lost track of how many days they've been looking for this plane. i think it's 47 now. they have the bluefin-21, and you're outlining all these pieces of technology, why not use more i guess is my question? >> well, there are different -- there are other technologies that can be brought to bear if the search area expands. some of these are deep towed
11:07 am
systems that can see out a much broader range. but it makes the coordination of efforts more difficult, if you have many of these systems operating in the same region. >> how do you mean? why? >> because of the various acoustics, like i said, the various acoustics. sonar signals put to play for each type of instrument. so the phoenix -- the people at phoenix international, they have their own deep sonar systems, but there's also the deep sur mer jens lab. the chinese have the deep tow sonar instruments. and all of these groups would have to coordinate, and stay far enough apart from each other to operate their systems without interfering with the other group. but also, then you have this tremendous amount of data that's going to be collected. and there's no real high-speed internet on these ships to coordinate it. it's much different than the
11:08 am
aircraft search, where the air crafts come in every day. and they can download their data, exchange it over the internet. when it comes to these ships gathering hundreds of megabytes of data an hour, somewhere that has to get coordinated where it can be brought to a central location and have somebody handle these efforts. the more people you get involved, although there's plenty of equipment out there, it just becomes a more challenging scenario. >> sounds like the challenges continue to mount. at least there are plans, and they're asking the questions, and again, the possibility of widening the search, really seems to be something they're exploring. how to deploy resources, including other search assets, the ones you just outlined. fred hegg, thank you so much. we'll watch as we get the new information on the hunt for this 777. coming up, the questions keep coming. how in the world did a teenager manage to hop an airport fence, climb up inside the wheel well of an airplane and survive a five-hour flight to hawaii.
11:09 am
remember, no oxygen in there. we'll discuss that. also ahead, vice president biden is in ukraine today, as pro-russian forces are defying any peace talks. what is next? we'll take you there live. later, the immense avalanche that killed 13 sherpas, the guides from the himalayas, helping people summit this beautiful mountain, after their death. now big questions about safety on that mountain. the climbing season, the best time to summit everest weeks away. will it go on? stay with me. you're watching special coverage here on cnn.
11:10 am
11:11 am
11:12 am
welcome back. i'm brooke baldwin. you know the teenage stowaway
11:13 am
who survived the overseas flight from california to hawaii, really defied death. it turns out the odds were not as severely stacked against him as you might have thought. here's the deal. the faa civil aerospace medical institute knows 105 cases of people trying to fly inside wheel wells goes back to 1947. of that number, 25 survived. and now the fbi says the 16-year-old boy is among them. he is with child welfare services, now in hawaii. officials have told his family in santa clara, california, that he is safe. dan simon joins me from santa clara. and dan, is he going to face charges? >> reporter: we don't think so, brooke. first of all, as you said, we're in the neighborhood where we believe this young man lives with his family. as you said, he's in protective -- in the custody of child protective services in maui. at some point they'll make arrangements to bring him to santa clara.
11:14 am
we're getting new details in terms of the timeline of all this. we're told by federal officials that the teenager, we're now told he's 15, by the way, he jumped the fence at the san jose airport approximately 1:00 a.m. sunday morning. the plane took off for maui approximately 8:00 in the morning. for a full seven hours, he's somewhere on the tarmac. is he in the wheel well the entire time? that, we don't know. in terms of possible charges, there's a whole laundry list of things that he could have faced. we're talking about trespassing. if he was charged as an adult, you could receive up to five years in prison for being a stowaway. but because he's a minor, and because authorities have discretion, in dealing with minors, they have made the decision not to charge him, because apparently he seemed -- he didn't have a motive to cause any ill intent here. that's what we're told at this point. >> dan, here's the obvious question. i know you're asking this as well. if we're now hearing this, this
11:15 am
15-year-old could have been somewhere, whether it's the tarmac or up in that wheel well for seven hours, he hops a fence, my question is, where were surveillance cameras? where was security? how did he pull this off? >> reporter: you know, that's the big question. we know that a surveillance camera did capture him hopping the fence, again, at 1:00 in the morning. we know there is a surveillance camera in maui, when he came off the airplane. so i think that's really the question, brooke. you hit it, the authorities are going to have to be looking at this very closely. are they going to have to bolster the perimeter, the fence line perimeter, not only at the san jose airport, but at airports across the country? where he apparently jumped the fence it's a bit flimsy, if you will. it apparently wasn't that difficult to do so. if there's a problem in san jose, chances are there's a problem at other airports across the country. that's something the fbi and tsa will have to look at closely.
11:16 am
>> yes, they will. we talk so much about a wheel well, you know what a wheel well looks like? we'll show you exactly how cramped a ride in a wheel well of a 767 can be. look at this for yourself. plus, the fbi told our hawaii tv affiliate kgnb, the stowaway was wearing just jeans, hoodie and sneakers, and carrying a comb. temperatures were as cold as 80 degrees below zero, and no oxygen, with altitudes as high as 38,000 feet. somehow this 15-year-old walked out of this wheel well on his own and officials say it was captured on airport surveillance video. >> he was weak. he hung from the wheel well. and then he fell to the ground and regained some strength and stood up and started walking to the front of the aircraft. >> senior medical correspondent, elizabeth cohen. when i hear he fell out of the
11:17 am
wheel well, it tells me he wasn't doing well in the wheel well of the plane. i don't care how old you are, how do you survive this? >> there's a chaps it might have been a little warmer. remember, he was in the wheel well, but he was in the plane. the plane is going to be a bit warmer. your body heat. all the machinery, the body, all of that. it is possible that it was warmer than that. but when you hear that, you think, to be 16 again, right? you can survive something like this. what happens is that when you aren't getting enough oxygen, yourimmedia metabolic processes down. when you're in that cold temperature, your metabolic processes slow down, so you actually need less oxygen. that may have helped him to be that cold. now you wonder, how did he regain consciousness? he probably lost kpgsness within a minute of being oxygen deprived. maybe he gradually got more oxygen in him with the slow
11:18 am
descent. maybe it was enough time to get the oxygen back in him. and he was able to walk. it really is -- i mean, stunning is really the only word to use. >> short-term, but wondering long-term here. we'll talk to a doctor next hour who knows a lot about this altitude and issues within the body. for now, thank you so much. it is stunning indeed. coming up, the families of those lost in the south korean ferry disaster, directing their anger, their frustration and grief at the captain and the crew of that ship. coming up, i'll talk to a retired coast guard officer that lessons can be learned from a tragedy like this. and what the captain of a ship really should do when it goes down. also ahead, vice president joe biden in ukraine today with tough talk for russia. we'll take you live to ukraine coming up. [ male announcer ] this is kevin.
11:19 am
to prove to you that aleve is the better choice for him, he's agreed to give it up. that's today? [ male announcer ] we'll be with him all day as he goes back to taking tylenol. i was okay, but after lunch my knee started to hurt again. and now i've got to take more pills. ♪ yup. another pill stop. can i get my aleve back yet? ♪ for my pain, i want my aleve. ♪ [ male announcer ] look for the easy-open red arthritis cap. [ female announcer ] f provokes lust. ♪ it elicits pride... incites envy...
11:20 am
♪ ...and unleashes wrath. ♪ temptation comes in many heart-pounding forms. but only one letter. "f". the performance marque from lexus.
11:21 am
11:22 am
breaking news from ukraine now. we're getting new information on some severely tortured bodies found in slavansk. arwa, what are you learning? >> reporter: these are two bodies that were fished out of the river, both seemingly bearing signs of torture. this happening over the weekend. one of those bodies now has been identified as being that of a local government official from a town not too far away from the city. his family identifying the body at the morgue earlier today. the second body that was found,
11:23 am
as of yet, still remains unidentified. these are, of course, incredibly disturbing developments as things continue to unravel, rather than de-escalate as many would have hoped after the geneva agreement. the acting president said he's going to relaunch anti-terrorism operations, saying the geneva agreement is off the table. this is because, as he says, an attack that took place yesterday in a city that saw pro-russian protesters, armed takeover one of the police buildings there. and also take the police chief into their custody. the situation here, brooke, as we've been saying, seeming to be unraveling rather than coming under more control to a resolution. >> arwa, so i'm crystal clear, because they're reporting what's happening with ukraine and russia for quite some time. we've reported on threats, we've reported on, you know, troops in and around the border. and within ukraine. but in terms of violence, this
11:24 am
is the first i'm hearing of tangible signs with the severely tortured bodies, is that correct? >> reporter: well, you do have that instance that took place with these two tortured bodies, and in listening to the reports that were coming out about them, it is chillingly reminiscent of the violence we saw taking place in iraq where unidentified mutilated bodies were regularly pulled out of the tigris river. but you also have the incident that took place a few nights ago where a pro-russian checkpoint was attacked. three pro-russian protesters manning that checkpoint were killed. their funerals took place earlier today. there have been a few instances of clashes, people being killed. but it most certainly seems when you look at all of this, with now this local politician's body being identified, with one of the police chiefs being taken into custody, the situation here does seem to be unraveling. despite all of the efforts, at least on the bigger political
11:25 am
level to try to bring about some resolution, on the ground, brooke, we're not seeing any of that materialize into anything concrete. >> unraveling, the appropriate word here, it sounds like in ukraine. arwa damon, live in donetsk, thank you. the adage here, other news, the adage said the captain should go down with the ship. what happens when he does not? the captain of the costa concordia faced a public shaming. what does the law say about this, when is it fair for a captain to abandon ship even when lives are at stake? a lot of questions people are asking after the south korean ferry disaster. cnn, back after this. [ male announcer ] this is jim. a man who doesn't stand still. but jim has afib, atrial fibrillation, an irregular heartbeat not caused by a heart valve problem. that puts jim at a greater risk of stroke. for years, jim's medicine tied him to a monthly trip to the clinic to get his blood tested. but now, with once-a-day xarelto jim's on the move.
11:26 am
jim's doctor recommended xarelto. like warfarin, xarelto is proven effective to reduce afib-related stroke risk. but xarelto is the first and only once-a-day prescription blood thinner for patients with afib not caused by a heart valve problem that doesn't require routine blood monitoring. so jim's not tied to that monitoring routine. [ gps ] proceed to the designated route. not today. [ male announcer ] for patients currently well managed on warfarin there is limited information on how xarelto and warfarin compare in reducing the risk of stroke. xarelto is just one pill a day taken with the evening meal. plus, with no known dietary restrictions, jim can eat the healthy foods he likes. do not stop taking xarelto, rivaroxaban, without talking to the doctor who prescribes it as this may increase the risk of having a stroke. get help right away if you develop any symptoms like bleeding, unusual bruising, or tingling. you may have a higher risk of bleeding if you take xarelto with aspirin products, nsaids, or blood thinners. talk to your doctor before taking xarelto
11:27 am
if you have abnormal bleeding. xarelto can cause bleeding, which can be serious and rarely may lead to death. you are likely to bruise more easily on xarelto and it may take longer for bleeding to stop. tell your doctors you are taking xarelto before any planned medical or dental procedures. before starting xarelto, tell your doctor about any conditions such as kidney, liver, or bleeding problems. xarelto is not for patients with artificial heart valves. jim changed his routine. ask your doctor about xarelto. once-a-day xarelto means no regular blood monitoring -- no known dietary restrictions. for more information and savings options, call 1-888-xarelto or visit goxarelto.com.
11:28 am
humans. we are beautifully imperfect creatures living in an imperfect world. that's why liberty mutual insurance has your back, offering exclusive products like optional better car replacement, where if your car is totaled, we give you the money to buy one a model year newer. call... and ask an insurance expert about all our benefits today, like our 24/7 support and service, because at liberty mutual insurance, we believe our customers do their best out there in the world, so we do everything we can to be there for them when they need us. plus, you could save hundreds when you switch, up to $423.
11:29 am
call... today. liberty mutual insurance -- responsibility. what's your policy? day seven now in the search for people onboard that capsized ferry in the frigid waters of the yellow sea. major developments this afternoon here. south korean rescue divers have finally made it into the ship's cafeteria. that was really important, because that's where they think many of the passengers, many of the young high school students were eating breakfast when that ferry began taking on all that water. they're also focusing on the third and fourth floors of the ferry where there are passenger cabins. might there be survivors in there. two buoys mark the spot where the ship sank, and dozens of rescue vessels are surrounding that site here. 121 people now confirmed dead. still 181 missing. and officials say most of the
11:30 am
bodies recovered were wearing life vests. also new today, the criminal investigation is growing, there are now more arrests to report. a total of nine crew members have been detained. four of them appearing in court today with heads bowed, faces covered, hats on. they're accused of causing deaths due to abandonment. tomorrow at the students' high school there will be a memorial for those who have died. but the ferry captain, his actions continue to be the focus of this investigation. he's not the first to be charged with abandoning his passengers here. the acclaimed hero of the "titanic" to the man at the helm of the costa concordia. >> reporter: he's blamed for the worst maritime accident of all-time. he turned in on the "titanic" when the crew told them they hit an iceberg.
11:31 am
it was april 1912. when the ship started to sink off the coast of canada, captain smith ordered the crew to prepare lifeboats. >> they gave an order, all passengers put on your life preservers, get up on the deck. >> reporter: captain smith ordered women and children be evacuated first. and helped save more than 700 people. he was on the bridge as the ship disappeared, lost among the 1,500 people who perished. decades later, in 1956, an italian vessel, the andrea doria, collided with another ship off nantucket. captain pierre had made a series of errors in dense fog and heavy traffic. yet when it began to sink, the captain tried to make sure all the passengers and crew were evacuated. 46 people died. he wanted to go down with the ship, and pay for his mistakes. but his officers talked him out of it. the captain was the last person
11:32 am
off, and never commanded another vessel again. the tale of another italian ship ended very differently. in 2012, when the costa concordia ran aground off the coast of italy, 32 people died. captain francesco got off the ship with hundreds still onboard. he says he fell and tripped into a lifeboat. listen as the coast guard ordered him to return to his ship. the captain is currently on trial. among the charges he's facing? abandoning ship with passengers still onboard, manslaughter, and causing maritime disaster. we did some checking and found there isn't any international maritime law that says a captain must stay on a sinking ship. many countries like south korea have their own law, a treaty adopted after the "titanic"
11:33 am
sank. it doesn't require a captain stay onboard, but it does say the captain is responsible for the vessel and his passengers. that same treaty also says passengers should be allowed to evacuate within 30 minutes. remember, the ferry took more than two hours to sink off south korea. but the passengers were told to stay in place. a warning that may prove to have cost hundreds of lives. randi kaye, cnn, new york. you just heard randi explain this, maritime experts say when captain lee jumped the sinking ship, he reneged op his key duties. how serious is the conduct that the captain go down with the ship? here's to help us is james loy. admiral, welcome. >> thank you, brooke. >> we heard from randi. she really spelled it out. our correspondent saying there is no international maritime law mandating a captain go down with his or her ship, though, of course, they have responsibilities.
11:34 am
what are those responsibilities? >> well, fundamentally, i think the -- it comes down to a couple few words. the captain is responsible for the safe navigation of the ship. he's responsible for the safe passage of the crew and passengers. even the cargo onboard. so there's nothing in the law that says the captain has to be the last one off, or go down with the ship certainly. in fact, we would like to think all the captains can survive these passengers as can their passengers and crew. but the ultimate nature of the responsibility of a captain at sea on a ship is such that his responsibilities are the first things he has to take care of, responsibility for. >> within the maritime community, i'm curious if it's unwritten law, or unwritten protocol, that the captain if something horrendous like this happens, the captain just stays onboard? >> the captain, as i say, is responsible for the safe passage of the crew. so when that crisis occurs, he
11:35 am
or she ought to be the last around, so to speak, still directing traffic, if you will, giving the orders, providing the direction to the crew, in that nightmare circumstance that they're dealing with. the bottom line here is, this is as much about preparation on the front end as it is about execution on the back end. >> let me jump in on that. that's a perfect segway. i want to quote you from your opinion piece. this is what you write, sir, collision or grounding or fire at sea is the immediate private hell on earth for a ship's captain and crew. their actions must be based on their preparation. but it makes you wonder here, sir, if this captain were prepared, yet compare that to the -- i don't know if you've seen this, this actual captain from this south korean ferry, he was in a promotion at video for this very company promoting safety. what does that sound like to you? >> well, rhetoric is cheap. and behavior counts.
11:36 am
at the other end of the day, the behavior in this instance, at least until the thorough investigations, which i'm certain will follow, we're still sort of in the phase where we're most focused on the tragedy, and the lives of these folks that we perhaps can still save. but at the other end of the day, the long phase is going to be a very thor i investigatory aftermath that will bring to light the sequence that was taken through the course of these very difficult days and hours. and the captain's responsibility certainly cannot be met when he's among the first that jumps into the lifeboat and floating safely away while his ship is sinking. >> mr. loy, i'm curious, my final question to you, reading more about maritime law when it comes to accidents at sea, correct me if i'm wrong, but there is no universal maritime law, south korea can do their thing, italy can do another, the united states can do another. do you think that these laws or protocols, et cetera, should be
11:37 am
ubiquitous? >> ubiquitous is a good goal. that's what the safety of life at sea is convention. which in fact is international in scope. all the members that are -- all the member countries to the international maritime organization, which is a subset of the united nations, do sign up for dealing with these things constructively when they occur. but again, i go back to the point where you prevent them from happening by focusing on competence and capability within your crew, and you also practice and train and exercise for these kind of eventualities, so when they do occur, you're able to prosecute your responsibilities according to both traditions of life at sea and, of course, the safety at sea, international law. >> rhetoric is one thing, behavior is another. retired admiral james loy, thank you so much. i encourage all of you to check out his opinion piece on cnn.com, it's called a captain
11:38 am
faces a private hell in sea disaster. thank you so much, sir. every year people pay tens of thousands of dollars to climb mount everest. maybe it's on your bucket list. i'd love to go to nepal. but this year, the sherpas are furious, and those trips are all potentially in jeopardy. we'll explain what that means for summiting mount everest. and later, when a ship capsizes, as we were just discussing, sometimes it's every man, woman and child for himself. you'll hear a stunning story from a woman who survived the costa concordia wreck. she said her family almost died six times. do not miss her story, the top of the next hour. what if a photo were more than a memory? what if it were more than something to share? what if a photo could build that shelf you've always wanted? or fix a leaky faucet? or even give you your saturday back? the new snapfix app revolutionizes local service.
11:39 am
just snap a photo and angie's list coordinates a top-rated provider to do the work on your schedule. the app makes it easy. the power of angie's list makes it work. download snapfix for free.
11:40 am
11:41 am
i'm taking off, but, uh, don't worry. i'm gonna leave the tv on for you. and if anything happens, don't forget about the new xfinity my account app. you can troubleshoot technical issues here. if you make an appointment, you can check out the status here. you can pay the bill, too. but don't worry about that right now. okay. how do i look? ♪ thanks. [ male announcer ] troubleshoot, manage appointments, and bill pay from your phone. introducing the xfinity my account app. hundreds of climbers tried to summit mount everest each and every year. but the short climbing season is
11:42 am
in jeopardy here, because 13 sherpas, these guides who are from the himalayas, they know this mountain, they were killed, and three are still missing after friday's avalanche. this is now, the single deadliest accident on the world's tallest mountains. now the sherpa community is threatening to strike. for more on this, here is cnn's emra walker. >> reporter: kathmandu, families of the sherpas killed in friday's avalanche on mount everest mourn the loss of their loved ones. the bodies of 13 local sherpa guides have been pulled from the snow. three sherpas still are missing. the avalanche was the single deadliest accident in the mountain's history. >> i believe that this is going to have great effect on the families. they've lost their bread winners, their husbands, their fathers, their sons. and it's going to have very
11:43 am
serious effect in the community as well as in the families. great loss for everyone. >> reporter: just days away from the start of the busiest climbing season, u.s.-based alpine international who lost five sherpas in the accident has canceled its expedition. the discovery channel planned a live broadcast at the first winged jumpsuit flight off everest. that's also canceled. now, it's unclear if anyone will scale the world's highest peak this year. some sherpas are calling for the mountain to be closed in respect for the dead. others are threatening a boycott to protest poor pay. >> translator: at the moment, the view of all sherpas is we should mourn for everest. some climbers will be too afraid to continue their ascents. >> translator: some are of the opinion we should return to work. others will feel compelled to return, mainly for the money, because they don't have any other employment. >> reporter: sherpa guides can make up to $6,000 a year.
11:44 am
while nepal's government stands to make about $3 million in royalties if and when climbing resumes. those who want to make the ascent now have to decide if the risk is worth the reward. now, before today, many of the sherpas had been in talks with nepal's government. they also want a welfare fund for sherpas who are hurt or killed climbing. they're also asking that the government enact a law that would keep them safer on the mountain. the government had agreed to some of their demands. there's no official word that it appears the sherpas are abandoning those talks at this point. now the more than 300 foreign climbers who planned to climb everest in the coming weeks, they may be out of luck. >> let's talk about the sherpas specifically. one of those points is, of course, about pay. how much do sherpas make now, what are they asking for? >> brooke, keep in mind, this is an extremely strenuous job. they're going before the foreign
11:45 am
climbers, laying out the path for them. it's also very dangerous. they're risking their lives every day. the sherpa guides make up to $6,000 per season, which runs from april to about june. that sounds like a lot when you compare it to the average citizen in nepal who makes about $700 a year. compare the in understand to what the government is making in royalties, about $3 million a season. it doesn't sound like very much. and we should also keep in mind for a lot of these sherpas, they are the sole bread winners. it's not just about money, but also about their safety. >> i know some of these really experienced hikers who have been up with the sherpas, they say that a lot of that money doesn't actually go back to the mountain. thank you so much. >> sure. >> we'll stay on this story. what if the sherpas stand firm and they go on strike, and people can't climb, and summit everest this season. i'll talk to a guest coming up here who said a trip to everest is much more about reaching the
11:46 am
summit. he will explain. imagine everything being turned upside down here, onboard a ship like this. when a cruise or ferry begins to capsize, it is any passenger's worst fear. ahead, you will hear straight from someone who barely survived that experience on the costa concordia. not only does her heart ache for these families with loved ones on that ferry, she is furious. don't miss that.
11:47 am
why relocating manufacturingpany to upstate new york? i tell people it's for the climate. the conditions in new york state are great for business. new york is ranked #2 in the nation for new private sector job creation. and now it's even better because they've introduced startup new york - dozens of tax-free zones where businesses pay no taxes for ten years. you'll get a warm welcome in the new new york. see if your business qualifies at startupny.com
11:48 am
11:49 am
(music) defiance is in our bones. defiance never grows old. citracal maximum. calcium citrate plus d.
11:50 am
essential if you're planning to climb mount everest, that the sherpa guides carry gear, cook food, pave the way up to the peak, make sure it's safe before you even make this trek. after last week's deadly avalanc avalanche, they are threatening to strike. on the phone from lar my wyoming, mark jenkins, a contributing writer to national geographic and been on dozens of climbing expeditions around the world. you've been to everest twice, summited it once. thank you for calling in. i read your piece in national geographic today, and how the sherpas are already having immediate repercussions on the business of climbing the world's highest peaks. what are the repercussions already? >> well, the sherpas have presented a 13-point kind of manifesto to the ministry of tourism in nepal. that's the ministry that
11:51 am
actually organizes and executes everything that happens around the everest region. the 13 points included more compensation if someone dies on an everest expedition. it also included more money if somebody's injured and also more compensation if someone's disabled permanently. the nepali government has responded quite quickly, to their credit. they didn't give the sherpa manifesto everything that was asked for. but they did increase the pay benefit from $10,000 to $15,000 for those who die. they agreed to build a memorial for these recent deaths. they agreed to raise the medical insurance for those people who are injured but can't return to work. >> what's your sense? there was a piece, john crocker wrote this piece in the "new yorker" where the sherpas are really the heart of the mountain, and they've not really been respected financially. and now you're mentioning sort of the responses of the
11:52 am
13-point, you know, manifesto and plan. do you think that the strike will happen now? >> i think we're going to see that choice made by individual sherpas. i don't think there's a lot of pressure for people to leave, nor is there a lot of pressure for people to stay at base camp. some of these sherpas, they want to work. it's not as if they're dragooned onto the mountain. typically sherpa makes about $5,000 or $6,000 in two months. it's very dangerous work. it's very difficult work. although the average income in nepal is about $700 a year. so in their own economy, they're well paid. but they also take enormous risks. i think what you'll see on everest is some of them will decide, this isn't worth it. my friends have died recently, perhaps some of them lost family members. it's a very close-knit community in the sherpa region. some of them will say, no, i've got to stay here because i want to make the money.
11:53 am
>> what about, too, this point -- so the issue with the sherpas, i would love your perspective on this conrad anchor that you quoted in your piece last week. three-time everest summiteer. he described it to you, bloated dysfunctional bureaucracy. he said that less than 1% of the $3 million in permit fees collected each year go back to the mountain. is that true? >> i think conrad knows what he's talking about. he spent a lot of time in the himalayas. he's running the kimbut climbing school, which is trying to train sherpas so they're better prepared to lead and guide on everest. i don't know if we know the exact number. but every mountain climber who wants to attempt everest from the nepal side pays the government $10,000. that's a peak fee. if you've got 300 climbers, you've got $3 million. but very little of this can you see an evidence at base camp or up higher on the mountain.
11:54 am
it's hard to see where that money paid to the government actually goes. not enough of it goes back to compensating sherpas' families, if one of the climbers has died. and certainly not enough goes back to sustaining the environment around everest. >> mark jenkins, shedding light writing for national geographic on the issues plaguing this beautiful mountain. mark, thank you so much for calling in. and not many people know, moving on, not many people know the passengers experiencing this terror onboard this south korean ferry. ahead, though, hear from a woman who knows all too well. she barely survived that wreck on the costa concordia. and when she hears about the ferry, she is furious. her personal story here of surviv survival, ahead. i dbefore i dosearch any projects on my home. i love my contractor, and i am so thankful to angie's list for bringing us together. find out why more than two million members
11:55 am
count on angie's list. angie's list -- reviews you can trust.
11:56 am
add vanishing deductible from nationwide insurance and get $100 off for every year of safe driving. we put members first. join the nation. ♪ nationwide is on your side
11:57 am
11:58 am
authorities in yemen are today beginning to acknowledge they may have a huge prize after reaching operations against al qaeda. they are now as we were initially reporting yesterday carrying out those dna tests to determine if this man is among the dead from that drone strike. his name, ibrahim squr, the bombmaker possibly responsible for making those underwear bombs. remember those used in detroit in 2009 on that plane, among other bombs? joining me now, we know this man has been in hiding for quite a while. this would be huge if they got him. >> yeah, no two ways about it, brooke. it would be absolutely massive. ibrahim is perhaps the most wanted man in yemen. the most high-value target in that country. which is full of high-value aqap targets. you look at the list of plots
11:59 am
that have been hatched in yemen the past few years that have had such an impact in the region and around the world. like you mentioned, the underwear bombing plot, or the cartridge bomb plot, or even the plot to assassinate the interior minister of saudi arabia. all of those plots have ibrahim's fingerprints all over them. if he were to have been killed, that would be huge for yemen's government, for america's counterterrorism efforts. that all being said, though, even though yemeni officials i'm speaking with today are more confident and questioning publicly that perhaps they did get him, it's still going to take some time to really make sure that these dna tests are thorough, and that this is the guy. what we know now is that there was a fire fight that ensued a couple of nights ago and that they got some militants. some of them are saudi. they believe they were high targets. they believe perhaps they've got him and now they're trying to confirm it for re.
12:00 pm
>> mohammed, thank you. top of the hour, hour two, i'm brooke baldwin. we begin with this. a potential massive break for the search teams off the coast of south korea, the site of the capsized ferry. rescue divers have now finally entered the ferry's cafeteria. and this big news simply because they believe many of the passengers were eating breakfast at the time the ship began to list. the bittersweet, the tragedy is the fact that the possibility of survivors is growing increasingly grim. investigators believe this is where a lot of those -- remember, a lot of high school students and teachers were when the ferry started to tip over. also new today, we know that the criminal investigation is growing. two more arrests here in this case. so that brings the total number of crew members detained to nine, including the captain. four of them appearing in court today. the man in the middle of your
12:01 pm
screen, face covered, hat town. many of them not wanting to show their faces. they're accused of causing death due to abandonment. and tomorrow, i can tell you this, that the students' high school will be holding a memorial for the victims. the latest numbers we have now, 121 bodies have been found. 181 are still missing. joining me by phone from jindo, south korea, is our correspondent there on the ground, will ripley. so, will, now that we know the divers have finally gotten into this cafeteria section of this boat, what happens next? >> reporter: well, sadly, brooke, we're afraid what will be happening next is what we're watching right now. i want to roll for you some video we just sent in a few minutes ago. these are coast guard ships that we're seeing come back to shore. we saw at least two bodies wrapped in white cloths, loaded onto ambulances, which then turned their lights on but stayed silent as they drove
12:02 pm
slowly through the tents where the bodies are identified. there's a man who speaks into a microphone and describes the gender, what the person's wearing. he gives as detailed a description as possible to families, which still at 4:00 in the morning here at jindo, are anxiously awaiting for word if their loved ones are among those who are being brought back. so it's just really a heartbreaking scene unfolding here, one that we expect will be repeated in the coming hours and days, now that the divers are in the cafeteria where there were so many young people have breakfast, as you said. >> as the death toll then will likely continue to rise, we also are learning, will, about the phone calls, the distress call made from the ferry, initially not coming from the captain, correct, but from one of the students? >> reporter: a young boy described by the government, telling us that the first call came at 8:52 a.m. a boy whose voice sounded very
12:03 pm
shaken, saying something has happened on the ferry. we think it's sinking. there were actually 20 calls made by students, frightened students on that ferry. the first call, the time 8:52 a.m. is three full minutes before the call from the ferry's crew. why the delay, why were students able to call from their phones minutes before there was actually an official call made that there was trouble on this ferry. brooke, i have to say, i'm looking out over at the search area right now, every few minutes they fire up these flares to illuminate the area. there are hundreds of divers out there that have been working tirelessly around the clock, going down to the area, risking their lives in dangerous conditions searching for survivors. to sit here and look out there, and see those flares, and know what is happening, after having been out there myself, it's a quiet grief. it's a feeling that we can feel here as observers, and certainly that these families are feeling
12:04 pm
here right now. >> beyond gut-wrenching. will, thank you so much. keep pressing for answers. and when hearing about this ferry tragedy, another maritime disaster immediately comes to mind, 32 lives lost when the costa concordia cruiseliner crashed into a reef off the coast of italy. this was back in january of 2012. witnesses said the captain jumped into a lifeboat to get away, to safety, even though hundreds of passengers were still onboard the cruise. francesco is right now on trial for charges of manslaughter. he still maintains he did nothing wrong. joining me now from los angeles, georgia and her family survived that costa concordia disaster. she has also written, co-written this book "s.o.s.: spirit of survival." georgia, welcome. >> thank you. >> i would like to just begin, i
12:05 pm
know that you -- your heart aches. i read that your heart absolutely aches. all of our hearts, of course, ache for the families with loved ones on that ferry. you are angry as well. tell me why. >> i'm angry, because this is what happened when on the costa concordia, when this happened, i was hoping the world would stand up and we would make changes so that something like this would never happen again. we have been fighting for that for two years. we have been working hard. but people around the world need to take a look at this. this is what we didn't want to happen. this should never have happened in korea. should never have happened on the costa concordia, but it did, and we didn't learn from our mistakes. we have to make change. >> just to your personal story, it was night number one of what was supposed to be this month -- long vacation for your family. you feel this -- i don't know if you said it was a thud, or something larger than that. but describe the immediate --
12:06 pm
your word was pandemonium. >> absolutely. the first minute that it happened, everything just started to shake like a mini earthquake. and then all of a sudden people just started screaming, and things started falling from the -- it was a two-story dining area, so everything from the top was falling below to everything. people were trampling each other. that was in the first minute and a half of the disaster. >> how do you know where to go? how do you know where to crawl? i imagine it's dark. you're avoiding, as you mentioned, things falling from the ceiling, and falling glass? how do you -- >> you know what, the minute-by-minute project, for us it was five and a half hours of that, and we just -- we had a lot of experience being on cruise ships. so we were able to try to think together. we stayed as a group. there were four of us in the family. we stayed together as a group. we made decisions just split-second decisions. you had split-second decisions in the final part of our journey
12:07 pm
where we had to jump into a moving lifeboat. we said, we can stay on this ship, sink with the ship, or we can jump for our lives. we jumped 20 feet into a moving lifeboat. you do what you think you can never do in life. >> describe that moment when you decide to jump. >> it was -- because it was four of us, my one daughter went first. and when she jumped, she landed on the roof. to watch your own daughter try to leap for her life is just treacherous as a mom. and then i was next. and i ended up on the top of the lifeboat. how i got there, i don't even understand. you do what you have to do to survive. i feel so badly for the children that were there. because i'm an educator, a former principal, and to see that the kids went on a field trip and they didn't have the knowledge you had. they were told, again, like the costa concordia, they were told, they were given false information, and that could have prevented them from surviving. >> we have heard that the
12:08 pm
speaker system from that ferry saying, don't move. and many of them didn't defy that, and they didn't move, and many of them are now being found with life vests on. and they chose to not move and follow direction. we also know about a lot of text messages back and forth from these young people, a lot of them only children, to parents are who are clearly grieving now. messages from students saying, i love you. messages from students accepting the inevitable. at one point you accepted your own death. >> yes. we absolutely did. we knew it. my husband was a former vietnam veteran in the navy. and he turned to us, and finally he said to us, this is it. it's over for us. and at that point, we just started praying, and crying. we said our good-byes to people at home, even tried our cell phones. there are so many similarities in what happened on that ferry, and what happened on the costa
12:09 pm
concordia. we tried desperately to use our cell phones. but other passengers actually notified the coast guard before the captain and the bridge notified them. on the costa concordia. people were told, go back to your cabin. the worst thing they could do. they knew tons of water was coming in on this vessel. yet they told them to go back. those people died. we have not learned. >> that's what i want to get back to. my final question to you, in terms of mistakes made, in terms of the lack of changes, in terms of maritime law, and what you're fighting for. what is change number one in your opinion? >> first of all, we've got to hire competent people on these vessels. there has to be cross-training. there has to be more regulatory -- a regulatory agency around the world for these vessels. everybody has different laws and different rules, and we need competent people, we need a
12:10 pm
regulatory agency that can monitor that, we need to put passengers' safety at the forefront. and we need to do it now. it's already too late. we've lost too many people. >> sounds like common sense. apparently it's not. georgia, thank you so much. your book "s.o.s.," thank you. >> thank you. the 47th day, the bluefin underwater drone has fewer than 15% of the search area left to survey. what if when it's finished it brings up nothing? we will tell you what's next according to the research leaders today. also ahead, that teenager, 15 years old, hid in the wheel well on that plane from hawaii -- from california to hawaii. he's safe. what happens to him long-term, though? the fact of losing consciousness, brain issues, organs. get all your favorites all day, everyday.
12:11 pm
olive garden's signature favorites, just $10 including creamy fettuccine alfredo, and our classic lasagna. plus unlimited soup or salad and warm breadsticks. signature favorites, just $10 all week long, at olive garden.
12:12 pm
12:13 pm
12:14 pm
welcome back. i'm brooke baldwin here. time is running out in the search to find this missing flight 370. you have the cyclone barreling down in the indian ocean. and then the bluefin-21 hours away from completing its week-long scan of the narrow search zone. if the u.s. navy's underwater drone comes up empty in the final mission, where do they go from here? well, australia is hammering out the details of a plan, a framework first put forward by malaysia. cnn has just learned some of the details of that. joining me with the said details, live from perth, 3:14
12:15 pm
your time, miguel. talk to me about the plan. it's early, we appreciate you. the three areas of focus set to be finalized next week. talk me through those. >> reporter: yeah, look, two things are happening at the same time. one, they're making plans if that search does not turn up anything this week. they're also still believing they're in the right area, that they will find something eventually, looking forward to the possibility that there will be the debris of the plane and the remains. the malaysians have put forward a plan that the australians are now considering. all the entities taking part will have to consider it at some point, regarding how the debris will be treated, how it will be mapped, where it will go, where it will be processed. same thing for the remains. those are the victims that they can bring up eventually from flight 370, where those will be processed and identified and how they will be handled. i can tell you we've talked to several of the -- almost every
12:16 pm
forensic pathologist across the country in recent days, and all of them believe that they will be at some point involved in the identification and the processing of those remains. the other piece of this is something the u.s. navy is also talking about, which is, if bluefin-21 does not come up with anything this week, in this most promised area, where the strongest ping was heard back on april 8th, then they will have to go to a wider plan. they will probably reset the search. they will look either for a different area to search for the bluefin or go to different technologies, whether it's a towed locator that will take a bigger picture of the ocean floor, or in the case of flight 447, the airfrance flight that went down over the atlantic, they have simultaneous and multiple autonomous underwater vehicles trying to locate this plane. >> sounds like pretty soon we should know whether any of this changes as far as expanding the search, throwing more resources at this, et cetera. we watch and we wait.
12:17 pm
miguel marquez in australia, thank you. and barely enough oxygen to breathe. and cold, that would leave you frozen. how could someone survive that for hours and hours after smuggling themselves into the wheel well of a plane? we'll ask. and malaysia airlines could face a wave of lawsuits over the disappearance of flight 370. but the partner of one passenger has a personal message for the government. one you have to hear.
12:18 pm
at farmers, we make you smarter about auto insurance, because the more you know, the more we can help you. cut. lower. shave. chop. and drop your insurance rates. if you want to save hundreds, talk to farmers. ♪ we are farmers bum - pa - dum, bum - bum - bum - bum ♪ [announcer] the more you know, the more you could save. farmers could help you save hundreds on your auto insurance. call your local agent or 1-800-470-8496 today.
12:19 pm
12:20 pm
here's what we now know. no criminal charges for the teenager, all experts agree shouldn't be alive. the 15-year-old boy sneaking into the wheel well of a flight that flew 2,300 miles from san jose, california, to maui. he defied death and the odds and
12:21 pm
security at the mineta san jose airport. the stowaway had plenty of time to find his hiding place. a federal official tells us he jumped the airport fence at 1:00 sunday morning. the jet didn't even take off until seven hours later. reportedly the stowaway went for the first plane he saw. gary tuchman shows us what climbing into the landing gear of the boeing 767 really looks like. gary? >> reporter: this is southern california aviation airport in victorville, california, in the desert, where airlines all over the world bring their planes they're not using anymore. we're going to demonstrate to you how someone would get in a wheel well of an aircraft. this is a boeing 767. this is the door that is closed. but there is a way to sneak in a hole to get into the wheel well. we'll show you how the process would start according to experts here. you would get on one of the two tires. step on the bars right here. climb all the way to the top
12:22 pm
right here. and this right here is where an opening would be to climb into the landing gear wheel well. once they climb through that hole, they would end up here. i'm going to show you what happens after they climb through the hole. they get in this area. this is the wheel well area. and we're told there's only one place to sit, where you could possibly survive, because when the wheels move in, the two huge wheels, there's no room except for right here in this spot. and this is where they say you would have to sit with your knees close to you. the wheel well would close. this is the only place you could possibly survive. there's nothing stupider in the world to do, but this is where you can do it. >> are you kidding me? let me pick my jaw off the floor after that, gary tuchman. thank you for that. he did this for how many hours? this stowaway, this 15-year-old
12:23 pm
basically had no room to move, no oxygen to breathe, no buffer from the sub-zero temperatures at 38,000 feet in the air. and yet, we are told, surveillance video shows this 15-year-old emerging from the wheel well weak, but on his own two feet. >> he was weak. he hung from the wheel well, and then he fell to the ground and regained some strength and stood up and started walking to the front of the aircraft. >> okay. dr. peter, executive director of the institute for altitude medicine is on the phone with me now. that hit home. seeing our correspondent trying to climb into a wheel well, here's my first question to you. i know the surveillance exists of this kid hopping the fence, some 105 known cases of people stowing away. 25 survive. what is your, for lack of a better phrase, your spiny sense tell you about this? do you believe this happened? >> well, it seems to be well
12:24 pm
documented. so if we assume it did happen, the only way that he could have survived is if there was a drop in his temperature, his core temperature, blood temperature, so that his brain cooled enough that he could tolerate those extremely low oxygen levels. >> so i'm clear, i mean, he was exposed to all of the elements for this whole flight, from san jose to hawaii. >> yes. he was exposed to extremely low oxygen levels, because the wheel well isn't pressurized like the cabin is. and there may have been some heat being transferred through the aluminum from the cargo hold into the wheel well, so that it wasn't quite as frigid as the outside air temperature. but there would not have been any air, pressurized air transferred across there, of course. so he definitely suffered lack of oxygen, which undoubtedly caused him to go unconscious
12:25 pm
fairly quickly. and then the only way he could have survived that is if he cooled quickly, and therefore, his brain didn't need as much oxygen. >> hmm. we heard, yes, he was weak, but he was walking on his own two feet. he appears to be okay. i'm wondering long term, what about the invisible issues? what about his organs? what about long-term brain damage? possibility, or no? >> yes, it's a possibility. you're exactly right, it's the brain that is the organ to be concerned about. and he may have come away unscathed, like some people with cold-water drowning or climbers on everest without oxygen. he may have come away unscathed, but he may have suffered minor brain damage as well. but only time will tell. >> final question, if you had this kid in front of you, what would be your question to him? >> i would ask him if he ever
12:26 pm
thought he'd like to do that again. >> let's hope not. dr. peter hackett, thank you so much for joining me. i appreciate it. it is absolutely stunning this young man has survived. coming up, could the captain of the south korean ferry actually face murder charges? we'll talk to an expert of maritime law. what kind of charges the captain and crew could ultimately face after this tragedy.
12:27 pm
(music) defiance is in our bones. defiance never grows old. citracal maximum. calcium citrate plus d. highly soluble, easily absorbed.
12:28 pm
12:29 pm
12:30 pm
bottom of the hour. with talk about the rescue mission for the capsized ferry in the frigid waters of the yellow sea, it is now honing in on the ship's cafeteria. that is where the rescue divers believe many of the passengers were gathered when that ferry started to sink. the death toll stands at 121. it is expected to dramatically rise. here is cnn's nic robertson reporting from jindo, south korea. >> reporter: more bodies, more solemn sad processions to waiting ambulances. the pace of police boats bringing ashore the grim cost of this tragedy is picking up. many of the victims wearing life vests. for just a few families, the arrival of each boat brings the waiting closer to an end. for so many more, the uncertainty continues.
12:31 pm
the company which operated the ferry posted a public apology on their website saying, in part, we frustrate ourselves before the victims' families. we apologize to the people grieving for the loss of their loved ones. the search for survivors in these waters is dangerous. divers must first swim down over 100 feet, following guide ropes to reach the ship. aboard the vessel, low visibility and debris make it nearly impossible to navigate. rescuers focus their search on the third and fourth levels inside lounge and cabin areas, where they believe many of the students are located. so far, nine crew members in all have been arrested, including these four who appeared in court on tuesday. outside the court, answering questions about the sinking. one crew member saying, after the ship began to list, they were trying to stabilize it and stop it capsizing.
12:32 pm
another says the captain issued a distress signal, then tried to deploy the lifeboats. but they couldn't reach them. the captain, who has defended his actions, faces possible life in prison if convicted of the charges against him. nic robertson, cnn, jindo, south korea. >> nic was talking about the crew. you have the family of the victims, many parents of those young high school students, absolutely in anguish, as they face a long road ahead when it comes to compensation for their loss. hundreds of families' lives are now forever changed. what about the legal route here? maritime attorney jack hickey joins me from miami. jack represents 20 passengers onboard the costa concordia cruiseline when that crashed off of italy in 2012. jack, how does one determine liability in this disaster specifically off south korea? the captain, crew, ferry
12:33 pm
company? >> well, you know, as far as civil liability, yes, the ferry company. but as far as criminal liability against this captain, that's really under the korean law. international law doesn't really provide a very specific prohibition on the captain getting off the vessel before the vessel goes down, or before all the other passengers. but, you know, the captain is the master of the vessel. he's master, and in charge of the safety of every single passenger onboard. how can you administer your duties as master of all the safety of everybody, without being there. you have to be there. what's interesting is, in the korean system, the legal system in korea, it is a civil law system different from ours. they have judges making almost all the decisions, not juries. but in certain criminal cases, since 2008, they have actually
12:34 pm
had advisory juries on certain criminal matters. it will be interesting to see whether there's an advisory jury on the criminal case against the captain in this situation. >> did you think in a situation like this, we know what's happening with the costa concordia, that captain is on trial and could face prison for the rest of his life. but in this case, could this take the litigious route, or might we see a settlement? >> well, you know, the criminal case, because, frankly, there's been so much media attention, if i had to guess on the criminal side, they're going to be pretty harsh. it's not going to be a situation, if we had to guess, i don't think it's going to be a situation where there's going to be a quick plea on that side. if it were a plea, it would be certainly only if the captain agreed to a very stiff sentence.
12:35 pm
that's criminally. civilly, it is, again, it's a different system from ours. and i think it's pretty clear, given the circumstances here, and the lack of connection with the united states, for example, that the litigation is going to stay in korea. and under this civil law system, there are schedules for compensation. and it will take some time. but the compensation just -- you know, it depends on the formulas in the schedules. >> i want to go back to a word you used at the top of that answer, harsh. south korea's president likened the actions of the captain and crew to murder. when you talk about criminality in this type of case. do you think murder, manslaughter charges could be likely in this scenario? >> well, you know, when you talk about murder, when you talk about taking somebody's life, you do talk about, you know, first degree, second degree,
12:36 pm
manslaughter and down from there. this certainly could rise to a situation of manslaughter, which is really the definition of that is not that he had premeditated intent to do bad things to people, to actually kill people, but that his actions were so grossly negligent, that he had to have foreseen that bad things, and in fact death, would have come to people. and this may be a case like that. and when manslaughter is appropriate, and i say that, because here we have a string of failures. not just one thing, but a string of failures, starting with the fact that they veered off course, being three hours late were the initial reports. secondly, that third mate at the helm. the latest reports were that the vessel may be -- may have been in a tricky area navigationally.
12:37 pm
>> that's right. we don't know deaf natally. nine people detained as we were hearing from the reporter in jindo on the ground. the bodies wrapped in white sheets coming back to land. jack hickey, let's leave it there. maritime trial attorney, thank you so much for joining me. >> thank you. >> we really appreciate it. now to this. could affirmative action be a thing of the past? our legal expert says today's supreme court ruling was very bad, if you support those policies. and later, likely never forgiving malaysia for their loved ones. soon they'll have a way to take out their frustration and anger on the airline. . vo: david's heart attack didn't come with a warning. today his doctor has him on a bayer aspirin regimen to help reduce the risk of another one.
12:38 pm
if you've had a heart attack be sure to talk to your doctor before you begin an aspirin regimen. golive garden'svorites asignature favorites, just $10 all week long! including everyone's favorite fettuccine alfredo, and our classic lasagna. with sauces made from scratch in our kitchens every morning. all served with unlimited homemade soup or fresh garden salad. and your all-time favorite, warm breadsticks. signature favorites now just $10. all day, everyday at olive garden, we're all family here. discover 70 lunch combinations
12:39 pm
including our chicken parmigiana sandwich starting at $6.99.
12:40 pm
12:41 pm
the u.s. supreme court could radically change would could attend college in our country. this was a 6-2 decision. the court upheld a ban passed by voters in the state of michigan that prevents the use of racial preferences in college admissions. jeff toobin is our analyst. joining us from omaha, nebraska, today. jeff toobin, i know that you're saying here that for in anyone who supports affirmative action, this is a bad decision. tell me why. >> well, this is really a case about who decides whether there should be affirmative action. what the justices said in their opinion today is, the states can decide essentially any way they want. if the voters decide, as they did in michigan, that they don't want affirmative action anymore at their state university, they can do that, presumably state legislatures can do the same thing. so what this suggests is that
12:42 pm
opponents of affirmative action can go state by state, by voter referendum, by state legislature vote, and say, look, we don't want it anymore. and the universities themselves have no say. it can be up to the states and they can exclude it. that's what happens in michigan. now. and it could happen elsewhere as well. >> it's up to the states. it's always interesting to look at the breakdown here. because we know justice breyer usually votes more on the liberal side. but sided with conservatives this time. why do you think? >> well, he wrote a separate opinion. he basically said, look, we have said, we the supreme court have said that affirmative action is permissible. universities can consider race as one factor among many. but we have not said that they have to do that. it's up to them. it's up to the university. and in turn, it's up to the
12:43 pm
state where the university is to decide whether they want to engage in affirmative action. so he was not saying affirmative action was a bad thing, he was simply saying, look, states can take it or not. michigan decided not. and other states presumably, given the way the polls show, other states may well do the same thing. michigan's a pretty liberal state. >> that's what i was wondering. >> well, 58% of the voters in michigan said, no affirmative action. that, i think, suggests that the anti-affirmative action side, at least, has the public on its side at the moment. >> jeff toobin, thank you so much. we appreciate it. >> all right. the u.s. is adding to military exercises in eastern europe. and it is certainly no coincidence it's going on the same time as the unrest in ukraine. here is the press secretary at the pentagon. >> they know each other.
12:44 pm
this isn't the first time that 173rd has done exercises with these countries. there's a relationship there. but yes, these exercises were conceived and added on to the exercise regimen as a result of what's going on in ukraine. >> washington sending a message to moscow. another message delivered this week, vice president joe biden visiting kiev at the same time a congressional delegation. so to washington we go. jake tapper, i know coming up on your show, you're talking to a congressman who is in ukraine, part of this delegation. >> that's right. we interviewed the chairman of the house foreign affairs committee, congressman ed royce in california yesterday. they met with vice president joe biden of the he recently tweeted he's hoping for a unified and democratic ukraine, unified presumably means he wants crimea returned to the ukraine.
12:45 pm
so we'll press him on how exactly he thinks that will come about. a lot of criticism from republican quarters for the obama administration for not adding lethal aid to this $50 million package for ukraine. we asked ben rhodes about that yesterday at the white house, and he said he doesn't think it would make a difference right now because russia has a bigger military than ukraine, even if they had the additional weapons. >> we'll stay tuned for that. what else do you have coming up on the show? >> we have live reports from all over the world. we have south korea, we have washington state, president obama will be touching down there, meeting with families from that natural disaster in oso, washington. also we'll be looking into the plane, and also a special earth day trip to the south pole that i know you're going to want to watch. the images are spectacular. we did this interview a while ago. >> not at the south pole?
12:46 pm
>> i was here. the person we were interviewing was in the south pole. there was literally a 30-second delay. >> oh, my goodness. >> we've edited that down. i don't know if you've tried to do an interview in the south pole. there's a little bit of a delay. >> pause, pause, pause. great seeing you in boston yesterday. thank you so much. we'll see him at the top of the hour for "the lead." lawyers have had to stay away from families who lost loved ones on flight 370. one family member has a message for any attorney who hopes to get in touch with her, after this tragedy. her message is next. in pursuit of all things awesome, amazing, and that's epic, bro, we've forgotten just how good good is. good is setting a personal best before going for a world record. good is swinging to get on base before swinging for a home run. [ crowd cheering ] good is choosing not to overshoot the moon, but to land right on it and do some experiments. ♪
12:47 pm
so start your day off good with a coffee that's good cup after cup. maxwell house. ♪ good to the last drop
12:48 pm
♪ honey, we need to talk. we do? i took the trash out. i know. and thank you so much for that. i think we should get a medicare supplement insurance plan. right now? [ male announcer ] whether you're new to medicare or not, you may know it only covers about 80% of your part b medical expenses. it's up to you to pay the difference. so think about an aarp medicare supplement insurance plan, insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company. like all standardized medicare supplement insurance plans, they help cover some of what medicare doesn't pay. i did a little research. with a medicare supplement plan, you'll be able to stay with your doctor. oh, you know, i love that guy. mm-hmm. [ male announcer ] these types of plans let you visit any doctor or hospital that accepts medicare patients. and there are no networks. is this a one-size-fits-all kind of thing?
12:49 pm
no. there are lots of plan options. it all depends on what we need and how much we want to spend. [ male announcer ] call now to request your free decision guide. it could help you find an aarp medicare supplement plan that's right for you. what happens when we travel? the plans go with us. anywhere in the country. i like that. you know what else? unitedhealthcare insurance company has years and years of experience. what do you say? ♪ i'm in. [ male announcer ] join the millions already enrolled in the only medicare supplement insurance plans endorsed by aarp. remember, all medicare supplement plans help cover some of what medicare doesn't pay and could really save you in out-of-pocket medical costs. you'll be able to choose your own doctor or hospital as long as they accept medicare patients. and with these plans, there could be low or no copays. you do your push-ups today? prepare to be amazed. [ male announcer ] don't wait.
12:50 pm
call today to request your free decision guide and find the aarp medicare supplement plan to go the distance with you. go long. . day 47 now since malaysian air flight 370 vanished over the southern indian ocean. a somber milestone because it now allows attorneys to swoop in. there's a law between attorneys and victims' families, they have to wait at least 45 days to give these families time to deal with the trauma and now we're past that threshold. but -- here's the but. brother of philip wood has a message. >> the briefings have become more of a stand-up routine, black comedy. our frustration is that there is no information given. the only thing that the
12:51 pm
malaysian government has released so far has been opinion, basically. so they have not released a single piece of data and the families have basically lost their patience with it. we're up to almost 200 total family members combined together between the chinese families, malaysian families and families from other countries, such as australia and india and, of course, the united states. and we're going to put a lot more political pressure to redecember data for third-party assessments and now they are trying to put our family members in coffins again. there's not the slightest bit of evidence that this flight has even crashed. there's no wreckage. there's no sightings. there's nothing at all that is deemed to the actual fact. it's only conjecture at this
12:52 pm
point. we'll keep going back to wanting to start the investigation. what they are doing now, searching in the ocean, is like continuing to trying to bail out a boat when the hole in the boat hasn't been found yet. they are just treating a symptom. they are not going back to the cause. it's absolutely astounding to me that they haven't been willing to release that data. now, the general perception within the family group, nobody is interested in compensation lawsuits and we're really quite tired of attorneys hassling us. that's got to stop. but we really do need advice in how to pressure malaysian airlines to open up what should be exposed information in a criminal investigation. >> now, we know that the malaysian government plans to issue death certificates for passengers but sarah bajac there says neither she nor philip's family has been contacted about it at all. and information coming in to us
12:53 pm
from australia, as officials are working out what the next steps of this investigation will be here, the search for the plane and beyond, the planned focus is on the key three areas. first you have the handling of debris if and when they find it, who gets it, where will the debris from this wreckage remain, who handles it. then you have the issue of human remains if and when they are found, who handles that and then this one, potentially widening the search area if bluefin's final search comes up empty. this is from martin dolan. and quick break. we'll be right back. ck? what if the plane gets delayed? what if i can't hide my symptoms? what if? but what if the most important question is the one you're not asking? what if the underlying cause of your symptoms is damaging inflammation? for help getting the answers you need, talk to your doctor and visit crohnsandcolitisinfo.com
12:54 pm
to get your complimentary q&a book, with information from experts on your condition. humans. even when we cross our "ts" and dot our "i's", we still run into problems. that's why liberty mutual insurance offers accident forgiveness with our auto policies. if you qualify, your rates won't go up due to your first accident. because making mistakes is only human, and so are we. we also offer new car replacement, so if you total your new car, we'll give you the money for a new one. call liberty mutual insurance at... and ask us all about our auto features, like guaranteed repairs, where if you get into an accident and use one of our certified repair shops, the repairs are guaranteed for life. so call... to talk with an insurance expert about everything that comes standard with our base auto policy.
12:55 pm
and if you switch, you could save up to $423. liberty mutual insurance -- responsibility. what's your policy?
12:56 pm
thcar loan didn't start here. it began way, way back. before he had children. before he got married. it started in his very first apartment. see that overdue bill? it arrived after he moved out. and he never got it. but he's not worried. checking his credit report and score at experian.com allowed him to identify and better address the issue... ... and drive off into the sunset. experian . live credit confident.™
12:57 pm
all right. if you love watching "house of cards" and other shows on netflix, you have to listen to this. netflix's prices are about to go up. they are going to raise monthly subscriptions. here's the catch. the price hike will only affect new customers. zain asher is live at the new york stock exchange. zain asher, how much more money are we talking? >> we're only talking 1 to $2. this is for new customers for the time being only. but it's the first price increase netflix has shown us since 2011. they want to use this new money to invest in original shows like "orange is the new black" and
12:58 pm
"house of cards." i have not seen a single episode. >> what? >> i know. and by the way, even though it's only 1 to $2, when you consider the fact that they have 48 million subscribers worldwide, that certainly does add up. but for existing customers, you pay about $8 a month now. that's likely to continue for the time being. but he will continue that price level for a generous period of time but it does, of course, open the door for possible price increases for existing customers in the near future. brooke? >> okay. so if they want this extra money, they want to invest in new shows and that's fully understandable, but didn't netflix report some huge jump in profit? how much more cash are they looking for? >> the reason they are doing the price increase now is, quite simply, because they can. they are coming from this huge position of strength. they did report earnings yesterday. they beat on profit.
12:59 pm
so they reported $50 million in profit. you compare that to this time last year, they only reported 3 million. last year their stock price rose 270%, brooke, as well. but also, they've tested out price increases before. so they tested it out in ireland. they increased prices by 1 euro and it didn't have that much of a huge fallout so they probably will be able to get away with this price increase. by the way, netflix stock today rising 6%. it does need a larger amount of revenue. >> since i have you with 20 minutes to spare, tell me how the markets are doing today. >> right. it's the sixth straight day of gains on the s&p 500. it's really about earnings, brooke. i mentioned to you netflix but also compact as well. by the way, if you look at the companies that reported earnings, almost 70% of the companies that have reported have beaten expectations, partly
1:00 pm
because the forecast is all about earnings today. brooke? >> zain asher for us and there it goes, on queue, the closing bell. i'm brooke baldwin. thanks so much for being with me. i'll be back here at the same time, same place tomorrow. "the lead" with jake tapper starts now. you will not walk this road alone, vice president biden tries to assure the ukrainians. do they buy it? does putin? i'm jake tapper. this is "the lead." he was speaking to the ukrainians but the vice president comes bearing a $50 million gift for ukraine but republicans want to know, why are weapons not part of the offer? also in world news, a desperate and initial call for help but not apparently from the crew of the south korean sinking ferry. cnn now confirming that a boy was thinking quicker than those at the helm as the