tv Forensic Files CNN July 14, 2014 11:00pm-11:31pm PDT
11:00 pm
>> go to cnn heroes.com. this young couple had everything. successful careers, money, time to enjoy it, and a home fit for a movie star. then everything changed. their three-year-old son developed serious respiratory problems. and his father started showing signs of alzheimer's disease. forensic scientists needed to know whether these illnesses are bad luck, bad genes or something else.
11:01 pm
dripping springs texas, a town where you can enjoy the beauty of the texas hill country yet commute to downtown austin in just over half an hour. me melinda ballard loved this area. in 1994 she met ron allison. after dating for less than a year the couple married. >> he was everything i had ever wanted in a man. very intelligent, a real go-getter. a workaholic, which is what i am so we seem to match up pretty well in that regard. just a super guy. >> we both had the same interests. we both wanted to have a family. i think that was the key. careerwise both similar
11:02 pm
interests. melinda has been head of her own public relations business, a firm she sold in 1989 but she still continued her career. >> i set at a board member of a bank and still represent a number of clients that are, i guess, holdovers from my company in new york. >> ron worked in investment banking and was head of corporate finance at his firm. in 1996 melinda gave birth to their son reece. ron loved being a father and a weekend baseball coach. then in february 1989, three-year-old reese developed what seemed like a flu. >> he started having some respiratory problems. and he would have a real hard time catching his breath. he'd -- and we thought golly, maybe he's
11:03 pm
exercising too much or something. >> the symptoms lingered. one month later reese seemed to be getting worse, not better. >> initially we thought maybe it is because reese is in preschool, in nursery school and you know how kids just -- they constantly just contaminate one another with a little bug or virus. >> doctors could find nothing wrong. tests were inconclusive. when he was taking for allergy tests, those too were negative. soon reese's problems moved from respiratory to neurological. reese who had learned his abcs from a-z suddenly couldn't get past d. >> he was deteriorating quickly and we were taking him to doctor after doctor after doctor. and they told us something was wrong but they didn't know what it was.
11:04 pm
>> when doctors came up emt, a team of forensic scientists and epidemiologists had better luck. you know.... there's a more enjoyable way to get your fiber. try phillips fiber good gummies. they're delicious and an excellent source of fiber to help support regularity. mmmm. these are good! the tasty side of fiber. from phillips we're trying our best to be role models.dels. we don't jump at the sound of the opening bell, because we're trying to make the school bell. corner booth beats corner office any day. we make the most of our time... and our money.
11:05 pm
the 2014 malibu. highest ranked midsize car in initial quality the car for the richest guys on earth. woman: what do you mean, homeowners insurance doesn't cover floods? [ heart rate increases ] man: a few inches of water caused all this? [ heart rate increases ] woman #2: but i don't even live near the water. what you don't know about flood insurance may shock you -- including the fact that a preferred risk policy
11:07 pm
melinda ballard was living a dream life. she and her husband had a beautiful home a healthy adorable son and successful careers. until their three-year-old son developed a serious illness. >> i didn't know if he had some kind of rare disease that nobody'd ever heard of. i didn't know what to think but i knew it was getting worse. >> reese was still asthmatic. very. in fact the pulmonologist said he had scarred lung tissue. >> but still the cause couldn't be found. it appeared to ron's coworkers that the stress associated with his son's illness was starting to get to him. >> ron was sitting at his desk looking at his computer screen which isn't unusual. but when i walked closer to his desk i realized he was staring at a blank screen.
11:08 pm
>> and ron exhibited other symptoms. >> he came out of the grocery store and could not remember where he had parked his car. or what car he even drove. it took him about five hours to come back from the grocery store, when it should have taken him 20 minutes. and when he gets home everything's melted. and he said, i don't know. i had a black out or something. >> i didn't know what was going on. and the wheels were coming off. and it was -- it was -- i was scared. ron went to a neurologist for testing. the results showed a dramatic decrease in his cognitive abilities. >> my doctor had told me that i was about halfway through the progression of alzheimer's and that is based on my neurological test results.
11:09 pm
but that's all he could tell me, is that you are functioning on this level. and it seems to be getting worse. but they didn't know exactly why or what to do about it. >> an april 1, 1999 melinda boarded a flight heading to the arkansas. it was a flight that forever changed the course of her life. a man named bill holder was assigned to the seat next to melinda. >> on the way to dallas i heard her talking to some people and she was complaining about all these illnesses and problems that she and her family were having. >> and without warning, melinda fell ill. >> i kept coughing up blood. and bill holder said to me, lady, what in the world is wrong with you? i said i really don't know. >> i just asked her, i said do you have a water leak at your
11:10 pm
house. and she said yes, i do. i have several water leaks. >> she told holder that a month earlier there was a leak in her home causing the downstairs floors to buckle. a plumber repaired the leak which was in the water line leading to the refrigerator's ice maker. holder began to suspect that it was a mold causing the family's illness. holder owns the assured indoor air quality business that removes toxic mold from buildings. but melinda dismissed this possibility. she kept her home spotless and no one in her family tested positive for allergies. but during their conversation on the plane, holder said something prophetic. >> he's telling me these aren't allergens lady. this is a poison. >> now suspecting there was some
11:11 pm
kind of mold behind the wall or above the ceiling, ron and melinda moved out of the house and into a apartment over the garage. but even with the move ron's neurological problems continued to get worse. >> at the office i would be on a phone call and 10 or 20 minutes into the phone call just not have any idea what we'd discussed. >> if there was some kind of mold behind a wall or ceiling, how would investigators find it? medical experts began to suspect that something in their home environment was making ron, melinda and reese sick.
11:12 pm
i'm living the life of dreams. i'm living the life of dreams, with good people all around me. i'm living the life of dreams. no! i'm living the life of dreams. i'm feeling hopefully. feeling quite hopefully, it's right up here, turn right, turn right. with good people all around me. right, right, right, right, right! with good people all around me. ok look you guys, she's up here somewhere. with good people all around me. there she is! cara! come here girl! i'm feeling hopefully. and the light shines bright all through the night. oh i don't know it. and the light shines bright all through the night. yes, you do. and the light shines bright all through the night. 42. and the light shines bright all through the night. good job. and the light shines bright all through the night. and the light shines bright all through the night. and our dreams are making us nice stories. and my loves are well sleeping just right. and i know know know know now... ...that we're, living the life of dreams...
11:13 pm
11:15 pm
medical experts began to suspect that something in their home environment was making ron, melinda and reese sick. the property included 72 acres. the house itself was enormous, 12,000 square feet, modeled after the movie version of tara, scarlet o'hara plantation home in "gone with the wind". >> it was a georgian style home antebellum. it was just gorgeous. >> scientists began to focus on the possibility that it was mold. >> for mold to grow it requires water to be where it shouldn't
11:16 pm
be. it requires cellulose which is a component of most building material, sheet rock, ceiling tile, press particle board and it also needs the appropriate temperature and oxygen. >> melinda asked bill holder to inspect their home to see if he could find anything suspicious. he started behind the refrigerator, the location of the original water leak and under the first floor floorboards. >> take clear cellophane tape, push it on the suspect area and attach it to a glass slide. at the same time take a sterile cotton swab and lift some of the material off of that surface, put it in a sterile container and send it to the laboratory. >> dr. david strauss is a professor of microbiology and immunology at texas tech
11:17 pm
university. >> i spent about a half hour in the house and i was talking with bill, mr. holder. and i said to him, bill i don't feel for good. i said i got to get out of here and just literally walked out the front door and pretty much collapsed. i lost any ability to stand without aid. >> the samples were processed at texas tech health sciences center. technicians there sterilized the slides, then examined them under a high powered microscope. the cotton swab samples were transferred to petri dishes. then put in an incubator for five to seven days. if there were spores present, they would grow mold which could be examined under the microscope. most household molds are harmless. but dr. strauss found one type
11:18 pm
of mold in the home that was not harmless. it was a toxic, deadly mold known as stachybotrys. experts believed stachybotrys spores exist on many building materials. as long as those materials stay dry, the spores don't present a problem. but when the spores get wet from a leaky roof for example or in a dark moist environment and are near a paper product like drywall and insulation, the spores multiply quickly. and they produce a potentially deadly poison called mycotoxins. >> mycotoxins are on the surface of these spores. so when you inhale these spores you are also taking the mycotoxins into your lungs as well. >> later bill holder went back to conduct an air borne test. canisters placed throughout the
11:19 pm
house capture any air borne spores which might be present. a short time later melinda was notified of the results. >> they informed us that it was literally everywhere and including in the apartment where we were living. and for us to -- it would be a good idea to leave. >> to avoid the possibility of cross-contamination, the family was told to leave the grounds immediately and to take nothing with them. >> buildings never get better by themselves. in fact if you leave a building alone that has mold infestation, it gets worse. >> melinda and ron hoped the family's held problems would clear up once they left the house but they didn't. >> ron is a bright, bright guy. but he's become almost -- it's -- he carries a little notebook in his pocket. got his phonebook and car license number and he's not a
11:20 pm
buffoon by any stretch. but i know he's seriously affected by this. >> ron just really loves his son. and on several occasions i would hear him talking about his son. and he would say my son -- and stop because he didn't remember his son's name. >> ron's memory problems forced him to resign from his firm. reese continued to suffer from asthma and learning disabilities. only melinda came through without permanent health problems. doctors had no idea why. toxic mold reproduces by shedding microscopic spores. can't be cleaned from surfaces, because to do so would release
11:21 pm
thousands of spores into the air. instead each piece of contaminated building material has to be dismantled, sealed in airtight plastic and carted a way. ere'stalk and text. we're working deals all day. you get 10 gigabytes of data to share. what about expansion potential? add a line anytime for 15 bucks a month. low dues... great terms... let's close. introducing at&t mobile share value plans... ...with our best-ever pricing for business.
11:24 pm
11:25 pm
walls and ceilings. the couple says the first time they noticed any water damage was the leak behind the refrigerator which the couple things.er had fixed. the leak had caused extensive damage throughout the area. the customer said they wanted to repair the damaged your right away but the insurance company said no. >> we had asked the insurance company in writing to allow us to begin repairs immediately and at least rip out some of the wet flooring. and the insurance said that if i had made repairs during their investigation, that i would lose coverage. >> scientific experts say that most household molds are harmless. but with stachybotrys, the mold must be removed immediately, since it is capable of
11:26 pm
spreading. the cost to eliminate all of the stachybotrys in ron and melinda's home was regally estimated to be $1 million. the insurance company offered less than $200,000. while the two sides tried to reach a settlement, construction experts found 13 additional plumbing leaks and one roof leak in the home causing even more stachybotrys contamination. >> they kept wanting to investigate claims which is their right and duty to do. but the problem is they would never allow us to begin making repairs. >> the investigations and disputes over cost dragged on for two years. by then experts concluded that the house and every thing in it was so contaminated, it was beyond repair. experts recommended that the
11:27 pm
home be demolished. melinda and ron filed suit against their insurance company for the financial loss of their property. the suit argued that the insurance company knew or should have known about the potentially dangerous effects to repairing water damage inside houses. dr. gray sees more than 150 patients a year who suffer from exposure to molds. >> i conclude he was defectly affected by the mycotoxins that he was exposed to in his living environment. >> in addition, ron's attorney presented epidemiological studies showing the relationship between trichothecene, the toxin found in stachybotrys mold and mental functioning. >> i was confident we had found the kind of scientific information that would allow us
11:28 pm
to try this case to a jury, yes. >> ron and melinda were asking the insurance company for the cost of their home and property, $6 million. the jury took two and a half days to come back with their verdict. but it was not for the $6 million melinda and ron asked for. the jury awarded the couple $32 million. >> it was a great relief to me that the jury system worked. >> i was obviously relieved. i had hoped that day would not get away with what they had done. >> the home, once a showplace is now sitting abandoned. it's been looted numerous times. ron is learning to live with an
11:29 pm
impaired memory. he enters his daily schedule into his handheld computer each morning and relies on its alarm to help him stay on track. to make certain that people know their rights relative to water damage in their home, melinda created her own website, "policy holders of america.org." >> it's not just been a home that's been lost here. it has been the health of a little boy and a very energetic workaholic man who has lost his identity. and i don't want to see this happen to any other family. i can promise you that. all of those medical doctors and quality scientists that have been involved in our case are my heros. they are our heros. he allowed his victim to
11:30 pm
write a last will and testament to her family, then taunted them with chilling phone calls. >> have you received the letter today. >> yes. >> okay. so you know now that this is not a hoax call. >> a trace phone line couldn't track the abductor. but scientists would find a clue in the victim's last words. 17-year-old cherry smith had her 17-year-old cherry smith had her whole life before her. in two days she would have the honor of singing her national anthem from the lexington high school. then she would sail off on a
491 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=2108879951)