tv Anderson Cooper 360 CNN January 12, 2015 5:00pm-6:01pm PST
5:00 pm
merican cartoonist. she's now in hiding her story is an incredible one. who is she. we have a special report tomorrow night. thank you for joining us tonight. set your dvr to record "outfront" so you can watch us anytime. see you at the same time tomorrow. "ac 360" starts now. the question right now, are there more members of the terror cell than just these three who are dead and the woman on the run. the answer could be yes. we are also learning more tonight about the lengthy paper trail the killers had and their terror connections they apparently made long before their deadly rampage last wednesday. we also learned as if we didn't already know after spending the week there, just what paris strong means. this is what it looked like in the city yesterday. a unity rally drawing more people than turned out to mark the liberation of paris during the second world war. it was that big. said one french commentateor today, they want us to lie down we stand up. they want to divide us we
5:01 pm
unite. leaders from around the world came to show solidarity from across the political and sectarian divide including benjamin netanyahu, and mahmoud abbas. notably absent president obama or vice president biden, or even secretary of state john kerry. we'll have more on that shortly. but first the manhunt and all the new reporting at this hour. jim sciutto joins us from paris. tell us about the force, as many as six suspects connected with the paris attacks may be on the run. >> reporter: anderson this has been the burning question since the moment gunned the offices of charlie. yes, likely there were accomplices. you now have a report from a.p. saying perhaps as many as six. unclear whether that's accomplices or members of a network that knew the attackers. right now, french authorities operating under the assumption
5:02 pm
that there are others out there that were involved and that explains the massive police and military presence around the country tonight. >> 10,000 forces. unprecedented display of force in france have been deployed. authorities are searching for this woman, the girlfriend and accomplice to the man who was killed after he took over the kosher supermarket. what's the latest on her? >> reporter: we now have video proof that she indeed crossed into turkey from a flight from madrid earlier. several days five days before the attack. turkish authorities believe she continued on from turkey into syria the day before the siege on the kosher market here. so she's out of pocket. certainly another person involved in this attack who they would want to speak to arrest. but disappearing in effect into syria. and it just shows the difficulty of tracking the people involved in this case. >> there are now reports
5:03 pm
bulgaria has arrested a frenchman suspected of having links to one of the kouachi brothers. what do you know about him? >> reporter: this is a man who attempted to cross from bulgaria into turkey the presumption from turkish authorities was he was going to continue on to syria. he was arrested. now there's a suggested link between him and the kouachi brothers. it's not certain if he knew them or was involved with them. the french now working on extraditing him from bulgaria to france. he's one of many people that they want to talk to under suspicion in connection with the attack. but clear whether he had involvement in the attack in paris. >> jim, appreciate the update. there are a lot of moving parts. i want to get the latest on how much authorities knew about these killers, and tragically how far in advance they actually knew it. drew griffin now investigates a paper trail that foreshadowed the trail of mayhem and death. >> reporter: they are court documents filed on december
5:04 pm
20th, 2013 just a little more than one year ago, which go into explicit detail of how a group of about a dozen french muslims were plotting to stage a prison break and free a fellow terrorist in 2010. two key figures in the plot the same two now dead suspects accused of carrying out last week's horrific attacks in paris. cherif kouachi, who with his brother staged a massacre at the newspaper office and his associate, accused of killing a french police officer, then killing four more at a jewish grocery store. documents obtained by cnn show the attacks should have come as no surprise to the french. >> these documents show as early as 2013 these individuals posed a significant threat to the national security. >> reporter: when french police
5:05 pm
investigated, ama amaddy was in charge of accumulating weapons and arms for the prison break block. he was found to have illegally stored a huge cache of high-caliber arms including some 240 cartridges for high-powered machine guns with the specific goal the documents say, of seriously hurting people through intimidation or terror acts. also found in his apartment, computers with security and encryption audio recordings of islamic religious figures, and even recipes written in arabic for making poison purportedly capable of killing 1 million people. and there were several photos showing him dressed in his islamic guard posing in front of a black flag with white arabic inscriptions on it. like other terror suspects
5:06 pm
french officials allowed him credit for time served then released him sometime early last year. we now know coulibaly terrorist ways never changed. after his death last week in this shootout. police again raided his apartment and again found a huge cache of arms. the court documents also reveal how close-knit the terror group was. cherif kouachi had apparently become more radicalized following his arrest in 2005. he had met a well-known jihadist spiritual leader and terror recruiter in prison a man by the name of jamal nagal. once they were freed, visited the same well-known terrorist, even staying with him for days at a time. his companions on some of the visits coulabaly. his now wanted wife would join them as well.
5:07 pm
all visiting the man they called the wise man. the documents describe a series of pictures dated april 2010 showing amadi posing with a crossbow. that companion is believed to be hayat hayat. they were known to police for years. the documents even detail how kouachi and coulabaly would hide conversations by using code names over portable or disposable cell phones sometimes even using pay phones. both men remained under surveillance. but in a move that has not yet been fully explained, the surveillance ended just six months ago. >> i think back to what we learned about the 9/11 plotters that many of them were known by authorities, suspicions even raised. this obviously, though is different in that they were actually in prison at one point.
5:08 pm
how much did american intelligence officials and maybe other countries know about these guys? >> reporter: anderson we learned two things today. coulabaly was on a terror watch group. we know the french and yemeni officials knew that the kouachi brothers had been to yemen. at one point one of the brothers reportedly shared a room with the failed underwear bomber. the fact is they were all well-known to counterterrorism officials and somehow slipped under the radar long enough to plot plan and carry out these attacks. >> and the explanation so far from the french is there are just soo many of these possible terrorists or potential terrorists to keep track of. and perhaps these guys kind of laid low for a while. so whatever tracking was being done they thought, well maybe these guys are no longer operational. are intelligence officials, are they buying that in terms of lack of manpower in light of all this information, are french officials sticking to that explanation?
5:09 pm
>> reporter: you know they say there are a lot of bad guys to follow. even france's prime minister is admitting, anderson there were failings in the intelligence system. they held this emergency meeting to discuss what could be done to make sure that what -- i mean obviously this stuff in hindsight looks very easy to connect the dots. they want to make sure they connect the dots beforehand. that sounds a lot like the aftermath of 9/11. one other thing, anderson you know these guys were getting out of prison at least coulabaly was just last year. however long he could have laid low, it seems could have only been one year. so that's something the french will look at. >> drew griffin, thanks very much. appreciate it. a lot more ahead on the terror attacks. make sure to set your dvr, watch 360 whenever you want. authorities say they know who the so-called wise man in drew's report is. it's a name that will not make anyone sleep better tonight. later, the hero who helped
5:10 pm
take these people give them shelter from one of the killers in the market. a remarkable story, and others now coming to light. [ narrator ] mama sherman and the legion of super fans. wow! [ narrator ] on a mission to get richard to his campbell's chunky soup. it's new chunky beer-n-cheese with beef and bacon soup. i love it. and mama loves
5:11 pm
you. ♪ ♪ how can power consumption in china impact wool exports from new zealand, textile production in spain, and the use of medical technology in the u.s.? at t. rowe price we understand the connections of a complex, global economy. it's just one reason over 70% of our mutual funds beat their 10-year lipper average. t. rowe price. invest with confidence. request a prospectus or summary prospectus with investment information, risks, fees and expenses to read and consider carefully before investing. i've smoked a lot and quit a lot but ended up nowhere. now...i use this. the nicoderm cq patch with unique extended release technology helps prevent the urge to smoke all day. i want this time to be my last time. that's why i choose nicoderm cq. narrator: these are the tennis shoes skater kid: whoa narrator: that got torture tested by teenagers and cried out for help. from the surprised designers. who came to the rescue with a brilliant fix
5:12 pm
male designer: i love it narrator: which created thousands of new customers for the tennis shoes that got torture tested by teenagers. the internet of everything is changing manufacturing. is your network ready? well, a mortgage shouldn't be a problem your credit is in pretty good shape. >>pretty good? i know i have a 798 fico score thanks to the tools and help on experian.com. kaboom... well, i just have a few other questions. >>chuck, the only other question you need to ask is, "what else can you do for me?" i'll just take a water... get your credit swagger on. become a member of experian credit tracker and find out your fico score powered by experian. fico scores are used in 90% of credit decisions.
5:13 pm
5:14 pm
reporting, paris conspirators had contact. debra feyerick joins us now. he's known as the al qaeda recruiter in europe and has connections to two of the terrorists. >> that's exactly right. this is what makes him so interesting. because this is a man who was convicted of two plots. not only the blot to blow up the u.s. embassy in paris in 2001, when it was hatched, but ten years later he's found guilty of plotting to free a man from prison. that man implicated and convicted in a plot that basically blew up the paris metro. >> the algerian national. >> that's exactly right. let's go back to the u.s. embassy plot. this is where it all begins. we know begal was in afghanistan for an eight-month period from november 2000 until july 2001. when he was there, he was instructed to carry out this u.s. embassy bombing plot which essentially meant he was to go from afghanistan to dubai.
5:15 pm
>> and this guy, i think, what on the lower -- >> right in the middle there. he's wearing tan pants and has the white jacket on. he was told effectively to carry out this plot. he was going to go from afghanistan, go to dubai, from dubai to mock rocco, lose his passport and travel up through sprain where he was supposed to get money to finance this plot. he was picked up into dubai, questioned by french and both u.s. intelligence agents and he was put in prison and then later found guilty of being involved in this. and so then you fast forward, and then you've got -- or when you look at the continuum of time really this was two years after the u.s. embassy attacks against the buildings in tanzania as well as kenya. it was just months before the 9/11 attack. >> and the plot to free this algerian guy from prison the guy who took over the supermarket was put in jail involved in that as well. as well as the younger kouachi
5:16 pm
brother, although there was not enough evidence really to bring him to trial. but this guy, the so-called wise man, he's been linked to al qaeda central. where as the kouachi brothers are linked to al qaeda in yemen. >> look at al qaeda itself. anwar al awacky he was considered the heir apparent to bin laden. he was considered the youtube bin laden. because his servants were so powerful that he was advocating a lone wolf insurgency for these young individuals. but you go back even farther, and now we've got a connection between a known recruiter, and afghanistan. and al qaeda. and not just any al qaeda, but bin laden's al qaeda. so it really shows that this sort of terrorist plot has been going on for a very long time. this is a picture of begal. >> on the left. and the one on the right who took over the supermarket. >> he's been in and out of
5:17 pm
prison on the significant terror plots. he's back in prison but now linked to these two individuals. the question is the surveillance you saw, that's part of a 45,000 pages the french authority have on begal. and this is what they collected on him over time. not just wire transcripts, but these aim knowledges that you just saw. >> a lot to talk about. a cnn terrorism analyst joins us and a special forces member. former cia and fbi counterterrorism official phillip mudd. phil the fact that cherif kouachi, one of the brothers made contact with the al qaeda recruiter two years after being released from prison it points to the dangers of not keeping track of these guys once they are released. >> yeah. you've got to think, though about how long we've been looking at this case and the number of cases you're weighing this against. i think this highlights a couple of things anderson about the complexity of the lengthy cases. the first is these guys we've
5:18 pm
been at this war for 15 years. the adversaries learned a lot about how the western security services operate in those 15 years. i've seen al qaeda operative fs studying transcripts from the west to learn how law enforcement had gotten up on some of the people we arrested. they learned a lot about us we learned a lot about them. they're very careful about evade law enforcement. as they learned about law enforcement, they're very careful in some cases about crossing the line. so collecting intelligence about someone suggests that they're dirty is not the same as collecting evidence that you can prove in a court of law. as this game of cat-and-mouse has gone along, some of these guys have been very sophisticated about how not to trigger law enforcement to arrest them in the midst 6 an intelligence investigation. >> and you and i talked about this in paris last week. is it just that security services in france in paris, are overwhelmed? that there are too many suspects and not enough personnel, not enough manpower?
5:19 pm
>> no i'm not convinced that we are overwhelmed by the threat actually. you know it's less than one week ago. the first part of 9 terrorist attack was to stop the three terrorists at that time. now they are killing them. now this is the second phase. and all the security forces and intelligence forces are focused to track those guys. now it's a race against the clock to find those guys. i think we have really the manpower necessary actually to find the suspects actually. it's not a problem of manpower or resources actually. >> fabrice, in terms of monitoring people who have obviously committed an attack but people who are suspects, if there are more than 1,000 suspects it takes a lot of people to follow somebody around
5:20 pm
the clock. >> yes, sure. yeah that is a point, actually. because, you know the threat changed in the last two years. and we are now -- the threat is accelerating very quickly on an exponential scale. of course now, we have to adapt our security system to be able to conquer this spread-out of jihadists on the ground. a few years ago, there were just maybe 100, maybe now 1,500. it's not so easy now to react in such a very short time you know. that's a challenge that we have to face to react very quickly and to be able to conquer those guys now. >> phil obviously the travel problems the ease of travel i guess i should say, is a huge problem for countries in western europe. we saw this female suspect who was able to get on a plane from
5:21 pm
ma grid. she ends up in turkey. she crosses over into syria. >> i think it's not just the ease of travel anderson it's the fact that the adversary has learned a lot about the kind of clues we look at. it's not complicated whether you're in new york or paris, not get a one-way ticket to yemen. let me go to someplace like turkey or jordan. so when you look at the volume of travelers from the united states and the number of people traveling overseas for example, on student visas, or traveling on tourist visas, to sit back and say, hey, let's start to look at every person between the ages of let's say 15 and 45, who's trasmveling to a place like turkey or jordan just because we might find one who is potentially going into syria. that kind of problem -- you can't solve that problem. the numbers are just too great. >> phil in terms of tracking this woman now that she's in syria, a, is it worthwhile do you think she's still a potential threat? >> i don't think she is. i don't think we'll ever see her come home.
5:22 pm
there's a great prospect she will become propaganda as someone who represents the new isis in syria and iraq. not necessarily beheadings but somebody who's participating in attacking the west. great propaganda value. but the likelihood when she comes home when she's identified not just by photos but things like dna, she's got a couple prospects, none good. one, they bomb where she's at. and dies in fighting. the u.s. military intelligence operating aircraft or drones kills her. i'm not saying they would target her, she might be affiliated with leadership that's targeted. i think eventually she will die out there. she will not come home. >> thank you both so much. you can find out a lot more on this story and many others at cnn.com. in the middle of his standoff with police the terrorist who took over that supermarket called a french newsroom from the kosher market he had seized. i'll talk to the deputy managing
5:23 pm
editor who got that call. and how several hostages survived that ordeal. what she saw and heard and how they managed to stay alive. ♪ ac/dc: "back in black" ♪ ♪♪ chevy colorado. when you find new roads, you win motor trend's truck of the year. ♪ music ♪ ...the getaway vehicle! for all the confidence you need. td
5:24 pm
ameritrade. you got this. flo: hey, big guy. i heard you lost a close one today. look, jamie, maybe we weren't the lowest rate this time. but when you show people their progressive direct rate and our competitors' rates you can't win them all. the important part is, you helped them save. thanks, flo. okay, let's go get you an ice cream cone, champ. with sprinkles?
5:27 pm
now the man who talked to a terrorist in the middle of carrying out an attack. he spoke for three minutes with the deputy managing editor of bfm tv. the standoff at a kosher supermarket was going on. >> i spoke to an interpreter with alexis. alexis how did you manage to get this guy on the phone in the middle of the hostage situation?
5:28 pm
5:29 pm
>>en believable. riveting details about how the french hostages who came so close to death on friday how they actually survived. some of the survivors are describing what they endured and they managed to stay alive until help arrived. we also learned what was happening inside the printing plant outside paris in the hours before police began their raid. each one of the hostages feared they would die, which makes their courage all the more remarkable. randi kaye reports. >> reporter: in the face of terror survivors and heroes emerge. like this man, a practicing muslim who herded people into a freezer at this kosher market where he worked. the gunman had just charged into the store and opened fire.
5:30 pm
>> translator: i switched off the light and freezer. he asked us all to come upstairs otherwise he would kill everyone who was downstairs. i asked my colleagues what they thought. should we go upstairs or stay here? with me there was one person with a 2-year-old baby. i told them you stay calm. i'm the one who is going to go up. i took the elevator and went upstairs. >> reporter: he then managed to run outside to tell police about the gunman and the hostages in the freezer. one of those in the freezer, rudy later spoke exclusively with israeli channel 2 news. >> translator: he was there to kill people. we heard a big explosion. we were still all closed in the fridge. we heard gunfire from everywhere. >> reporter: when they were freed -- >> translator: they said to climb upstairs and not look on the floor because there was a lot of blood on the floor. it's a miracle we're all still here me and the people who were in the fridge. >> reporter: as news of the freezer hideaway spread, social
5:31 pm
media lit up. this man was hailed a hero. muslim worker in kosher store hid jews saved them. right now, beteli is the coolest man on the planet. just north of paris, the suspects from another massacre were enclosed inside a printing plant. a graphic designer was hiding inside a cardboard box, texting police about the gunman's movement and his own whereabouts in the building. he also reportedly sent this chilling text to his father. i am hidden on the first floor. i think they have killed everyone. tell the police to intervene. his text likely helped the snipers set their positions. a hostage held at gun point survived. turns out, there were no other victims. another man at the printing plant earlier also survived a close encounter with the kouachi
5:32 pm
brothers. he told french radio he mistakenly shook hands with one of the suspects before the owner told him to leave. >> i took him as a nonpoliceman. he wasn't wearing a uniform and he had a bulletproof vest on. >> reporter: when the siege was over he told reporters he was going to buy a lottery ticket. that it was the luckiest day of his life. randi kaye, cnn, new york. >> lucky indeed. president obama was a no-show at the rally in paris. the white house now admits it messed up. the question is how does that happen. plus we've gotten hold of new reporting, potentially of a significant development in the area.
5:33 pm
5:34 pm
5:35 pm
the white house did something pretty surprising basically admitting publicly there was in fact something wrong with this picture. as we said earlier, leaders from 40 countries marched with french president yesterday leading the paris rally that drew more than 1 million people. notably absent president obama or the vice president or the secretary of state.
5:36 pm
mr. obama's failure to show or send a high-level envoy sparked a lot of criticism. tonight the white house admitted they messed up. >> some have asked whether or not the united states should have sent someone with a higher profile than the ambassador to france. and i think it's fair to say we should have sent someone with a higher profile to be there. that said, there is no doubt that the american people and this administration stand four-square behind our allies in france as they face down this threat. >> today secretary of state john kerry said he'll fly to paris on friday to show support for the french government. joining me is political analyst david gergen and fareed zahar yeah. i don't get the thinking why wouldn't you send somebody. the vice president? that's what they're there for, isn't it? >> i think we were ought mystified yesterday when the
5:37 pm
vice president wasn't going. he was the most obvious choice. they represent the united states overseas. many many times when there are international incidents. this occasion more than most i think was one that was so clear that the united states should be there. we asked them to stand with us time after time when we think we're threatened and now they're threatened and we have to stand with them the. >> the president did go to the french embassy in washington to sign the condolence book but still, it seems like a -- kind of a ridiculous oversight. >> one of his interviews obama said something very frank, and interesting, which is he said i realize that i'm very good on policy but i sometimes don't give any thought to the optics of situations. and it's actually true. you think about his campaign -- >> yes. >> but once he began governing, he sort of approaches it more like a policy one. it strangely seemed to miss in
5:38 pm
this particular case. the policy was the symbol. the symbolism was policy. and not to be there, not to demonstrate that unity was a mistake. not just of optics but actually of the substance here. >> i think fareed it goes beyond the optics and that's the humanity. when people are killed in this way, and the world unites. we've never seen such a massive demonstration in france such an emotional component. >> the policy let's look forward. what happens now? you now have a situation in france where you have 10,000 troops deployed. unprecedented security operation going on in france. obviously u.s. intelligence has got to be extremely concerned about this. i don't know if the chance of an attack in the united states has gone up or because of the focus it has reduced. what do you think? >> well i think first of all, we ought to give credit to the administration to the president today when they reversed themselves and said they made a mistake. how refreshing. when was the last time someone in power -- >> nobody says that in politics.
5:39 pm
>> nobody ever says it, we made a mistake. and beyond that i would assume that this is a moment when the united states in a leadership role with france can help pull the nation more closely together in terms of borders. the french can't handle these thousands of people who have in one way or another engaged -- they couldn't keep up with these folks because there were so many different potential threats. the border is really important. to me the other question is what does it mean for the united states. and do you think there are chances of an attack in the united states has gone up? >> i do. the officials i've talked to said they're surprised this has not occurred already in the united states. >> it clearly has gone up. there really is a copycat phenomenon. but the big difference let's remember that the united states does not have a large disgruntled radicalized muslim or arab community. >> not only is it a better
5:40 pm
assimilated population here but also just though the borders -- we have obviously have problems on the southern border to have to fly to the united states. there are no-fly lists, whereas in western europe you can travel by train, you can travel by car. there's basically virtually no borders, and that makes it far easier for people to get around. >> it does. but if we've got that many people floating around we're going to have problem, too. >> it is a weapon of the weak. part of the objective of it is to get an overreaction so that you actually further polarize the sides. i think that's some of what's at the -- some of what these terrorists want is get the overreaction to get a war between islam and the west and getting people using that kind of rhetoric. that feeds into what the terrorists -- the messages of the terrorists. >> if their effort is to divide what's so important about that mass rally yesterday was how
5:41 pm
massive it was. when you have three-man people four-man people walking all over france joined by people from all over the world, that sends an extraordinarily important signal. >> the point anderson is making is terrorism is a tactic that depends on the response of the onlookers. >> absolutely. >> if you are not terrorized it didn't work. >> but they were saying we're not afraid. >> the signal of that is crucial to success. >> thank you. we have to leave it there. the latest on some of the other stories we're following. amber walker has a 360 bulletin. >> the twitter account for the u.s. military central command is suspended after being hacked by isis sympathizers. no classified information was taken. and a 360 follow to albuquerque, new mexico police who shot to death a mentally ill homeless man in the back will
5:42 pm
face murder charges. they killed james boyd when they confronted him about the illegal camp he set up last march. the shooting was captured on an officer's helmet camera. the new york clinic where joan rivers suffered a fatal complication during a vocal cord surgery will lose accreditation at the end of the month. no federal funds to cover for medicare and medicaid patients at the clinic. they will appeal the decision. rivers died in september, a week after going into cardiac arrest at the clinic. she was 81. a former miami dolphins fullback has an extraordinary story of survival. robert conrad fought back tears at a news conference in florida today. conrad said he fell off his boat last wednesday, swam milesylesiles in about 16 hours. incredible story of survival.
5:43 pm
>> amara, thanks very much. the story of a radical islamist turned double agent is now lifting the lid on some of the world's best-kept secrets. a double agent inside al qaeda for the cia coming up at 9:00 p.m. eastern here on cnn. up next on this program, breaking news reuters now reporting searchers have retrieved both black boxes from the airasia flight 8501. it said the plane exploded after it hit the water.
5:44 pm
the world is filled with air. but for people with copd sometimes breathing air can be difficult. if you have copd, ask your doctor about once-daily anoro ellipta. it helps people with copd breathe better for a full 24hours. anoro ellipta is the first fda-approved product containing two long-acting bronchodilators in one inhaler. anoro is not for asthma. anoro contains a type of medicine that increases risk of death in people with asthma. it is not known if this risk is increased in copd. anoro won't replace rescue inhalers for sudden copd symptoms and should not be used more than once a day. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition, or high blood pressure. tell your doctor if you have glaucoma, prostate or bladder problems, or problems passing urine as anoro may make these problems worse. call your doctor right away if you have worsened breathing chest pain, swelling of your mouth or tongue, problems urinating or eye problems including vision changes or eye pain while taking anoro. nothing can reverse copd.
5:45 pm
the world is filled with air and anoro is helping people with copd breath air better. get your first prescription free at anoro.com. i've been called a control freak... i like to think of myself as more of a control... enthusiast. mmm, a perfect 177-degrees. and that's why this road warrior rents from national. i can bypass the counter and go straight to my car. and i don't have to talk to any humans,
5:46 pm
unless i want to. and i don't. and national lets me choose any car in the aisle. control. it's so, what's the word?... sexy. go national. go like a pro. [ male announcer ] this is the cat that drank the milk... [ meows ] ...and let in the dog that woke the man who drove to the control room [ woman ] driverless mode engaged. find parking space. [ woman ] parking space found. [ male announcer ] ...that secured the data that directed the turbines that powered the farm that made the milk that went to the store that reminded the man to buy the milk that was poured by the girl who loved the cat. [ meows ] the internet of everything is changing everything. cisco. tomorrow starts here. tripadvisor not only has millions of real traveler's reviews and opinions but checks hundreds of websites, so people can get the best hotel prices. to plan, compare & book the perfect trip visit tripadvisor.com today.
5:47 pm
big discovery in the flight of 8501. divers found the flight data recorder under one of the wreckage of the plane's wings. the cockpit voice recorder was also located in the debris. it's also been retrieved according to reuters. the black boxes could be the key to solving the mystery of what actually brought the flight down last month. meanwhile, an official with the indonesian rescue agency is telling cnn analysis of the debris pattern indicates the plane exploded after it hit the water. joining me now is safety analyst david sousi and richard quest. richard, in terms of the information one can get off the
5:48 pm
black boxes, i know it's not completely everything but basically what is it? >> oh it's everything. this is going to tell you -- you've got the flight data recorder and you've got the cockpit voice recorder. you can marry it up with what the timeline of what the weather was doing at the same time so you get a full picture of what was going on on the aircraft. i would be astonished if they did not as a result of this information get chapter and verse of what happened in that plane. >> how long does it take to get that information from the black boxes? >> getting the information, the data doesn't take very long at all. what takes the time is the analysis of the data and recreating the accident after the fact. which they have software now that will do that. it takes the data actually creates a three-dimensional model, a picture of what the aircraft was doing at the time. that can take as much as weesks and even a month or two. but we may not see it then because a lot of times they won't release that information
5:49 pm
specifically until they've made a determination on the cause. >> do you think it might be quicker than that? >> this is something that david and i have discussed many times. this is the united states. and the ntsb. you look at all the incidents, the ntsb will be out very quickly, giving us a pretty good thumbnail sketch of what had happened. almost in decent haste to give out the information. indonesia, we may find them playing much harder towards the rules of their team, which is very restrictive. but the u.s. has changed the procedures hugely in the way people do these things. >> richard, we talk about the data from this. what does it actually look like? is it just computerized? obviously the flight voice recorder is digitized. >> it is. you then put it into a graph. and you can see the various movements that have been made by the different control surfaces. and you'll be told which pilot made them. if you then put on top of that
5:50 pm
the voice recorder second by second millisecond by millisecond, you get this total picture. >> the voice recorder david, picks up anything that was said in the cockpit. an intercom doesn't have to be flipped on it automatically records what was said? >> there's actually three microphones, anderson. one is on the co-pilot one is on the pilot, and one for an ambience in the cabin. that can pick up noises like switches being thrown. you can anticipate how large hail is if it hits the windshield just from the sound of how it hits the windshield. >> what do you think, david, of this report from the one indonesian official who says they believe the plane broke up after it hit the water? or exploded after it hit the water? >> well the word exploded i think is a little bit -- maybe loses a little in translation. i think what he's meaning is a rupture from the impact itself as you can imagine any hollow
5:51 pm
object hitting something very hard. the pressure differential between the outside and inside is very significant and will tear apart the aircraft on the top. >> so that's pretty obvious. when it hits the water it would break apart and destruct wouldn't it? >> well yeah except it tells you something about the way it hit the water. if it goes in nose first, it would be torn in a different way than it is now as you look at it being pulled out of the water. the caution here is that if you look at it being pulled out of the water, a lot of damage happens if you don't pull it out properly. sometimes in the haste of getting the thing out of the water and up from the ocean, they can lift it up too quickly and that can cause some subsequent damage. a lot of the investigation is just determining what happened during the accident and what happened afterwards which requires a microscopic look at that metal to see if it was a rapid rupture or if it was something torn later. >> richard, you and i were talking earlier about how military planes have black boxes
5:52 pm
eject before a crash, so they're much more easily retrieved. i understand the airbus has now actually asked for, among international regulators, to actually get ejectable black boxes. >> they're exploring, in the last 24 hours, they've discussed this. they are exploring putting ejectable black boxes, recorders on the a-350. the reason is the primary long haul aircraft. >> david, this seems an obvious thing to do no? >> it does. the nice thing about these things in fact is that it goes beyond the black box. with the black box, the proximity to the underwater locator beacon is all we have. in these devices you have a box sends out a transmitter signal. that's picked up by satellites that are constantly monitoring. it would be important because you can triangulate where the position is on that device
5:53 pm
within seconds. you could tell exactly where that is. and this mystery of this if people survived or not, rescuable or not, would all be answered if that was able to be retrieved immediately. >> what does that stand for? a beacon? >> it's emergency position indicator radio beacon. >> okay. wow. that was not an attempt to stump you, i was genuinely curious. david, richard, thank you. amazing show of solidarity in france. we'll have the sights and sounds of the march that drew so many people to the streets of paris and all over france. vo: 85 percent of people who travel will go someplace they've already been. where's the fun in that? it's time to find someplace new. book the hotel you want with the flight you want and we'll find the savings to get you there.
5:54 pm
you pay for you data every month. so why does your carrier take back what you don't use? it's your data. now at t-mobile, all your unused data rolls forward to the next month. and we'll even get you started with 10gb of free 4g lte data. (prof. burke) the more you learn about your insurance the more gaps you may find. like how you thought you were covered for this... (pirate) ahh, haha! (prof. burke) ...when you're really
5:55 pm
5:56 pm
5:57 pm
french people with the french values. you know this nation has -- you know this nation has a lot behind it. you know achieving these values. i may disagree with you, but i would die defending your right to say it. >> >> we are all shocked by what has happened. it's a worldwide movement. for myself i always demonstrate for a better world. and the planet for suffering of all sorts. >> nationality doesn't matter religions don't matter we want to show the world we are
5:58 pm
fighting against them. we will never give up. >> wow. what a day. we'll see you again at 11:00 p.m. eastern. inside al qaeda for the cia starts now. -- captions by vitac -- www.vitac.com for half a decade he said he moved back and forth between two worlds, and two identities. when one misplaced sentence could have cost him his life. >> you don't know what angle he's playing. >> traveling between atheism, english and arabic. >> one minute he's 007, on the other side he's now parted ofpart of the militant
190 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN (San Francisco)Uploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=1626694341)