tv Smerconish CNN April 4, 2015 6:00am-7:01am PDT
6:00 am
good? they are. the problem is on a lot of teams the list is like this and it's like this for kentucky so it is a challenge. >> we take pride in the fact that we're kind of misfits who not everyone wanted coming out of high school. we came together and had a goal and worked as hard as we could to achieve those goals. >> they get started at 6:00 eastern on tbs. duke followed by kentucky taking on wisconsin. we're going to get you ready here on cnn at 2:30 eastern with all access at the final four cnn, talking to all of the coaches in the final four and talk about the role sports played in the religious freedom law in indiana. >> thank you so much. stay with us. "smerconish" is starting for you next. i'm michael smerconish. the battle between religious
6:01 am
rights and gay rights exploded this week. and in attempt to quiet the uproar the governors of arkansas and indiana signed fixed versions of their state's religious freedom laws. potential 2016 presidential candidate and ordained baptist minister mike huckabee has taken a hard stance saying the gay community won't rest until quote there are no more churches. governor huckabee thank you for being here and happy easter. >> michael, great to be with you. thank you very much. happy easter to you. >> thank you, sir. the question of the week should the baker have to bake the cake for the gay couple? >> well i think the question is really whether or not a person of conscience is able to say no to something. this is not about discrimination it's about discretion. the fact is if the baker said no you can't come into my shop you can't eat a cupcake, i'm not going to serve you a donut that's discrimination. but if the baker is asked to do something that would require him
6:02 am
to do something artistic that is the not within his personal convictions, of course he should be able to say i can do this but i can't do that. that would be true for anyone. >> how would you distinctguish that from the lunch counter circa 1960 with an african-american patron? >> i don't think there is any -- any comparison michael. i think it's a false parallel. if a person walks into a lunch counter, he doesn't walk in saying i'm gay, don't serve me. there is no one suggesting that a person is going to be turned away because of sexual preference. i mean i don't know of anybody who can say that's happening in great numbers or at all for that matter. but we're talking about is whether people who have a business and are asked to participate in a service ceremony or something along the lines of that have the artistic freedom to decline.
6:03 am
try going to a muslim bakery and seeing whether or not they will do a same-sex wedding cake. so it's not just christians but the issue is religious liberty. whether or not people have a right to believe what they want to believe, practice their faith, and not have the government come down on them and tell them they have to do something and beyond that to try to have people put them out of business because they don't agree with a particular view of marriage. i find that very strange that in america where we're supposed to be tolerant and have die strersty this is intolerance and a lack of die strersty and a push to uniformity. >> you said earlier this week it won't stop until there are no more churches and occurred to me and i listened to the interview, that in this particular instance it wasn't the lgbt community that i think caused the reversal in both arkansas and indiana, but rather business interests.
6:04 am
traditionally republican supporting business interests. whether it's entities like walmart in your home state, angie's list in indiana, react to that alliance the alliance between the gay lesbian community and transgenders and the business entipties that would have been in the chamber of commerce realm with the gop. >> michael, first of all, the reason that those corporations put the pressure on indiana and arkansas was because militant gay community put the pressure on them. i found it a little hypocritical when you have companies even and i love walmart, big company in my home state, but they do business in china for gosh sake. i don't think the chinese are exactly the pair agone of human rights. you've got apple compute e they are selling apple computers in saudi arabia. is tim cook going to pull out of there? i don't think so. he doesn't mind making millions if not billions of dollars in cultures and countries where human rights are really an
6:05 am
issue. and for anybody to try to draw some comparison between what's happening by not getting a wedding cake made and people having their hands cut off or being hanged or imprisoned. i mean i find that a stretch and i think these corporations really ought to either be consistent quit making money from these countries that are really oppressing human rights and quit bowing to the pressure and just sell their stuff. that's what they are in business for. sell stuff. >> that's the argument -- governor that's the argument that is made from the other side about the baker and the florist and the candle stick maker. you're in business to bake the cake. and go home and be a good christian. whatever that means. >> a lot of people will do that they will bake the cake. shouldn't they have the discretion. that's really once again the issue. if they want to turn the business down they are not turning down the business of being open being willing to serve any customer what they have got on the shelf.
6:06 am
again it's the religious liberty when people are asked to do something which they believe violates their conscience and the big, to me confusion over riffa was it didn't garnl tee the baker, the florist, the pizza maker for that matter was going to win. it meant he would have a hearing in court and over the the 22 years that it has been in place, very few times has the religious objector even won. so i'm not sure why democrats loved riffra in 1993 and you had al gore and bill clinton trumpeting it and charles schumer sponsoring it. and 22 years later because of political pressure now they run from something they once embraced. i find it hypocritical. >> what's your opinion of the deal that's been announced that the parameters of the deal with regard to iran? >> very disappointing and frightening. i think particularly for the stabilization of the middle east. i'm not sure why we would ever think that negotiating with iran to begin with makes a lot of
6:07 am
sense since they never kept a deal they ever made. for them to have nuclear even capability is illegal for them to push that they are going to end up with 6,000 centrifuges instead of 19,000 michael it's like giving a pyro maniac 6,000 gallons of gasoline instead of 19,000. but he's still got a bunch of gasoline to start a fire. you're talking about a country whose primary leader has been leading chants death to america, and has vowed to wipe israel off the face of the map. that's not the kind of folks you want to make nice with and assume they are going to be keeping their bargain, i don't think they will. >> president obama said look there are three choices, one is to negotiate a deal such as now being put together. two is to bomb iran three is to walk away from the table. first of all, are those the three options, and if so which does governor huckabee haver? >> the president has missed one. the fourth one and one that was
6:08 am
working was to continue to put heavy sanctions on them and bankrupt them. force them to have to accept something other than now on their terms. i don't understand why we took the frsh off when the pressure was working. we really haven't gotten much out of this deal michael. it doesn't sound to me like that anything that's happening in tehran other than laughter but there is weeping in saudi arabia kuwait egypt and the rest of the middle east where they now understand that the americans have capitulated and let iran move forward. somebody who is a blogger made an observation this week i thought interesting that there has been more pressure to put sanction on indiana than iran. i thought that was a wise observation, it's a real almost distraction from something that is a whole lot more significant in terms of our national security than anything that's been occupying the front pages here. >> governor i want to show you something that the president said this week and allow you to respond. roll the tape please. >> so when you hear the
6:09 am
inevitable critics of the deal sound off, ask them a simple question. do you really think that this verifiable deal if the fully implemented backed by the world's major powers is a worse option than the risk of another war in the middle east? >> what's your response to that? >> first of all, i'm not sure how verifiable anything is with the iranians if the you think they are going to let inspectors see everything then you have a different view of the iranians than i do. and secondly the notion that the only option is either to bomb them and have a big war all over the middle east or let them have nuclear devices, if they get nuclear devices you think they are just going to sit and hold them and not use them for some nefarious purpose, the same people who have murdered americans, kidnapped americans, financed more terrorism around the world than anybody, funded hamas and hezbollah, these aren't good people. why we expect something good from bad people? we're expecting good fruit from
6:10 am
a bad tree and it rarely if ever will happen. >> i want to ask a question about your intentions with regard to 2016. first of all are you prepared to make news today? will you say you are formally getting into this thing? >> let's hold off a little while. we're working on the process, and it's coming along but i said all along it will be during the spring so that gives me a few more weeks to finalize the decision. >> all right. while you're working on the process, ted cruz senator cruz is airing the first commercial of the 2016 cycle. let's both take a look. >> were it not for the transformative love of jesus christ i would have been raised by a single mom without my father in the house. god's blessing has been on america from the very beginning of this nation. over the and over again when we failsed impossible odds, the american people rose to the challenge. this is our fight, and that is why i'm running for president of the united states.
6:11 am
i'm ted cruz and i approve this message. >> governor that's the type of message i anticipate coming from you and i think the problem politically is that it's also the type of message i anticipate from senator sanitorium ben carsen from a number of individuals who are thinking of running i'll say for the republican nomination. here is the question. if you are all in are you guaranteeing the nomination of jeb bush? >> i don't think so. i mean first of all, i don't remember doing many ads like that. i spoke a lot about joblessness, about the fact that people are working hard and getting further behind. i think the narrative on me is that the only support i had was evangelicals. i often said if all had supported me in a monolithic way my gosh i'd have been the nominee. i had working class people who were the rank and file the sort of nuts and bolts of my 2008 campaign. and i would suspect a lot of the support i'm going to have are going to be the same kind of people.
6:12 am
many of them yeah sure many of them are people of fathd but not all of them and a lot of them are just working class people who feel like they have been left behind and while the economy is supposedly recovering according to washington it's certainly not recovering for a lot of people across america who are lifting heavy things every day. >> governor huckabee thank you for your time. >> michael, great to be with you again. thank you. >> you too. coming up the showdown between gay rights and religious rights isn't just limited to wedding cakes and pizza. the stakes are higher once you are denied medical care. coming up the couple whose pediatrician refused to care for their newborn. stunning new details investigators are learning about the actions of the germanwings co-pilot in the days leading up to the fatal crash. and dozens of cell phones recovered from the crash site. what that means for the investigation. m caridee. i've had moderate to severe plaque psoriasis most my life. but that hasn't stopped me from modeling. my doctor told me about stelara®. it helps keep my skin clearer.
6:13 am
with only 4 doses a year after 2 starter doses... ... stelara® helps me be in season. stelara® may lower your ability to fight infections and increase your risk of infections. some serious infections require hospitalization. before starting stelara®... ...your doctor should test for tuberculosis. stelara® may increase your risk of cancer. always tell your doctor if you have any sign of infection, have had cancer, or if you develop any new skin growths. do not take stelara® if you are allergic to stelara® or any of its ingredients. alert your doctor of new or worsening problems including headaches, seizures, confusion and vision problems- these may be signs of a rare, potentially fatal brain condition. serious allergic reactions can occur. tell your doctor if you or anyone in your house needs or has recently received a vaccine. in a medical study most stelara® patients saw at least 75% clearer skin... ...and the majority were rated as cleared or minimal at 12 weeks. stelara® helps keep my skin clearer. ask your doctor about stelara®.
6:14 am
6:15 am
use jublia as instructed by your doctor. once applied jublia gets to the site of infection by going under, around and through the nail. most common side effects include ingrown toenail, application-site redness itching, swelling, burning or stinging, blisters, and pain. tackle it! ask your doctor now if jublia is right for you. okay, listen up! i'm re-workin' the menu. mayo? corn dogs? you are so outta here! aah! [ female announcer ] the complete balanced nutrition of great-tasting ensure. 24 vitamins and minerals antioxidants and 9 grams of protein. [ bottle ] ensure®. nutrition in charge™.
6:16 am
6:17 am
premeditated murder. one i haved the crash of flight 9525 and now we know new details about the co-pilot's deadly path. investigators say he used the controls to speed up the decent. officials say the 28-year-old researched ways to commit suicide and cockpit door security in the days before the crash. investigators are also taking a closer look at mobile phones found at the crash site. joining me now is a psychiatrist and former faa safety inspector. you two, you know i've got my questions. >> you do. >> doctor eight straight days of doing online research sounds likes a chronic suicidal i'diation and not a fleeting thought. is that typical? >> it depends. none of this is typical so it's not typical for mass murder this doesn't even fit the picture you know of depression and just suicidal ideation. but some people who commit
6:18 am
suicide do think about it quite a while, do plan and some people it's an impulsive act. this sounds like a planned act which has to make us think about whether if there had been some sort of evaluation present or whether there was some way to let doctors be able to communicate more effectively, this could have been prevented. >> how does this fit with a diagnosis of depression? >> it doesn't. most people who are depressed, if they are going to harm themselves, harm only themselves. they do not kill a large group of people. so this really doesn't fit. what does it fit with? you have to think about sosy esosh yopathy. they were willing to take themselves with that plan. and you also have to think about another diagnosis which no one mentioned. that is bipolar disorder. you look at his age and past history of depression one high risk possibility is that he wasn't just depressed but he was hatching what's called bipolar
6:19 am
disorder and episode of brewing mania or hypomania. people could become at high risk for suicide and at high risk for risky ventures. >> david, speeding up upon descent. how would that have felt in the cabin? >> well at that point in descent it would have been oppose owe they would have known what's going on. they would have heard the engine spooling up higher they would have felt the actual movement back in the seat because of the way that he didit. he increased the speed rapidly. and he did it twice. so he did that by adjusting the speed, there's three different controls that he can adjust the descent, the speed, and the attitude of the descent as well. it's tragic. it would have been noticeable. >> this black box actually was black, because it was submerged eight inches in the soil and my understanding is that it was detengted by law enforcement on
6:20 am
a second go round. i remember from many of our conversations about mh-370 how in water the black boxes were emitting a signal. why is that not done in this circumstance? >> it really should be. the difference in water is the fact it could be pretty much anywhere because of the drift and the float. in the idea here is that when the impact happens it's a heavy box it's going to go toward real close to the actual impact spot so typically it's easy to find. i'm not sure why they didn't use a metal detector in this sense because a massive piece of stainless steel like that or steel itself would have been noticeable. with a metal detector. you would look at all of this metal you think that doesn't make sense but most of the metal is there aluminum which wouldn't be picked up. so surprised they didn't catch it on the first pass. >> what else is this black box going to tell us? >> it will tell us a number of things. what i'm hopeful is that it will
6:21 am
tell us whether or not the switch was depressed and held in the down position. one of the things that remains a question is did the pilot have access to the system work where you put in the code and the door opens. balls there was no buzzer that went off which is what is part of that system. so if it did not go off that means that he was depressing that switch down. if we conclude that the switch was depressed then we don't have to look further into the door system to see if it worked properly. if it didn't work properly that's something that needs to be fixed and the flight data recorder will tell us if that happened or not. >> doctor i have just 30 seconds left. might medication have been a trigger? >> in some instance when's someone is depressed or manic and you give them an antidepressant and it's in the early stage it can stoke agitated feelings it can energize them it can actually aid in hatching a plan. i don't want to blame suicide on medication because it is critical and very helpful for many people. but in the earliest stages of medication someone should be
6:22 am
monitored closely because there can be some increased risk. >> as always thank you both. a framework is in place to stop iran's nuclear program, president obama has the tough task of trying to sell the deal to those who oppose it. and one of those voices is the first navy s.e.a.l. in the congress. he is passionate barometric pressure why he feels iran cannot be trusted. and as the final four get ready to battle it out the ncaa says in response to a lawsuit it's not our job to ensure educational quality. you are about to meet a man who gives new definition to the words student athlete.
6:23 am
6:24 am
and you've got to feed it with scotts turf builder. that a boy, mikey! two feedings now in the springtime strengthens and helps protect your lawn from future problems. get scotts turf builder lawn food. it's guaranteed. feed your lawn. feed it! and to keep crabgrass away all season long, get scotts turf builder with halts crabgrass preventer.
6:26 am
6:27 am
and the world are keeping a close eye on iran and he's optimistic this deal is the best option. joining me now is contributing et ter peter byner. many are trying to evaluate this deal. what should they be comparing it to? >> they should be comparing it to the potentialitytive. the alternative was the u.s. walks away in all likelihood the international sanctions regime collapses because russia and china have a strong interest in doing business with iran. they were not going to maintain sanctions forever in the absence of the possibility of a deal. and i think the pressure therefor on iran goes down and because we have no other alternative we move toward war. so i think while this deal is not perfect, it's far better than the alternative which would have led to the collapse of the sanctions regime and the collapse of the inspections that give us allow us to know something about what's actually happening with iran's nuclear program. >> i asked that question because
6:28 am
during the course of this week with my radio audience we had this same exchange and many people were calling and viewing it against the alternative of a complete eradication of the iranian nuclear program. to those you would say what? >> we don't have the capacity to destroy the iranian nuclear program completely. it's worth noting that under international law, the ieae iran does have the right to a peaceful nuclear program. we only have -- we can stop them from building a weapons program but they have every right to have a peaceful nuclear program. of course it's hashed to know where the line between one and the other is which is why it's so important we have these sanctions. but we don't have the capacity to force iran into complete capitulation, we tried that with iraq when iraq did not completely capitulate to us we tried invading and we did own the entire place but we saw what happened after that. >> let's work through some of the other criticisms. what stops iran from getting a nuclear weapon in 15 years?
6:29 am
>> well even after the the entire -- even after 15 years iran as long as it's still a member of the ieae will be subject to international inspections. they will be subject to the same inspections that everyone else is. for the next 15 years they are subject to these super heightened inspections that other countries don't have to go through. we don't know it's conceivable iran 15 years later could be cheating and playing hide and seek with inspectors but i think that the bed of this deal is that an opening of iran to the rest of the world is more likely to produce political change in iran and part of the reason we're so concerned about iranian nuclear weapon is balls of the nature of this regime. you look at the iranian people celebrating out in the streets, they are not celebrating because of the technical details of this deal. they are celebrating because they know that the possibility of an opening to the world will help them economically and it
6:30 am
will help them politically, empower them and disempower their oppressors in this regime. >> what if it helps them economically as you say and they use that funding to support sides that are antagonistic to the united states around the globe? >> well they may well do that. our own allies like saudi arabia qatar, also support groups around the world that are antagonistic to us. iran supports the houthis in yemen but some of our gulf allies support geejihadists. this deal does not solve all of america's problems with iran. but it does create the basis for a dialogue conversation with iran and i think it makes the price of iranian bad behavior higher because then iran jeopardizes the relationship they now potentially have p with the rest of the world. >> prime minister benjamin netanyahu said he views this as a threat to the survival of israel. dutz he have the political power
6:31 am
to disrail, derail pardon me this deal? >> i don't think so. first of all i think it's important to note that while benjamin netanyahu was repeatedly called iran an existential threat several officials in the israeli security establishment said in fact that's not true that while they see iran's nuclear -- potential nuclear weapon a threat they don't believe it is it's not a threat to israel's survival. israel is a country with a couple of hundred nuclear weapons. why are they there? but for deterrence to deter any country that could develop a nuclear weapon from using it. i think that's the perspective that many in the israeli security establishment see this through. >> final question was prime minister netanyahu of benefit to the americans in this negotiation? i know you paid close attention to what was going on in switzerland. was there a good cop, bad cop routine that secretary kerry was able to play out? >> it's a good question.
6:32 am
it's hard to really know. i don't know enough about the thinking on the iranian side to know that. what i do know is that i think benjamin netanyahu was actually made it easier for barack obama to sell this deal at home. he has made the fight over this deal so partisan that i think it's made it harder for democrats to ultimately oppose barack obama on what will be the signature foreign policy initiative of his administration and it is democrats that the opponents of this deal need if they are going to override obama veto. i think netanyahu has made that prospect harder. >> thank you so much. happy passover. >> thank you. so has netanyahu made it easier for obama to sell this deal? has the deal become so partisan that democrats can't oppose it? joining me is the first navy s.e.a.l. elected to the house, a member of the armed services committee republican congressman ryan zinke. please react to what you heard.
6:33 am
>> i think it's a false narrative. the negotiations should be clear, no legal pathway for iran to have a nuclear device. no enrichment of uranium, no facilities that can be used to have a nuclear device and robust inspections from our perspective i think that's fair. and above board. we're talking about a nuclear armed iran which will almost surely result in a nuclear arms race in the middle east with saudi, perhaps uae, turkey jordan all having nuclear weapons. in an area that's notoriously unstable. so i think that -- congress we have a right under the constitution, the president has the power, but certainly congress has the advise and consent of a treaty under the constitution and will exercise it. >> congressman, the president said this week any critic of the
6:34 am
deal and you're in that category needs to answer the question of why a verifiable deal is worse as an option than the risk of another war in the middle east? respond to the president. >> i think it's a false narrative. one is the devil is in the details. cleaverly, there's celebration in the streets of iran. there is very somber in israel and we don't know the details of the framework are here. so i think the president should by constitution consult congress we should look at the details and make assure that this is not a legal pathway for iran to have a nuclear weapon. but it's a false narrative saying that sanctions didn't work. sanctions were to the point that's why iran came to the table. so it's not a question of war. that's a false narrative. the question is what can we do what do we have the capacity to do sanctions certainly worked before and if this deal is bad, we shouldn't take it. we don't have to take a bad deal. we don't have to have a path
6:35 am
where iran has a nuclear weapon. >> it's also been pointed out this week that a military option if it were exercised and you're not advocating that i understand but you have expertise, that's why i want to ask you, that a military option would probably wipe out an iranian nuclear capability for a period of two or three years, viewed against this prospect of 15 years of no iranian nuclear capability. doesn't that make this proposal more appetizing? >> well no. we're talking about iran having a nuclear weapon. this is a khomeini regime which had multiple times has said they would want america destroyed. if you're looking at iran through a lens of are they a responsible nation state? has their conduct been one that would suggest they should have a path to a nuclear weapon? and the answer most assuredly is
6:36 am
no. this is iran. one of the funders of worldwide terrorism. wasn't that long ago when remember the hostage taking action remember beirut remember africa remember iraq in the war. you have embedded troops right now, iranian troops in the territory of iraq. so i don't think it's a good idea it's not in our best interest given this state is also oil rich amend has gas, they don't need a nuclear capability. i think the only reason why they have they are approaching a nuclear capability as far as power goes is to generate enough material to make a nuclear weapon. >> congressman, thank you so much for being here sir. >> always a pleasure. coming up next while college basketball's elite gear up for the final four the ncaa prepares for a showdown of its own. the surprising statement that sparked a major backlash.
6:37 am
i take prilosec otc each morning for my frequent heartburn. because it gives me... zero heartburn! prilosec otc. the number 1 doctor-recommended frequent heartburn medicine for 9 straight years. one pill each morning. 24 hours. zero heartburn. [ male announcer ] you wouldn't leave your car unprotected. but a lot of us leave our identities unprotected. nearly half a million cars were stolen in 2012. but for every car stolen 34 people had their identities stolen. identity thieves can steal your money damage your credit and wreak havoc on your life.
6:38 am
why risk it when you can help protect yourself from identity theft with one call to lifelock, a leader in identity theft protection? lifelock actively patrols your sensitive personal information helping to guard your social security number, your bank accounts and credit, even the equity in your home. your valuable personal assets! look, your credit card company may alert you to suspicious activity on the accounts you have with them, but that still may leave you vulnerable to big losses if a thief opens new accounts in your name or decides to drain your savings, home equity, or retirement accounts. and your credit report may only tell you after your identity has been compromised. but lifelock is proactive protection and watches out for you in ways that banks and credit card companies alone just can't giving you comprehensive identity theft protection. the patented lifelock identity alert® system looks for threats to your identity helping to protect your finances and credit. you even get a $1 million service guarantee.
6:39 am
that's right. if your identity is ever compromised lifelock will spend up to $1 million dollars on experts to help restore it. you wouldn't leave your car unprotected. don't leave your money, credit and good name unprotected. call now and try lifelock risk-free for 60 days. act now and get this document shredder free -- a $29 value -- when you use promo code "go." or go to lifelock.com/go. try lifelock risk-free for 60 days and get this document shredder free -- a $29 value -- when you use promo code "go." that's promo code "go." call now!
6:40 am
6:41 am
four. but despite the excitement in the arena a dark cloud is hanging over the nca, a, in response to a lawsuit filed by former university of north carolina athletes the ncaa has said it's not their job to ensure educational quality. well my next guest knows all too well about balancing academics and the pressure of sports at a high level. myron played at florida state university is a rhodes scholar, played in the nfl and now a medical student. thanks for being here. is there more that the ncaa can do they say we don't have day-to-day responsibility for what happens in the classroom. >> well thank you for having me. i do believe there's more that the ncaa can do as well as individual institutions. i think that once the ncaa and institutions realize that this once amateur model of college sports no longer exists i think that's when we can make real progress. as you said i'm a second year medical student to be a pediatric neurosurgeon.
6:42 am
if the i see a patient and this patient has all of the clinical signs of some kind of pneumonia i say this is lowbar pneumonia. the physician says it's a broken foot. i think that's the same thing to the ncaa. they are denying that there is so much money and pressure and highlights and exposure for these young athletes that it's bordering on professionalism. >> the rhodes scholarship application process is legendary for its rigorous nature. what was the reaction of your football coaches in college when they became aware of the fact you were making that application? >> well i wanted to do the rhodes scholarship since i heard about bill bradley. i had a chance to hear about bill bradley's awesomeness, basically, in college and in being a rock star in that respect. when i got to florida state i went to the office of national fellowships and said look, i want to be a rhodes scholar like
6:43 am
bill bradley. when i applied as you said it's intense, you have to go through many interviews write a personal statement that tells the trust why you want to be a rhodes scholar and how this education kand help your interests moving forward. there was a little resistance from coaches but for the most part i got a lot of support from florida state, teammates, faculty, they felt if i did well and i showed that you can actually balance academics and athletics in a major division 1 college institution like florida state, then that would be good for the program that could be good for student athletes and good all the way around. so they told me i can go interview for the scholarship. i had to win it. i did did and it's a remarkable thing for me. >> when you delayed your entry to the nfl was the nfl as understanding as the coaches that you just described? >> not at first. i believe some people in the nfl are used to a certain athlete, they are used to a certain
6:44 am
player and when there is a player that comes from a different sort of frame of mind has a bit of a different ideology and doesn't have i would say 100% you know outlook or perspective on just football. i was somebody and my parents wanted me to have a breadth of knowledge. football was a part of my person but it didn't describe all of me. so i received a little resistance more from the nfl. it was a great opportunity to play at the highest level and am i got out the game healthy, safe hands good so i can operate in the future and excited about the choices i've been able to make. >> there is so much money wrapped up in the final four which as you know tips off this evening. and some say that ought to be shared with the athletes response is the athletes get paid in terms of scholarships for education. what's your take on that issue? >> you see, i got to florida
6:45 am
state with a framework and structure and support from family that could help my journey. i came in with a good vision to understanding not only come into this school to play football and do well but also to gain and accrue intellectual capital, to enrich my experience. whether i played football or went on to be a doctor i was going to be ready to take on the world. a lot of my teammates and classmates didn't have that same support. so i believe that ncaa and some institutions should fill that void that some of these athletes are missing in their life and whether it's paying players directly making them millionaires i'm not sold on that idea. but perhaps putting a fund together to help these athletes reach their goals. i think that's a good request idea. >> final question. yes or no. jameis winston, round one? >> round one and first overall pick. no question. >> whoa. okay. dr. rolle wanted in surgery. thank you.
6:46 am
>> thank you, michael. appreciate it. >> coming up it's one thing to refuse wedding-related services to same-sex couples for religious reasons. it's another when a pediatrician tells you she can't care for your newborn baby. that's what one michigan couple says happened to them and their story is next. honey. the setting is perfect. but then erectile dysfunction happens again. plenty of guys have this issue not just getting an erection, but keeping it. well, viagra helps guys with ed get and keep an erection. and you only take it when you need it. ask your doctor if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take viagra if you take nitrates for chest pain; it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. side effects include headache, flushing upset stomach and abnormal vision. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. stop taking viagra and call your doctor right away if you experience a sudden decrease or loss in vision or hearing. ask your doctor if...
6:47 am
...viagra is right for you. ♪ ♪ the pursuit of healthier. it begins from the second we're born. after all, healthier doesn't happen all by itself. it needs to be earned... every day... from the smallest detail to the boldest leap. healthier means using wellness to keep away illness... knowing a prescription is way more than the pills... and believing that a single life can be made better by millions of others. healthier takes somebody who can power modern health care... by connecting every single part of it. realizing cold hard data can inspire warmth and compassion... and that when technology meets expertise... everything is possible. for as long as the world keeps on searching for healthier... we're here to make healthier happen. optum. healthier is here.
6:48 am
6:51 am
welcome back to the program. the debate over religious freedom and gay rights sparked all kinds of talk about flowers and cakes and even pizza but what if a pediatrician said she couldn't care for your child because of religious reasons? krista contreras and her wife jamie say that happened to them. the physician refused to treat their newborn daughter because they're gay. i spoke to them recently. krista and jamie contreras and their daughter, meg, all three join me now. thank you so much for being here. when you interviewed the pediatrician before the birth of bay, were there any signs of trouble? >> no. we really liked her. we thought she really liked us. we really didn't have any clue that she had a problem with our sexual orientation. >> so bay is then born and at age 6 days time for her first pediatric visit. what happened? >> well we go into the room
6:52 am
right when we got there and we were just waiting for dr. roy and, a different doctor came in and said i will be the one seeing you today, dr. roy had prayed on it and she decided she won't be able to care for bay and take her on as a patient. >> did you know what that meant, did you recognize those words, prayed on it to be a reflection of the doctor's view of your sexuality? >> yes. she made it pretty clear. she said she prayed on it and she followed it up by saying i don't care. i'll take care of anyone as long as they're loving parents i'll care for any baby so she really kind of explained it in a round-about way of what she meant by that. so we really could recognize the red flag there, that there was an issue with our sexuality. >> eventually and it's not immediately but eventually you get an apology letter from the pediatrician which i'm going to show the audience now and there are two lines i want to focus on. first of all, one line says
6:53 am
after much prayer following your prenatal, i felt that i would not be able to develop the personal patient/doctor relationship that i normally do with my patients. this was intended to be a wholistic approach. at some level did you say i guess we're glad she told us because we wanted a full sense of care for the family unit not just for baby bay. >> yes, definitely we're glad we're not in the care of a doctor that doesn't support our family. it would have been really nice of her to let us know that ahead of time. i don't know that we would be sitting here right now if she had let us know ahead of time. i'm sure it would have hurt and we wouldn't have been very happy with it but at least we could have tpd on to our plan to continue to meet with pediatricians and find the one that was a good fit. >> help me interpret another line in the apology letter "i believe that god gives us free choice and i would never judge anyone based on what they do with that free choice."
6:54 am
what choice is she referring to? >> obviously she makes it pretty clear especially with the "prayed about it" line she's referring to us being gay and basically saying that we chose our sexual orientation, so you know that word really jumped out of the page at us you know. if that's what she believes that's what she believes. that's her belief but you know to say she doesn't judge us by that she's definitely judging by that and saying that we chose this lifestyle, but you know bay didn't choose anything so even if you do believe that bay is sitting here as a 6-day-old baby because her parents are, you know gay that you can't care for her. and it was interesting. >> i want to make something else clear, jamie and krista. there's no litigation pending, there's no litigation contemplated. you're here today to build awareness of an important issue.
6:55 am
explain. >> yes, so basically in michigan this is totally cool like it's legal. she did nothing wrong according to our laws and we just want to you know we think, yes, bay was 6 days when we were sitting in that doctor's appointment but what if she was 6 years old and asking why is my family being treated differently than any other family? and not understanding. so what we really want to do is raise awareness to the status of the laws currently are and hope to change those lives so add lgbt protections to different laws in the state of michigan and hopefully around the country. >> only 22 states prohibit the type of conduct that we're discussing and there's no federal law on the books that gufz protection to your family unit in a circumstance like this. >> yes. you know and right now michigan also has a law on the table the
6:56 am
religious freedom act on the table being discussed. if that goes through it futhers the doctors' rights to keep discriminating and any business to say here is a license to discriminate however and whoever you want. i think we really need to be aware of what laws are being passed right now. all we need is a history book that shows that this isn't going to better our society for anyone involved. we just want to make people aware that this is happening to families like ours and others like ours all around the country. >> jamie and krista best of luck all good health with bay and thank you so much. >> thank you. >> thank you for having us. >> thank you for sharing our story. >> yes, we really appreciate it. i'll be right back.
6:57 am
i'm caridee. i've had moderate to severe plaque psoriasis most my life. but that hasn't stopped me from modeling. my doctor told me about stelara®. it helps keep my skin clearer. with only 4 doses a year after 2 starter doses... ... stelara® helps me be in season. stelara® may lower your ability to fight infections and increase your risk of infections. some serious infections require hospitalization. before starting stelara®... ...your doctor should test for tuberculosis. stelara® may increase your risk of cancer. always tell your doctor if you have any sign of infection, have had cancer, or if you develop any new skin growths. do not take stelara® if you are allergic to stelara® or any of its ingredients. alert your doctor of new or worsening problems including headaches, seizures, confusion and vision problems- these may be signs of a rare, potentially fatal brain condition. serious allergic reactions can occur. tell your doctor if you or anyone
6:58 am
in your house needs or has recently received a vaccine. in a medical study most stelara® patients saw at least 75% clearer skin... ...and the majority were rated as cleared or minimal at 12 weeks. stelara® helps keep my skin clearer. ask your doctor about stelara®. how can you just stand there? what do you mean? your grass man, it's famished. with just two springtime feedings with scotts turf builder lawn food helps strengthen and protects your lawn from future problems. thanks scott. feed your lawn. feed it!
7:00 am
105 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN (San Francisco)Uploaded by TV Archive on
