tv Forensic Files CNN May 30, 2015 10:00pm-10:31pm PDT
10:00 pm
pixie glitter. that was amazing that they could put those pieces of pixie glitter together and show that it had been located in all those different areas and it was consistent amongst each other. up next -- a young aspiring singer disappears. >> a telltale sign of somebody who is running away from something. >> she had a history of running away. she has always come back. >> surveillance cameras tell at least part of the story. >> when i saw the video, i started feeling very confident that we were focusing on the right guy. >> all they had to do now was to find him. ♪ i wanna love someone who'll stand by my side ♪ >> 16-year-old joshan ashbrook had dreams of stardom.
10:01 pm
>> her sister and joshan used to write songs, different little lyrics and things and they wrote one song called "wanna." ♪ i wanna love you but could you love me too i feel so safe when i'm with you, i wanna love you ♪ >> and joshan sang this song and they really wanted to get it recorded and to do something nice with it. and she just didn't get the chance to finish that. >> and if a singing career didn't work out, she had a backup plan. >> joshan wanted to be an entertainment lawyer so she could make deals and make everybody happy. >> like many teenagers, joshan had her share of conflicts with her parents. but they were usually resolved. >> joshan had a history of running away. normally she would run away, spend the night somewhere else and come home the following day or maybe two days later. >> but after an argument with her parents about smoking marijuana, she left. this time, for good.
10:02 pm
>> joshan's parents were very concerned about her. they were aware she had substance abuse problems. >> her parents notified the police, called all of her friends, and went to all of her known hangouts. >> towards the end of the evening, it was more frustrating. because it was like we had no other leads. we had nowhere else to go. we couldn't think of any other places or any other people to talk to. >> the next morning, electricians working for the power company spotted a woman's body off the side of the road outside of tampa, florida. the body was identified as joshan ashbrook. >> you could see that her throat was cut, blunt trauma to her face, her head. there were cuts, defensive wounds on her hands. >> joshan's pants weren't found at the scene. >> looking at her body, being nude from the waist down, you cannot help think that maybe she was sexually assaulted. >> gosh, i don't know how to
10:03 pm
describe that feeling. i'm never going to see my daughter get married or have babies. i'm never going to hold her first child. and i'm never going to see her make her dreams come true. >> investigators found a single hair in a defensive wound on joshan's thumb. >> it appeared that this might be the hair from her attacker. like if she went to grab him and when she was fighting him, and she grabbed him and it just got embedded in there. >> the hair had the root intact. about 30 feet from the body were fresh tire tracks. >> it was obvious that whoever was driving that vehicle backed into the area and then dragged her body into the woods. >> the tire tracks were in the sand, a surface ideal for making plaster casts. >> these were so clear, i could
10:04 pm
say that there was not any rain had occurred or any damage in the environment at that time. because they were such nice, clear, quality impressions. >> no one knew of anyone who wanted to harm joshan, but for investigators, these clues were a very good start. i am rich. on the grounds of my estate, i hob nob with the glitterati and play equestrian sports. out on the veranda, we enjoy finger sandwiches and other assorted dainties. i wear nothing less than the finest designer footwear. wherever i go, the paparazzi capture my every move. yes, i am rich. that's why i drink the champagne of beers. but i've managed.e crohn's disease is tough, except that managing my symptoms was all i was doing. and when i finally told my doctor,
10:05 pm
he said humira is for adults like me who have tried other medications but still experience the symptoms of moderate to severe crohn's disease. and that in clinical studies, the majority of patients on humira saw significant symptom relief. and many achieved remission. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. ask your gastroenterologist about humira. with humira, remission is possible. visit tripadvisor orlandondo
10:06 pm
10:07 pm
as police searched for joshan ashbrook's killer, the medical examiner learned that the knife wound to her throat was not the cause of death. >> the medical examiner explained that the suspect may have put her in some type of wrestling move, like a half nelson, and turned or put extreme pressure on her, which dislocated -- which broke her neck. >> an autopsy found no evidence of sexual assault. in a search for suspects, joshan's family suggested police interview john hansen, a 60-year-old family friend who lived nearby. >> john was an older gentleman who hung out at the house all the time with us. but, in my opinion, he seemed after awhile to get too close to the children. he always wanted to be their
10:08 pm
friend, more so than the friends of an adult. >> within 24 hours of finding joshan's body, investigators went to hansen's trailer to question him, but he was gone. >> we talked to the park manager and some of the neighbors and they said they hadn't seen him in a day or two. >> a background check revealed hansen, a day laborer, estranged from his wife, had no history of violence. >> a 60-year-old man, having teenagers visit the house and hang around, i think it does lead to suspicion as to what is going on. >> while police searched for hansen, criminalists measured the tire impressions found near joshan's body. those measurements and tread patterns were entered into a computer database of 20,000 different tires manufactured around the world. >> there was then seven different manufacture models that could have made that tire impression at the crime scene. different manufacturers
10:09 pm
sometimes sell their mold to other manufacturers, so therefore, you would have the same mold but yet under different manufacturer model names. >> all seven of these tire models were for larger vehicles, which meant joshan's killer was driving either a truck or an suv. then police got an important lead from a woman who saw joshan the day she ran away. >> hello? >> hi, it's joshan. >> she received a phone call from joshan about 8:30 in the morning on july 31st. >> joshan asked if she could come by and drop off a letter. >> within minutes, a red ford pickup pulls up, joshan gets out, runs to the door. >> the note was for the woman's son, max, who was joshan's boyfriend. >> it was, "hi. i miss you. i love you. i'll call you later." that type of note. >> she just appeared to be in a hurry and wanted to leave.
10:10 pm
>> the woman said the driver was a middle-aged white male, but she didn't get a good look at his face. she did, however, provide a valuable piece of information. >> max's mother provided us with the cell phone number that was on her caller i.d. >> when investigators called the number, a man answered the phone. >> we're able to get the person on the phone. he said his name was phillup thompson. and he was asked if he knew anybody by the name of joshan ashbrook, and if he had picked up anybody or knew this female. >> phillup thompson confirmed he and his daughter had picked up joshan when she was hitchhiking. >> hey, can i borrow your phone real quick? >> took her to her boyfriend's house to leave the note. >> sure. >> and then they dropped her off at the local walmart. >> and that is the last that he had seen of her. >> phillup thompson agreed to meet police later that day, but he failed to show up for his
10:11 pm
appointment. >> investigators looked at that as possibly, you know, a telltale sign of somebody, you know, who was running away from something. >> but police received some troubling news. the cell phone was not registered to phillup thompson. it was registered to phillup partin, a convicted killer. >> phillup partin was convicted of a murder that he committed in 1987 in which he strangled a man with a phone cord or some kind of cord. >> short version was that phillup partin was what they call a hustler, a male prostitute. he had picked up this gay math teacher at a local club. they went back to the teacher's place. something happened. partin beat him, strangled him to death with the telephone cord. once he killed him, he took his his wallet, money, credit cards, and got into the guy's car and drove off. >> partin was convicted of
10:12 pm
second degree murder, served six years in prison and was released in 1995. police believed that it was partin they had been speaking to about joshan. partin said he and his daughter dropped joshan off at this walmart the morning she disappeared. but that's not what store surveillance tapes showed. >> the walmart surveillance video shows them pulling in at around 8:48. you see the suspect, you see joshan, and you see the suspect's little girl. they spend five, ten minutes, purchase a couple of fishing items. and then they leave, get back in the vehicle, and drive off. >> the videotape left no doubt joshan was with partin, a convicted murderer, just hours before her body was found. >> when i saw the video, i started feeling very confident that we were focusing on the right guy. >> there was only one problem. where was he?
10:13 pm
hey, what are you doing? you said you were going to find out about plenti, the new rewards program. i did. in fact, i'm earning plenti points right now. but you're not doing anything right now. lily? he's right. sign up, and you could earn plenti points just for being a wireless customer. in the meantime, i just kick back and watch the points roll in. where did you get those noodles? at&t cafeteria. you mean the break room... at&t - the only wireless carrier to be a part of plenti, now when you add a new phone line to your wireless plan you get 5,000 plenti points to use in lots of places.
10:14 pm
ugh...you're the valet? yea, sorta the valet. both drive for a living, both like to save money on car insurance, and we both know you may not get this car back in the same condition. watch your toes. wo! ya boy... get it! sorta you isn't you. with drivesense from esurance, you can earn a personalized discount based on how you drive, not how someone sorta like you drives. you'll even get a discount just for signing up.
10:16 pm
10:17 pm
investigators learned that partin and his daughter were living in newport richey, florida, with a friend he had met in prison. when questioned, partin's roommate said he hadn't seen partin or his daughter since joshan's murder was covered in the local news. he also said he had never seen joshan ashbrook at his house either. with a search warrant, police examined the room partin and his daughter had been using, and initially found nothing suspicious. >> we lifted up a throw rug that was in between the two beds, and when we pulled the throw rug back, there was a huge, discolored stain. >> the stain was about four feet long and smelled of bleach. it looked like someone had recently tried to clean it, so criminalists lifted the carpet and found traces of blood underneath, which they collected for dna testing.
10:18 pm
forensic analysts also went over every inch of the room. >> they started searching, and on the wall they found a speck of blood that looked like it might have been a cast-off, a little teardrop. >> the blood on the wall and underneath the carpet yielded a genetic profile and it matched joshan's dna. >> we can say that joshan was killed in that bedroom. >> partin's roommate insisted he had nothing to do with joshan's murder, but wouldn't cooperate further. >> he did not want to cooperate with investigators nor the state attorney's office. very belligerent. just hated authority. despised us. >> meanwhile, the search for phillup partin wasn't going well, even though he was in constant contact with police, via his cell phone. >> detective? >> phillup liked to talk. he would question detectives as
10:19 pm
to, what do you have on me? why do you think i'm the one who did this? he was seeking answers. >> you have nothing on me. >> the problem was, partin would make a call and then drive away. so, it was impossible to pin down his location. one call came from across the country in washington state. >> this was just another way of mr. partin taunting the detectives. >> finally, the phone calls stopped completely. but then, two months after joshan's murder, police found an abandoned red pickup truck in a walmart parking lot, 50 miles away from where joshan's body was discovered. the license plate showed it was partin's truck. but on the truck were four bald tires. that didn't match the tire impressions at the crime scene. was partin trying to show he
10:20 pm
wasn't the killer by using decoy tires? >> he's got to know we're going to take tire casts and we're going to know what kind of vehicle he was driving. he's pretty smart. >> but if that were the case, partin made a colossal mistake. in the glove compartment, investigators found three rolls of film. when developed, one picture showed his truck with different tires. one of them was a wild country brand tire. >> i was able to determine that the tire impressions made at the crime scene was made by one of seven. and one of them being the cooper wild country tire. >> this became a crucial piece of evidence for us in this case. >> with the help of an informant, police found partin's 7-year-old daughter. partin had dropped her off at a friend's home after the murder and never came back. >> partin tells her, you don't know where i'm at, you don't
10:21 pm
know where i'm going, and don't tell anybody. take care of my child. i'll get back with you later on. he's never seen again. >> partin's daughter confirmed joshan's whereabouts on the night of the murder and said joshan never left the bedroom. >> she remembered that they went back to the house where they lived. went into the bedroom, and that she and joshan played video games and watched tv. >> partin's daughter said she was asleep in the living room while her father and joshan were in the bedroom. when she awoke, joshan was gone. >> we asked her what time did joshan leave, and she didn't remember, probably after she went to bed. she had no knowledge of when they left. >> and she couldn't tell investigators where her father was hiding. >> this guy is pissing me off. if you're taking multiple medications, does your mouth often feel dry?
10:22 pm
a dry mouth can be a side effect of many medications. but it can also lead to tooth decay and bad breath. that's why there's biotene, available as an oral rinse, toothpaste, spray or gel. biotene can provide soothing relief and it helps keep your mouth healthy too. remember, while your medication is doing you good, a dry mouth isn't biotene, for people who suffer from a dry mouth. verizon say neversettle. t-mobile agrees. never settle for verizon's overpriced gimmicks. try the un-carrier risk-free for 14 days you'll love it, or we'll pay for you to go back. can a a subconscious. mind?
10:23 pm
a knack for predicting the future. reflexes faster than the speed of thought. can a business have a spirit? can a business have a soul? can a business be...alive? apples fall, but the apples of your cheeks dodefy gravity. juvéderm voluma® is the only fda-approved injectable gel to instantly add volume to your cheek area. as you age, cheeks can lose volume. voluma adds volume creating contour and lift for a more youthful profile. for up to two years. temporary side effects include tenderness, swelling, firmness, lumps, bumps, bruising, pain, redness, discoloration and itching. ask your doctor. juvéderm voluma®. defy gravity.
10:24 pm
your buddy ron once said he could insthe couldn't.ling fan. and that one time ron said another chili dog was a good idea. yeah, it wasn't. so when ron said you'd never afford a john deere tractor, you knew better. now ron does too. introducing the e series. legendary john deere quality. unexpected low price. see your john deere dealer for great green tag savings on the e series family of tractors.
10:25 pm
all the evidence in the joshan ashbrook murder pointed to one man. phillup partin, he was the last known person to see joshan alive. his truck once had the same brand of tires that left tracks just feet from her body. his own daughter put him with the victim the night of the murder. and perhaps, most tellingly of
10:26 pm
all, when police went to question him, he went on the run. but he couldn't control his curiosity about the case and called detectives from all over the country. >> he ultimately thought he could beat the system. well, in doing that, we were able to trace his phone calls. >> with a warrant, investigators tapped his roommate's phone, just to see if partin would eventually call him. and that's what he did. when partin called his roommate, the police were listening in. they traced the call to a pay phone in fayetteville, north carolina. >> we knew that mr. partin was involved in the air conditioning business. we had a general area where the phone call came from. so we concentrated our search in that area. >> and that's exactly where they found him. >> mr. partin was quite shocked to see detectives.
10:27 pm
he was taken into custody on a warrant. upon questioning by detectives, he refused most of the questions. he didn't confess. >> but dna finally told the tale. partin's dna matched dna on the hair found on joshan's body. >> this dna just sealed the deal. >> to see whether partin's roommate was involved, investigators searched his suv, and on the front seat found a blood stain. but a test on the blood stain didn't match joshan ashbrook. it was dna from the man's son. the roommate also claimed he was at work in tampa on the night joshan was murdered. an alibi corroborated by his employer. prosecutors believed partin picked up joshan while she was hitchhiking. >> hey, there. >> hi. >> partin gained joshan's trust
10:28 pm
by having his daughter with him. and by helping her with her errands. the security tapes show the three of them went shopping later that morning, bought some fishing gear, and according to partin's daughter, went fishing later that afternoon. partin's daughter said they returned to their rented room sometime late in the day. after dark, partin's daughter fell asleep on the sofa. partin may have made a sexual advance towards joshan, which she rebuffed. there was a fight. joshan grabbed some of his hair. and partin used a knife to cut her throat. blood spatter got onto the wall. but it was a broken neck that caused joshan's death.
10:29 pm
partin took joshan's body to the woods 15 miles from her home. she had in her hand his dna. partin left his tire impression in the sand. later, partin attempted unsuccessfully to clean the blood from the bedroom. >> phillup partin is an opportunist who preys on young victims and vulnerable victims. i would consider him a sick individual. >> phillup partin went on trial for first-degree murder. he was found guilty and sentenced to death. >> the forensics evidence was the case. it was the case. her dna in the bedroom, and his dna, his hair found in her finger. that's the case. everything else was circumstantial. >> mr. partin had a tattoo on
10:30 pm
his body that said "live free or die." and that was his motto that he went by. either let me live free or kill me. and, ultimately, i think it speaks for itself. up next, two brutal murders put a city on edge. >> we're all bothered by it. it's hard to sleep at night. >> was this the work of a serial killer? >> there were multiple similarities between the two scenes. >> police have few clues. >> these crime scenes primarily were all debris basically. >> but plenty of motive. >> he has obviously a hatred towards women. >> the case went cold until a lover's quarrel flew out of control. ♪ in the early 1990s, seattle, washington, was one of the fastest growing cities in the country. renee powell, a 43-year-old registered nurse visited seattle v
216 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on