tv Forensic Files CNN June 28, 2015 12:00am-12:31am PDT
12:00 am
remember it. and you know that she knows she did it. she killed her baby on june 6th, 1996, in a suburb of dallas, texas, there was a crime of unprecedented horror. an intruder entered this home and attacked two young children, along with their mother. police hoped that science would lead them to the assailant. >> my babies are dying. they're dead. oh, my god! >> darin and darlie routier were a young couple in their mid-20s with three children, 6-year-old devon, 5-year-old day mon, and 8-month-old drake. darin routier was a successful
12:01 am
entrepreneur. darlie stayed at home to care for the children. >> this was a young couple who had made good. darin owned his own business. in 1995 he had made close to $300,000 in his business. in his business he repaired mainframe computers and had extensive contracts with government agencies. >> on the night of the attack, darin was asleep upstairs with 8-month-old drake. downstairs in the family room, the two older boys fell asleep watching television. their mother darlie was asleep on the sofa. around 2:30 in the morning, an intruder stabbed the children, then woke darlie, who felt a knife at her throat. after a brief struggle the intruder fled, and darlie called police. >> 911, what is your emergency? >> somebody came in the house,
12:02 am
stabbed my little boys while they were sleeping downstairs. some man come in and stabbed my babies, stabbed me when i looked up. he ran out of the garage. my babies are dying. they're dead! oh, my god. >> when paramedics arrived, 6-year-old devon was dead. 5-year-old damon was barely alive. but he died en route to the hospital. darlie was taken into surgery to repair her neck wound, which missed her carotid artery by only two centimeters. she also suffered a stab wound to her arm. paramedics noticed that darlie's panties were missing. >> when i asked her if she thought she had been raped, her answer to me was, "well, when i woke up, i felt some pressure down there." that was her answer. >> but a rape test was negative.
12:03 am
darlie described the assailant as a white male about 6 feet tall wearing a black shirt, jeans, and a baseball cap. a screen in the routiers' garage had been cut. darlie said the intruder dropped the murder weapon onto the floor as he fled. in the alley two houses away, police discovered a bloody sock. the motive did not appear to be robbery. >> between the kitchen and the room where the murders occurred, there was 13 rings and a gold lady's watch laying out there. that indicated to us if it was in fact a burglary or robbery that had gone bad, there was valuables out there to be taken and nothing was disturbed. >> now we don't know why. now we know this is a sick individual that took absolutely nothing from our house but took the two most important things that were important to us away from us. >> the most prominent evidence at the crime scene was blood. forensic scientists hoped the
12:04 am
blood spatter pattern would tell them more about these horrific murders. why weigh yourself down? try new aveeno® sheer hydration. its active naturals® oat formula... ...goes on feather light. absorbs in seconds... ...keeps skin healthy looking... ...and soft. aveeno®. naturally beautiful results. how's it progressing with the prisoner? he'll tell us everything he knows very shortly, sir. as you were... where were we? 13 serving 14! service! if your boss stops by, you act like you're working. it's what you do. if you want to save fifteen percent or more on car insurance, you switch to geico. it's what you do. to enhance your eyes. introducing a whole new way it's 1-day acuvue® define™
12:05 am
brand contact lenses. the eye enhancement lenses that comfortably accentuate your eyes' natural beauty. ask your doctor today about 1-day acuvue® define™ brand. a lot of peoplei didn't believe in me. but things took off when i got a domain and built my website all at godaddy. now i can tell the doubters to stick it. hey, honey. stick it! stick it! stick it! nana? hi... stick it! can you give your mommy a message for me? stick it! get a domain, website and email starting at $1/month all at godaddy. many wbut hope...ms come with high hopes, doesn't work on wrinkles. neutrogena® rapid wrinkle repair has the fastest retinol formula... to work on fine lines and even deep wrinkles in just one week. neutrogena®.
12:07 am
when police examined the murder scene, it appeared the assailant entered the routier home through a screened window in the garage. darlie routier said she was asleep when the intruder murdered her two boys. darlie awoke when she felt a knife to her throat and there was a struggle and the assailant fled through the garage. darlie said he dropped the murder weapon onto the floor on his way out. darin routier said he was upstairs with 8-month-old blake and awoke when he heard glass breaking. >> when he walked into the family room where the detectives were waiting for him, the first thing out of his mouth was not, how is damon? how is darlie. it is have you seen darlie? isn't she beautiful and doesn't she have gorgeous breasts? >> darin said, you know, i can see why somebody came in, good
12:08 am
looking blond, you know, 38 double ds. thought that was a little strange, too, considering he had just lost both of his sons. i don't believe at that time he knew for a fact if darlie was going to live or not. >> in the kitchen, police noticed a set of white handled knives. one space was empty. it appeared the murder weapon, a 10 inch white handled knife came from the routier's own kitchen. the blood drops on the floor were photographed and collected for dna testing. the size and shape of the blood droplets would be analyzed to see if they were consistent with darlie's version of events. darlie's night shirt was another important piece of blood evidence. forensic scientists hoped that it, too, would provide information about the murders. dna testing of the bloody sock found in the alley revealed the blood was that of the two boys, devon and damon.
12:09 am
however, police bloodhounds were not able to track the intruder's scent beyond the location of the sock. >> why would an intruder leave a murder weapon behind in a house and yet take a sock down the alley? why would an intruder leave the sock in open view for the police to find instead of disposing of it in a garbage can or down a storm sewer drain? >> police found some other inconsistencies. darlie said she chased the intruder through the kitchen and he knocked a wineglass on the floor. but pieces of glass were on top of the blood drops on the floor and there were no cuts on darlie's feet. underneath the overturned vacuum cleaner was more blood splatter and a wheel impression in the blood. it appeared that darlie ran through the kitchen before the glass broke and the vacuum cleaner overturned. on the handle of the vacuum cleaner was a bloodstain. dna tests revealed it was
12:10 am
darlie's. the blood dripped onto the handle at an 80 degree angle as if darlie were leaning over the vacuum cleaner. the pattern was not consistent with darlie's running past the vacuum, as she told police. either darlie routier was mistaken about what happened in the kitchen or she knew more about the murders than she was telling police. behind? new neutrogena cooldry sport. micromesh technology lets sweat pass through and evaporate so skin stays comfortable, while clinically proven protection stays on. new cooldry sport. neutrogena. i built my business with passion. but i keep it growing by making every dollar count. that's why i have the spark cash card from capital one. i earn unlimited 2% cash back on everything i buy for my studio. ♪ and that unlimited 2% cash back from spark means thousands
12:11 am
of dollars each year going back into my business... that's huge for my bottom line. what's in your wallet? time for the perfect night time snack. ♪ beautiful on the tongue, ♪ delightful to the bite, ♪ easy on the conscience. who said, breakfast has to wait until morning? kellogg's®. see you at breakfast, tonight.™ with roc® multi correxion® 5 in 1. proven to hydrate dryness, illuminate dullness, lift sagging, diminish the look of dark spots, and smooth the appearance of wrinkles. high performance skincare™ only from roc®.
12:14 am
blood spatter expert, tom bevell, was asked to analyze the blood drops found in the routier home. as a well-known expert on blood spatter analysis, it was bevell's job to interpret the story told by the blood trail. bevell noticed the blood drops on the kitchen floor were circular in shape, meaning they were deposited by someone standing still or walking very slowly. darlie said she was stabbed on the sofa, and while bleeding, ran through the kitchen after her assailant. but running would have produced blood drops more elliptical in shape, usually with a tail, indicating the direction and path of the person running. darlie also told police that the intruder dropped the knife onto
12:15 am
the kitchen floor, but tom bevell could find no evidence of that. >> numerous people, to include myself, examined that floor to try and find evidence of a knife drop, either pointed straight down or falling on its handle or falling on its side or whatever. and we were unable to find anything that would be consistent with that. if it had as much blood on it as it was found, which it would have to, then it should have produced an outline of the knife or evidence of the knife dropping onto the floor. we simply didn't find that. >> barry dickey is a forensic audio expert assigned to analyze darlie's telephone call to police. in order to conduct his analysis, dickey isolated darlie's voice by eliminating all of the background noise. >> somebody came in while i was sleeping, me and my little boys were sleeping downstairs. they came in and stabbed my babies. stabbed me. i woke up --
12:16 am
>> in my opinion, darlie had moved from at least three different rooms in the house. these rooms were moved in a very rapid fashion and she did not stay in any one of the ambiences very long. >> but if darlie walked briskly in between rooms, this contradicted her story to police. when police interviewed darlie after the murder, she was holding a wet towel to her neck wound. police wondered if the towel had been used to clean up blood before they arrived. to find out, investigators used luminol, a chemical that glows when sprayed on an area where blood has been removed. >> once we darkened the kitchen down and applied the lumenol, we were able to see footprints there in front of the sink which kind of made the hair on the back of our necks stand up. >> the footprints in front of the kitchen sink were darlie's. on the cabinet beneath the sink,
12:17 am
there was visible blood. and lumenol revealed that more had been cleaned up before police arrived. >> the blood evidence in front of the sink indicated to us that someone had bled -- had stood there in front of the sink for a significant amount of time bleeding and not moving around. there was blood drops on top of blood drops on the floor in front of the sink. >> dna testing revealed the blood belonged to darlie. prosecutors suspected that it was here where darlie cut her neck and arm. >> if there was an intruder and he came in, he came in without leaving any evidence of walking through there. >> also, on the carpet was an unusual blood impression, the distinct outline of the murder weapon, the heavy line of blood near the tip of the blade told forensic experts something important about the killer. >> the only way that i am aware that you could get something coming off of the knife in that
12:18 am
manner, as we found it, would be to have the knife in the hand of a person that is bleeding, in other words, they are contributing blood continuously. so if you had a wound on this arm with the knife in this hand, with the blood flowing down the arm, ultimately across the hand and then down the blade of the knife, that will produce that very heavy bleeding that we got in the front of the knife in the impression. >> coincidentally, darlie had a knife wound on her right arm. dna tests revealed that the blood was that of both damon and darlie and not that of an unknown assailant. darlie said she picked up the knife from the kitchen floor and put it on the counter-. she said nothing about taking it into the family room. >> no bloody trail, no fingerprints, no trace of the suspect. peter pan came down the chimney maybe and committed the murder, tinkerbell or somebody. but we have no evidence of any
12:19 am
coming through the window, committing the murders and leaving. >> police were now convinced that there was no intruder in the routier home on the night of the murders. does your makeup remover every kiss-proof,ff? cry-proof, stay-proof look? neutrogena® makeup remover does. it erases 99% of your most stubborn makeup with one towelette. need any more proof than that? neutrogena. ...is as easy as it gets. wouldn't it be great... ...if hiring plumbers, carpenters and even piano tuners were just as simple? thanks to angie's list, now it is. we've made hiring anyone, from a handyman to a dog-walker as simple as a few clicks. buy their services directly at angieslist.com. no more calling around. no more hassles. and you don't even have to be a member to start shopping today. angie's list is revolutionizing local service again.
12:20 am
visit angieslist.com today. [p[man] hello,totten designs. sales department? yes...i can put you right through. sales department-this is nate. human resources. technical support. hold please. [announcer]you work hard to grow your business. [man] yes!i can totally do that for you. [announcer]our new online business planning tools will help your business thrive. wells fargo.together we'll go far. a lot of peoplei didn't believe in me. but things took off when i got a domain and built my website all at godaddy. now i can tell the doubters to stick it. hey, honey. stick it! stick it! stick it! nana? hi... stick it! can you give your mommy a message for me? stick it!
12:21 am
12:23 am
just eight days after the murders the routiers celebrated what would have been devin's seventh birthday at the cemetery. family members invited a local television news crew to attend. >> if you knew devin and damon, you would know that they're up in heaven and they're up there having the biggest birthday party we could ever imagine and they wouldn't want us to be down here being sad. i know devin and damon would want us to be happy. >> district attorney greg davis watched the celebration on television. >> i was just sickened by what i saw. because it had only been a week since these boys' deaths and yet we have a full-blown birthday party out there at the grave site. and it really struck me as more than curious.
12:24 am
>> charles linch discovered the most damaging piece of evidence contradicting darlie's intruder story. on one of the bread knives from the routier's kitchen, linch found a single fiberglass rod and some rubber dust. the cut window screen in the routier garage was made from polycarbide bundles. the fiberglass rod found on the kitchen knife was identical to the fiberglass rod from the routier screen. linch could not find any other source of fiberglass inside the routier home that was similar. >> i was able to eliminate all the sources of fiberglass i could find as being a source. so the fiberglass rod found on the bread knife may have come from the window screen.
12:25 am
but not to the exclusion of all over sources. >> fbi profiler alan brantley was convinced there was no intruder. >> we have never seen a case where an offender comes from outside the residence, breaks into the home, takes a knife and go back outside the home and cuts the screen to come back in. those steps, that kind of behavior is just unnecessary to the commission of any kind of an offense unless you are attempting to make the scene look like something you should look like or you want other people to believe occurred. and again that is an element of staging. >> and on darlie's night shirt, scientists found cast-off blood spatter on the right shoulder area. dna testing revealed that the blood belonged to the two boys. >> some of those two stains are coming in a direction consistent with the movement of the item
12:26 am
that was bloodstained. in my opinion in this case, the knife. as you're drawing the knife backwards the blood is coming off the end of the knife as it is drawn backwards and if it is close enough it will point in an upward direction with the bloodstains. >> the blood spatter was pointed upwards. the forensic evidence all told a story. a story quite different from the one darlie told police. prosecutors believe that the murders were premeditated and that darlie encouraged the boys to sleep with her that night in the family room. some time after 2:00 a.m., darlie took a bread knife from the kitchen and cut the screen in the garage.
12:27 am
she returned the knife to the holder without rinsing the fiberglass residue found later by forensic scientists. darlie used the largest knife she had to murder her two children. blood spatter on the back right shoulder of her night shirt placed the murder weapon in darlie's hand. speculation is that darlie may have removed her panties to suggest the possibility of a sexual assault. standing at the kitchen sink, darlie turned the knife on herself, slicing both her neck and right arm. then something unexpected happened, five-year-old damon was still alive crawling through the family room. he was stabbed two more times. the knife impression on the carpet was caused by blood from her arm wound as it dripped over the tip of the knife.
12:28 am
the audio analysis of the 911 call reveals that darlie was moving in between rooms quickly as she staged the crime scene and removed some of the blood evidence. >> stabbed my babies. i -- they're dead. oh, my god! >> but darlie's attempt to mislead investigators failed. >> it's hard to explain it. but these kids were in her way. they were in the way of her lifestyle and her ambitions. and what she wanted to do. and she simply made a decision that those children would no longer be in her way. >> darlie routier was arrested
12:29 am
and charged with the murder of her two sons. darren routine denied he was involved and no charges were filed against him. patricia springer described the possible motive in her book "flesh and blood". >> there is no one reason why darlie routier did this, it had nothing to the with money. it had to do with the multiple births, with the total responsibility. we have learned that darren didn't help a lot with the children. >> darlie routier was found guilty of first degree murder and was sentenced to death. she currently sits on death row awaiting execution. >> i think that darlie got exactly what she deserved in this case. we probably gave her more justice than she deserved in this case. if you look at the barbaric acts
12:30 am
that brought her to that courtroom we did all that the system allowed us to do to her. but she richly deserves to be on death row and she richly deserves to be executed one day. on a windy october night in 1995, a mysterious house fire swept through the palatial home of a doctor and his family. two of the family members made it out alive. two of the children did not. in the debris, medical detectives discovered much more than simply how the fire started. michael farrar and debora green first met in medical school in 1977. both were gifted students with near-genius i.q.s. there was an instant attraction,
239 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on