tv Erin Burnett Out Front CNN March 24, 2017 4:00pm-5:01pm PDT
4:00 pm
>> see what if anything the house and senate intelligence committee investigations into all of this develops. brian todd reporting for us. thanks very much. that's it for me. thanks very much for watching. i hope you have a great weekend. "erin burnett out front" starts right now. "out front" next, breaking news, the president tonight lashing out at democrats and threatening to let obamacare, quote, explode after a shocking and embarrassing defeat. did the closer blow it? plus, why was jared kushner skiing in aspen as his father-in-law's health care bill was going downhill? and he calls them the failing "new york times" and dishonest "washington post," so why were they some of trump's first calls after the vote got pulled? good evening, everyone. i'm kate bolduan in for erin burnett. the art of no deal. president trump in a stunning defeat abruptly cancels the vote on the republican health care bill facing what would have been an embarrassing loss on the
4:01 pm
house floor. for republicans, it was a seven-year promise. for trump, it put his reputation as a master deal maker on the line. moments ago the president in the oval office defending his defeat. >> i never said -- i guess i'm here, what, 64 days? i never said repeal and replace obamacare. you heard my speeches. i never said repeal and replace within 64 days. i have a long time. >> of course the president did promise to repeal and replace not on day 64, on his first day, actually. >> we will also repeal and replace the total disaster known as obamacare. we're going to stop it day one. >> the other man whose reputation is on the line tonight, house speaker paul ryan. >> i will not sugar coat this. this is a disappointing day for us. doing big things is hard. obamacare is a the law of the land and will remain the law of the land.
4:02 pm
>> sara murray is out front at the white house. the president has always called himself the ultimate deal maker. he couldn't get this one done. what is the white house saying tonight? >> reporter: i think the white house is trying to shift a lilt bit of the blame here. you're absolutely right, he campaigned on this, he insisted that he was the man who could fwetd things done in washington that other people could not. and we know that behind the scenes there was a lot of frustration among the president and his top aides about being unable to coax republicans into agreeing to this deal, but we saw a very disciplined president today not blaming members of his own party. listen to what he said. >> i think the losers are nancy pelosi and chuck schumer because now they own obamacare, they own it, 100% own it, and this is not a republican health care. this is not anything but a democrat health care. >> reporter: the reality is, and this was a political defeat for this white house in a week where they certainly needed a win.
4:03 pm
perhaps the worst week of his presidency so far. but if you trust senior administration officials tonight, they say he's not all that perturbed by it. in fact, he's sort of happy to have health care behind him ready to move on to other things. >> how far is it behind him? sara, thank you so much. what went so wrong for the republican party today? sunlen serfaty is out front on capitol hill. >> reporter: president trump and house republican leaders tonight are grappling with a staggering health care defeat. the gop's long-promised plan to repeal and replace the affordable care act pulled from the house floor after leaders determined the proposal lacked enough support to pass. >> we came close today but we fell short. doing big things is hard. >> reporter: it was a stunning turn of events coming less than 24 hours after the president issued an ultimatum to house republic republicans to move forward with
4:04 pm
the vote or he was ready to move on to other items on his agenda. >> i think we have to let obamacare go its way for a little while. see how things go. it's imploding and soon will explode. and it's not going to be pretty. >> reporter: the decision to call off the vote came after house speaker paul ryan left the capitol to visit the white house and deliver message in person to the president that republicans did not have the votes to pass the plan. sources tell cnn a key part of that closed-door conversation dealt with whether the president would take any responsibility for the disdecision to scrap the vote. as that meeting played out behind the scenes, the white house press secretary was publicly making the case to reporters that the president had done all he could to deliver a legislative victory. >> there's no question in my mind, at least, that the president and the team here have left everything on the field. >> reporter: part of the administration's last-minute push included dispatching mike
4:05 pm
pence. >> one of the worst bills i've ever seen. >> reporter: even though the mood from the white house soundedless optimistic than recent days, spicer refused to throw in the towel. >> off president that's going to sign the bill if you pass it, and now is that time. >> reporter: while the president refused to hint at what his next step would be if the vote didn't succeed. >> did you rush it, do you think? >> we'll see what happens. >> reporter: what ultimately happened is rank and file members of the president's own party never fully got on board. with leaders losing votes from more moderate members with changes to the proposal aimed at swaying conservatives. that included a late revision to eliminate the ten essential health benefits required to be part of insurance plans under obamacare. >> suppose that was added to move in the direction of the freedom caucus. i'm in what is known as the tuesday group, and i do not think that that is a good amendment. >> reporter: tonight speaker ryan and president trump both
4:06 pm
making it crystal clear they are not going to try again on repealing obamacare anytime soon. they are now saying that ear going to move on to other items on their legislative agenda. first up, very well could be tax reform. but, kate, that is as complicated as what they just attempted and failed at. >> absolutely. amazing how things changed today. thank you so much, sunlen. the panel with me tonight, will be with me unless they leave me, for the entire hour. mark preston is here. caitlyn huey burns. nia-malika henderson is cnn's senior political reporter. jeffrey lord is here. reagan white house political director. doug hyde. and keith boykin was a white house aide in the clinton white house. all right. a lot as changed since we spoke last. mark, this is embarrassing to say the least for the republican party. for this president. how pad is this?
4:07 pm
>> very bad. look, it's very bad because they had seven years to try to craft something together. it's very bad because they tried to legislate off a campaign slogan of repeal and replace instead of saying we're going to go in and fix and make better, which literally they probably could have done. and it's bad really going forward because every bit of legislation now is going to be viewed at least in the near term through donald trump's inability to cut a deal to get things done. >> what the president said tonight when he faced cameras, faced reporters, he says basically this wasn't on me, this is all democrats. can he really say -- can you say with a straight face tonight, jeffrey lord, this is the democrats' fault as the president is trying to tonight? >> well, obamacare is their fault. but -- >> no, no. he wants to say this, where they are today, is democrats are at fault. >> let me partially agree with my friend mark over there. >> you should partially answer my question. >> i am. this is the republicans' fault. this is speaker ryan's fault.
4:08 pm
i like speaker ryan. but let me give you two speakers, newt gingrich and nancy pelosi, the contract for america with newt gingrich and obamacare, which should be called pelosi care. they were speakers of the house. they got their programs through. they got it done. speaker ryan, great guy, just didn't get this done. mark is correct. they had seven years to do this. they should have had this all road tested. >> so it's not the president's fault at all. >> well, i mean, any president would have walked into this for the first time, but no, it's the legislative body's fault, absolutely. they're the ones in charge of the house. not the president. >> keith? president trump -- >> promised you wouldn't laugh. >> well, sorry. he lied. president trump says this is on the biggest losers tonight are nancy pelosi and chuck schumer. this is on obamacare. this is on democrats. your fault. >> president obama deserves an apology from president trump because he has been criticized for being too professor sor yal, couldn't make a deal.
4:09 pm
he cut a deal to make obamacare happen, something that this guy couldn't do. the buck stops in the oval office, not somewhere else. he refuses to take responsibility. frankly, the reason why he's responsible is because he is engaged, he's demonstrated a careless, casual, reckless indifference to the mechanics of governing. he hasn't even tried to learn how to do his job. he's so busy out campaigning in kentucky and tennessee, he hasn't bothered to do the substantive work to be the president of the united states. >> to keith's president, the president himself acknowledged it's been an interesting experience for him. he has learned a lot, a lot about the arcane rules of legislating was one thing he said. but also i can't get off of this. this is a president who said he is the ultimate deal maker. he spent years criticizing president obama for not being able to close a deal. found this doozy from 2013 when the government shutdown stuff was all happens. listen to what then just donald trump had to say. >> you have to get everybody in
4:10 pm
a room. you have to be a leader. the president has to lead. he's got to get mr. boehner and everybody else in a room and they have to make a deal and you have to be nice and be angry and be wild and cajole and do all sorts of things. but you have to get a deal. and unfortunately he's never been a deal maker. >> why does it seem that he did not take his own advice? >> he didn't. that's why it seems like he didn't. there weren't those moments, certainly initially in getting people together, getting a coalition together, getting sort of outside interest groups together, the doctors' groups, aarp, club for growth, all of those groups let alone the house freedom caucus or bringing ryan in in the beginning days and try and figure out what this deal would look like. they wanted this done quickly and in some ways that was ryan's design. spicer today said over and over that this president left everything out on the field. that must have been a really small field because he didn't really do much. right? he went out a couple times to
4:11 pm
kentucky -- even in those speeches it wasn't eve an full speech about health care. there was a line in there or two about health care, but he never was really all in on this, didn't take obama's sort of advice in terms of how he approached it, eight-month period, lots of speech, lots of long interviews about health care and making the sale. >> so if president trump could have done more, doug, in your opinion the house of representatives how many times that they worked to repeal and replace -- or repeal obamacare. how much blame does paul ryan deserve? >> well, i think the lion's share goes to two different spots, one the president, because he is the only new dynamic in this. we had republicans who were passing bill, sometimes not passing bills. we were pushing for a senate shgt finally got a senate. that wasn't enough. we needed a president. we've got a president who's the great negotiator. that's part of it. the other is we talk about seven years of trying to replace this. president it's not just about obamacare but how we struggled to reopen the government, had to
4:12 pm
pull the farm bill from the floor. time and time again republicans couldn't pass legislation, we couldn't govern ourselves and having observed these creatures in their native habitat, it's tough to get people who don't want to follow you, tough to lead them and that's why republicans are stuck where they are and will be stuck tomorrow and there aren't real answers for where we go next at this point. that's what's troubling is we have to answer the question of whether or not we can govern ourselves and we don't know that yet. >> they also need to answer to constituents. i truly do wonder, and paul ryan didn't have an answer when dan asked him about today, what do lawmakers say when they go back to their districts tonight? >> exactly. to doug's point, what this did today was real hi embolden the reluctant crew, right, and emboldened the house conservatives, that they got a victory tonight. they have no incentive now. >> any case this helps republicans? >> for them, but not for the larger party -- the party at large that wants to get things done. these are republicans who are in very safe districts.
4:13 pm
threats of primary challenges, of losing their seats really rang hollow among a lot of these republicans who, yes, trump won their districts but they outperformed trump in many cases, far outperformed any rivals that they had in those races. so i think this is what people were concerned about was emboldening these types of folks. so when you get to things like tax reform, they can hold their line too. they got a victory. >> tax reform is going to be so much easier. >> oh, yeah. next -- why is the president fuming at hi son-in-law right now? it may have something to do with this picture. plus, why this picture is taking on new significance at this hour. and the chairman of the house intelligence committee abruptly canceled the hearing on russia as democrats accuse him of doing donald trump's bidding. (vo) this is not a video game. this is not a screensaver. this is the destruction of a cancer cell by the body's own immune system, thanks to medicine that didn't exist until now. and today can save your life.
4:14 pm
4:15 pm
it's been hard, but some of the stuff he says is actually pretty helpful. pumpkin, bundling our home and auto insurance is a good deal! like buying in bulk! that's fun, right? progressive can't protect you from becoming your parents, but we can protect your home and auto. progressive can't protect you from becoming your parents, modern life deserves a and we'll end up in venice. oh..venice... let's get the check. nope! i got it. you can use it online and what's with this one? and on your phone. taking care of the check. it's all masterpassed. first impressions. priceless thank you so where to now? well we're thinking shoe shopping. i was hoping you were going to say shoe shopping. masterpass, the secure way to pay from your bank don't just buy it, masterpass it.
4:16 pm
4:17 pm
house republicans defying their leaders and donald trump. phil mattingly is "out front" on capitol hill. you've been there all day. what's happened behind the scenes as republicans were meeting today? where are they maplacing the blame? >> reporter: most fingers are pointed at the house freedom caucus. the freedom caucus doesn't apologize at all for what they did in this process. they had specific things they wanted and made clear they were willing to call leadership's bluff and hold out to get those. i'm told behind the scenes the recriminations, the anger is strong. just look on twitter. adam kinslinger saying the house freedom caucus single-handedly saved obamacare. this carries over. it's a concern from advisers on both sides of the debate inside the republican conference. they want to do big agenda items going forward. they're moving on past obamacare. how do they work this out?
4:18 pm
is this a harbinger of things to come? because the freedom caucus feel emboldened? or do they recognize they've touched the stove and need to come together and to get things done? we were told by paul ryan that president trump was not bluffing, they were dope with the repeal and replace and moving on, nobody even responded. it was that jarring of a moment. we'll see if they learn from that or if it's just kind of what we're going to see going forward consistently. >> phil, thank you. "out front" tonight, republican congressman of ohio mike turner. he was planning to vote no on this bill. congressman, thanks for coming in. >> sure. thanks for having me. >> simply put, how do you describe what happened today? >> you know, i was in conversations with the white house and the speaker's office including conversations today trying to modify this bill. in the end, as you know, this bill would result in the coverage of many people in my community losing their health care coverage. that was a bridge too far. in addition, with the concession that was made to the freedom
4:19 pm
caucus of removing sennial health care benefits which included as you noma tern ti care and other care that everyone believes was essential, this became a bill i could not support. >> here's the thing, congressman. republicans right now have the keys to the kingdom. you control all of washington. so did the party squander a huge opportunity here today? >> well, they don't control everything. it takes 60 votes in the senate to get a bill through. >> they sure control the house. >> this bill was going through continue or thingses and pieces were moving through procedural modes to try to get it through ultimately through senate. because of that, this piece, which was supposed to be part of larger pie, certainly, you know, had continue or tortions that i i could not support. >> the president and speaker ryan says obamacare is the law
4:20 pm
of the land. they're not bringing this up in the near future. can you just leave this after campaigning and promising for cycle after cycle and move on to something like tax reform now? >> that's going to be the decision of the speaker and of the president. i'd be surprised. it certainly is a process that's worthy of continuing. it's not this bill. and i think, you know, if they do a postmortem they'll find there's some serious flaws in the bill and perhaps we need to move forward with a bill that can protect the american public, ensure that i'm not voting to cut health care benefits to my constituents, and a bill that people see real savings and reductions in premiums and quality of care for the future. >> the message has been pretty clear. it's basically good luck trying to tell your constituents at home you essentially stood in the way and allowed obamacare to stand. here's what sean spicer said today from the white house about republicans that don't support the bill. >> they're the ones who have to
4:21 pm
go back and answer to their constituent why is they didn't fulfill a pledge they made. >> what do you say to your constituents tonight? >> i didn't campaign with president trump and i certainly didn't pledge to support whatever he brought to the house floor. i pledged to support something that would maintain the quality of care of people who need medical care and not result in putcuts in benefits. that's not the bill they brought forward, so i'm comfortable going back to my constituents and saying i'm for repeal and replace, i'm not for this bill, i don't think they are either. >> everyone this week was calling the president the closer. he couldn't seal the deal, plain and simply. what does it say about the president? >> well, i think, you know, this says less about the president than it does about the process. you know, this is isn't closing the deal. this is what the is the process. many times when legislation is going forward -- >> but this is a little bit about the deal. i know it's not about a business deal, but this is a deal. this is how you guys get votes in the house.
4:22 pm
you cut deals. that's exactly the deal making that's been going on for the past week at the white house and the capitol. he couldn't get it done. >> well, you know, i had this specific conversation with the vice president and that is this, that i'm a business lawyer, i work with entrepreneurs like the president and i certainly understand negotiating tactics. but legislation isn't a, you know, that's my final offer. legislation is a process. even this was only going to be a piece of a larger process. certainly hope the president becomes engaged and that we get a bill that can be passed but what we know is that this bill couldn't even pass the senate. so regardless of whether or not it stopped here, it certainly wasn't a bill that was going to his desk. >> does the president need to learn some lessons how business deals are different than deals in washington? >> well, i think the president needs to engage in the conversation. >> not engaged in it enough right now. >> well, you know, he's been negotiating and engaged in why you should be for this bill, not necessarily the question of what's wrong with this bill.
4:23 pm
and i can tell you any bill that cuts health care benefits from my community, my community won't support and i certainly won't support. >> congressman mike turner, thanks for your time. a wild day in washington. >> thank you. "out front" next, jared kushner on the slopes of aspen while his father-in-law and republicans were sweating it out over health care. the president not so happy. and trump said if the health care bill failed there is no plan b. so what's next? and why does this picture matter tonight? various: (shouting) heigh! ho! ( ♪ ) it's off to work we go! woman: on the gulf coast, new exxonmobil projects are expected to create over 45,000 jobs. and each job created by the energy industry supports two others in the community. altogether, the industry supports over 9 million jobs nationwide. these are jobs that natural gas is helping make happen, all while reducing america's emissions. energy lives here.
4:24 pm
with 9 lobster dishes.est is back all while reducing america's emissions. try succulent new lobster mix & match or see how sweet a lobster lover's dream can be. there's something for everyone and everyone's invited. so come in soon. when i was a navy seal, ♪ i trained as hard as i could to stay alive. i have more than 30 pieces of shrapnel still in my leg. but i still push myself to the limit. if it weren't for my tempur-pedic, i wouldn't be able to sleep on my left side at all. my unit put in a special request to get one and i realized that tempur-pedic was exponentially better than anything else. it gave me a huge performance advantage, it still does. tempur-pedic. this sleep is power. dearthere's no other way to say this. it's over. i've found a permanent escape from monotony. together, we are perfectly balanced, our senses awake, our hearts racing as one.
4:25 pm
i know this is sudden, but they say: if you love something... set it free. see you around, giulia ♪ today, it's the dawn of a new lawn. that's because new roundup for lawns has arrived. finally, there's a roundup made just for your lawn, so you can put unwelcome lawn weeds to rest. draw the line. with roundup for lawns, there is no better way to kill lawn weeds to the root without harming a single blade of grass. it's a great day to be a lawn. draw the line with roundup for lawns. and for weeds in other spaces, turn to roundup weed & grass killer products. a 401(k) is the most sound way to go. let's talk asset allocation. -sure. you seem knowledgeable, professional. i'm actually a deejay. -[ laughing ] no way! -that really is you? if they're not a cfp pro, you just don't know. cfp. work with the highest standard.
4:27 pm
tonight president trump fuming and a source says it's directed at an unlikely target, his son-in-law and senior adviser jared kushner as trump and his top aides scrambled to win over skeptical republicans to support the health care bill, kushner was skiing in aspen with his wife, ivanka, and other members of the family, a source saying, quote, he's upset his son-in-law and adviser was not around during this crucial week. athena jones, what else are you hearing? >> reporter: it's important to state that jared kushner is one of the president's closest and most trusted advisers. you often see pictures of him in
4:28 pm
the room, in the oval office during meetings, various important meetings, meeting important officials. but in the end, this trump source, a source close to trump, said the president was upset that kushner, his son-in-law, his senior adviser, was not nearby, was not here during what turned out to be a crucial week. and it was a crucial week. it was supposed to be a week that ended with a big win for the white house, another campaign promise kept. in the end, it ended with this huge loss that this young presidency now has to recover from. i should note it was not clear entirely what specific role kushner would have played in all of this, attempts to win over the votes of republican members of the house. he doesn't have experience on capitol hill or in washington. but it seems pretty clear that the president wanted to have one of his closest advisers nearby and is upset that kushner is out in aspen for the past week or so
4:29 pm
with his family. there were pictures -- the paparazzi caught pictures of he and his wife strolling through the sfreets of aspen, enjoying ice cream with their children, wind do you think the ski slopes but the president would have liked to have kushner on his side on this big and ultimately disappointing week. >> thank you so much. back to the panel. keith, you worked at the clinton white house. if you're a senior adviser to president clinton are you away on a week you think your biggest legislative fight will go down? >> that's softball question. obviously, no. you want to be there. this is a guy, you know, donald trump went to the mat to make sure he could get a security clearance for this guy. and there are a lot of people like myself who had questions about the nepotism violation of having a son-in-law in this position. and here he is in this crucial moment, the most crucial moment so far of the president's young administration and he's absent. he's awol. that's unacceptable, but what do you do? fire your son-in-law? he's got an unpaid position.
4:30 pm
what are you going do do in this position? donald trump has to create an environment in the white house of a real structure of government. he hasn't done that. he has to start behave like a real chief executive of the presidency, of the country, not like the ceo of the family business like he's been doing. >> toug, do you read into this that he wasn't around and the president is fuming? does this signal the president was taking this seriously or at least wasn't sweating it, thought he had a win here? >> as athena pointed out he eat not well versed, jared kushner, on capitol hill. this speaks to trump and the presidency. ultimately donald trump the his best advocate with republican members. jared kushner was not going to be the one to get that past the finish line for trump, but this speaks why trump needed to be out there more aggressively than he is. perfect example is the appropriate chair, there's a trump golf course in his district. he needed to hear from the president and he didn't.
4:31 pm
the president needs to work the phones harder on this on whatever the next issue is they face. >> if you can't sa say freedlinghausen three times fast, don't say it. other peictures from the week. everyone says the president can walk and chew gum at the same time. but in the hours before a crucial vote, is this the president hanging out in a cab of a big rig, is this the narrative picture you want out there? >> he's with truckers. go for it. >> full stop. >> better than skiing in aspen, i would say. but i would add before i ever chose to get between the president's son-in-law i would skinny dip in my vi soouf yus. >> i have a mental image i'm going to pass on. mark, save me. the white house said that the president gave this his all. the speaker gave him that as well, said that essentially he
4:32 pm
left it all on the field. there were lots of meetings, yes, at the white house. the president went over the capitol. but when it came to the public push, changing public opinion on this, those two big campaign rallies that he had, we tallied it up. he spent 7 out of 42 minutes talking about health care one. five out of 37 minutes at the other. do you think the white house will regret that? >> if they don't now, they should regret it because it all goes back to casting forward and how are they going to operate when they're trying to get other very difficult things done. you know, we talk about tax reform and how easy that's going to be. that's going to be extremely difficult to do. and, you know, if there is a positive for president trump to take away from this, if there is one, he learned a lesson early on about legislating in washington and working with 535 free agents is a lot different than trying to negotiate a deal with one person over real
4:33 pm
estate. >> something that i found amazing about how this wild afternoon played out, the media and some of the outlets that the president loves to hate on, were some of his first calls after this -- after he pulled the vote, after they decided to pull the vote, and it seemed even before some lawmakers, some of his own party knew that the vote had even been pulled, what does that say to you? >> this idea that trump hates the media, i mean, it's always not been quite true. he's a consumer of cable news and "the new york times," maybe more than any other president we've seen. certainly the cable news part of it. so it's not surprising one of his first calls seemed to be to robert costa of t"the washingto pos post", second to maggie haberman and robert costa live tweeting about this -- >> when i will he's on the phone. >> on the phone with him. i think a lot of people on the hill found out through those tweets. again, it goes to his sort of priorities, he should have been reaching out to those folks first, but he was thinking about
4:34 pm
himself. >> i think i saw a quote one lawmaker said, it's on twitter so it must be true! that's where we hbig discussion about this last night because of the final magazine article. he's not one to admit fault. did you see and what you heard from the president today that this is on him at all? >> no. in fact, what was startling to me was how disciplined this was. yes, he talked to two reporters then made a statement, but he kind of said, no, paul ryan's great, freedom caucus guys, sure, we get along, this is the democrats' fault, and kind of shrugged it off, which, you know, may be a reflection of how little time he spent invested in this fight, just given the amount of days involved. but it was also quite startling to kind of say, well, we'll just move on. >> surprising. he's known to freelance when he's at rallies and go after people when something's really bothering him.
4:35 pm
why wasn't there freelancing today? he didn't blame anyone in the republican party. >> right. he was shocked. i mean, i think that he thought -- >> is that a compliment, though, a testament to him, though, that maybe he's just letting it roll off and he's like i got many more battles to go? >> but he also sounded like a bystander president, right? i mean, it sounds like he's going to be fine with premiums going up and fine to blame the democrats as people might lose their health care, and that's bizarre. he's not going to take responsibility. >> i really think he believes, okay, this is collapse on its own weight, let the democrats get the -- >> are you comfortable with the president saying i believe -- the president believes that obamacare is horrible and it's hurting americans, you're okay with the president and the party saying it's hurting you and we're going to let it -- >> we have the other side saying this is a huge suck says, so okay. let's see. >> the other side is saying it
4:36 pm
need work to fix it but the republicans have been sabotaging it for the past seven years. this is a guy who needs to take responsibility again. you can't just continue to pass the buck to everybody else, and to say that -- >> but it's your bill. this is what you wanted. you got it. >> no, no. >> please. republicans own washington right now. >> republican president. and about to have another republican supreme court justice, possibly. >> i want to speak for the freedom caucus or as i call them the reagan caucus. these are the guys are making the old reagan argument about peal pastels versus bold colors. they're the reagan guys. >> my question has been about the president, not the freedom caucus at this moment. >> i think the president as party leader, he plunged into this, he did do his job. >> where does the buck stop? [ talking over each other ]
4:37 pm
>> where does the buck stop? >> always with the president. >> even if he doesn't acknowledge it? >> yes. that is why you seek that office. but republicans in congress still need to try and whether they do it piecemeal or coming back in six months with a big plan figure that out. the problem is it's not just freedom caucus members who are nervous about this. it's moderates. what happens operationally, every time we have a tough vote is this pendulum effect of where we go to the right to get some of the freedom caucus members, lose some moderates, swing back to the left, swing back and forth and lose our moral center on this. >> moral center. two words that don't exist right now in washington. i'm not listening. he's in the penalty box. jeffrey lord, stand by. "out front" next, the president has bragged quite a bit about getting things done. >> i will make a great deal and lots of great deals for the american people. >> so i ask, what happened today? and will it impact president trump's new priority, tax
4:38 pm
reform? plus, three former trump advisers now coming forward offering to answer questions about their alleged ties to russia. ♪ blue moon is brewed with valencia orange peel, for a taste that shines brighter. find fast relief behind the counter allergies with nasal congestion? with claritin-d. [ upbeat music ] strut past that aisle for the allergy relief that starts working in as little as 30 minutes and contains the best oral decongestant. live claritin clear, with claritin-d. the unpredictability of a flaree may weigh on your mind. thinking about what to avoid, where to go, and how to work around your uc. that's how i thought it had to be. but then i talked to my doctor about humira, and learned humira can help get and keep uc under control...
4:39 pm
when certain medications haven't worked well enough. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. raise your expectations and ask your gastroenterologist if humira may be right for you. with humira, control is possible. ♪ ♪ wanna get away?
4:40 pm
4:42 pm
pruch already looking i head after the defeat on health care. president trump and paul ryan saying next up they want to tackle tax reform. >> we'll probably be going right now for tax reform, which we could have done earlier but this really would have worked out better if we could have had some democrats support. >> this does make tax reform more difficult but not impossible. we will proceed with it. >> bringing back the panel. doug, can you really walk away from health care all of the discussions they're having right now and move on to tax reform? it's no easier. >> no easier but in the short term there's nothing else they can do. they need to lick their wounds, walk it off and live to fight another day even if they're fighting with themselves. it's not nancy pelosi who
4:43 pm
defeated this. it's the friendly fire from republicans. what's frustrating to so many is this should have been a good week for republicans. should have focused on nooem gorsuch but we focused on russia and -- >> who? >> exactly. russia and a disaster that happened last night and on the floor today. >> what's the impact of this on that? this defeat in health care make it harder or easier to get tax reform across the line? >> maybe a little harder but i've seen presidents of both parties get defeated and then they rebound. as i was saying off camera, remember that donald trump also wrote "the art of the comeback" and "never give up." >> take his own advice from "art of the deal." >> or "the art of the comeback." he'll be back on that. but, you know, president reagan suffered a big defeat at reykjavik. i was there. the headlines for terrible.
4:44 pm
a year later there was gosh d f gorbachev signing the agreement he wanted. >> only 64 days and look what fact, when you have a defeat. you pick up your socks and move on to the next -- and you get a victory. >> everyone acknowledges obamacare needs fixing. any alternate universe, is there a possibility that this defeat could possibly open it up that democrats and republicans could work together? i saw a tweet from chuck grassley that said -- stop laughing, nia -- these things need to be done in a bipartisan fashion or am i delusional? >> i think you're delusional. it could happen in secret if there's a way to do that in washington, d.c. the honest truth is people don't want to work together and the republican party is now weakened because of this and they know that trump can't get a deal. the democrats have no incentive to want to work with them because of that. but tax reform is going to be a very difficult haul. not only do you have to deal with your caucuses but the different interest groups.
4:45 pm
>> you thought interest groups on health care were bad, just wait. >> everybody has a cause they want to save in the tax code. >> there was -- we found out today there was a question, was there a plan b. there had to have been. amanda carpenter said i hope there's a c, d, e, and f. no plan b. does that surprise you? >> no. >> why? i would think they had something in their back pocket. >> honestly i'm still thinking of jeffrey lord jumping in -- >> the skinny dipping. >> here's the reason why i'm not surprised. two reasons to be serious. i think donald trump, president trump, thinks that when he issues an edict that it is set in stone, it is gold, it happens. that's how he's lived his life and his business life and he thought he could carry that to washington, d.c. in addition to that, i think that paul ryan was probably forced in some ways even though he did it himself, he was forced in some ways to speed up a
4:46 pm
process that they cheerily weren't -- >> tax reform, quickly, would it -- would it have gone better first? >> needed obamacare first because they needed the savings from that first. i think it will be tedious, a slog, it will be boring, and there's no sense that this is the way trump wants to operate, that he wants to get in the weeds and learn policy and talk about policy and sell policy. so i don't know. >> real quick. >> there's a reason it hasn't happened in 30 years, tax reform. on health care, donald trump never really campaigned on the merits of the bill. it was vote for this or else, vote for this or you'll lose your seat, never talked tact actual bill and it was unpopular. >> what he donald trump didn't know about health care policy, i would argue he would know maybe more about tax policy. i might be living in a delusional world. out front next, the top republican of the intelligence
4:47 pm
committee abruptly cancels a hear hearing on russia. is he doing the president's bitting? you can't predict the market. but through good times and bad... ...at t. rowe price... ...we've helped our investors stay confident for over 75 years. call us or your advisor. t. rowe price. invest with confidence.
4:48 pm
home loan, that newly listed,ank mid-century ranch withed for a the garden patio will be gone. or you could push that button. [dong] [rocket launching] skip the bank, skip the waiting, and go completely online. get the confidence that comes from a secure, qualified mortgage approval in minutes. lift the burden of getting a home loan with rocket mortgage by quicken loans. [whisper: rocket]
4:49 pm
he's a nascar champion who's she's a world-class swimmer who's stared down the best in her sport. but for both of them, the most challenging opponent was... pe blood clots in my lung. it was really scary. a dvt in my leg. i had to learn all i could to help protect myself. my doctor and i choose xarelto® xarelto®... to help keep me protected. xarelto® is a latest-generation blood thinner... ...that's proven to treat and reduce the risk of dvt and pe blood clots from happening again. in clinical studies, almost 98% of patients on xarelto® did not experience another dvt or pe. here's how xarelto works. xarelto® works differently. warfarin interferes with at least six blood-clotting factors. xarelto® is selective... ...targeting just one critical factor, interacting with less of your body's natural blood-clotting function. don't stop taking xarelto® without talking to your doctor as this may increase risk of blood clots. while taking, you may bruise more easily, or take longer for bleeding to stop.
4:50 pm
it may increase your risk of bleeding if you take certain medicines. xarelto® can cause serious, and in rare cases, fatal bleeding. get help right away for unexpected bleeding, unusual bruising, or tingling. if you've had spinal anesthesia, watch for back pain or any nerve or muscle-related signs or symptoms. do not take xarelto® if you have an artificial heart valve or abnormal bleeding. tell your doctor before all planned medical or dental procedures and before starting xarelto® about any conditions, such as kidney, liver, or bleeding problems. you've got to learn all you can... ...to help protect yourself from dvt and pe blood clots. talk to your doctor about xarelto®. there's more to know. a major development of the house investigation into possible ties between donald trump's campaign and russia. three former trump advisers including paul manafort say they are now willing to talk to the house intelligence committee but that committee is in turmoil tonight. today chairman devin nunes abruptly calling off a hearing next week and democrats are
4:51 pm
fuming. manu raju is live on capitol hill with more. are the former trump campaign advisers, who are these advisers that they now say will talk to the committee? >> reporter: there are three. paul manafort, the former head of the campaign, as well as roger stone, a longtime trump associate, and carter page, who was onetime a foreign policy adviser for the trump campaign, all telling the committee privately they're willing to have these conversations. even carter page telling me earlier today he's willing to have a public hearing to testify to clear his name. carter page firing off a pretty angry letter to the committee saying that he believes that his name has been essentially dragged through the mud. he wants to set the record straight and he said he's eagerly awaiting his chance to talk before the committee. the question is will that be public. we don't know that yet. devin nunes, the chairman of the committee, would not commit to that, said he would wait to see what these three witnesses would want to say before the public may have a chance to hear them, kate. >> speaking of public hearings,
4:52 pm
why is chairman nunes canceling what was to be a public hearing next week? >> reporter: he said because he wanted to to have a private classified briefing with the two men who did testify publicly earlier this week, fbi director james comey and mike rogers, the head of the national security agency. he explains his decision earlier today in a press conference. >> the committee will ask director comey and admiral rogers to appear in closed session and will postpone the earlier hearing in order to make time for them. >> reporter: but, kate, this has infuriated democrats who believe canceling this hearing will squelch public debate and understanding of the russia issue as well as any campaign contacts or coordination that may have occurred between trump officials and russian officials. of course this comes after mr. nunes decided to privately brief president trump over findings that he secretly found out from a source about some
4:53 pm
communications that may have appeared in the intelligence reports but over trump officials that he believes were improper. and democrats of course were unhappy that he privately ahmet trump before talking to the committee even as the committee was investigating russia and trump campaign contacts. all this come as some of the members of the committee want mr. nunes to step down as the chairman of the committee, but right now he's not showing any signs he will. >> thanks so much. "out front" now, democratic congressman who sits on the house intelligence committee. thanks for coming in. >> good evening. >> the top democrat adam schiff on the panel, he called the chairman's decision to cancel this hearing next week a serious mistake. what do you call it? >> i call it further obstruct n obstruction. it's so disappointing because russia attacked our democracy this past election, we're the committee charged with getting to the bottom of it and up until this week democrats and
4:54 pm
republicans have gone down this road together. we had a productive hearing monday when we learned more about the trump/russia ties and the fbi director confirming a criminal investigation into the campaign was under way and surprisingly chairman nunes took an exit from that road to go help the white house and we were left without knowing what the evidence is that he took to the white house and wondering is the credibility of our committee going to stand. >> nunes says he's not helping the white house, just felt a duty to inform the president of what he's uncovered. again, he hasn't even received material to show you what he thinks he may or may not have uncovered. i want to talk more about the canceled hearing next week. paul manafort, roger stone, carter page, they won't be at the hearing but they are going to testify now, they have agreed, to the committee. all of them agreeing today announcing they will testify before the committee. what do you want to hear from them when they come before you? >> these are some of the most
4:55 pm
relevant witnesses to russia's interference in donald trump's orbit. we are hoping that will testify in public and without any preconditions. with paul manafort, of course, he was the chairman, had a $10 million contract reportedly with a putin ally and he was a part of the change in the republican party platform that had always stood for ukraine and against russia and they took that out this past summer. carter page, senior foreign policy adviser to the president, a month after russia's appearance appeared and of course roger stone a self-described dirty trickster reveals before john podesta's e-mails are hacked that podesta is about to spend his time in a barrel. it's important that the american people hear what they have to say. >> do you want nunes to sfep down from the chairmanship? >> he needs to find an on-ramp back to the investigation. >> you're not there yet? >> not yet. we need to see the evidence he took to the white house. >> let's talk health care.
4:56 pm
here is what the president said today after house republicans pulled the bill. >> best thing that could happen is exactly what happened today. because we'll end up with a truly great health care bill in the future after this mess known as obamacare explodes. >> he also said democrats need to reach out. those are his words. your response? >> he also said that democrats defeated it and he's right. we defeated it because we heard the american people, we fought for them, and today we won for them. what we can do next is work with republicans to improve the affordable care act. right now we're seeing in a few places the individual marketplaces don't have enough competition. we can work to fix that. we can put back into place the -- >> you're confident you'll work with republicans on this? >> well, they need to come to us. they took on this enterprise without including democrats so i hope they take a lesson here. >> staring contest. thank skryou for your time. >> my pleasure. upstate new yod place to pursue your dreams.
4:57 pm
at vicarious visions, i get to be creative, work with awesome people, and we get to make great games. ( ♪ ) what i like about the area, feels like everybody knows each other. and i can go to my local coffee shop and they know who i am. it's really cool. new york state is filled with bright minds like lisa's. to find the companies and talent of tomorrow, search for our page, jobsinnewyorkstate on linkedin. search for our page,
4:59 pm
5:00 pm
thank you so much for joining us tonight. "ac 360" starts right now. geepg from the smoking political crater formerly known as washington. today republicans failed to do what they've been promising for year, the president failed to do what he said he would from the beginning of his campaign. >> we have to repeal obamacare and it can be -- and it can be replaced with something much better for everybody. let it be for everybody. but much better and much less expensive for people and for the government. and we can do it. so, i've watched the politicians, i've dealt with them all my life. if you can't make a good deal with a politician, then there's something wrong with you. you're cta
206 Views
1 Favorite
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN (San Francisco)Uploaded by TV Archive on
![](http://athena.archive.org/0.gif?kind=track_js&track_js_case=control&cache_bust=678572199)